Does this look infected? Vishgraz vs Sidar Jabari vs Vhal vs Halana and Alena EDH / CMDR game

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 69

  • @DarkEinherjar
    @DarkEinherjar Рік тому +48

    For those confused, Reflections of Littjara doesn't actually create tokens, which is what Primal Vigor's replacement effect looks for. It copies a spell, and copies of permanent spells become tokens, but this doesn't count as creating tokens.

  • @justinmorsch3208
    @justinmorsch3208 Рік тому +11

    Sidar Jabari is a really well designed commander. His eminence ability doesn’t feel busted but synergizes well with his combat damage ability when you get him into the field. That ability actually encourages players to cast him and not leave him in the command zone, unlike EM

  • @BobbyBev95
    @BobbyBev95 Рік тому +3

    I would have never thought of that background pairing for Vhal. Super interesting

  • @brendylove4285
    @brendylove4285 Рік тому +12

    That val build is so fun and interesting to play. Saw it on this channel a few months back and had to try it out myself

  • @Thadeusz_
    @Thadeusz_ Рік тому +4

    @MTGMuddstah, do you know when the Vishgraz deck will be released? I am really curious about the decklist 🤩😬

    • @DuneEcho
      @DuneEcho Рік тому

      I'm still waiting myself.

  • @Princederbat
    @Princederbat Рік тому +13

    Rockfall Veil would've come in tapped. Sorry just thought it was funny. Glad the hand sort of worked out for you though haha

    • @KBergs
      @KBergs Рік тому +1

      Yeah that messed with me too. I assume he thought he grabbed his copperline.

    • @orogustus
      @orogustus Рік тому +1

      I assume he does this just to get comments 😂

    • @MTGMuddstah
      @MTGMuddstah  Рік тому +1

      Correct. I should, in theory, have gotten another land. For some reason I thought Vale came in untapped at that time.

  • @Gostodon
    @Gostodon Рік тому +4

    Always approve of a Sum 41 reference 👏

    • @rodolfog.8087
      @rodolfog.8087 Рік тому

      Came here to say this. Cheers to you, mate 👍

  • @Nr4747
    @Nr4747 Рік тому +14

    You couldn't have cast Woodelves at 2:37 because you didn't have a green mana source as Rockfall Vale would have entered tapped (you didn't control 2 other lands).

    • @MTGMuddstah
      @MTGMuddstah  Рік тому +7

      Correct. I should, in theory, have gotten another land. For some reason I thought Vale came in untapped at that time.

    • @TheObstalace
      @TheObstalace Рік тому +1

      @@MTGMuddstah i dont think its an issue here since i trust in your deck having literally any untapped dual land. its funny to me that u picked exactly that one when searching tho!

  • @Wyrm7774
    @Wyrm7774 Рік тому +2

    The swords to plowshares on sidar was a weird call considering he discarded worthy knight. Which isn't exactly threatening

    • @jorochimaru
      @jorochimaru Рік тому

      Yup, completely wasted that spell considering what else was on the board. He didn't properly threat assess

  • @latinojackson9694
    @latinojackson9694 Рік тому +3

    Why ever hold back the mites, they can't block anyway...

  • @TelepathicWhale
    @TelepathicWhale Рік тому +4

    Don't counters that are placed onto the Ozolith get doubled from the Primal Vigor, and then the counters get doubled again when the Ozolith puts them onto a creature?

    • @DarkEinherjar
      @DarkEinherjar Рік тому +5

      No. Primal Vigor only doubles counters placed on creatures.

  • @Amnistypakistan
    @Amnistypakistan Рік тому +1

    Reference in your video title is appreciated :)

  • @Zaalbarjedi
    @Zaalbarjedi Рік тому +1

    2:36
    Rockfall Vale should've entered tapped here.

    • @MTGMuddstah
      @MTGMuddstah  Рік тому

      Correct. I should, in theory, have gotten another land. For some reason I thought Vale came in untapped at that time.

  • @ardras4649
    @ardras4649 Рік тому +1

    2:34 : Normally, Rockfall vale should have etb tapped, am I right? I don't think it's a big deal, though, since you could have fetched a rootbound crag or a forest instead

    • @MTGMuddstah
      @MTGMuddstah  Рік тому +1

      Correct. I should, in theory, have gotten another land. For some reason I thought Vale came in untapped at that time.

  • @MrKubilaykaya
    @MrKubilaykaya Рік тому

    At 8:20 Arca attacks with 6 mite tokens with toxic 1 so that means he should get 6 poison counters and not 5.

    • @slamuraijack
      @slamuraijack 11 місяців тому

      One of the mites was blocked, only 5 did combat damage to the player.

  • @septred3
    @septred3 Рік тому +1

    How about the green outlast creatures from Khans of Tarkir?

