ohyiu there are some that disappointed and hating it specially those non fans and antis but i really appreciate and love this stage.. we all know that they haven't get a decent rest and the days that they not seen on public they might still working .. but they still gave us a live stage with their live voices only was a blessing for me.
pretty much all the mbc performances were fully live, i actually loved it and appreciated all the real live voices. Regardless of whether some find it hard to sing while dancing. I just prefer to hear their actual voices, like damn I’m not expecting full perfection.
Who can blame Yeri for still being sad? I can't. And massive thumbs up to her for still standing on stage and trying to smile the best she can give. I admire her strength.
agree! i mean we all knew SHINee but i wasnt a SHAWOL, i cried a lot for Jonghyun, just imagine all the pain he was suffering and no one knew... no, we cant imagine... they were all friends we know how close all the SM artist are, so his death was as shoking as unespected... but she, as the rest of the people close to him are trying their best to move on ,so dont be unfair with them if they dont look as bright as they used to be, lets keep him in our hearts and thoughts thats the best way i know to remember an amazing being like Kim Jonghyun. Stay Strong SHAWOLS!
For whoever that critics them for not being stable, *for me* I prefer them singing live with unstable voice than perfect stage but lip sync. Flawless more beautiful than perfectionist but fake.
I think so too....when you did live singing you have to divide your energy to stabilize your singing and to dance....looking at how they’re not that energetic in dancing prove that they sings live and it feels more real to me😍👍
ntzkyh 95. Their voices sounded tired cause they are usually more stable especially Wendy. At one point it looked like she was about to fall over. Red Velvet fighting.
I prefer this over pre-recorded any day! Sure their voices are a little shaky but with the combination of the choreo and the fact that they have been promoting a lot their voices are still pretty impressive!
Irene give that cute and innocent look with that bangs Seulgi give that edgy and fierce look with that hairstyle. I still think her look is the best during this era. I mean,, no one can rock that cleopatra hair just like seulgi did. Joy still will be a sexy queen. And that ponytail slayed. Wendy gives a feminine and charismatic office girl in the outfit. She looks so pretty. Yeri give that cool aura look lol. I love her . And did she intentionally wears that glove?? Cause she rocked it. Also, why does she look like a leader?? lol 😂
FINALLY SM LET YOU GIRLS sang live without backup vocals I'M SO PROUD to hear that you're still eating your CDs, THE RED VELVET I KNOW. now I can leave 2017 in peace.
hohou namla thank you so much for reminding me. Yes i never doubted sm vocals but these people here dare to say horrible things to this beautiful performance without thinking further that it might affect them in every ways possible just hurts. And i guess some people are just way too used to listening lipsync performance thinking that it's great and thought otherwise to live when it shakes a little.
Sddre bom então o que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que ❤❤❤❤❤❤é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💍🎤🥾🎶🎶🎶💍🎵👖👖💌💔💔💔💜💜💜💔
Fffd bom então o que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💜💍💍🎶🎶👕👕👕👖❣❣😍😍😘💓💓
Remember last year when rv was stuck outside in the cold in dresses and were freezing to death? Yeah thank you for putting our girls inside this year..
y'all really out here bashing wendy for not being stable or comparing her to other members but????? she's a MAIN vocal and does waaaaay more high notes as compared to the rest. give her a break dang it's not that easy carrying a high note while having such a choreo don't come for my woman p.s. if you watch reaction videos or fancams of this performance she doesn't sound like this so bEFORE YALL COME FOR HER
bloopbloop and what's keeping us pissed was that one part wendy messed a little while other parts she's doing exactly like the studio ver. and they dare to say stuff? Fight me
Right. They've basically been promoting red flavor and peek a boo since July and havent stopped since then. Of course preforming with a mixture of high notes from both songs for MONTHS on end will wear her voice out. I really hope she rests because her voice and range is so amazing, I don't want her to lose that. The fact she even tried to hit them despite her condition is great.
For girlgroups you can hear mostly boy fanchants but for red velvet it's mostly girls omg girl crushes😫😂 and they slayed altough they should've performed more songs AND I'M STILL WAITING FOR A LOOK PERFORMANCE!!!
