Jamie Carragher "CANNOT FATHOM" why Trent Alexander-Arnold isn't starting for England 😳
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 лип 2024
- SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/SubscribeSkyFootball
Jamie Carragher speaks to Sky Sports ahead of England's Euro 2024 quarter-final against Switzerland, disagreeing with Gareth Southgate's persistence with Kieran Trippier instead of Trent Alexander-Arnold.
►TWITTER: / skysportsfootball
►FACEBOOK: / skysportsfootball
►WEBSITE: www.skysports.com/football
MORE FROM SKY SPORTS ON UA-cam:
►SKY SPORTS PREMIER LEAGUE: bit.ly/SubscribeSkySportsPL
►SKY SPORTS FOOTBALL: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyFootball
►SKY SPORTS BOXING: bit.ly/SSBoxingSub
►SKY SPORTS CRICKET: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyCricket
►SOCCER AM: bit.ly/SoccerAMSub
►SKY SPORTS F1: bit.ly/SubscribeSkyF1
►SKY SPORTS: bit.ly/SkySportsSub
►SKY SPORTS GOLF: bit.ly/SubscribeSkySportsGolf - Спорт
Jamie Carragher's got a point! 🤔 Trent Alexander-Arnold is such a game-changer!
That’s why he’s not in the team. Southgate wants consistency rather than game changers.
@@livyalexx Gardth wants safe and strong defensive players
Don’t forget the 2 champions league finals and premier league title race he changed in the wrong way making mistakes. With us barely being able to score one Trent mistake and we could be out.
Wym@@benyoung1224
Arnold created the most chances for england in the group stages. he played 129 minutes.
Interesting. I wasn’t aware of any chances during the group stage.
Yeah well...there is no one up top to run on to his passes
@@mm9773Your not Harry Kane than are you....he also missed them
Trippier has been in poor form all season including this tournament, he’s 33 and isn’t fully fit. Fully agree with Carragher here.
Played too many games without getting rested
Hes been awful and he cost Newcastle more goals this year than Trent has cost liverpool in his career
He's absolutely dog poop he's shot to pieces and shouldn't be playing at all
Southgate is all about moments. If Trippier can produce the service (like that chance Kane missed) then it's justified in the manager's eyes.
Trippier was good until mid season and then downhill.
Southgates philosophy isnt about creating chances its about keeping tight and nicking a goal. Depressing
Yep, and it makes every game hard work cos he will never go out out and try and put the game to bed by scoring 3 or 4. As soon as we get 1 he doesn't even try and nick another goal, he just goes into 100% defend and invite pressure, even if we were on top, it's stupid!
I really don’t think Gareth has told
Them To sit back after getting a goal
Like France yesterday
Do f all and pray for a moment of magic
Every teams been the same other then spain
@@jayt6200 Maybe but he doesn't inspire them or give them confidence to get forward and be aggressive either
He should really. His passing range is only rivaled by KDB in the PL for years now, seems silly not to utilise that. He ain't no midfielder though
Bruno aswell
@@stephenfinglas6220couldn’t lace the boots of taa and kdb
Rivaled? Hmm
Say someone reading these doesn't know about those two. It gives an impression that, if there was anyone who would even come closer to how good Trent is.... Kdb comes in mind.
Unless of course that's exactly what you meant 😂
@@tyler136 he does quite regularly KDB loses the ball more then him so if you even try make that argument your biased. Bruno is 100% in that upper bracket in passing go watch a compilation of his passing and tell me otherwise, Odegarrd is also in that bracket acting like Trent is better because he can hit a diag is ridiculous.
many youtuber analysis tactics defines Trent role in liverpool just to push no 8 and 6 higher and bring more number in midfield battle, he can breakthrough the defensive block without being marked, because the opponents has to handle the advance no 6 and no 8
All the people in the comments saying he’s not good enough defending are just lazy football takes. You don’t play 3 champions league finals, win the premier league, numerous domestic cups being bad at defending. Seeing Kyle walker and trippier get done constantly last game against an opposition with little attacking threat doesn’t make everyone say they can’t defend, but if Trent did the same thing it’s amplified and blown out of proportion.
