完全同意你嘅分析. Chantel 有一種好大家閨秀好wholesome嘅氣質, similar to kelly. 蓮姐 由第一日開始比我嘅感覺就係好 driven by emotions. 佢入娛樂圈我反而有啲擔心..... 可能佢仲細, 容易被自己情感牽制. 不過佢把聲真係好特別! These two girls will go far with their talents.
Thanks Leyton for his experience and knowledge yo share with the 2 singers to learn more about their strong and weak points. Hope Kaitlyn learn to control her temperance and emotions as she grow up to a good singer.
其實我覺得Chantel好有potential但係唱功可以再improve下，佢音色唔錯但係一上高音就有少少好用力嗌嘅感覺，唔係好自然，而蓮姐把聲好有character不過暫時黎講未爆得起，想佢減少D呼吸聲同揀D冇咁depressing嘅歌，once again, thanks for your insight! Looking forward to future episodes!
Could not agree with you more, great job on the insights and analysis. IMO Chantel has all the attributes; "star qualities", a beautiful mellow, sweet voice and timbre and a "goddess'' persona. Not the best technically; that would go to Gigi,Windy and Kaitlyn. It may come down to a fairly close fight to the end but I believe Gigi will prevail. IMO Felix like Chantel has a very nice voice but will need a fair amount of work on his vocal delivery.
Kaitlyn率直率性，Chantel blue blood，各有各的niche。如果聲夢的賽果由觀眾投票決定，我已經可以預見不失手的Chantel會得第一。張老師說得很對，星夢當然旨在尋星，但是更重要的mission是啓發學員，讓他們發掘一己潛能，走出自己的聲夢旅程。同意你所說，這班小朋友很了不起。
You're the guy who criticized the How you Like That performance right? Oh my gosh, if you couldn't see the team spirit and the hard work the girls put in than I question your suitability as a judge. We must encourage the commitment, collaboration and cooperation shown by the team members and if you are too self-centered to be impartial than you should bow-out and resign from the show
Steve, thanks for your message. It's truly great the show has audience like you because it shows you care. While I did say I appreciated their effort to put together the act which was cut out perhaps for a more dramatic effect and I totally understand, my most important points were certainly left in. As you have heard I did stress if I had seen that performance as an unknown group at some random company annual dinner I would be quite entertained and happy. But do understand that this show is a serious quest for new super stars, and the bar needs to be very high, and if an act like that was to prove to the judges and viewers they are in their path to stardom, that's not going to happen in a million years. While they had certain team spirit and hard work/collaboration put into it, that's just the very basic quality every successful star should have, but to become real super stars and for people to pay hard cash to see them, they need much more. The real world is even more cruel than the judges. Their dancing probably was worse than many random people who pretend to be Blackpink on youtube all over the world. Their vocals lack attitude and direction to carry a cool song like that. The entire act was, although entertaining, basically mediocre and more or less just using precious airtime pretending to be Blackpink, delivering no original creativity and personal character. If no one was there to point out for them what they actually lack to be real stars, and if they even thought they had what it takes with an act like that to become champions and stars, their dreams to become successful would end pretty soon which I can guarantee. But I'm very glad to see the show has audience like you who care about the contestants so much, and I guess we come from the same place in the end. If I didn't care or not impartial, I could easily say something that made them feel good and everybody can be happy, including you. But that's not the point to have these kids on the show. I'm not here to make anyone feel good. I'm here to tell the truth.
@@claytonmusicClayton, thank-you very much for sharing your thoughts in the reply. You are a professional with broad expertise and of course I do not question your judgement. I do want to say however I do not agree with your use of negative criticism as it is unhelpful to the development of the young kids. Your comments did not suggest any change or solutions, they did not seem to be delivered thoughtfully, and it seems they were more for your own needs than the needs of the team receiving the feedback. I saw other professionals such as John Laudon and Harry Ng amongst the judges, maybe you can ask them (as Peers) to provide you with feedback on your feedback so that you can learn how your comments were perceived and at the same time allow you to improve your feedback giving skills. Your have come a long way since the Black Box days and am a legend in your own right. Please do your best to nurture and develop these young artists for the success and sustainability of the Hong Kong music industry. Thank-you so much for your effort and passion
請大家留意，我不是在比較Chantel 和 Kaitlyn, 而是獨立分析他們的潛力。節目雖然有輸贏，但要贏人永遠要先贏自己，所以我在節目裡其實最想看到的是學員以今天的我打敗昨天的自己
Couldn’t agree more!
