Wow there's a reason she was made the minister of finance. She's so smart and eloquent and able to hit back so sharply. Living in the US I find Indian women in politics to be wayyyy more outspoken than the US :)
No matter how important and ultimate a question is, the answer has a potential to solve the query and therefore should be heard. The guy presumed that Nirmala Sitharaman was giving an example of parliamentarians of being marginalised themselves and comparing plight of such MPs of marginalised sections to plight of vegetable vendors from marginalised section. However she was saying that these MPs are representative of these people and must have given there opinion on the problems their own communities will face(vegetable vendors etc. the guy was talking about) But due to his stupidity we couldn't hear the answer. I so wanted to know what she wanted to say about those MPs who represent these classes but thank you Mr. Impatient you deprived me of this information and will remain a fool forever like this. Specimen JNU really.
Exactly!!! he did a blunder argument that left Mrs. Sitharaman from concluding the answer....he should regret for what he did 😅... (it's a sole opinion of mine and I don't want to insult anyone)
The amount of patience she held was outstanding. The smartness of most of the ministers of the Modi government forces me to vote for BJP. Even this time, I’m going to vote for the BJP.
now give me reason to support bjp.. you've missed manmohan Singh he said India will be in jeopardy now we're in.. do you have job?? or an good business right now 😂.. that's the difference between jnu they're educated able to envisage future.. education is more expensive..
Dude just keeping numb over your mistakes doesn't qualify you to be smart.😂 You lose there and there itself if you cannot give a credible answer for the mistakes you have done. 😂 How about Nirav Modi. How does he finance himself now if black money is being eradicated!
@@rohitgandhi4991 If you know how money laundering works you wouldn't be asking this question. And its not black money thats the money he scamed or stole from PNB.
And still NDTV is labelled as Anti BJP? If such seminsars are conducted on regular basis Bjp Could showcase their knowledge in a structured manner
4 роки тому
jithne bhi surveys hua tha 2019 main usme INDIA bottom 20 -30 main ake gir gayi bauth sare parameters main tho hum Bangladesh se bhi neeche hai IIT jisme gusne ke liye one of the toughest entrance exam likthe hai vo abhi top 400 best colleges main bhi nahi athi hai world wide JNU jo India ka best university mana jatha hai ithna ganda maintenance kiya jatha hai education ke liye GDP ka sirf 2.7% use hotha hai jo bahuth kum hai Bhutan se bhi kum aur usme bhi 40 lakh crore funds unused hai abhi hospitals main dang se ppe kit nahi ja rha aur modi ne naya jumla nikal diya ki hum bahar ppe kit export karenge , pehle apne desh ke logon ko tho dedo statue of unity jisko 3000 crore dekhe banaya tha ek bada failure tha aur agar us paise se hospitals banthe tho jyada kaam atha abhi jab india ka economy ithne downfall main hai humare modi ji ko naya parliament chaye , migrants ke travel ke liye paisa diya hotha tho unki mauth nahi hui hothi ek democratic country ke liye prime minister ya government ko accountable hona hotha hai lekin modi 0 press conference , data of farmer suicides- NA , DEATHS of Migrant - NA , jo bhi poocho not available 2018 main modi sarkar ne bola har ghar main bijli pahunch gayi hai lekin aji ghanta abhi bhi bahuth sare villages hai jahan na bijli hai na internet internet se yad aya kashmir assam aur kahin sare jage main frequent internet shutdown , world ke total internet shutdown main 67% india ka hai aur kya bola modi ne pakodebechne vale ko bhi employed mano tho mai kehtha hun use underemployed kehthe hai mathlab hoga tho vo commerce student ya engineer lekin pakode bech rha hai aur kahin cases main ye seasonal employement main atha hai ab bolo waah modi ji waah
JNU is PAGALKHANA i learn to use PayTm from my village boys who were using it as it is impossible to charge the mobile in village and i surprised a lot when they advised me to use EverNote also. these duffer in JNU have no iedia what is really village. village have good road water and electricity than cities today. i m sure these duffer will be fron bengal.
Please do not generalise. If 1 student is ill-informed and impatient then it doesn't mean the whole university is bad. Thode bohot namoone har jagah milte hain. And villages ki baat kari jaaye toh yes many of them are well off with good roads and electricity.. But majority of them are not.
haha.. can't even raise a question properly they call themselves larders?? that beard guy speaking about chai n dhoodwala he himself looking plumber so funny.. madam you just wasted your time
Rifaz hussain, u are a disgrace to Islam. Quran does not allow defamation of women in general. Go to the mosque to pray to allah like majority of Muslims do. Do not insult their faith by spewing hatred
🤣🤣😂😂 Lol Got the Same Idea Bro To my Surprise Well We are Contributing Ourselves to their Education by Paying Taxes But they seem to be Not Deserving For it
BTW none of them look like kids.... they all seem to be in the late 20s or early 30s . it's to the credit of the honorable minister that she graciously answered the students despite the hostile interviewer.
@@manuvirajkhare Nope i don't see any better arguments from radical communists...the type of garbage comes from their mouth is nothing but rants and pseudo politics.
By starting their question they didnt even greet her or they didnt even introduce themselves , they are sitting in front of finance minister , you should give respect .
Amazing.........They want to question her but not want to listen what she says. NDTV should remember thr r better universities in India other than JNU....try to go thr sumtime also!!!!