Exactly, there’s always been strong confirmation bias there
Nobody in the comments saying that tho… killing imaginary dragons
And they lost the last champions league final because trent can't defend
@@kieran9882Arnold is shite 👍
Have you watched Trent play? As a Liverpool fan i love him but he has no clue defensively, and we have won with him by holding a midfielder back to cover for him. We gave up less goals when he got injured and Bradley took over. It does make sense to play him when playing with 5 at the back with three center backs. He doesn't fit Southgate's style of fear of losing. Liverpool play attractive soccer aimed at winning.
You don't need to be the best defender when you play three at the back and you use Walkers pace to cover the gap in behind. Crazy not to use Trent in this formation, when he offers so much going forward. You think Klopp or Guardiola would leave Trent on the bench?
It depends trent doesnt like to defend thats the problem
@@Zacksolos2007 who does he need to defend against?? they have literally 7 defenders.
@@Zacksolos2007 defend againts who? England haven't played any of the big teams yet. They should be dominating. Netherland would be their 1st big test maybe you could argue taking trent out.
trent isn't the best defensively ?? the same people who use this excuse have nothing to say about Saka at LB lmao make it make sense
Everyday it’s makes sense why Ben White fell out with this England staff . Trent should do the same , they know absolutely nothing. It’s like they are still learning to be coaches
Yes. Also scousers are not patriotic.
Good shout, no-one mentions Ben White,, he should be there
40 million quid he’s been paid - enjoy ur weekend 😊
Ben should keep his head down and play for the country not for the management
@@jamesmilligan2797 🤣🤣
I must agree. In a back 3 you have to play trent. This coach is nuts
Totally agree. He has a point. Trent has the ability to whip crosses and find avenues and team mates and switch play he does this best! he can link up with Mainoo and Jude and progess the ball further forward and get the crosses in!
Did you see that penalty...pure gold Trent. Can't wait to see him play for Liverpool this coming season.
No knock on Trippier, who has been a great servant for his country, but this is like choosing a hamburger over a fillet steak. Even in the MF role, TA was the most creative (in a team full of static players). He is one of those players that can do something really special, and Trippier really isn't.
Makes no sense, infact i would call it a FARCE. In that formation TAA is the best RWB in the country. Tripps should not even be in the squad.
as soon as he starts saying Southgate done a brilliant job, I have to switch off. can’t listen to nonsense
Southgate has done a BAD job
Were you guys alive before Southgate took charge? England barely got into the knockout stages let alone go deep into competitions. Since Southgate we have been in the QF minimum.
You can hate his tactics (me included) but you can't argue with the big results.
@@mega7070 the big results against big teams we have lost because on his negativity, we havent beaten a good side in a knockout game during his reign.
@mega7070 That is true, so Southgate deserves credit for that 100%. Let's be honest though, the bar was set incredibly low. A country of England's size and resources should have achieved more than they have. When you compare them to similar sized footballing nations in Europe ie France, Germany, Italy, Spain. England has massively underperformed over the years.
Growing up was disappointing for me watching England. Now it's been amazing to watch. Yes.... This tournament hasn't been brilliant from all the top sides let's be honest. Southgates last tournament and then we look forward to the next journey! Comon England!!
Southgate is a wally.
That's a nice way of putting it
Haha! Haven't heard word that for while but it is accurate.
Trent is the best living English player and we're treating him like a spare part.
Yes, the guy is a special player. And I think at club level he will be better going abroad, he'll flourish and grow even more on the continent. And then he will be more appreciated too at England too.
A back 5 with Arnold as the RWB is literally the perfect system and position for Arnold. Accentuates his crossing ability which is probably best in the world after KDB and limits his lack of defensive prowess with the RCB covering him.
Same bloke who said Trent wouldnt look out of place in midfield!!!!!
Him and Gary Neville have shares in TAA
He's right though. Truly nuts you have the best attacking right back in europe, you play wing backs and don't pick him!
