I think New Dance choreographer was Sienna Lalau. Also, the reason XG didn’t debut in Japan js they wanted to promote globally and the J-pop music industry is more focused domestically. The Korean music shows and promotions are more easily reached by a global audience
I think there are two points of view that XG is really trying to capture and sell in terms of concepts visually and musically. One is the "alien/extraterrestrial" concept and storyline which runs through all of their MVs since shooting star for sure. The other is musically they are really committed to a very early 2000s/late 90s rnb vibe like TLC/Aaliyah. I'm in my mid 30s so I love that because it really hits a nostalgic place for me and I think it's a very underrepresented musical inspiration. They do a lot of camera angles that really capture that nostalgia as well. Left and Right literally felt like an updated MV from 1997 and I was obsessed lol.
it's good to see that neither of you have taken criticisms personally. i think the main reason you have gotten any at all is because of your fixation on whether it's kpop or not. it's easy enough to understand that XG dont label themselves kpop bc that would also create controversy - theyre not korean and they dont sing in korean which traditionally means "not kpop". Simon labelling them xpop seems like more of an ambiguous pocket where XG can freely express themselves without limits of a fixed genre/industry/culture, plus it's GREAT marketing for them. also if it helps to understand why they didnt debut in Japan, i remember seeing a Japanese comment which said that the amount of exposure and investment that South Korea pours into idol groups is incomparable to anywhere else so i see it as kpop and South Korea being recognised as a massive entertainment industry - wouldnt be surprised to see more international artists debut in South Korea in a few years.
@@user.chdner4wjd as already mentioned, Korea's idol industry is the best of the best, so where else would they go? take it as a compliment. your society (i assume you're Korean) made K-Pop big enough for people around the world to come to your country for fame, just like how artists flock to the US to make it big in Hollywood. is it really hard to understand, or do you just not want to?
K-pop 시스템을 쓰더라도 일본인의 감성과 음악적 해석이 묻으면 새로운 창작이 되고 오히려 K-pop의 외연이 넓어질 수 있는 계기가 될수도 있다고 생각함. 단지 XG 탄생의 모태 자체가 "한국을 이용해서 한국을 이겨보겠다"는 심리가 기저에 깔려있어서 어떻게 해도 국내에서 인기얻기는 힘들다는게 문제..
This guys 😂. You guys are kawaii on God. Adults giving energy of twitter teengers that fight about how xg is kpop or jpop and how they refuse to see any reason in the explanation of xg's concept. 대단하다 당신들😅.
You guys definitely don't know anything about XG but Jurin, Hinata and Chisa are 21, Harvey is 20, would be 21 December. Juria is 19, Maya is 18 already. Cocona would be 18 by Dec. International age not korean age. Jurin is not the only 20 among them. You clearly don't know anything about and i dont think you are even interested. Chisa is the oldest member
I think New Dance choreographer was Sienna Lalau.
Also, the reason XG didn’t debut in Japan js they wanted to promote globally and the J-pop music industry is more focused domestically. The Korean music shows and promotions are more easily reached by a global audience
And also because of the copyright laws in Japan. They’re very strict with that, in Korea the CP laws are way lighter
I think there are two points of view that XG is really trying to capture and sell in terms of concepts visually and musically. One is the "alien/extraterrestrial" concept and storyline which runs through all of their MVs since shooting star for sure. The other is musically they are really committed to a very early 2000s/late 90s rnb vibe like TLC/Aaliyah. I'm in my mid 30s so I love that because it really hits a nostalgic place for me and I think it's a very underrepresented musical inspiration. They do a lot of camera angles that really capture that nostalgia as well. Left and Right literally felt like an updated MV from 1997 and I was obsessed lol.
