Yamaha FG5 VS Yamaha FG9

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 104

  • @pacificgreen9690
    @pacificgreen9690 9 місяців тому +10

    I ordered an FG9M after playing one. I played it against an LL36 and loved them both, but they were very different. The FG9 just had everything for me - warmth, volume, resonance, and responsiveness. Thanks for sharing!

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  9 місяців тому +2

      Hope you really enjoy it when it arrives it's a super instrument brother 😀

    • @stevebernard221
      @stevebernard221 8 місяців тому +1

      I think for my preferences would go with the LL36. But, I did enjoy the FG9 Mahogany when I played it.

    • @jmsamborski
      @jmsamborski 6 місяців тому +2

      Having both the LL36 and FG9M, the FG is probably more immediately impressive because it's louder and has more clarity. The LL36 is sweeter sounding and sometimes is just more of a joy to play. Get the LL36 next time, totally worth having both.

    • @pacificgreen9690
      @pacificgreen9690 6 місяців тому

      @@jmsamborski Yeah, I actually bought one not long after I made this comment! I can't decide which one I like better. I have several great guitars, but these two are getting all of my playing time lately. Happy playing!

    • @joshuafernandes4935
      @joshuafernandes4935 4 місяці тому +1

      I cannot decide between the LL36 and FG9 as I can only order them online without checking it in store . Can anyone help with why one one is better than the other ? Which one sounds better ?

  • @DavidJosephBoth
    @DavidJosephBoth 4 місяці тому +2

    one sounds vintage, and one modern boutique style dread. both sounds great

  • @nikolasnehmer1101
    @nikolasnehmer1101 9 місяців тому +2

    Thanks for the comparison. The FG9M is a big step up tone wise. I hope there will be a FS9 as well soon. Have you also tried the rosewood version? According to other videos there is only a small difference between the mahogany and rosewood versions.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  9 місяців тому +1

      Hey brother, I have not tried the rosewood version but I'm sure it's awesome! I love mahogany . Yamaha are releasing the fs9s this year so keep an eye out it's only a matter of time that's from a good source!! Hope this helps brother, thanks for the comment really helps the video get a few views 🙏 if I can help with anything else please ask 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪

    • @kamarienedwards1757
      @kamarienedwards1757 6 місяців тому

      FS9 JUST CAME OUT!!!

    • @Joe-m6p6b
      @Joe-m6p6b 3 місяці тому

      @@kamarienedwards1757 and? Did you order one?

  • @Joe-m6p6b
    @Joe-m6p6b 3 місяці тому +1

    May I recommend you a recent video from Banjo Ben Clarke for guitar technique, especially for the right hand?

  • @thisjaredrussell
    @thisjaredrussell 4 місяці тому

    Great vid, cheers. Really good sound too with that 57 👌

  • @erikjakobsson5128
    @erikjakobsson5128 Місяць тому

    Just sold my FG5 last month in order to purchase the new FG9, could not be happier with it and wouldn’t trade it for the world. At the same time cannot stress enough how nice of a guitar the fg5 is, especially for the price. Such a warm sounding guitar, it really does sound vintage. Was surprised Yamaha never used a Torrified top on the FG9 and would love to know how it would sound. If I had to pick one I’d still choose my FG9 all day long as I find it’s more versatile. Thanks for the video, was the exact comparison I was looking for when I came time to make my decision, cheers.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  Місяць тому

      @@erikjakobsson5128 Yep I agree no doubt the FG5 is a stunning guitar but the FG9 is something special ! Enjoy your FG9 👌

  • @robert-wr6md
    @robert-wr6md 4 місяці тому

    Yes thanks. Very different and it's easy to see why you have both.

  • @theapplepaul
    @theapplepaul Місяць тому

    They both sound amazing. They have their own sound, very different from Martin, Gibson, Guild, etc. At that quality level, which is high in the FG5 let alone the FG9 it just comes down to personal preference. The sound is full and robust. Should be even better once broken in. I have a owned a D18 back in the day- apples and oranges. Not on quality mind you, just sound profile.
    Certainly these are worthy of consideration. Enjoyed your playing!

  • @bongocuba
    @bongocuba 5 місяців тому +2

    Own an FGX5, love it. Not sure if or when I’d be able to spring for the $$ of an FG9 though.

