Can Chinese Write Chinese Characters? | Social Experiment

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 177

  • @neometalx9
    @neometalx9 4 роки тому +120

    My Chinese parents actually use handwriting in their cellphone to communicate and not pinyin, I guess that would help them remember how to write most of the characters.

    • @abcdefghi29111
      @abcdefghi29111 3 роки тому +3

      Yep that's what I do the most

    • @_stars.in.void_
      @_stars.in.void_ 3 роки тому +1

      I'm sorry if I sound rude put what does Pinyin mean

    • @grantorino2325
      @grantorino2325 3 роки тому +7

      @@_stars.in.void_
      It's the name of the system used (since 1949) to write Chinese words *alphabetically* . It replaced the old Wade-Giles system.
      For instance, the word "northern capital," in Wade-Giles, is "pe king," but in Pin Yin, it's "bei jing." "Fragrant harbor" in Wade-Giles is "hong kong," but in Pin Yin, it's "xiang gang."
      But "on the sea," in *both* , is "shang hai."

    • @_stars.in.void_
      @_stars.in.void_ 3 роки тому +2

      @@grantorino2325 tysm for telling me what it means

    • @yonggeun4222
      @yonggeun4222 10 місяців тому

      chinese language is stupid

  • @jenelyncamerino1980
    @jenelyncamerino1980 4 роки тому +123

    All those years of studying went for nothing...DAMN THAT'S ALSO MY LINE😂

    • @clintzieandromeda6216
      @clintzieandromeda6216 3 роки тому +3

      You mean you've been studying how to write in Chinese but sooner later it ended nothing?

    • @Soreto23
      @Soreto23 Рік тому +2

      ​@@clintzieandromeda6216this is of course not true, but some characters Chinese people might forget, but it is not like they forgot half of them, just small part, these one in video I believe are tricky, that's why they have some problems, nowadays people who wants to learn chinese, skip writing part, honestly I am one of them, and I wonder if it is a good idea, because thanks to the writing characters I would remember them much easier

  • @TIMHAOW
    @TIMHAOW 5 років тому +27

    我們這裡
    1.妨礙 ㄈㄤˊㄞˋ
    2.賄賂 ㄏㄨㄟˋㄌㄨˋ
    3.肇事 ㄓㄠˋㄕˋ

  • @buldakcarbo
    @buldakcarbo 4 роки тому +43

    if you see it it’s easy to know what character it is but writing it from scratch is much harder

  • @samgg9502
    @samgg9502 6 років тому +71

    我看见这视频 默默拿起了纸,拿起了笔。视频结束,放下了笔 纸上全部错别字....我默默
    打开电脑 玩游戏XD

  • @國父-e9t
    @國父-e9t 7 років тому +47

    手机/电脑惹的祸

  • @skpuaduriantv6738
    @skpuaduriantv6738 7 років тому +36

    年輕人都是用手機,電腦,老年人反而比較少這些東西

  • @jakdexter2075
    @jakdexter2075 2 роки тому +7

    My Chinese teacher had always praise my handwriting at that time. I had never seen how an authentic Chinese student write but now looking at it I can see why.

  • @myGiantPandaChinese
    @myGiantPandaChinese 4 роки тому +51

    我喜欢写汉字。I like Chinese handwriting!

    • @hobbytales6800
      @hobbytales6800 2 місяці тому

      是的!这感是中文喜欢的全部!

  • @hawthornroot
    @hawthornroot 5 років тому +12

    02:05, oooh that’s beautiful. looks so balanced. love the lines! just wow!
    dunno what it means but i find it so pretty!

    • @with_exo_eternally
      @with_exo_eternally 4 роки тому +1

      It means 'is' (I'm not sure tho😂)

    • @hawthornroot
      @hawthornroot 4 роки тому

      @@with_exo_eternally oh ty. i mean i love it. the lines. ooof. she has a beautiful penmanship. 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

    • @LestrovoCoder6646
      @LestrovoCoder6646 4 роки тому +5

      事 means matter, incidents and story and so on

    • @LestrovoCoder6646
      @LestrovoCoder6646 4 роки тому +1

      It will get different meaning which depends on the combination of the words u use

    • @neometalx9
      @neometalx9 4 роки тому +1

      Troublemaker I think it means

  • @艾米-c7k
    @艾米-c7k 7 років тому +68

    老大爷比较厉害阿...