有信心唔代表一定贏 冇信心就輸更
認同！是应该自己跟自己比較，或吸取他人的長處，加以運用，才会有所進步！
Chantel真係好有觀眾緣，未學過唱歌，但學得好快
張佳添老師 分析非常👍👍👍 今晚chantel唱戀愛預告 超甜！
Chantel 把聲係幾靚，樣子又可愛，我亦比較鐘意佢唱歌時聽唔到抖氣聲！如果佢依家二十歲，我真係好讚成佢依家出道！不過佢依家得十四歲，人又聰明，我比較想佢讀多啲書先再正式出道，咁樣對佢將來演藝事業都有幫助！
老師，Chantel 有學跳舞，跳舞好好睇💃 睇電視報紙訪問，佢好真誠，有思想，有性格，有教養，有禮貌，有大將風範，小小年紀，真係不得了！仲要人見人愛，完全冇haters ！期待睇佢嘅演出！😍
係呀！冇haters 先至重點！
@@misslee3253 TVB 今次真係執到寶 ! 以後實有大把商演。。超級期待💖💖上次聲夢十強活動，見到佢真人好靚，好nice, 又冇架子😍😍
個人係Kaitlyn 粉絲，畢竟磁性聲線在香港比較少，但亦同意張先生嘅睇法，希望蓮姐可以在舞台上衝破障礙同埋情緒上嘅起伏，突破自己！十強都各有天賦同埋優勢，希望全部都會紅起嚟！話俾人聽在香港有夢想係可以成真！星夢之所以受歡迎係因為即將會出現番一班有份量嘅巨星，係普通人變成巨星，香港仍可以追夢，亦可以夢想成真！
多謝講Kaitlyn 希望Kaitlyn可以一直進步同突破自己
好想kaitlyn贏冠軍🏆😆
Thank you 張佳添老師🙏🏻😂this is kaitlyn. 仲記得九歲嘅時候你問我「想唔想係歌手方面發展 定係純粹係興趣」我唸你已經唔記得 不過呢個問題一直都係我個腦度 所以依家勇敢踏出第一步
捕獲蓮姐🤩
難得見到蓮姐真人，同你講聲加油！同埋比賽笑多D，觀眾會睇得開心D🤩
蓮姐加油，妳是最好的！
really?? 點解我會咁問你嘅？你來過我 studio?
蓮姐啊啊啊🤍🤍🤍加油💪🏻🖤
多謝講Kaitlyn同Chantel!自己都挺喜歡kaitlyn,chantel同gigi!!GIGI大把前途,Kaitlyn同chantel都好有潛力,大家都好有自己既風格,希望Kaitlyn,chantel同gigi一直都進步和突破自己,keep going,期待之後更多的精彩表演,繼續實現大家的目標和夢想,繼續喜歡唱歌,享受舞台,提昇自己的實力和能力!!
由從前「亞洲星光大道」開始，一直都好喜歡聽張佳添老師的見解。Chantel 和 Kaitlyn都是我喜歡的學員，有做歌星的潛質，暫時未唱得好好，但假以時日一定有不錯發揮。不過有好歌手之餘，都希望可以有適合「大眾」的「流行曲」，一直覺得香港現在的廣東歌偏離「大眾」和「流行」的感覺，變成只有「我我我」，今天有沒有歌星願意唱《花花宇宙》或《降重登場》這些聽得過隱，台上又看得開心的「流行曲」？期待之後他們的表現。👍
謝謝你多年的支持🙏
多謝張sir🙌🏻請繼續出片
你的分析好中肯，很有見地。 你是芸芸評審中，每次最期待你的精劈見解。
完全同意你嘅分析. Chantel 有一種好大家閨秀好wholesome嘅氣質, similar to kelly. 蓮姐 由第一日開始比我嘅感覺就係好 driven by emotions. 佢入娛樂圈我反而有啲擔心..... 可能佢仲細, 容易被自己情感牽制. 不過佢把聲真係好特別! These two girls will go far with their talents.
