이영상 좀 소리가 작게 날 뿐이지, 다른 영상에 채영이 부분만 확대해서 나와있는거 있는데 거기서는 채영이 목소리 들렸어요. There's only a little bit of sound coming out, but there's a little clip on the other side of the clip, and there's a voice heard there. It could be weird using a translator.
For anyone wondering they were singing live if you watch the official video on you can find it on melonmint93 channel you can hear Chaeyoung sing the part after the audio stopped clearly there
Twice isn't my fav girl group but the hate they get is unbelievable, like yea they didn't sing live but I doubt they have control over that, pretty sure it's the management that decides if they'll sing or not. I think they improved a lot since Cheer Up and with their new Japanese album coming out this month it's kind of logical to take care of their voices and keep it from straining due to little rest
Jessica M LOL its "BACKTRACK" 😂 they still singing live, all group use this in music show (include this event) seriously, i'm laughing so hard, so many people looks new into KPOP XD lmao hahaha
queen Liem yea I know now from the previous comments, I was just responding earlier to the people teasing about twice lip syncing because it's dumb to hate on a group just for that
queen Liem and I'm not a new kpop fan, it was just me defending Twice over people hating on them for "lip syncing" and pointed out the reasons why it'll be ok for them to do so. If you thought this was really funny well good for you, I can tell you're probably 10
Jessica M yes i know it, respect with your comment, and thanks for defending and support them 😊 i just tell you about the truth about this performances, and yup! they improved so much, i'm happy that you are not a fan but also notice it, this is kpop, just enjoy it and support our idol for thrice: just try to get a life 😊
why you Hating Is it because Twice Sang Good, You always Say they Lipsync and you say Your Favorite idols Are better. Some of you fav lipsync too. the only reason they lipsync Because They are tired And exhausted for all the Comebacks or things they do They Are normal Ok So stop hating..
people being so rude and mean about this when in fact its not Twice fault. Its a technical issue... just my opion.. i think they really did lipsync but not only Twice ..even Red Velvet Im a ReVeluv and I notice that they are turning on/off their mic. Its not the Idols fault. I think it was decided by production or producer of dream concert. maybe the other group also did lipsync. Its not really a bad thing. Lets not make it a big thing and stop insulting Twice.
in my opinion mayb there two type of fan in once the upper and the bottom and we can conclude that actually the "haters" are actually maybe the bottom as they also kept updated about the girls and watching their vid at the same time gave support for the view and comment fot the girls.. just wait for them to become the upper one #TwiceFighting
asdfj pato Si cantan en vivo. Inkigayo y Show Champion es donde puedes escuchar sus voces mejor, no un Fancam 😂😂. Es mas, la parte en donde chaeyoung (la del pelo corto) estava cantando, esta dando una respiro. Lo iba a cantar, pero de aqui no se ve. Tienes que ir a otro video.
jeeez thrice are so salty, they just started singing, you expect them to sing and dance without music the whole way with their choreography like that??😒😒
They were actually singing live watch the official clip you can find it on melonmint93 channel Chaeyoung sang the part after the audio stopped and you can hear it clearly there
Heromi U know twice haters everywhere.. they are jealous with twice getting famous..Twice popularity in korea is no joke..ofcourse they're jealous and being salty to twice..Poor my twice..
I don't need to be a fan to be realistic and unblind by the false hate, have you seen the official video I told you about? There you can clearly hear Chaeyoung continued singing after the music stopped, or are you too afraid of being proven wrong?
oh didnt know u so stupid like that ..all audio suddenly stoped that they need to performed again then u think they lypsync ?? Everyone at there , they can heard their voice & breath clearly unlike u
Honey Oh sweetie they weren't even lip syncing. Chaeyoung was obviously going to start singimg the next part but the music stopped. Stop being so ignorant and actually pay attention. The backtrack is too loud and in Dream Concert all artists have to sing live. Try again.
And you know that how??? Were you part of the staff at dream concert??? Why is it when TWICE sings well, people are too closed into the fact that they "can't" sing and stick to it?. You can obviously hear they have been singing the majority of this comeback live. Even if it was pre-recorded or some shit, they still recorded their own voice.
buzz buzz just go to official vid and u will get it LOL its called live with backtrack honey 😂, for ALL GUEST 😂 Ahhhh new into kpop?? you work so hard sweety 👏 #poorhaters
+buzz buzz, you are making yourslef look pitiful honestly.. when majority of idols on the list uses Live AR, here you are pouring all your focus and hate on twice.. lol educate yourself please. lol
Wasipatil Ulya mobile.twitter.com/hynusik/status/870898117943599104 its called live AR, with prerecorded tet they sing over it. not just twice though, majority of those who performed used it, only btob uses the MR.