    • @Joe-m6p6b
      @Joe-m6p6b 4 місяці тому +1

      Relax and enjoy which great sounding Instrument you already have. Tame your mind and your GAS!🤔✍️🚔🙏🎸🎸🎸

  • @sospel65
    @sospel65 8 місяців тому +5

    Hi Gavin. Thanks for the demo. The FG9 sounds absolutely fantastic! The FG5 sounds great too, in a more subdued way. As a singer, I would probably get the latter, which, I think, would complement my voice. The FG9 seems to be what I call a guitarist’s guitar, i.e., great for bluegrass and instrumental music, but a little intimidating for someone who enjoys singing ballads and fingerpicking. Does that make any sense to you?

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  8 місяців тому +1

      Its a great choice for a singer songwriter, great for strumming chords alot of power behind you and it's incredibly dynamic highly recommended the FG9 brother

    • @jmsamborski
      @jmsamborski 6 місяців тому

      I would also say the FG9 is actually great for finger style. Its dynamic range is ridiculous, especially for an Adi top. It can be played whisper quite. Because of the above, I’m actually forgoing picking up the FS9 I planned on gettting. The FG9 just does everything exceptionally well.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  6 місяців тому

      @@jmsamborski I was looking at the FS9s and they sure do look impressive but I would agree with you I think the FG9 ticks the boxes they are really really good

  • @shogi6790
    @shogi6790 8 місяців тому +2

    Thanks for the nice video. Great choice, I love both of your guitars. As a owner of 2 Yamaha FS3s, I really wish Yamaha would release FS9M with 25inchs scale length. As a singer, I really like the scale length of Red label FG/FS for finger-picking and light strumming!

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  8 місяців тому +1

      The FS9 will most certainly be out this year keep an eye out brother

    • @shogi6790
      @shogi6790 6 місяців тому +1

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 Wow, you were right! FS9s are out!

    • @jmsamborski
      @jmsamborski 6 місяців тому

      yeah, but its not the red label scale length. It's 25.9 like the FG9.

    • @shogi6790
      @shogi6790 5 місяців тому

      @@jmsamborski FS9 has 25" just like Red label. It seems to be a great one for me! My wallet says no, right now, and I am still very happy with my FS3.

    • @jmsamborski
      @jmsamborski 5 місяців тому

      @@shogi6790 You're right, the FS9 is 25. I stand corrected.

  • @Joe-m6p6b
    @Joe-m6p6b 3 місяці тому

    Hi, did you ever check for dead spots on the fingerboards of your dreads and on what frets did you find them?
    Cheers.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  3 місяці тому

      @@Joe-m6p6b hi Joe my guitar tech always checks the frets on my guitars when he is doing a set up

    • @Joe-m6p6b
      @Joe-m6p6b 3 місяці тому

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 do you know what dead spots are?

  • @arranatkinson8348
    @arranatkinson8348 7 місяців тому

    Enjoyed the comparison, such beautiful sounding guitars. I was set on a D-18 too but after tons of research i've just bit the bullet and ordered a FG9M! Only thing that I'm anxious about is that everywhere I'm reading that they recommend only using the light strings on them, have you been sticking to this or got any experience putting mediums on it? Cheers!

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  7 місяців тому +1

      I play 12s but honestly I don't buy into it being an issue! The most important thing is to get the guitar set up to your own strings , once you do that it shouldn't be an issue brother

    • @jmsamborski
      @jmsamborski 6 місяців тому

      I have the FG9M and have played D’Addario phosphor bronze strings my whole life. It comes with 80/20 Elixirs which I thought I hated, but man they work with the FG9. Might actually keep running the strings it comes with myself.

    • @arranatkinson8348
      @arranatkinson8348 6 місяців тому

      @@jmsamborski Yeah, same! Haven't been able to put the FG9 down since it came, what a guitar! I also have also used those strings forever and in mediums, but i don't think i'll even bother going up to mediums on the FG9 either. I've bought a pack of D'Addario XS phosphor bronze lights to try when (if ever) these 80/20 Elixirs die, but will be very happy to continue with the 80/20 Elixirs forever if the XS's dont float my boat!

