Fathers name Abdullah(slave of Allah) Mother Aminah(honest,trust worthy,faithful) Both in HELL FIRE burning and tormented for all eternity according to THEM. What is goin on here???
@WaqasAli-ct7ly the killer of Ali is not the parents of a prophet who took care of him and loved him.i mean the least a muslim can say regarding the prophets parent is ONLY ALLAH knows where they r now.
Assalam alaikum my brother Dr. Sayed Ammar, is the Shie't Creed book online? I mean if it could be possible to download it... And if it is, would you please help me with the link? May Allah grant all of us steadiness in loving Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.w) and his pure progeny Allahumma aamin. Am from Kenya.
For my Sunni ppl. God created ppl in many different forms; some good, some evil, some with good and bad traits, and a handful are perfect beings. god created them with the knowledge of the reality of the universe, the grave, and the day of judgement. Do you really believe god is unable to manifest ppl who are pure to his liking who have all the knowledge because god wanted them to have it? Do you honestly believe that’s too difficult for god and it is far fetched?
Every good tree shall bare good fruit.... just the way Mariam as was chosen to bare the masih, so was Amina as chosen to bare Muhammad p&b.... it's highly interesting how we find that in sunni sources information is at opposite ends of the spectrum when it comes to the parents of our Prophet..... ......However there's something far more interesting - if we want to set a precedent regarding the naming and shaming of key figures, we'd start right at the top. For this reason there should never be any surprise as to why the family of the Prophet was treated as they were... Anyway, it is well established that Hanifs were prevelant prior to the first revelation delivered to the Prophet. They may have been few in number but they were around and this easily opens the door to possibilities. The kind being discussed here!
Astagfirullah as a sunni our believe is that you cannot lower the status of our beloved Prophet Syedunna Muhammed (saw) parents, our believe should be that Allahs most beloveds parents are in Junnah
That's stupid Cause it doesn't bring our prophet down in any way The parents of ibrahim as were not believers did it effect him or his position Shias are obsessed with the family if prophet that they fail to remember every prophet had a family member or a wife who was an enemy of Islam
@@ahmedmadeeh4399 The wife is different from a father, how do you educate a child by miracle? From a child he has to be a believer to be a prophet. He has to have a solid knowledge
@@ahmedmadeeh4399 In practice, it is very rare for good children to come out if the parents are negative, to be a prophet you have to come from a lineage, from pious parents.It is common sense, where would he have the knowledge, the piety?, the prophets had that characteristic, to affirm that his parents were unbelievers that is clearly a slander, and on top of that, for a prophet to speak like that about his parents makes no sense.
@@marcofernandez7392 didn't ibrahim came out of good lineage Ur stupidity is amusing to me Aren't jews from good lineage Wasn't jesus amongst the children of yahoodhi ?
I am Shia, and your comment should never be said (even in your context). It's not on Us to judge, we DO know AbuBakr was a Great friend of the Prophet, that's enough for Me to like him. Now was their stories about shit that went down? Yeah, maybe, but I'm not here to judge, and we shouldn't be divided because of that. 5 pillars, we both believe in them, that should be enough.
It is a disgrace the Ummah think this of our beloved Prophet how a muslim could go that low unbelieval until we correct this infamy there will no peace and succes for us believe it or not better change dajjal is coming i warned you
The big problems with our sunni Brothers are ready to put down Parents of the Prophet,Prophet himself,Abu Talib and ,Imam Ali,Fatma bint Rasul,Hassan,Hussein,Lady Khadija and Ahalulybayt in general....! They pretend to love them but deep inside their hearts nothing but hatred towards Ahalulybayt,for them is better to fight for the reputation of Omar and Abubakar Abubakar than of Ahalulybayt
No bro. Come on? I really don't know what makes you think that. I really don't. If someone hates Ahlul Bayt, why would he/she be a muslim? What is the purpose of his/her islam then? I don't know if you've heard this from somewhere or what. But let me tell you, neither are we taught anything like this neither do we believe in any of all this. We love them, as we love the companions of Rasul Allah (pbuh). For us, all of them have sacrificed for islam. Saying that, sunnis just pretend to like ahlul bayt is an ignorant comment. Fi Amanillah ❤
@@shariq4927 If you say that, I believe you. However, it is still a fact that a percentage of Sunni Muslims do not place as much importance or any importance on the ahlul bayt. Proof of this is in the common propagation of the mistranslation of Hadith e thaqlain, in which many Sunni scholars say the prophet was referring to the Quran and Sunnah, however this is not true. In sahih bukhari and Muslim, the two things that will never leave a believer astray are Quran and itra'at (close family), since the prophet said this, that means ahlul bayt. I agree that the statement "all sunnis love Omar Abu Bakr othman more than the prophet and his family" is inflammatory, but unfortunately it is sometimes the case. I think it's important to realize not all sunnis are like this, but for me personally, just the fact that someone can support othman Abu Bakr and Umar at all, or refuse to do laanat on the likes of yazid, is a disrespect to the ahlul bayt.