Manas Kale aree to india ki top most university m bhu ka naam aata h..bt wha ni jayenge ndtv wale qki wha k student pdhne wale hote h inki trh rajneeti krne wale ni..jindi padhai hi ni puri hoti 40 saal tk
Hi Mary u know after doing M Phil then followed by Phd how many years it will take just after your graduation I think this will help you in calculating their age should I calculate ok let's calculate at 3 yrs people start going school pre school is of 3 yrs nursery kg 1 kg2 at 6 yr of age person would be in 1st class then 12yrs of higher secondary which would be 12+3+3=18 yrs then 3 yrs graduation which would be 18+3=21 yrs 2 yrs of M Phil 21+2=23 yrs then phd 23+3yrs=26 yrs so exact age would be 26 yrs and if there is any drop in between or late admission in school can go upto 28 yrs so these people seems to be 26-28 isn't it.
@@rumman2883 @ thats why these chutiya people have so much time for afjal guru program after learning time period of the day. i heard that upto 28* year age government gives funding to enjoy such brand ( JNU)....
Miss Sitharaman very well handled the congressi bapsa and the leftist who were pretending that they are the only reprentative of the marginalised people.Accurate and upfront answers by the minister.
Is this the level of debate this bearded guy from NSUI want, I m not big BJP fan but the guy in beard is just behaving pathetic, allow nirmalaji to speak. This student clearly showed his political inclination towards Congress party.
There is no gain without pain. Demonitisation is an excellent and courageous step taken by BJP government.I too suffered little problem. But I am also a part of my country and I don't have any problem in that.
That said I am not affiliated with any political party, any religion, caste, last name, race, tribe, language, region, nationality, gender(women including LGBT) etc. I’m able to watch this program from few thousand miles away living in a different time-zone and be able to write this comment because I have a high-speed internet connection though I do not have an expensive TV connection. What about those in India who do not have electricity and internet?(especially those living in small towns and villages?) Hence let us accelerate on ‘war footing’ two most important infrastructure projects, Electricity and Internet proliferation (due to ‘Digital India’ campaign launched by PMji’s Government) to mitigate ignorance and reduce ‘information gap’ strengthening ties between all “human beings”(Manavatha Vadi/Insaaniyat) on earth and make the world one big global village (Vasudaiva Kutumbakam). Those who cannot travel around the world may still edify themselves and make friends with people around the planet via internet right from their own homes/facilities. Also I pray and wish a day dawns when one don’t need pay high tuition fees or travel across India (to institutes like JNU, IIT, IIM, AIMS, Hyderabad university etc.) or elsewhere in the world (like Ukraine, USA, Australia etc.) to study if one has no money to study sciences, medicine, business, law, politics, technologies, acting, cinema, sociology, psychology, philosophy, religion etc. Just a computer and internet connection will do. (It is possible to reduce the costs of education by a good mix of online classes & necessary in-person classroom lectures and labs.) Also, Girl-children who are under several restrictions by their traditional-parents could get educated from their own homes under supervision of their traditional parents. I beg all privileged (including you) travel around India and the world. I wish they not only enjoy their trips & take pictures/videos and “experience foods, nature, imaraten/buildings, shopping foreign mall, finding/getting/giving spouses, music, wine, dance, night-life and cultures” but also advise/teach their fellow human-beings their experiences/wisdom (old & new) for progress, peace, harmony and prosperity of not only the entire world but also of India. (Given a chance, like you, they are also keen, highly adaptive and always refine themselves!) I apologize if I said anything inconvenient. Majority of people in this world reason though they may be afraid to express themselves in public. The modern India(world) is faced with many grave challenges like poverty, malnutrition, pollution, corruption, dirty politics, extortions, mental diseases, riots, suicides, parasitic economies, prostitutes/concubines & their cuckolding, religiously-enforced-no-choice pregnancies, teen-pregnancies/marriages, divorces, gender inequalities(including LGBT), misguided proselytizations/religious terrorism, human-trafficking, Visa slavery, adverse climate changes and Global warming. Let us all humbly meditate and introspect “Do we, even now in 21st century, fight amongst ourselves and make children(especially girls) of Mother India cry or we now vow to, at least, wipe their tears properly with shame and dignity, let alone keep swearing again and again that we are gonna strive to protect them and make their lives better only if we have lots of funds?” STANDUP INDIA! STARTUP INDIA! Once again, please kindly forgive me if I said anything incorrect and wrong or hurt anyone’s feelings! I wholeheartedly felt it is my duty as a human being to submit this humble feedback/request/comment. I am open to criticisms/corrections/feedback. I am not an expert or respected but only a common Indian citizen (a looser begging for Justice & Unity not for money). Also due to time constraints, please kindly forgive my Indlish mistakes too! I will correct my Indlish mistakes as time permits! Satyameva Jayathe! Kal Gandikota Note: I am not paid to comment and not seeking favors. I made this comment so I get replies from fellow viewers to educate myself. I am not affiliated with any political party, any religion, any caste, tribe, last name, media, NGO, business or any Government institution. Hence, if anyone uses this comment for making their decisions, I am not responsible for any failures incurred. Before my voice is suppressed copy to 1. All Political Parties of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world 2. Tribes of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world 3. NGOs(including religious missionaries) of the world 4. News Media/Papers of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world 5. Banned revolutionaries of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world 6. Translators of all languages of the universe 7. All sapient beings of the universe 8. All sentient beings of the universe
Even today, after 12 years later, I can't speak to my school principal in that manner. And that bearded person doesn't have any realisation that he is speaking to a Union Commerce Minister.
