The Battle of Hürtgen Forest (DE - EN Subtitles)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 9 лют 2020
  • We tour the most important sites in the Rur Eifel region in Germany, focusing on the 75th commemorations of the Battle of Hürtgen Forest.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 7

  • @crafter170
    @crafter170 3 роки тому +3

    Very decent of the German people to remember both their own and the American losses too.Very decent.

  • @thedetectorist
    @thedetectorist 3 роки тому +4

    The music played on the background is very misplaced. The battle of the Hürtgenwald was not a very happy event was it? Then why play this happy music?

    • @bigtrucklittlerv7969
      @bigtrucklittlerv7969 2 роки тому

      Modern Germany is all about Americanized entertainment. They have moved on from the war.

  • @luiscalcano4359
    @luiscalcano4359 2 роки тому

    I wouldn't want to be camping out in those big deep green hills, and putting up with the elements, NO WAY, orders are orders!

  • @christianwouters6764
    @christianwouters6764 2 роки тому +2

    The military cemetery in Vossenack is in a terrible state of neglect. I wonder if this is a deliberate act of the current German authorities, a perverse way of criminalising their own fallen soldiers.

  • @andreas2489
    @andreas2489 3 роки тому +3

    Danke für diesen informativen Beitrag zu diesen fragwürdigen historischen Ereignissen. Aber die Hintergrundmusik ist so was von voll daneben, einfach nur peinlich.

  • @luiscalcano4359
    @luiscalcano4359 2 роки тому

    Just like with Pacific Island of Pelelieu , which was to cover General McArthurs (I think) right flank , as he invaded the Phillipines , The Hurtgen Forrest should of been by passed ! These two objectives weren't of any importance except it's cost in lives Axis , Allied.
    The Hurtgen could of been skipped ,but the USA forces wanted to be macho , and paid for it in nearly 28- 34,000 losses , as did The Nazis too. Nothing was signicantly gained by trying to flush out the Wehrmacht that was very adroitly hunkered in well emplaced defensive positions , and the Same went for Pelelieu . Both operations began in early 9/1944 , with the Hurtgen going on a few mos. more. Casualties were heavy for the USA in both operations , on both sides of the world.
    The Hurtgen campaign was not meticulously looked @ , and studied. Not one higher up came to Evan take a sneak peek at the situation on Hurtgen , nor on Pelelieu. But our industrial might , and gutsy troops prevailed.
    In Hurtgen the Americans had @ least 7 well trained IDs fed piecemeal , and were mauled. It was a near blunder. And, there were others around that time. General Field Marshall Bernard Montgomery's Operation Market Garden ( my grandpa was in that w/ the 82nd Airborne Division), the Walcheren Islands around the Dutch/ Belgian Coasts , The Battle For Aachen 9/1944, General Patton getting a bloody nose @ The Battle For Metz around mid- 9/1944, General Patch's 7th Army struggling in The Vosges Mtn's, , and the Pelelieu , Phillipines, and Saipan campaigns , which were bloody.
    The Allies would prevail due to its manpower and industrial might!