And in the books, not even that. He had a night of passion and got a girl pregnant. And to not dishonor her or have a bastard - not wanting to be his father in that moment and making another Jon Snow, knowing that disgrace and the hardship for Jon - he married her. So in the books, he didn't even choose love over honour, but chose to honour one thing in lieu of another.
@@tealsummers2316 it’s just my copium. Maybe it was smart but I wouldn’t want a man like that running shit in westeros if I was alive in these times. No thanks lol that man allows children to be executed he’s demonic
This episode is the reason reaction channels exists. Everyone who read the books already knew what was coming and they recorded their family or friends reactions to the Red wedding and uploaded in UA-cam so here we are today watching other people’s reactions to the GOT or other TV series
I think they existed before this, but were a very small niche market. This episode was when they took off and went mega-viral. Book readers, knowing this was coming, set up cameras to record their friends and families watching this because they knew the reactions would be epic. It was the spark that ignited the phenomenon that reaction channels have become.
Walder Frey invited them into his home, and broke bread with them. That is considered the ultimate peace offering and you do not break it under any circumstances. Inviting guests under your roof and then slaughtering them is regarded as worse than breaking any oath. That's why Robb was so relaxed. He would have never expected Frey to do that after breaking bread!
Exactly! Its insane to me that Tywin, Walder Frey and Roose Bolton violated such an important tradition, thats bound to break trust all over the 7 kingdoms
@@lalalalala198 Even then though, it's a crazy thing. It's the tradition in Westeros that symbolises ultimate trust in order to have diplomacy. Without that to rely on, you can never again have peace talks or negotiations because the tradition might be broken. Of course, David and Dan decided this wasn't interesting or important in later seasons and had peace talks with blind trust because fuck it.
The song they were playing before the slaughter was "The Rains of Castamere," which is a Lannister song about House Reyne, who Tywin Lannister destroyed.
That's another brutal story. Someone should read it to them. Cersei just used it to threaten Margaery in a recent scene. (Was it at Tyrion and Sansa's wedding? Close to there...)
Love and his mother. Let's not forget the only reason he needed Frey’s help in the first place was because she freed Jaime. Freeing Jaime led to Kastark betrayal... which led to needing frey. A combination of cat's and Robb mistakes is the reason they're dead.
@@rudyhernandez7128 Not really. Robb would eventually get f'd by the Freys anyway. He wanted to go North again and even if he didnt he would have been trapped in the Riverlands with the Freys at his back. He is the one who burned his bridges with them, and without knowing made it really easy for Walder Frey to do what he was going to do anyway. But he was already f'd when he married Jeyne Westerling/Volantisgirl. If Walder Frey wasnt the kind of person to join the winning side at the end Robb would have been dead way earlier.
@@teunvanderveen6477 not if Robb won the war... tyrion said it best "frey wouldn't risk such actions without certain insurances" if he defeated Lanniesters then frey wouldn't do it. Besides, defeating the Lanniesters means taking the royal fleet... so they could sail up to white harbor. But we're talking about a alternate reality... so who knows. You can go by what could have happen, I'll go by what did happen. And Cat just at fault as much as Robb... go ahead and ignore her mistakes though lol
@@rudyhernandez7128 I think you didnt get what i was saying. He couldnt have won the war because he made the Freys his enemy. I think your dislike of Cat is leading here. You should reread the books
@@teunvanderveen6477 I'm talking about the show since that is what they are watching bro... they ain't reading the Damn book. Robb: "I need men to replace the kastarks that haven't already sided with the Lanniesters" if cat didn't free Jaime then he wouldn't need men to replace Kastark because Kastark would still be there. Let me get this straight... just because I don't ignore cat's mistakes means I dislike her? Give me a break... you funny AF. Holding cat accountable does not mean I hate or dislike her. It's a simple fact that freeing Jaime play just as big a part in thier deaths as much as Robb being dishonorable. Would they have died anyways? Maybe, but we don't know. I only know what did happen. But if you think freeing Jaime had no consequences then you're just delusional
There is still a really high chance that the Freys and Boltons would have betrayed Robb. Tywin's sister was married to one of the Freys. And the Boltons have been at heads with the Starks for the North for millennia. Robb (and to some extent Cat) just made it all the more easy for them.
I think Robb executing Rickard Karstark was one of the most important decisions because it drove away Karstarks, which emboldened Boltons and Freys in their decision to betray Robb.
I was as giddy as Jackson & McKay to see everyone's reaction until Cathlyn's wailed. Her despair over the loss of her "last" son just made me cried, again. Recommenting here cus this one deserves it.
In the books, long before the red wedding when Dany was walking in the house of the Undying one of the rooms had a feast filled with dead people, there was a man with a crowned wolf's head at the head of the table. But they didn't put it in the show 😔
Instead the show substitutes it for the scene next episode where Arya is being led away from the twins and she sees his head sewn onto his direwolf atop the horse (unless that was this episode and they didnt how that part but I think it's next)
@@AfterlifeAnubis If my memory is correct from reading the books then the scene where arya sees the wolf head on the body was already in the book... so it wasn't substituted. But it's been over 5 years since I read them, so I could be wrong.
They’re both in the books. I remember because the Arya scene was so difficult to read and I wondered if I had a strong enough stomach to make it. It’s amazing how much foreshadowing GRRM was able to put into the House of the Undying scene in the books. Not a single detail lacking in significance.
@@rudyhernandez7128 oh no I was more confused about which episode they had her visually see the body with the wolves head, just finished rereading the series again but haven't seen the show in a bit
It hurts so much, she thought. Our children, Ned, all our sweet babes. Rickon, Bran, Arya, Sansa, Robb . . . Robb . . . please, Ned, please, make it stop, make it stop hurting . . . The white tears and the red ones ran together until her face was torn and tattered, the face that Ned had loved. Catelyn Stark raised her hands and watched the blood run down her long fingers, over her wrists, beneath the sleeves of her gown. Slow red worms crawled along her arms and under her clothes. It tickles. That made her laugh until she screamed. ‘‘Mad,’’ someone said, ‘‘she’s lost her wits,’’ and someone else said, ‘‘Make an end,’’ and a hand grabbed her scalp just as she’d done with Jinglebell, and she thought, No, don’t, don’t cut my hair, Ned loves my hair. Then the steel was at her throat, and its bite was red and cold.
"No, don’t, don’t cut my hair, Ned loves my hair." ugh that hurts the most. I had always thought the Lady Stoneheart thing was cool, but it's even more tragic than the Red Wedding; at least in her madness Cat thought she'd see Ned again. Now as Stoneheart she isn't even really alive anymore, just a hollow shell of Catelyn Stark...and still separated from her family. God it hurts.