Gaurav arre to jnu ka h n..khd ko bht smart smjh rha h..bt h ni..ye uski gltfehmi h..isko khte h ghmnd..thoda sa pdha v h ya ni apne ap ko Einstein smjh rha pgla😂
Why wouldn't they turn to an uncle during their graduation? They get free accommodation, free food, free education and freedom of practicing chutiyapa. Why would they even leave such a heavenly palace?
Black money can be in any form be it real estate, gold etc.. but it always starts and ends in cash. So Demonetization was necessary. And due to digitising economy by pushing people to be more cashless by using debit cards ..corruption will be reduced. And India is so huge with billion people, no matter how much good plans u do to execute such plans ,it won't work extremely perfect.. there would always be some issues.. that shouldn't make us stop conducting such huge plans
Hey bro,nope she was spot on..we admire her for her staunch answers..she singlehandedly and coll headedly answered everyone but at the same time mocked the guys who needed it..hats of to the great leaders of modi cabinet..
dont insult the left by callling them left these are sudoleftists who just wan to win an argument facts dont matter to them...jst winning the argument by hook or by crook....chutiya sala
They are not very meritorious student they just take admission in JNU you know foreign language, or any stupid subject , just for get a stamp of JNU so they people think that oooo oo JNU ole baba ye bohot intelligent hoga,,, Thank's to MODI govt atleast I just got to know that there are also so many Bhanchods in this CAMPUS,,,, now I did not feel any inferiority complex now... :)
Could have got all Indian currencies printed at 12 different nation SK, Japan, UK, USA, EU, UAE. Within 6 months entire system would have changed. Developed nations would be stunned looking at Currency Printing cost at 40,000 crores and demonitization losses of upto 7 trillion rupees, still continuing. Totally summing upto to approximately, 10 trillion rupees. This is called ultimate madness. Should have discussed with UK, USA, UAE, EU, Japan, & SK for printing currencies of India at their nations within 6 to 10 months , with a smooth transtision. When 130 crore people, present their old notes, its automatically replaced with same values printed abroad. Simple Economics. 40-50,000 crores printing cost, a massacre of democracy by Marginalized MPs.
if someone is reading this ..... the student shown as a jnu president of nsui was not letting her speak and then was telling others "let her speak" . what a level of Hippocracy. and thanks to NDTV to show this even though this channel has degraded it's own benchmark standards of reporting still u unknowingly exposed JNU IDEOLOGY.
Nice example of women empowerment.I just loved the way she treated every student leader just as a student. A best example of a minister who is clear with her thoughts and action.Superb.Salute.
The question was not about who was marginalised and who was not. The only things that can be inferred is that the Congress student wing president wanted an explanation about the people who suffered due to the backlash of demonetisation and introduction of digital payment without adequate infrastructure. Our finance minister does seem boiled by the stance he takes which is not wrong. But, diverting an answer to bring it to constitutional aspects of our country does not seem right either. Yes, there are people representing the marginalised but either way why aren't they being uplifted If there's so much representation? So, maybe only representation is not the answer. The guy didn't let her talk. She didn't listen to him. And we see a potentially good question get lost in the debate.
After seeing this debate now I able to understand that why congress seats are declining day by day. Their main problem was that they are unable to understand the real situation like their Top leaders ...
Mr.beard u r biased....u should be more practical with some examples who are likely to use now ATM, Paytm,phonepe.....in my locatity a thelawal now starting use Paytm with a smartphone....
To NDTV, a quick suggestion, pls put date of post for the comments as well...it will be great to verify the veracity of the claims made without any foresight.
Soo much to learn from our Honble FM. She is Pride Of Our Nation. These kids are just on the path of leftists. But So unfortunate not a single student was able to defend a single point they posed.
That guy with bed sheet or Wat ever.. See his mannerism his posture of seating such an attitude and the way he was addressing defence minister .. Yuck. Don't sponsor these people education.. Fully arrogance
Nirmalaji, you are great person. Your replies are very apt and sincere. But some students with sickly mind don't understand your point of view. We, the people of India can easily understand your motive behind the de-monitation
Vibhor S Dalaal of BJP.... and I THINK Another Wife of Modi...!!!! haha 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Modi Murdabad.... And their bhakt also murdabad....!!!! All supporter of BJP are antinational... They should be treated like traitors....!!!!! JAI HIND JAI BHARAT....!!!!
@@curious9650 I am sorry already if it offends u but HOW IN EARTH DO YOU HOLD SUCH AN AUDACITY TO SPEAK WITH SUCH DISRESPECT FOR A WOMAN .....it's not a matter of a party or anything but very very basic manners
I admire and appreciate the way she dealt with them. I've seen the entire debate (this isn't the complete version) and realised that whatever she said soothed all the questions that came her way. The students were impatient at many instances and hell bent on their points. It didn't look as if they were looking for solutions rather it was quite the opposite.
Even after demonitization my family didn't suffered , yes we had some problems regarding transaction of money after demonitization .... But that was ok unlike these people who are trying to make it a big issue... If you dont have any black money why you will worry??
