It has to be both, at least for Island Time. You need to complete the campaign on both sides, and there are quests/vendors from faction-specific NPCs. Now is a good time to level whatever faction you need with the 20 year anniversary XP and rep buffs.
meme was spot on
so do you need to complete the achieve with an ally chara AND a horde or can it all be done with 1 faction?
It has to be both, at least for Island Time. You need to complete the campaign on both sides, and there are quests/vendors from faction-specific NPCs. Now is a good time to level whatever faction you need with the 20 year anniversary XP and rep buffs.