I loved hearing you sing a song that had totally different vibe from usual - glad to finally get to see the video! Fantastic work as always, Kiwawa-senpai!!!
When Kiara said she wanted a punk/emo song on the album, I honestly didn't expect it would be so perfect. Like, wow. This went beyond my wildest expectations. Once again she proves why she should not be underestimated.
@pumpkincoffee Kiara originally mentioned wanting to do a song like Paramore, one of her favorite punk bands, so that's why I mentioned it. The result ended up more like emo-rock, tho.
I really like how "clean" this MV is. I think it conveys a lot of emotion in a really refined way. It's also really easy to read the lyrics, something that's useful with an MV like this.
Kiara was the first vtuber I discovered who shared a love for early Y2K punk rock, and seeing her have her own song in this style made me immensely proud!
This right here. I'd heard her previous lighthearted songs, but the CLARITY and downright gorgeousness of her voice on this album absolutely blew me away and stunned me.
[Verse 1] Oh baby, I'm looking at what remains I couldn't tell you the same, I guess that's life If you couldn't tell by now, I'm hopelessly waiting Begging all night to break through Stuck in an endless loop, I'll deny the truth Asking why [Chorus] I can't redo The past and present calls me to truth And every part of my being doubts the best feeling So tell me what am I to you? I can't renew The part of me I lost in the view Hooked up on all the wavering eyes leaves me paralyzed Taking two stеps back but I keep moving on [Verse 2] Concern is filling up your lies, once again I'm all but brokеn I'll save me if I can, ah let it go, let it go, breathe again If you couldn't tell by now, I'm hopelessly wasting Away to the core inside It keeps eating away at me everyday Asking why [Chorus] I can't redo The past and present calls me to truth And every part of my being doubts the best feeling So tell me what am I to you? I can't renew The part of me I lost in the view Hooked up on all the wavering eyes leaves me paralyzed Taking two steps back but I keep moving on [Post-Chorus] And I tried to change me but my mind can't just erase me anymore than I have already done And looking back I'm ready to admit it was all me who destroyed everything I am [Bridge] Caught up in my demise (Caught up and I can't ignite) The doubt puts out my light I can't be sure of who I am or when I'm alive [Chorus] I can't redo The past and present calls me to truth And every part of my being doubts the best feeling So tell me what am I to you? [Outro] Ooh Oh I am Turning back
Jeezas, Mamaloni just cranked the edginess up to 11 for this one...as it should be Smol, cute EmoWawa from 4blood has all grown up. Now the stage belongs to the hard-core and mature Gothiara❤🖤❤🖤❤
There is NO WAY this "only" has 300k views. I'm listening to all of Hololive's songs, and this would easily take 1st or 2nd place and stay there for a while. Thank you Kiara for this masterpiece ❤
I really love how kiara is tackling styles outside of the typical anime/jpop genres. They may not be as popular in the Hololive community but i think they have a chance of appealing to fans outside of the vtuber sphere.
Edited : You know that feeling when you're listening to a song that immerses you in these incredible emotions because, they remind you of something you've once had or been? Retrospective does that to me. Because I've been someone incredibly different back then, compared to who I am now. And just like what the lyrics mention, I can't change the past. The only thing to do, is learn from it, take two steps into the future and move on with life. Because the only way to succeed in life is going forward. 🧡🧡 Thank you for the wonderful new music video for Retrospective, Wawa. I felt how deep this song was to you, seeing how your journey as a HoloLive idol progressed over the years - and turned you into the majestic phoenix that you are now. Big ups to Mamaloni's art and the team who worked on this MV. This was amazing, and once again, I won't hesitate to share Point of View and its songs to everyone i know - because they're your songs, Wawa. 🧡🧡🧡✨
We always see genki Kiwawa, it’s easy to forget everyone has self doubts and negative thoughts. This song is a beautiful representation of those flaws and challenges we all face ❤
Kiara's songs are so beautiful bro, POV really hits you in the soul also Mamaloni once again delivering a gorgeous Neuron-activating Kiwawa look that i hope becomes an outfit someday
Oh yes, I loved the art. It felt like something I'd see from a really good manhwa (mostly cause most Korean manga are fully colored, as far as I've seen). Not one for fashion much either, but the outfit was one to garner my attention. Looked amazing.