Nowadays vegetable vendors are readily accepting phone pay / Paytm / Google pay... so this proves BJP govt had so far successfully implemented the financial inclusion project.
1- Black money was hoarded at various forms, Less than 4% of black money was at currency. # Govt was made hectic suffer to underprivilege people, daily wages labours and small traders despite it can curbs less than 4% black money. 2- When PM announcing the demonetization he said high denomination 500/1K currency is are major notes for hoarding. # Later introduced 2K notes. Which Economist expert have those suggestion ?. Every wrong decision by govt, bottom class people will having worst impact... It does mean Govt not considering all class people.
We have a great breed of economist in JNU with great background in current scenarios. Stupids of JNU doing more creative and constructive work in their respective research field. What makes more painful that they wasting money and time of respected govt and people of India.
the students are right to an extent, this policy does not really effect their chance of livelihood . Also Finance Minister need to know how to differentiate between policy of short run and long run policy to really be effective for both
All students are just blown away by her personality, they even don't know what they are asking what they want to know.
Wow there's a reason she was made the minister of finance. She's so smart and eloquent and able to hit back so sharply. Living in the US I find Indian women in politics to be wayyyy more outspoken than the US :)
If this is the level of so called "student leaders" in India, China has nothing to worry about.
I totally agree with you 😂😂, but it is sad for India.
Jnu student thinks they have seen all problems and only they are studying in this country
Exactly🤦♀️
student psychologies. especially JNU
😂😂
No need to ban JNU just kick out useless 40 years old students who are only doing politics.
Make it pain in the ass.
soul is lord with ur mom.
U r all born by mixture of many dnas..
Bjp is a waste and worst party misleading india towards dust.
Well said
She's so bold that's a real woman.
Nirmala the real JNU stuff
No matter how important and ultimate a question is, the answer has a potential to solve the query and therefore should be heard.
The guy presumed that Nirmala Sitharaman was giving an example of parliamentarians of being marginalised themselves and comparing plight of such MPs of marginalised sections to plight of vegetable vendors from marginalised section. However she was saying that these MPs are representative of these people and must have given there opinion on the problems their own communities will face(vegetable vendors etc. the guy was talking about) But due to his stupidity we couldn't hear the answer. I so wanted to know what she wanted to say about those MPs who represent these classes but thank you Mr. Impatient you deprived me of this information and will remain a fool forever like this. Specimen JNU really.
Exactly!!! he did a blunder argument that left Mrs. Sitharaman from concluding the answer....he should regret for what he did 😅... (it's a sole opinion of mine and I don't want to insult anyone)
Exactly I was curious to know her answer but because of his disability to listen or even frame a coherent sentence, we missed out
@@prabhanjankr5471 come on dude there shud b no guilt for insulting this useless dumbasss....
@@prabhanjankr5471 well we know that guy was president of NSUI Congress. So we should know from where they are getting this disability.
Impatient Moron he was... Know what to ask but no guts to hear the other side... Such a waste
I feel like banging my head after listening to the questions of these student leaders. 😤
Me too
Lets do it together brother
These are not student leaders they are useless beggers feeding on govt scholarships no knowledge of ground reality
True... N they behave arrogantly too
@@thannerulavanya4117 accha what they would have asked or rather praised BJP...that would have satisfied u?
The amount of patience she held was outstanding. The smartness of most of the ministers of the Modi government forces me to vote for BJP.
Even this time, I’m going to vote for the BJP.
now give me reason to support bjp.. you've missed manmohan Singh he said India will be in jeopardy now we're in.. do you have job?? or an good business right now 😂.. that's the difference between jnu they're educated able to envisage future.. education is more expensive..
Dude just keeping numb over your mistakes doesn't qualify you to be smart.😂 You lose there and there itself if you cannot give a credible answer for the mistakes you have done. 😂
How about Nirav Modi. How does he finance himself now if black money is being eradicated!
Stupid donkey
@@removing.complexity are you really that stupid dear, trying reason with bjp supporter🤣🤣
@@rohitgandhi4991 If you know how money laundering works you wouldn't be asking this question. And its not black money thats the money he scamed or stole from PNB.
And still NDTV is labelled as Anti BJP? If such seminsars are conducted on regular basis Bjp Could showcase their knowledge in a structured manner
jithne bhi surveys hua tha 2019 main usme INDIA bottom 20 -30 main ake gir gayi
bauth sare parameters main tho hum Bangladesh se bhi neeche hai
IIT jisme gusne ke liye one of the toughest entrance exam likthe hai vo abhi top 400 best colleges main bhi nahi athi hai world wide
JNU jo India ka best university mana jatha hai ithna ganda maintenance kiya jatha hai
education ke liye GDP ka sirf 2.7% use hotha hai jo bahuth kum hai Bhutan se bhi kum aur usme bhi 40 lakh crore funds unused hai
abhi hospitals main dang se ppe kit nahi ja rha aur modi ne naya jumla nikal diya ki hum bahar ppe kit export karenge , pehle apne desh ke logon ko tho dedo
statue of unity jisko 3000 crore dekhe banaya tha ek bada failure tha aur agar us paise se hospitals banthe tho jyada kaam atha
abhi jab india ka economy ithne downfall main hai humare modi ji ko naya parliament chaye , migrants ke travel ke liye paisa diya hotha tho unki mauth nahi hui hothi
ek democratic country ke liye prime minister ya government ko accountable hona hotha hai lekin modi 0 press conference , data of farmer suicides- NA , DEATHS of Migrant - NA , jo bhi poocho not available
2018 main modi sarkar ne bola har ghar main bijli pahunch gayi hai lekin aji ghanta abhi bhi bahuth sare villages hai jahan na bijli hai na internet
internet se yad aya kashmir assam aur kahin sare jage main frequent internet shutdown , world ke total internet shutdown main 67% india ka hai
aur kya bola modi ne pakodebechne vale ko bhi employed mano tho mai kehtha hun use underemployed kehthe hai mathlab hoga tho vo commerce student ya engineer lekin pakode bech rha hai aur kahin cases main ye seasonal employement main atha hai
ab bolo waah modi ji waah
Bro it backs to 2016
@@aryamanchauhan1438 but bjp stopped sending their ministers to NDTV after 2014
Well I guess they thought the leftist JNU lecturer's students will roast her. Then they realized that she makes them look like fools.