@@kevplaysuaot545 you can't play wars with small percentages bro. By this game, there is also a shia population that directly prays to Ali ibn Abi Talib (R.A) or even asks for help from him. Or there's even a shia population that cuts their backs open with chains and blades mercilessly. But I know for a fact that, these practices are not a part of Islam and I hope you do too, because polytheism and Islam are the opposites. So yeah, doing such things is DISRESPECTFUL TOWARDS ISLAM. Secondly, I can't curse any of the sahaba (in this case yazid or muawiyah) , because I leave the matter to Allah. Whether they wanted it or not, i don't know, as there is lack of evidence and knowledge in this regard. Also, I don't have them in my highest regard as for what they've done to the progeny of the prophet of Islam (pbuh) whether directly or indirectly. They were incharge at that time, so they will take responsibility on the day of judgement i believe. The theology of cursing the sahabas was started in the period of Muawiyah as you say, and tbh it has now again started in the shiaism faith. We don't curse the sahabas... You do! Ali (r.a) never did it. Even though he was always right. Lastly, if you're talking about Ghadeer e Qoum with regard to the quran and sunnah, it is a lost cause brother😂. Out of all arguments, you guys make, this is the weakest one, i swear. People in certain countries wishing each other eid greetings on ghadeer e qoum is itself a portrayal of an innovation in the vast innovations of shiaism.
@@shariq4927 funny you say you don't do laanat, considering the prophet himself did laanat and the Quran and Hadith both verify that doing laanat on the evildoer is a form of ibadat.
Ahl-e-Kitaab (Christians and Jews) have not done what the majority of Muslims did, from sects other than Shia. That of replacing the leader (Caliph) appointed by Allah swt with someone of their own choice. May Allah guide them towards haq and truth.
A pure infallible prophet is said to have parents who are in hell. How is that supposed to be possible? These can only be the ideas of those who want to harm the Prophet.
@@sadikkadom9566 i m just joking... Alhumdulilah In Pakistan we have some of the most learned people but at the same time like any other nation we have some worst of worst people as well... but as a nation we have a tendency of criticising anyone anytime anyplace 😬 (again not generalising)
@@sumnbleenqazi absolutely, this is almost true with every nation. Therefore, it is never the region but it is in human nature. Very important to not generalize even though you may not mean too , some may get offended when it is far from the truth (for them). Your intention is clean. My salam from a distant with utmost respect my sister. p.s excuse my ignorance.
Nice video, btw Pope Francis has dialogue with the marja before and this is Good. I wonder if the future pope will visit Iran. We Catholics believe that sufis and shit'tes will be saved in heaven due to our common similarities, ❤❤ God bless. Purgatory is real good thing Shit'tes dont view Catholic practice as shirk.