I know Kiwawa said it wasn't easy for her to hit those low notes but this is proof that she can and she sounds incredible. POV is the perfect demonstration of her vocal range and her stepping into new territory she hasn't tried before. She prefers KPop and more up beat songs like Pineapple and Love Rush, which she does excel at, but it's really special seeing her in other genres. Even if she never makes a song like Retrospective, The Great Wanderer or Sleep Talking again, I'm glad we'll always have these songs to her name
Somehow I feel that this style of music has an easier time evoking feelings for me than "slower" songs. Songs that I liked before had a way more upbeat feel to them that gave me energy but this one feels so right to just drive back home after work, like its nostalgic in a way
We're so blessed to hear Kiara sing your amazing lyrics . I love the tragic irony of a "phoenix" that can't renew itself on a deeper level (like, "Caught up in my demise (Caught up and I can't ignite"). The writing is so dang cool.
That art is gorgeous and really drives home how emotional this song truly is. What an amazing track. The deep vocals and somber vibes are utterly contagious. It's a beautiful ballad, Boss.
Honestly, I really like the lyrics of this song and Kiara's vocals enhance their effects. I find myself coming back to this song often. A really great song.
Hope Kiara makes more songs like this - her vocal's are brilliant. Been waiting for her do something like this. Great work for everyone involved with the MV!
Well, this MV came out at the best time for me. I am going through some hardship which was entirely my bad. The thing I've done cannot be undone and I cannot restore the faith in myself for causing such harm. Nevertheless, I will keep going on. It's a long road to redemption but there's no other way out. Thank you, tenchou. Your music and stream shall accompany me through this long journey.
NICE, my favourite new song from the album is getting an MV, I love to see it. By the way, with this all songs except Sleep Talking have MVs. Whichs is really impressive that Kiwawa has a full album but all but one song in it have their own music video. My deepest appreciation goes to Kiara for giving all her songs MVs not something everyone does (nor is it feasible for everyone tbh, but still I really do appreciate it. MVs make songs all the more enjoyable).
It is lovely that I got a heart from Kiwawa but that made me look at the comment again and see my typos so now I want to edit the comment but can't lol. But thanks for the heart Tenchou! 🧡 Your album is lovely and I would love to see you make more original songs.
I'm getting early 2000s vibe from this song and I've been bopping my head to it the second the music started. This genre suits you, Kiara. You should do more of these.
This song is not only the most personal out of this album but probably all songs Kiara released so far in her entire career, the more you watch her the more it makes sense and it sounds great.
This outfit reminds me a lot of Velvet from Tales of Berseria with the red and black, sasuga Tales of fan. Many KFP love this song, so I see this MV doing well for numbers
My favorite of the album! Finally we get the MV! I always love how we get all different Kiara’s costume and theme in each MV. Just like how the songs are all different in style.
love this song it gives an entirely different vibe since most of your songs are all upbeat and choose songs that really tug at the heartstrings and your singing is always so beautiful kiara can’t wait to hear more of your songs and your singing
Definitely my favorite song from the album. The lyrics are very relatable and the song really showcases Kiara's vocal work, which I think is some of the best she's ever done.
This song, and Great Wanderer ended up being my surprise favorites of the album. Obviously, all the song are great, Pineapple is super catchy, Love Rush is very sweet, and Sleep Talking is a whole vibe, but something about this song and Great Wanderer feel so personal, I love it
The long awaited MV to one of the best songs of the album is finally here! I really love Retrospective and generally the diversity of songs that Point of View entails.
I love this song so much. At first you'd think the "you" refered to in the song like in a lot of Kiara's songs refers to a third person... but considering the title is Retrospective, I think those are meant to be questions you're asking to yourself. I think it portrays really well how difficult it can be to actually question your life decisions. And Kiara is singing it with such passion too! She's been killing it with this album.
Dies ist der Song der mich dazu gebracht hat, das Album zu kaufen. Die tiefe Melancholie der Stimme und der Instrumente hat etwas fesselndes und doch bleibt ein Kern Hoffnung der leise in jeder Silbe mitschwingt.
