The Massacre of Karbala: A Historical Analysis - Dr. Yasir Qadhi | 10th November 2013
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лис 2013
- The Massacre of Karbala: A Historical Analysis" from the Sunni tradition.
"Is it appropriate for you to kill the likes of me? I am the son of the daughter of your Prophet. There is no other grandson of a prophet who remains on the face of the earth aside from me."
Journey back in history to revisit one of the most controversial and misconstrued events in Islamic history: The Massacre of Karbala.
Are Sunnis 'on the side of Yazid' or 'on the side of Husayn'? Who is to blame for the death of Husayn? Should we curse Yazid?
Join Dr. Yasir Qadhi as he analyzes and contextualizes the events that led up to the martyrdom of al-Husayn (radiAllahu `anhu), its occurrence and aftermath.
Shias and Sunnis both believe Hussain ibn Ali opposed tyranny and stood for principles of justice. Let us unite here.
Unite with the hypocrite and betrayer shias? were you not following the sheikh's lecture?
Unite on quran and sunnah
hz Fan Qurah is the sunnah. Let’s unite on Quran and Ahle Bayt
How Can You defend imam hussain on the one side and Love his enemies on the other Side ? Could you explain me that 🤔
Sand Buzz take a stand against the government today and check what happens.
Put your self in the same situation as the people of koofa
The leaders who invited hazrat hussain were killed in streets of koofa and you still think that the leaderless people would’ve fought the army of yazeed
"Those who are silent when others are oppressed are guilty of oppression themselves."
- Hussain Ibn Ali.
So u r trying to say hasan ra was guilty of oppression himself?
@General Guile Muslims working with Zionist Jews to oppress Europeans?! That is the craziest thing I have ever heard in my entire life!
@General Guile - As a European you want to discuss colonization??? Are you ok? Any recent trips or falls?
General Guile im still waiting for hamza to discuss whay he doesnt have a clue about.any recent studies?hamza?
@@muhammadshakil3723 imam Hassan signed the truce pact with The dogs of hell because he wanted to preserve the blood of muslims
I'm shia and thank you for this lecture. I respect all my Sunni brothers and sisters. We are one and should stay together.
are you ithna ashari or jayedi? or any other sect?
Bro we r only muslims there is no sunni or Shia .
Allah SWT made us and called us muslims. So plzz bro call yourself muslim and not sunni Shia
@@zeyanshahidkhan8841 no we will NEVER align ourselves with people who call the companions of sayidina Muhammad ﷺ MUNAFIQS AND FORNICATORS
@@zeyanshahidkhan8841 how do you suggest we differentiate ourselves from different sects?
Being a sunni I don't agree his false history, how can you? Ask him did our Prophet had not prophesied the matridom of Imam Hussain? Why he is skipping the narrations.
"Death with honor is better than a life of degradation"
Hussain Ibn Ali
Evidence?
@@ekaunteik4573 Majlisi, Bihārul Anwār, vol.44 p. 192
Source: quotepark.com/quotes/1861223-husayn-ibn-ali-death-with-honor-is-better-than-a-life-of-degradat/
it's a Shia book though.
whatever comes in your mind and looks beautiful to you, just attribute that to Hussain RA.....this way you will become Kazzab soon.
@@justneedlife2001 there is a book which claims Prophet Mohammad SAWS was not a prophet. should we accept it? It is in the book I can give the reference. It is hindu book though...
When will Muslim learn that every thing comes from anyside doesn't become fact. Especially when something requires revelation. History is a great game of play. It is a narration. How you nattare today, is taken as historic tomorrow. Very soon you will hear some idiots narrating that rana pratap killed Akbar in the battle of haldi ghati and then himself died of mosqite bit perhaps.
@@ae00505 ok calm down I wasn't saying if it's true or not.
I am a Christian from the US and I would without any hesitation defend and fight on the side of Hussain. It was a battle against injustice, evil and not politics. I have read Mandela's books and I remember him mentioning Hussain multiple times and I had no idea who he was. I started researching about him and I was truly moved by his story. It is astonishing to see a "Muslim scholar" praise this evil man Yazid who have committed some of the most atrocious and heinous crimes. I guess not that many people understand what courage is and what it means to stand against an oppressor even when all odds are against you.
He is not praising him at all.
Several months ago, in his lectures on the companions of the Prophet - he discussed the rule of Yazid in detail and what an evil man he was i.e he was a drunkard, and his responsibility for the massacre of 100s if not 1000s of Muslims of Madinah in the Al-Harrah massacre.
He has nothing good to say about Yazid at all.
Christians and justice are contradictory terms. You cannot use Christianity and justice in the same sentence. I love Jesus but he's not a Christian.
yeah common sense. injustice
@@redsox7897 yes, the term was used by the roman, the enemy
God bless you brother. You have a good soul. I pray you go to heaven.
Husain RA was indeed a brave man & his story beings tears
May Allah be pleased with him❤️
Agreed....Hasan RA had stopped the resistance against the khalifa of the time.....
@@Rafay7969Ameen
Shk. Yasir Qadhi is like your favorite old uncle whose stories/accounts you look forward to listening to on Eid or other family get-together. Very informative! Thank you Shk
I can listen to him for hours
ua-cam.com/video/HqUyhLiY774/v-deo.html
@@hadi83ful ua-cam.com/video/HqUyhLiY774/v-deo.html
Shame on those calling yazid as innocent.
I got goosebumps when he described the part where no one was willing to raise the sword against Hussain RA out of fear that he is the grandson of Prophet SAW.
It is the most heartbreaking part of islamic history alongside the shahadat of Usman RA.
agreed
Bloody misguided
@@zahrahusain5965 yeah bloody misguided betrayers
Faraaz Khan they were all cowards, worriers of shaytan that’s why they feared Imam Hussain even in his most weakest state. Narrators say that when they killed his brother Al-Abbas, the flag barrier and most fierce worrier in his army, he came running towards him like a hawk, they started fleeing like sheep. He said who are you running from now that you killed my father’s son” Allahu Akbar 💔💔
@@khadijaabdulmajid1462 Caliph Uthman was killed by the rebels,and Uthman had became very unpopular. One of the rebel was Muhammad bin Abu Bakr(son of Abu Bakr and stepson of Ali).
Hussein was killed for not giving allegience to Caliph Yazid. Yazid was afraid if Hussein did not gave the bai'ah,Yazid's position would not be safe.
And Hussein doesn't want to make a treaty with Yazid like his brother did with Muawiyah. Anyway,Yazid cannot be trusted.
Muawiya and Yazid,and the most of the Ummayads and the Abbasids were power crazy. And many Muslim leaders are power crazy until today!
May Allah preserve our scholars for teaching us in so much detail and make it as easy as possible for us to understand. Ameen
ua-cam.com/video/HqUyhLiY774/v-deo.html
May Allah preserve The Sermon of Seyyedah Zainab (as) ..
Nothing even the stories of the Sahabas has made me cry more than this. Wallahi I have never felt such sorrow and sadness. As a Sunni Muslim I see now why the Shia commemorate the death of IMAM Husayn (RA) I see now why people cry during the 10th of Muharram. My message to all my Muslim brothers and sisters never let politics or hypocritical scholars from both sides of the spectrum to separate the UMMAH we are all Muslims. We all cry for Husayn (RA) as well may Allah bless the prophet (PBUH) and his family.
Well said 👏
Who betrayed Hussen? It was the Shia themselves who betrayed him by promising false support to him. Then they start shedding crocodile tears for his death.
May Allah darken their faces for using the name of Hussen to divide Muslims and sow discord among their ranks.
According to Hadiyth,
a period of mourning should not exceed 3 days. There
should not be beatings,
lamentations, self harm or humiliation, etc. in it,
but dignified according to
the SUNNAH of the
PROPHET (SAW).
ALL MUSLIMS love
AL HUSSAYN (AS),
but it is HYPOCHRITICAL of
SHIAS to make the
ANNUAL COMMEMORATION of his
DEATH the highest edifice of their religious calendar .