Sahih Muslim 203: Verily, a person said: Messenger of Allah, where is my father? He said: (He) is in the Fire. When he turned away, he (the Holy Prophet) called him and said: Verily my father and your father are in the Fire. حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو بَكْرِ بْنُ أَبِي شَيْبَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا عَفَّانُ، حَدَّثَنَا حَمَّادُ بْنُ سَلَمَةَ، عَنْ ثَابِتٍ، عَنْ أَنَسٍ، أَنَّ رَجُلاً، قَالَ يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ أَيْنَ أَبِي قَالَ " فِي النَّارِ " . فَلَمَّا قَفَّى دَعَاهُ فَقَالَ " إِنَّ أَبِي وَأَبَاكَ فِي النَّارِ
the arabic says "abi". "abi" in arabic doesnt always mean father, but also uncles. So the hadith might talk about Abi Jahal or Abi Lahab, who are still uncles of Rasulullah
As-Salaamu alaikum, dear brother. My name is Salim Talib. I listen to you quite frequently & respect your opinions on various topics. I want to know if you are familiar with this man named Abdullah Hashem, who has proclaimed that he the present Qaim of Imam Al-Mahdi ibn Hassan (A.S.) & one of twelve Mahdi’s who represent Imam Zaman(A.S.), & what is opinion of his claim & who he is, Inshallah? SALAWAT 🤲🏼❤️
Jazakallah, May Allah reward you Syed for the effort you snd your team has put into delivering this series. Please continue adding episodes to this series, it has been truly educational
May Allah's lanah be on Sunni and Wahabi for calling RasoolAllah (saw) parents myshrik and hellbound ..shame on you peeps 😏🙄 Lanaik ya Mehdi (as) al ajal farajahum 💚
That's why Noestra Aetate is right, we Catholics worship the same God as Shi'ttes and Sufis. We Catholics has more in common with Shi'ttes and Sufis. Sufis celebrate saints birthday so we Catholics has more in common with Sufis 🙏🙏🙏🙏 May lord jesus bless us all.
i would say, you are one of a humble, learned shia scholars who would express his view clearly and i tend to agree to most of it. jazak Allah btw i am a sunni
If the prophet was in his 40s when he became actually became a prophet than how could the teachings of the religion reach his parents who died shortly into his life???
The prophet's families were already believers in god. Muslim does not just mean "believer of quran", it means someone who is subservient to allah swa. It's not the prophet's parents fault that they died before Islam's message. They were truly subservient to god, so they go to heaven.
I'm afraid I agree with Yasir Qadhi. While it's hurtful to imagine the Prophet's (saw) parents being elsewhere but heaven, I just don't see the benefit of debating a matter that's hard to derive a conclusion on, where we have way more important issues to talk about in today's era. We love and respect the Prophet's (saw) family, but we're not obsessed.
The Prophet‘s SAW family is mentioned in the Quran and the Prophet SAW has various times highlighted the importance of his Ahlulbayt. There is a reason why there is a surah called family of Imran and ayahs saying Allah SWT favoured/preferred the family of Imran and Ibrahim above others. So it’s important to establish the kin of the Prophet SAW as being believers especially to non-Muslims. Otherwise, there would be no reason for there being a Hadith that talks about the parents of the Prophet SAW being in hell.
Not sure why you're quoting the families of Ibrahim & Imran, because while they do share common lineages, they're still very far removed from the parents of the Prophet (saw). But the pertinent question is if scholars haven't been able to conclude this debate for over a thousand years, what makes you think we'll be able to do so now?
@@LP-ly3zf ok then why bother sharing your views and opinions as a laymen. You can check many scholars opinions on this matter but at the end of the day everyone has their own opinion. The reason I mentioned family of Imran and family of Ibrahim is to highlight to you that family is an important part of the prophets, to show that every prophet comes from a pure lineage of believers. Also, if there is an ayah, which there is, that says Allah SWT preferred the family of Ibrahim, then don’t you think that the most beloved of Allah SWT would be given the best of families, from fathers, to grandchildren. And the Almighty SWT did give RusulAllah SAW the best of families, He gave us Ahlulbayt.
I didn't share any opinion on *whether* the Prophet's parents are in hell or not, that much should be clear if you've read my comment correctly. What I *am* sharing my opinion on is the fact that some of us Muslims still insist on this debate even though we as an Ummah haven't been able to reach a conclusion on this over 1000 years and probably never will, and I have every right to opinionate on the latter as a member of the Ummah.
@@LP-ly3zf look you can try to pick out what I’ve said in response to yours but that doesn’t change what I say. The Shia don’t actually debate about this, we are unanimous on this matter that the parents are not in hell. The Sunni world argues on this matter. But sometimes the Shia need to reapproach the matter in order to help the Sunni world understand why it’s illogical for the parents of the greatest creation to be in hell.
Stop taking people’s lectures and clickbait if you are confident with Shia have a debate with them Oh Shia people please read the Quran and don’t follow your scholars blindly coz wallahi there won’t be no excuse on the day of judgement saying oh Allah so and so said so and I follow it
Maybe you should read the Quran. 17:15 "we will not punish a group of people until we raise a prophet from amongst them." The prophet's parents never met a prophet. Very clear. They both died before the prophet could reveal his message.
