Previo a conmemorarse ya 19 años sin Papá quiero poner esta canción que se la dedico y se la he dedicado siempre a mi padre que esta en el cielo, debe estar tocando guitarra con los angeles y por ahi se ha de haber topado a cualquier cantidad de musicos siempre en mi mente papa ...
To Stonewall711 Both Roger and David have said that Roger wrote the lyrics, and David wrote the riff. And Roger Can still play and sing, which David can too, but he is to tired.
Actually he did have a reason. This was for charity. I'd do it too if I where in his position to make a difference. I think he did a great job and certainly got into it. Just look at all the "body english" he puts into the playing. :)
rodger can perform most any pink floyd song he wants.seeing as how he did write most of them himself.dont forget gilmore came in after sid wasn't able to on any more.lets see just how smart you are.does any one knows what year did sid stop playing in the band??
@alphacause: no doubt gilmour is a better singer. However I'd say Waters did a quite epic version here making the best of what he had and producing a very demure and melodious version (the original is albeit unrivaled)
Don't try to be smart,when you can't even spell Syd right...It's a disgrace,he spent he's life trying not to be SID..He was forced to leave in 68 you know ;) . And also , too bad that such great voice as Roger Waters is gone..Dave Gilmour is still holding..R.I.P Rick. .. And no,Roger's voice isn't nothing..He,s just more like the psycho person...While Gilmour is full of music ;) .
It seems like there is a stone in Clapton's shoe. Lol. Great job Waters & Clapton...... and the the three ladies.
I never knew and imagined that Clapton and Waters sang TOGETHER! This is AMAZING :)
Santiago... you hit the nail on the head brother!
Great song. Never heard this version before
Love Clapton's leg movement, he can't keep still.. He is the true blues/rock God!
Clapton really adds a different approach, love it
Previo a conmemorarse ya 19 años sin Papá quiero poner esta canción que se la dedico y se la he dedicado siempre a mi padre que esta en el cielo, debe estar tocando guitarra con los angeles y por ahi se ha de haber topado a cualquier cantidad de musicos siempre en mi mente papa ...
legendss!
you´re great dear waters.but the voice of guilmour is the best for this beautiful song!!!!
To Stonewall711
Both Roger and David have said that Roger wrote the lyrics, and David wrote the riff.
And Roger Can still play and sing, which David can too, but he is to tired.
agree in general about waters' voice but think it kind of lends it to the mournful nature of this version for the tsunami victims.
Sonia, I love you my baby
@Anorag I'm not sure, i can't remember writing that
Actually he did have a reason. This was for charity. I'd do it too if I where in his position to make a difference. I think he did a great job and certainly got into it. Just look at all the "body english" he puts into the playing. :)
What's Matt Damen doing there?
rodger can perform most any pink floyd song he wants.seeing as how he did write most of them himself.dont forget gilmore came in after sid wasn't able to on any more.lets see just how smart you are.does any one knows what year did sid stop playing in the band??
Eric Clapton plays guitar in front of his bedroom mirror pretending he's David Gilmour.
@alphacause: no doubt gilmour is a better singer. However I'd say Waters did a quite epic version here making the best of what he had and producing a very demure and melodious version (the original is albeit unrivaled)
But it is a nice vercion craying babys
Who wrote most of the Floyd songs? Was it Gilmour? Is Floyd like Simon and Garfunkle, Gilmour is the genius while Waters is just the "voice"?
waters made the song...
i agree but Eric Clapton isn't the right person
Don't try to be smart,when you can't even spell Syd right...It's a disgrace,he spent he's life trying not to be SID..He was forced to leave in 68 you know ;) . And also , too bad that such great voice as Roger Waters is gone..Dave Gilmour is still holding..R.I.P Rick. .. And no,Roger's voice isn't nothing..He,s just more like the psycho person...While Gilmour is full of music ;) .
Hes not singing. He's talking!
rogers doesn't sing well any more :/.
Great song. Never heard this version before