God...I read this in the mid-2000s. I remember throwing my book across the room. It hit the wall, and some of the pages fell out. Makes me laugh whenever I open the book now and see the evidence of my reaction.
Michelle Fairley's performance is so underrated in Game of Thrones, she did an amazing job portraying Catelyn Stark. Some Fun Facts from the books: Greywind was being aggressive with the Freys since Robb arrived at The Twins. Catelyn basically claws her face with her nails in madness as she sees Robb being killed. Walder was going to keep her alive as an hostage to force the river lords to bend the knee to King Joffrey but seeing her descend into madness, the ended up killing her. Her naked body is thrown in the river (as a mockery of the funeral customs of House Tully.💀). She's dragged out by Arya's direwolf and then found by the brotherhood without banners. This man named Harwin, the former Master of Horse in Winterfell begs the brotherhood to bring her back to life, Beric gives up his life to bring her back to life. She's called Lady Stoneheart and is basically going around killing anyone related to the red wedding. She's specifically looking for Jaime Lannister bc in the books they say "Jaime Lannister send his regards" instead of "The Lannisters". GRRM said she will have big impact on the ending of Game of Thrones. Is a shame the writers never portrayed her in the show😭😭
might wanna add "spoilers" to your comment for the guys that haven't read/watched beyond this point. Also, I hope GRRM finishes the series man I can't wait for the next book 😭
@@yellowrain2062 oh sorry!😅 didn't even think about that. Omg there's a rumour trending on twitter, basically this cake company or bakery in new mexico, got a order to make a cake in dragon shape and is to celebrate a book release. Not trying to get my hopes up but we might get it soon.
This is why Tywin was telling Tyrion to hurry up and consummate the marriage with Sansa… he knew Robbs days were numbered and wanted Tyrion to inherit Sansa’s claim to the North
That's heart breaking. I wonder if they had decided to keep her hostage after Rob was killed but then she went absolutely mad so they realised there was nothing to do with her and decided to kill her?
In the book, Robb instinctively goes to warg into Grey Wind, but he's already been killed and there's only darkness. Jon and Robb figure out the warging to different degrees in the books. Also, just as Ned's death aired on Father's Day, this episode aired on Mother's Day!!
Did you read the books? Robb isn't a POV character, so we have no idea. We know Bran and Jon and Arya can Warg because they are POV characters and we're inside their heads. But we just assume Robb and Rickon have the ability based on details other POV characters observe about their relationships with their wolves. So we actually have no confirmation that Robb could Warg into Grey Wind. We just assume. And the Red Wedding is told through Cat's POV, so we don't know what Robb was thinking when he died.
You know, I'm just a girl. A girl who relates with McKay, who can't help but just smile throughout the bloodshed because he knows exactly how his friends are feeling right now.
The best twists aren't the ones we didn't see coming, they're the ones we *should* have seen coming. That's what makes the Red Wedding such genius writing. The clues were all there. But we were so used to the typical "son will avenge his father" trope, and "good guys ALWAYS triumph" tropes, that we either willfully ignored the signs, or missed them entirely. In hindsight, I always felt kind of stupid for assuming that Robb would win the war, especially after beheading Lord Rickard Karstark. Karstark was right. Robb lost the moment he married Talisa. It was only a matter of when and how.
@@akhnatenpage4854 Robert did those things during a time of peace as king whereas Robb messed up during a war where his life was constantly at stake, especially against an enemy like Tywin who was known for fighting wars in the most devious ways to win. Marrying Talisa was the only mistake Robb made but it hurt his reputation and honour as a king which only breeds rebellion during a time as volatile as war, especially when his followers are Northerners who respect honour above anything else. So that eventually snowballed into the Karstarks and Frey's abandoning his cause who made up over half of his army and resulted in his downfall since Tywin got to Walder Frey first and allied with him so Robb could never win him back. Robb's fate was sealed the moment he broke his marriage vow.
@@eggz5877 Robert had too many strong supporters backing him - Jon Arryn in the Vale, Ned in the North, and Hoster Tully in the Riverlands. Tywin had power during Robert's reign, but not allies. (And full-out enemies in Dorne due to the Elia and the children. And the Tyrells also had been Targ supporters.) He needed to play a long game. He's more free to make moves without repercussion now that the kingdom is divided into several factions and at war. Robb needed to gain allies and men beyond the North. Robb had the men from the Riverlands loyal to House Tully, but not all of the Riverlands. The Freys are essentially the Boltons of the Riverlands, hungry for years to take over Top Family from the Tullys. And Robb broke the terms of their alliance.
@@jcompton8507 Yeah tbh Robb couldve won regardless of who he married if Stannis didn't have the cheat code of killing Renly with a demon lmao. That whole thing also destroyed Robb's chances of winning cause Renly was the best ally Robb could've had since he had like over 100,000 soldiers and was willing to let Robb be king of the north.
One of the hardest scenes to watch in television history. And “The Rains of Castamere” is a Lannister song and Cat recognized it when it started playing and immediately knew Frey wasn’t an ally if a Lannister song was playing. You’re no longer summer children. The North Remembers ❤
well, this is actually the scene that CREATED the love for reaction videos... all the people that had read the books and knew what was coming, recorded their friends/family's reactions and they went viral!! truly an unforgettable scene, I was looking forward to your reaction!
Well, I already saw this reaction the first time it was uploaded, but glad it's back up again for the ones who missed out. It'd be nice if y'all would drop the reupload and the new upload on the same day at times like this. Anyway, I'll say it again, after witnessing the Red Wedding, y'all are no longer sweet summer children, so congrats! This accomplishment comes with depression and trauma, courtesy of Game of Thrones. And yeah, I'm pretty sure the Talisa part is the most traumatizing part for most people.
The best thing about being a book reader however bazillion years ago while your friends were sobbing on the couch, the rest of us were cackling that they named the baby Ned.
Bwahahaha. Yes! Everyone I watched the show with were book readers, so we knew it was coming. But the Red Wedding is one of a few examples of where the stuff that D&D added really created additional value. The suffering was terrible!
This is one episode you remember where and when you watched it. Think it "spawned" the reaction genre on youtube. People that read the books filmed their friends/partners reacting to it and it blew up on youtube.,
Almost nobody recognizes bolton in the wedding at first watch. No one cares who bolton is until now. Kudos to you guys for keeping track of his side story.
Nooo, didn't realize the video had been taken down so was expecting ep. 10 🥲 these re-uploads when the new episode should come out are just painful guys. Oh well, now to wait til monday...
