I appreciate you posting this video. While I personally wish that they had released the outfit by itself- I collect in a different way than you, and don't do duplicates- I can see why she exists, and I do believe in not yucking someone's yum. I appreciate your work to keep things positive; when things get super negative it stresses me out, lol. I loved seeing this gentle, kind review of this edition of Kirsten. She looks very cute, and I can see how she fits so well in your style of collecting! So glad you were able to get her. Thank you so much for sharing. Always appreciate you.
@@eliseelliot have you seen these cheap St Lucia outfits everyone is claiming we can buy instead? I looked lol, but I had no luck. Hopefully you can find one or the outift will be rereleased someday. I really do think this was a special release, so I’m glad it happened. I’m a sucker for a beautiful display lol.
@@DisBlaine I am in total agreement that when AG rereleases something, they should look to see what the secondhand market is going for, but the idea that there are cheap St Lucia complete outfits out there is... certainly one of the more wild claims I've seen AG collectors make, lol. I mean, sure, you can generally find the gown, but good luck getting a complete wreath and the socks, too, for a decent price. But maybe I'm just not looking in the right places! So glad you're enjoying your new doll (and did you see that historicals are discounted today? Maybe time for a new Nanea...?).
@@Danny-gp6jn awww yes she is cute - but she takes up a lot of space, so don’t be too upset if she doesn’t find her way to you. You might find her outift one day
I just got my new Kirsten, and I got a good one too! I’m going to use her and the FAO Shwartz Tin Soldier doll as Christmas decor. I love your Pleasant Co Kirsten, and her outfit. Adorable!❤
@@crystalbluepersuasion3897 oh yay! I’ve seen some questionable ones, so I was a bit apprehensive. Congrats! Isn’t she so cute? And yes my PC Kirsten is a little cutie. Thank you 🥰
I loved the topic at the end, so true! Thank you for talking about the discourse surrounding new releases! I’m so glad you like your Kirsten, she’ll make a beautiful tree! ❤🎄❤️
@@americangirlfilms I totally understand not liking something, but collectors asking people who like something not to buy it because they don’t like it is very new to me lol! What a time we live in. Did I mention I might use her as a tree?? Because I was thinking of sticking gifts under her 🤣
String! String! String! There, I now understand where this doll is so special. Though I would still prefer ALL of the dolls being this way, and not as a collector but as a parent. Thank you for the gentle attitude, it just adds to the Christmassy moods :) 💖
@@DollsAllGrown-Up I was excited about the string too. You mean as a parent you prefer string over cable ties? I once mentioned the need to bring back string, and a few people said they don’t meet safety requirements - yet here we are with a new doll with strings
@@DisBlaine I find that a plastic tie (that is super sharp around the edges) is, potentially, more harmful than a string - particularly in a doll that is intended for children aged 6+. You wouldn't expect a child at this age to put everything they find into their mouths, yet, there will definitely be hygiene issues with a doll that cannot be cleaned properly, especially the one with cloth body. That's at a first glance... Anyways - hip hip hooray to your stringed Kirsten with even eyes :)
@@Grandma_HoneyVA that 15% code they sent for Summer’s collection was all I needed 🤣 The doll may not be for me (I can see she’s lovely for others however) but I did like a lot of her clothes. Now I can add them to my collection 🥳 Oh and thank you. I’m sure I seem a bit thin skinned about my dolls sometimes Because i am 🤪
Just discovered your channel and I really enjoy your video. I don’t collect American Girl, I’m mostly Barbie, but I love to watch collectors of other dolls too. Thank you for your positive commentary, it brings us joy too! ❤your doll is beautiful ❤
@@catalinaquijano6477 aww well I’m glad you started with a video where I explained why I’m a little too optimistic about my dolls sometimes lol. The only Barbie I have is the American Girl Barbie behind me in the video. But I used to play with my cousins Barbie’s with her when we were kids 😆
@@DisBlaine AWWW so cute! i bought American Girl Barbie too! She's my first and only AG. My Barbie bestie owns all the original AG dolls tho, so i learned to appreciate them! 💝
My Kirsten was perfect! No problems with mine. I bought her for a Christmas seasonal doll. I just love her. My daughter had an original but got silver eye, so this one is great. I think the comments are reflective of what is going on on the outside. I let them pass like you and be appreciative of the release. I think AG needs a Christmas doll and they released a wonderful one. Thank you for sharing.
@@JoanneSag oh yay I’m glad you got a good one too! I didn’t mention the problems, but I saw some with lopsided teeth paint!! I don’t know why, but the comments are getting weirder and weirder. As soon as I read a couple I stopped and moved on. But it was strange lol. These are just dolls.
@@ahomefordolls166 yay, thank you! I’ve seen some janky ones, so we both got lucky! I took a better look after I was done recording… and I’m so thrilled!
I just got Kit her Christmas dress and I'm obsessed!! My poor Kit needs restrung and new legs due to marks not coming off despite my efforts, but I've been really bonding with her... which I am so happy because she came in worse condition than was disclosed... but her face is what made me pick this one. I'm glad my disappointment is waning and more I am in falling love with her. She even wore a mini-flight suit like I wore when I was in the Air Force and came with us to the Air Force Museum for Veteran's Day. She rocked it and I got some cool pictures!
@@jessnawoods it’s funny how fixing up a doll can create such a bond, like a personal connection. I love fixing dolls but it’s annoying when it’s more work than you expect. I hope you paid the correct price for her condition. I was catfished by a doll once! But I love her now.
Hi Blaine, thanks for another great video. I love my Kirsten. A lot of people seem to be upset by this release, but I couldn't be happier with her. I love her packaging and how closely they made it match the book cover. Sure, they could have released more of her accessories or meet outfit, but you can't please everyone. I'm looking forward, and hoping to seeing all the Surprise Doll releases, particularly Addy. ❤
@@mykls2153 hey Michael! Yes it’s such a nice presentation, which I knew would sell me on her. If they do more of the Surprise dolls, I hope the boxes are close in size, even tho they had to make this tall for her crown. They also had to make it deep for the book. Anyway lol she’s really lovely, so I’m starting to wonder if the upset is fomo. I can understand that if so.