You’re Average Twice Fan well, if they can sing live, why dont they do so on must music shows? I wld want to appreciate their vocals, but i only hv few vds of they performing live.. and this performance is 👌👌, but i want more of their vocals, i want them to show their true vocals on stage and admire their talents instead of doing lip sync..
You can tell red velvet has alot of fangirls omg one of the benefits they got from fangirls is the loyalty they are such a talented and versatile group definitely my second favorite next to Girls’ Generation.
yeah you can tell that she is trying so hard even with her flu 😭😭 she is so hardworking and talented! especially with all of their performances and schedules recently im still surprised that she can sing as well as she did 💗💗
Yeri please stay strong, we are here for you and we will fight the haters for you❤ Also Irene, Seulgi, Wendy and Joy we love you, because you girls are amazing
For people who said that their voice is bad, it is because they're not in good condition. You can listen their live perform at other event and they are good. I sing peek a boo while dance in karaoke but just one sentences already make me tired though I used to dance and sing. Dumb dumb, rookie, and peek a boo are the most difficult to singing while dancing in Red Velvet list. You should try it yourselves before talking.
Don't get triggered, we know they have the best main vocal, as well the other girls never fail to amaze. I think most of the ReveLuvs are worryied (sorry, don't know how to write that word lol)
I'm not trying to hate or anything, but we don't have to be a farmer to tell if an apple is rotten or not. Their voices were in bad condition. They're tired and exhausted, making this sort of sound bad. It's not that bad, though. It's impressive, but not the best.
Ok but Wendy wasn't good in this era, I think her voice was more powerful and strog back then. I read that the continous diets can couse vocal problems, I mean in the vocal chords, bulimia also cause that problems.
Even through its almost 3 year old video, I can't help watching this performance all over again. This summarize that Red Velvet are ARTISTS. The way they literally sing it live, the way that they miss some notes, that's what make an ARTISTS, ARTISTS. They aren't scared to crack nor miss a note, they're confidently singing and dancing. The professionalism is 100%. Stan real talent.
I replayed this video so many times for the perfect velvet live vocals. And for Yeri’s visuals with this hair. A true goddess. And Irene looks absolutely gorgeous with the new bangs.
*THE SHORTEST YET THE LIFE OF THE PARTY PERFORMANCE. THEY SANG STABLE AND DANCE PERFECTLY WITH THAT HARD CHOREO! AND YES ONCE AGAIN RED VELVET DID THAT WITH THEIR OUTSTANDING LIVE PERFORMANCE. HOPE 2018 WILL BRING RV AND REVELUVS MORE LUCK AND HAPPINESS! I'D LOVE TO SEE WE GROW STRONGER THIS YEAR
Just like first commenter said, Wendy sounded really exhausted... Like It's clear that It's not about her being bad but just being tired or sick. I hope the girls are fine...
To be honest, this time they're not performance as well as before, since many things happened in 2017's Dec... But we still support red velvet but not blindly to say they did perfect in every performance, cause they're also human ~
I bet you guys said that only bc of her high notes part where she was a bit shaky without even considering her other parts where she delivered exactly like the studio version. Gosh
Everyone know that Red Velvet can sing, duh. Haters just get jelly all the time they keep trying to find some cracks on Red Velvet but it never happened tho.
yes, they sound different and there are many possible causes. This may not be their best performance but on the bright side, they werent using much on background vocals-they were singing live while dancing. We gotta applaud for them. With so many schedules and events coming to them lately, of course they wouldnt be in bad shape. Lets all not hate on them for things we should have expected from them and just congratulate them for their hard work. All groups did a great job for balancing their schedules together. All groups have at least their bad days so lets not look into the small things. They might be tired or they might be sick. There are many things so we cant just assume by it. I just want to say i am proud of red velvet still
PREACH. I get exhausted dancing to Peek A Boo and I'm not singing at all. I can mouth the words but my organs would kill me if I tried to use my breath for anything else.