اللهم صل على محمد وآل محمد وعجل فرجهم الشريف حفظكم الله ورعاكم يا سيد
You are doing great work. I can see the hard work you have done for each topic. I have gained a lot from you. Thank you.
Beautiful speech and clarification, may Allah SWT bless you.
Unfortunately in Pakistan the followers of ahlulbait are very few i converted to shia from a sunni like after 30 years
lanat on the enemies of ahlebait
lanat upon the enemies of Aisha, Khadijah, Hafsa, Jawaria Abubakar, Umar and Uthman Alayhummas Salaam
@@sullyqureshi676 umar the runner 🤣🤣🤣
@@sullyqureshi676 aisha is the biggest enemy of islam
@@sullyqureshi676 Explain Bukhari 4914
Fathers name Abdullah(slave of Allah)
Mother Aminah(honest,trust worthy,faithful)
Both in HELL FIRE burning and tormented for all eternity according to THEM.
What is goin on here???
what does a name have to do with anything? the killer of ali was called abdurahman
@WaqasAli-ct7ly the killer of Ali is not the parents of a prophet who took care of him and loved him.i mean the least a muslim can say regarding the prophets parent is ONLY ALLAH knows where they r now.
@@WaqasAli-ct7ly this would mean he has connection with Islam. U are accusing on not being a Muslim ever.
Subhan Allah what a lecture
Assalam alaikum my brother Dr. Sayed Ammar, is the Shie't Creed book online? I mean if it could be possible to download it...
And if it is, would you please help me with the link?
May Allah grant all of us steadiness in loving Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.w) and his pure progeny Allahumma aamin.
Am from Kenya.
Hmmm, you might need to clarify the question. Do you mean books about Shia practices?
even though i am also sunni but when any cleric says or I listen that the prophet parents are in hell-fire, got amazed, got wondered, got taken aback.
For my Sunni ppl. God created ppl in many different forms; some good, some evil, some with good and bad traits, and a handful are perfect beings. god created them with the knowledge of the reality of the universe, the grave, and the day of judgement.
Do you really believe god is unable to manifest ppl who are pure to his liking who have all the knowledge because god wanted them to have it? Do you honestly believe that’s too difficult for god and it is far fetched?
Jazakalahu khair جزاك الله خير الجزاء. رحم الله والديك أخي سيدنا و أخوي الكاريم.
ماشاءالله سيد عمار. شكرا على جهودك. 🎉❤
Every good tree shall bare good fruit.... just the way Mariam as was chosen to bare the masih, so was Amina as chosen to bare Muhammad p&b.... it's highly interesting how we find that in sunni sources information is at opposite ends of the spectrum when it comes to the parents of our Prophet.....
......However there's something far more interesting - if we want to set a precedent regarding the naming and shaming of key figures, we'd start right at the top. For this reason there should never be any surprise as to why the family of the Prophet was treated as they were... Anyway, it is well established that Hanifs were prevelant prior to the first revelation delivered to the Prophet. They may have been few in number but they were around and this easily opens the door to possibilities. The kind being discussed here!
أللهم صل على محمد وآل محمد
Astagfirullah as a sunni our believe is that you cannot lower the status of our beloved Prophet Syedunna Muhammed (saw) parents, our believe should be that Allahs most beloveds parents are in Junnah
That's stupid
Cause it doesn't bring our prophet down in any way
The parents of ibrahim as were not believers did it effect him or his position
Shias are obsessed with the family if prophet that they fail to remember every prophet had a family member or a wife who was an enemy of Islam
@@ahmedmadeeh4399 The wife is different from a father, how do you educate a child by miracle? From a child he has to be a believer to be a prophet. He has to have a solid knowledge
@@marcofernandez7392 what are ypu talking about im talking about the parents of prophet
@@ahmedmadeeh4399 In practice, it is very rare for good children to come out if the parents are negative, to be a prophet you have to come from a lineage, from pious parents.It is common sense, where would he have the knowledge, the piety?, the prophets had that characteristic, to affirm that his parents were unbelievers that is clearly a slander, and on top of that, for a prophet to speak like that about his parents makes no sense.
@@marcofernandez7392 didn't ibrahim came out of good lineage
Ur stupidity is amusing to me
Aren't jews from good lineage
Wasn't jesus amongst the children of yahoodhi ?