Ignoring the fact that Greater men and women
than AL HUSSAYN have been killed , murdered,
poisoned or assassinated
before him yet no DAY is set aside
In memory of their deaths
for example:-
1.PROPHET MUHAMMAD
(SAW)
2. HAMZA IBN ABIY
MUTWALIB (AS)
3. JÀFAR IBN ABIY
TWÀLIYB (AS)
4. FÀTIMAH BINT
MUHAMMAD (SAW)
5. ALIY IBN ABIY TWÀLIB
(AS)
6. AL HASSAN IBN ALIY
(AS)
This shows the
height of HYPOCRISY that
the SHIAS address to.
What is more relevant
and appropriate Is for the
DAY OF MATYRDOM OF
AL HUSSAYN (AS), to
be regarded as not a DAY OF MOURNING, but a
DAY OF CELEBRATION.
For to die as a MATYR in the SERVICE of ALLWAAH (AS),
Is the HIGHEST PINNACLE
of HONOUR that a
MUWMIYN may achieve.
This day should be celebrated as a 3rd IYD
in the SHIA CALENDER,
with OFFICILA BUSSINESS,
COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES
SCHOOLS closed.
CHILDREN and the POOR
given treats. FRIENDSand
NEIGHBOURS exchanging
GIFTS. With PARADES ,
DRAMATIC reenactment
of the EVENT, Fanfare
and and an atmosphere of
FUN and FIESTA for ALL.
Unfortunately the
SHIAS are acting in DISREGARD of the SUNNAH
and have made this a DAY
of DISGRACE, MOCKERY,
HUMILIATION, IMMOLATION and SELF
TORTURE to themselves Children , and even INNOCENT BABIES,
to the mockery and
snide remarks of the
NON MUSLIM viewers.
We can only conclude that contunuation of this
Morbid Charade only serves
the purpose of scoring
points against Decent
innocent Muslims on whom the SHIA try to set the
Blame of the killing of
AL HUSSAYN over a thousand of years ago, while it is a historical fact which they well know that the killers are non
others than the
SHIA KHAWAARIJS who
enticed AL HUSSAYN, and
set him up for sacrifice.
@@abdillahijalalkhan2128
The beloved uncle of the Prophet hamza was martyred and the Prophet did not commemorate his death.
His beloved wife Khadija died and he did not commemorate her death.
His beloved cousin Jaafar, brother to Ali was martyred and he did not commemorate his death.
Also; the Prophet did not commemorate the deaths of his own parents.
The issue of commemorating the dead is simply not part of Islam.
The dead only require our
Prayers and Charity.
@@saidhashi2856
That is the plain truth.
No ASSASSIN CREED
GAME THERE!
May Almighty Allah bless you for your efforts on explaining this sensitive topic in a wise manner, Ameen.
I myself find myself in the crossfire from both my own Sunni community and some 12'er friends that I know from a long time. But your explanation without any extreme emotion has made the most sense with clarity. Thank you brother, may Allah bless you, Ameen.
"Hussain is from me and I am from Hussain. Allah loves those who love Hussain"
- Jami At-Tirmidhi
English reference : Vol. 1, Book 46, Hadith 3775
Arabic reference : Book 49, Hadith 4144
May Allah guide you, Yasir Qadhi
Salam alaika ya Hussain ibne Haider
May Allah guide you, Yasir Qadhi ..... are you mad???
Mad is who is against imam hussain Alaysalam
So have you heard in this whole lecture any hate toward Hussain? He almost cried when he talked about the event.
@@emulicus The lecture was good on history from a one-sided perspective while leaving many topics untouched and almost relieving yazid ibn muawiyya from what he did. First, his appointment was unjust, and in another lecture dr. sb has pointed out the fitna that split ummah after Uthman R.A murder which was instigated by muawiyya bin abi sufyan. read both sides and you'll find more
@@emulicus they are blind believers. We love Hussain R.A due to his character, belief and strong practice
The way that sh.yasir qadhi narrates the story is just mind blowing.
May Allah bless you and your family for all your efforts
Ma Sha Allah! I learnt a lot from this lecture, great insight- Jazakalla khair
Yazeed was in every way responsible for imam Hussain's death by sending hit man ibn zyad to handle the matter. So hadith or not ... he was guilty of unthinkable atrocity.
And what about the population of Kufa (the so called Shia tu Ali) who deserted Ibn Aqeel and Hussain?
@@azhar5034 They are responsible too. They claimed to be Shiaan-e-Ali but in fact they were the betrayers.
@@sobiarashid9880 More than Yazid, the people of Kufa (who called themselves as Shiatu Hussain) are responsible for the death of Hussain.
More than being angry at Yazid, you Shias mourn for Hussain’s death because of the treachery and betrayal your forefathers of Kufa did to Hussain
@@azhar5034 For your kind information I am neither a shia nor a Kufi. 🙂
@@azhar5034 i am not shia either. But i don't agree with some people and ulma who try to minimize the involvement of yazid by pointing fingers else where. Kufi are sure responsible for this tragedy. But yazid could have handle it differently. He could have given strict order not to harm imam hussain. Or he could have order that bring hussain to me. But he didn't do that. When you send a killer to do the job ,you dont have to tell him to kill. He could have said to ibn ziyad, " bring me good dates from kufa" and everyone knew what that mean. So sunni should not display hadith to prove he is jannati. Either hadees is wrong or we didn't interpret it better.
I am not shia or sunni but I like to be pious MUSLIM, Quran is my guide for this life Our Nabi (pbuh) is my role model to be good muslim. I pray for all muslim Ummah to unite undet banner of SHAHADA. don't give your self different name when Allah given us one.
Salam....how i wish they were united, but the disagreement, hatred, started when the brash, coward and once upon a time killer of his own daughter refuse to oblige The prophet Of Islam's request of pen and paper. To make matters worse, the earliest scholars of Islamic History, somehow, for reward of money and title or even fame, deviated in their recording of events, Fabrication of hadith was widespread, even the first three caliph played anothet major part in disuniting the Muslim Ummah, the first already been said and the second was their secret congregation at Saqifah when they put forth their plan in electing abu bkr without any shame or dignity leaving the man who were foremost among them in fear of God, the first who answered to the Prophet call in helping him in conveying his messages, the lion of God, Imam Ali bin Abi Talib....
@Ike Dakhlallah says who.....
@Ike Dakhlallah majority means nothing to Allah. Didnt u read the Quran and see for yourself verses that said ... but only a few who were thankful, ...but only a few who.believe' so on and so forth. If you think majority means the truth, then the christian were thr truthful one bcoz there are more christian than Muslim.
@Ike Dakhlallah now it does... you mean to to tell me that now numbers means something to Allah or the bigger the numbers the more truthful they will be. U also means to say that when prophet Musa a.s told the Seal of all The Prophet that he should go and see Allah again and again to make a request to Allah to somehow decrease the prayers rakaat because he (Musa a.s) knows Prophet Muhammad's ummah better than prophet Muhammad Saw himself. Can you dig it? The narration you narrate i believe is from the sunni source. Then you must also believe with regards to the 12 imams cause your eminent scholar bukhari recorded it so does muslim. But the majority issues stills stands as it is... oh btw, happy Ramadan .
@Ike Dakhlallah as a muslim who tried to highlight something that you may know and i may not, i respect that. I hope there will be mutual respect among all of us in presenting their views in the social media, because we are what we write..
Wallaahi whenever I hear the story of karbala,I sometimes shed a tear.How could these criminals be so cruel to the grandson of whom they claimed to be their most beloved,Muhammad sal allaahu aalayhi wa salaam.Yazeed and his gang were criminals.
Yep, that's the problem when people, who can only ever have a subjective understanding of God, try to pretend that they are the God's enforcers on Earth. Only God has the objective view of his truth, and he alone will judge. If I'm not mistaken, I think there was another prophet who brought this issue to light. How do you think God will judge such people, and do you think that you should act in a similar manner as those who did such things?