XG Puppet show, WINTER WITHOUT YOU도 리뷰해주세요
it's good to see that neither of you have taken criticisms personally. i think the main reason you have gotten any at all is because of your fixation on whether it's kpop or not. it's easy enough to understand that XG dont label themselves kpop bc that would also create controversy - theyre not korean and they dont sing in korean which traditionally means "not kpop". Simon labelling them xpop seems like more of an ambiguous pocket where XG can freely express themselves without limits of a fixed genre/industry/culture, plus it's GREAT marketing for them. also if it helps to understand why they didnt debut in Japan, i remember seeing a Japanese comment which said that the amount of exposure and investment that South Korea pours into idol groups is incomparable to anywhere else so i see it as kpop and South Korea being recognised as a massive entertainment industry - wouldnt be surprised to see more international artists debut in South Korea in a few years.
근데 왜 한국와서 음악방송을 찍냐구..
@@user.chdner4wjd why they can't?kpop idols also promote in japan music shows?
@@user.chdner4wjd as already mentioned, Korea's idol industry is the best of the best, so where else would they go? take it as a compliment. your society (i assume you're Korean) made K-Pop big enough for people around the world to come to your country for fame, just like how artists flock to the US to make it big in Hollywood. is it really hard to understand, or do you just not want to?
회장 인터뷰때문에 솔직히 인식은 안좋은데 XG 노래와 실력은 인정합니다
전체적으로 곡도 세련되고 자꾸 듣고 싶은 노래에요
正直、日本人にもあの社長は嫌われてます。印象悪いです。好きな人見たことないな。笑
大手レーベルの社長ってみんな腹黒そうだなって思うけど、
出しゃばって誤解生む発言するなおじさんって思います。才能を黙って応援してもらいたいです。
K-pop 시스템을 쓰더라도 일본인의 감성과 음악적 해석이 묻으면 새로운 창작이 되고 오히려 K-pop의 외연이 넓어질 수 있는 계기가 될수도 있다고 생각함. 단지 XG 탄생의 모태 자체가 "한국을 이용해서 한국을 이겨보겠다"는 심리가 기저에 깔려있어서 어떻게 해도 국내에서 인기얻기는 힘들다는게 문제..
@@llil11lli근데 저런건 아이돌 아니면 없지 저런 스타일도 다 아이돌이 많이 하는 스타일이고
勝った負けた。
やっぱり音楽でも、そこにこだわってしまうんですね。
日本人ですが、XGは日本代表という価値観とかでは無く、色んな人を自由にするような活動しているから好きなんです。
宇宙人というコンセプトが好きなんです。
こんなにK popが認められてるのに、なんでもっと自信を持たないのだろうと思う。良いものは良いと、日本人の若者は言いますよ。
自分の利権みたいに音楽に向き合うと、New jeansみたいに大人の事情で対立したり、素晴らしい女の子達が巻き込まれちゃうことになります。
国の事情を持ち出したら、
世界のアーティストは表現を邪魔されてしまう。
XGが活躍することで、また次世代のどこかにいる才能が自由になる感覚で見ています。
Kpopにリスペクトがあるから韓国に若いうちから親元離れて韓国語を一生懸命覚えた子達です。
XG 리뷰해쥬셔서 감사합니다. XG - HESONOO & X-GENE 이노래도 좋습니다.
역시..실력자를 알아보는건 전문가들뿐이네요
유독 XG가 말도 안되는 안티들이 있어서..