Chantel 只是14歲，好有潛質，而且聰明，領悞力強，樣貌甜美可愛，硬件齊備，就算今次不獲勝，當吸取經驗以備日後之用，未嘗不是好事，是可以哉培的明日之星！
Chantel唱《逃生門》嘅時候已經覺得佢學習吸收能力好快，咁短時間內學以致用 真係潛力無限👍🏻雖然佢唱歌經驗少，但單憑以上幾點 可見佢係一個唔簡單嘅參賽者😂
至於蓮姐佢把聲係幾特別,一開始對佢最深印象係佢唱《世事何曾是絕對》，佢個曲風與眾不同
駕馭得好好 其實單憑呢樣嘢已經加晒分😤
我只係一個普通觀眾，而唔係專業唱歌人士 以上意見希望同大眾一樣😂😂
我好鍾意聽歌。我不敢評論歌手。不過我好開心.樂見無線有一個非常好節目，另我知道香港樂壇是有希望的。大約十年前,我好鐘意一位日本歌手May'n.(唱超時空要塞2).但今天我看到姚婥非有她的影子,又是十四歲,又是歌唱比賽發掘出來.如果未來有自己的歌曲.我會支持她的。
我覺得Chantel同kaitlyn有個共同點就係聲線辨識度好高,好容易畀觀眾記得,同意張老師講chantel識合走陳慧琳路線,因為大家又係顏值高,有觀眾緣,而kaitlyn唱歌嗰感覺我覺得似葉德嫻,正如老師所講一樣係一個好講feel嘅歌手
agree!
好鍾意睇呢D專業分析~因為真係學到好多野~thank you張老師!
十分同意你講真正嘅 Star 要有的特質，發放正能量，能力越大責任越大！希望香港樂顫再發光發亮！
Kaitlyn 聲音好特別，某啲音唱得特別好聽，每次睇比賽都好令人期待。其他人評論佢情緒，其實以18歲來講仲係年紀好細，啱啱才學做人學成熟，面對公眾好多野要學習，妹妹仔繼續努力呀。其他星夢參賽者嘅片段都好好睇，相比起我們當年後生的時候，懂事及事情處理得好好。
18啱啱攞戒奶紙😁
我個人喜歡kaitlyn，佢嘅聲線好特別。
姚焯菲唱戀愛預告唱得超水準
香港有好多好有heart的歌手及音樂人，欠缺的是市場及推廣，版稅是雙面刃，要做到媒體，市場，歌手共贏其實不易，睇TVB就知，十多年固步自封，希望佢帶動到群眾多些注意樂壇，小財唔出，大財唔入嘛
祝願將來這些小朋友可以潔身自愛，一飛沖天
支持張老師! 期待下一條片!
Chantel好有potential👍
在林珊珊的訪問中,好一句：“張我哋啲Auntie變成少女啊！” 。這就是今次演出的成功了吧！ 聽咗幾十年歌,未見過咁嘅兩代互動感動場面啊！無得頂,音樂的至高景界👍
蓮姐好有性格,覚得佢唱得好投入,好吸引人繼續聽睇落去,有種神秘感! 另外亦很喜欢Gigi
我最鍾意嘅Chantel同蓮姐！
希望Kaitlyn睇到張Sir嘅comment! 好中肯好有用👍👍👍
收音有點小，如果可以加大一些會更好
希望下次講下Steven，太早foul佢啦！
莲姐比较情绪化，所以不夠穩定，可以好好，又可以好差，但感情丰富，要學習控制一下情緒，如果成為職業歌手，不可以因為私人事而影響演出，要夠專業才可以走更長的路。喜歡她的聲缐和情感的表達，也是可做之才。
好中肯嘅評論!👍👍
兩位都唱得好好越嚟越進步
非常專業，分解精準
專業評論👏👏👏
老師，下集講Steven ,真太可惜咁早被人foul,我真係覺得佢係人才，把聲好聽，好舒服
蓮姐的 才藝 好多，請發掘一下。希望 大家 不要一窩鋒 只捧一兩個而已。樂壇應該不只少數人。🙏🙏🙏
Thanks Leyton for his experience and knowledge yo share with the 2 singers to learn more about their strong and weak points. Hope Kaitlyn learn to control her temperance and emotions as she grow up to a good singer.