![트와이스 TWICE[4K 직캠]다시해줘 Do It Again@20160911 Rock Music](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/o6dKS7XvgLo/mqdefault.jpg)
이영상 좀 소리가 작게 날 뿐이지, 다른 영상에 채영이 부분만 확대해서 나와있는거 있는데 거기서는 채영이 목소리 들렸어요.
There's only a little bit of sound coming out, but there's a little clip on the other side of the clip, and there's a voice heard there.
It could be weird using a translator.
For anyone wondering they were singing live if you watch the official video on you can find it on melonmint93 channel you can hear Chaeyoung sing the part after the audio stopped clearly there
Heromi
haters hobby, always make their own stupid statement 😂
Twice isn't my fav girl group but the hate they get is unbelievable, like yea they didn't sing live but I doubt they have control over that, pretty sure it's the management that decides if they'll sing or not. I think they improved a lot since Cheer Up and with their new Japanese album coming out this month it's kind of logical to take care of their voices and keep it from straining due to little rest
Jessica M
LOL its "BACKTRACK" 😂 they still singing live, all group use this in music show (include this event) seriously, i'm laughing so hard, so many people looks new into KPOP XD lmao hahaha
queen Liem yea I know now from the previous comments, I was just responding earlier to the people teasing about twice lip syncing because it's dumb to hate on a group just for that
queen Liem and I'm not a new kpop fan, it was just me defending Twice over people hating on them for "lip syncing" and pointed out the reasons why it'll be ok for them to do so. If you thought this was really funny well good for you, I can tell you're probably 10
Jessica M
yes i know it, respect with your comment, and thanks for defending and support them 😊 i just tell you about the truth about this performances, and yup! they improved so much, i'm happy that you are not a fan but also notice it, this is kpop, just enjoy it and support our idol
for thrice: just try to get a life 😊
So... what's up with the lipsyncing complaints? Does it make them less a person or something?
"surprise!" hahaha 😂 that's why i love twice ❤
queen Liem to cover the embaresment
Enrique Nur Teay
lol to handle the situation, and just enjoy it, not panic or over reaction ;)
Enrique Nur Teay
positively and stay happy! keep performing with smile
poor ur idol LMFAO
alex bridge
prefer to come here, poor your idol LMAO 😂 btw happy watching ;)
Surpriseeeee 😂😂😂 this made my day
when they sound so good that people claim they didn't sing lol also check the official line up by twice name it says LIVE AR SLAY QUEENS💖
they are singing live... waaa... the part nae when the music stop still can hear it... chaeng shocked reaction too cute to be handle... 😍😍😍
why you Hating Is it because Twice Sang Good, You always Say they Lipsync and you say Your Favorite idols Are better. Some of you fav lipsync too. the only reason they lipsync Because They are tired And exhausted for all the Comebacks or things they do They Are normal Ok So stop hating..
Twice they are so perfect .
For the first time in forever my nayeon didn't do the opening for the song 😂 it's okay, love nayeon!
트와이스 진짜 팬이예요.
Thank you ^^! twice Fighting!
people being so rude and mean about this when in fact its not Twice fault. Its a technical issue... just my opion.. i think they really did lipsync but not only Twice ..even Red Velvet Im a ReVeluv and I notice that they are turning on/off their mic. Its not the Idols fault. I think it was decided by production or producer of dream concert. maybe the other group also did lipsync. Its not really a bad thing. Lets not make it a big thing and stop insulting Twice.
TWICE😍😍
when music off.. now i see 😂😂
love twice
TWICE FIGHTING!!!! TWICE TWICE TWICE TWICE 😘💗💋💗💗💗💗💗💋💋💋🍀🍀🍀🎉🎉🎉
트와이스도 완전 당황했을텐데 태연하게 넘기는거 진짜 대단하네...
them saying surprise was hinting that the microphones work
드콘 맞나요? 보러 갔었는데.