Wendy sounded under the weather, if that is the case, hope she gets better soon. On a side note, Seulgi looks amazing with that outfit and that hair style suits her so well *o*
I really admire them for continuing to sing live during that period of time. It wasn't easy to perform and sing live like this especially when you had emotional turmoil. I knew RV always can sing live (sketchbook performances are legit perfect), and they could have just made it with the backup track for this, but they didn't. I'm really feeling sad for them to have to go through that period of time, but at the same time, I feel happy that they are staying strong to continue what they were doing. It wasn't easy, but they have made it.
![RED VELVET Special / 레드벨벳 스페셜 [2017 KBS Song Festival | 2017 KBS 가요대축제 / 2017.12.29]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/i1QEZH1sbFE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2017 MAMA in Hong Kong] Red Velvet/NCT 127&Hitchhiker_Peek-A-Boo + Red Flavor + $10](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/l0tV9L9wjJc/mqdefault.jpg)
*JOY IN PONYTAIL IS MY END*
joy never fails to amaze me so pretty!
Ponitale sooo prettyyy🍏💚
she looks so fresh😍😍😍
Wendy deserves the world
but the world does not deserve Wendy
she is too good for us. bless her.
Robb Wilson literally.. bless the goddess Wendy
We really don't deserve her. Bless her pure heart for still staying 💖
are they singing completely live?? i can't hear any backtrack!! queens!!!
ohyiu yes its live with no backtrack 😊😊
ohyiu there are some that disappointed and hating it specially those non fans and antis but i really appreciate and love this stage.. we all know that they haven't get a decent rest and the days that they not seen on public they might still working .. but they still gave us a live stage with their live voices only was a blessing for me.
They are singing completely live! It’s so good!!!
pretty much all the mbc performances were fully live, i actually loved it and appreciated all the real live voices.
Regardless of whether some find it hard to sing while dancing. I just prefer to hear their actual voices, like damn I’m not expecting full perfection.
No hate but They sang bad😓only fans can accept it. But they are forever the best even they sang bad because they come from SM
Who can blame Yeri for still being sad? I can't. And massive thumbs up to her for still standing on stage and trying to smile the best she can give. I admire her strength.
K - Pop - K What? Why?
Because of jh’s dead
Honestly, it still effects me and I didn’t know him personally. I can’t imagine how her or others who were super close to him feel.
agree! i mean we all knew SHINee but i wasnt a SHAWOL, i cried a lot for Jonghyun, just imagine all the pain he was suffering and no one knew... no, we cant imagine... they were all friends we know how close all the SM artist are, so his death was as shoking as unespected... but she, as the rest of the people close to him are trying their best to move on ,so dont be unfair with them if they dont look as bright as they used to be, lets keep him in our hearts and thoughts thats the best way i know to remember an amazing being like Kim Jonghyun. Stay Strong SHAWOLS!
But Why?
Seulgi slayed. Joy slayed. Yeri slayed. Irene slayed. Wendy slayed. They all slayed and their gonna slay in 2018 too
thanks your comment made my day :) happy new year
you’re goddam rightt ❣️
*they’re (:
Am i the only one who is attracted to the Holy Wendy with that outfit and that hair?
I mean...the stylist did a good job today
The Violet SHE LOOK SO EFFIN GORGEOUS
Bruh you are not the only one, the dark purple hair SUITS SO HER SO MUCH
i agree with you
shes so beautiful
Yes you are the only one
For whoever that critics them for not being stable, *for me* I prefer them singing live with unstable voice than perfect stage but lip sync. Flawless more beautiful than perfectionist but fake.
ntzkyh 95 plus their choreo is tiring too, it must be hard trying to sing and dance at the same time
I think so too....when you did live singing you have to divide your energy to stabilize your singing and to dance....looking at how they’re not that energetic in dancing prove that they sings live and it feels more real to me😍👍
ntzkyh 95. Their voices sounded tired cause they are usually more stable especially Wendy. At one point it looked like she was about to fall over. Red Velvet fighting.
This is what I'm talking about 😍
I prefer this over pre-recorded any day! Sure their voices are a little shaky but with the combination of the choreo and the fact that they have been promoting a lot their voices are still pretty impressive!