24:50 The Freys throw her body into the river because she's a Tully. (Fish is their sigil) Then Arya in one of her wolf dreams in Nymeria pulls the body out the river and it's found by the Brotherhood without Banners. The guys who follow Beric Dondarrion, the guy who can come back to life. Beric transferred his "fire" into Catelyn and thus Lady Stoneheart was born.
The two smiles casually 😅😅 cracked me up. Also the little close ups of Mckay side eying the audience throughout little moments are the best. “And who are you the proud lord said, that I must bow so low” the Lannisters are on top of the game right now. Will you guys do the history and lore videos?
The line "The Lannister's send their regards" was actually different in the book, the line itself is a reference to when Jaime tells lord Bolton to send the Lannister's regards but in the book Jaime instead said something along the lines of "Tell Robb Stark I send my regards" so the line instead turns into "Jaime Lannister sends his regards" which just creates this sweet irony of believing that the person who Catelyn freed was the one who did this. It's a small thing but I'm quite sad they changed it, though "The Lannister's send their regards" is still quite good.
@@Hafsah_Adil It was just a throw away, asshole comment by Jaime to Roose Bolton when Roose releases him to continue on to Kings Landing. Tywin, Roose, and Walder Frey were the masterminds behind this. Jaime knows nothing of the plan. In his fevered state, I don't think Jaime has even picked up on the fact that Roose has "switched sides" (since, of course, it would spoil it for the readers, too). And, in another asshole move, Roose passes on Jaime's regards to Robb like he asked. In some ways, I think George wrote this in to make the readers wonder if we missed something... But even more important, the Red Wedding is Cat's POV chapter. So _she_ hears "Jaime Lannister sends his regards" and assumes Jaime is behind everything. And I imagine it' s going to matter _a lot_ to Lady Stoneheart...who seems to be completely driven by revenge... ...if we ever get more books...
@jcompton8507 thank you for explaining everything, I always thought jamie know cuz of what he said ,but i only watched the show ,my friend finished the book and he is going crazy waiting for the others to be released, so i will not submit myself to the same fate, Another question if i may ask, i saw some people saying that even if robb married a frey girl ,walder was going to Betray him ,is it true?
And sent Theon to his family, allowing the Greyjoys to raid the North. People forget that the North is a mess. It's the major reason Robb was losing support of the Northern lords.
This is what makes early Game of Thrones so brilliant. Every death (and, really, every major plot point) feels _earned_. It shocks you, but it doesn't come out of nowhere. You go back and see the build-up.
i watched this episode yesterday aswell and when i tell you the tears were running down my face! i dont cry but i was definitely crying for this episode.
Jon just doesn’t have the Stark name but Ned is his father so he is a Stark. He’s got Stark blood! And yeah, no matter how many times I see The Red Wedding, I still get traumatized. “The Lannister’s send their regards!”…OMG! 😳 Death to The Frey’s and The Bolton’s!
That Sunday night this episode came out the internet was going NUTS…. this is why reaction channels exists. It’s so sick I laugh at these reactions now to this episode 😂😂😂
Y’all have to chill! They had to completely re edit this episode because UA-cam removed it…it wasn’t by choice.On top of the other shows that they’re watching which I’m sure had to be edited as well. It was a small set back…it happens.Show some compassion and have some grace for the free content you’re receiving.
@@brownbutterb-roll921 fyi- they already are a season ahead in watching per their Patreon and episode 10 was already filmed. Editing episode 9 again didn't have anything to do with 10.
@@G3ForMe If you’re a Patron then why are you here whining about episode 10 that you can watch at your leisure? Episode 10 being watched and uploaded to Patreon does not mean that episode 10 was edited for UA-cam. Patreon episodes are unedited and uncut and over an hour long. Editing an episode that fits UA-cam’s copyright requirements can take HOURS especially these days as UA-cam has become more rigorous…any reactor will tell you this…EVERY reactor will tell you this and these guys are watching two series on this channel and have a whole second channel of content to edit and upload as well. If exercising a minuscule amount of patience is not your strong suit just say that.
Okay I better see 3x10 today as well because 3x9 was wednesdays episode lol Jokes aside i see some people pressuring yall about this but i think its bcuz we like yalls reactions and just want to see more. Maybe you guys dont think about this a lot but I am sure plenty of us look forward to your episodes. Its 5:12am in california I woke up 20 minutes ago and here I am typing a comment to yall meaning that checking Cinema Gek was one of the first things I did today lol. Its part of my morning routine and I am sure its part of others as well. Havent been this hooked on a channel in a while and I just dont wanna se yall loose momentum
I remember watching the Red wedding the first time it came up. I was 17/18 yo i think and I was completely lying on the floor, weeping at the end of that episode. Give me trauma to this day but still enjoy watching people reacting to this episode especially.
Finally a group that understands the even though we love(ed) Rob, he made stupid decisions that lead to this. They don’t know how to play the Game of Thrones.
The song that was played is the official theme for the Lannisters "The rain of castamere" which is why Cat reacted. She heard the theme and started to piece everything together.
The show tried to drop the song in here and there as much as they could - Lannister men singing it in a brothel, Bronn singing it as he and Tyrion journey to KL. They ended one of the episodes with a cover of the song by The National. And of course playing it as the Lannister theme during big moments. Too bad many _still_ didn't pick up on it.
NO NOT THE RE UPLOAD!!😫 If you remember a couple of episodes ago even JOFFERY was looking at everyone sideways when they were telling him not to marry Sansa anymore!! He said something about how the a vow of marriage is sacred!! So yeah Rob fucked up pretty bad after a bunch of rewatches I don’t fuck with him or Kat🤣😂Right after capturing Jaime all they did was fumble!! Side note Carter is becoming desensitized he just watched a ladies neck get sliced wide open and he didn’t cover his eyes he barely flinched😂
Kat made a few mistakes, but the two major ones that fucked them (executing lord Karkstark and betraying the betrothal) were Robbs. They wouldn't have needed the Frey troops if the Karkstarks hadn't left them. And Kat explicitly warned Robb against both of those decisions.
@@JessYapping Robb is only 16 when he dies here in the books. He's just turned 15 at the beginning of the books. (And Jon is 14, Theon is 18, Dany is 13 - crazy to think she's only a little over a year older than Sansa in the books... And Tyrion is only mid-20s.)
oh it's too bad that they knew something big was coming! the shock factor is the best for the first time watchers who have no idea this is such a big episode!!
