Dairy udyog ki majboori (Hindi)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
- 📲 Updates: t.me/peepalfarm
Subscribe: bit.ly/2W2IaAE
---
(Hindi; Scroll down for English description)
डेयरी किसानों की मजबूरी और हमारा समाधान
डेयरी किसान विपिन दंगी ने #CleanMilk अभियान के संबंध में कुछ चिंताओं को संबोधित करते हुए एक वीडियो बनाया। रॉबिन ने उन्हें फोन किया ताकि दोनों पक्ष एक-दूसरे को थोड़ा बेहतर समझने की कोशिश कर सकें।
Vipin Dangi, a dairy farmer made a video addressing some of the concerns he has regarding the #CleanMilk campaign. Robin decided to call him so that both parties could try and understand each other a little bit better.
Watch the video to find out the answers to some very interesting questions like:
• What are the challenges before farmers and dairy companies to keep cows after they are deemed unprofitable?
• What happens to cows after they are milked dry?
• Is it not possible to keep cows only for manure?
• What will happen to cows if we stop consuming dairy?
• Will a business model that’s purely based on money and is not animal centric ever thrive?
• How can profit earning methods based on milk production and consumption be substituted?
• And most importantly, are people ready for a change?
The discussion pans out to various other factors as to how influencing and transitioning of farmers is not so easy and about various prospective solutions and business models to overcome these problems.
#robinsingh #cleanmilk
---
👍 Facebook: / peepalfarm
📸 Instagram: / peepalfarm
एक रोबिन के कारण आज बहुत से रोबिन समाज में उठ खड़े हुए हैं, आप को नमन है रोबिन भाई🙏🙏🙏
I like how Robin understands the point of view of the Dairy farmers as well. He is so thorough with how they feel and what problems they are facing. Super job. This balance in communication i.e. listening and understanding is very rare. Thanks for doing what you do Robin ❤️
U have encouraged me to leave milk finally
I have quit
M a animal lover my dreams were like you but no body supported me
I wish I could have done something like u sir
U r a real hero
So so good to hear that :) It makes me more happy that Peepal Farm was able to help in your transition. Also it's never to late, you can start helping animals whenever you're ready by taking small steps. Start by feeding and helping animals around you. You can also join/volunteer at any animal welfare around your area. You can join our Whatsapp network! Type in your Pin Code to connect with other animal lovers in your area - peepalfarm.org/hha ! More power to you :)
@@peepalfarm sure sir
Thank you so much
Same here but dear not just milk but also avoid all animal products like ghee, milk, cheese, chaas.
रॉबीन सर लोगों में गायों के प्रति सम्वेदनशील भावना पैदा करनी पडेगी जिससे गायों के प्रति करुणा का भाव मानवता में आए और जो दुध का व्यपार और प्रयोग व उपयोग करते है उन्हे स्वयं अपनी कमाई से कुच हिस्सा निकाल कर उन्के लिये गौ शाला NGO गौ कल्याण जैसे कार्य में सुधार और विकास हो पाये जिससे गायों को इन अत्याचार से बचाया जा सके....
🙏🙏
For the last three years I have not taken milk. For calcium I eat millets and veggies. My health has improved. My knee pain gone.
भगवान ने सब जीव जंतुओं को एक समान बनाया है पर इंसान एक जैसा बन गया है जो सोचता है कि यह धरती हमारी है इसीलिए वह दूसरे जियो को कष्ट पहुंचाता है मारता है खाता है और इस पर ना तो सरकार ने कोई नियम बना रखा है क्योंकि सोमवार और मंगलवार को बहुत लोगमीट नहीं खाते क्योंकि उस दिन उन्हें भगवान याद आ जाते हैं और इंसानों पर कष्ट होता है तो वह भगवान को याद करते हैं और वह इंसान जीव जंतुओं को हानि उस टाइम उसको यह याद नहीं आता है कि हम भी किसी जीव जंतु को परेशान कर रहे हैं
Very healthy and positive discussion. 🙏🏻
Every animal welfare activist should learn from this. We can only change someone's mindset if we start from understanding their point of view and respecting it. 🙏🏻
We cannot force our opinion on anyone.
I will be blessed if you demolish your house . Please understand my perspective.
@@prashantbudhauliya7978 okay I will try to understand your perspective , how would demolition of my house please you?
You are clearly picking my word brother not under standing what's my real perspective. See approx 8 to 9 lakh rs ka required to to start a diary . In this amount any non violence could have started.
