i was SO excited when i finally got a mini size of pillow talk only to get home and try it and...concealer lips. concealer lips hell.😅
Celine concealer lips are obviously how light patchy and Asheee a light concealer which is usually what people use a lighter concealer than their complexion on your lips basically just ashy it doesn't comply non-compatible doesn't match useless
@@celinechien8598 oh its just the term most tan/dark people use when referring to a shade that looks good on lighter people so we try it and it ends up looking like we put concealer on our lips because of color theory and all that lol
tbh i really liked the deep pillow talk on you. darker skinned people have darker lips, so it looked very natural and juicy. the rare beauty one actually gave you a slight concealer lip in my opinion. but maybe i’m biased bc i prefer a deeper juicier nude in general
She liked Pillow Talk intense 3 as well, but it's not a nude. It's a berry color. I don't know anyone whose nude is berry. It should be more brown if they want to call it anyone's perfect nude. I think that's the point she's trying to make.
@@shireads2954 My nude is berry… Oddly enough. However I do see where you’re coming from.
@@No12559I think berry colors look more natural than “nude” lips. They look more like “my lips but better “
@@gigiuwu5642 Thank. You. Obviously some people will have nude coloured lips but majority of people I’ve seen has some berry colour or peachy colour.
Same!!! Chaaarlotte Tiiilbury can shut up with her "for all skin tones" bs! 😠
@@junkievideo it’s a valid complaint when their adverts claim that they’re perfect for all skin tones
@@junkievideo Respectfully, you don’t have the right to tell anyone not to complain about a product from a company that boasts about catering to all skin tones. Please stay in your lane. Thanks.
She's white that's why lmao. Her makeup n skincare is way over priced for the product you get. I Mean is different so that's my opinion bcuz I don't like her eyeshadow but her flawless filter is okay.
im glad someone is talking about this. the only thing that works on all skin tones is a clear gloss
Rare beauty shade wise lipstick is so pretty for dark skin girls
I don’t think it skin tone as much as pigmented lips. I’m light/medium & pillow talk is concealer lips on me. Tilbury nude romance works much better. It may be the peach/brown undertone that helps.
They have pillow talk in the shade medium, and it's perfect for more brown skin tones!
Girl, the pillow talk does look great on you! ✨️
There’s a medium shade too, I would love to see a video of you trying that one just to compare :)
thank you for saying something Charlotte made 3 to complement each skintone!
Just commented the same thing. Love Pillow Talk Medium. Pillow Talk Intense is more of a dark berry shade on me.
@@martinvainit’s so dumb when they buy the light one and expect it to word like istg just buy the dark one and use your common sense
@@sashawhyte7396 it's a different formula too. The Pillow Talk Medium is what she should have compared.
100% agree! I'm so tired of people hyping things up with the word "perfect" when it's far from it. 🙄
The CT pillow talk intense looks much better than the other lipstick. The rare beauty kinda washed out.
I think they both look lovely on you.
Maybe try pillowtalk medium?
That's what I was thinking! there's literally different shades for deeper skin tones 😂
It’s “universal” because that particular shade comes in 3 different tones for that reason.
she just tried the darkest one, so clearly those 3 versions are not enough for the universe
Eh, not really. The medium and deep versions came out years after the original pillow talk, which was advertised as the perfect nude for everyone since its inception. Which, by the way, as someone with a light/light-medium olive skin tone, I can say it absolutely does not work on me.
I wonder who CT meant with "everyone" every time I look at it lol
I felt like it kind of matched your natural lip color
They have pillow talk medium and deep.
Pillow Talk Intense is the deep shade you mentioned, which is what she used here. I still think she needs the Pillow Talk Medium, and I’m not sure why she hasn’t tried it, as that’s the nude shade in the range that is made for her!
@@janesays1278she didn't try it because she wanted to prove some point (which failed anyway).
Love love love Rare Beauty Wise. It's my go-to shade right now. ❤
There’s an in between!!!! You should try the 2!!!
I believe Pillow Talk has different version or levels. There's a darker one...
@@glows1701 But it's not always about how dark they are but the undertones.
@Penny Dela Cruz pillow talk intense is the darkest one. They have a light which is the original one and medium
@@pennyinheaven Yes, this is everything on how Pillow Talk, their Medium, and Intense show up differently on not just skin tones but undertones!