Your PC Kirsten looks cozy! And your AG Barbie looks awesome in her outfit in the background. With the historical repros Mattel is producing and they sell out, it should be a clear indicator that the fans want more of them. (Outfits only please). It would be a great idea to display your beautiful new Kirsten on a table with lots of greenery (large trees, fake snow) around her for the wintery season!
@@buffmontana4203 haha I just want to hug her every time I see her in this outift. I love the way this doll is presented, and even tho I like to open everything, she’s a beautiful display piece to leave inside her box. Maybe they’ll release the outift later
Kirsten is my favorite of the original 3 dolls! I never had any AG dolls growing up but my sister got Kirsten for Christmas one year and I loved her so much (just a bit jealous😆). She wasn’t available anymore when I started down this dolly rabbit hole so I was super excited when they re-released her. I’m a Minnesota girl, and I am interested in pioneer life so I’ve always been drawn to her. I like how she is displayed in the box to look like the book cover - so cool. I am a little bummed that AG didn’t release just the outfit since her collection is amazing and so expensive on the secondhand market, but I’m not torn up about it. I’m in a lot of AG Facebook groups and have seen the negative posts about her. There is always going to be somebody who doesn’t like something - there are all sorts of collectors out there. Like others have said, I do appreciate your positive viewpoint and you don’t get views by complaining - your videos are so genuine. I just think you seem like the sweetest soul!
@@rebeccahoffman1938 did you get her recent release, with her complete outift and meet accessories? I assume you did lol. That’s cool that her story is so close to your heart. She has so many beautiful outfits - so I’m glad it’s mostly hard to get, because space. I stopped reading comments on other social media after I saw people tryin to boycott a dol. Like, why do you care what other people enjoy? There might be more to it (fomo)
I’m so glad you got her! She is very cute. I can see why she is a perfect pick for you. Your doll looks like she has longer bangs which I like a lot. Your Pleasant co Kirstin is so darn cute too. Love them all. Thanks for sharing! I always believe if you can’t say something nice don’t say anything at all. I like your positive attitude. You are awesome. 😃👍
@@CherishedDollFriends I didn’t notice while I was recording but she doesn’t just have longer bangs, her wig is much shinier. The other Kirsten is only a few months old, so I don’t think that’s why Maybe it’s that limited edition quality 🤪
Thank you for opening your Kristen doll. I’ve watched unboxing videos that say “unboxing”, but they never actually unbox their doll because they want to sell them eventually. It happened a lot with Barbie.
@@alyssajose2684 yyyyeah I’m a bit of an animal opening my dolls. I did the same for Barbie - and I redressed her. I’ll probably redo her hair someday too ☠️
I never thought I would get a Kirsten, but your PC girl is so cute I'm very tempted! I love her lighter eye color, rounded face, and more sculptured face mold! (not to mention the adorable outfit and hairdo!) I think having a Christmas doll that just comes out at the holidays is a great idea!🎄It's always exciting for me to pull out the decorations and see them every year!😁
@@paulettepalmer4860 there’s just something about the PC dolls isn’t there? It was almost rude of me to put her between the 2 Mattel dolls, but I wanted her in the center 😆 I’m excited to pull her out at the holidays… but first I need to figure out where to store her pahaaaa
I don't have a negative opinion of her release at all. I just knew that it didn't make much sense for me to get her for myself and my collection. I would have loved to have the St. Lucia outfit on its own, but I am happy that she exists for people that love her and want her and do choose to buy and enjoy her. I really enjoyed watching this unboxing of her. She's gorgeous 😍
@@diamondsanddolls you should try to find the older outfit-tbh it’s probably nicer (PC always is), and people are saying it’s not very expensive. But who knows? It may get released on its own one day.
Hi Blaine! I think you Kirsten is adorable! I'm so happy you got her!😃I loved the way you explained that! That's why I love your videos! You love your dolls as much as I do! You are great! ❤️
Thank you for this review! I have five Kirsten dolls and I have the outfit so I don’t feel the need to get her. I still enjoy the reviews though! She looks very pretty.
@@sjordan9586 I think this will be my last Kirsten (I hate saying that lolol) but she’s my 4th and one is a fixer upper. Which versions of her do you have?
I love your positivity about your dolls. That's how I feel about mine too, and if I don't care for a doll, I don't trash it, I just don't get it. I love focusing on the positive and the joy my dolls bring me. They make my day better a lot of the time, you know? Keep being gungho or over the top, you are delightful to watch and I love your collection. (BTW, was able to get a like new 104 - boy doll- in box for $85 shipped USD, so excited)
@@DarcysNova626 I’ve realized over the past couple years there are people who enjoy disliking stuff. I don’t mean that in a critical way, just in a “we’re different” way. They get a satisfaction out of hating on something (like hate fans in the k-pop world… but less dangerous I hope!) So I’m glad they have places to share their hate enjoyment - and I just have to remember they’re allowed to express their discontent the way I’m allowed to express my joy. But we should probably do it in separate places lol!
@@DarcysNova626 the holiday spirit started in Canada last week (Remembrance Day was last Monday) so I’m in it lol! But I think I have 3 more Christmas videos and a Hanukah video.
@@DisBlaineas someone who was raised Methodist and then Baptist (scary, lol), who is now just spiritual - but whose parents and one brother now choose to follow the Jewish path - I'm looking forward to seeing your Hanukkah collection. Wow, run-on sentence, sorry. I love different cultures and learning about religious observations as well. And I need to see lots of your holiday displays. They just make me happy.
The hair on your vintage Kirsten is so cute! I have an older Kirsten and the re-release. I like the newer Mattel classic mold a bit better but think that AG should have used the lighter blue eyes. Still, I love them both. I don't have the St. Lucia outfit, but there is a sewing pattern and the socks are available various places. It's the wreath!! Doggone, wish I could figure out how to make that!
@@nanasewdear I have such mixed feelings about the classic mold! When I look at it on its own, the mattel version is so cute and has grown on me a lot - and I think I prefer it. Then I put a PC doll next to it, and I flip right back to the OG 😝 But I definitely like them both in their own way.