Legend ❤
Mashallah, Dis Was Very, Very Interesting, I’m Enjoying This Series So Much… And I Dnt Claim Shia, Allahu Aalim ☝🏽
Best Lecture Sayed Ammar ❤❤❤
❤mashallah Sayed
If i say abu Bakr is in hell how would the sunnis feel??
mad
I am Shia, and your comment should never be said (even in your context).
It's not on Us to judge, we DO know AbuBakr was a Great friend of the Prophet, that's enough for Me to like him.
Now was their stories about shit that went down? Yeah, maybe, but I'm not here to judge, and we shouldn't be divided because of that.
5 pillars, we both believe in them, that should be enough.
@@RGC217 abu bakr was not a great friend
It is a disgrace the Ummah think this of our beloved Prophet how a muslim could go that low unbelieval until we correct this infamy there will no peace and succes for us believe it or not better change dajjal is coming i warned you
The big problems with our sunni Brothers are ready to put down Parents of the Prophet,Prophet himself,Abu Talib and ,Imam Ali,Fatma bint Rasul,Hassan,Hussein,Lady Khadija and Ahalulybayt in general....! They pretend to love them but deep inside their hearts nothing but hatred towards Ahalulybayt,for them is better to fight for the reputation of Omar and Abubakar Abubakar than of Ahalulybayt
@@SaidJuma-ru7vm this is very accurate. Even more saddening is that they refuse to send laanat on the likes of marwaan and yazid laanatula
No bro. Come on? I really don't know what makes you think that. I really don't.
If someone hates Ahlul Bayt, why would he/she be a muslim? What is the purpose of his/her islam then?
I don't know if you've heard this from somewhere or what. But let me tell you, neither are we taught anything like this neither do we believe in any of all this.
We love them, as we love the companions of Rasul Allah (pbuh).
For us, all of them have sacrificed for islam.
Saying that, sunnis just pretend to like ahlul bayt is an ignorant comment.
Fi Amanillah ❤
@@shariq4927 If you say that, I believe you. However, it is still a fact that a percentage of Sunni Muslims do not place as much importance or any importance on the ahlul bayt. Proof of this is in the common propagation of the mistranslation of Hadith e thaqlain, in which many Sunni scholars say the prophet was referring to the Quran and Sunnah, however this is not true. In sahih bukhari and Muslim, the two things that will never leave a believer astray are Quran and itra'at (close family), since the prophet said this, that means ahlul bayt. I agree that the statement "all sunnis love Omar Abu Bakr othman more than the prophet and his family" is inflammatory, but unfortunately it is sometimes the case. I think it's important to realize not all sunnis are like this, but for me personally, just the fact that someone can support othman Abu Bakr and Umar at all, or refuse to do laanat on the likes of yazid, is a disrespect to the ahlul bayt.
@@kevplaysuaot545 you can't play wars with small percentages bro. By this game, there is also a shia population that directly prays to Ali ibn Abi Talib (R.A) or even asks for help from him. Or there's even a shia population that cuts their backs open with chains and blades mercilessly. But I know for a fact that, these practices are not a part of Islam and I hope you do too, because polytheism and Islam are the opposites.
So yeah, doing such things is DISRESPECTFUL TOWARDS ISLAM.
Secondly, I can't curse any of the sahaba (in this case yazid or muawiyah) , because I leave the matter to Allah. Whether they wanted it or not, i don't know, as there is lack of evidence and knowledge in this regard.
Also, I don't have them in my highest regard as for what they've done to the progeny of the prophet of Islam (pbuh) whether directly or indirectly. They were incharge at that time, so they will take responsibility on the day of judgement i believe.
The theology of cursing the sahabas was started in the period of Muawiyah as you say, and tbh it has now again started in the shiaism faith.
We don't curse the sahabas... You do!
Ali (r.a) never did it. Even though he was always right.
Lastly, if you're talking about Ghadeer e Qoum with regard to the quran and sunnah, it is a lost cause brother😂. Out of all arguments, you guys make, this is the weakest one, i swear. People in certain countries wishing each other eid greetings on ghadeer e qoum is itself a portrayal of an innovation in the vast innovations of shiaism.
@@shariq4927 funny you say you don't do laanat, considering the prophet himself did laanat and the Quran and Hadith both verify that doing laanat on the evildoer is a form of ibadat.