Thought my house was shaking but i realized it was just Red Velvet slaying again.
sipping on holy water best comment👍
sipping on holy water This comment deserve more like
you're doing something else thats *MAKING THE HOUSE SHAKE*
@@jasoniskewl49 sis im-
@@jasoniskewl49 I-
Am I the only one who loves when girl groups wear outfits like this with the knee high boots? You get to appreciate their thighs and I live for that
lol celia yes i do, I'M a Reveluv And a Moomoo And both groups used high over the knee boots, I'M in heaven :'3
AyAReI00 SAME
Specially when it's Joy or Hwasa
BFjordsman wheein’s also deserve an honorable mention
lol celia that they most definitely do
I can imagine *Suho* dancing to this at the backstage
X2 yeeees hahah
Of course...he have to maintain the pride of reveulve president 😂
Of course! Suho is Red Velvet's 6th member 😩
Sneha Salvatore 1st thing that came into my mind when I watched this 😂
The rest of the groups are on the side of the stage lmao
연말무대는 이처럼 타가수들이 주위에서 관람하고 같이 호응해주는게 보기좋은데 앞으론 이럴수 없으니 아쉽다
코로나 끝나서 ㄱㅊ을 듯
Joy is so pretty and her vocals are so stable.
It's fucking live and they nailed it.
Shai Valcorza ????
Visual Irene on the thumbnail😍🔥
Bbang Deokki beautyful🙆🙆
I really love Joy and Seulgi 😍😍😍😍
And Irene also..!!
All members
joy my lovee 💚
와 초반에 루키 인트로 나올 때 소름;;
루키-빨간맛-피카부가 한 해에 나온 노래라니 컨셉깡패다
Irene give that cute and innocent look with that bangs
Seulgi give that edgy and fierce look with that hairstyle. I still think her look is the best during this era. I mean,, no one can rock that cleopatra hair just like seulgi did.
Joy still will be a sexy queen. And that ponytail slayed.
Wendy gives a feminine and charismatic office girl in the outfit. She looks so pretty.
Yeri give that cool aura look lol. I love her . And did she intentionally wears that glove?? Cause she rocked it. Also, why does she look like a leader?? lol 😂
The Violet i think she wore that gloves at SBS and KBS too. That black gloves.
The Violet yeri really looks good wearing that gloves 💜
She looks like a girl gang leader and I love it tbh
I think she she wears it since Jonghyun incident.. as her symbol of mourning..
I agree
WENDY WITH THIS MAHOGANY/ PURPLE HAIR OML IM DEAD
분위기가 공주님들 오셨으니까 다들 봐. 이느낌..
Irene~💖
Seulgi~💛
Wendy ~💙
Joy~💚
Yeri~💜
*RED VELVET SLAYY* ❤😍😍
Jonh * joy
💙💙💙💙
FINALLY SM LET YOU GIRLS sang live without backup vocals I'M SO PROUD to hear that you're still eating your CDs, THE RED VELVET I KNOW. now I can leave 2017 in peace.
hohou namla thank you so much for reminding me. Yes i never doubted sm vocals but these people here dare to say horrible things to this beautiful performance without thinking further that it might affect them in every ways possible just hurts. And i guess some people are just way too used to listening lipsync performance thinking that it's great and thought otherwise to live when it shakes a little.
They already did in their 3rd week of promotion in music bank i guess
Those girls doing the fanchant. Thank you.
진짜 노래랑 스타일링 황금기였다 4년 흘렀는데 짧을지라 하더라도 저 사이 가수들 중에서 가장 세련됐음 얘네만 올해 찍은 무대 같아 ㅋㅋ
Sddre bom então o que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que ❤❤❤❤❤❤é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💍🎤🥾🎶🎶🎶💍🎵👖👖💌💔💔💔💜💜💜💔
Fffd bom então o que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de um homem que é a vida de ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💜💍💍🎶🎶👕👕👕👖❣❣😍😍😘💓💓
Joy is so perfect, omg I love that girl so badly 💕😍 and she looks so hot
I really like the deep red/brown/burgundy hair on Wendy. It totally suits her!
impossichannel its purple
Live voice
Red velvet daebak
The only group that went actually live.
some say they're still live today
chim chim bitch bts don’t sing in live, mamamoo of course and red velvet sometimes
ua-cam.com/video/tNtcYIo6N04/v-deo.html
They sang live at the amas
Eka Asti You should listen to wjsn it's 100 % live
Rookie intro: "And we're live..."