So in the books Catelyn’s body is thrown naked to the lake as a mock to the customs of the Tully. And actually Arya’s wolf (because arya is connected with her wolf with wolf dreams and in this time she is extremely depressed that catelyn is dead) so Arya’s wolf fishes her out of the sea and Beric broughts her back to life but the way she died is very brutal so when she comes back she is like a zombie looking, vengeance fueled person who basically leads the brotherhood of the banners. Arya is kind of traumatized and not convinced that her mother is dead but via her wolf dreams i feel like she sees/feels her body and then the wolf fishes her out. She gets vengeance on the freys. Lady Stoneheart yep
The way this episode had everyone in a choke hold. Fun fact the song that Catelyn recognised is the "Rains of Castermere" which tells the tale of house Castermere that fell for crossing the lannisters. The previous episode it was discussed with Cersi and Magaery. The songs serves as a warning and a lesson and Cat knew that something was low-key wrong because everyone at the wedding were Northerners so why play a Lannisters song at the wedding when the two houses are at war?
In the books Catelyn is revived by Thoros of Myr the same way he revives Lord Beric Dondarrion, but if I remember correctly that ability can de used once at a time, so Beric dies instead and I believe then Cat takes over The Brotherhood and starts hunting down every Lannister ally she can find and executes them, gaining the name "Lady Stoneheart". Sadly, it was never adapted to the show. (Forgive any mistakes, I've only read the book more than ten years ago and only read them once)
No, Thoros refuses to try to resurrect her because she has been dead for days, and her body is waterlogged from floating in the river. (Nymeria pulls her out.) It was Beric who gave his "last life" to her through "the kiss of life." Making Lady Stoneheart the de facto leader of the Brotherhood, giving her all of Beric's followers.
They keep the wedding to Edmure (Cat's brother) because 1. It means the freys have rights to riverrun and 2. Now Riverrun won't continue to fight the war since the Freys are holding their lord
And, Dammit!, Walder Frey has been trying to marry into the Tully family for decades!!! The chip on his shoulder is huge! Even though Hoster is dead, Walder would get so much satisfaction for finally sticking it to him!
Jackson and Mckay smiling during the Red Wedding is freaking cracking me up.
😂😂😂
es que son unos sádicos xD
Mckay when something good happens: 😃
Mckay when something bad happens: 😃
Hate them. The most smirking one especially. Really hate him for this behaviour.
@@angr2773 you should see a therapist
Dead at the three looking depressed and the two smirking. It is Robb's fault. He chose love over honour and it got everyone killed.
And in the books, not even that. He had a night of passion and got a girl pregnant. And to not dishonor her or have a bastard - not wanting to be his father in that moment and making another Jon Snow, knowing that disgrace and the hardship for Jon - he married her.
So in the books, he didn't even choose love over honour, but chose to honour one thing in lieu of another.
@@emiliad.858 Actually that was an extremely smart move on Tywin's part.
@@tealsummers2316 it’s just my copium. Maybe it was smart but I wouldn’t want a man like that running shit in westeros if I was alive in these times. No thanks lol that man allows children to be executed he’s demonic
I think the Boltons and the Freys would have betrayed the Starks further down the line anyway.
@@emiliad.858 I wouldn't say desperate, rather a great strategist. He would've found a way to destroy Robb's army either way.
This episode is the reason reaction channels exists. Everyone who read the books already knew what was coming and they recorded their family or friends reactions to the Red wedding and uploaded in UA-cam so here we are today watching other people’s reactions to the GOT or other TV series
I said this during the first load of this reaction video.
What happened that there needed to be a re upload?
Where is episode 10 reaction?
I remember when this first came out and the very first reaction videos were posted on UA-cam with the cameras hidden and low quality.
@@OpeningsOpenings Their video got restricted that’s why they re uploaded
@@juffy29 yes that reaction videos taken 11 years ago still in here which is really crazy
I think they existed before this, but were a very small niche market.
This episode was when they took off and went mega-viral. Book readers, knowing this was coming, set up cameras to record their friends and families watching this because they knew the reactions would be epic. It was the spark that ignited the phenomenon that reaction channels have become.
Everyone: 😮☹️☹️☹️
McKay: 😃😃😃
Walder Frey invited them into his home, and broke bread with them. That is considered the ultimate peace offering and you do not break it under any circumstances. Inviting guests under your roof and then slaughtering them is regarded as worse than breaking any oath.
That's why Robb was so relaxed. He would have never expected Frey to do that after breaking bread!
And for that he will be Rat Cook
Exactly! Its insane to me that Tywin, Walder Frey and Roose Bolton violated such an important tradition, thats bound to break trust all over the 7 kingdoms
Yeah but after it happens it makes sense like rob broke a wedding oath and Frey would’ve been father of the queen in the north
@@lalalalala198 and the riverlands, my boy walder got didnt deserve that disrespect
@@lalalalala198 Even then though, it's a crazy thing. It's the tradition in Westeros that symbolises ultimate trust in order to have diplomacy. Without that to rely on, you can never again have peace talks or negotiations because the tradition might be broken. Of course, David and Dan decided this wasn't interesting or important in later seasons and had peace talks with blind trust because fuck it.
Yay, red wedding. Calling my therapist now.
4th mustache guy start laughing as soon as they started stabbing pregnant lady what a sick person
@@llllllNYU The only sick one here is you.
The song they were playing before the slaughter was "The Rains of Castamere," which is a Lannister song about House Reyne, who Tywin Lannister destroyed.
That's another brutal story. Someone should read it to them.
Cersei just used it to threaten Margaery in a recent scene. (Was it at Tyrion and Sansa's wedding? Close to there...)
They are children of spring no longer. Now they are men of winter.
… and the north remembers
the left one wolf alive.
@@keystorm8598 and the sheep are never safe...
The north remembers
The North remembers.
carter being frozen in shock for like half the debrief
“Love is the death of Duty” - Maester Aemon
Love got Robb killed
Love and his mother. Let's not forget the only reason he needed Frey’s help in the first place was because she freed Jaime. Freeing Jaime led to Kastark betrayal... which led to needing frey. A combination of cat's and Robb mistakes is the reason they're dead.
@@rudyhernandez7128 Not really. Robb would eventually get f'd by the Freys anyway. He wanted to go North again and even if he didnt he would have been trapped in the Riverlands with the Freys at his back. He is the one who burned his bridges with them, and without knowing made it really easy for Walder Frey to do what he was going to do anyway. But he was already f'd when he married Jeyne Westerling/Volantisgirl. If Walder Frey wasnt the kind of person to join the winning side at the end Robb would have been dead way earlier.