  • @anthonykelly5
    @anthonykelly5 6 місяців тому

    Sound class did you buy in ireland.that sound hole looks larger .

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  6 місяців тому

      Thanks bro both were baught on line . Standard sound hole not modified or anything

  • @josejcastaneda5826
    @josejcastaneda5826 7 місяців тому +1

    The deep tone of the fg9 is unbelievable!

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  7 місяців тому +1

      She's a keeper 😁

    • @Joe-m6p6b
      @Joe-m6p6b 4 місяці тому

      Yes, but they are more clearly an with more definition and articiulation sounding guitars. They do not have the Martin vintage oomph with the" built in loudness button" ✍️ for more upper bass warnth.

  • @karlmartin849
    @karlmartin849 4 місяці тому

    Did you purchase it from Promusica?

  • @RadarsRadicalRides
    @RadarsRadicalRides 4 місяці тому

    I can't seem to find the difference online! An FG5 seems a lot lower priced than an FG5r/FG5m - but they all seem solids so why the price difference?

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  4 місяці тому

      @@RadarsRadicalRides do you mean FG9r/FG9M? Both the FG5 and FG9 are all solid but with the FG9 your getting Adirondack spruce top and a bolt on neck plus the over all construction of the guitar is higher quality

    • @RadarsRadicalRides
      @RadarsRadicalRides 4 місяці тому

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 I think I've got myself all confused there! It seems to be a £2000 difference between the 5 and the 9 which threw me. I have a hummingbird which TBH I've never got on with that well, and I actually prefer playing my old FG750S. So I'm juggling between the D-18 of something like the FG9m. Any thoughts? I suppose that the Martin would make a better 'heirloom' to my daughter but I won't make that the driving force if the Yam plays and sounds better.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  4 місяці тому

      @@RadarsRadicalRides My opinion on that is the FG9M is far superior to a standard Martin d18 , I would even prefer the FG5 to a standard d18 but that's just me . Although the FG9 is expensive but it really does hang with guitars worth 8 or 9 thousand euros, they are built to last aswel

    • @RadarsRadicalRides
      @RadarsRadicalRides 4 місяці тому

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 I can easily believe you! There's a reason that I have Yamaha instruments and motorcycles! And I'll be honest with you I haven't been that impressed with either my Gibson or HD ;-)

  • @Gixxer340
    @Gixxer340 9 місяців тому +1

    Dream guitar!!

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  9 місяців тому

      What one would you prefer?

    • @Gixxer340
      @Gixxer340 8 місяців тому +1

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 The FG9. I have the FG5 and I think the 9 is my next guitar. I need to decide between the M and the R. Hard to find them to play. Just need to save and practice. :)

  • @richardstones6445
    @richardstones6445 6 місяців тому

    I have an FG5. It is the only “big” guitar I own. I absolutely love it, but I’m more of a small body guitar player, preferably with short scale to help my old fingers a little. I am planning to buy an FS9-R after I’ve saved a few more pennies.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  6 місяців тому +1

      @@richardstones6445 the FS9 sound incredible, I am more of a dread guy but I wouldn't mind picking one up sometime 😀

  • @randysrhythm
    @randysrhythm 7 місяців тому +1

    So that’s the FG9, eh? Okay Gavin, if I can find one used at a good price, I’ll see what it does. Very beautiful sound, brother man 👍🏻

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  7 місяців тому +1

      Thanks a mill Randy love your channel! Nice to have you on here , I am a big Yamaha head as you can probably tell 🤣 also have a sweet j45 IBG Indonesian model cracking guitar that

  • @dylan3058
    @dylan3058 6 місяців тому

    Hey mate, got a fg5 ordered, just wondering what pick up you installed?
    Thanks

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  6 місяців тому +1

      Hey dude I use the LR Baggs anthem it's my favourite pickup, the LR Baggs hi fi pickup also looks great but I have not tried it yet

    • @dylan3058
      @dylan3058 6 місяців тому

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401
      Cheers Gavin, did you install ?
      Pretty easy ?
      I sold my Martin d10 for the fg5, I hope Iv made the right decision lol

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  6 місяців тому +1

      @@dylan3058 I had my guitar tech drill out the endpin and hole for piezo under the saddle then I installed the pickup, with the hi fi you would only need to drill out the endpin it's very straightforward to install. Really think you will be happy with the FG5 brother they are awesome

    • @dylan3058
      @dylan3058 6 місяців тому

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 nice one man.