And then they really went 100% live! Iconic queens of taking intros literally 👑 That's Red Velvet for you! ❤💛💙💚💜
joy is really beautiful in her hair..
THE FANCHANT THANK U K-LUVIES
seulgi is so pretty and her vocal is so stable omg
YERI WITH BLONDE BOB CUT IS HOT
JOY'S VOICE IS SO LIT
Seulgi's live never failed to amaze me even when they're all so tired from their promotion
Seulrenity they sound so tired. I feel sorry for them.
especially Wendy... I feel like her Vocal chords have been strained much and she isn't really hitting teh notes completely or they shame shaky? :/
Both mentally and physically drained tbh. I think they really took it hard after Jonghyun’s tragedy.
Ikr! She is the best in this
Seulrenity Thats the reason I like her. Seulgi always gave her 200% whenever she performs. 💛
irene’s bangs has once again left me shaking
Joyieeee you're so pretty with that ponytail 💕 i love you
Joy slayed my life especially her ponytail
SeulGi is gorgeous, omg
Remember last year when rv was stuck outside in the cold in dresses and were freezing to death? Yeah thank you for putting our girls inside this year..
Seulgi and Joy slayed. 😻❤️
joy is looking sooo beautiful
Omg Irene, her bangs is everything I'm in love
wendy is the goddess of goddesses
I just realized that the sweet voice squad lmao (Yeri and Joy) have the most stable voices.
Joy is so stable 😍
y'all really out here bashing wendy for not being stable or comparing her to other members but????? she's a MAIN vocal and does waaaaay more high notes as compared to the rest. give her a break dang it's not that easy carrying a high note while having such a choreo don't come for my woman
p.s. if you watch reaction videos or fancams of this performance she doesn't sound like this so bEFORE YALL COME FOR HER
bloopbloop and what's keeping us pissed was that one part wendy messed a little while other parts she's doing exactly like the studio ver. and they dare to say stuff? Fight me
yes omgjdkfjd she really sounded so good for the other parts people are always coming for her istg
Right. They've basically been promoting red flavor and peek a boo since July and havent stopped since then. Of course preforming with a mixture of high notes from both songs for MONTHS on end will wear her voice out. I really hope she rests because her voice and range is so amazing, I don't want her to lose that. The fact she even tried to hit them despite her condition is great.
Actually this even better than lip sync group right 😂😂😂
Nera Fadriyn no reason for you to say that
Seulgi baby your voice so stable.☺️☺️
아진짜ㅡㅡ 한글댓글좀 보고싶다. 외국인들이 케이팝 좋아해주는건 기분좋은일인데 댓글창 외국말로 도배된거보면 힘빠짐
김땅콩 1 어떻해X 어떡해..
I very love yeri's out fit 😍
*JOYYYYY DESTROY ME ALREADY*
😂😂😂😂😂
me 2
😌❤️❤️
Same 💗
IRENES BANGS ARE LIVING FOR ANOTHER DAY SLAYYYY
Joy in that ponytail is 😍😍❤️💓💗
For girlgroups you can hear mostly boy fanchants but for red velvet it's mostly girls omg girl crushes😫😂 and they slayed altough they should've performed more songs AND I'M STILL WAITING FOR A LOOK PERFORMANCE!!!
proud for them, but i see they are so tired, rest well rv, and comeback in 2018 againn with amazing comeback....
Gimas Bijaksana twice lagi penat
blvckvelvet Leave.
You’re Average Twice Fan but they dont do live in most music shows #TrueFact ☺
You’re Average Twice Fan well, if they can sing live, why dont they do so on must music shows? I wld want to appreciate their vocals, but i only hv few vds of they performing live.. and this performance is 👌👌, but i want more of their vocals, i want them to show their true vocals on stage and admire their talents instead of doing lip sync..