@@prashantbudhauliya7978 understanding where someone is coming from, and agreeing with are two different things yaar. we can disagree, but if we understand, only then we can nudge them in a different direction ... unless of course we have dictator type powers ... which we don't
@@peepalfarm if being water you think that you can help the fire or understand it is not practical . By this water will not be able to control the fire and the fire will burn everything .
Jitna bhi thanks kiya jaye kam hai apke liye Robin and team. Apka video dekh kar bht inspiration milti hai. Mai bhi vegan hu ab 1 saal se. More power and blessing to you all. 🙏🙏
Thank you for the kind words :)
The farmer/dairy owner is very sensible, understanding, articulate and good listener considering his occupation. We need more such people. And, as usual Robin Singh is spot on.
दोनों छोरों पर बहुत परिपक्व चर्चा। विशेष रूप से रॉबिन जी ने जो विकल्प सुझाए हैं, वे बहुत अद्भुत हैं। जो समस्या मुझे भारी लग रही थी वह अब काम करने योग्य लगती है। टीम पीपल फार्म को हृदय से धन्यवाद । ♥️🙇🙏
Really its a healthy and positive discussion....You are 100% correct Mr Robin...God bless You.
रोबिन जी, व्यवसायिक तौर पे मैं इंजीनियर हू।
मैं आप की बातो और विचारों से पूर्णतः सहमत हूं, मैं प्रकृति प्रेमी हू और मुझे भी खेती करना बहुत पसंद है। कभी कभी लगता है कि सब छोड़ कर आपको जॉइन कर लूं , पर पारिवारिक जिम्मेदारियों से भी घिरा हु। कृपया मार्गदर्शन करें।।।।।
दरअसल मनुष्य प्राणी छोड़कर और कौनसा भी प्राणी का बच्चा और प्रजाति के मां का दूध नहीं पीता!हम मानव पैदा होने से मरते दम तक दूध का इस्तेमाल करते हैं! वो भी कौन-से भी जानवर का क्यूं ना हो, ये एक अत्याचार ही है!राॅबिन सर आपका विचार अहिंसावादी और प्रोफेशनल भी है ,,कमाल का लाजवाब है ! धन्यवाद
विट्ठल जी धन्यवाद 🙏🏽
@@peepalfarm धन्यवाद राॅबिन सरजी!
राजेश्वरा नंद जी महाराज की एक कथा है
हम किसी से हारते नहीं है
कारण की हम किसी की मानते ही नहीं है ।
हम कुछ समय पहले खेती में आये और जो पहली बड़ी समस्या देखी वो खुला पशुओं द्वारा
एक दिन जैसे ही घर से निकला एक नंदी के पैर में खुर के थोड़ी ऊपर कोई नायलान की रस्सी बांध रखा था जो पूरी तरह उसके पैर में कट कर घुस गया था हम अपने गाॅव के राजकीय पशु अस्पताल गए वे बोले खुद ही आप उसको पकड़ कर रस्सी काट कर दवा कर दे फिर हमने अपने लोगो की मदद से वैसा ही किया
वास्तव में हमें बहुत दुख होता है यदि हम किसी ऐसे प्राणी की मदद नहीं कर पाते
बहुत अच्छा वीडियो बनाया है सर जी मेंरे गांव के डेरी किसानो किभी यही राय है पर आपकी ,*लास्ट वाली बात दिल को छू गयी कुछ भी करने के लिए तैयार है बस गौमाता को अन्य प्राणी को हानि ना हो बस🙏🚩
Shukariya. Aap video ko zaroor apne gaon ki logo ko bhi dikhaye. Shayad koi pariwartan aa jaye :)
Robin ji ..you hav so much patience to deal with ignorant people..to be harsh actually selfish nd unkind people..if money is everything then poor should leave their parents too they become uselss in old age but still they keep their parents nd live anyhow even in poverty..
Very true
Very well balanced and patient explanation by Robin Singh. If the farmers start to change their mindset and find alternatives for the 3 months till their grains are ready then the cows will definitely be saved and will live a natural life.
Of course the mindset of the consumer also has to change. Their should be awareness campaigns for the consumer also.
Such an honest conversation. Thank you Robin for putting up the points so beautifully. Everything that you said was so apt! Though it may take some time, but we'll see positive change in near future.