.....That' s an understatement... He' was a hooligan but at the same time a coward. Just to mention his nsme along Imam Hussein a.s me akes me want to throw up. Along with his father, grsndfather, and together with their croonies, they'll will surely burn in hell..... if only i could lit the Hell Fire, if only
@Sarah Rose Masha Allah may Allah reward you my sister
@Sarah Rose, Unity of umah can not stand on falsehood, falsehood started with innovations in religion. When we clean up our religion from all innovations in religion, unity will come naturally.
@@safetsalihovic5372 distancing will only increase such innovations. If we can give dawah to non Muslims then why is it so hard to get together with "innovators" Muslim brothers and sisters under the flag of Islam. Uniting as a family and knowledge share will remove many misconceptions and innovations from multiple sects of Islam. But I don't think politicians want that
As far as historians claim yazeed was a strict ruler and without his approval/authorization the commander wouldn’t have dared to kill hazrat hussain
Learned so much from this lecture. Thank you sheikh, may Allah bless you and your family.
There were cowards in kufa who did not defend the grandson of the prophet against a tyrant. But, there were those who stood with huessin, and died as shaheed. These are the true shia. It's not about the quantity of your followers, but the quality. We must learn from those who stood against oppression in the name of Allah swt. And to never give allegiance to tyrants
When Imam Husayn left Madina for Makkah he wrote a testament for his brother Muhammad bin Hanafiya. It has been narrated by Ibn Tawus. In this testament the Imam mentioned the motive for his rising and clarified the policy which he intended to pursue in all circumstances. He also referred to the false motives which instigate a man and make him fight to satisfy his carnal desires and stated that the godly persons are free from such motives. The testament reads as follows:
In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful.
"This is the testament of Husayn bin Ali bin Abi Talib written by him for his brother Muhammad, known as Ibn Hanafiya. Indeed Husayn testifies that there is no god except Allah and no being other than Him is fit to be worshipped and He has no partner. He also testifies that Muhammad is Allah's servant and messenger, who has brought truth from Him, and that Paradise and Hell do exist and the Day of Judgment is bound to come and there is no doubt about it, and on that day, Allah will bring the dead to life".
What the Imam said consists of the very doctrines which it is necessary for every Muslim to hold, and one who does not hold them cannot be a Muslim. Apparently the Imam meant to say that these very principles were in danger and, if the matters were allowed to continue in that manner, it was possible that the regime of the time might not refrain even from attacking these Principles of Faith. In fact the real motive for the Imam's rising was the protection of these very principles on which other religious and social tenets of Islam are based.
The Imam continued: "This movement of mine is not on account of stubbornness, rebellion, worldly passions or instigation by Satan. It is also not my object to create trouble or to oppress anyone. The only thing which invites me to this great movement is that I should reform the affairs of the followers of my grandfather, eradicate corruption, undertake enjoining to do good and restraining from evil and follow the tradition of my grandfather, the Prophet of Allah and my father, Ali".
This testament does not mention the formalities that usually form part of the last will made nowadays. On the other hand the Imam wished to clarify his motive. He wanted to tell the people that his movement was not an ordinary one based on human passions and worldly desires. He, therefore, says: I am not going out for merry-making and amusement or to create mischief. I am also not perusing the path of oppression". He adds: "I have come out to reform the followers of my grandfather".
These words show that in the year 60 A.H. the Muslim ummah was faced with a dreadful social and religious crisis, which could not be overcome with a severe and bloody revolution. It was a danger that could be faced only by a leader like Husayn bin Ali, whose infallibility has been testified by the Holy Qur'an in the verse of Purification of Surah al-Ahzab (33:33). It was a peril that could not be dealt with by means of speeches and religious sermons.
He added: "If the people respond to my call, and accept truth from me, well and good; and if they do not accept it, I shall observe patience and am not afraid of unpleasant events, hardships, and sufferings". By saying that he would observe patience, the Imam did not mean to say that he would sit with folded hands so that Yazid might do whatever he liked. On the contrary he used this word in its correct sense, which is suited to the position of an Imam, and is the basis of faith and godliness. In other words he said: "Even if I am alone I shall pursue this path till Allah decides justly between me and these people, and He is the most Wise and the most Powerful of the judges".
Thank you for sharing the information with other Muslims who are never told of these facts
source?
May Allah bless you , Yasir Qadhi. The way you explained the Karbala Massacre was mesmerizing. It was like watching a movie. Tears kept dropping from my eyes. Wallahi, when you described how Hussain was martyred. This is still the case of the Muslim world. This also reminds me how Jamal Kashogi was barbarically decapitated, just because a king thought he was threat. Subhanallahi, Asthaufirullahi. May Allah protects the Isami Umma from this kind of fitnah. May Allah grant us people of Thaguwah and wisdom as our leaders and May Allah give Izza to our Umman. Ammen.
Such an exclusive bayan by Mufti...listening today on 10th of Muharramul haram 2021!
*Best description in best possible way. May Allah grant high grades to Ahl-ul-Bait.* May Allah bless you sir
Everytime I came back to this lecture of AlFadil, I shed tears in pain & in higher imaan for the grandchildren of Rasulullah صلى الله عليه وسلم . The infinite sacrifice until their last blood, losing all their loved ones. We are nothing, compared to their jeehad Fisabilillah. The betrayal & cowardness of the Kuffi will never be forgotten. Stories to be told to every kid. Islam, the ahlul sunnah wal jamaah always wins. May Allah reunite us & our families with them in Jannahtul Firdausi al-A'la. Allahumma Bareek. ❤
May Allah bless your Sh Yasir Qadi and continue to bless you with deep and beneficial knowledge...
But he bias. He should say yazid and his father committed crime . How his father idiot muvawia appointed his son . How
Both should go to hell
Knowledge never gets old… SUBAHANALLAH
The culprits were :
1. People of Koofa
2. Ibn Ziyad
3. Yazeed
Story goes back to Muawiyah (Father of Yazeed Paleed) as well, he was also one of the culprits ... People of Koofa were not the only culprits .. Under the command of Sulayman ibn Surad al Khuzai (Sahabi), the first letter was wrote to Imam Hussain A.S., with the agreements of other tribal elders of Koofa
Şhad Ahmet
So is this the “akhlaq” of a muslim? You want to refute a shi’i and you do it with such filth? Would the Prophet (saw) ever think of such words let alone even use them against the likes of abu jahl?
Doesn’t matter who started it...
Usman Khugyani
People of kuffa were not sahaba because the last few remaining sahaba alive such as ibn abbas and ibn Umar themselves (who were like 7-12 years old at the time of the Prophet (saw)) were around 70-80 during the events of karbala.
These were new muslims from the newly conquered territories.
all followers of muhammad
Plz correct your list
Mauwvia
Yazid
Ibn e zyaad
Amar bin saad
My heart aches so much on what the ahlul bayt had to go through. May Allah سبحانه وتعالى grant Hussain رضي الله عنه highest rank of Jannah
The Prophet AlaihisSalaam has already mentioned that "...Imam Husain is among the Youth Leaders of Jannah"
Mashallah Shaikh Qadhi, May Allah give you the best reward for putting this together. I'm a sunni Muslim and have always wondered who was at fault. You have explained it so well in the utmost logical way. Jazakallah khair
At 1.05.45 he says that Imam Hussain(A.S) did not know that he was going to die and that he genuinely believed that people of Kufa will support him.
But at 1.20.05, he says that the Prophet (PBUH), had foretold that Imam Hussain((AS) will be martyred, so obviously there is a contradiction here. Obviously, Imam Hussain((AS) knew what his grandfather had said and knew what he was doing. Also, who takes women and children along with them if they are going for a battle. The women folk and children were not left behind, because Imam Hussain((AS) wanted to tell history that this was not a battle to become a Caliph or for power, but to show the true character of the Caliph of the muslims I.e Yazid and to give the muslims the much needed awakening and also to restore the religion which was originally brought by the Prophet(PBUH) to the muslims.
Just because the prophet foretold his death, does not mean that at the time, one is able to put two and two together and realise that this particular event will result in his death. The prophet did not specify or give particulars. And Hussain could not stop living his life or stop making decisions because of the Prophet's prophesy.