I love this, it feels really good to hear this type of sound come out of Hololive! My only TINY complaint/critique would be, the producer using less auto tune. So Kiaras voice can be more open sounding. Because Kiaras natural singing voice is already good. Thats it. But i still love this song!
I can't believe I only just realized she released an MV for this song. This was my favorite song on the album, and I love the outfit in the MV to go with it.
I loved hearing you sing a song that had totally different vibe from usual - glad to finally get to see the video! Fantastic work as always, Kiwawa-senpai!!!
BASED
Sanest KFP
;))
it's good to see a bird appreciating another bird
Her pure hearted adoration is based asf
real
Sneaks in, drops a one word comment to support her friend, refuses to elaborate
Based dad
Proof that no matter how much we grow up, the emo never leaves us: it just evolves.
@@7shinta7 That's the Mori way.
Real
damn, real
When Kiara said she wanted a punk/emo song on the album, I honestly didn't expect it would be so perfect. Like, wow. This went beyond my wildest expectations. Once again she proves why she should not be underestimated.
Kiara's outfit reminds me of Velvet Crowe from Tales of Berseria!
is this really that punk?
@pumpkincoffee Kiara originally mentioned wanting to do a song like Paramore, one of her favorite punk bands, so that's why I mentioned it. The result ended up more like emo-rock, tho.
@@UnwrittenBirdsye i guess your right
Definitely reminds me of velvet!@@fernandozavaletabustos205
Dang spamming mirage made me appreciate all of kiara's song and discovering gems like this.. myth is really my oshi
I really like how "clean" this MV is. I think it conveys a lot of emotion in a really refined way.
It's also really easy to read the lyrics, something that's useful with an MV like this.
Such an underrated song, it deserve a lot more views
It's one of my favorite Kiara songs
Retrospective is such a heavy hitter for this album, can't wait to see the MV come to life
exactly my thoughts!
@@nearata It was incredible as expected and nice profile picture
@@SwatterKFP nice profile picture to you too
I didn't know I needed Rockstar Kiara in my life, but here I am replaying the MV again.
Kiara was the first vtuber I discovered who shared a love for early Y2K punk rock, and seeing her have her own song in this style made me immensely proud!
One of the best songs on the album finally gets its MV
Retrospective really showcases how good Kiara's vocals are. This song made me fall in love with Kiara's voice all over again
Ain't that the pure truth.
This right here. I'd heard her previous lighthearted songs, but the CLARITY and downright gorgeousness of her voice on this album absolutely blew me away and stunned me.
[Verse 1]
Oh baby, I'm looking at what remains
I couldn't tell you the same, I guess that's life
If you couldn't tell by now, I'm hopelessly waiting
Begging all night to break through
Stuck in an endless loop, I'll deny the truth
Asking why
[Chorus]
I can't redo
The past and present calls me to truth
And every part of my being doubts the best feeling
So tell me what am I to you?
I can't renew
The part of me I lost in the view
Hooked up on all the wavering eyes leaves me paralyzed
Taking two stеps back but I keep moving on
[Verse 2]
Concern is filling up your lies, once again I'm all but brokеn
I'll save me if I can, ah let it go, let it go, breathe again
If you couldn't tell by now, I'm hopelessly wasting
Away to the core inside
It keeps eating away at me everyday
Asking why
[Chorus]
I can't redo
The past and present calls me to truth
And every part of my being doubts the best feeling
So tell me what am I to you?
I can't renew
The part of me I lost in the view
Hooked up on all the wavering eyes leaves me paralyzed
Taking two steps back but I keep moving on
[Post-Chorus]
And I tried to change me but my mind can't just erase me anymore than I have already done
And looking back I'm ready to admit it was all me who destroyed everything I am
[Bridge]
Caught up in my demise (Caught up and I can't ignite)
The doubt puts out my light
I can't be sure of who I am or when I'm alive
[Chorus]
I can't redo
The past and present calls me to truth
And every part of my being doubts the best feeling
So tell me what am I to you?