Namaste robin ji aapki baat sahi h dudh k liye janbaro pr hinsa nahi honi Chahiye pr kishan sirf dudh k liye hi gay ya bhaish palta h ye bhi sahi h to hme kishano ko ye shamjhana padega ki dudh k alawa gay or bhi bhut kuch deti h jo jiwan bhar deti h gobar hme is taraf bhi dhyan dena hoga gobar se gobar gais plat chote chote gao me lga sakte h jisse hamare idhan ki jarura bhi puri hogi or khad bhi bana sakte h vh bhi paisa bachega bossiness bhi kr sakte hamari gove ko bhi is or dhyan dena Chahiye ghar ek gao me gao k hishab se plan lagana Chahiye gobar gais se light ki bhi purti ho sakti or kishano ki aay bhi badegi or gay bhi nahi kategi 🙏
It was a very healthy discussion. But I totally disagree that farmers are unable to survive without selling milk.
मेरे कई रिश्तेदार, सगे सम्बन्धी डेयरी फार्म कर रहे हैं, मै भी करने वाला था और मेरा इंट्रेस्ट भी बहुत था, लेकिन जब सच्चाई दिख गई अब मेरे लिए ये काम करना नामुमकिन है चाहे जो कीमत चुकानी पड़े।🙏
और में पिछले 6 महीनों से वीगन हूं।❤️
Arrey bhai aapka comment pad kar maza aagya! Mai aap se anurodh karunga ki aap yeh group join kare aur apni kahaani share kare! Isse aur bhi log protsahit honge :) - facebook.com/groups/peepalfarm
@@peepalfarm जी जरूर 🙏 मै अभी ग्रुप ज्वाइन कर रहा हूं 🙏
Pankaj bhai dil jeet liya good decision 👌👌👌
thank you pankaj
Wow.. Me b vegan ban chuki hu ab
A healthy small debate. That's what i like in robin Singh's behaviour that he calmly listens, clears the air and give solutions too.
अब दौर शुरु हो रहा है Vegan दुनियां का !!
सूर्योदय हो रहा है !!
Good job sir. Awareness k liye counter arguments sunna bhi zruri h taki unhe samjhaya ja ske
Sari most of cows ko kasaiyo ko bech diya jata hai ........... Delhi up mp Haryana mein .jitna maine dekha hai
@@KULDEEPSINGH-em3nd kasaiyo ko bechte to tb bhi pashu ek he mot mrte...sdko p chodhne se vo roz ek mot ka samna krte h which is more horrible
@@dsingh.63 mtlb kaat do , kahi road oar accident na hojaye. Hippocracy 😂😂😂
Shame on you tum keh re ho dudh dene wali gae ko palte ho paisa kharch karate hi, o tum Apne liye karte ho janwar ke lite Nahi wo invest karte hi.
@robin ji instead of stopping milk consumption, I think it's better to stop sloughter houses and beef export.
If a milk yielding cow,gives milk for life, in her old age she can be at farmers house or at an gaoushala.
Point is to stop Cow sloughter or milk consumption + Cow sloughter.
U have to understand the concept first dheeraj u r not getting it.
Every year so many old cows will be there and male calves too since that are made pregnant every year, how will the farmers take care of all of them without any profit? Also, gaushala has limited capacity it is not possible to take care of all of them. Milk is the reason cows are sent to slaughter house
What a constructive discussion! A lot of respect for Robin for everything he is doing
It's all depends on population who eat meat, we can stop consuming milk but we can't kill supply chain of beef. It will be produced anyway if demand is there
What I like about peepal farm is they are always open to discussion whether farmer have different approach because farmer main source of income comes of selling milk...
Very useful message
Thank you
Bohot jald ek aur vegan aap logo se jurne wala hai
Outstanding communication skill you have sir..
I support Rabin Sing view. Responsibility is not only for farmer Responsibility also should be for every milk drinker. If can't take collective responsibility then stop milk drinking. But meat lovers grow it for their meat eating habits. Actually human is the only cruel, most dangerous, most explosive, living being of the world. if vegetarian people percentage increase in the world then peace percentage will increase.
Very practical discussion. That person from Maharashtra is very humble and knowledgeable.
Wahhh robin sir aapne bahot acche se samjaya 😊🙏
Ek hi समाधान है। जैविक खेती में के साथ मूल्यवर्धन।
Amazing super fantastic
I like ur way of making him understand ...😂❣️ Nice work sir
Achha laga conversation sun ke
Very good . Pls keep up the Good work. I became vegan 4 years back .and I am perfectly fine as healthy as before.