💯
I am a proud Sunni and fully accept the creed of Ahlus-Sunna wal-Jama’a of focusing on the positives of all the Sahaba and to gloss over the conflicts of Ali and Mu’awiya rather than focus on all these negative Fitna. However, I can never say one word positive about Yazid and these tyrants. How dare they do this to the beloved Husayn RA.
Yazid is not bad
1.Think good about the believers and Yazid was among the believers it is a right a believer has over another
2.When Muawiya was dying he told his son to listen to a specific people and obey them he was obeying his father
3.He eventually went to the believers in Madina and gave his sincerest apologies he felt bad about what he did
If you want more details go to a video in which someone asked Assim al Hakeem about Yazid
@@hamdiyazid200 “Does anybody with Iman have love for Yazid?” - Ahmad ibn Hanbal (r).
Three incidents alone in Yazid’s Khilafah: 1) Karbala and the massacre of Hussain and the Ahlul-Bayt. 2) Harrah where he gave his soldiers three days free reign to plunder and rape Madinah. 3) Assault on Makkah where he approved the use of catapults on the Ka’bah itself.
I do not feel like I’m lacking in my Islam if I hold no good feeling towards Yazid. I don’t curse or hate him to the point where it’s Bid’ah like the Rawafidh.
But you were not there when it was going on a lot these accounts that he was bad were incorrect and false you should probably watch the video on assim al Hakeem stance
@@hamdiyazid200 I trust the sources of the Salaf over a new scholar, as respected as they may be.
Look I don't want to debate over this so let's agree to disagree and part our separate ways
Sunnis and Shias UNITE!!! ❤🙏🏻
Guys, the Ummah is in peril.
We have to UNITE first and defeat our enemies, THEN we can look at our differences and come to an agreement.
For now, we must put our differences aside and UNITE!
The Ummah is being whipped by its enemies, there's no need to whip ourselves too.
#PowerInUnity
@al-Haifawi Sunnis have: 4 madhabs,Wahhabi,Deobandi,Salafi,Sufism.
Shias have:Twelvers,Seveners,Ismaili,Bohras,Khojas,Alavis,Alevis.
Others:Druze, Qadiyani(?),Black Muslim(USA),Malcom X,Bahai(?).
So many........
@@peacefulindian318 islam is one thing following the book of Allah and the teaching of his messenger nothing more nothing else anything beside this dare not consider himself a muslim and by the way salfi means following the rightous salf the sahaba and the prophet and its not a madhb its a sunna 😒
One way to help this ummah unite is by taking away the name Sunni, Shia, and all of these other sects. They weren't around the time of the Prophet peace be upon him, so they shouldn't be after him. As long as you follow the Quran and the Sunnah, and you love whom the Prophet peace be upon him loved, you are a Muslim. Let's start there.
But first, the Shias must stop practicing mutaah. And they must stop cursing the companions and mother of believers, may Allah have mercy on them. Because those types of Shias are not the Shia of Ali (radiAllahanhu), but they are Shia of Mr. Khomeini. We have no business uniting with those, better to unite with the Orthodox Jews who have TAwheed, than to these people who say ‘Ya Ali Madad’, it is shameful that even Orthodox Jews have better TAwheed than them and know better than them not to call upon any other than Allah subhanawata’ala.
very profound by Abdullah Ibn Umar at 1:00:00, that really shows his wisdom.
Wow, yeah
We will learn the history and let Allah decide it
Agree. It's people of the past, we can learn something from it for our benefit, for our current time.
masha Allah
ua-cam.com/video/HqUyhLiY774/v-deo.html
It's really a true story and great pictures of the kerbala ..Yasir kadhi is really a great scholar no dout mash a Allah you are great sir Yasir .. jazakallah khair 💞
What a heart wrenching story.
Omar RA proposed to mary Ali’s RA daughter & Ali RA accepted the Omar’s RA proposal & Ali RA married her daughter to Omar, RA.
This means Ali RA & Omar RA did not have any rivalry, in fact bonded their families & this means Ali RA liked Omar RA because Ali RA gave his daughter to Omar RA in marriage union.
That is a unsmart view. Ali bin abi Talib himself hated Omar as much as the prophet did. He is the one who murdered Fatima, the Holy Daughter of the Holy Prophet using a door to sufficate her and the child she was carrying. Shame on you and all Omar bin khattab's followers.
Rizwan Hassan the first sensible comment👍🏻
Exactly such deluded hateful people spreading lies against one of the strongest forts of Islam.
@@khadijaabdulmajid1462 yeah exactly
@@hemlock751 is there justificstion?
Indeed knowledge is the most powerful weapon in the world ....& I wish this could reach to everyone specially to the PPL who are still lacking the real information about real history of Islam and tragedy of Karbala.
A lot of information, well explained! May Allah give us guidance, knowledge and soften our hearts.
I am sunni but bias. Mucawia how dare he appointed his your son a.leader . That is wrong and created a civil war between Islam..
May Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'Ala punish his murderers severely.
Allah will. You have nothing to do with that rather you have practice your life like Hussain R.A
@@factcheck8936 Hussain AS does in no way change the way we have to practice our deen he came after the door to changes in Islam were closed. He was still a child when the prophet was around
@@abdulazizbadi2782 do you think Hussain عليه اسلام practiced a different kind of deen?
@@UmarAli-cr1nl no, he practiced it the way his father Ali RA did, and the way the prophet SAW did, and the way we, Ahlul sunnah do
@@abdulazizbadi2782 so why did u have a problem when the person above said you have to practice your life like Hussain عليه السلام
I can't get tire of listening to this topic...to the point of I almost memorize it!
Revisiting this lecture for the 3rd time- Muharram 10 1445. JazakAllah khair Shaikh for this incredible lecture♥️
Visit Karbala .. next year .. I pray for you Inshallah
This is not a historical analysis. This is a "let me pick my own hadiths and convey what "I" want to convey about Karbala so I can try to absolve Bani Ummayads from their heinous crimes" analysis.
Just like how shias do! Fair Enough?!!
why dont you tell us the real one instead of criticising in hiding. not constructive.
Didn't he say cruelty on part of Umayyads? He is right rejecting exaggerations.
@@interactazhar there is a comment above that shows sunni translated hadith contradicting this lecture. As a sunni muslim myself, i am trying to learn as well but your fueling hatred against people who are more knowledgable at the moment. Please read above comments from other sunni muslims (not the hatred comments).
Malaradi7, not necessarily 😐😐😐😐😐😐😐
May we become united upon the truth ameen
The people and so called scholars who send blessings to Tyrant Yazid should raise with him on the day of Judgment as Tyrant Yazid's friend and followers, InshaAllah. May Allah save us from these groups and such so called scholars.
What about the people of kufa who betrayed once Hazrat Ali and also Hazrat Hussain
@@hakimjunejo9026 All these were due to power. And Hussein does not have a big Army. Yazid had a big military!
@@peacefulindian318 But were these Shiatul Ali forced to betray Muslim Ibn Aqil? Even today, this very day, can anyone bribe you or me to betray The Prophet's family if we are asked to? As a Muslim, I would take a bullet and a sword for Hussein and Ali Radhiallahu Anhu. I would NEVER Ever have betrayed Ahlul Bayt had I been in Kufa . No Yazid no government no governor no amount of money would have made me do it. How could these Shiatul Ali have done it whilst Hussein was alive? How?
Your buddy Dr.Zakir Naik loves Yazid
Listening to this in muharram 1445.. as a reminder ❤
Thank you for this. I am not a Muslim, but I have been interested in your religion and the Sunni/Shi'a split. I have heard much from the Shi'a about this incident, but never have I heard the Sunni position explained like this. Thank you.
Revisiting on 9th Muharram 2021 and reviving my knowledge of the events as the day passes... The subject in question is indeed touched in detail and explained eloquently by dear brother Yasir!🌷
Jazak Allah
Same here
Same..