Edit: I have Pillow Talk Medium, but it washes me out a little since it’s a warm berry rose and I have cool undertones and pale pink lips
Oh my goodness, yes! Pillow Talk gives me concealer lips too. It’s such a relief to see someone else experience this too with all the hype around the shade.
Unless you’re hella pink I doubt it gives you concealer lips. It may not be a flattering shade on you, but this is not a good example of what concealer lips looks like. Concealer lips are not just extremely light, but flesh toned. Like you’re trying your erase your lips with concealer. That’s not what PT looks like on Monica and I can’t picture the type of person who has a skintone where that could happen here.
@@xqueenfrostineThat is not what concealer lips mean😂
Concealer lips mean ashy washed out ...as a colloquial term.
Not concealer as literally
Finally someone who understands my struggles with nude shades.
To be honest when she first tried that it didn’t look like concealer lips to me. I thought it looked really pretty on her.
Especially with a deeper liner, like it’s intended to be paired with, it would be perfect
Colour theory is so interesting, when I was very very tanned, lighter colours like pillow talk and Bi*ch perfect looked soo good on me, with or without liner.
I feeel. My undertones change throughout the year and I have to be mindful of the different saturations and colors I use in different seasons 😭
Generally I would agree, but the change in my skin tone obscures how some of my undertones are expressed. I'm mostly neutral througout the year except for a couple of months where I am much darker, and my skin veers warm. This checks out with the vein test (sometimes blue-green and purple, others just green) and the colors I use throughout the year. To give you a better idea within one shade range (Maybelline Fit Me! Matte + Poreless), one year I had 220 Natural Beige as my February shade, 245 Classic Beige as my May shade, and was 338 Spicy Brown by September. (I don't even go out a whole lot, that's just the tan I'll get from driving around in my car or maybe one day outside and it lasts for months 😭 and sometimes my forehead will be a perfect match for that warm dark shade but my neck will still be in winter 😅)
The trick with neutral skin like mine, is that even if I have a better chance at being able to rock any color I pick, i have to be super careful about what I pair it with. I also have to think about differences in saturation when choosing colors.
Pillow talk, Kim kw and Penelope pink are my favorites when I’m lighter!!
When I’m tan, bitch perfect is my all time favorite lipstick.
Nude Kate is nice but I’ve always felt like something about it is off.
I'm a pale white girl and I get concealer lips from it. Thank god I only got the sample but I have to mix it with something else or use a darker liner.
I thought you looked so beautiful with it on!
I'm light skinned and I've always hated pillowtalk. I'm really interested in this new shade!
You might love Bobbie Brown's Crush lip color in Italian Rose! It's described as a warm brown rose. I get so many compliments when I wear it! My skin I similar to yours
Intense all the wayyy! Don't put the liner with it and it's the PERFECT your lips but better! To me, the Rare was just a darker shade of concealer lips!
now I think we have the same skin talk since the sales person recommended me ‘pillowtalk intense’ when I asked for the classic pillowtalk shade. Also the rare beauty lipstick in wise is the best nude shade for me.
Yup rare beauty wise pencil my favv too.
RARE BEAUTY best makeup brand ever 🩷 I love love it’s my favorite.
I actually love the light pink on your skintone it's beautiful
I do think the pillow talk berry pink one is a pretty color if your going for a cute kind of pinky color but not necessarily a perfect nude like you said. But the last one you tried was very pretty with your skin tone !
I LOVE CT! The Kim K shade is my fav ❤
Rare beauty shade looks so beautiful on you. I never cared for CT makeup. So I’m loving these videos.
Same!! Been wanting to buy them for months and when I bought them. Felt like a concealer on my lips.
MAC is the OG in "perfect lip shades." I'm an NC 42 here - Persistence and Retro are my perfect nude shades, or like old youtubers used to call it - MLBB ;)
Final look was lit
Omg … 10000% right same it doesn’t give my lips any shade
I couldn't stop looking at how shiny and thick her hair is. So pretty and yeah her lips look amazing also.