I mean Clayton
謝謝張佳添老師的用心comments 和 sharing.. 我自己覺得 Chantel 靚女，有觀眾緣。蓮姐同Felix唱月半小夜曲我覺得跟原唱很不同，我自己很喜歡，正如你所說的，他們得咗😂但我兩個同事都不喜歡蓮姐唱呢首歌的 style.. 我同兩位同事每集都睇星夢, 回到公司都會講講自己感受和睇法。其中一個同事很喜歡Aska, Aska 被 foul 很不開心而他有 talent 作合唱歌好聽，唱眼色都好 creative 好有心思。另一同事認為分組而 foul 隊員很不公平，例如 Steven, 因為他合唱首歌取了分。。我覺得睇得星夢的觀眾應該大部分都喜歡唱歌或聽歌。希望之後的星夢是單對單比賽或個人賽累積分數可能會更好😊今次星夢的評判好高要求亦是令我們追看的其中一個原因，又可以學野。順便想請教張老師，我看完你上次的片說要先放鬆喉嚨，我 weekend 嘗試了然後玩全民K歌，我自己覺得是好一些，但還是有些高音唱不到，我以前小學和中學都是學校 choir 女高音，唔知點解好似年紀大咗，把聲沙咗同好似好多痰，是甚麼原因呢？我也有學 gigi 唱沒有你還是愛你，當然我無小妹妹 gigi 唱得咁好，但都覺得唱得好過之前☺️期待張老師繼續出片教學😊
我好喜歡她們
同意，Chantel好有potential, 好期待看她往後的表演和發展！
張老師，請問下次可以講Archie和Rock嗎？謝謝
看到你在此頻道的分析，的確推翻了我從節目中對你的印象。很用心，加油💪🏻
Chantel把聲好獨特，前途無可限量
好專業嘅評論，林君蓮係可造之才聲底厚帶點沙，佢可以試吓唱葉德嫻啲歌例如唱明星
“明星”不合年紀輕、資歷淺的歌者唱,唔可以監硬塞隻歌畀佢就以為幫到佢
未睇先支持
陳慧琳成功之處徐了自己好天份，外型、家境外，最重耍係有經理人鍾珍顶力相助🥰👍💪希望Chantel. 將來會有😍祝福她
Chantel 和 Kaitlyn 的個人演出
ua-cam.com/video/l_Mes1TyMAE/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/hA_6W2XiKJk/v-deo.html
張老師非常細心，謝謝！
張佳添,我第一次認識你係10年前嘅亞視“星光大道”歌唱比賽,嗰時我認為好睇過TVB嘅“超級巨星”,阿Lo 同曾寶儀做主持表現非常出色,其他評判包括你嘅評論都非常到位有水準,令到觀眾睇得投入,成個星光團隊無論参賽者、司儀、歌唱及形象評判、觀眾都令整個比賽節目非常溫暖及具有超高可觀性。
如今又再見你狠而準嘅專業評論,真係參賽者之福！
完全認同，亞洲星光大道實在是一個很出色的節目，我亦很懷念當時的台前幕後。十年後現在非常高興可以在聲夢和youtube 和大家見面。謝謝你的欣賞
個日citywalk 聽過Chantel 同蓮姐既現場，可能音響問題，Chantel 唱開頭幾乎無聲，佢都臨危不亂好淡定完成演出。
至於蓮姐，好有個人風格，把聲入咪個下已經聽到人毛管戙，商場啲人行行下都停低聽佢唱，呢樣野得Gigi可以一樣做到
嗰日我有去，嗰個膠口罩好累事，隔音，到Rock至開始有人留意到，支咪其實可以放下巴位，收音會好啲，可惜節目已到尾聲。
張Sir, 我甚麼都不懂，我睇你這個channel 只是希望更懂得欣賞音樂，是多層次，由編曲到演繹，希望不浪費每一個單元對一首歌的貢獻，所以多謝張Sir。
好鍾意Chantel👍👍
在這裡沒有時限，可以暢所欲言，也不用怕意見沒有播出街
你令我諗返起 一切很美只因有你 的美麗時光
你好, 每集也看你的評語. 能否再叫無 線播: 全部(比分的導師不被剪輯..都播出) 足本版. ??? 希望明天又知道你的結論. 謝.
不好意思，姚焯菲説錯了顔焯菲 🤦🏻♂️
是姚 焯 菲😂😂
是姚焯菲!!