[Outro]
Ooh
Oh I am
Turning back
Jeezas, Mamaloni just cranked the edginess up to 11 for this one...as it should be Smol, cute EmoWawa from 4blood has all grown up. Now the stage belongs to the hard-core and mature Gothiara❤🖤❤🖤❤
There is NO WAY this "only" has 300k views.
I'm listening to all of Hololive's songs, and this would easily take 1st or 2nd place and stay there for a while.
Thank you Kiara for this masterpiece ❤
I really love how kiara is tackling styles outside of the typical anime/jpop genres. They may not be as popular in the Hololive community but i think they have a chance of appealing to fans outside of the vtuber sphere.
This is too good, I thought it was a cover but didn't know it's an official music
Man Kiara's voice suits these types of songs so well
Love seeing mamaloni's art for this one too when I'm not in tears. What an outfit!
Extremely hype for the full illustration and MV
Edited : You know that feeling when you're listening to a song that immerses you in these incredible emotions because, they remind you of something you've once had or been? Retrospective does that to me. Because I've been someone incredibly different back then, compared to who I am now. And just like what the lyrics mention, I can't change the past. The only thing to do, is learn from it, take two steps into the future and move on with life. Because the only way to succeed in life is going forward. 🧡🧡
Thank you for the wonderful new music video for Retrospective, Wawa. I felt how deep this song was to you, seeing how your journey as a HoloLive idol progressed over the years - and turned you into the majestic phoenix that you are now. Big ups to Mamaloni's art and the team who worked on this MV. This was amazing, and once again, I won't hesitate to share Point of View and its songs to everyone i know - because they're your songs, Wawa. 🧡🧡🧡✨
We always see genki Kiwawa, it’s easy to forget everyone has self doubts and negative thoughts. This song is a beautiful representation of those flaws and challenges we all face ❤
Kiara's songs are so beautiful bro, POV really hits you in the soul
also Mamaloni once again delivering a gorgeous Neuron-activating Kiwawa look that i hope becomes an outfit someday
Oh yes, I loved the art. It felt like something I'd see from a really good manhwa (mostly cause most Korean manga are fully colored, as far as I've seen). Not one for fashion much either, but the outfit was one to garner my attention. Looked amazing.
This style of music might suit her voice the most, and does her strong accent justice
I know Kiwawa said it wasn't easy for her to hit those low notes but this is proof that she can and she sounds incredible. POV is the perfect demonstration of her vocal range and her stepping into new territory she hasn't tried before. She prefers KPop and more up beat songs like Pineapple and Love Rush, which she does excel at, but it's really special seeing her in other genres. Even if she never makes a song like Retrospective, The Great Wanderer or Sleep Talking again, I'm glad we'll always have these songs to her name
This is my favorite Kiara song ever. Such a lovely dark tone and great lyrics.
Fantastic job!
The MV, the instrumentals, the vocals, even the angst. Retrospective just gets everything so right.
Why is this not a 1 million views…
This song landed on me on… an appropriate time, so I might be biased, but I am clearly not alone in that sentiment.
The Musical talent of this Phoenix never ceases to amaze me xD
this might be your most underrated song. it is absolutely phenomenal kiaraaaaa
kiwawa can do any genre i swear
Somehow I feel that this style of music has an easier time evoking feelings for me than "slower" songs.
Songs that I liked before had a way more upbeat feel to them that gave me energy but this one feels so right to just drive back home after work, like its nostalgic in a way
Come on KFP let's gets this banger to a million!!!
Doing my part.
My favorite song of the album!!!! thank you Kiwawa for the MV!!!!
This might be my favorite vocals from Kiara to date. This style suits her voice beautifully.
Heavily in favor of every MV meaning we get another cute look for Kiara. The song is cool and different from the others on the album too!
A song so dear to my heart :') The art is super fitting (seggsy emo wawa i love you) and you sound amazing my gorl
We're so blessed to hear Kiara sing your amazing lyrics . I love the tragic irony of a "phoenix" that can't renew itself on a deeper level (like, "Caught up in my demise (Caught up and I can't ignite"). The writing is so dang cool.
Finally my fave from the album is gettin an MV! Emowawa lookin great in the art too!