솔직히 최근 데뷔한 걸그룹중에는
퀄리티에 있어서 탑급 이라 생각합니다
많은 기획사에서 교보재로 삼을만하죠
심지어 한국어도 잘하더라구요
이제 그만 부정적인 시선은 거둬지고
이 팀이 더욱 잘되었으면 좋겠습니다
다들 엑스지 보고 긴장해야함
thx reaction XG 👍
希望韓國不要這麼排斥XG
換個方向思考 XG選擇在韓國發展 表示KPOP是很成功的
요즘 제일 멋있다고 생각 드는 그룹입니다. 😊 (노래. 스타일 너무 이쁜 것만 고집하지 않아서 좋아요)
XG is the best girl group of 2023
Thank you for review. It's good to see not all koreans hate XG. Lets just enjoy good music together
Chisa, hinata, jurin and harvey they all in twenties ❤
xg가 논란은 있지만 노래의 퀄리티나 컨셉은 좋다고 생각합니다 특히 지난번 grl gvng은 즐겨들었던 곡입니다
일본 걸그룹이 나왔길래 JO1 이라는 일본 보이그룹 추천합니다 최근 venus 라는 곡으로 컴백했는데 곡이 좋더라구요
kpop이던 jpop이던 그냥pop이던 상관 안 함
근데 xg는 그게 문제가 아니라 모든 것을 케이팝 산업에서 끌어와 만들면서 ‘한국을 이겨보겠다’ ‘케이팝이 아니다’ ‘한국 질문은 피한다’ 그런 태도가 문제인거지
그냥 xg 자체를 싫어하는 게 아니라고😊
저도 xg 노래 좋아해서 음악의 근원을 인정하고 올바르게 방송에서 인터뷰 하면 좋겠다 생각했는데, 옛날에는 한국 질문은 거의 대놓고 피했는데 요즘에는 많이 개선하고 있나보네요?
@@오오오옹-l4j 그러면 예전에 인터뷰에서 했던 말이 없는게 됨? 그 인터뷰에 대해서 해명도 안 했는데? 너야말로 알지도 못하면서(알지도 모르면서가 아니라 못하면서임) 댓글달지 마. 뭔가 혐한을 한혐이라고 한다든가 하는 거 보면 한국인도 아닌거 같지만
@@wuwuwu1757 한국인 맞고 흥분해서 잘못 쓴게 쪽팔려서 지움
혐한 발언한 대표는 지금 있지도 않은데 해명해서 뭐함? 나는 댓글에서 엑스지가 한국을 무시한다는 식으로 말한 걸 지적한 거임
Tiot - 백전무패 도 리액션 부탁드립니다! 클릭비 - 백전무패의 리메이크 곡이고 클릭비의 첫 리메이크 발매곡이자 데뷔곡입니다!
I mean they’re all of the above K-pop Jpop Xpop just pop, so we can enjoy the music regardless
X Pop just means “insert letter” pop . X means incognito
@@kant.68 yeah all the pops
xg 노래도 좋고 실력도 좋은데 일본소속사 사장 마인드가 글러먹어서 욕 많이 먹는 케이스죠. 쓸데없는 망언만 안했어도 충분히 한국에서도 인기 많았을텐데 아쉽습니다ㅜ
💗XG!!💗
This guys 😂. You guys are kawaii on God. Adults giving energy of twitter teengers that fight about how xg is kpop or jpop and how they refuse to see any reason in the explanation of xg's concept. 대단하다 당신들😅.
Please react to XG Shooting Star mv
리뷰해주셔서 감사합니다
뉴댄스 노래 좋더라구용 트와이스노래같았어요 한글가사도 잘어울릴거같아요
I don’t think you guys even hear the song. It’s just non stop talking
calm down~
It's so refreshing seeing ADULTS salty like kids😂
Salty? Why?😂
@@kant.68 the way they talk
그냥 좋음 j pop이든 x pop이든 k pop 이든 좋으면 그만
Garcia Michelle Harris Mary Lee Lisa
我是覺得韓國能在日本發展，也該接受日本人在韓國發展吧？
Tama na ante. Research research muna. 😂
You guys definitely don't know anything about XG but Jurin, Hinata and Chisa are 21, Harvey is 20, would be 21 December. Juria is 19, Maya is 18 already. Cocona would be 18 by Dec. International age not korean age. Jurin is not the only 20 among them. You clearly don't know anything about and i dont think you are even interested.
Chisa is the oldest member
Chisa is the mum of the group, and the Korean Age isn’t a thing anymore and no korean would ever apply korean age to non koreans anyway
@@kant.68 The ages I wrote is not their Korean age but normal age
@@kant.68yes but as Korean we still use Korean age during conversation i guess😂 sometimes it's quite confusing
kpopだろうとx popだろうと僕たちに言わないでくださいって言うんだったらあなた方もこれはkpopだって言う必要ないのでは笑
много болтовни
난해한 전문가들이네
Stop talking!