I’m not too big a Kirsten fan, so this one isn’t for me. I enjoyed the unboxing and I’m glad you called attention to the details in the display box! I do think you got a doll with a really cute face, too. But I love classic mold, so I’m biased. I enjoy your channel because of your positivity and clear love for the dolls and the hobby. I am a new collector - I only have 3 dolls so far - and I have already seen a lot of negativity about certain dolls. It’s kind of frustrating. I’m also a Star Wars fan and collector, and it is unfortunately similar there. Thank you for keeping the joy in the community.
@@settheworldonfire94 the mold has grown on me A LOT, but it was the last one to do so. Do you have a preference for the old (PC) or the new one? They both have different charms for me. It makes the old dolls and new ones seem like cousins or something lol. Oh yes every collecting community has negativity, so I think that must be an appeal for lots of people. I can’t imagine collecting something I have so much disdain for, but maybe I don’t have the same eye for detail 🥴🤪 3 so far? Hmmm you may be in for a ride lol!
@ honestly I kind of separate the PC mold and the newer classic mold in my head. They are very different, but I do like both. I’d say I prefer the new one, though I really like the Kirsten you have in the winter outfit with the skates. I’m with you! I think I just prefer to enjoy the things I enjoy. If I don’t like something, I just don’t watch it or buy it whatever. I’m really considering just jumping to get Claudie today with the 20% off Black Friday sale!! She’s been on my list since I first saw her. I started with Kit since she’s the doll I’ve wanted since childhood.
Hello Blaine, I was so excited when they started speaking about releasing this doll. I remember waiting until midnight so that they could finally have it online. So I could order her. She is beautiful in my eyes. I feel like you, I collect for my enjoyment. I always tend to stay away from the negativity of how other people feel because that is their prerogative. and not everyone has to agree with one another's choice. I'm so glad you got her enjoy and can't wait for your next video.
@@annettefedd488 haha I did the same thing!! But the mobile site was acting up for me, so I had to rush home in a panic to order on my computer. It was really weird! Did you get yours yet? It’s such a beautiful presentation of the doll!! 🥰😍🥰
Your Kirsten is beautiful!! Congratulations! Actually, all your Kirsten’s are beautiful. I can see her fitting nicely into your collection as you like to display all the outfits in dolls, this makes sense. She fills a niche and some people will want her and some don’t. I don’t know why we can’t be more civil in the doll collector community. If a doll isn’t for you, don’t buy her, but don’t take the joy out of someone else’s day. Too much if that going around now.
@@melangellperry5984 thanks Mel! I was so happy when I saw her box. It was what I “needed” to convince me. (I like to pretend I need coaxing sometimes 🤪) And yes I think joykilling going around made it hit me in a different way. Hence my little sob story at the end there lol.
I understand both sides of the argument, and I can agree with both. I wish they had an option to just buy the outfit by itself. I feel like they'd probably make more if they did both the display doll, and a separate 'just the outfit' option. I enjoy dressing my dolls up for holidays, but I don't have the space for multiple dolls, so I'm passing on her. But if they had an option to just buy the outfit, I would have been all over that.
@@caitlynv1167 oh yes I definitely understand not liking something - we all have different taste and different reasons to dislike something. I’ll never underhand telling other people they should refuse to buy something just because they don’t like it. As in, I’ll never understand disliking something enough to want others not to like it too 🥴 Hopefully they’ll release the outift one day - or anyone who wants it can find one on the secondary market for a good price
I love all 3 of your Kirsten’s! You got a really beautiful St.Lucia Kirsten she looks so happy! Off topic question- did you preorder Moana? I can’t wait to see her in person!
@@EStern-18 I’m SO THRILLED with the St. Lucia Kirsten I got, what a relief! Yes my Moana was delivered to my American address today, but I’m not sure when I’ll pick her up. Is yours on her way?
Hi Blaine I'm going to be doing the AGSurprise book reading challenge were we read as many of the surprise, Changes for and other Histocal and GOTY books that takes place during Christmas time. I'm starting the reading challenge on November 25th and ending the book reading challenge on Christmas Day. I posted a video about and I thought I'd let other AGTubers know and I did it because of this special edition Kirsten surprise doll. I want as many people to read the American Girl Christmas and holiday books.
@DisBlaine in my video l linked a Google doc with just about every dolls holiday book on internet archives or run down to the library and bareow them. I'll be doing a more in depth video on the 25th when the book challenge starts
I picked her out at the store when she first came out. I have 3 PC Kirstens and now the LE Kirsten’s Surprise doll. Where did you get the coat for your PC Kirsten? Love it!
@@nettiezdolls6742 how was she in store? Much variation? I’ve seen complaints of bad hair and the teeth stamped wrong. Her winter coat was party of the special edition series. I got it from someone locally. Isn’t it adorable???
@@iamsoverybored878 I think she’s also nice as a special doll to keep in box. I’m not sure why limited edition holiday dolls are a thing, but when they’re nice they’re nice lol
@DisBlaine I got a couple of holiday Barbies. I'm also half Jewish, so it sucks that they never made a Hanakah one. I made my own. I know AG has Hanakah stuff, but it's pricey.
@ did you collect the millennium twins… I’m only asking because they’re half Jewish too lol. I wasn’t raised in any religion, but I still decorate my dolls for Hanukah because I lived with Jewish people when I was younger (long story)
People trashing summer made me so sad. I didn't let them make me feel bad about Kirsten though. She's always been one of my favorites. I love how much of a radical she is... And naughty lol😅
@@kerrysmiles after so many Summer videos came out, I felt so bad doing an opinion video about a doll I don’t have. I don’t think I’ll ever do that again.
@@DisBlaineit's okay. Once in a while we need to say what's on our minds. Those who are hurt by a negative review, should leave and find someone who did love her. And I know there were several. Noone should be so overly sensitive when none of it is personal. 😊
@@brutallyhonestdollreviews I think you are right. I saw AG takes over's Kristie and her wife bought one, dressed it differently, and it is beautiful, IMHO . A lighter Nanea. So I succumbed.