Same
Sahih Muslim - 6220
کتاب:کتاب: صحابہ کرام رضی اللہ عنہم کے فضائل ومناقب
باب:حضرت علی رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ کے فضائل
ARABIC:
حَدَّثَنَا قُتَيْبَةُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ، وَمُحَمَّدُ بْنُ عَبَّادٍ - وَتَقَارَبَا فِي اللَّفْظِ - قَالَا: حَدَّثَنَا حَاتِمٌ وَهُوَ ابْنُ إِسْمَاعِيلَ - عَنْ بُكَيْرِ بْنِ مِسْمَارٍ، عَنْ عَامِرِ بْنِ سَعْدِ بْنِ أَبِي وَقَّاصٍ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، قَالَ: أَمَرَ مُعَاوِيَةُ بْنُ أَبِي سُفْيَانَ سَعْدًا فَقَالَ: مَا مَنَعَكَ أَنْ تَسُبَّ أَبَا التُّرَابِ؟ فَقَالَ: أَمَّا مَا ذَكَرْتُ ثَلَاثًا قَالَهُنَّ لَهُ رَسُولُ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ فَلَنْ أَسُبَّهُ، لَأَنْ تَكُونَ لِي وَاحِدَةٌ مِنْهُنَّ أَحَبُّ إِلَيَّ مِنْ حُمْرِ النَّعَمِ، سَمِعْتُ رَسُولَ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ يَقُولُ لَهُ، خَلَّفَهُ فِي بَعْضِ مَغَازِيهِ، فَقَالَ لَهُ عَلِيٌّ: يَا رَسُولَ اللهِ خَلَّفْتَنِي مَعَ النِّسَاءِ وَالصِّبْيَانِ؟ فَقَالَ لَهُ رَسُولُ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ: «أَمَا تَرْضَى أَنْ تَكُونَ مِنِّي بِمَنْزِلَةِ هَارُونَ مِنْ مُوسَى؟ إِلَّا أَنَّهُ لَا نُبُوَّةَ بَعْدِي» وَسَمِعْتُهُ يَقُولُ يَوْمَ خَيْبَرَ «لَأُعْطِيَنَّ الرَّايَةَ رَجُلًا يُحِبُّ اللهَ وَرَسُولَهُ، وَيُحِبُّهُ اللهُ وَرَسُولُهُ» قَالَ فَتَطَاوَلْنَا لَهَا فَقَالَ: «ادْعُوا لِي عَلِيًّا» فَأُتِيَ بِهِ أَرْمَدَ، فَبَصَقَ فِي عَيْنِهِ وَدَفَعَ الرَّايَةَ إِلَيْهِ، فَفَتَحَ اللهُ عَلَيْهِ، وَلَمَّا نَزَلَتْ هَذِهِ الْآيَةُ: {فَقُلْ تَعَالَوْا نَدْعُ أَبْنَاءَنَا وَأَبْنَاءَكُمْ} [آل عمران: 61] دَعَا رَسُولُ اللهِ صَلَّى اللهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ عَلِيًّا وَفَاطِمَةَ وَحَسَنًا وَحُسَيْنًا فَقَالَ: «اللهُمَّ هَؤُلَاءِ أَهْلِي»
TRANSLATION:
Amir b. Sa'd b. Abi Waqqas reported on the authority of his father that Muawiya b. Abi Sufyan appointed Sa'd as the Governor and said:
What prevents you from abusing Abu Turab (Hadrat 'Ali), whereupon be said: It is because of three things which I remember Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) having said about him that I would not abuse him and even if I find one of those three things for me, it would be more dear to me than the red camels. I heard Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) say about 'Ali as he left him behind in one of his campaigns (that was Tabuk). 'Ali said to him: Allah's Messenger, you leave me behind along with women and children. Thereupon Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) said to him: Aren't you satisfied with being unto me what Aaron was unto Moses but with this exception that there is no prophethood after me. And I (also) heard him say on the Day of Khaibar: I would certainly give this standard to a person who loves Allah and his Messenger, and Allah and his Messenger love him too. He (the narrator) said: We had been anxiously waiting for it, when he (the Holy Prophet) said: Call 'Ali. He was called and his eyes were inflamed. He applied saliva to his eyes and handed over the standard to him, and Allah gave him victory. (The third occasion is this) when the (following) verse was revealed: Let us summon our children and your children. Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) called 'Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Husain and said: O Allah, they are my family.
www.theislam360.com
Hmmm I did cry......May Allah give us clarity...and may Allah make us really mean it when we send our salawat on our prophet and he's household .cos they really did go through a lot to bring us this beloved deen
Yazid killed imam Hussein, the grandson of Rasulullah,,, You made mentioned that Yazid consciously selected the most vicious and harsh governor ibn ziad to take charged of the matter of Hussein. if Hussein get killed by Ibn Ziad, Yazid would'nt be surprised. but to my grief on the fate of imam Hussein, the grandson of Rasulullah, he didn't die a simple murder as per the record of history. it was so brutal and heinous. Clearly the martyrdom of imam Hussein was to save the muslims from the unjust by exposing Yazid brutality.
Raul Usama , My dear brother *please* you must watch my very important videos in my *Playlists*
@@kitkatpleasesubscribe6720 please share me the link
You Shia killed hussain, betrayed him, thats why you beat yourselves
Not yasid the governor he said pls watch again
I'm not a Shia. But I'm ashamed of my Sunni brothers who are soft on Yazid.
Astaghfirullah ! He was just being the "Loyal Soldier", never mind that he killed the grandson of our Nabi (S) . Listen , the atrocity of Karbala wasn't some kind of epic or play in which every one is some kind of character just acting out his or her part. No , No and No , the Prophet's (S) family was murdered and slaughtered.
Kerbala was a massacre and not a war. 4000 against 72
@@habibqadir1
Think the same.
They that do that hope Allah directed to the hardest part of Ghahanam.
The people's to blame are people of Koufa yes but Yazid, Ibn Yazid and the blood thirsty Umayads
JazakAllah sheikh for such an amazing description
The part where Prophet Muhammad SAW heard about Hussein’s death from Jibreel, and was crying; it broke my heart.
The Hadith of forgiveness to the first army Who attack Constantinople sounds like it was created by banu umayya to legitimize the faith of yazid.
Absolutely!
You can't go to the Jannah where you've killed the Master of its youth !!
Lahaula Wala quwata Ila billah Dr Yasir it's very sad it's like it's happening right now I cry for Ahlul bait
My heart was in my throat throughout. I was so so uneasy because listening to something you know the ending of makes u very stressed. What a horrible incident!
Grateful for this lecture as I learned something, part of Islamic history. Allahumma baarik. I watched in one sitting! Sooo interesting
I advise Dr. Yasir to call him with respect Imam Hussein in stead of hussein and to say RA or AS when you mention his name please
But isn't AS is reserved for Prophets?
@@kinguzi24 No, it's also reserved for the Household (Aal) of the prophets.
Allahumma salli ala Muhammad wa Aal Muhammed wa sallim ala Muhammed wa Aal Muhammed wa barik ala Muhammed wa Aal Muhammed...
So we send our peace and blessings to Muhammed and the Household of Muhammed
@@mohamedbelkadi9696 We can also use A.S for Sahaba also not only for the family of Muhammad (S.A.W). For example Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddique (A.S).
@@mk-qc5zgI talk about the Quranic peace and blessings that God has order us to say: O you who believe send your blessings and peace to the prophet. The prophet teached us how: Allahumma salli ala Muhammad wa Aal Muhammed wa sallim ala Muhammed wa Aal Muhammed.
No sahaba mentioned, it's exclusively for the Propbet and His Houshold.
I don't talk about the salam that we say to each other. assalamu alayk and you reply with wa3alyka salam
Zeyad and Yazid both seem arrogant and fowl. Looking at the character of these people, the prophets family definitely displayed a better character.
I personally blame for this massacre the people kufa in iraq, ibn ziyad and yazid. Yes, i actually blame yazid also together with the people of kufa and ibn ziyad. Also i blame shimir, the army of yazid and its leaders.
Shamir was also a Kufan himself who fought for Ali at Siffin and then defected and switched sides..Kufans called Hussain and Stitched him up by not showing up..Not Just Yazid Ibn Muawiyah the Kufans should be taken the equal blame which they have been quitely deflecting on one man alone
Yes, I agree with you
Shame on all those who praise Yazid or Muawiya like Zakir Naik praises him.
