Silent Hunter 3 Battles: HMS Duke of York Versus IJN Hyuga

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 85

  • @BOORAGG
    @BOORAGG 10 років тому +5

    Hyuga would have its hands full with USS California.

  • @thatoldmilkcarton7029
    @thatoldmilkcarton7029 10 років тому +4

    Damn, why does every Japanese ship look so epic when it sinks? I love it... ;D

    • @buster9692
      @buster9692 9 років тому +1

      A Japanese's ship speciality: looking sexy to the sea bed

  • @alexius23
    @alexius23 9 років тому

    When battleship "turn turtle" the turrets would fall off. Held in place by gravity.

  • @Angelr031
    @Angelr031 9 років тому

    Love how the anime Arpeggio of Blue Steel is based on ships like Hyuga and Kongo, and even uses the ship class titles for character names

    • @huskythedinosaur1592
      @huskythedinosaur1592 8 років тому

      Your Mom Says Ikr, The Humans could've realised that they are WW2 ships... And then just use WW2 weapons against them Fleet of Fog

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому

      Except these "World War 2" ships have energy shields, laser cannons and homing missiles, not to mention a big ass death star gun.

    • @huskythedinosaur1592
      @huskythedinosaur1592 8 років тому

      still_guns Still why can't they use WW2 guns?

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому

      Husky The Dinosaur "Energy shields". They could send battleship Iowa against them, and still have less effective than lobbing a hand grenade at them.

  • @Katerocks5000
    @Katerocks5000 10 років тому

    notice how right as the hyung appears onscreen the 5.25" are hitting her that is a bad sign for her duke is already pounding her

    • @seth_fed
      @seth_fed 10 років тому

      Yeah, first scene, BOOM, rounds pound em'

  • @thesovietunion6640
    @thesovietunion6640 4 роки тому

    Or as I call it: Hyuga, pillar class battleship

  • @Liamflynnphoto
    @Liamflynnphoto 10 років тому

    King George the v class were some of the most modern after the Iowa class

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  9 років тому

      +Fnaf sucks Fite me u furries You obviously don't understand that term of speech

  • @Exilninja
    @Exilninja 8 років тому

    As soon as the battle begins, the 5.25ers are putting the Hyuga to work......looks badass in-game but they wouldn't be causing a tremendous amount of damage..........

  • @gunner-pm7jh
    @gunner-pm7jh 8 років тому

    damn where this guy finds this songs? some of them makes us cry....

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому

      Did you want the metal version of My Heart Will Go On instead?

    • @gunner-pm7jh
      @gunner-pm7jh 8 років тому

      no hard officer

  • @vrefjyn
    @vrefjyn 8 років тому

    Forgot to tell you but the end part is from Arpeggio Of Blue Steel Ars Nova Ep.Desprete Escape

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому

      +Kyle Kam Yoo don't need to leave multiple comments, just leave one and add to it with the edit function.
      Also, I'm not stupid, I already knew the ending audio was from Blue Steel, why do you think I included it?

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому

      Kyle Kam And I was was supposed to know that, how?
      YOU don't need to tell people. They can ask, I'll answer, you don't need to bring that upon yourself

    • @vrefjyn
      @vrefjyn 8 років тому

      +BMWM3GTRLOVER Ah Ok Have A Good Afternoon! Love your sh vids by the way :)

  • @SpecCrazy
    @SpecCrazy 7 років тому

    If you cut text 0:07 - 0:14 out. It will be come more epic!

  • @ronadamiec3006
    @ronadamiec3006 10 років тому +2

    The English battle wagon would of been blasted out the water by the Yamoto. The KGV class was under guned compared to others of its day. She also had main gun problems that plagued the hole class.

    • @adamtruong1759
      @adamtruong1759 3 роки тому

      The guns themselves work just fine, it was the quad turret mountings that were the issue, the dual mountings were fine too. Also, 356mm guns aren't small by any means.

  • @theroyalpickle8322
    @theroyalpickle8322 8 років тому

    and what is the music called at the time when hyuga sinks)

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому

      It's in the credits, jesus, you people never look do you?
      Thomas Bergerson - Remember Me

  • @Katerocks5000
    @Katerocks5000 10 років тому

    i would say that hyung souldn't be here wasn't she being turned into a aircraft carrier

    • @thatoldmilkcarton7029
      @thatoldmilkcarton7029 10 років тому

      She was refit as a Half carrier- Half BB, with 8 of her guns and a flight deck at the back.

  • @vrefjyn
    @vrefjyn 8 років тому

    I'm rooting for both ships

  • @gunner-pm7jh
    @gunner-pm7jh 8 років тому

    like the pipe organ at start ;)

  • @animalhero641
    @animalhero641 7 років тому +1

    Havent watched yet but I predict British.

    • @animalhero641
      @animalhero641 7 років тому

      Yup. Also, nice cinematography dude!

  • @jakinoff7147
    @jakinoff7147 8 років тому

    What is the conning tower?