  • @lokumo13
    @lokumo13 Рік тому

    Great timing. I was about to take apart my Myrkul deck because wasn't really enjoying what it did. Either locked the game out too early until it found its combo, or it was just too slow, so was looking for a different Abzan deck and I was thinking bout Vishgraz for a while and yeah I think this give some the green light for the conversion.

    • @DarkEinherjar
      @DarkEinherjar Рік тому

      I want the hobbit precon (which is also Abzan) to tinker with.

  • @BelieMyBurial
    @BelieMyBurial Рік тому

    enjoying the new Commanders in these past couple of videos
    was starting to feel like i was seeing certain Commanders a lil often

  • @gypsieking3280
    @gypsieking3280 Рік тому

    Great game. I agree everyone had chances to get their decks going.

  • @georgemarquez4308
    @georgemarquez4308 Рік тому

    Out of all my commanders sidar has been my favorite !!

  • @DarkEinherjar
    @DarkEinherjar Рік тому

    Huh... I just realized it: did Kevin use Vhal's mana to cast Planar Bridge, or was it a narration error?

  • @Cormix34
    @Cormix34 Рік тому

    Will the Vishgraz deck list be posted ?

  • @Thadeusz_
    @Thadeusz_ Рік тому +1

    No vishgraz Decklist? 😢

    • @jaisonk22
      @jaisonk22 11 місяців тому

      I'm so sad too

  • @derAlphabet
    @derAlphabet Рік тому

    that got complicated rly fast o.o

  • @Punisher1818
    @Punisher1818 Рік тому

    Guys im slow and reread all the cards in his hand. Why did he reveal to the table?

    • @DuneEcho
      @DuneEcho Рік тому

      Probably to show just how risky it was.

  • @ArcFallen1
    @ArcFallen1 Рік тому

    I didn´t get it. What happened?
    After showing the started hands, what did you mean by " Yes! I know"? And why showing your oppening hand? I am so confused!
    Can someone please explain??

    • @franno70
      @franno70 Рік тому

      I might need an explanation too

    • @kickinwang1817
      @kickinwang1817 Рік тому +1

      He kept a one lander leaning hard on Sol Ring and gamble to not just immediately lock himself out of playing the game. He constantly gets comments like "don't keep one landers!" So he knew he was going to catch flak in the comment section for it. Why he showed his opponents I'm not sure, but I imagine it's because they're very casual and it's not that serious so Andrew didn't really care.

    • @DarkEinherjar
      @DarkEinherjar Рік тому +1

      His hand was Sol Ring, Mountain, Gamble and four green cards, a very greedy opener that require him to either topdeck a land that tapped for green mana or Gamble for one and hope not to discard it. It paid off in the end (despite him not getting a land that entered untapped, but everyone on the table missed that), but if he had discarded that land, he would've been screwed.

  • @deathpenguinjoe3644
    @deathpenguinjoe3644 Рік тому

    Why couldn't Halana block? She has reach

    • @DarkEinherjar
      @DarkEinherjar Рік тому

      Andrew didn't mention it, but Kevin activated Rogue's Passage to make Vhal unblockable.

  • @dess8815
    @dess8815 Рік тому

    So did the vale player cast the bridge for six with lands and mana rocks and used her mana to activate it or did they use vales mana to both cast the bridge and activate it

    • @DarkEinherjar
      @DarkEinherjar Рік тому

      I think it was a narration error, because Kevin tapped his four lands and Sol Ring, which he only needed to do because Vhal's mana couldn't be spent to cast the Bridge.

    • @dess8815
      @dess8815 Рік тому

      @@DarkEinherjar ok thanks for clarifying

  • @astonrichardson5288
    @astonrichardson5288 Рік тому

    It’s more the fact that eminence is a thing again which is why some players are annoyed

  • @jorochimaru
    @jorochimaru Рік тому

    Gotta be honest, kevin played like crap this match. Completely removed and countered the wrong things this game. Threat assessment was way off from him.

  • @sambuss7764
    @sambuss7764 Рік тому +8

    Sick game, but was it really necessary to put pronouns?

    • @MTGMuddstah
      @MTGMuddstah  Рік тому +15

      Yes

    • @sambuss7764
      @sambuss7764 Рік тому +2

      @@MTGMuddstah I'm not meaning to be disrespectful but it's a game of magic and it seems unnecessary

    • @MTGMuddstah
      @MTGMuddstah  Рік тому +13

      @@sambuss7764 it’s important to me.

    • @sunflowertheog
      @sunflowertheog Рік тому +3

      @@sambuss7764 it's a good thing he didn't check with you whether or not it was necessary then eh

    • @Wyrm7774
      @Wyrm7774 Рік тому +3

      Why would it not be necessary to refer to people in a way that makes them comfortable?