LOL I cant believe you got her SMH. No shade she is a beautiful doll glad you got her. I need an extra Tiana dress for my grand daughters doll do you have any left for sale. Sorry about the loss of your ornaments. The berries and leaves are Lingon berry. I did not get the Kirsten doll because I have three Kirsten dolls and I only wanted the crown since I also have several St. Lucia dresses. Between the cost and just space it was not in the cards for me to get this doll.
@@nailahvenable7989 lol you’re surprised I got Kirsten’s Surprise?? Yeah I have a Tiana doll on the way and the original buyer backed out of her outfit. Canada post is on strike, so I’d have to aim to shop on one of my many trips to Buffalo. You have several St Lucia dresses?? How? Yeah space is definitely an issue. I even have to figure out where I’ll store after the holidays ☠️
@@DisBlaine great no rush he much for the dress and I got the st. Lucia dresses on eBay and one in a shop goodwill lot. With a Kirsten doll. I am working on a diy for the crown wish me luck maybe by next year
@@DisBlaine Blain wanted to let you know I don't need the Tiana dress as My daughter bought the doll as it was on sale recently from AG I hope I did not inconvenience you. Thank you for considering me.
@ oh no worries! Haha that outfit became available in the first place because someone else bought her at that sale (which was when I bought the doll the outfit came from pahaaaaa!)
She is beautiful, I’m just mad you are not matching outfit with her hahha, with Monster High happens the same, every single drop you see toma of people online hating… If they don’t like it is fine, don’t but it and move on, don’t know why they need to feed on the hate and people change their own opinions based on someone else’s…
@@NecrossVamp okay here’s an embarrassing secret - I don’t any white clothes so I’m wearing a shirt to match her meet outfit instead 🤓🤣 Yeah it’s weird how people want to chime in with criticism, but I’m even more disturbed by people who think because they don’t like something, no one else should enjoy it.
Awww, you got a cute one! I have my PC Kirsten girly, but I'm so tempted to get a "refreshed" new Kirsten. And while I already have this outfit, why the heck do I still want this???? My goddddddddduh. 🥴🥴🫨 But hey can I ask you which collector you're talking about that shares the numbers left of these collector dolls? Do you monitor this yourself? I'd like to be able to check these stock numbers myself but not exactly sure how people do it.
@@Kari-G it’s the beautiful presentation!! I might’ve been able to pass if she came in a regular box like the last wave of historicals. The collector doesn’t have a channel. She adds hundreds to her cart (a number she knows will be too many) and the cart will get corrected with how many are left. I tried once but gave up because it take wayyyyy too long!
@@DisBlaine YES, it's the presentation of Kirsten, you're totally right. I just have a weakness for her. I actually used to sing on St. Lucia Day with candles/wreaths and the whole shebang at my Swedish college in Southern Minnesota, so she's my girl. :). Ugh, I didn't think I needed a second Kirsten, but now I'm worried she's going to sell out. Thanks for letting me know about the "stock" check method. I figured that's how it works, but never actually tried it cause it seems like it would take forever just like you say....lol.
@ oh wow that is a cool connection!! I’m not saying this to be a bad influence but out of empathy… I feel like you’d regret it if you passed on her. You can put her away after the holidays if it’s a space issue. But this is a special release (imo)
I bought this doll, and I am happy to have her. She reminds me Christmas.
@@dollmom3597 exactly! She’s the perfect center piece to a Christmas display.
I appreciate you posting this video. While I personally wish that they had released the outfit by itself- I collect in a different way than you, and don't do duplicates- I can see why she exists, and I do believe in not yucking someone's yum. I appreciate your work to keep things positive; when things get super negative it stresses me out, lol. I loved seeing this gentle, kind review of this edition of Kirsten. She looks very cute, and I can see how she fits so well in your style of collecting! So glad you were able to get her. Thank you so much for sharing. Always appreciate you.
@@eliseelliot have you seen these cheap St Lucia outfits everyone is claiming we can buy instead? I looked lol, but I had no luck. Hopefully you can find one or the outift will be rereleased someday. I really do think this was a special release, so I’m glad it happened. I’m a sucker for a beautiful display lol.
@@DisBlaine I am in total agreement that when AG rereleases something, they should look to see what the secondhand market is going for, but the idea that there are cheap St Lucia complete outfits out there is... certainly one of the more wild claims I've seen AG collectors make, lol. I mean, sure, you can generally find the gown, but good luck getting a complete wreath and the socks, too, for a decent price. But maybe I'm just not looking in the right places! So glad you're enjoying your new doll (and did you see that historicals are discounted today? Maybe time for a new Nanea...?).
I think she is a beautiful doll in a beautiful historical outfit. The box is also very lovely, I wish I could have her!
@@Danny-gp6jn awww yes she is cute - but she takes up a lot of space, so don’t be too upset if she doesn’t find her way to you. You might find her outift one day
I just got my new Kirsten, and I got a good one too! I’m going to use her and the FAO Shwartz Tin Soldier doll as Christmas decor. I love your Pleasant Co Kirsten, and her outfit. Adorable!❤
@@crystalbluepersuasion3897 oh yay! I’ve seen some questionable ones, so I was a bit apprehensive. Congrats! Isn’t she so cute?
And yes my PC Kirsten is a little cutie. Thank you 🥰
I really liked the tin soldier!
I loved the topic at the end, so true! Thank you for talking about the discourse surrounding new releases! I’m so glad you like your Kirsten, she’ll make a beautiful tree! ❤🎄❤️
@@americangirlfilms I totally understand not liking something, but collectors asking people who like something not to buy it because they don’t like it is very new to me lol! What a time we live in.