Cell Zone Muawiyah was a Sahabi so we should respect him,I’m not saying we should agree with all things he did but we should respect him.
@@skoofisf We should have no respect for him, He put Yazid his son in power even he knew what kind of son he has raised. Muawiya never loved Ahlulbayt or else he would of not went to war against imam Ali. Remember we are not talking about simple or normal people here we are taking about Ahlulbayt where Allah in Quran states that the Ahlulbayt Allah keeps impurity away from them.
Well done. Great lecture. I've listed to it a few times now.
Jaza kullah brother yasir qahdi for this amazing lecture may Alllah give you the best of both world and may Allah continue to bless you and your family we need people like you in this world keep up the great work
When Zainab reached Kufa, she addressed people with fury words: "Praise to Allah, and may the blessing of Allah be upon Muhammad and his progeny. O people of Kufa, you are hypocrites and deceitful. You feign to be sorry for the death of my brother and his companions. May you always shed tears. I find nothing in you but flattery, evil acts and thoughts, pride and spite and ill will. By Allah (SWT)! You deserve lasting sorrow instead of joy. Shames on you, your hands are imbrued with the blood of the son of Prophet Muhammad (saw), the one who was your sole refuge in case of adversity. By your evil act and disloyalty, you incurred the wrath of Allah (SWT) against you. Woe betides you! No one will intercede with Allah (SWT) for you." Her furious words provoked people of Kufa to avenge Imam Hussein's martyrdom. This frightened Ubaidullah ibn Ziyad and his cruel agents. She also delivered a furious sermon in the court of the caliph that made his authority and despotic rule feel undermined. She said: "I fear no one but Allah (SWT). Make whatever evil plot you can. Blazes are waiting for you in the hereafter. You'll he accountable to Allah (SWT) for your atrocities."
Please under line the words; MAY YOU ALWAYS SHED TEARS. - - - also- - - YOU DESERVE LASTING SORROW INSTEAD OF JOY. SHAME ON YOU. YOUR HANDS ARE IMBUED WITH THE BLOOD OF THE SON OF THE PROPHET MUHAMMAD (s.a.w.)
Reyaz Sahab Masha Allah... Quoting would have been helpful!
I was torn between adopting Sunni or Shia madhab, this lecture has helped me make up my mind.
i hope you find peace and salvation much love to you ❤
Don't adopt both
Just be a muslim, thats enough
Shia is a persianize personalized islam, built on hatred and revenge
Sunni don't exist, they just create the identity somewhere around abbasids era as a counter identity of shia
Meaning, both is better of disregard
Hopefully you choose sunnah
If you've to ask this question then I suggest you learn more about basic aqidah, it requires you to believe in qada and qadr, ask yourself, not accepting what has happened and previous khulafas because of political lineage is this according to Quran and Sunnah.
Welcome to.muslim ummah
Im a sunni but it is very evident from your analysis that yazid was responsible for everything. Along with his general ans shimar. If he had tjis much respect foe Nabi saw, he would have come him self to face imam hussain. And delt the situation with him self but it seems he avoided imam hussain. Shame on all the people who are defending the murderers.
@@HS-13 Actually,all these were politics. Yazid wants power,he wants allegience. He had a powerful Army.
Unfortunately,Hussein does not have a big army. The Kufans were controlled by Ubaydullah.
Mina -yes, I am a Sunni and as Sunnis we have a very high level of respect for Imam Hussain. I don’t get what your problem is when calling Imam Hussain an ‘imam’? He deserves this level of respect. Of course, we do not beat ourselves up and shed blood as the Shias do as that’s seen as an extreme extent which should not be done.
@@hakimjunejo9026 May the curse of Allah be on those kuffans at the time that didn't help Hussein.
I am sunni from Iraq and wallahi may Allah curse those did to Hussein what they did. And the Iraqis amongst them. Beating yourselves over it won't make the pain go away. The only way back is through Allah.
@@nimrahhussain1930 Imam Hussain RA is more than an Imam I love him more than my family He is more close to my heart than my family
Hussain AS didn't want power.
What kind of analysis is this
@Alex H why what Happened?
Alex H Haven’t you listen first three disclaimer?
As the proverb goes: "Love for something makes a man blind and deaf.”
Depends whether you are Shia or sunni. You would judge according to the narrative you've been told. Here Yasir Qadhi is providing a sunni analysis.
This is worst kind of lecture I’ve heard on Karbala topic and that too coming from a renowned scholar like Yasir Qadhi. Same propaganda garbage from the defenders of Umayyads, not at all a neutral perspective. There are tons of hadiths on this topic for references and yet he chose Tarikh i.e. historical records which are biased and not authentic for topic as sensitive as Karbala
May Allah forgive me and my daughter and my deaceasd father n adopted mom and grant us jannatul firdus with the company of Rasul Allah(s.a.w) a make us pass the bridge assrat and save us torture of grave ameen thuma ameen Allahuma ameen ya rabbulalamin
Wallahi Sheikh Yasir Qadhi makes this so clear even though it's 9 years old. I am sunni iraqi and wallahi after hearing about this I wish I wasn't born Iraqi. I wish so badly that Hussein was not killed and something was done about it. But the Iraqis were cowards and hypocrites and I wish to not be from them. I have cousins that are Shia and they are amazing people in terms of morals but now I wish I wasn't cousins with them. I traveled to Iraq 2 years ago to visit family and my Shia cousins took me to karbala and the imam hussein mosque or whatever it was called. People in there kept crying and kissing the doors of the place and when they prayed they prayed on this stone with words on it. I kept saying to them this was so weird and it doesn't make sense and was strange to me why the hell they'd do it. I prayed in there 2 ruqaat as normal sunnah people do and left. Wallahi if the so called Shia of Hussein people really felt sorry they'd turn back to Allah directly and ask a person of true islamic knowledge on what to do and leave it at that. They literally didn't have to make a forever sadness thing where they're sad forever. It's so stupid I can't understand it. I just want to be beside the Prophet in jannah. Inshallah. I know I wrote long but I had to because I couldn't stay quiet about it. It's so stupid what the Iraqis did.
Sad, from me in Indonesian.
Alhamdulillah you are not easily influenced by your surroundings but do not be ashamed or apologize for your people as this is of the past and in Islam there's no concept of original sins like the Christians believe, no one shall bear the sin of another. The best you can do is to advice them to return to the teachings following the Quran and Sunnah.
"Is it other than Allāh I should desire as a lord while He is the Lord of all things? And every soul earns not [blame] except against itself, and no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another. Then to your Lord is your return, and He will inform you concerning that over which you used to differ." (6:164)
Then how can you explain that Allah commands you to love the Allulbayt that Allah mentioned in the Quran 42:23
That ˹reward˺ is the good news which Allah gives to His servants who believe and do good. Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “I do not ask you for a reward for this ˹message˺-only honour for ˹our˺ kinship.”1 Whoever earns a good deed, We will increase it in goodness for them. Surely Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Appreciative.
Footnote
This could also be a call to all believers to love and respect the immediate family of the Prophet (ﷺ).
The sins of your ancestor is not your burden, unless you follow exactly the same footsteps. You will gain new sins instead! Nauzubillah!
May we all remain steadfast in our iman of Allah
It just shows how pitiful us humans are that somebody can kill the grandson of our beloved prophet (saw). A very sad & tragic event in Islamic history. God bless you Dr Yasir
So true 👍
A Prophet of Allah was killed.
His name was Yahya.
Since I first saw this video.... I always re watch this video every Muharram like a ritual 😀😀
You should do more research before believe this video, he is not telling the truth
Why are you smiling?
Yazid and ibn ziyad would be answerable to Allah on the day of judgement
adb taqi
Yes,
We should not be judging back biting or cursing the dead.
@@tasneemfawzi The permissibility of cursing Yazid is a valid Sunni position that won't change with Fatwas that state otherwise. Imam Suyuti (rh) has cursed him by name as have other prestigious scholars.
adb taqi
Yes,
Since none of us were there we need not worry who did what
Let Almighty Allah handle it
5544
Let Almighty Allah swt deal with it.