@@teunvanderveen6477 not if Robb won the war... tyrion said it best "frey wouldn't risk such actions without certain insurances" if he defeated Lanniesters then frey wouldn't do it. Besides, defeating the Lanniesters means taking the royal fleet... so they could sail up to white harbor. But we're talking about a alternate reality... so who knows. You can go by what could have happen, I'll go by what did happen. And Cat just at fault as much as Robb... go ahead and ignore her mistakes though lol
@@rudyhernandez7128 I think you didnt get what i was saying. He couldnt have won the war because he made the Freys his enemy. I think your dislike of Cat is leading here. You should reread the books
@@teunvanderveen6477 I'm talking about the show since that is what they are watching bro... they ain't reading the Damn book. Robb: "I need men to replace the kastarks that haven't already sided with the Lanniesters" if cat didn't free Jaime then he wouldn't need men to replace Kastark because Kastark would still be there.
Let me get this straight... just because I don't ignore cat's mistakes means I dislike her? Give me a break... you funny AF. Holding cat accountable does not mean I hate or dislike her. It's a simple fact that freeing Jaime play just as big a part in thier deaths as much as Robb being dishonorable.
Would they have died anyways? Maybe, but we don't know. I only know what did happen. But if you think freeing Jaime had no consequences then you're just delusional
So many crucial decisions led to this. The first being Robb sending away Theon, followed by Cat giving away Jaime, and Robb breaking his vow.
There is still a really high chance that the Freys and Boltons would have betrayed Robb. Tywin's sister was married to one of the Freys. And the Boltons have been at heads with the Starks for the North for millennia. Robb (and to some extent Cat) just made it all the more easy for them.
I hope Cannon and carter are okay😂😩
I think Robb executing Rickard Karstark was one of the most important decisions because it drove away Karstarks, which emboldened Boltons and Freys in their decision to betray Robb.
@@gingermojito8 definitely. The reason that happened though is because Cat sent away Jaime.
Also, House Bolton supplied the 2000 men sacrificed to capture Jaime in Season 1. Roose Bolton was able to get away but he was sent to die by Robb.
I was as giddy as Jackson & McKay to see everyone's reaction until Cathlyn's wailed. Her despair over the loss of her "last" son just made me cried, again.
Recommenting here cus this one deserves it.
The indifference on her face when she gets the knife... she already died during that scream.
In the books, long before the red wedding when Dany was walking in the house of the Undying one of the rooms had a feast filled with dead people, there was a man with a crowned wolf's head at the head of the table. But they didn't put it in the show 😔
Instead the show substitutes it for the scene next episode where Arya is being led away from the twins and she sees his head sewn onto his direwolf atop the horse (unless that was this episode and they didnt how that part but I think it's next)
@@AfterlifeAnubis If my memory is correct from reading the books then the scene where arya sees the wolf head on the body was already in the book... so it wasn't substituted. But it's been over 5 years since I read them, so I could be wrong.
They’re both in the books. I remember because the Arya scene was so difficult to read and I wondered if I had a strong enough stomach to make it. It’s amazing how much foreshadowing GRRM was able to put into the House of the Undying scene in the books. Not a single detail lacking in significance.
@@rudyhernandez7128 oh no I was more confused about which episode they had her visually see the body with the wolves head, just finished rereading the series again but haven't seen the show in a bit
@@AfterlifeAnubis ohh. Yeah it's the finale 3x10. First couple of minutes
It hurts so much, she thought. Our children, Ned, all our sweet babes. Rickon, Bran, Arya, Sansa, Robb . . . Robb . . . please, Ned, please, make it stop, make it stop hurting . . . The white tears and the red ones ran together until her face was torn and tattered, the face that Ned had loved. Catelyn Stark raised her hands and watched the blood run down her long fingers, over her wrists, beneath the sleeves of her gown. Slow red worms crawled along her arms and under her clothes. It tickles. That made her laugh until she screamed. ‘‘Mad,’’ someone said, ‘‘she’s lost her wits,’’ and someone else said, ‘‘Make an end,’’ and a hand grabbed her scalp just as she’d done with Jinglebell, and she thought, No, don’t, don’t cut my hair, Ned loves my hair. Then the steel was at her throat, and its bite was red and cold.
"No, don’t, don’t cut my hair, Ned loves my hair."
ugh that hurts the most. I had always thought the Lady Stoneheart thing was cool, but it's even more tragic than the Red Wedding; at least in her madness Cat thought she'd see Ned again. Now as Stoneheart she isn't even really alive anymore, just a hollow shell of Catelyn Stark...and still separated from her family. God it hurts.
George's prose is so good that even this scene is beautiful in a way
Honestly I really want to see how Lady Stoneheart plays out.
God...I read this in the mid-2000s. I remember throwing my book across the room. It hit the wall, and some of the pages fell out. Makes me laugh whenever I open the book now and see the evidence of my reaction.
The red wedding is actually based on 2 real life events from Scottish history the black dinner and the glencoe massacre.
29 episodes in and they’ve finally started Game Of Thrones!
Michelle Fairley's performance is so underrated in Game of Thrones, she did an amazing job portraying Catelyn Stark. Some Fun Facts from the books: Greywind was being aggressive with the Freys since Robb arrived at The Twins. Catelyn basically claws her face with her nails in madness as she sees Robb being killed. Walder was going to keep her alive as an hostage to force the river lords to bend the knee to King Joffrey but seeing her descend into madness, the ended up killing her. Her naked body is thrown in the river (as a mockery of the funeral customs of House Tully.💀). She's dragged out by Arya's direwolf and then found by the brotherhood without banners. This man named Harwin, the former Master of Horse in Winterfell begs the brotherhood to bring her back to life, Beric gives up his life to bring her back to life. She's called Lady Stoneheart and is basically going around killing anyone related to the red wedding. She's specifically looking for Jaime Lannister bc in the books they say "Jaime Lannister send his regards" instead of "The Lannisters". GRRM said she will have big impact on the ending of Game of Thrones. Is a shame the writers never portrayed her in the show😭😭
might wanna add "spoilers" to your comment for the guys that haven't read/watched beyond this point. Also, I hope GRRM finishes the series man I can't wait for the next book 😭
@@yellowrain2062 oh sorry!😅 didn't even think about that. Omg there's a rumour trending on twitter, basically this cake company or bakery in new mexico, got a order to make a cake in dragon shape and is to celebrate a book release. Not trying to get my hopes up but we might get it soon.
@@amnasiddique6886 no problem! I really hope it is the Winds of Winter they're talking about, highly doubt it though 😔 Maybe another spin off book?
@@amnasiddique6886I think it might be at the end of this year or next year.