  • @stevebernard221
    @stevebernard221 4 місяці тому +1

    Yes sir, the FG9's are nice. A good buy for sure.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  4 місяці тому +2

      @@stevebernard221 can't go wrong with Yamaha Steve I have a few they are really good guitars

    • @stevebernard221
      @stevebernard221 4 місяці тому +1

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 yes, they certainly are...one of my favorite brands.

  • @mrx-b3i
    @mrx-b3i 7 місяців тому

    thank you for posting i love these yamaha,s i own a LL400

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  7 місяців тому

      Your very welcome, me too Yamaha really are just awesome 👍👍

  • @christopherhawthorne5395
    @christopherhawthorne5395 7 місяців тому

    Can’t speak to the FG9 but I own the FS5 and love it. I got to guitar center a couple times since and the only guitar I ever found that I liked better was the FG5. I’m looking at getting the FG5 now and possibly a ll36 or ll26 for something in rosewood

  • @Wobbz9413
    @Wobbz9413 7 місяців тому +1

    I just could not justify the outlay for an FG9. not enough of a player. But its my dream guitar.

  • @1025257
    @1025257 6 місяців тому

    Weird but my FG5 doesn't look like yours. Different rosette and pick guard .

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  6 місяців тому +1

      It's a stranded FG5 but I removed the fake ebony pickguard because it was noisy with a pick , it's just a sticker but underneath is a stranded plastic pickguard. You will need to remove the glue once you peel it back it took quite a bit of elbow grease

  • @Joe-m6p6b
    @Joe-m6p6b 4 місяці тому

    I think they made a design mistake with the pure maple center stripe.
    For this amount of money they should have used the same japanese rope patterned stripe design from the top binding.
    Just for the beauty and as well for a consistent corporate design art to mark IT as there speciality and identity design mark.

  • @GShockWatchFan.
    @GShockWatchFan. 3 місяці тому

    Wonder what Taylor 814 CE sounds like V FG9. FG9 sounds great V FG5

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  3 місяці тому

      @@GShockWatchFan. I think the FG9 will hold its own against pretty much anything

  • @Joe-m6p6b
    @Joe-m6p6b 4 місяці тому

    I bought a FG-9 R.... Great guitar.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  4 місяці тому +1

      @@Joe-m6p6b sweet Joe 🤘

    • @Joe-m6p6b
      @Joe-m6p6b 4 місяці тому

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 Did yours come with 13th....?

  • @DB-jf6fm
    @DB-jf6fm 7 місяців тому

    I too bought a FG5 over a D18. While the lower price was nice, it was not a factor in my decision. The FG5 just had a nicer tone than the D18 and it also played better - I really don't like the Martin modified low oval necks. If Yamaha would make a FG9 with the ARE treatment coupled with the look of the FG5, I would buy it in a heartbeat. Not a fan of the FG9 fret markers...they're classy and nice, but just not for me.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  7 місяців тому +1

      Yeah I totally get you , the FG5 looks vintage and is a cracking guitar I won't be parting with mine it's a quality instrument. That said the FG9 is a level above and it would want to be for the money, it's not cheap by any means . That Adirondack top really puts some power behind it aswel . Its basically like an FG5 on steroids

  • @TheGuitarSpaSingapore
    @TheGuitarSpaSingapore 2 місяці тому

    FG9
    sounds cleaner and clearer

  • @Joe-m6p6b
    @Joe-m6p6b 4 місяці тому

    Wild Wood flower...🎸✍️🙏

  • @77guitarts22
    @77guitarts22 2 місяці тому

    Sounds fabulous! Both sound great. I love my Yamaha LL-TA sound, seems better than all other guitars I've tried, and it's like 1 k new, you can't beat that... Well, in fact if you want an Adirondack Top and Rosewood B&S, check out my Recording Kings videos on my channel... You might be surprised... Astonishing value around 600 Euros and sounds like 3 k...