フォーメーション分かりやすい！
in my opinion mayb there two type of fan in once the upper and the bottom and we can conclude that actually the "haters" are actually maybe the bottom as they also kept updated about the girls and watching their vid at the same time gave support for the view and comment fot the girls.. just wait for them to become the upper one #TwiceFighting
쯔위 ❤❤❤
Tzuyu 💕💕
Twice is sing very good
and dance goodgood
2:40 사나 얼굴 얼마나 작길래 애들얼굴이 크게 나오냐 개쩐다
괜찬아요 ㅎㅎ
으악ㄱ애애앵 한국어가.....😂😂
twice fighting!!
que bueno que ganó seventeen
트둥이 😘😘😘
Ginger Lai 립싱크😜😜
"surprise" lol 😂
why so many dislikes?
3:40나연
❤❤❤❤❤
미나 언니 너무 예쁘고,나연이 언니 너무 착해요
당황했는데도 서프라이즈~하면서 대처하는게 보기좋네요ㅠ
chaeng! not lips, twice real sing. twice 😍😘 fighting
Just check this video in melonmint93 channel and You can hear Chaeyeong voice while the music stopped
they lysinc why can't you accepte that XD
그와중에도 사랑스럽네
LYPSINC QUEENS onces can't accepte that XD
챙이 당황한거 봐 ㅎㅎ
그래두 프로답게 잘 끝냈어☆
Justo cuando empezaba a creer que cantaban en vivo me salen esto D':
asdfj pato Si cantan en vivo. Inkigayo y Show Champion es donde puedes escuchar sus voces mejor, no un Fancam 😂😂. Es mas, la parte en donde chaeyoung (la del pelo corto) estava cantando, esta dando una respiro. Lo iba a cantar, pero de aqui no se ve. Tienes que ir a otro video.
채영아애아애어 넘 기여벙💖
I just don't get it why thrice keep on mentioning 'lipsync' towards every twice's performances like it will make their life better? go get your life.
한국사람 없나요???
다현♡♡귀요미
그냥 댄서들임
Mina 😍😍😍
mr제거 들어도 거의 안부르는데 이해 가는게 저런 큰 무대에서 노래하기가 쉽진 않을것같담
They had to sing acapella!
no music no voice! lol😁😋😂😂
no haters, no laugh 😂
jeeez thrice are so salty, they just started singing, you expect them to sing and dance without music the whole way with their choreography like that??😒😒
Watch the official clip on melonmint93 channel Chaeyoung sang the part after the audio stopped and you can hear it clearly there
Heromi
actually i'm sure haters hear too lol but they choose to be salty as always
the choreography only consist of aegyo where's the real dance duh
TV 레몬 whut??
아~다 댓글이 영어야~ 복잡해~!
no music = no voice 😂😂
Dahyun
내 친구 여기 갔는데 엄청 부럽
§미나토 자키 사나~♥
no music no voice..HAHAHAHAA! lol😁😋😂😂
JYP should train they just like Wonder Girl, they can sing perfectly on stage
They were actually singing live watch the official clip you can find it on melonmint93 channel Chaeyoung sang the part after the audio stopped and you can hear it clearly there
iam Dannels' pathetic hater. in official video. They sing live. Can hear two voice.
huh..TWICE QUEEN OF LIP SYNC
Heromi U know twice haters everywhere.. they are jealous with twice getting famous..Twice popularity in korea is no joke..ofcourse they're jealous and being salty to twice..Poor my twice..
I don't need to be a fan to be realistic and unblind by the false hate, have you seen the official video I told you about? There you can clearly hear Chaeyoung continued singing after the music stopped, or are you too afraid of being proven wrong?
hahaha lol
여긴다 외국인이라 머리가 아프군.....
트와이스 반응 너무 귀여운거 아니얌!!!!!♥
잘됨
립싱크아니라는분들 뭐지;mr제거 안들은건지 아니면 알면서 모르는척하는건지;
0:30
THE SOUND IS HATER OF TWICE GRRRRR
진짜 노래도그렇고 케이팝의 옥에티다 ㄹㅇ;;
No music = No voice
서프라이즈~~!!ㅋㅋ자연스러움
쯔위 3분 25초 안무 실수!
idols is figure not singer :D
oh i'm sorry i didn't know that lipsyncing was considered "professionalism"
oh didnt know u so stupid like that ..all audio suddenly stoped that they need to performed again then u think they lypsync ?? Everyone at there , they can heard their voice & breath clearly unlike u
Honey sure it does😂 ..and I didn't know an Alien like you really "exist" like what the hell ur really jelous eyyt😂😂
Honey
Oh sweetie they weren't even lip syncing. Chaeyoung was obviously going to start singimg the next part but the music stopped. Stop being so ignorant and actually pay attention. The backtrack is too loud and in Dream Concert all artists have to sing live. Try again.