Okay, the RB one was fire
That color looks so pretty on you. I don’t see concealer lips at all
The rate beauty was 👌🏽
The last one is fire!! Looks amazing!! Very snatched
When you said shimmer bejeweled by Taylor swift popped up in my head lol
THANK YOU FOR YOUR ALTERNATIVES ALWAYS
RARE BEAUTY is the best ♥️
I think all of the shades look nice on her - her “concealer lips” are a really lovely pink
I love how you always open a new world to me unlike the other beauty guru lol Ive been lied to my whole life til I met you
The rare beauty lipsticks are so soft and beautiful!
I’m going to try out this color from rare beauty. It looks beautiful
Whem you put on the rare beauty, I gasped. It looks so good on you!
Yessss, same with the lip liner, talented im so in love
I like Pillow Talk 2 on my Filipino morena skin.
I have your skin tone. Finally someone who can help me with my makeup. Thank you! I love your videos, so helpful!
I think videos like this is valid for poc since its spreading awareness for brands to be more diverse but at the same time spread hate against brands.
Lets be real for a sec cause no brand is one size fits all and they might try but will fail so instead of hating a brand that doesnt force you to buy their product let acknowledge that there are more options now in the market.its all depends on your need and preference.
Although I have very light skin. I have dark brown hair and darker eyes. I can’t wear lighter lip Color’s because they either look wrong or weird on me. The don’t blend in while a dramatic dark red lip looks seem less and amazing. I tried Pillow Talk once and although I have light skin it looked horrible and a bit like concealer not even a darker lipliner made a difference. I don’t know why but light Colors on create an effect of wrongness and it simply doesn’t suit me. Also I have like three shades to choose from while the same pink tone is sold fifty times with tiny variations???
That’s so interesting!!
I have super “bronze” skin. Especially during summer. My skintone is like a true golden bronze.
Summer time, I get way lighter but still very golden.
It’s the opposite with me. Nudes look best. I have to be very specific with my lip color options when choosing a bolder lip. Because most non nudes clash with the warmth of my skin.
I have very light skin with dark brown hair too and I feel the same. A lot of these "nude" shade I find too light on me, almost like pink toned or sometimes peach toned concealer. I find that I have better luck when I only go for shades that are darker than my natural lip color and just stay away from light shades.
Not her going straight for the darkest shade when there’s a medium shade that would be better for her
in my personal opinion the “intense”, without liner , one looks like a better nude than the rare beauty one, rare beauty gave concealer lips the most to me out of all 3
No LITERALLY!! idk sometimes i think she just shits on certain brands just because she feels like it. It’s kind of annoying to me idk.
@@breannamarie3214brands deserve it, they are not god just because they produce makeup. i promise you, they are not crying into their pillows over this. criticism is good for improvement
@@kermitthefrog5446the criticism isn't warranted here tho when Pillow Talk Medium literally exists & would have been a better comparison.
The rare beauty lipstick looks just like CT Pillowtalk medium. You should try that shade
I use it with yes Honey & it looks perfect
The CT intense looks better on you imo, at least from the lighting of that video. They have medium shade now for PT too
So basically my girl Rihanna is killing everybody in the makeup game 😂
I’m going to try the rare beauty color you mentioned. Charlotte Tillbury “medium” pillowtalk is so pretty
Charlotte Tilbury pillow talk medium is the perfect shade for brown skin tones.
Wow the rare beauty one looks amazing on her
Girl but tell me why it looks so pretty on u … ❤
Actually looks good in my opinion
Thank you for saying this! I’ve been having this problem.
Milani has similar lipstick colors.. for yearss
I honestly think matte formulas are the only nudes that I can apply solo, without a stain, liner, or topper balm/oil to adjust the color. I have a couple very fancy nudes with shine that should look great, but the shine messes with the color perception somehow. I also still have two Jordana matte lipsticks that look quite different in the tube, but look very similar on the face - I can swipe em on in 5 secs & it looks fantastic. sadly Jordana products did not wear long on me, but I like to use those mattes when I know I will be photo'd or video'd- the right nude matte on mature skin is so transforming - really helps de-emphasize lines & texture.
Pillow talk intense looks gorgeous on you!
Your natural lip color is gorgeous 💜
I think she needs to use a different word in this case bc that is not concealer lips - it is maybe a nude shade (for her skin tone). Concealer lips would have too much chalkiness and it is way too pink.