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  2 місяці тому

      @@77guitarts22 I have been tempted to buy a recording king several times they do sound incredible and for half nothing! Some great guitars out there now it's hard choose

  • @gregt4202
    @gregt4202 6 місяців тому

    I've owned an FG5 for a couple of years. I guess based on this review, I'll stop looking for an upgrade to the FG9. I like the sound projection from the 9 but the 5 has all of the tone qualities I look for. The FG9 seems to me to be a bluegrass instrument. I'm more 60's folk.

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  6 місяців тому

      FG5 is sweet mellow tone to my ears and the FG9M is just a power house , both cracking guitars brother I think the FG9 will open up and get sweeter in time tho

  • @Joe-m6p6b
    @Joe-m6p6b 4 місяці тому +1

    FG-9 Videos: Martin Vs. Yamaha?!: Comparing the Famous Martin HD-28 and the Stunning Yamaha FG9R! ua-cam.com/video/MuEFXZaxvoY/v-deo.html
    #02 J.P. Cormier talks about the Yamaha FG9 Rosewood at Guitar Haus ua-cam.com/video/oIc3FVeHttU/v-deo.html
    Yamaha FG9R review vs martin d41 ua-cam.com/video/WP-y7e20qY8/v-deo.html
    Yamaha FG9 M & FG9 R - Quick test ua-cam.com/video/iD9kUAENu3s/v-deo.html
    Yamaha's Best Guitar: Yamaha FG9 M | Specs and Samples Acoustic Tone Demos ua-cam.com/video/Hw_8SJ6TIaM/v-deo.html
    Yamaha FG9M | The High Standard of Yamaha's Japan-Made Acoustics ua-cam.com/video/Nmaf8cmIwQw/v-deo.html
    Yamaha | FG9 | Jordan Tice & Jake Eddy Perform Duet “Roll on Buddy” ua-cam.com/video/0L_xbiv_wFs/v-deo.html
    Yamaha | FG9 Tone Development Story ua-cam.com/video/gMlv7KXi2WY/v-deo.html
    Yamaha | FG9 R | Rosewood Sound Sample Demo ua-cam.com/video/Dn2LOyrwZ2A/v-deo.html
    Sweetwater Demo:
    ua-cam.com/video/Fa5jKM9FVJE/v-deo.html
    Shocking Blind Test - Yamaha FG9 Rosewood VS Mahogany | Which One Is Best? ua-cam.com/video/UHOER9LMW6k/v-deo.html
    Banjo Ben's General Store Test Drive : The Yamaha FG9 Rosewood! Exclusive Look! www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDI
    Yamaha | FG9 R | Rosewood Sound Sample Demo ua-cam.com/video/MNXlk9NIyscm/v-deo.htmlLLC1WDg
    Bluegrass Cover With The Yamaha FG9: "John Hardy" ua-cam.com/video/70uOWEbckyk/v-deo.html
    Bluegrass Cover With The Yamaha FG9: "John Hardy" ua-cam.com/video/70uOWEbckyk/v-deo.html
    Yamaha FG9 で弾く ”Blackberry Blossom” | 西海孝 & 齊藤ジョニー ua-cam.com/video/xHCttZIXtJk/v-deo.html
    Extreme expensive Yamaha guitar FG9R vs LL56 ua-cam.com/video/PSkxe_kRsP8/v-deo.html
    New Gear: The Yamaha FG9 R Delivers Distinct and Complex Tones | Acoustic Guitar ua-cam.com/video/st7ZLebOi5c/v-deo.html
    Guter Artikel:
    New Gear: The Yamaha FG9 R Delivers Distinct and Complex Tones | Acoustic Guitar ua-cam.com/video/st7ZLebOi5c/v-deo.html acousticguitar.com/review-yamaha-fg9/

  • @gibsonj45hu
    @gibsonj45hu 2 місяці тому

    FG9 is better with indian rosewood back but twice price sorry

    • @gavincarrollmusic7401
      @gavincarrollmusic7401  2 місяці тому

      ​@@gibsonj45hu Don't be sorry it's just a matter of opinion! I like the FG9M that's why I bought it! Same price here in Ireland 👍

    • @gibsonj45hu
      @gibsonj45hu 2 місяці тому

      @@gavincarrollmusic7401 FG5 same price is in Irland the FG9M ( mahagoni back ) ? You are a lucky man !