JNU is PAGALKHANA i learn to use PayTm from my village boys who were using it as it is impossible to charge the mobile in village and i surprised a lot when they advised me to use EverNote also. these duffer in JNU have no iedia what is really village. village have good road water and electricity than cities today.
i m sure these duffer will be fron bengal.
Nice jokes.
Don't through insults on bengal...that is recist... And shows ur true aukat and education
Please do not generalise. If 1 student is ill-informed and impatient then it doesn't mean the whole university is bad. Thode bohot namoone har jagah milte hain.
And villages ki baat kari jaaye toh yes many of them are well off with good roads and electricity.. But majority of them are not.
She was handled JNU pretty well...
haha.. can't even raise a question properly they call themselves larders?? that beard guy speaking about chai n dhoodwala he himself looking plumber so funny.. madam you just wasted your time
rahul dumu 😂😂✌
rahul dumu 👌
Stray dogs are barking in the background.
Rifaz hussain, u are a disgrace to Islam. Quran does not allow defamation of women in general. Go to the mosque to pray to allah like majority of Muslims do. Do not insult their faith by spewing hatred
@@rifazhussain5469 Beedi smoking low self esteemed damaged 80s minded idiots. 😅
She(Nirmala Sitaraman)is very strong enough to handle any Stupid
20:10 Though his question was geniune he did have the patience to listen and he paid for it
U meant he didn't? 😜
nirmala ji is brilliant in this debate..she just burn there egos to ground
Exactly!
Omg! Never knew I am paying taxes so that these types of people get free education?
*I'll not waste my money anymore*
Your tax money also used for army, hospitals, schools, infrastructure and what not. Its a betrayal whenever someone's evades tax
🤣🤣😂😂 Lol Got the Same Idea Bro To my Surprise Well We are Contributing Ourselves to their Education by Paying Taxes But they seem to be Not Deserving For it
You are right bro
ModiG needs 5 more women like Nirmala Sitaram
why just 5?
But why?
Modi is not muslim
তখন ভারতে আর মানুষ থাকবেনা । থাকবে শুধু গরু আর আবাল ।
I hope your happy
What an awesome lady. Lot of respect for her. She had an answer for everything. Intelligent lady.
BTW none of them look like kids.... they all seem to be in the late 20s or early 30s . it's to the credit of the honorable minister that she graciously answered the students despite the hostile interviewer.
I'm proud of the women in BJP. I wish this was the same for the men as well.
Kudos to nirmala ma'am . Nailed downed the novice kids....
Anyone wondered how come the anchor knows most of the students by their direct name.
Krishna Oza ghar ki Baat h inkii
Yeah I thought that too... Must have rehearsed together many a times ....
Omg she is so elegant and graceful 🇮🇳🇮🇳 what a positive aura mam u have 🙏🙏
Right bro
Jnu needs better English professors. Maybe also common sane people that are not Communists. 😃
Even communists make better arguments.
@@manuvirajkhare Nope i don't see any better arguments from radical communists...the type of garbage comes from their mouth is nothing but rants and pseudo politics.
Each and every answer was given with a perfect flow. She is an absolute confident of what she knows and says.
What grace.
By starting their question they didnt even greet her or they didnt even introduce themselves , they are sitting in front of finance minister , you should give respect .
May God save these students from becoming another kanhaiya.
I want to see her as PM modi's utaradhikari. The way she turns the arguments is what we need to get many things done. Her words make her.!!
Very smart responses.......thanks Minister....Modiji ki jai
Amazing.........They want to question her but not want to listen what she says.
NDTV should remember thr r better universities in India other than JNU....try to go thr sumtime also!!!!
Well JNU is the topmost university in this country
@@jenniferdsouza2105 not for long if they keep taking these type of silly fellows
Manas Kale aree to india ki top most university m bhu ka naam aata h..bt wha ni jayenge ndtv wale qki wha k student pdhne wale hote h inki trh rajneeti krne wale ni..jindi padhai hi ni puri hoti 40 saal tk
JNU is the topmost university of India bete. Ab isse chahiye tho USA jao
@@amarr8483 But it still is good yr believe it or not, Staying away from protests it whole different liberal environment
Such a shame.. See the difference between Honorable Defense Minister and these "new breed" both who graduated from same college.
hey by the way what is the age limit u cn b called '' student ''of jnu ????????