    • @amorming1391
      @amorming1391 6 років тому +5

      你大爷永远是你大爷

    • @nanwu3650
      @nanwu3650 5 років тому +8

      因为老人用手机的比较少

  • @Intzar.7860
    @Intzar.7860 3 роки тому +9

    I just laughed when he (eye guy) said All those years went for nothing 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @feeeeeeeee2694
    @feeeeeeeee2694 4 роки тому +8

    I don't even know some words of my native language specially those words that are rarely used.

  • @焖娚人
    @焖娚人 5 років тому +2

    其实提笔忘字这不是什么的严重问题。字体的使用频率往往和你的工作生活有关系。在日常工作生活中有些字体你可能写得少,但不代表说你不会认。参加工作用电脑打字这是为提高更好的效率。所以手动写字的这个举动慢慢的减少。如果能把书法当成是一种爱好,那你对于汉字的理解就不只是在写这么简单。

  • @ykbuddy9012
    @ykbuddy9012 4 роки тому +7

    Chinese alphabet looks really difficult.... It's Awesome...
    From Mizoram

    • @Neyobe
      @Neyobe 4 роки тому

      Installer Rent LOVE INDIAAA

    • @ohayo1225
      @ohayo1225 3 роки тому +1

      Not an alphabet, it's a symbol

  • @lastmusic7031
    @lastmusic7031 4 роки тому +2

    that's not a big issue, Chinese character like pics, we can read them, we understand the meaning of those words t, we can type them into computer and cellphone...only we can not write all of them correctly...

  • @hebneh
    @hebneh 2 роки тому +6

    This is now the situation in China and Japan - writing proficiency peaks at college level and then rapidly deteriorates, because people type everything and no longer write by hand. It’s not going to change, either. This is the evolution that this difficult and cumbersome system is inevitably going to undergo.

  • @arydimitri3100
    @arydimitri3100 3 роки тому +2

    2:05 the amount of stroke for write zhào is kinda amazed me

  • @stalkerman6903
    @stalkerman6903 3 роки тому +4

    When I see a chinese character, I can regconize what it is. But i have trouble writing it. I hardly memorize the order of the strokes in a word.

    • @akielsteewart8577
      @akielsteewart8577 Рік тому +1

      那是普通的. 現代不用手寫漢字. 但想手寫的人就可以

  • @danidejaneiro8378
    @danidejaneiro8378 4 місяці тому

    Would be good if we had the English translation of the word so we knew if it was something really obscure or something everyday and mundane. Also, let us know if they got it right because it’s hard to see the difference if you’re not fluent in Chinese.

  • @lilyli163
    @lilyli163 6 років тому +9

    那个老爷爷透题

  • @仪光
    @仪光 6 років тому +5

    普通人六年级、初中生应该是一个人会写的字最多的时期了吧,初三要上九门课,高中上六门课,语文被大大压缩,到了大学就基本不用笔了,工作后大量书写的机会就更少了。国家应该提高语文占比,高中的英语学习压缩掉百分之三十五,英语考试难度降低或干脆归入选修课,在大学前了解基本词句就可以了,专业词汇上大学再学也不迟,反正英语真是坑了太多人。我高中有一个理科天才同学,跟我关系不错,他物理几乎每次都接近满分,结果高考英语考了四十多,就进了个差一本

    • @仪光
      @仪光 4 роки тому

      @@d_l3266 以为自己是个什么东西?这么爱讲英语一天到晚去讲啊,又没人逼着你说汉语,到处小粉红小粉红,nc

  • @onthelastdayofsummer
    @onthelastdayofsummer 4 роки тому +6

    what were the words meaning

  • @qingxiao2988
    @qingxiao2988 2 роки тому +1

    现在人用太多手机自动输入法看太多图像化的东西,写字记忆水平真是直线下降,这真是需要担忧的地方。

  • @qq6569078
    @qq6569078 6 років тому +6

    我都会 我用五笔的还好 五笔要知道字怎么写才会打

  • @junpingli2542
    @junpingli2542 6 років тому +9

    喜欢老爷爷

  • @louishe115
    @louishe115 5 років тому +3

    这辈子就是搜狗拼音害了我,刚学会五笔打字,结果出了搜狗拼音

  • @ayhenm.
    @ayhenm. 3 роки тому +1

    All those studies went for nothing. 😅 Right

  • @BingDwenDwen
    @BingDwenDwen 4 роки тому +2

    people using too much cellphone and computers, that don't know how to write proper chinese anymore

  • @vincentchan3813
    @vincentchan3813 6 років тому +17

    「贿赂」两字都想不起来
    「妨碍」妨写成仿
    「肇事」肇想不起来了.还经常乘地铁到肇嘉浜路呢
    日常生活中写字机会太少了

  • @jameshenry2845
    @jameshenry2845 6 років тому +2

    您知识系统最完整的时候,可能就是高中的时候

  • @vignesshwarvenkatachalam7786
    @vignesshwarvenkatachalam7786 4 роки тому +25

    Even rocket science seems easier than Mandarin.