So I guess they are never in condition because they never sing live ;/
Yeris blonde hair looks so good on her
Omg JOY nailed it♥️♥️
Seuljoy is very pretty with her black dress and her black hair....I love you Seuljoy
KIM YERIM 😍😍 WHY SO PRETTY?!💜
FINALLY YERI IS NOT USING EXTENTION ANYMORE❤
You can tell red velvet has alot of fangirls omg one of the benefits they got from fangirls is the loyalty they are such a talented and versatile group definitely my second favorite next to Girls’ Generation.
joy why so pretty😍
I dont know..!!
joy looks so pretty with her hair ponytailed 😍💖
omg give Wendy a break you haters, she has a flu which is 100% apparent here
She sounds just like me when im sick
Can't believe people are talking about her. Like Wendy has always been known to have amazing vocals even before debut. She still slay
yeah you can tell that she is trying so hard even with her flu 😭😭 she is so hardworking and talented! especially with all of their performances and schedules recently im still surprised that she can sing as well as she did 💗💗
When seulgi part came out and the girls screaming
Kang's They have a thing for a certain bear 🐻 😍😍
Red velvet!!!!
Hot Irene hot seulgi hot Wendy hot joy hot yeri!!!!
Yeri please stay strong, we are here for you and we will fight the haters for you❤
Also Irene, Seulgi, Wendy and Joy we love you, because you girls are amazing
For people who said that their voice is bad, it is because they're not in good condition. You can listen their live perform at other event and they are good. I sing peek a boo while dance in karaoke but just one sentences already make me tired though I used to dance and sing. Dumb dumb, rookie, and peek a boo are the most difficult to singing while dancing in Red Velvet list. You should try it yourselves before talking.
Don't get triggered, we know they have the best main vocal, as well the other girls never fail to amaze. I think most of the ReveLuvs are worryied (sorry, don't know how to write that word lol)
I think their voice is bad
KPOP FOREVER and we think your life is bad but we don’t say anything
I'm not trying to hate or anything, but we don't have to be a farmer to tell if an apple is rotten or not.
Their voices were in bad condition. They're tired and exhausted, making this sort of sound bad. It's not that bad, though. It's impressive, but not the best.
Ok but Wendy wasn't good in this era, I think her voice was more powerful and strog back then. I read that the continous diets can couse vocal problems, I mean in the vocal chords, bulimia also cause that problems.
Kang Seulgi, you are so fine.
Even through its almost 3 year old video, I can't help watching this performance all over again. This summarize that Red Velvet are ARTISTS.
The way they literally sing it live, the way that they miss some notes, that's what make an ARTISTS, ARTISTS.
They aren't scared to crack nor miss a note, they're confidently singing and dancing. The professionalism is 100%.
Stan real talent.
I replayed this video so many times for the perfect velvet live vocals. And for Yeri’s visuals with this hair. A true goddess. And Irene looks absolutely gorgeous with the new bangs.
omg Yeri back to short hair 😍
BISH YERI CHANGING HAIRSTYLES AND COLOR EVERY LIVE PERF I DONT UNDERSTAND
Matty she wears extensions
i know but cant her hair stylist calm down like girl we all know it suits her but let me take each style in before switching huhu
I like joy red velvet
Yeri is a Queen. FIGHT ME!!!
*THE SHORTEST YET THE LIFE OF THE PARTY PERFORMANCE. THEY SANG STABLE AND DANCE PERFECTLY WITH THAT HARD CHOREO! AND YES ONCE AGAIN RED VELVET DID THAT WITH THEIR OUTSTANDING LIVE PERFORMANCE. HOPE 2018 WILL BRING RV AND REVELUVS MORE LUCK AND HAPPINESS! I'D LOVE TO SEE WE GROW STRONGER THIS YEAR
joy never fails to amaze me im sorry but our wendy's voice seemed weak. I hope SM let them rest.
Just like first commenter said, Wendy sounded really exhausted... Like It's clear that It's not about her being bad but just being tired or sick. I hope the girls are fine...