And in this video he admits that it didn't work. Football pundits aren't gods who can get everything right
He didn’t look out of place in midfield either. The players ahead of him were the problem. They aren’t fast runners but are rather good when they’re on the ball. You don’t expect Trent to release long passes 😢to players who can’t run but are rather standing and waiting for the ball.
Put Ollie and Tony upfront with Trent in that midfield and you’ll see that difference.
TAA was made the scape goat. Gallagher was even worse when he came into midfield and TAA still had the most impact in chance creation after the first two games than anyone
Southgate is a defence coach...United dodged a bullet.
TAA won it for them by blowing the net off!
Keep praying 3 🦁 fans as Destiny has chosen England to win. Cmon Gareth. Maths Profs want u to drop Foden & use him as an impact sub as he is off it. Start with Trent & Saka down the right, please, so we can win in 90 mins 2-0 im both semi & final
He’s not starting because Southgate hasn’t got any clue how to manage such talent on the big stage.
I think it was Trippier that one game for Newcastle gave two goals away that were Karius like. It was unbelievable. But he seems to be the first man penned in by Southgate.
Put Watkins on instead of Kane and put Trent on rb. Watkins will do the run and Trent can find him. It will stretch teams and move Eng up the pitch quickly.
Carra seriously thinks GS will NOT have to resign of we lose today?
SERIOUSLY ????
@@barnbersonol they're probably mates..
@@MarkFugitive- his loyalty shud be to England.
The difference with the Foden still being in the centre is that the width should exist from the wingbacks and they should all have more space. Not sure about Saka at left back and agree with the take on Trippier over TAA. Not sure it makes sense, I feel Gareth doesn't want to upset Trippier and also signals prioritising defense over attack.
How can the team be leaked? I am not sure I believe it.
Klopp for England manager
He can't Fathom much to be fair
With 5 at the back using wing backs. You have to play Trent to play Trent RWB and Shaw LWB
These people? They've got no ounce of Managerial skills yet they sit behind screen and act as if they can win champions League with Ipswich town.. They'll say this today and change their goalpost another day.. Having decent players doesn't mean you've got a great team
To be fair, we as fans haven't won anything yet we fill every comment section with our, often ill-informed, opinions. At least these people have experience, even if they do talk nonsense at times.
@@SteveAustin-zv1nnthen everyone should SHUT THE F**K UP and let Southgate do his job
Yeah I mean why would u play one the worlds best RB em when u can play Trippier 😂
lfc rent free 🤣
When Southgate goes Ben White will be right back. It’s a no brainer with Saka on the right
Play luke shaw with a leg cast and crutches over trent - gareth southgate
Id drop the following players- Rice,Foden,Trippier, Kane. And set up like this -
Pickford
TAA. Stones. Guehi. Walker
Bellingham. Mainoo.
Saka. Palmer. Gordon
Watkins
play with this team and I think we would smash anyone if we set up like this. Don’t need 5 defenders should be an attacking formation with plenty of width. Bellingham drops to midfield and MainOo stays ahead of rice. We don’t need all 3. Kane is dead weight and Foden has been inconsistent too. It’s very simple but the manager is a fool.
It's very difficult to escape from social media, and how the negative remarks about England's performances have affected the team remains to be seen. It can either inhibit the players or galvanize them. They did look nervous in the first half v Slovakia.
Did anybody notice that while Southgate did play with 3 atb and wing backs but saka is playing at rwb and trippier at lwb 🤯
The irony of this is TAA saved the day for us last night 😂
A complete myth has developed with TAA that he played badly in midfield. Every midfielder has played badly, Bellingham may have scored but his midfield play has been far worse than Trent. In many ways Trent was our best midfielder in those first games.
You are absolutely clueless. Trent was totally lost in centre mid, he has zero idea how to play the position. Open you eyes man.
Only mainoo has looked ok in midfield this tournament
@@kevincarter2020 Rice has been fine. The biggest issue with England has been the lack of width down the left hand side.
No, I'm afraid you need to pay greater attention. Trent does know how to play in midfield, he has done it for extended periods this season. I don't believe he can play alongside Rice and Bellingham but to say he's unable to is plainly incorrect. Personally I would play Mainoo, Rice and Foden with Trent as a RB - that does not in any way result from Trent but rather the balance of the team and available players. And you say Rice has been fine in midfield? Other than a better overall team performance against Switzerland he has been no better than Trent.