Video bad me dekhta hu like pahle hi krta hu
Same
Same here
Same for me
Robinbhai you really have good convincing power ...
He does not convince he makes them aware about options change is upto individual
U are an inspiration sir, i wish to be like u when i grow up
That's really sweet of you Diksha! More power to you
भाई किसान जी पहली बात कि आप सेवा नहीं व्यवसाय करते हैं, दूसरी बात बछड़े का दूध आप आप ले लेते हैं, कोई भी जिव दूध अपने बच्चे के लिए देता है, आपको पता है इन्सान का दूध बहुत महंगा बिकता है क्यों ? क्योकि कोई माँ अपने बच्चे के हिस्से का दूध नहीं बेचना चाहती, तीसरी बात आप गाय को बंधन में बाँध कर रखते हैं मतलब क्रूरता
Best utilisation of time to watch this video
Very nice discussion.
Carry on with more such discussion.
Namaste Robin ji...apko apni baat kahne bahut acha dang hai....salute
Shukariya :)
Sir I promise...mujhe bhi yhi krna h future me...aapne to life ko dekhne Ka tareeka hi badal diya.. ..
Very nice 👌 Robin sir and very intellectual bhaiya
Such a intelligent talk from both sides 🔥
Healthy discussion....sir
This guy has a mindset that doesn't go beyond the aspect of commerce. Sadly the world is full of people like him. You must have nerves of steel to be able to put across your point to him
Alternate income sources start karna padega tabhi solution hoga cow ka. Ek bahut bada mission hai ye. Bahut yoddha chayie aapko. Aapki is kosis ke liye dhanywad. Jigra chayie thoda sa bhi change laane ke liye society mein .Hats off to you for first step.
लोग दूध पीते है उनकी भी जिम्मेदारी है ना सुभाव देने की तथा रक्षा करने की । जैसे दिल्ली मेही इतनी स सोसाइटी है उनमे मन्दिर भी है । क्या सिर्फ दो गाये हर apartment नहीं रख सकता । सिर्फ सुझाव है।🙏🏼
Aap kishaan kaan singh se baat krke bahut kuch jaan sakte hai
Every farmer must see this thoughtful video
Robin bhai iska sahi solution hai ki gobar aur urine ka use karke hume business model tayar karna chaiye aur iski value bhi bhot hai uske liye aap shri rajiv dixit ji ki video bhi dekh sakte hain unhone ye prastav court mein bhi pahunchaya tha but humari sarkrein is taraf dhyan nhi dete kyonki koi bhi gaye bail akhiri saans tk gobar aur pesab karta hai jisse uski jivika to aram se chl jaye 🚩🚩🚩
Hi Robin, I saw your video and while I follow the same mindset of self awareness and positive change and Hindu as a way of life , but the questions raised by our friend are genuine and the counter arguments we're not very convincing.There needs to be larger solutions available to Farmers if we need them to think differently and bring about a positive change. Also would love to come and visit you some day.Keep up the good work
Very good conversation for awareness.
Good video. Choose Money module ?? Or Animal pain ?? Good message. Dry the vegetables and sell on amazon
Nice job sir ji 🙏❤️❤️🙏🙏❤️❤️🙏❤️❤️🙏❤️🙏❤️🙏
I am farmer and 99℅ can keep old cow and calf because they eat crop waste of wheat and other crops like soyabean. 1 acre crop waste is enough for 2-3 animals for year.
Bhot ache se aap dono nai apni baat rakhi hai
Plz organic farming ke bare me full video banaiye aur storage ke bare me bhi bataiye thank you.
Aap Dono hi aadhi BAAT Kar rahe Hain 🙏Gaye aur kheti Dono Ka choli daaman Ka sath hai Bhai 🙏yeh dairy farming aur vegan sab West ke culture Hain ,aur hum apni cheez ki ehmiyat Nahi Jaan rahe 🙏hum sirf apni desi Gaye ya buffalo rakhe ,sab thik ho jayega
Bahut bahut shukriya Robin Bhai
I would love to come, and main stay krke app ke tarike sikhna chahunga, agr ye kabhi possible hua to. Maine 1.5 yrs pehle milk and non veg dono ko chod dia,, and 1 -2 months pehle mujhe peeple farms ke baare main pta lga and ab main soch rha hu khud ko to badal lia, dusro ko bhi badla jaye.