Did I mention I might use her as a tree?? Because I was thinking of sticking gifts under her 🤣
Congratulations on the 9 months of your channel too!!!!!❤❤❤
@@Grandma_HoneyVA thanks so much 🥳
(I didn’t do my planned video for it, so I wasn’t sure I mentioned that)
String! String! String! There, I now understand where this doll is so special. Though I would still prefer ALL of the dolls being this way, and not as a collector but as a parent. Thank you for the gentle attitude, it just adds to the Christmassy moods :) 💖
@@DollsAllGrown-Up I was excited about the string too. You mean as a parent you prefer string over cable ties? I once mentioned the need to bring back string, and a few people said they don’t meet safety requirements - yet here we are with a new doll with strings
@@DisBlaine I find that a plastic tie (that is super sharp around the edges) is, potentially, more harmful than a string - particularly in a doll that is intended for children aged 6+. You wouldn't expect a child at this age to put everything they find into their mouths, yet, there will definitely be hygiene issues with a doll that cannot be cleaned properly, especially the one with cloth body. That's at a first glance... Anyways - hip hip hooray to your stringed Kirsten with even eyes :)
She looks precious and that is a really pretty display box.
@@kydrasims9734 it’s the box that got me!! Haha I love it.
Your Kirsten Surprise is a beautiful doll. May you enjoy her this and many more Christmas seasons to come.❤
@@azeverinarizona1931 Instead of an angel… I’ll have Kirsten 😆
Oh, you must keep her forever. She is so so sweet, and so, so the essence of American Girl at its very best.
@@lisbetsoda4874 yes! She can be my angel substitute (if I ever get another tree). Or I can just display her as normal lol
I love your attitude! I didn’t like Summer at first but I do like seeing her dressed in modern clothes! I appreciate your points of view always!!!!!!❤
@@Grandma_HoneyVA that 15% code they sent for Summer’s collection was all I needed 🤣
The doll may not be for me (I can see she’s lovely for others however) but I did like a lot of her clothes. Now I can add them to my collection 🥳
Oh and thank you. I’m sure I seem a bit thin skinned about my dolls sometimes
Because i am 🤪
Your videos are so cozy! I love hearing your positive ramblings!
@@chanbrew3175 awww yay, what a lovely way to put it. I like that: cozy 🥰
I love your positivity! So refreshing. She is fabulous. I hope you enjoy her a whole lot. Have a good night.
@@sarahb9240 awww thank you! I think she’ll be nice to pull out of storage every year and go 😍🥰😍
Just discovered your channel and I really enjoy your video. I don’t collect American Girl, I’m mostly Barbie, but I love to watch collectors of other dolls too. Thank you for your positive commentary, it brings us joy too! ❤your doll is beautiful ❤
@@catalinaquijano6477 aww well I’m glad you started with a video where I explained why I’m a little too optimistic about my dolls sometimes lol. The only Barbie I have is the American Girl Barbie behind me in the video. But I used to play with my cousins Barbie’s with her when we were kids 😆
@@DisBlaine AWWW so cute! i bought American Girl Barbie too! She's my first and only AG. My Barbie bestie owns all the original AG dolls tho, so i learned to appreciate them! 💝
I really love your PC Kirsten’s face! She just looks so HAPPY! Amazes me how each doll can look so different. Great video
@@ledstoke isn’t she so sweet?? And yes I feel the same way whenever I get multiples of a doll. How do they look different??
❤ your pc kirstens buns are adorable! ❤
@@brutallyhonestdollreviews haha I think people will be sick of seeing them soon enough - I keep finding excuses to show her
My Kirsten was perfect! No problems with mine. I bought her for a Christmas seasonal doll. I just love her. My daughter had an original but got silver eye, so this one is great. I think the comments are reflective of what is going on on the outside. I let them pass like you and be appreciative of the release. I think AG needs a Christmas doll and they released a wonderful one. Thank you for sharing.
@@JoanneSag oh yay I’m glad you got a good one too! I didn’t mention the problems, but I saw some with lopsided teeth paint!!
I don’t know why, but the comments are getting weirder and weirder. As soon as I read a couple I stopped and moved on. But it was strange lol. These are just dolls.
You sure got a nice one! I love mine too.
@@ahomefordolls166 yay, thank you! I’ve seen some janky ones, so we both got lucky!
I took a better look after I was done recording… and I’m so thrilled!
I just got Kit her Christmas dress and I'm obsessed!! My poor Kit needs restrung and new legs due to marks not coming off despite my efforts, but I've been really bonding with her... which I am so happy because she came in worse condition than was disclosed... but her face is what made me pick this one. I'm glad my disappointment is waning and more I am in falling love with her. She even wore a mini-flight suit like I wore when I was in the Air Force and came with us to the Air Force Museum for Veteran's Day. She rocked it and I got some cool pictures!
@@jessnawoods it’s funny how fixing up a doll can create such a bond, like a personal connection. I love fixing dolls but it’s annoying when it’s more work than you expect. I hope you paid the correct price for her condition. I was catfished by a doll once! But I love her now.
Hi Blaine, thanks for another great video. I love my Kirsten. A lot of people seem to be upset by this release, but I couldn't be happier with her. I love her packaging and how closely they made it match the book cover. Sure, they could have released more of her accessories or meet outfit, but you can't please everyone. I'm looking forward, and hoping to seeing all the Surprise Doll releases, particularly Addy. ❤
@@mykls2153 hey Michael! Yes it’s such a nice presentation, which I knew would sell me on her. If they do more of the Surprise dolls, I hope the boxes are close in size, even tho they had to make this tall for her crown. They also had to make it deep for the book.
Anyway lol she’s really lovely, so I’m starting to wonder if the upset is fomo. I can understand that if so.
I like her and I’m glad you are happy 💕💕💕💕
@@thoward3523 awww thank you! I’m thrilled I got a good one 🥳
I just got mine in store, I wasn’t planning on it, but I couldn’t resist
She’s very pretty!!🩷💕
@@beatriz9293 thank you!!! I’m so thrilled with her 😭
Your PC Kirsten looks cozy! And your AG Barbie looks awesome in her outfit in the background. With the historical repros Mattel is producing and they sell out, it should be a clear indicator that the fans want more of them. (Outfits only please).
It would be a great idea to display your beautiful new Kirsten on a table with lots of greenery (large trees, fake snow) around her for the wintery season!
@@buffmontana4203 haha I just want to hug her every time I see her in this outift.
