20:03 I feel like Eraser'd be the one to go here, Because he's friends with Blocky who kept popping Bubble before and after both his eliminations. But that's just my opinion, Good what-if man 👍💜
4:32 the rivalry was pretty random so this would be a nice setup 5:35 also why *_did_* he make final 6? All he did was barf and “mmhmph!” If he talked more in the series, he would probably be more popular on tpot.
25:23 Considering how many votes Teardrop got, I feel like Teardrop would rejoin instead due to making it so much further and having interactions with Eraser
Eh, in Another Name's first elimination of otl rocky got the most votes, even more than GB the 'mean' one of the bunch. He probably got most of his fans during the merge
This was a really good what if! I feel like pen and eraser would've gotten out earlier (I don't even hate them they are some of my favoeite characters) but I feel in this timeline they would make it to bfdia! you should make a part 2
Why the hell does spongy always get screwed over in these, he is actually very loved in bfdi, when rejoining he never got many voters and was always near the fan favorites like leafy, icy, firey and bubble in votes always being next safe. When getting out to leafy it wasn’t even by that much either.
I think it’s mainly because of the fact that the viewers now hate Spongy so much despite only doing one thing, so it may have changed their view of Spongy and made him seem less popular than he was. Which is probably also why TD usually does well in these, because she’s now such a fan fav, unlike in Bfdi where she had no personality besides not being able to talk, which made her not as favorable compared to the others.
@@kirbster-4 Most times the reason why TD does so well is because of her not HAVING any personality like she's better than someone who only barfs (also i like spongy)
@@Beefydiefan2763plus4 i can already see some changes (she would probably ask a different question to ice cube before the events of the show and ice cube would still say no to whatever it is even though lollipop was looking for a yes, but instead of raging and kicking ice cube away, she was more annoyed and disappointed)
My opinion Pencil survives over Flower I mean Rocky was pretty disliked around then always being bottom 3 and pencil just has the no votes thing which....isn't here anymore. I mean she was a bit aggressive but I still say pencil survives by 20-30 votes as some people voted Rocky out of sheer hate and not to save flower which pencil had less of.
2:47 I think coiny would go because firey and the alliance are popular and those few popular contestants targeting coiny would result in coiny’s demise
Exactly, people always have Match more hated than what she actually was. She received 1 vote in all of the Cherry’s elimination which probably means the same person voted her all 4 times. She got less votes than Eraser in BFDI 6.
Oh hey, my thing from if the finalists didn’t exist video made it into the next what-if. I hope that remark didn't insult you at all, I wasn’t meaning to be insulting. I just wanted to point out how Pencil progressed, sorry if I sounded mean.
Spongy isn’t that hated tho.. He normally would get like around twice as many votes as the fan favorites and would be safe after them. People would vote pen for cheating and he is more hated than spongy anyway
Bfdi 12 is unrealistic sorry but even if coiny and firey aren’t literally trying to slap each other coiny still gets out by 15 votes ngl gb voters prob save tb and so do Firey voters
Brown Kenneth Williams Elizabeth Walker Barbara
wow such beautiful words!
so bkwewb. nice object show!
Alternate Title: What If Eraser was Really Popular in Season 1?
Fr tho
@@Rbpen2763yes
20:03 I feel like Eraser'd be the one to go here, Because he's friends with Blocky who kept popping Bubble before and after both his eliminations. But that's just my opinion, Good what-if man 👍💜
4:32 the rivalry was pretty random so this would be a nice setup
5:35 also why *_did_* he make final 6? All he did was barf and “mmhmph!” If he talked more in the series, he would probably be more popular on tpot.
the first half of the video is just consistent tennis ball abuse XD
13:10 good job. the uoovee team is happy cause of your decision
Good thing someone here watches them too
spongy is my 2nd fav contestant, glad to see someone who also likes him finally
I love the idea of Eraser making it a lot farther in the season.
Same
Same
“Hey, this eliminated button didn’t work”
@@EpicUniqueWill9”Eraser you dumb f*ck why would you try to press that”
@@EpicUniqueWill9 lol
You found a great way to make Teardrop and Eraser interesting, I kinda wish they did that in the origibal show
25:23
Considering how many votes Teardrop got, I feel like Teardrop would rejoin instead due to making it so much further and having interactions with Eraser
I hate how everyone says rocky would get out but then forgets this is season 1 and all the kids are watching this, not adults with common sense.
Eh, in Another Name's first elimination of otl rocky got the most votes, even more than GB the 'mean' one of the bunch. He probably got most of his fans during the merge
poopoo mayonnaise
-a gem that eats gumdrops
poopy*
ahh ok whatever, same thing.
me when ruby's only eaten it once
This was a really good what if! I feel like pen and eraser would've gotten out earlier (I don't even hate them they are some of my favoeite characters) but I feel in this timeline they would make it to bfdia! you should make a part 2
Why the hell does spongy always get screwed over in these, he is actually very loved in bfdi, when rejoining he never got many voters and was always near the fan favorites like leafy, icy, firey and bubble in votes always being next safe. When getting out to leafy it wasn’t even by that much either.