He is the greatest
5544
The biggest enemy of Muslim is the ignorant they need education to be more flexible and tolerant.
Cursing somebody is the sign of weakness,
The speaker fails to analyse Husain's grander strategy. He also makes it look like Husain did an inadvisable thing which everyone advised against making a rebellion against Yazid, as if that was not what one should do. Yazid and his father were an insult to Islam, as was Marwan and others later. A self sacrifice of Husain deserves a better historical analysis.
Great point. Imam Hussain was the most knowledgeable and just man of his time, a divinely appointed leader. He would have known better than any other what was in the best interest of the Ummah and his Grand Father’s religion. He didn’t need to be advised by anyone. In his own words Hussain said, ‘ I did not rise up for wickedness, amusement, corruption and oppression, but I rose to reform the Muslim community of my Grandfather’s religion. prophet Muhammed. I want to promote virtue and prevent vice.”
Prophet Muhammad prepared Imam Hussein for this journey his entire life... this was his Devine calling and purpose in life. The prophet wept for Hussein from the day he was born because he was informed by angel Jabraiel that a day would come when members of his own Ummah would kill his beloved grandson. Hussain’s blood and that of his family members and righteous companions is what saved our religion from corruption and tyranny and his death serves as a reminder to all of us believers to stand up to the oppression that exists in our own time. Labaik ya Hussain, may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon you oh master of all martyrs.
ua-cam.com/video/SC0g_b-CUFU/v-deo.html
Muawiyah was a sahaba right?
Skoofis F yes but that doesn’t make him an automatically righteous person. He was a very corrupt leader that had a lot of animosity towards the household of the prophet.
H M he spread Islam very much, and one more thing please, how do you know if he was a righteous leader
Having listened to the lecture I believe that this calamity could have been avoided if a majority of the people of Kufa were not hypocrites and if they really loved and respected the Great Prophet SAS and his grandson.
What about Mecca and Medina?? Hussain was in Mecca and Medina before Karbala. Where were they ?? They didn't back him either
The people of the Kufah cannot be trusted. After Siffin,they deserted Ali. The Khawarij was another issue. After Muslim bin Aqil was killed,Hussein could have aborted his plan to go to Kufah,but Yazid will chase him until he obtains Hussein's bai'ah! The people of Kufah cannot help Hussein because the Governor Ubaydullah was too powerful.
@@afguy2p2 The people of Mecca and Medina were afraid of the Governor of Medina. Only the people of Kufah,who were staunch supporters of Ali wanted Hussein to be the next Caliph. That's why Hussein wanted to go to Kufah! Politically,the Kufans and the Basrans were more active.
@@peacefulindian318 Hussain was in Medina they could have helped him but they didnt. He went to Mecca they didn't help him and didnt.Okay atleast the Kufans wanted to do something where as Medina and Mecca were silent which is just as bad and they knew an alcholic/corrupt person was ruling the muslims. I can make the argument that Medina and Mecca were complicit in his killing and in time of help for Hussain they ignored him. Medina, Mecca and Kufa are at fault here.
@@afguy2p2 In fact Hussein had an army while going to Kufah.But many deserted him on the way. Hussein's major supporters were in Kufah and Basra and not in Mecca or Medina.
The decision of not giving the bai'ah to Yazid was Hussein's own. His brother Hasan had given bai'ah to Muawiyah to avoid Muslim bloodshed and the promise of Muawiyah to give Hasan the caliphate after him. Muawiyah cheated Hasan.
Hussein knew the characters of Muawiyah and Yazid. He don't want give bai'ah to the Ummayads!
Assalamualaikum I come here every year to listen this 😢💖
Thank you Sheikh, may Allah bless you and increase your wisdom, imaan and knowledge.
Told with so much information withheld and not alm true
@Alex H What is the full truth then? You don't have to criticize him either.
JazakAllahu Khairan shaykh for all ur efforts..
Don't know why? I have seen many sunni scholars defending Yazeed...Being Sunni I don't understand Why some people have to defend some one who was culprit, tyrant and clearly responsible of Hussein (RA, S)murder. Thanks Almighty I have understood the concept clearly . May Allah reward you shekh...
Because those sunnis are followers of yet another firqah in Deen called Salaf. Yasir qadhi sb subtly called them out in the beginning when he said that he doesn't associate with those who don't regard ahl ul bait as nothing (like the Salaf do). We must have love for ahl ul bail because our Nabi sallalahu alaihi wa sallam had great love for his children and grandchildren. How can we not then? And then how can we not hate the one who mercilessly ordered to kill them ?
@@memoiories The salaf are very Sunni tho..these are the Sahaba and those that follow the prophet peace and blessings be upon him...you can search السلف الصالح ابن باز it'll help ypu understand more...that's one of the greatest Ulamaa of this generation
@@memoiories Sheikh Albani was a salafi and a lover of Ahlul bait AS.
Modern salafis defend yazid due to their opponent towards Iran. May Allah give these modern salafis hidaya and put love of Ahlul bait in their hearts and guts to oppose banu ummayah
Dr Yasir Qadhi, you also mention that Yazeed may have been a good man, but he was in charge of the army which attacked Medina killings thousands and this was shortly after the Kaballa.
As a sunni, I respectfully disagree with you saying we cannot pick at the intention of Muawiya when he nominated his son to be caliph, but we can somehow decipher the intention of Hussein AS? by saying he rashly proceeded to Kuffa because he'd always basically wanted to fight the the Ummayads (something his brother Hassan couldn't do in his life time). It saddens me that so many people convert to shi'ism (and this is being said respectfully to the shia) because our narrations do not defend the integrity and honor of ahlul bayt. As the grandson of the beloved prophet Mohammad asws, I am certain his sole intention was to stand up against the corruption of the Ummayads, and this is why he was so determined to lead against them. The prophet Mohammad asws even said "Hussain is of me and I am of Hussain" - both Hassan and Hussein had their own wisdom in their own lifetimes and I do not believe one was wiser than the other as their circumstances were different w Allahu a3lam.
Separately, I do appreciate the differentiation between political shi'ism and theological. This was an important distinction to highlight.
Thank you for sharing your perspective.
P.s. I'm a huge fan of Adnan Rashid as he is a historian, and he mentions that the story about Abdullah ibn Omar intercepting Hussain AS and telling him not to go to Kuffa is an inauthentic narration (he too is Sunni). You must remember that ahlul bayt and the sahaba did nothing without praying istikhara and seeking Allah's guidance in their actions - it makes no sense as you've portrayed: that Hussain AS went to kuffa against the full advisory and plea of the sahaba and others who didn't initially give bay3a to Yazid.
Just to clarify, When one loses his loved one or family member he cries and beats his head out of pure sadness. He isn’t crying because he feels that he is the killer of that loved one. Please don’t spread lies and hate.
Very beneficial in neutral manner
We have to face world when dealing comparative exchange of views. JazakumULLAHU khairan hazrat salaam WRWB
this goes to the shia that curse the sahabah.
In the hadith Ibn Umar related that the Holy Prophet said: If a Muslim calls another kafir, then if he is a kafir let it be so; otherwise, he [the caller] is himself a kafir.'' (Abu Dawud, Book of Sunna,
Ibne Umar gave allegiance to Yazid.
when? according to who? and do you know why?
When? When Imam Hussein did not.
According to ? The narratives of Sahi h Al Bukhari
Why? Because he, like Muawiah, did not understand the concept of lmamat.
Ali Dawah Narrated Nafi': When the people of Medina dethroned Yazid bin Muawiya, Ibn 'Umar gathered his special friends and children and said, "I heard the Prophet saying, 'A flag will be fixed for every betrayer on the Day of Resurrection,'and we have given the oath of allegiance to this person (Yazid) in accordance with the conditions enjoined by Allah and His Apostle and I do not know of anything more faithless than fighting a person who has been given the oath of allegiance in accordance with the conditions enjoined by Allah and His Apostle , and if ever I learn that any person among you has agreed to dethrone Yazid, by giving the oath of allegiance (to somebody else) then there will be separation between him and me."