改返🤣
Tim Sir 嘅意思係颜值高嘅焯菲，因為太多人話佢颜值高啦🤣🤣🤣
最中意蓮姐 😘😘😘 😙😙😙
可以稳一集讲讲Windy 我觉得距无甘差 实力都系有啊 但系点解距集集惨败
chantel呢個野同連姐係好姐妹…正如你話齋大家都會失禮…但chantel係不斷進步…連姐要考慮下點幫幫佢
收音細聲佐d，多謝分享
努力加油又係未來接班人
星夢傳奇可出 歌后
張老師，你好，好耐冇見
老師，男仔我睇好Steven 和Felix，可否下集講吓佢哋，我認為樂壇欠缺呢類型嘅歌手
係囉，我都認為張老師應該要講吓呢兩位學員
下一集可唔可以講下Yumi,Aeren同埋導師😁
Chantel 人靚聲甜😍😍THX 老師😊
Nice
張老師，你對抖氣聲有咩見解或如何改善？因為聽到有D參賽者D抖氣聲勁大而影響聽眾聽歌時間嘅感覺。
想聽Archie and Windy ❤️佢哋唱歌好好聽
支持
老師幾時有新片出？十分期待😁
剛出了😁
其實我覺得Chantel好有potential但係唱功可以再improve下，佢音色唔錯但係一上高音就有少少好用力嗌嘅感覺，唔係好自然，而蓮姐把聲好有character不過暫時黎講未爆得起，想佢減少D呼吸聲同揀D冇咁depressing嘅歌，once again, thanks for your insight! Looking forward to future episodes!
Totally agree. Thanks for your messages every time!
個人覺得蓮姐有點似莫文慰style，但感覺她太用氣唱歌&不太穩定，有時聽得都的幾辛苦，歌路較窄，加上少笑容，有點吃虧。不過聽過Jonny Yim 講過好欣賞她，連趙僧熹都請她表演，咁多專業音樂人喜歡她一定有原因，應該是我不識欣賞而已。希望蓮姐加油，慢慢找到適合自己的路線及多啲演出機會💪
Rock is the best performer.
期待之後出片分析男學員既表現🥺但感覺男學員暫時未有一個好似gigi 咁突出🤔
Gigi有Gin Lee特訓當然
Please evaluate Archie and Felix
好細聲
我好認同你講Chantel有潛質同俱備一切可以走紅嘅條件，但講到有能力做Kelly嘅接班人呢頂高帽就太大喇，會對佢做成太大壓！
這只是一個市場學/brand building 的願景，不要把它看成高帽
@@claytonmusic 希望你之後出多d呢類片，因為好都畀TVB剪走睇唔到！
Chantel 沒參加過歌唱比賽，沒學過唱歌，那她是天生天份的吧
報名參加比賽後開始學
佢最吸引人嘅地方,就喺你感覺倒佢喺一顆未經雕琢嘅寶石,有無限可能性,希望睇住佢成長!
有天分😆
希望老師
可以教我唱
片頭蓮姐個大叫樣好趕客
超中意🤗 整多啲評論影片🤤
PS. 2:23 姚* 焯菲
是的，sorry 😅
Could not agree with you more, great job on the insights and analysis.
IMO Chantel has all the attributes; "star qualities", a beautiful mellow, sweet voice and timbre and a "goddess'' persona. Not the best technically; that would go to Gigi,Windy and Kaitlyn. It may come down to a fairly close fight to the end but I believe Gigi will prevail. IMO Felix like Chantel has a very nice voice but will need a fair amount of work on his vocal delivery.
很細聲
👍👍👍👍👍👍
期待你的評語
Kaitlyn率直率性，Chantel blue blood，各有各的niche。如果聲夢的賽果由觀眾投票決定，我已經可以預見不失手的Chantel會得第一。張老師說得很對，星夢當然旨在尋星，但是更重要的mission是啓發學員，讓他們發掘一己潛能，走出自己的聲夢旅程。同意你所說，這班小朋友很了不起。
可能你唔記得，觀眾投票gigi 是最高分的。
睇完張SIR深入評價,再翻睇佢地演出真係起哂雞皮
感覺Chantel 可能入錯隊，紅隊好像沒有特別培養佢，因為她之前肚痛，不敢叫她handle 1個回合嗎？
其實佢有實力，聲音辨識度高，就是經驗有點不足。
希望之後可以多些比佢獨唱的機會。
老師你好
你有沒有教人唱歌
有啊
Chantel係蘇花至愛，聲線令人有記憶，《逃生門》十分touch到！GiGi最主要係太多影子，至今都好難回想到佢把聲，同埋唱歌太刻意。相反Chantel係恰到好處，瑕不掩瑜！
我都同意其實Gigi唱得有啲刻意. 佢係有天份嘅, 我都鍾意呢位小妹妹，但係我留意到佢成日喺同一首歌會一時就係cute嗲聲，一時就好澎湃，好似仲未控制得到究竟佢想自己把聲係點樣。chantel 比較自然, 覺得佢仲未爆發小宇宙。
莲姐玩塔罗！？
Sherman 呢？
另外，张老师有时我未必赞同你所有意见，但是其实我爱你的，因为我小时候经常听你的Blackbox：）青春回忆，你不要挂住讲其他人啦，你有无新歌听下，😄。
ua-cam.com/video/KaypwA5hWXQ/v-deo.html
去年我的新歌 😊
張佳添音樂 The music of Clayton Cheung 好好听啊 好正！把声keep得太好啦，好年轻的感觉！😹
火雞火雞 下一期講下火雞
火雞係邊個？😅
@@claytonmusic 孫漢霖 火雞哥
慘，無人識火雞
Steven
@@claytonmusic 洋蔥 爭啲hit到你g spot果個😂😂
其實，我認為蓮姐一般，似歌手漠文尉嗰類型，佢不太有觀眾緣。反而我認為gi Gi可以接Joey 捧，姚卓菲我認同真係睇好👍
Gigi 的音樂感很強，她可能是王菲，王菀之，容祖兒，A lin，梅艷芳集於一身，終有一天她會自成一派，未必是接任何人的捧
Chantel 之前危學過唱歌，但聲底唔錯，呢樣係天賦。把聲係難聽嘅，後天練得唱功有幾犀利，唱歌都係難聽。
張Sir 睇預告片唔係foul Windy 嘛Hugo 差佢好多喎！
🙊
張sir,chantel接陳慧琳棒，蓮姐接joey棒，gigi接邊個棒？😂😂
Sammi
@@wongmankit132 🥲咪玩啦
周深
張佳添老師有係上面某個網友度回覆左：「Gigi音樂感很強，她可能是王菲、王苑之、容祖兒、Alin、梅艷芳集於一身，終有一天佢會自成一派，未必是接任何人的棒。」
@@kkkeee2333 謝謝
You're the guy who criticized the How you Like That performance right? Oh my gosh, if you couldn't see the team spirit and the hard work the girls put in than I question your suitability as a judge. We must encourage the commitment, collaboration and cooperation shown by the team members and if you are too self-centered to be impartial than you should bow-out and resign from the show