@@josephdowse922 You don't understand the difference between a RB inverting into centre mid and a natural centre mid. The positions are VERY different as are the attributes required.
Kane clogs up space for potential runs . They will be ineffective in the same team
If southgate really doesn't rate trent's defending he could play 3 at the back with walker rcb and trent rwb. Like the solution is right there staring at his face.
Don’t always agree with Carra; but surely Trent is the pick. Isn’t that the whole point of the formation change? Too safe, as always.
I was wondering what I was enjoying about this tournament, even though watching England is torture. Just realised it's not having to listen to Carragher's voice for a few weeks.
Kane doesn't run mate. We saw even with Saka's balls into the box
He'll utilise Trent from the bench . Maybe 90th minute
That’s a bit early! No need to over react.
😂😂😂
Still chose Trippier over Trent
John Stones playing square balls to Guéhi was an issue too. England seem obsessed with keeping the ball so the opposition can't hurt them, rather than trying to score. They had the 3rd most possession but half the chances of other teams.
John Stones doesn't feel comfortable passing into midfield if the midfielders have a man on them. Then it becomes slow and lethargic and they lose the England fans and atmosphere.
Just like Roberto Martinez did to Jota, I don't want Southfail to use Trent to avoid injury and fatigue when the new season starts.
If luke shaw is fit, he should be thrown in, but we have to change formation. 3-5-2 or 3-4-3. Surely we can't be missing Maguire at the back?
Its okay, you've still got Jude Bellingham aka Delli Ali Mk II
I can not stand Carragher. But he's right
Trent won everything at club level at mediocre tripper will get southgate the sack what a farce
So has NEVILLE - Do you agree with all his points
Because in these games one mistake can mean your out of the competition, don’t forget the champions league 2x and prem titles we lost at Liverpool because of his mistakes. I love Trent he’s absolutely unreal but I don’t think this is the tournament for him to be playing in defence with how hard we’re finding it to score goals. He would become a weak point that would be targeted as he is for Liverpool.
Southgate FINALLY changes something but he still can't help himself can he! He still has to make a negative choice by picking Trippier over Trent! Honestly the man is a joke!!!!
Because you can only select 10 outfield players, simple as that.
Walked should go cb and Trent on the right. Walker has played there multiple times.
Rather have tripper on the right tbh he is fast snd defensive😂😂
@@Zacksolos2007 nah, walked RCB covers Trent and you get the creativeness. I don't know what universe you would pick trippier over TAA
Because Southgate hasn't a Scooby doo about what to do.
I don't think Trent starting on the bench is necessarily a bad thing... As long as Southgate brings him in at a decent time, with some impactful subs to make use of his skills. But that's wishful thinking haha
Hes definitely getting on it
How is he so certain of the team
He did alright didnt he eh la! Go on trent lad ⚽
Thing is Saka was man of the match, scored the equaliser, playing in the position where Trent would play - so where would he go?
Only option I can imagine would be switching Saka to the left, but for me Saka is one of the only players performing rn so why change him?!
Trent isn't a right winger mate.
@@Talis7212 in the system we played against Swiss, was three CB with wing backs. The right wing back was Saka. Where else do you think they’re suggesting Trent would play? Tbf he ain’t a midfielder either and they play him there
** deep sigh ** Maybe you need to put England first and your club second. Trent doesn't work in midfield and Walker's a quicker full back.
He doesn't play because he had a terrible first game, and is prone to defensive errors which is Southgate's worst fear.
Trent is a wild card, the very thing Southgate hates. He's more a last gasp throw everything at it player for Southgate when England are losing near the end.
Agree with Jamie 100%
As we all know their is only one football league in the world i mean all the top and only players in the EPL. no other country has a football league with football players in it. thats why the Engish always wins tournaments SINCE 1866 OR 1766
So why not play Trent as a 7?