Mary Jones above 60
Good question Example kanayachutiya kumar
Hahaha
Hi Mary u know after doing M Phil then followed by Phd how many years it will take just after your graduation I think this will help you in calculating their age should I calculate ok let's calculate at 3 yrs people start going school pre school is of 3 yrs nursery kg 1 kg2 at 6 yr of age person would be in 1st class then 12yrs of higher secondary which would be 12+3+3=18 yrs then 3 yrs graduation which would be 18+3=21 yrs 2 yrs of M Phil
21+2=23 yrs then phd 23+3yrs=26 yrs so exact age would be 26 yrs and if there is any drop in between or late admission in school can go upto 28 yrs so these people seems to be 26-28 isn't it.
@@rumman2883 @ thats why these chutiya people have so much time for afjal guru program after learning time period of the day. i heard that upto 28* year age government gives funding to enjoy such brand ( JNU)....
Miss Sitharaman very well handled the congressi bapsa and the leftist who were pretending that they are the only reprentative of the marginalised people.Accurate and upfront answers by the minister.
where is that presstitute burkha dutta khan...
Kosaraju Basavapunniah you miss burkha khala
😂
listening is a big skill. go get it Mr. Beard. " New uncles on the block " + Bad hosting.
Is this the level of debate this bearded guy from NSUI want, I m not big BJP fan but the guy in beard is just behaving pathetic, allow nirmalaji to speak. This student clearly showed his political inclination towards Congress party.
There is no gain without pain. Demonitisation is an excellent and courageous step taken by BJP government.I too suffered little problem. But I am also a part of my country and I don't have any problem in that.
I m from Nepal and I would say BJP has Elected so pure and talented people not poppu like rahul
Oh very pure, see now what's those talented people are doing now.
Nirmala conquered Left bastion JNU
Sh Sh - Nirmala Sitharaman graduated from JNU
That said I am not affiliated with any political party, any religion, caste, last name, race, tribe, language, region, nationality, gender(women including LGBT) etc.
I’m able to watch this program from few thousand miles away living in a different time-zone and be able to write this comment because I have a high-speed internet connection though I do not have an expensive TV connection. What about those in India who do not have electricity and internet?(especially those living in small towns and villages?) Hence let us accelerate on ‘war footing’ two most important infrastructure projects, Electricity and Internet proliferation (due to ‘Digital India’ campaign launched by PMji’s Government) to mitigate ignorance and reduce ‘information gap’ strengthening ties between all “human beings”(Manavatha Vadi/Insaaniyat) on earth and make the world one big global village (Vasudaiva Kutumbakam). Those who cannot travel around the world may still edify themselves and make friends with people around the planet via internet right from their own homes/facilities.
Also I pray and wish a day dawns when one don’t need pay high tuition fees or travel across India (to institutes like JNU, IIT, IIM, AIMS, Hyderabad university etc.) or elsewhere in the world (like Ukraine, USA, Australia etc.) to study if one has no money to study sciences, medicine, business, law, politics, technologies, acting, cinema, sociology, psychology, philosophy, religion etc. Just a computer and internet connection will do. (It is possible to reduce the costs of education by a good mix of online classes & necessary in-person classroom lectures and labs.) Also, Girl-children who are under several restrictions by their traditional-parents could get educated from their own homes under supervision of their traditional parents.
I beg all privileged (including you) travel around India and the world. I wish they not only enjoy their trips & take pictures/videos and “experience foods, nature, imaraten/buildings, shopping foreign mall, finding/getting/giving spouses, music, wine, dance, night-life and cultures” but also advise/teach their fellow human-beings their experiences/wisdom (old & new) for progress, peace, harmony and prosperity of not only the entire world but also of India. (Given a chance, like you, they are also keen, highly adaptive and always refine themselves!)
I apologize if I said anything inconvenient. Majority of people in this world reason though they may be afraid to express themselves in public. The modern India(world) is faced with many grave challenges like poverty, malnutrition, pollution, corruption, dirty politics, extortions, mental diseases, riots, suicides, parasitic economies, prostitutes/concubines & their cuckolding, religiously-enforced-no-choice pregnancies, teen-pregnancies/marriages, divorces, gender inequalities(including LGBT), misguided proselytizations/religious terrorism, human-trafficking, Visa slavery, adverse climate changes and Global warming. Let us all humbly meditate and introspect
“Do we, even now in 21st century, fight amongst ourselves and make children(especially girls) of Mother India cry or we now vow to, at least, wipe their tears properly with shame and dignity, let alone keep swearing again and again that we are gonna strive to protect them and make their lives better only if we have lots of funds?”
STANDUP INDIA! STARTUP INDIA!
Once again, please kindly forgive me if I said anything incorrect and wrong or hurt anyone’s feelings! I wholeheartedly felt it is my duty as a human being to submit this humble feedback/request/comment. I am open to criticisms/corrections/feedback. I am not an expert or respected but only a common Indian citizen (a looser begging for Justice & Unity not for money). Also due to time constraints, please kindly forgive my Indlish mistakes too! I will correct my Indlish mistakes as time permits!
Satyameva Jayathe!