I think it’s mainly because of the fact that the viewers now hate Spongy so much despite only doing one thing, so it may have changed their view of Spongy and made him seem less popular than he was. Which is probably also why TD usually does well in these, because she’s now such a fan fav, unlike in Bfdi where she had no personality besides not being able to talk, which made her not as favorable compared to the others.
@@kirbster-4 tbf tho, td wasn’t too hated I’d see around a 8th place finish seem normal to her or her getting out by contestants
@@kirbster-4 Most times the reason why TD does so well is because of her not HAVING any personality like she's better than someone who only barfs (also i like spongy)
and bias dont get me wrong
@@Abdullah-mon tru
request:BFDI: what if the teams merged in bfdi 14?
Do "What if BFDI had BFDIA rules where you could switch teams before a challenge?"
This is absolutely awesome! Could i make a what if like this, ill credit you!
sure go ahead i dont care
insert windows 95 reference here
in terms of final ranks, flower hasn't moved nowhere when compared to canon
@@gengar-1997 probably not what you’re thinking but
NO RULES
Revolve can you make a Bfdia continuation of this pretty please?
i have an idea (what if lollipop and flower swapped seasons so flower made her debut in season 4 and lollipop was there since season 1)
Yea, and lolli would be nicer so she would survive over bossy bot.
@@Beefydiefan2763plus4 i can already see some changes (she would probably ask a different question to ice cube before the events of the show and ice cube would still say no to whatever it is even though lollipop was looking for a yes, but instead of raging and kicking ice cube away, she was more annoyed and disappointed)
@@Beefydiefan2763plus4GB U MEAN NOT BOSSY U
@TonyTheTigerGT bruh thats just a nickname we're talking about the first season here
@@Beefydiefan2763plus4no kidding Sherlock
Icy consistently got less votes than even the finalists, I don’t think these predictions that have her out early are accurate
My opinion Pencil survives over Flower I mean Rocky was pretty disliked around then always being bottom 3 and pencil just has the no votes thing which....isn't here anymore. I mean she was a bit aggressive but I still say pencil survives by 20-30 votes as some people voted Rocky out of sheer hate and not to save flower which pencil had less of.
bro wdym flower just rejoined
@@kyleplayz8777 well pencil is way less disliked than rocky, and was the most popular to a stretch before the no vote thing
@@RedmarkerTpot yes, true, but why would people vote someone back in but then eliminate them right away
@@kyleplayz8777 but also: Spongy and Loser in bfb. nobody cared that they were rejoinders and got out as soon as possible
@@RedmarkerTpot yes but thats because the voters didnt vote them in they rejoined unfairly
id probably enjoy watching bfdia with this new elim order aswell
2:47 I think coiny would go because firey and the alliance are popular and those few popular contestants targeting coiny would result in coiny’s demise
Exactly, people always have Match more hated than what she actually was. She received 1 vote in all of the Cherry’s elimination which probably means the same person voted her all 4 times. She got less votes than Eraser in BFDI 6.
@@PixeledPuffballexactly
Coiny survived so many bottom twos, he’s the BFDI version of Golf Ball
GB was only in the bottom 2 like twice and then got eliminated
@@ElloBoi712 name at least 3 times where she wasn’t in at least the bottom 3 when UFE. Shouldn’t be hard.
@@baileybhamjee8080 there were only two times. between her and Flower and then against her and Rocky and lost aginast rocky
@@baileybhamjee8080 Plus Rocky has been in the bottom 2 way more than Golf Ball (Season 1)
@@ElloBoi712 I’m talking about BFDIA.
It looks like Needle is gossiping with Match.
thats true
How about what if there was no teams
4:17 TpOt RefErEnCe!!! 1! 1! 11
Honestly, just a lil nitpick, but I feel like pen nd eraser are better friends, so they would pair up in bfdi 12 instead, but great vid!
Tbh I don't blame you for eliminating Ice Cube over Spongy
I do because it doesn’t make sense at all.
Idea: if firey and coiny are friends
I didnt like Eraser much in season 1, but if his rivalry with TD started back then, Id definitely like him more
Oh hey, my thing from if the finalists didn’t exist video made it into the next what-if. I hope that remark didn't insult you at all, I wasn’t meaning to be insulting. I just wanted to point out how Pencil progressed, sorry if I sounded mean.
It's fine lol
@@RevolvingFate oki good
Assemble eraser fans
Eraser he he was liked !!! Really anyways indeed poor match (respect)
get Blueberrie’d
Spongy isn’t that hated tho..
He normally would get like around twice as many votes as the fan favorites and would be safe after them. People would vote pen for cheating and he is more hated than spongy anyway
pen didnt cheat in this timeline. he didnt even do the taco challenge..
"Spongy isn't that hated" bfb 14: r u sure about that?
@@IHATEPINSOMUCHit takes place in bfdi so he didn’t do that down fall in bfb
@@IHATEPINSOMUCHthis takes place in the first season
@@IHATEPINSOMUCH That was like way after BFDI.
Bfdi 12 is unrealistic sorry but even if coiny and firey aren’t literally trying to slap each other coiny still gets out by 15 votes ngl gb voters prob save tb and so do Firey voters
25:33 that elimination is so inaccurate
What How?