Trent has won more than Trippier could only dream of
They have the same amount of League Championship Winners Medals
if you don`t appreciate what tripps has offered England team for the past ten years then it is not Southgate problem , tripps has been an essential part of the team success in the past three big tournaments , a man with leadership qualities and experience , dead ball specialist and great vision of the field , he is not just a good player , he is a fantastic team player , one more thing tripps didn`t have a bad season , just a few bad moments and an injury mid season , other than that he was a key factor of Newcastle success and made over 20 assists the past two seasons , he EARNED his place as a starter in England , as for Trent even when walker and Kieran retires he won`t be a starter if he doesn`t develop field qualities other than crosses and free kicks .
Southgate has reached his plateau. When he first started he was great with the players. Much more comfortable and confident than before he was at the helm but now it’s clear this should be his final tournament. But I cannot blame him for everything. But you have, you have got to be brave when it comes to tournament football. We all know being progressive and brave is not in his D.N.A.
Everyone can see that Walker , Trippier and Kane are stinking the place out with extremely average performances. Trent / Palmer / Watkins / Toney are fresh , ready and playing well. Southgate will wait ( once again ) until we go 0-1 down before being “ adventurous”. It’s pathetic…..😢
Yea why is he playing Trippier over Trent? Trippier has never played for a top team only for Newcastle and Atletico, not sure if he has ever won champions league and the premier league. Mediocre manager picks mediocre players.
It's not who. starts but who finishes
We are not confident 😢
Can Carra not afford wallpaper or even paint on the walls of his house??
In the same sentence: Trent will naturally push up higher... tough for Saka because you've got to get back and defend. I hope he gets his wish and once and for all we can see all this world class ability he supposedly has or just how limited Trent is as a footballer like I suspect. Needing time and lots of space to play a good long ball or a cross with horrendous defensive awareness, a lack of dynamic energy to press and an inability on the ball to escape the press really doesn't sound world class. Let's see, play him Gareth!
Ben white would have come right it
Walker is Messi/Ronaldo of right backs. As long as he's fit enough and ready to go, i don't see why he should warm a bench. Trent is good, he's just unfortunate it's Kyle era. His time will come he's still young😂😂
If Saka will be leftback and Trippier as rightback with Konza coming in then who are going to play as the wingers?
@@tomodul2619 they’re talking wing backs with a back 3 so no wingers
I would rsther gomez over trippier.
4231, 343, no matter still backwards, sideways and then back to Pickford who hoofs it back to the opposition. Southgate’s masterclass tactics to win the Euros.
Southgate and his favorites changing system with the same players no pace no attacking style just boring hope to nick a goal cannot wait
I’ve been saying for so many times. Englands personnel fits a 3-5-2. The problem is they a middling to mediocre coach. When will the English look for a coach OUTSIDE OF ENGLAND?
Maybe not starting. I'd bring him on after 25 mins
Absolutely bonkers
Let’s have a fair Match no yellow cards please lads 🏴 after the Match if we don’t get any yellow cards all yellow cards will be wiped off
Southgate doesn't trust him defensively
Trent cant defend he cant play as a holding midfielder. He wants to be a 10 but bellingham and foden are better. I think he should jus come on do a job for england. When he is back at lfc he can make demands on where he wants to play. But i still say he cant defend.
Southgate is a muppet. I understand we have won games but his decision and tactics have been tragic.
Question… IF and I know it’s a big if… we win the Euros will Southgate be the worst ever manager to win a major trophy?
It’s a back 5
Maguire is underrated !!!
Switzerland 3 - 0 England
Media are the most hypocritical bunch of people around - them answering q's about punditry is hilarious
Saka is good but can’t cross a ball. Surely as a wing back you would want someone who can cross the ball
Escape goat will be the centre back if England lose
So Southgate doesn't pick a left footed CB
His thinking is that of a manager who doesn't know what he's doing
Gareth is playing 6-3-0.
Every one pushing their own player agenda😂😂😂😂😂😂. Rio is walking. The spitter cannot fathom Trent not starting
He can’t defend…… going forward he’s unreal but positionally he’s shocking. All the positives about him are for attacking but when your not in the top 6 or 7 defensively I wouldn’t pick him