Kal Gandikota
Note: I am not paid to comment and not seeking favors. I made this comment so I get replies from fellow viewers to educate myself. I am not affiliated with any political party, any religion, any caste, tribe, last name, media, NGO, business or any Government institution. Hence, if anyone uses this comment for making their decisions, I am not responsible for any failures incurred. Before my voice is suppressed copy to 1. All Political Parties of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
2. Tribes of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
3. NGOs(including religious missionaries) of the world
4. News Media/Papers of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
5. Banned revolutionaries of India, Pakistan, Bangla Desh and the world
6. Translators of all languages of the universe
7. All sapient beings of the universe
8. All sentient beings of the universe
Kal Gandikota fog
ghnnnnn.m..mhjhjkjkcbm
Sitharaman has taught me how just having and exuding confidence while conversing can project a well known lie as the golden truth. Lesson learnt.
bullshit.
nonsense
In Bengaluru my 99% value of transactions are in Digital
Even today, after 12 years later, I can't speak to my school principal in that manner.
And that bearded person doesn't have any realisation that he is speaking to a Union Commerce Minister.
he was saying reservation is propoganda.......lol
That's not the case here. One should be confident enough to question any one but the way he was behaving is questionable
Gaurav arre to jnu ka h n..khd ko bht smart smjh rha h..bt h ni..ye uski gltfehmi h..isko khte h ghmnd..thoda sa pdha v h ya ni apne ap ko Einstein smjh rha pgla😂
do they look like students....
or
"" UNCLE"'
Uncle
Even I thought the same
Why wouldn't they turn to an uncle during their graduation? They get free accommodation, free food, free education and freedom of practicing chutiyapa. Why would they even leave such a heavenly palace?
😀😀😀😀😀they are upcoming leaders
Students by profession and elders by age😄
There's a Bengali word for JNU students: PONDPAKA
He said dudh wala don’t use paytm welcome to 2019😂
JNU has gone down the drains in terms of quality of education
Black money can be in any form be it real estate, gold etc.. but it always starts and ends in cash. So Demonetization was necessary. And due to digitising economy by pushing people to be more cashless by using debit cards ..corruption will be reduced. And India is so huge with billion people, no matter how much good plans u do to execute such plans ,it won't work extremely perfect.. there would always be some issues.. that shouldn't make us stop conducting such huge plans
Nice debate but she avoiding questions...
She should keep her cool and respond patiently even if others ask provoking questions. I totally back modi on demonetization.
I think she kept her cool quite well.
Hey bro,nope she was spot on..we admire her for her staunch answers..she singlehandedly and coll headedly answered everyone but at the same time mocked the guys who needed it..hats of to the great leaders of modi cabinet..
Umesh Ram Yarlagadda haha bhakt what happened now?
Full of anti-nationalist in the name of students in JNU...
Dadhi wala GADU was not clapping at the time of interaction... Frustration of LEFT current condition in India
dont insult the left by callling them left these are sudoleftists who just wan to win an argument facts dont matter to them...jst winning the argument by hook or by crook....chutiya sala
They are not very meritorious student they just take admission in JNU you know foreign language, or any stupid subject , just for get a stamp of JNU so they people think that oooo oo JNU ole baba ye bohot intelligent hoga,,, Thank's to MODI govt atleast I just got to know that there are also so many Bhanchods in this CAMPUS,,,, now I did not feel any inferiority complex now... :)
Yash Baisla
Yes .No respect at all. Useless person
Rajesh Verma I also notice that
JNU anti nationalists nt aware about RBI provisions,bankingregulation,& tax laws. so that they ask cheap questions..
Could have got all Indian currencies printed at 12 different nation SK, Japan, UK, USA, EU, UAE. Within 6 months entire system would have changed.
Developed nations would be stunned looking at Currency Printing cost at 40,000 crores and demonitization losses of upto 7 trillion rupees, still continuing. Totally summing upto to approximately, 10 trillion rupees.
This is called ultimate madness. Should have discussed with UK, USA, UAE, EU, Japan, & SK for printing currencies of India at their nations within 6 to 10 months , with a smooth transtision. When 130 crore people, present their old notes, its automatically replaced with same values printed abroad. Simple Economics.
40-50,000 crores printing cost, a massacre of democracy by Marginalized MPs.
Most of then seems tutored for a straight phrased question but panic when asked to explain the real problem !!
She is trying to hide answer by suppressing and scolding,...hell it
Yes seems so
No thats not true they are getting impatient as like they have been waiting to put her down
Wow! Gr8! Bold, courageous and smart
Why all the jnu students look like sadak-chhap!
@@ashutoshuke2998 burnol bheju kya
if someone is reading this .....
the student shown as a jnu president of nsui was not letting her speak and then was telling others "let her speak" . what a level of Hippocracy. and thanks to NDTV to show this even though this channel has degraded it's own benchmark standards of reporting still u unknowingly exposed JNU IDEOLOGY.
Nice example of women empowerment.I just loved the way she treated every student leader just as a student. A best example of a minister who is clear with her thoughts and action.Superb.Salute.
The question was not about who was marginalised and who was not. The only things that can be inferred is that the Congress student wing president wanted an explanation about the people who suffered due to the backlash of demonetisation and introduction of digital payment without adequate infrastructure. Our finance minister does seem boiled by the stance he takes which is not wrong. But, diverting an answer to bring it to constitutional aspects of our country does not seem right either. Yes, there are people representing the marginalised but either way why aren't they being uplifted If there's so much representation? So, maybe only representation is not the answer. The guy didn't let her talk. She didn't listen to him. And we see a potentially good question get lost in the debate.