  • @suki8027
    @suki8027 2 роки тому

    I feel like they need more cell brain to store all characters, I have learnt Chinese and Korean for 2 years, till now 6 years ago, I am sure Chinese is hard. You can know how to say in words but can not write (unspellable) and there are a lot of homonym words as at 1:20 the elder guy didn't which words refer to. The same Korean have their consonants, vowels even if you don't what it's mean but you can write by your thinking combine the vowels consonants not 100% correct but can be done.

  • @bego6279
    @bego6279 6 років тому +3

    賄賂 妨礙還可以 肇事不會寫了 😂

  • @didiprangsak1757
    @didiprangsak1757 5 років тому +1

    其实影视的人一直说他们不会写,结果大多数的都写对了😂(除了最后的词语。最后的就连我也写不出来😂)

  • @thomaschen5466
    @thomaschen5466 6 років тому +11

    0:48
    1:31
    2:12

    • @Neyobe
      @Neyobe 4 роки тому +3

      Thomas Chen Oh my gosh ur right

  • @user-bw6de5ve4f
    @user-bw6de5ve4f 6 років тому +1

    因为拼音你会读他就自动帮你写了,这些字根本平时不会用

  • @TheSunshineRequiem
    @TheSunshineRequiem 4 роки тому +1

    今天是我第一次手写贿赂和肇事一直以为是hui luo, 也不知道那个字读zhao...

  • @purushottamkumar6712
    @purushottamkumar6712 4 роки тому +45

    Chinese is totally depended on technology for even writing

    • @选项李
      @选项李 2 роки тому +3

      象形文字就好像图案 看的时候你有记忆 书写需要更明确的信息!

  • @geli978
    @geli978 Рік тому

    很正常的现象,这都不是日常生活中的常用字,就像你问英国人一些高阶词汇他们也不一定知道。就算每天都写文书,不会写这些也是很正常的

  • @ZAhraaZAhraa-km9mk
    @ZAhraaZAhraa-km9mk 4 роки тому +1

    Are Chinese words difficult for the Chinese?

    • @けい-l3h
      @けい-l3h 4 роки тому

      ZAhraa ZAhraa Actually, nope. Those words are just not used unusually by ppl.

  • @Toesuckr
    @Toesuckr 3 роки тому +2

    white ppl: that’s easy how do u forget to write?
    Chinese ppl: we have over 50,000 Chinese characters

  • @SkyActives
    @SkyActives 3 роки тому

    Why is hard ? Keyboard character are from hand writing, yes ? Just write it down

    • @1madlilgrunt
      @1madlilgrunt 3 роки тому +2

      No. Generally their keyboard is qwerty and they (can) type Pinyin - which is a Latin alphabet representation of how characters are pronounced. Like to type 你好 I have to type “ni hao”. Too many characters to have on a keyboard. It’s not an alphabet, each pretty much every character is a different word entirely

  • @vv5956
    @vv5956 4 роки тому +1

    她写了照事 🤣🤣🤣我去

  • @clintzieandromeda6216
    @clintzieandromeda6216 3 роки тому +4

    I was once writing in Chinese and it was so difficult and now I'm writing in Japanese which is better but still not fluent but I'm good.

    • @iasmina-kb8qh
      @iasmina-kb8qh Рік тому

      Japanese is not that difficult since it has hiragana and katakana

    • @jurjitsingh3728
      @jurjitsingh3728 Рік тому +2

      ​@@iasmina-kb8qhthe kanji is just the same as difficult as chinese since it is a same characters

  • @elainechan00
    @elainechan00 6 років тому +2

    穿校服正是上学阶段的学生竟然不会写啊?

  • @Minal6794
    @Minal6794 Рік тому

    What are Chinese characters?

  • @lpin9211
    @lpin9211 2 роки тому +2

    中学生会写出会lu…

  • @ksmith4712
    @ksmith4712 3 місяці тому

    Everyone knew how to write Bribery!