Steve, thanks for your message. It's
truly great the show has audience like you because it shows you care. While I did say I appreciated their effort to put together the act which was cut out perhaps for a more dramatic effect and I totally understand, my most important points were certainly left in. As you have heard I did stress if I had seen that performance as an unknown group at some random company annual dinner I would be quite entertained and happy. But do understand that this show is a serious quest for new super stars, and the bar needs to be very high, and if an act like that was to prove to the judges and viewers they are in their path to stardom, that's not going to happen in a million years. While they had certain team spirit and hard work/collaboration put into it, that's just the very basic quality every successful star should have, but to become real super stars and for people to pay hard cash to see them, they need much more. The real world is even more cruel than the judges. Their dancing probably was worse than many random people who pretend to be Blackpink on youtube all over the world. Their vocals lack attitude and direction to carry a cool song like that. The entire act was, although entertaining, basically mediocre and more or less just using precious airtime pretending to be Blackpink, delivering no original creativity and personal character. If no one was there to point out for them what they actually lack to be real stars, and if they even thought they had what it takes with an act like that to become champions and stars, their dreams to become successful would end pretty soon which I can guarantee. But I'm very glad to see the show has audience like you who care about the contestants so much, and I guess we come from
the same place in the end. If I didn't care or not impartial, I could easily say something that made them feel good and everybody can be happy, including you. But that's not the point to have these kids on the show. I'm not here to make anyone feel good. I'm here to tell the truth.
@@claytonmusicClayton, thank-you very much for sharing your thoughts in the reply. You are a professional with broad expertise and of course I do not question your judgement. I do want to say however I do not agree with your use of negative criticism as it is unhelpful to the development of the young kids. Your comments did not suggest any change or solutions, they did not seem to be delivered thoughtfully, and it seems they were more for your own needs than the needs of the team receiving the feedback. I saw other professionals such as John Laudon and Harry Ng amongst the judges, maybe you can ask them (as Peers) to provide you with feedback on your feedback so that you can learn how your comments were perceived and at the same time allow you to improve your feedback giving skills. Your have come a long way since the Black Box days and am a legend in your own right. Please do your best to nurture and develop these young artists for the success and sustainability of the Hong Kong music industry. Thank-you so much for your effort and passion