This is my favorite song on the album. So powerful and haunting. Please more songs like this.
I can't wait for The8bitDrummer to do a drum cover of this! I love Retrospective so much!
Hehe
I’m starting to listen to songs by Kiara, best decision I have made.
That art is gorgeous and really drives home how emotional this song truly is. What an amazing track.
The deep vocals and somber vibes are utterly contagious.
It's a beautiful ballad, Boss.
And just like that I'm back in 2007. Amazing work, Kiwawa! Appreciate that you value this seminal era of music!!
Honestly, I really like the lyrics of this song and Kiara's vocals enhance their effects. I find myself coming back to this song often. A really great song.
和訳歌詞作ってみました。（下手だから笑わないで；；）
ねえ、あの時のこと覚えてる？
あんなに伝えたかったのにさ
一切合財失くしたとしても きっと戻らないだろう
マジで、堂々巡りの結末じゃない 教えて
二人戻れない
思い出せば 全ての出来事が
ありえぬ夢 嘘じゃない夜
愛していたのは誰なの？ 教えて
二人帰れない
見失った あなたの姿が
揺れる瞳 魔法に掛け
二歩下がっても 私は進み続ける！
心配事が貴方の嘘ばっか もう知らない
そうは言っても レリゴーレリゴー こりごり
こんな事続けていたら きっと痩せられる
何で、想像過多の嫉妬じゃない 教えて
二人戻れない
思い出せば 全ての出来事が
ありえぬ夢 嘘じゃない夜
愛していたのは誰なの？ 教えて
二人帰れない
見失った あなたの姿が
揺れる瞳 魔法に掛け
二歩下がっても 私は進み続ける！
でも、心 赴（おもむ）くままに
過去を消すなんて出来ないから
そして振り返れば 全部自分がやった事
こんな幕にしたのは誰？
最悪のオチ（こんなつもりじゃ）
疑いに瞳が落ち
二人生きているのかも解らない
二人戻れない
思い出せば 全ての出来事が
ありえぬ夢 嘘じゃない夜
愛していたのは誰なの？ 教えて
それが聞けるまで・・・
Hope Kiara makes more songs like this - her vocal's are brilliant. Been waiting for her do something like this. Great work for everyone involved with the MV!
Kiara constantly surprises me with the different styles of singing and she always NAILS it!
Well, this MV came out at the best time for me. I am going through some hardship which was entirely my bad. The thing I've done cannot be undone and I cannot restore the faith in myself for causing such harm. Nevertheless, I will keep going on. It's a long road to redemption but there's no other way out. Thank you, tenchou. Your music and stream shall accompany me through this long journey.
NICE, my favourite new song from the album is getting an MV, I love to see it.
By the way, with this all songs except Sleep Talking have MVs. Whichs is really impressive that Kiwawa has a full album but all but one song in it have their own music video. My deepest appreciation goes to Kiara for giving all her songs MVs not something everyone does (nor is it feasible for everyone tbh, but still I really do appreciate it. MVs make songs all the more enjoyable).
It is lovely that I got a heart from Kiwawa but that made me look at the comment again and see my typos so now I want to edit the comment but can't lol.
But thanks for the heart Tenchou! 🧡 Your album is lovely and I would love to see you make more original songs.
Just from the thumbnail I can already see that I'm gonna love the mv and outfit
It took 7 months but glad youtube music algoritrm showed me this one.
WOW, You also do songs! That is so cool. I will go watch them all.
Ahhh, I'm so excited for this.
My favourite song out of the new ones.
The artwork looks so amazing already. Can't wait for the MV
Our oshi's beautiful voice. Gorgeous Mamaloni art. Amazing banger of a song.
Man, these lyrics hit hard. I love this song so much!
Time to relive another hard hitting banger from the album!
i rarely watch hololive nowadays but this song has been stuck on my head for weeks
I know Wawa said these are simple MVs but Mamaloni art and Raina never misses. EmoTori is just so good!
I waited all night for the MV and it's so amazing, this song is so amazing, Kiara's voice is so amazing and I just want to put this song on repeat
Finally my favorite song from the album gets its own MV~
I CAN'T REDOOOOO
Wow, didn’t know you had this hidden banger.