This is why Tywin was telling Tyrion to hurry up and consummate the marriage with Sansa… he knew Robbs days were numbered and wanted Tyrion to inherit Sansa’s claim to the North
“Yes, now the rains weep o’er his halls and not a soul to hear.” - The Rains of Castamere
In the books is kind of worse as last Cat's thoughts were something like "Please dont cut my hair. Ned loves my hair."
The way the book describes Cat going mad while clawing her face and her thoughts was a masterpiece honestly
Catelyn's pov at that moment are heart wrenching
That's heart breaking. I wonder if they had decided to keep her hostage after Rob was killed but then she went absolutely mad so they realised there was nothing to do with her and decided to kill her?
@@johnnyskinwalker4095in the books she gets resurrected and is vengeful and mad and wants to kill the freys and Lannisters
@@SaeedUrRehman1 yea I knew that lol.
"I'll find another" is one of the coldest lines in the whole show.
And it was written for the show! Cat grabs one of Walder's sons in the books. And he basically says he has others.
That's not "cold", that's disgusting and evil.
The silence at the end of that episode always gets me.
Never been this excited to see grown men cry
Im always excited for that
In the book, Robb instinctively goes to warg into Grey Wind, but he's already been killed and there's only darkness. Jon and Robb figure out the warging to different degrees in the books. Also, just as Ned's death aired on Father's Day, this episode aired on Mother's Day!!
Did you read the books? Robb isn't a POV character, so we have no idea.
We know Bran and Jon and Arya can Warg because they are POV characters and we're inside their heads.
But we just assume Robb and Rickon have the ability based on details other POV characters observe about their relationships with their wolves.
So we actually have no confirmation that Robb could Warg into Grey Wind. We just assume.
And the Red Wedding is told through Cat's POV, so we don't know what Robb was thinking when he died.
Oh, that's messed up! 😂
I will never forget the first time I saw this episode, one of my greatest traumas of all the series I have seen
Can't begin to tell you how many cuss words I threw at Walder Frey when this was going on and he was smirking
I will never forget the way they stabbed Talisa. literally makes me feel ill.
You know, I'm just a girl.
A girl who relates with McKay, who can't help but just smile throughout the bloodshed because he knows exactly how his friends are feeling right now.
The best twists aren't the ones we didn't see coming, they're the ones we *should* have seen coming.
That's what makes the Red Wedding such genius writing. The clues were all there. But we were so used to the typical "son will avenge his father" trope, and "good guys ALWAYS triumph" tropes, that we either willfully ignored the signs, or missed them entirely. In hindsight, I always felt kind of stupid for assuming that Robb would win the war, especially after beheading Lord Rickard Karstark. Karstark was right. Robb lost the moment he married Talisa. It was only a matter of when and how.
It’s silly that marrying one girl would ruin Rob in my opinion. Especially with how openly the last king cheated for like 20 years.
@@akhnatenpage4854 Robert did those things during a time of peace as king whereas Robb messed up during a war where his life was constantly at stake, especially against an enemy like Tywin who was known for fighting wars in the most devious ways to win. Marrying Talisa was the only mistake Robb made but it hurt his reputation and honour as a king which only breeds rebellion during a time as volatile as war, especially when his followers are Northerners who respect honour above anything else. So that eventually snowballed into the Karstarks and Frey's abandoning his cause who made up over half of his army and resulted in his downfall since Tywin got to Walder Frey first and allied with him so Robb could never win him back. Robb's fate was sealed the moment he broke his marriage vow.
I didn't help that Winterfell and parts of the North along the coast were under control of the Greyjoys at this time.
@@eggz5877 Robert had too many strong supporters backing him - Jon Arryn in the Vale, Ned in the North, and Hoster Tully in the Riverlands. Tywin had power during Robert's reign, but not allies. (And full-out enemies in Dorne due to the Elia and the children. And the Tyrells also had been Targ supporters.) He needed to play a long game. He's more free to make moves without repercussion now that the kingdom is divided into several factions and at war.
Robb needed to gain allies and men beyond the North. Robb had the men from the Riverlands loyal to House Tully, but not all of the Riverlands. The Freys are essentially the Boltons of the Riverlands, hungry for years to take over Top Family from the Tullys. And Robb broke the terms of their alliance.
@@jcompton8507 Yeah tbh Robb couldve won regardless of who he married if Stannis didn't have the cheat code of killing Renly with a demon lmao. That whole thing also destroyed Robb's chances of winning cause Renly was the best ally Robb could've had since he had like over 100,000 soldiers and was willing to let Robb be king of the north.
One of the hardest scenes to watch in television history. And “The Rains of Castamere” is a Lannister song and Cat recognized it when it started playing and immediately knew Frey wasn’t an ally if a Lannister song was playing. You’re no longer summer children.
The North Remembers ❤
well, this is actually the scene that CREATED the love for reaction videos... all the people that had read the books and knew what was coming, recorded their friends/family's reactions and they went viral!! truly an unforgettable scene, I was looking forward to your reaction!
Cannon looked so defeated, Carter was in shock, and Brig was unusually so quiet. I can’t stand seeing these 3 like this.
Well, I already saw this reaction the first time it was uploaded, but glad it's back up again for the ones who missed out. It'd be nice if y'all would drop the reupload and the new upload on the same day at times like this.
Anyway, I'll say it again, after witnessing the Red Wedding, y'all are no longer sweet summer children, so congrats! This accomplishment comes with depression and trauma, courtesy of Game of Thrones. And yeah, I'm pretty sure the Talisa part is the most traumatizing part for most people.
The best thing about being a book reader however bazillion years ago while your friends were sobbing on the couch, the rest of us were cackling that they named the baby Ned.
Bwahahaha. Yes! Everyone I watched the show with were book readers, so we knew it was coming. But the Red Wedding is one of a few examples of where the stuff that D&D added really created additional value. The suffering was terrible!
THE WAY THEY PAUSED THE SHOW LMAOOO I was smirking like jackson and mckay because the rest's reaction was so genuine and hilarious lmao
This is one episode you remember where and when you watched it. Think it "spawned" the reaction genre on youtube.
People that read the books filmed their friends/partners reacting to it and it blew up on youtube.,
You can edit your comment, but the north rembers 👀👀
@@Nexrasa
Ned's death and the Red Wedding really changed storytelling. Now everyone tries to write these sorts of scenes in their shows/books/movies/etc.
Almost nobody recognizes bolton in the wedding at first watch. No one cares who bolton is until now. Kudos to you guys for keeping track of his side story.
Nooo, didn't realize the video had been taken down so was expecting ep. 10 🥲 these re-uploads when the new episode should come out are just painful guys. Oh well, now to wait til monday...