"is this syed ammar shia edition" XD ahahahaha
Laanat on the enemies of The Prophet sawaw and His parents.😮
brailvi sub sect in sunnis tend to have same view of father of Ibrahim A.S.
Ahl-e-Kitaab (Christians and Jews) have not done what the majority of Muslims did, from sects other than Shia. That of replacing the leader (Caliph) appointed by Allah swt with someone of their own choice.
May Allah guide them towards haq and truth.
"is this syed ammar shia edition" 🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀
A pure infallible prophet is said to have parents who are in hell. How is that supposed to be possible? These can only be the ideas of those who want to harm the Prophet.
Sunnis do not even analyze their own doctrine and criticize Christians for fanaticism.
12:30 Sayedna ignore Pakistanis... they don’t know zilch
as a Pakistani i agree lol
No habibi, don't say that. There are wonderful Pakistanis with amazing Iman and Ikhlaaq. It is best not to generalize.
@@sadikkadom9566 i m just joking... Alhumdulilah In Pakistan we have some of the most learned people but at the same time like any other nation we have some worst of worst people as well... but as a nation we have a tendency of criticising anyone anytime anyplace 😬 (again not generalising)
@@sumnbleenqazi absolutely, this is almost true with every nation. Therefore, it is never the region but it is in human nature.
Very important to not generalize even though you may not mean too , some may get offended when it is far from the truth (for them). Your intention is clean.
My salam from a distant with utmost respect my sister.
p.s excuse my ignorance.
@@sadikkadom9566 u may want to edit your comments bro... i m your sister not a brother 😆🤣
Nice video, btw Pope Francis has dialogue with the marja before and this is Good. I wonder if the future pope will visit Iran. We Catholics believe that sufis and shit'tes will be saved in heaven due to our common similarities, ❤❤ God bless. Purgatory is real good thing Shit'tes dont view Catholic practice as shirk.
ABD ALLAH ( Banda of Allah)
Sahih Muslim 203:
Verily, a person said: Messenger of Allah, where is my father? He said: (He) is in the Fire. When he turned away, he (the Holy Prophet) called him and said: Verily my father and your father are in the Fire.
حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو بَكْرِ بْنُ أَبِي شَيْبَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا عَفَّانُ، حَدَّثَنَا حَمَّادُ بْنُ سَلَمَةَ، عَنْ ثَابِتٍ، عَنْ أَنَسٍ، أَنَّ رَجُلاً، قَالَ يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ أَيْنَ أَبِي قَالَ " فِي النَّارِ " . فَلَمَّا قَفَّى دَعَاهُ فَقَالَ " إِنَّ أَبِي وَأَبَاكَ فِي النَّارِ
the arabic says "abi". "abi" in arabic doesnt always mean father, but also uncles. So the hadith might talk about Abi Jahal or Abi Lahab, who are still uncles of Rasulullah
As-Salaamu alaikum, dear brother. My name is Salim Talib. I listen to you quite frequently & respect your opinions on various topics. I want to know if you are familiar with this man named Abdullah Hashem, who has proclaimed that he the present Qaim of Imam Al-Mahdi ibn Hassan (A.S.) & one of twelve Mahdi’s who represent Imam Zaman(A.S.), & what is opinion of his claim & who he is, Inshallah? SALAWAT 🤲🏼❤️
Jazakallah, May Allah reward you Syed for the effort you snd your team has put into delivering this series. Please continue adding episodes to this series, it has been truly educational
i can even imagine the thought of it and would regard it as an utter disrespect regarding Prophets parents
Add English subtitles on the videos of Arabic speakers clips.
There are many like this Yaseen, based in England just lead the people like soothsayers! They're afraid to lose their position & money perhaps !
Allahu Akbar Allahu Akbar Allahu Akbar #BrightFacedPeople 🖤💚🤲🏾🕋☪️
As their parents are going to be in hell so they think that..............😂
May Allah's lanah be on Sunni and Wahabi for calling RasoolAllah (saw) parents myshrik and hellbound ..shame on you peeps 😏🙄
Lanaik ya Mehdi (as) al ajal farajahum 💚
Don't speak all this , all are muslims . Only Allah knows who will go to hell and heaven , no shia sunni
ALHAMDULILLAH, I AS A SHIA BELIEVE THAT OUR HOLY PROPHET MUHAMMAD (ASAM) WAS BORN FROM PURIFIED SOURCES, AS WELL AS HIS HOLY AHLUL BAYT.❤ SALAWAT 🤲🏼❤️
That's why Noestra Aetate is right, we Catholics worship the same God as Shi'ttes and Sufis. We Catholics has more in common with Shi'ttes and Sufis. Sufis celebrate saints birthday so we Catholics has more in common with Sufis 🙏🙏🙏🙏 May lord jesus bless us all.