Sahih Bukhari Book 88 H 227
Regarding accepting Money to accept Bayah
"Abdullah Ibn Umar did not mention the caliphate of Ali because he did not give bayah to him…. But he gave bayah to Yazeed son of Muayyiah"
Fatah al Bari Sharh Sahih Bukhari book 18 p.145
You've just replied to a post that contains two quotes, each of them from Sunni books. l didn't express my opinion.
They (the quotes) clarify the fact that the Sahaba Abdullah ibn Umar, gave allegiance to Yazid
Another Sahabah, (& member of Ahlul Bayt) Imam Hussein, did 'not' give allegiance to Yazid
You do not wish to differentiate between the Sahabah & the Ahlul Bayt, but here, we see a clear difference in the loyalties of Abdullah the son of Umar, & Hussein the son of Ali.
Please enlighten me as to how you, as a Sunni Muslim, are able to reconcile this 'particular' difference.
Brilliant. Absolutely marvelous Sheikh. London is looking forward to your visit... In-shallah.
I don't understand why people always fight on this topic. I am 13 years old and I know that a true Muslim never curse anyone... literally no one not even Satan. And there are some brothers who curse the most beloved sahabas of prophet Muhammad (pbuh). This just disturbs my mind. It's already hard to digest that Muslims fought each other at that time.😭😭😭 May Allah bless all of us and May we will unite with imam Hussain (ra) in Jannah.Pls don't fight Muslims.😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
I m 15 nd this breaks my heart too💔😢.. May Allah accept our duwa❤
Ameen😭😭🙏🙏
@@aashiakram7145 who gave you phone at this age!!!!
@@bullseye9723
He using laptop.
Soo true and well said. May Allah protect your beautiful innocent heart and it never hardens.
Amazing lecture!!! Thanks
MashaAllah, I had a full picturesque view of what happened in Karbala. Thanks to Dr Yasir Kadhi.
But it is not the full picture my friend... It is the incomplete and miss interpreted truth... Which is making Hussain ibn Ali look like just another Arab who lived in those days....
@@laurasarkaar1365 everything that happened in the past is history my friend.... Even all the prophets are history but we still learn from their actions and teachings.... Similarly the action and teaching of Imam Hussain is important and please don't defame it by saying it's only history and he was an irrelevant person.
Thank you for the informative lecture but I believe even the Shia of today should not share the blame of what their ancestors did. What happened was unfortunate and saddens every Muslim, but none of us bears the sins of his or her forefathers. Allah is our only Judge. He knows best. I think Ustadh should have pointed that out.
Aafreen K. Shia of today support and celebrate what their ancestors did. There's no end to the madness.
ITHA JAAA'T NASROU AL-FATH!. There are two types of Islam, one "sweet", the other "sour". You may yet see the entire world embracing sweet Islam --- once the "blood-hungry" Yazid-types are banished from the world! They are the ones who say "Peace, peace" to nasty men who HATE ALLAH (Jeremiah 23:17-22 & 8:15-9:4*).
zipo dipo One must either be an idiot or a dishonest person to put the blame more on the bystanders than on the perpetrators.
I'm an ex-Shii but lol the leaders of the Rafidah are mostly (authentic) Sayyids. Their forefathers were Al Husayn and the Ahlul bait, not the Rafidah of Kufa. Besides the point but let's break this 'forefathers' slur :P
He should, shouldn't he. It almost sound like he's deceivingly trying to switch the blame even in the matters that we stand by..
Mashallah
Great and detailed
Allah (swt) knows best
Credit to Dr Yasir
ua-cam.com/video/HqUyhLiY774/v-deo.html
I am Ahla Sunnah , Laa Ilaaha Ilaa Allah. The pain i feel about the murder of the grandson of the noble Messenger s. a. w(Imaam Hussien)
May Allah curse those who abandoned the grandson of the Noble Prophet s.a.w.
May Allah's curse be upon them.
please correct the initial part of your statement. Grandson of the Nabi s.a.w
@@Nomadic333 Estaghfurullah! thanks bro.
Thanks for correcting me bros/sis. It was a typo. Indeed Allah The Most Generous is beyond having a son/wife/daughter etc. Subahaanah!
I found this a very balanced lecture few things he didn't talked about was the children get killed by the cruel Yazid Army, as Shia Muslims narrate in there side of the history.
Imam Hussein’s army were comprised of 72 men, many of which were young adolescents such as Al-Qassim, age 14, son of Imam Al-Hassan. There were also about 20 women that accompanied Imam Hussein to Iraq that brought along their young children. The youngest killed was Imam Hussein 6 month old baby Abdullah. When all of Imam Hussein’s men lost their lives in the battle field, lady Zainab brought the baby and handed him to Imam Hussein requesting him to ask the army for some water for the dehydrated child.. his mother Lady Rabab was unable to nurse him because her milk supply had ran dry due to not having had water for three days. Imam Hussain took the child and requested water for him, upon doing so the army of Ibn ziad became conflicted and split in two.. those who wanted to give the child water and those who didn’t. Ibn ziad fearing retaliation from his army of thirty thousand, wanted to put an end to this dispute. He order one of his most skilled archers Harmala Ibn Kahel to target the child’s neck with a three headed arrow killing him instantly. This was just one reported account of children being killed merciless at the hands of Bani ummaya during the battle of Karbala. Today, the infant of Imam Hussein is buried along side his father Imam Hussein and his brother Ali Al-Akbar age 27 who also lost his life fighting along side his Father in Karbala. The shrine of Imam Hussein stands as the most visited shrine in the world.
Whoisthemaingultyofkilledofhussainra
Beautiful lecture and thank you for the efforts. May Allah grant you Aljanah
Seydi Bah. I'm from Senegal 😊 I am a Ba as well. Happy to see you here....
hmm standing in front of Imam Husein and Hasaan how he going to justify his stance..
abvant they are not gods, even if Shias' are correct, then he will only answer Allah.
@@saabiquuna5255apologies for the late reply, totally missed it. Yes Seydi Ba, from Guinea Conakry.
@@abvant Hassan and Hussain are not Allah or his messengers he doesn't have to justify anything.
1:02 please listen very carefully, it is fundamentally very key. And it is indeed our stand.
I wanted to know what happened as a Muslim who loves the grandchildren of our beloved rasulAllah sallahu alaihi wassam
MashaAllah very knowledgeable bayan Dr Yasir Qadhi. May Allah SWT always keep you blessed and protect you. Aameen
Why is Ashura unique/distinct?
Because 30,000 Muslim soldiers stood with their swords seeking the blood of the beloved grandson of our last Prophet, Mohammed pbuh.
They murdered him, massacred his family in the NAME OF ISLAM, and for the love of Allah swt. Imagine!!
This ummah was in a great jahl (ignornance) for this calamity to happen. And this was only 50 years after the Prophet pbuh died.
What on Earth happened for the ummah of Mohammed to turn against his own flesh and blood and shed the blood of innocents IN THE NAME OF ISLAM so soon? Where is this jahl and fitna from.
Simple - they disobeyed the Prophets command to hold onto the TWO WEIGHTY THINGS (see hadith thaqalayn) - Hold onto the Holy Quran and MY AHLULBAYT after I die.
The Ahlulbayt are the guardians of the Prophet's sunnah.
But the ummah forgot the Prophet's will to them. They killed the ahlulbayt and did it in the name of Islam.
Only by Hussain's killing did truth become distilled from the fitna and falsehood that had spread in the Muslim ummah.
No only by the jesus blood according to some. And some say its guru gavind or krishna.
Show your proof that the army who committed the murder did it in the name of Islam and love for Allah.They did it for their love of this world.
@@ishrakmohammad7307 They represented the 'Khalifa' of the time - the representative of Muslims at the time - Yazid. And Muslims must follow the orders of their Caliph, no?
@@blobbins17 Seriously,that's your lame evidence. You still did not prove that they were doing it out of love for Allah and Islam.
Ishrak Mohammad they did it on the instruction of their caliph - that is true. In Islam you have to follow your Caliph.
“you were never meant to be kings” that hit different. Islam is so beautiful
I've learned a lot more about this matter, JazakaAllah