"Love is the death of duty." - Maester Aemon
«Leave one wolf alive, and sheep’s are never safe”
Congratulations on surviving the red wedding trauma. 😂
I'm not sure they survived though. everybody dies a little inside watching the red wedding ;)))
Wouldn’t say Carter died a little though. He died A LOT 😂
Mckay just couldn't stop smiling during the wedding 😂😂
Can't believe we're finally here.
Again. They posted this two days ago too! :(
24:50 The Freys throw her body into the river because she's a Tully. (Fish is their sigil) Then Arya in one of her wolf dreams in Nymeria pulls the body out the river and it's found by the Brotherhood without Banners. The guys who follow Beric Dondarrion, the guy who can come back to life. Beric transferred his "fire" into Catelyn and thus Lady Stoneheart was born.
I'm glad they didn't go that route in the show because Cat made so many horrible decisions I was glad she was gone.
The two smiles casually 😅😅 cracked me up. Also the little close ups of Mckay side eying the audience throughout little moments are the best.
“And who are you the proud lord said, that I must bow so low” the Lannisters are on top of the game right now. Will you guys do the history and lore videos?
carter checked out the moment talisa got stabbed, cant blame him tbh
The line "The Lannister's send their regards" was actually different in the book, the line itself is a reference to when Jaime tells lord Bolton to send the Lannister's regards but in the book Jaime instead said something along the lines of "Tell Robb Stark I send my regards" so the line instead turns into "Jaime Lannister sends his regards" which just creates this sweet irony of believing that the person who Catelyn freed was the one who did this. It's a small thing but I'm quite sad they changed it, though "The Lannister's send their regards" is still quite good.
So jamie in the book wasn't going to let arya and sansa go as he promised?
@@Hafsah_Adil It was just a throw away, asshole comment by Jaime to Roose Bolton when Roose releases him to continue on to Kings Landing. Tywin, Roose, and Walder Frey were the masterminds behind this. Jaime knows nothing of the plan. In his fevered state, I don't think Jaime has even picked up on the fact that Roose has "switched sides" (since, of course, it would spoil it for the readers, too).
And, in another asshole move, Roose passes on Jaime's regards to Robb like he asked.
In some ways, I think George wrote this in to make the readers wonder if we missed something...
But even more important, the Red Wedding is Cat's POV chapter. So _she_ hears "Jaime Lannister sends his regards" and assumes Jaime is behind everything. And I imagine it' s going to matter _a lot_ to Lady Stoneheart...who seems to be completely driven by revenge...
...if we ever get more books...
@jcompton8507 thank you for explaining everything, I always thought jamie know cuz of what he said ,but i only watched the show ,my friend finished the book and he is going crazy waiting for the others to be released, so i will not submit myself to the same fate,
Another question if i may ask, i saw some people saying that even if robb married a frey girl ,walder was going to Betray him ,is it true?
B-briggs….. a-are you okay bud.
“I’m not angry, I’m just sad.” - 😂
Thanks for the upload, Lord of Light. Lead us from the darkness, O my Lord. Fill our hearts with fire, so we may walk your shining path.
Rob made 2 major mistakes he betrayed his oath to walder frey and executed lord karstark. Both times he went against what katlyn said
And sent Theon to his family, allowing the Greyjoys to raid the North. People forget that the North is a mess. It's the major reason Robb was losing support of the Northern lords.
Most gut punching moment in TV that was also aggressively foreshadowed.
This is what makes early Game of Thrones so brilliant. Every death (and, really, every major plot point) feels _earned_. It shocks you, but it doesn't come out of nowhere. You go back and see the build-up.
The silence at the end lmao
4:10 ”Bro, this is painful“
Oh you sweet summer child~
Rat Bolton... Just wait till you meet Rat Junior!
We can see the satisfaction in the eye of whose already watched the red wedding and see the chock of whose haven't yet
i watched this episode yesterday aswell and when i tell you the tears were running down my face! i dont cry but i was definitely crying for this episode.
Jon just doesn’t have the Stark name but Ned is his father so he is a Stark. He’s got Stark blood! And yeah, no matter how many times I see The Red Wedding, I still get traumatized. “The Lannister’s send their regards!”…OMG! 😳 Death to The Frey’s and The Bolton’s!
And now it begins
That Sunday night this episode came out the internet was going NUTS…. this is why reaction channels exists. It’s so sick I laugh at these reactions now to this episode 😂😂😂
I swear this one was uploaded on Wednesday and today was supposed to be 3x10. What a bummer!
Yep exactly! Upload both!😅
Y’all have to chill! They had to completely re edit this episode because UA-cam removed it…it wasn’t by choice.On top of the other shows that they’re watching which I’m sure had to be edited as well. It was a small set back…it happens.Show some compassion and have some grace for the free content you’re receiving.
@@brownbutterb-roll921 fyi- they already are a season ahead in watching per their Patreon and episode 10 was already filmed. Editing episode 9 again didn't have anything to do with 10.
@@G3ForMe If you’re a Patron then why are you here whining about episode 10 that you can watch at your leisure?
Episode 10 being watched and uploaded to Patreon does not mean that episode 10 was edited for UA-cam. Patreon episodes are unedited and uncut and over an hour long. Editing an episode that fits UA-cam’s copyright requirements can take HOURS especially these days as UA-cam has become more rigorous…any reactor will tell you this…EVERY reactor will tell you this and these guys are watching two series on this channel and have a whole second channel of content to edit and upload as well. If exercising a minuscule amount of patience is not your strong suit just say that.
@@brownbutterb-roll921 it's funny that people like you who think that having discourse is whining. A typical JCDer.
Okay I better see 3x10 today as well because 3x9 was wednesdays episode lol
Jokes aside i see some people pressuring yall about this but i think its bcuz we like yalls reactions and just want to see more. Maybe you guys dont think about this a lot but I am sure plenty of us look forward to your episodes. Its 5:12am in california I woke up 20 minutes ago and here I am typing a comment to yall meaning that checking Cinema Gek was one of the first things I did today lol. Its part of my morning routine and I am sure its part of others as well. Havent been this hooked on a channel in a while and I just dont wanna se yall loose momentum
Same hahah and I’m
In New Zealand
And the way the credits come up with no music/just complete silence gives me chills
Wound up here late night randomly in my feed but these reactions are so much more goated on Patreon
I remember watching the Red wedding the first time it came up. I was 17/18 yo i think and I was completely lying on the floor, weeping at the end of that episode. Give me trauma to this day but still enjoy watching people reacting to this episode especially.
Oh this was just as amazing as expected! 2 are smiling and the rest are super depressed. 😁 Perfection.