I love the way this doll is presented, and even tho I like to open everything, she’s a beautiful display piece to leave inside her box. Maybe they’ll release the outift later
She's real pretty! I love seeing how excited you get when you open a new doll!
@@charlotteamaro7165 thank you - I’m glad I got a nice one!
And lowkey I wish I got a little less excited so I could focus more on recording 🤓
Kirsten is my favorite of the original 3 dolls! I never had any AG dolls growing up but my sister got Kirsten for Christmas one year and I loved her so much (just a bit jealous😆). She wasn’t available anymore when I started down this dolly rabbit hole so I was super excited when they re-released her. I’m a Minnesota girl, and I am interested in pioneer life so I’ve always been drawn to her. I like how she is displayed in the box to look like the book cover - so cool. I am a little bummed that AG didn’t release just the outfit since her collection is amazing and so expensive on the secondhand market, but I’m not torn up about it. I’m in a lot of AG Facebook groups and have seen the negative posts about her. There is always going to be somebody who doesn’t like something - there are all sorts of collectors out there. Like others have said, I do appreciate your positive viewpoint and you don’t get views by complaining - your videos are so genuine. I just think you seem like the sweetest soul!
@@rebeccahoffman1938 did you get her recent release, with her complete outift and meet accessories? I assume you did lol. That’s cool that her story is so close to your heart. She has so many beautiful outfits - so I’m glad it’s mostly hard to get, because space.
I stopped reading comments on other social media after I saw people tryin to boycott a dol. Like, why do you care what other people enjoy? There might be more to it (fomo)
I’m so glad you got her! She is very cute. I can see why she is a perfect pick for you. Your doll looks like she has longer bangs which I like a lot. Your Pleasant co Kirstin is so darn cute too. Love them all. Thanks for sharing! I always believe if you can’t say something nice don’t say anything at all. I like your positive attitude. You are awesome. 😃👍
@@CherishedDollFriends I didn’t notice while I was recording but she doesn’t just have longer bangs, her wig is much shinier. The other Kirsten is only a few months old, so I don’t think that’s why
Maybe it’s that limited edition quality 🤪
Thank you for opening your Kristen doll. I’ve watched unboxing videos that say “unboxing”, but they never actually unbox their doll because they want to sell them eventually. It happened a lot with Barbie.
@@alyssajose2684 yyyyeah I’m a bit of an animal opening my dolls. I did the same for Barbie - and I redressed her. I’ll probably redo her hair someday too ☠️
I never thought I would get a Kirsten, but your PC girl is so cute I'm very tempted! I love her lighter eye color, rounded face, and more sculptured face mold! (not to mention the adorable outfit and hairdo!) I think having a Christmas doll that just comes out at the holidays is a great idea!🎄It's always exciting for me to pull out the decorations and see them every year!😁
@@paulettepalmer4860 there’s just something about the PC dolls isn’t there? It was almost rude of me to put her between the 2 Mattel dolls, but I wanted her in the center 😆
I’m excited to pull her out at the holidays… but first I need to figure out where to store her pahaaaa
I don't have a negative opinion of her release at all. I just knew that it didn't make much sense for me to get her for myself and my collection. I would have loved to have the St. Lucia outfit on its own, but I am happy that she exists for people that love her and want her and do choose to buy and enjoy her. I really enjoyed watching this unboxing of her. She's gorgeous 😍
@@diamondsanddolls you should try to find the older outfit-tbh it’s probably nicer (PC always is), and people are saying it’s not very expensive. But who knows? It may get released on its own one day.
Hi Blaine! I think you Kirsten is adorable! I'm so happy you got her!😃I loved the way you explained that! That's why I love your videos! You love your dolls as much as I do! You are great! ❤️
@@robinkrueger5977 hey Robin! Tbh I’ve seen some janky looking ones, so I’m so glad I got lucky with mine!
I’m glad you “get” me 🥰
@@DisBlaine oh wow! Really? I'm glad yours was good too! Yes I do "get" you!🥰
Thank you for this review! I have five Kirsten dolls and I have the outfit so I don’t feel the need to get her. I still enjoy the reviews though! She looks very pretty.
@@sjordan9586 I think this will be my last Kirsten (I hate saying that lolol) but she’s my 4th and one is a fixer upper. Which versions of her do you have?
I love your positivity about your dolls. That's how I feel about mine too, and if I don't care for a doll, I don't trash it, I just don't get it. I love focusing on the positive and the joy my dolls bring me. They make my day better a lot of the time, you know? Keep being gungho or over the top, you are delightful to watch and I love your collection. (BTW, was able to get a like new 104 - boy doll- in box for $85 shipped USD, so excited)
Also... please keep posting your Christmas videos! Since we're close to US Thanksgiving, I'm getting more into the spirit of the holiday!
@@DarcysNova626 I’ve realized over the past couple years there are people who enjoy disliking stuff. I don’t mean that in a critical way, just in a “we’re different” way. They get a satisfaction out of hating on something (like hate fans in the k-pop world… but less dangerous I hope!)
So I’m glad they have places to share their hate enjoyment - and I just have to remember they’re allowed to express their discontent the way I’m allowed to express my joy.
But we should probably do it in separate places lol!
@@DarcysNova626 the holiday spirit started in Canada last week (Remembrance Day was last Monday) so I’m in it lol! But I think I have 3 more Christmas videos and a Hanukah video.
@@DisBlaineas someone who was raised Methodist and then Baptist (scary, lol), who is now just spiritual - but whose parents and one brother now choose to follow the Jewish path - I'm looking forward to seeing your Hanukkah collection. Wow, run-on sentence, sorry. I love different cultures and learning about religious observations as well. And I need to see lots of your holiday displays. They just make me happy.
The hair on your vintage Kirsten is so cute! I have an older Kirsten and the re-release. I like the newer Mattel classic mold a bit better but think that AG should have used the lighter blue eyes. Still, I love them both. I don't have the St. Lucia outfit, but there is a sewing pattern and the socks are available various places. It's the wreath!! Doggone, wish I could figure out how to make that!