  • @god_noobc
    @god_noobc 2 роки тому

    I'm chinese but it's too hard to write them

  • @ivory__31
    @ivory__31 3 роки тому

    akhirnya bisa tidur nyenyak klo org chinese jg suka lupa karakter hanzi :v

  • @KharKhin
    @KharKhin 5 років тому

    拼音惹的祸,香港人用仓颉输入法不会提笔忘字的

  • @maricelanaranjo5847
    @maricelanaranjo5847 4 роки тому +2

    Me doy cuenta que el chino es muy difícil de escribir... Bueno, a seguir estudiando

  • @i_wj-e7k
    @i_wj-e7k 3 роки тому

    I can't write those word without keyboard

  • @sogt2765
    @sogt2765 6 років тому

    把老师教的都还回去了。所以说我不欠他什么。

  • @liudshui8386
    @liudshui8386 5 років тому

    我就把“妨碍”写对了,其余的全错。😅

  • @peng1790
    @peng1790 2 роки тому

    This isn't funny, I didn't know what half of the words meant...

  • @DaaJa-CN
    @DaaJa-CN 6 років тому

    非常有意义

  • @alg-uh9gt
    @alg-uh9gt 6 років тому

    全對✌有一樣的嗎

  • @刑天-k9h
    @刑天-k9h 6 років тому

    好吧!我能说句,初高中文言文我都还记得!

  • @欧阳晓峰-d7j
    @欧阳晓峰-d7j 5 років тому +1

    我发现我居然一个都不会

  • @Squier123
    @Squier123 2 роки тому

    提筆忘字

  • @民進黨下台我對民進黨
    @民進黨下台我對民進黨 6 років тому +1

    現在人都用手機弄 所以當然會忘記啊

  • @吴玉惠
    @吴玉惠 6 років тому +1

    我写的满纸都是错别字

  • @王谨博
    @王谨博 6 років тому +1

    我发现我也不会写...

  • @tulosegaslimalama3487
    @tulosegaslimalama3487 2 роки тому

    entonces cuando quieren escribir algo como cojones lo hacen????

    • @geli978
      @geli978 Рік тому

      这些都不是常用字。我现在正在参加考试需要大量书写,但我从来没遇到过写不出来的现象,然而视频里这些我还真有几个不会写

  • @camilamaiaaraujo8011
    @camilamaiaaraujo8011 3 роки тому +2

    Se eles não sabem imagine eu kkkkkkk

  • @口折
    @口折 5 років тому

    肇写不出来还是正常的吧

  • @27潘致齊
    @27潘致齊 6 років тому +1

    簡體比繁體難 繁體有4書

    • @panorama7654
      @panorama7654 3 роки тому

      寫字都是靠肌肉記憶,沒人寫字前要想這個字的造字原理

  • @XL-1485
    @XL-1485 3 роки тому

    حتى همه ما يعرفون 😂😂😂

    • @shou0610
      @shou0610 3 роки тому

      اللغة فيها اكثر من ٢٠٠٠٠ حرف تقريبا ومو كل الصينيين يعرفو الحروف كلها والبعض يعتمد على الكتابة بالحروف الإنجليزية في الجوال وتتحول بالصيني

  • @andres3622
    @andres3622 2 роки тому

    坦是我不知道如果你可以说我的各字

  • @AmelieZh
    @AmelieZh 3 роки тому +2

    omg。。。孩子们

  • @a.morjan3615
    @a.morjan3615 3 роки тому

    Confused!!! Why they can't remember thier language???

    • @Tommygunn258
      @Tommygunn258 3 роки тому +1

      Remembering it and seeing it visually is very easy compared to physically writing it by hand. If the natives have a hard time writing by hand, us foreigners have no reason to learn either. It's easier to keep it in the brain as a visual, since everything is typed nowadays anyway

  • @dullhk
    @dullhk 3 роки тому +3

    Living in China for a decade, I am often amazed by the deteriorating proficiency in Chinese characters among young people.

    • @AmelieZh
      @AmelieZh 3 роки тому +6

      It's not deteriorating. Ppl type more now. That goes for any language

    • @dullhk
      @dullhk 3 роки тому +4

      @@AmelieZh true but the prevalence of pinyin input method makes it more difficult for people to remember how characters are written

    • @ohayo1225
      @ohayo1225 3 роки тому

      Japanese is experiencing the same thing, don't say anything bad about Chinese 😊😊😊🤗🤗🤗🤭

    • @dullhk
      @dullhk 3 роки тому +1

      @@ohayo1225 it’s not news that the Japanese people are poor at reading Chinese characters. Chinese proficiency in kanji isn’t as terrible as the Japanese but the gap is closing now

    • @vincentwei9869
      @vincentwei9869 Рік тому

      ​@@dullhk but so what? If i can recognise its meaning, pronounce it flawlessly, and type it in pinyin, why does it need to be written well on a piece of paper? The reasons for learning for how to write hanzi are predominantly for leisure/cultural reasons rather than practical ones.