Smirking like Palpatine 😂😂 before a massacre . It’s a painful right of passage
EP 10 babes! already seen this, don't do this to me 🤸♂️ can't wait!!
Finally a group that understands the even though we love(ed) Rob, he made stupid decisions that lead to this. They don’t know how to play the Game of Thrones.
To all the Geks,
On the level from one to Robb Stark, how much do you like attending Carter's wedding?
You mean Jackson?
He also got married @@toonbax3
@@toonbax3 Carter married last week.
@@LameKitten55 Oh what!?!?!? Him too!? Oh okay, that's awesome! Thanks for letting me know
Oh was it filmed somewhere?
Thank you for this! Hopefully we can see the 10th episode too by this week.
The song that was played is the official theme for the Lannisters "The rain of castamere" which is why Cat reacted. She heard the theme and started to piece everything together.
The show tried to drop the song in here and there as much as they could - Lannister men singing it in a brothel, Bronn singing it as he and Tyrion journey to KL. They ended one of the episodes with a cover of the song by The National.
And of course playing it as the Lannister theme during big moments.
Too bad many _still_ didn't pick up on it.
"I have known Lord Walder since I was a girl. He would never harm me."
NO NOT THE RE UPLOAD!!😫
If you remember a couple of episodes ago even JOFFERY was looking at everyone sideways when they were telling him not to marry Sansa anymore!! He said something about how the a vow of marriage is sacred!! So yeah Rob fucked up pretty bad after a bunch of rewatches I don’t fuck with him or Kat🤣😂Right after capturing Jaime all they did was fumble!! Side note Carter is becoming desensitized he just watched a ladies neck get sliced wide open and he didn’t cover his eyes he barely flinched😂
Kat made a few mistakes, but the two major ones that fucked them (executing lord Karkstark and betraying the betrothal) were Robbs. They wouldn't have needed the Frey troops if the Karkstarks hadn't left them. And Kat explicitly warned Robb against both of those decisions.
@@tortoiseoflegends4466 true Rob messed up huge but I think everyone says he’s suppose to be young in the books so that makes it a little better
@@tortoiseoflegends4466 And Theon and the Greyjoys raiding the North.
@@JessYapping Robb is only 16 when he dies here in the books. He's just turned 15 at the beginning of the books. (And Jon is 14, Theon is 18, Dany is 13 - crazy to think she's only a little over a year older than Sansa in the books... And Tyrion is only mid-20s.)
@@jcompton8507 yeah it’s crazy I really want to read the books but knowing G.R.R.M left everyone with blue balls I don’t want to be left in read too🤣
Carter's face is the same as mine, the trauma was reflected in my face after the red wedding.
Cheeky of you to re upload on a regular day. Should've uploaded that day
I’m grateful they uploaded it again! Be nice
Got scammed brev
@@jodyvollmer4125 I was waiting for ep10 bruv
this episode was one of the hardest pieces of television I've ever watched...
I was waiting for this to be uploaded. Golden reactions from u guys 😂
"The NORTH Remembers" 🐺🥶
This is the part of the show where you very quickly find out EXACTLY who you hate and love. There is no more in between for many
@17:04 everyone shocked. Mckay smiling hahaah
One good thing about the red wedding is that no one expected it to happen (aside from book readers) making people shocks and devastated at the end
I’ve been waiting for this reaction haha
I love McKay so much 😂give these poor boys a hug though, oh my god.
oh it's too bad that they knew something big was coming! the shock factor is the best for the first time watchers who have no idea this is such a big episode!!
LMAO at the 2 cracking up 😂 and other 3 depressed
People who read the books knew... but we keep our mouths shut. A true book fan will never spoil it for you.
We just come to drink your tears ❤😉
So in the books Catelyn’s body is thrown naked to the lake as a mock to the customs of the Tully. And actually Arya’s wolf (because arya is connected with her wolf with wolf dreams and in this time she is extremely depressed that catelyn is dead) so Arya’s wolf fishes her out of the sea and Beric broughts her back to life but the way she died is very brutal so when she comes back she is like a zombie looking, vengeance fueled person who basically leads the brotherhood of the banners. Arya is kind of traumatized and not convinced that her mother is dead but via her wolf dreams i feel like she sees/feels her body and then the wolf fishes her out. She gets vengeance on the freys. Lady Stoneheart yep
Carter taken that moment of Silence.
The RED WEDDING... PTSD is coming back
The way this episode had everyone in a choke hold.
Fun fact the song that Catelyn recognised is the "Rains of Castermere" which tells the tale of house Castermere that fell for crossing the lannisters. The previous episode it was discussed with Cersi and Magaery. The songs serves as a warning and a lesson and Cat knew that something was low-key wrong because everyone at the wedding were Northerners so why play a Lannisters song at the wedding when the two houses are at war?
I was crying however when I saw the three being depress and speechless and Mckay and Jack smiling can't help but laugh😂
watched this couple of times now and still makes me cry. Imagine seeing this episode the first time...
In the books Catelyn is revived by Thoros of Myr the same way he revives Lord Beric Dondarrion, but if I remember correctly that ability can de used once at a time, so Beric dies instead and I believe then Cat takes over The Brotherhood and starts hunting down every Lannister ally she can find and executes them, gaining the name "Lady Stoneheart". Sadly, it was never adapted to the show.
(Forgive any mistakes, I've only read the book more than ten years ago and only read them once)
No, Thoros refuses to try to resurrect her because she has been dead for days, and her body is waterlogged from floating in the river. (Nymeria pulls her out.)
It was Beric who gave his "last life" to her through "the kiss of life."
Making Lady Stoneheart the de facto leader of the Brotherhood, giving her all of Beric's followers.
This is epic ! Welcome in GOT guys..... It's still not much... there's still a lot waiting for you ! 😊
No children of summer here anymore. Just 5 men of winter.
I spy with my little eyes 3 broken men…
Lol McKay is the physical embodiment of the audience….
“Love is the death of duty.”
JACKSON AND MAKAYS FACES😂😂😂😂😂 It’s me when I recomend something that broked my heart to someone and it breaks their heart😂😂
The emotional damage at the end 🤣🤣🤣
26:45 “Love is the death of duty”
They keep the wedding to Edmure (Cat's brother) because 1. It means the freys have rights to riverrun and 2. Now Riverrun won't continue to fight the war since the Freys are holding their lord
And, Dammit!, Walder Frey has been trying to marry into the Tully family for decades!!! The chip on his shoulder is huge! Even though Hoster is dead, Walder would get so much satisfaction for finally sticking it to him!
Oh alright, you've twisted my arm...I will rewatch 😂
4th mustache guy start laughing as soon as they started stabbing pregnant lady what a sick person