@@nanasewdear I have such mixed feelings about the classic mold! When I look at it on its own, the mattel version is so cute and has grown on me a lot - and I think I prefer it. Then I put a PC doll next to it, and I flip right back to the OG 😝
But I definitely like them both in their own way.
I’m not too big a Kirsten fan, so this one isn’t for me. I enjoyed the unboxing and I’m glad you called attention to the details in the display box! I do think you got a doll with a really cute face, too. But I love classic mold, so I’m biased.
I enjoy your channel because of your positivity and clear love for the dolls and the hobby. I am a new collector - I only have 3 dolls so far - and I have already seen a lot of negativity about certain dolls. It’s kind of frustrating. I’m also a Star Wars fan and collector, and it is unfortunately similar there. Thank you for keeping the joy in the community.
@@settheworldonfire94 the mold has grown on me A LOT, but it was the last one to do so. Do you have a preference for the old (PC) or the new one? They both have different charms for me. It makes the old dolls and new ones seem like cousins or something lol.
Oh yes every collecting community has negativity, so I think that must be an appeal for lots of people. I can’t imagine collecting something I have so much disdain for, but maybe I don’t have the same eye for detail 🥴🤪
3 so far? Hmmm you may be in for a ride lol!
@ honestly I kind of separate the PC mold and the newer classic mold in my head. They are very different, but I do like both. I’d say I prefer the new one, though I really like the Kirsten you have in the winter outfit with the skates.
I’m with you! I think I just prefer to enjoy the things I enjoy. If I don’t like something, I just don’t watch it or buy it whatever.
I’m really considering just jumping to get Claudie today with the 20% off Black Friday sale!! She’s been on my list since I first saw her. I started with Kit since she’s the doll I’ve wanted since childhood.
Hello Blaine, I was so excited when they started speaking about releasing this doll. I remember waiting until midnight so that they could finally have it online. So I could order her. She is beautiful in my eyes. I feel like you, I collect for my enjoyment.
I always tend to stay away from the negativity of how other people feel because that is their prerogative. and not everyone has to agree with one another's choice. I'm so glad you got her enjoy and can't wait for your next video.
@@annettefedd488 haha I did the same thing!! But the mobile site was acting up for me, so I had to rush home in a panic to order on my computer. It was really weird!
Did you get yours yet? It’s such a beautiful presentation of the doll!! 🥰😍🥰
@DisBlaine oh, yes, I got mine right away. She is stunning. I love her. I also got Moana. I hope you order her because she is stunning, as well.
@ oh yes my Moana was delivered yesterday, but I don’t know when I’ll drive to my American address to pick her up. You already got yours?
Yes, I did receive mine on a monday. You are going to love her.
Your Kirsten is beautiful!! Congratulations! Actually, all your Kirsten’s are beautiful.
I can see her fitting nicely into your collection as you like to display all the outfits in dolls, this makes sense. She fills a niche and some people will want her and some don’t. I don’t know why we can’t be more civil in the doll collector community. If a doll isn’t for you, don’t buy her, but don’t take the joy out of someone else’s day. Too much if that going around now.
@@melangellperry5984 thanks Mel! I was so happy when I saw her box. It was what I “needed” to convince me. (I like to pretend I need coaxing sometimes 🤪)
And yes I think joykilling going around made it hit me in a different way. Hence my little sob story at the end there lol.
I think the outfit looks beautiful ❤ i have the Vintage AG Crown from 98’ and it was actually more durable in this case than PC. Pcs candles came out.
@@brokegirl1452 wow, mattel finally made something higher quality than pc?? This really is a special doll lol.
yeah so excited to see this!! mine just arrived today but at work so havent unboxed her yet
@@stephaniefriend9912 oooh!! Open yours first! I waited a bit for reasons, but you’ve waited long enough!
Yay this video was uploaded at a perfect time for my break at work!🥳
@@stephmariem luckily this is a shorter one (for me), but I hope I’m not interrupting anything…
I understand both sides of the argument, and I can agree with both. I wish they had an option to just buy the outfit by itself. I feel like they'd probably make more if they did both the display doll, and a separate 'just the outfit' option. I enjoy dressing my dolls up for holidays, but I don't have the space for multiple dolls, so I'm passing on her. But if they had an option to just buy the outfit, I would have been all over that.
@@caitlynv1167 oh yes I definitely understand not liking something - we all have different taste and different reasons to dislike something. I’ll never underhand telling other people they should refuse to buy something just because they don’t like it. As in, I’ll never understand disliking something enough to want others not to like it too 🥴
Hopefully they’ll release the outift one day - or anyone who wants it can find one on the secondary market for a good price
Interesting that it is woven cotton. I have an old outfit and it is flannel.
@@steph585 flannel??? Like soft fuzzy pjs flannel?? This outfit is a thick cotton. Not overly thick but thicker than Claudie’s meet dress for example.
I love all 3 of your Kirsten’s! You got a really beautiful St.Lucia Kirsten she looks so happy! Off topic question- did you preorder Moana? I can’t wait to see her in person!
@@EStern-18 I’m SO THRILLED with the St. Lucia Kirsten I got, what a relief!
Yes my Moana was delivered to my American address today, but I’m not sure when I’ll pick her up. Is yours on her way?
I’m gonna go pick her out in store! I’m very lucky that I live pretty close to the LA store. Can’t wait to see your review of her!
Hi Blaine I'm going to be doing the AGSurprise book reading challenge were we read as many of the surprise, Changes for and other Histocal and GOTY books that takes place during Christmas time. I'm starting the reading challenge on November 25th and ending the book reading challenge on Christmas Day. I posted a video about and I thought I'd let other AGTubers know and I did it because of this special edition Kirsten surprise doll. I want as many people to read the American Girl Christmas and holiday books.
@@tinmanlover1994 hmmm I don’t have many of the surprise books… maybe just this one ☠️
lol let me dig through my books and see what I’ve got!!
@DisBlaine in my video l linked a Google doc with just about every dolls holiday book on internet archives or run down to the library and bareow them. I'll be doing a more in depth video on the 25th when the book challenge starts
I picked her out at the store when she first came out. I have 3 PC Kirstens and now the LE Kirsten’s Surprise doll.