Very underrated song. If this song came out in the early 2010s if would be on top of music charts.
This gotta be one of my favs from Kiara
This is easily one of the best songs of 2023 for me. Not only it is relatable, but also strangely nostalgic.
I hope this is only at 274k because people bought this song. It is really good.
I CAN'T REDOOOOOOOOOOOOO is my fav song in the album
The illustration looks so good!
I had no idea this song existed. I've never heard this side of Kiara's music before. Breathtaking.
I'm getting early 2000s vibe from this song and I've been bopping my head to it the second the music started.
This genre suits you, Kiara. You should do more of these.
how did i miss this one kiara goes so hard on this track so much passion
my favorite wawa song from the album now with an mv? count me in! and goodness golly wow the art!! AAAAAAAA!
Melancholic Tenchou always gets me.
Stuck In.. Side
This song is not only the most personal out of this album but probably all songs Kiara released so far in her entire career, the more you watch her the more it makes sense and it sounds great.
don't know who drew the art, but I love how Kiara looks with this style
LETS GOOO im so excited for this one retrospective is my favorite from the album
Why does this song keep hitting so hard?
3:53 Now that would be a great album or single cover!
This outfit reminds me a lot of Velvet from Tales of Berseria with the red and black, sasuga Tales of fan. Many KFP love this song, so I see this MV doing well for numbers
bro, for a second I thought it was the Serval from Honkai Star Rail (HRS)
@@fatehiakuyaNgl, I also thought it was Serval
i missed the premiere cuz of work, but this video is so pretty. Mamaloni’s art is always blessed. again and again, congrats on the album Tenchou!!
still listenin
LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOOO
Retrospective is soooo good Rock on Queen ! It really show cases how great Wawa's voice range is
This and Great Wanderer are my Favorites, cant wait for the MV
1:42 🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡
This is my favorite song from the album. I love it especially the mamaloni art.
Tenchou can't miss, even with her eyes closed
My favorite of the album! Finally we get the MV!
I always love how we get all different Kiara’s costume and theme in each MV. Just like how the songs are all different in style.
There is always time!
love this song it gives an entirely different vibe since most of your songs are all upbeat and choose songs that really tug at the heartstrings and your singing is always so beautiful kiara can’t wait to hear more of your songs and your singing
Definitely my favorite song from the album. The lyrics are very relatable and the song really showcases Kiara's vocal work, which I think is some of the best she's ever done.
Kiara needs to be signed to a record label with Kiara's Angels 10 out of 10 yet again.
So many great dance songs and then this powerful song comes out and goes an entirely different direction.
This song, and Great Wanderer ended up being my surprise favorites of the album. Obviously, all the song are great, Pineapple is super catchy, Love Rush is very sweet, and Sleep Talking is a whole vibe, but something about this song and Great Wanderer feel so personal, I love it
Cant stop replaying this over and over 🥹
とても良い曲ですね、何度もリピートして聞いてしまいます
The long awaited MV to one of the best songs of the album is finally here! I really love Retrospective and generally the diversity of songs that Point of View entails.
I love this song so much. At first you'd think the "you" refered to in the song like in a lot of Kiara's songs refers to a third person... but considering the title is Retrospective, I think those are meant to be questions you're asking to yourself. I think it portrays really well how difficult it can be to actually question your life decisions.
And Kiara is singing it with such passion too! She's been killing it with this album.
Definitely one of her best songs. I love this one.
Dies ist der Song der mich dazu gebracht hat, das Album zu kaufen. Die tiefe Melancholie der Stimme und der Instrumente hat etwas fesselndes und doch bleibt ein Kern Hoffnung der leise in jeder Silbe mitschwingt.
The more I listen to this, the more it grows on me. Really vibing with this song now.
I love this, it feels really good to hear this type of sound come out of Hololive!
My only TINY complaint/critique would be, the producer using less auto tune. So Kiaras voice can be more open sounding.
Because Kiaras natural singing voice is already good. Thats it. But i still love this song!
I can't believe I only just realized she released an MV for this song. This was my favorite song on the album, and I love the outfit in the MV to go with it.