  • @bickz4767
    @bickz4767 5 років тому

    抱歉,我一个字都不会写了

  • @f.y.d.t8038
    @f.y.d.t8038 3 роки тому

    To many characters and the u'll forget that

  • @karlmin8471
    @karlmin8471 4 роки тому +1

    能看懂,不会写

  • @irenemin1415
    @irenemin1415 6 років тому +1

    肇事....我一直以为是造事 哈哈哈

  • @vw8264
    @vw8264 6 років тому +5

    中华汉字文化啊。。。唉!……

  • @gmichielon
    @gmichielon Рік тому

    OMG, unbelievable.

  • @gadisdesa2419
    @gadisdesa2419 5 років тому

    English please ....

  • @fullmoon0488
    @fullmoon0488 4 роки тому

    표의문자는 정말 비효율적인 것 같다..

    • @lolo-nu8cn
      @lolo-nu8cn 4 роки тому

      어!!한국사람
      안녕하세요..저는 한국어를 이 년에 공부해요

    • @ohayo1225
      @ohayo1225 3 роки тому

      당신이 더 바보 수 있습니까?

  • @serbaserbi6004
    @serbaserbi6004 4 роки тому +3

    They should combine with hiragana or katakana. Coz if u r forget the kanji u still can write with hiragana. Thats why japanese mix it. its too difficult to remember all the kanji character

    • @serbaserbi6004
      @serbaserbi6004 4 роки тому

      @Munia do u really know what is language n letter?
      Chinese n japanese share the same letter, call hanzi or kanji.
      japanese is using kanji too but they combine it with hiragana katakana. Thats the point.

    • @serbaserbi6004
      @serbaserbi6004 4 роки тому

      @Munia so maybe they should combine it with their own alphabet like hiragana to completely suits their language.

    • @serbaserbi6004
      @serbaserbi6004 4 роки тому

      @Munia yeah i know only taiwanese n jpnese still use traditional kanji

    • @小猫咪-t7l
      @小猫咪-t7l 4 роки тому +1

      @@serbaserbi6004 dude Japanese uses lots of simplified kanji characters too, except China uses more of it. It's just widespread misinformation amongst foreigners who always think that Japanese still use all traditional.

  • @omegaliu1289
    @omegaliu1289 5 років тому

    只会写“事”“碍”两个字

  • @kingprotea3964
    @kingprotea3964 4 роки тому

    我佛了,人均农民?一个识字儿的都没有?

  • @eceaksoy05867
    @eceaksoy05867 4 роки тому +1

    TÜRKLER SES VERIN🇹🇷🇹🇷❤

  • @villanelle1047
    @villanelle1047 4 роки тому +1

    قلتلكم اصعب لغة

  • @victorginger
    @victorginger 5 років тому +1

    赵四都不会写

  • @louishe115
    @louishe115 5 років тому

    主要是拼音打字害死人

  • @lasttime500
    @lasttime500 11 місяців тому

    It's probably why China has such rigorous education. It's likely due to the complexity of their scripture.

  • @anjukashico288
    @anjukashico288 4 роки тому

    Que difícil 😔

  • @jennii1779
    @jennii1779 4 роки тому +1

    日本と同じだ!

    • @panorama7654
      @panorama7654 3 роки тому

      日本語の漢字の読み方が多すぎて混乱だから、中国人より日本人にはもっと覚えにくいだろう😂

  • @fedspe3596
    @fedspe3596 3 роки тому

    会 lu xD

  • @ednafeliciano6288
    @ednafeliciano6288 4 роки тому

    2020 hihi

  • @xz1891
    @xz1891 4 роки тому

    有点肇皮

  • @gaoching9998
    @gaoching9998 4 роки тому

    If u want a lot views and a lot subscrib translate all your videos in chanel to Arabic language
    Arab people love china and love people chinese

  • @gaoching9998
    @gaoching9998 4 роки тому

    If u want a lot views and a lot subscrib translate all your videos in chanel to Arabic language

  • @melissasanches9576
    @melissasanches9576 3 роки тому

    《《《 or》》》》》》》》

  • @carlasantosc_
    @carlasantosc_ 4 роки тому

    LOL

  • @叶挺-w9w
    @叶挺-w9w 5 років тому

    你妹一个都不会