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому

      +Jose Eduardo Ortañez Superstructure, the bit where the bridge is

    • @jakinoff7147
      @jakinoff7147 8 років тому

      +still_guns Ok thanks

  • @mrakodrap7816
    @mrakodrap7816 8 років тому +1

    i thought Ise was BBV

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому +1

      Only from 1943 onwards, she spent most of her life as a true battleship

    • @mrakodrap7816
      @mrakodrap7816 8 років тому

      still_guns ah thx

    • @Musashi_460
      @Musashi_460 8 років тому

      Her AA was a lot better than it was when she was a BB though

    • @mrakodrap7816
      @mrakodrap7816 8 років тому

      Dog Fighter72 and still got sunk by planes

    • @Musashi_460
      @Musashi_460 8 років тому

      That is true, but her AA was better than what it was when it was a BB, although it would have been better for her to stay as a BB maybe

  • @SuperDjbrutus
    @SuperDjbrutus 8 років тому

    lovely

  • @Musashi_460
    @Musashi_460 8 років тому

    Of course the Duke of York, she was better than the Hyuga in everything

    • @Ryan-gq9lr
      @Ryan-gq9lr 6 років тому +1

      Dog Fighter72 was the duke of York half aircraft carrier? Hyuuga was

    • @adamtruong1759
      @adamtruong1759 3 роки тому

      @@Ryan-gq9lr How's that going to change matters?

  • @theroyalpickle8322
    @theroyalpickle8322 8 років тому

    what is RoF

  • @Trades46
    @Trades46 10 років тому

    ...that Ars Nova ending was intentional wasn't it?

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  10 років тому

      Yeas... OMG, someone who watched the full video who isn't me!

    • @Trades46
      @Trades46 10 років тому

      BMWM3GTRLOVER
      Next time, you might have as well put Kantai Collection lines in for the lolz.

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  10 років тому

      heh ok

    • @northernKaizer
      @northernKaizer 9 років тому

      BMWM3GTRLOVER i would have preferred the 1930s rebuild of the hyuga with the aircraft on-board However it would have to be available i imagine

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  9 років тому

      Of course, you mean the 1943 rebuild. That took away four guns and would have made this match-up unbalanced.

  • @fastygo5639
    @fastygo5639 4 роки тому +1

    Why japan always lose!?

  • @DisSabot
    @DisSabot 9 років тому

    Lion vs Nagato

    • @DisSabot
      @DisSabot 9 років тому

      Or Yamato

    • @adamtruong1759
      @adamtruong1759 3 роки тому

      @Communist space bears Now that's not true, the 10 second reload, anyway.

  • @vonmazur1
    @vonmazur1 10 років тому

    There is a big time defect with this program.....All of the simulations are lacking in one thing...guess??

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  10 років тому

      Oomph?

    • @vonmazur1
      @vonmazur1 10 років тому

      That too, the main guns firing is somewhat lacking, in addition, on a ship to ship battle, like shown in these lame simulations, the main guns would be firing as fast as possible. It is unlikely that the secondary guns would be fired at a battleship except in desperation. It is very unrealistic at long range in any case...

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  10 років тому

      That is something annoying. The ships can't shoot at each-other beyond about 6kms. But the guns are firing about every 30-40 seconds

    • @waggerification
      @waggerification 10 років тому

      the battle and the sinking are not very realistic.

    • @vonmazur1
      @vonmazur1 10 років тому

      Yes among other things.....

  • @ToonandBBfan
    @ToonandBBfan 10 років тому

    The Duke would murder Hyuga

    • @i_nameless_i-jgsdf
      @i_nameless_i-jgsdf 3 роки тому

      HAHAHAHAHA no

    • @adamtruong1759
      @adamtruong1759 3 роки тому

      @@i_nameless_i-jgsdf Yeah, Duke of York was in no real danger of losing that battle.

  • @ijnamagiri
    @ijnamagiri 6 років тому

    動画としては良くできているが、日本人としては良い評価は付けられません!

  • @brendancrummey5723
    @brendancrummey5723 10 років тому

    Hms BARNHAM vs the Italian battleship Andrea Doria

  • @peterw4319
    @peterw4319 Рік тому

    What a complete load of nonsense. This never happened.

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  Рік тому

      Guys! Sherlock over here just pointed out the bleeding obvious!

  • @pierrebouillon9403
    @pierrebouillon9403 8 років тому

    Who gonna win ? Of Course the Duke of York , the programmeur of this show is british !!
    What will be the outcome if the programmeur to be japenese ??
    Totally biased . Prefer to have somebody ( programmeur ) to be spanish or portuguese , they will study on the specific power of each battleship , & this would be a better show !!
    Silent hunter .... full of CRAPPER !!

    • @still_guns
      @still_guns  8 років тому +2

      -_-
      Mate, I didn't skew the results. Check the results of West Virginia vs Nagato. Nagato won! In both videos I did on that! Valiant vs Roma. Roma won! Iowa vs Yamato. YAMATO won. I am biased in those videos as well? Not to mention the historical fact that the KGV class battleship was superior to the Ise class in every regard (better guns, thicker armour, faster, more range, better fire control etc.).
      I shit you not. I put these ships into a battle, and this is what happened. I only fiddle with the ships if they are broken, such as buggy secondary guns thinking they're main calibre, or if the ship has FAR too many hitpoints (such as 5000. The norm is 900). Would you prefer it if the Duke of york was fighting a one-sided battle against a ship with 5000 hitpoints and 25 main calibre guns? Yes, much fairer isn't it, to leave a poorly balanced ship, poorly balanced, just so the British ship doesn't win. Pffft.
      You're seeing things that aren't there. And the sad thing is, I reckon you aren't going to believe me, for some reason.