Honey it's call AR live , same other idols too.^^
And you know that how??? Were you part of the staff at dream concert??? Why is it when TWICE sings well, people are too closed into the fact that they "can't" sing and stick to it?. You can obviously hear they have been singing the majority of this comeback live. Even if it was pre-recorded or some shit, they still recorded their own voice.
박진영 만든 평범이하인노래 트와이스가 개인기로 살리네. 갓와이스다
when other girlgroup's music stop they will still continue to sing while when twice's music stop they will just say surprise tskk
AMH BRN yes because other gg try to be proffesional, no music but still have their voice so why not sing?
으악 다 영어얌
3분 25초 쯔의 실수
3:25
그렌
JAJAJAJAJAJAJAJAJA surprise surprise jejejej xddxdxddxddxd
Idiots.
립싱크들통났넹
@@양승희-c8d ㅋㅋㅇㅈ 채영은 소리냈는데 작게 들린거임
ㅋㅋㅋ
걍 부르지
쯔위 탔어?
전.....트와이스 펜이예요
그것도 다연이가 좋아욤
설눈님 기분나쁘실수있는데
펜=팬,다연=다현이에요
모모언니머리묶으니까 넘나이쁘다♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
Twice?? They are really not good at singing... Why don't you listen mr removed version?
ふーー！！！
다 외국인잉네
립싱크 들켰다~^^와~~
Tommy 엄 응 립싱크
씨스타 립싱크 들킨거 티낸다....ㅋ
씨스타 네 립싱크 아니고요 안티 티오지게 네져
씨스타 립싱크 아닙니다
ALL KPOP THE SAME~~~POOR TWICE
buzz buzz
☝this kid is everywhere again lmao 😂 #poorhaters
buzz buzz just go to official vid and u will get it LOL its called live with backtrack honey 😂, for ALL GUEST 😂 Ahhhh new into kpop?? you work so hard sweety 👏 #poorhaters
NO HATERS NO DRAMA -> NO LAUGH😂😂
+buzz buzz, you are making yourslef look pitiful honestly.. when majority of idols on the list uses Live AR, here you are pouring all your focus and hate on twice.. lol educate yourself please. lol
서프라이즈!를 사쿠라이즈! 라고 들음ㅋㅋ
근데 나만 한국인? 한국인 사람 손🖐
나는 나연이가 제일 좋다
채영이 파트에서 겨드랑이가 탔다!!
Mira ese playback papuh :v ok no
Mariano RZ. A ok
Yaslie naomi vazquez torres v;
lips sync 😁😁😁😂😂😂
Wasipatil Ulya mobile.twitter.com/hynusik/status/870898117943599104 its called live AR, with prerecorded tet they sing over it. not just twice though, majority of those who performed used it, only btob uses the MR.
외국넘들은 립싱크해도 그저좋단다ㅎㅎ
새벽별 외국엔 대부분 라이브니까 신기한가보죠
hahahahahahahaha!!
lah ga ada suaranya 😂
영어못읽겠다
lol lip sync queen
립싱크 오진다
빵빵덕 [i] 링싱크 아닌데요 ㅋㅋ 좀 알고 말하시길 다른영상에 올라온건 분명 채영이 목소리가 들렸어요 이 영상만 유독 작게 들린건데 그것같거 까는 당신은 참 하핫
륍쓍크? ㅋ
씨스타 멍청이냐 립싱크아닌거 인증한거잖 ㅋ
쓰나봉 어떤부분에서 인증한거임?ㅋㅋㅋ
노우석 본방 보고와 ㅎ
서승희 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ마이크잇으면 립싱크안한거냐 꼽고 입만움직이면 립싱큰데? 논리보소 00:29에 노래가 중간에끊겼는데 노랫소리가 들리지 않다는건 누가봐도 립싱크지ㅋㅋㅋ밑에 외국인분들 댓글을 봐 잘못없는사람한테 알지도못하면서 ㅈ논리 펼치지말고 그리고 전 트와이스비하하는 마음은 전혀없고 이분논리때문에 하는소립니다
서승희 드콘갔다온사람인데요 음향끊기고 노래아예 안들렸어요 립싱크 맞아요