Where did you get the coat for your PC Kirsten? Love it!
@@nettiezdolls6742 how was she in store? Much variation? I’ve seen complaints of bad hair and the teeth stamped wrong.
Her winter coat was party of the special edition series. I got it from someone locally. Isn’t it adorable???
@@DisBlaine there was an in-store Holiday event early in November for Berry members. Mine is ok. I’m happy with her.
If you don't have a Kristin, I can see buying this doll. When I first saw her, I thought of the movie Midsommer.
@@iamsoverybored878 I think she’s also nice as a special doll to keep in box. I’m not sure why limited edition holiday dolls are a thing, but when they’re nice they’re nice lol
@DisBlaine I got a couple of holiday Barbies. I'm also half Jewish, so it sucks that they never made a Hanakah one. I made my own. I know AG has Hanakah stuff, but it's pricey.
@ did you collect the millennium twins… I’m only asking because they’re half Jewish too lol.
I wasn’t raised in any religion, but I still decorate my dolls for Hanukah because I lived with Jewish people when I was younger (long story)
@@DisBlaineof course se you know that Rebecca is Jewish, right?
People trashing summer made me so sad. I didn't let them make me feel bad about Kirsten though. She's always been one of my favorites. I love how much of a radical she is... And naughty lol😅
@@kerrysmiles after so many Summer videos came out, I felt so bad doing an opinion video about a doll I don’t have. I don’t think I’ll ever do that again.
@@DisBlaineit's okay. Once in a while we need to say what's on our minds. Those who are hurt by a negative review, should leave and find someone who did love her. And I know there were several. Noone should be so overly sensitive when none of it is personal. 😊
Summer is really beautiful in my opinion. Her accessories are not something really new, I think that is what bothers people about her.
@@brutallyhonestdollreviews I think you are right. I saw AG takes over's Kristie and her wife bought one, dressed it differently, and it is beautiful, IMHO . A lighter Nanea. So I succumbed.
@@lisbetsoda4874 I don't own any American girl dolls, but in my opinion the Nanea mold is the most beautiful one there is. Have you seen Moana?
I might be going nuts but your shirt looks like the pattern of Claudies Meet dress
@@pjrox93 haha my shirt is blue vertical stripes, but similar colors to her gingham dress. Maybe one day I’ll think to wear it when I show her.
Stop apologizing for making your videos too long😂 You are allowed to take up space literally we like it.
I agree!!!
@@kerrysmiles oh no, have I been doing that again??? I swear I stopped. I’ll try to be cognizant of that habit lol
@@diamondsanddollsDitto
LOL I cant believe you got her SMH. No shade she is a beautiful doll glad you got her. I need an extra Tiana dress for my grand daughters doll do you have any left for sale. Sorry about the loss of your ornaments. The berries and leaves are Lingon berry. I did not get the Kirsten doll because I have three Kirsten dolls and I only wanted the crown since I also have several St. Lucia dresses. Between the cost and just space it was not in the cards for me to get this doll.
@@nailahvenable7989 lol you’re surprised I got Kirsten’s Surprise??
Yeah I have a Tiana doll on the way and the original buyer backed out of her outfit. Canada post is on strike, so I’d have to aim to shop on one of my many trips to Buffalo.
You have several St Lucia dresses?? How? Yeah space is definitely an issue. I even have to figure out where I’ll store after the holidays ☠️
@@DisBlaine great no rush he much for the dress and I got the st. Lucia dresses on eBay and one in a shop goodwill lot. With a Kirsten doll. I am working on a diy for the crown wish me luck maybe by next year
@@DisBlaine Blain wanted to let you know I don't need the Tiana dress as My daughter bought the doll as it was on sale recently from AG I hope I did not inconvenience you. Thank you for considering me.
@ oh no worries! Haha that outfit became available in the first place because someone else bought her at that sale (which was when I bought the doll the outfit came from pahaaaaa!)
@@DisBlaine full circle thanks for your understanding. Did you score anything great at the sale. If yes looking forward to the video
She is beautiful, I’m just mad you are not matching outfit with her hahha, with Monster High happens the same, every single drop you see toma of people online hating… If they don’t like it is fine, don’t but it and move on, don’t know why they need to feed on the hate and people change their own opinions based on someone else’s…
@@NecrossVamp okay here’s an embarrassing secret - I don’t any white clothes so I’m wearing a shirt to match her meet outfit instead 🤓🤣
Yeah it’s weird how people want to chime in with criticism, but I’m even more disturbed by people who think because they don’t like something, no one else should enjoy it.
@@DisBlaineBlaine, get a white shirt! You'll love having one
@@DisBlaine I understand, all my clothes are black hahah
Awww, you got a cute one! I have my PC Kirsten girly, but I'm so tempted to get a "refreshed" new Kirsten. And while I already have this outfit, why the heck do I still want this???? My goddddddddduh. 🥴🥴🫨 But hey can I ask you which collector you're talking about that shares the numbers left of these collector dolls? Do you monitor this yourself? I'd like to be able to check these stock numbers myself but not exactly sure how people do it.
@@Kari-G it’s the beautiful presentation!! I might’ve been able to pass if she came in a regular box like the last wave of historicals.
The collector doesn’t have a channel. She adds hundreds to her cart (a number she knows will be too many) and the cart will get corrected with how many are left.
I tried once but gave up because it take wayyyyy too long!
@@DisBlaine YES, it's the presentation of Kirsten, you're totally right. I just have a weakness for her. I actually used to sing on St. Lucia Day with candles/wreaths and the whole shebang at my Swedish college in Southern Minnesota, so she's my girl. :). Ugh, I didn't think I needed a second Kirsten, but now I'm worried she's going to sell out. Thanks for letting me know about the "stock" check method. I figured that's how it works, but never actually tried it cause it seems like it would take forever just like you say....lol.
@ oh wow that is a cool connection!! I’m not saying this to be a bad influence but out of empathy… I feel like you’d regret it if you passed on her. You can put her away after the holidays if it’s a space issue. But this is a special release (imo)