JNU students call them Scholars 😂😂
she clearly nailed it!
After seeing this debate now I able to understand that why congress seats are declining day by day. Their main problem was that they are unable to understand the real situation like their Top leaders ...
Awesome interview. The way Nirmala Sitaramanji answered the question was very awesome.
Mr.beard u r biased....u should be more practical with some examples who are likely to use now ATM, Paytm,phonepe.....in my locatity a thelawal now starting use Paytm with a smartphone....
Mallu girl studying on tax payer's money asking false question
At 21:50 the lady asks "Is it not a corruption?" R.I.P. Grammar
What's wrong in it?
O please, try to get the idea also, rather then focusing only on English... Its not a literature class of English going on after all.
One nirmala is enough for whole JNU
0:40 "Let's have a big hand for our Union Minister" tap tap' on phone
He just didn't have that courtesy...why don't he question the Congress regime like that!!!!!!!
To NDTV, a quick suggestion, pls put date of post for the comments as well...it will be great to verify the veracity of the claims made without any foresight.
She was behaving like a teacher 😂
A great teacher.
Soo much to learn from our Honble FM.
She is Pride Of Our Nation.
These kids are just on the path of leftists.
But
So unfortunate not a single student was able to defend a single point they posed.
That guy with bed sheet or Wat ever.. See his mannerism his posture of seating such an attitude and the way he was addressing defence minister .. Yuck. Don't sponsor these people education.. Fully arrogance
Yep
Powerful lady Niramala seetharaman. Hats off
She doesn't answer the question antha bakth
Nirmalaji, you are great person. Your replies are very apt and sincere. But some students with sickly mind don't understand your point of view. We, the people of India can easily understand your motive behind the de-monitation
wow ironlady..
tricky chacha - Fraud lady she is
Vibhor S Dalaal of BJP.... and I THINK Another Wife of Modi...!!!! haha 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Modi Murdabad.... And their bhakt also murdabad....!!!! All supporter of BJP are antinational... They should be treated like traitors....!!!!! JAI HIND JAI BHARAT....!!!!
oh yeah she is a bold speaker but she is justifying every bad and evils...this is not done!
@@curious9650 I am sorry already if it offends u but HOW IN EARTH DO YOU HOLD SUCH AN AUDACITY TO SPEAK WITH SUCH DISRESPECT FOR A WOMAN .....it's not a matter of a party or anything but very very basic manners
I admire and appreciate the way she dealt with them. I've seen the entire debate (this isn't the complete version) and realised that whatever she said soothed all the questions that came her way.
The students were impatient at many instances and hell bent on their points. It didn't look as if they were looking for solutions rather it was quite the opposite.
Sunny Dhiman is very rude and uninformed. Never allows people to speak and always interrupts.
thank u madam good replied to cong group students
She has done a very good job
Possibility some people don't want the vegetable vendor or milk man to be a smart guy....
Even after demonitization my family didn't suffered , yes we had some problems regarding transaction of money after demonitization .... But that was ok unlike these people who are trying to make it a big issue... If you dont have any black money why you will worry??
Because you are not a farmer, a daily wage worker, from poor family background. Why would you have problem.
kudos to Nirmala sitharaman !!such a powerful woman
You are a great Nirmala madam 👍
I like the way nirmala madam answering very cool
Nowadays vegetable vendors are readily accepting phone pay / Paytm / Google pay... so this proves BJP govt had so far successfully implemented the financial inclusion project.
NDTV news app is not available for Apple or Microsoft phones and only for Android ones. Why?
Napoleon4778 because they are Naxalite. iphone and Microsoft are symbol of capitalism.
UA-cam philosopher Hahaha, good one!
But Android (Google) is also a sign of capitalism, ain't it? ;-)
1- Black money was hoarded at various forms, Less than 4% of black money was at currency. # Govt was made hectic suffer to underprivilege people, daily wages labours and small traders despite it can curbs less than 4% black money.
2- When PM announcing the demonetization he said high denomination 500/1K currency is are major notes for hoarding. # Later introduced 2K notes. Which
Economist expert have those suggestion ?.
Every wrong decision by govt, bottom class people will having worst impact... It does mean Govt not considering all class people.
these all duffers are on one side, and our Sitaraman is handling them single handedly
they Are talking to the the finance minister of India pls show some respect
We have a great breed of economist in JNU with great background in current scenarios. Stupids of JNU doing more creative and constructive work in their respective research field. What makes more painful that they wasting money and time of respected govt and people of India.
Are those dogs howling in the background??
They sound sweeter than these pseudo secular liberals.
I pity the dogs of JNU. No dog deserves this.
No matter what your viewpoint, the rudeness is not acceptable. The union minister has an equal right to voice her pov.
Almost 5 years down the line I still can't see the poor using digital transaction
the students are right to an extent, this policy does not really effect their chance of livelihood . Also Finance Minister need to know how to differentiate between policy of short run and long run policy to really be effective for both
A better reply would have been "I don't eat much of onion and garlic"
At 3:13 what drama these politicians are doing.
he didn't even want to hear her answer!!
this guy should mind his manner first , just coz he is talking to a political leader but to a women ....