It looks good on you imo
Yassssss speak on it bestie, I got pillowtalk during the pandemic and was disappointed lol
I prefer the rare beauty finish way more, it’s a soft matte almost
I like the “intense” version, but you’re right, I don’t think it’s your perfect nude. It’s pretty. I ❤ A LOT of other lip combos w/different brands that you wear day to day better though. Including the Rare beauty one that you mentioned! Pillow talk didn’t work out well on me either.
Thanks for speaking on us brown gals behalf
am
i the only one who thinks it looked great on her
still velvet teddy for me i'm a fair yellowy with some brown filipino more on chinese looking person and the orig pillow talk, it IS concealer lips on me too... so i just go back to velvet teddy
Pillow Talk 2 medium lipstick and lip liner is my is my favourite❤
I loveee pillow talk medium
“Concealer lips” *flashbacks in early 2000’s, spider lashes and saying ‘That’s Hot.’ and ‘It’s T-Shirt Time!’*
I wear the pillow talk medium with the matching liner and I love it!!
I thought it looked amazing on you!!!🥰 both!!
The Pillow talk Intense 3 looked great on you.💋
Try Nars “pigalle” one of my favorites ❤
Oh hardly concealer lips. The Orig looks gorgeous on you! I WISH that’s how original Pillow Talk looks on me. On my skin tone for some reason looks ashen brown against my cool olive skin. I have to layer Pillow Talk with a coral lip gloss to make me look less like a zombie. I envy all the women who can make Pillow Talk work because I love the formulation. I had to give mine to my very fair-skinned sister. I think on you it was a lovely No-Makeup-Makeup pink.
I disagree. I have tried this lipstick,I’m the same tone like her, this lipstick gives a tan/ tan-deep person an unattractive muted pink tone on the lips. Yes, you can work with it by wearing a darker liner or gloss, but for the price of lipstick, it’s not worth the extra work. Especially, since there are so many other high end lipsticks that caters to POC.
if you want a really cheap alternative and happen to be in germany, get the alverde color and care lipstick in shade simply brown, i got it on a vacation there and its been my brown girl fave ever since, especially since it was like $2.50
tbh many ct products are overhyped
Honestly the only things that I’ve tried from CT and really liked is the liquid contour magic wand and the Pillow Talk mascara in Dream Pop.
I really need shorts make up on this genre for dark beauty girlies
could you try on ‘velvet teddy’ or any of the popular mac nudes? they’re touted as universal nudes, too
I love pillow talk and wore it on my wedding day and it lasted all day I’m olive skinned my mom who’s got paler skin tried it and it was a completely different shade on her. It was more dark and berry coloured on her against her skin but on me it was a perfect my lips but better dusky pink nude shade.
I'm fair with rosy neutral undertones, and pillow talk leaned orangey peach on me 😭 I was so sad!
Love the Intense version of PT on you, really wonder what PT Medium would work for you tjo
No one shade will ever look perfect on every different skin tone, any color COULD work if you make it work for you, like with a liner or gloss. It’s not a big deal. That’s why this shade comes in different variants, FOR different skin tones🙄 people just find the silliest things to complain about, if something doesn’t work for you then just use something that DOES. I don’t understand
The pillow tall looks so good on you
I love Pillowtalk Medium
it's impossible for one shade to be the perfect nude for everybody
that’s the point she’s extremely famous and is popular , and she can’t even do color theory ? Poc people also want to try products do yk it’s so annoying poc can’t even have the access to same colors ? She should try better because woc wants to try shades that reveal similar to white women
This. Pillow talk is so dark on me. But light on this girl.
@@itsmina3841 Pillow talk actually has 3 or 4 different shades though that are darker than the original. This girl wears one of them in the vid. So I do give them credit for coming up with different shades.
It doesn’t work for me either, only „Very Victoria“ does it for me
@@gigiblack2231these brands are rich 🤑 they have employees on every level. They shouldn’t get credit for having a shade range which should be expected. It’s their job. They should only get credit for doing their job well. They are not doing it well. They would be richer and more successful if they actually cared about people having a match. If most people have a match, most people can buy it. It also shows who their target audience is if they get all the shades right unless u have melanin