To be honest, this time they're not performance as well as before, since many things happened in 2017's Dec...
But we still support red velvet but not blindly to say they did perfect in every performance, cause they're also human ~
I bet you guys said that only bc of her high notes part where she was a bit shaky without even considering her other parts where she delivered exactly like the studio version. Gosh
BABE, THEY ATE THEIR CDS
Everyone know that Red Velvet can sing, duh. Haters just get jelly all the time they keep trying to find some cracks on Red Velvet but it never happened tho.
Seulgi always looks so amazing as usually
Seulgi's amazing vocals and we can hear it live, plus her awesome dance moves. 😍
WENDY SO PRETTY
omg those fanchants 😭
i hope red velvet will have an even better year in 2018, with more luvies joining our fandom!
JOY SLAYED AS ALWAYS! Red Velvet JJANG! 💓💓
yeri so pretty!!
yes, they sound different and there are many possible causes. This may not be their best performance but on the bright side, they werent using much on background vocals-they were singing live while dancing. We gotta applaud for them. With so many schedules and events coming to them lately, of course they wouldnt be in bad shape. Lets all not hate on them for things we should have expected from them and just congratulate them for their hard work. All groups did a great job for balancing their schedules together. All groups have at least their bad days so lets not look into the small things. They might be tired or they might be sick. There are many things so we cant just assume by it. I just want to say i am proud of red velvet still
they always sing live so thats usual
Yassh!! Setuju
PREACH. I get exhausted dancing to Peek A Boo and I'm not singing at all. I can mouth the words but my organs would kill me if I tried to use my breath for anything else.
But they were singing live and sounded awesome
I thought it was just me. They sound really tired in this performance.
wendy's voice is straining. :((((( stay healthy, wannie and my babies!!
Probably strained her voice from performing few days ago
It could be her vocal nodules? I don’t know :((
Joy 💙
My queen Joy
Wendy sounded under the weather, if that is the case, hope she gets better soon. On a side note, Seulgi looks amazing with that outfit and that hair style suits her so well *o*
Siknah yeah she was sick and still sang beautifully, I couldn’t see a difference❤️🧡💛💚
Red Velvet, you girls worked hard in 2017. You all did great.
Here is to hoping for a succesfull 2018 for Red Velvet!
Wtf?! Joy is looking good in those ponytail
개 예뻐 진짜 예뻐 배주현
개 예뻐 진짜 예뻐 손승완
개 예뻐 진짜 예뻐 강슬기
개 예뻐 진짜 예뻐 박수영
개 예뻐 진짜 예뻐 김예림
Seulgi is killing me with that look ahh 😭❤️❤️
Joy good job!!!
i’m so proud of yeri for being so strong during this time
I really admire them for continuing to sing live during that period of time. It wasn't easy to perform and sing live like this especially when you had emotional turmoil. I knew RV always can sing live (sketchbook performances are legit perfect), and they could have just made it with the backup track for this, but they didn't.
I'm really feeling sad for them to have to go through that period of time, but at the same time, I feel happy that they are staying strong to continue what they were doing. It wasn't easy, but they have made it.
they looks tired rest well babies rv did so good in 2017 i am so proud of them
Yeris Hair and perfectness❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
JOY ❤️
Peekaboo was definitely the maknae line's era
Yeri looked so pretty
THE FANCHANTS OMG 😭
yeri eating CD's
Periodt.
wbk stable queen
@@moonlightbae7015 aaAaaaaAaaaAaaaAaaaaaaaaaAaaAaaAaaaaaaaAaaaaaaaaaaaaQaaaaaaAAAAAaaaAaaaAaaAaaaaaAaaaAAaaaaAaaaAAAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaAaAaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaAaaaaAaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaAaaawaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawaaawaaaaaa2aaaaaaaaawaaaaaaaasaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawAaaaaaaaaawaaaaaAaaakwswwww2wwwwwswwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww22wsswwwwww
존나 예쁘다 누가 덜예쁘고 더예쁘고 할 것 없이 걍 다섯명이 다 조오오오옹ㄴㄴ나ㅏㄴ 예쁨