33:43, pause the video here, he looks very triggered off.
i would say, you are one of a humble, learned shia scholars who would express his view clearly and i tend to agree to most of it. jazak Allah
btw i am a sunni
NO COMMENT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 😘👩
If the prophet was in his 40s when he became actually became a prophet than how could the teachings of the religion reach his parents who died shortly into his life???
The prophet's families were already believers in god. Muslim does not just mean "believer of quran", it means someone who is subservient to allah swa. It's not the prophet's parents fault that they died before Islam's message. They were truly subservient to god, so they go to heaven.
@@kevplaysuaot545where’s the proof they were believers in Allah and that
They were truly subservient to him?
Phophets fathers name was abdullah u can guess where that came from
@@Hamzathefirst ??? What is the name of the prophets father? That alone should answer your question.
@@TravelersTalesGaming didn’t know names was the way to tell a person’s religion
Ahsant
I'm afraid I agree with Yasir Qadhi. While it's hurtful to imagine the Prophet's (saw) parents being elsewhere but heaven, I just don't see the benefit of debating a matter that's hard to derive a conclusion on, where we have way more important issues to talk about in today's era. We love and respect the Prophet's (saw) family, but we're not obsessed.
The Prophet‘s SAW family is mentioned in the Quran and the Prophet SAW has various times highlighted the importance of his Ahlulbayt. There is a reason why there is a surah called family of Imran and ayahs saying Allah SWT favoured/preferred the family of Imran and Ibrahim above others. So it’s important to establish the kin of the Prophet SAW as being believers especially to non-Muslims. Otherwise, there would be no reason for there being a Hadith that talks about the parents of the Prophet SAW being in hell.
Not sure why you're quoting the families of Ibrahim & Imran, because while they do share common lineages, they're still very far removed from the parents of the Prophet (saw). But the pertinent question is if scholars haven't been able to conclude this debate for over a thousand years, what makes you think we'll be able to do so now?
@@LP-ly3zf ok then why bother sharing your views and opinions as a laymen. You can check many scholars opinions on this matter but at the end of the day everyone has their own opinion. The reason I mentioned family of Imran and family of Ibrahim is to highlight to you that family is an important part of the prophets, to show that every prophet comes from a pure lineage of believers. Also, if there is an ayah, which there is, that says Allah SWT preferred the family of Ibrahim, then don’t you think that the most beloved of Allah SWT would be given the best of families, from fathers, to grandchildren. And the Almighty SWT did give RusulAllah SAW the best of families, He gave us Ahlulbayt.
I didn't share any opinion on *whether* the Prophet's parents are in hell or not, that much should be clear if you've read my comment correctly. What I *am* sharing my opinion on is the fact that some of us Muslims still insist on this debate even though we as an Ummah haven't been able to reach a conclusion on this over 1000 years and probably never will, and I have every right to opinionate on the latter as a member of the Ummah.
@@LP-ly3zf look you can try to pick out what I’ve said in response to yours but that doesn’t change what I say. The Shia don’t actually debate about this, we are unanimous on this matter that the parents are not in hell. The Sunni world argues on this matter. But sometimes the Shia need to reapproach the matter in order to help the Sunni world understand why it’s illogical for the parents of the greatest creation to be in hell.
Stop taking people’s lectures and clickbait if you are confident with Shia have a debate with them
Oh Shia people please read the Quran and don’t follow your scholars blindly coz wallahi there won’t be no excuse on the day of judgement saying oh Allah so and so said so and I follow it
Why not just comment in relation to the topic
care to say what the creator of this video is saying wrong?
So should we after Qur'an follow sahihs from shaikhain (Bukhari & Muslim) or what are you trying to hide here?
Maybe you should read the Quran. 17:15 "we will not punish a group of people until we raise a prophet from amongst them." The prophet's parents never met a prophet. Very clear. They both died before the prophet could reveal his message.
As a Catholic, Shi'ttes are right❤️❤️ they read the Quran more than Salafis and they are very kind to Christians(Catholic).