Robin Sir, kindly make dedicated videos educating our farmers about alternate sources of income. This will help them implement your model and earn money and eventually give up dairy business or take care of their cattle. At the end everything boils down to money, if they will have income from other sources, they'll give up dairy business.
Hello Ritesh! Thank you for this amazing idea, will try to post one video on this topic. :)
Robin bhai ki tata soch honi chahiy
This is so so good. peepalfarm rocks !
This was very productive conversation. However, I noticed that the kisan bhai was talking about a model business from cow by product and a training center where kisano learn so that they don't need to sell their cows .
I am very interested to see if Robin can do something about it
I found another UA-cam chennel Hello kisan where talked about 100 cow bio gas and organic compost plant.. may be Peeples farm colaborate with them...together they can bring positive change to lot of lifes
Dairy products ke allawa kai aur sources hi earnings ke par kisan innovation nahi chahte isi liye
Mostly kisan gareeb hote hi agar kissan chahe to paise kma sakta hi par khud kuch janta nahi kisi aur ki sunta nahi
Keep it up sir...❤️❤️❤️👍🏻
Robin sir right.
After many time I hear these practical thought.
🙏🏼
Last wala ''Marriage Theory'' bahot hi badhia hai.🙂👍
Mere hisab se, Kisaanon mein itni samarthya nahi hoti hai ki wo budhi gaiyon ko au bachdon ko pal sake, par agar AMIR log jinke pass samarthya hein, wo agar un gaiyon ko palna chahein, to unki rakshya ho sakti. Aur sabse badi baat hai ki jab tak insanon ke man mein Janwaron ke prati pyaar na ajaye..tab tak kuch bhi nahi ho sakta.
Aur duniya mein sare log vegetarian ya vegan ban jaye...ye bhi mumkin nahi. Par humein itni kosish jarur karni chahiye ki...logon mein janwar prati pyar jagayein aur jitna ho sake praniyon ki rakhsya karein.🙏🏻
Beautiful conversation ❤️
Also videos of Rajiv Dixit Ji should be watched......
I have also left Dairy Products almost 99% !!
Soon i will be 100% vegan
Very impresive
Aap sahi bolre ho Robin sir😒
Me aapka pahali video se fan hu.... Har jagah log privileged ni hote
Aapke pàas toh bahut saare new ideas hai for agriculture .ku na aap in idea's logome share karte. Jaise training dena.
I think for the solution is to make cow centuries instead of goushala... In india we have religious aspects for cows... So in old times there used to be government grazing fields for cows (Gocharan bhoomi) we can turn them into natural jungle or a century and leave all cows and bulls there and let nature do their work..make all bulls castrated!!
Solid reply bhaiya iske kahte hai debet without abusing each other love u Bhaiya from Raebareli Uttar Pradesh
Very nice conversation sir
only one solution for this ,farmer should adopt organic farming. I also started organic farming for this.
Stop using chemical fertilizer
Jai Ho shree gaumata ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
This is selfishness . For your existence you are spoiling some other life.
Good
Dhire dhire main bhi vegan ho jayunga
Soyamilk is best option bro
Good job😊
May Maharashtra se chote se gaon se hu meri small poltri hai muze palna accha lagta hai mgar bechna bhot accha nhi lagta eslay maine kuch time ke lay band kiya lekin financial problems ki vajha se fir start kiya mai nhi karna chata lekin kheti se utna income nhi hota eslay kay app kheti se accha income ho iskelay ek vedio banyge. Please
❤❤❤❤
We have brain, we can try other initiatives and other methods to generate income even keeping every livestock in the form natural agriculture or permaculture!
Exactly! What I feel is that there is lack of awareness. The onus is on us, who are educated and more importantly who are aware, to spread awareness or make them understand that there more better alternative to earn livelihood.
Last point jo sir ne samjaya vo bohot best tha 💞👍
Jai shree Radhey Radhey ❤❤❤❤
Respect for Robin sir 🙏👍
इस तरह की वीडियो बिना देखे लाइक करो चैनल फटाफट सस्क्रिबे करो औरो को शेयर करो पीपल फार्म अमर रहे
🤗
Sir one more sollution.... Jo gareeb gochar zameen hadap kar bethe hai unko wahan se hata k kai dusri jagaha shift kiya jae, residence areas me.... To agar kisan cow chor de to wo log gochar me char pae.... Dood peea jae but butchery na ho.... Uspe aap nai bolte....butchery pe
💯👍
🙏
I think you should create a training programme/Seminar to tell how they can earn extra and with that money they can take care animal in better way.