@@motivateprofit no LOL. She could have lowered the tone in butterfly, not highered 🤣 . Here is the same key from the butterfly era: a semitone lower than the original .
@Singapore Pearl i agree. the cologne one she sounded tired. here she had a lot more reasonance and this one almost sounded like she lipped it! but she didnt.
This performance is amazing. I wonder why she was able to sing this song with such ease, this sounds as effortless as the ones from 1993/1994. I am aware of the fact the key is lowered by a semitone. I wonder how this would have sounded, if she had sung it in its original key.
@@maurogentile7669 during rainbow, her vocal fatigue effected how high belts she could sing. Sustaining notes was never an issue for her even during rainbow. Her vocal tiredness never effected it
All of her Without You performances from 1995-2000 were a lot better than any Without You performances in 1993 and 1994. It goes to show her technique improved dramatically despite her nodules getting worse.
Yeah, it's great. But I think it would be better if she stands up. It's way harder to sit down and sing such a difficult song. She dropped her breath support at some points, especially at 2:15 when the note was sang by the back-up singer
@@johnle7705 She hits the note for a couple beats but added a small run to change the vowel and then went for a lower note. While I get what mean by her letting the bg singer do the whole top note, it doesn't sound like Mariah dropped her support. She probably dodged it out of habit or discomfort with the closed vowel. She would dodge notes like crazy during this time and the latter years of Butterfly but I personally like this specific note change. I think it created shades of interest to the chords that sounded more dark and unique to me.
cant believe she could still sing it during the rainbow era (probably because this was the 2nd show) I know she still sang it fully live during the Butterfly tour.
too bad we don't have the ending of the video -.- she did great here, which is really impressive considering that her voice has never sounded worse than that period (1999-2000)
@Idontknowlol uhm yeah when you sit down, your diaphragm is less than in an ideal position. If you hunch a bit, it can constrict the diaphragm and affect your breath control
@Singapore Pearl when your sitting down, it’s easier to hit high notes, tested this myself. But it’s harder for your breath and harder to support your belte
@iiAmitx3 that's true, her voice wasn't so great during this era but sounded great on Glitter. Actually, I thin she sounded better on Glitter than Rainbow.
@aod2k9 Yea she sang this on the Butterfly, Charmbracelet, and Adventures of Mimi Tour as well as other mini concerts, there all on youtube just search
The fact that there’s professional cameras and there’s still no official release of the rainbow tour is so annoying. I hope they haven’t lost the footage and we see it one day.
Ela soa como uma mistura de Daydream (posicionamento mais nasal) com Music Box (posicionamento mais oral), definitivamente a melhor performance totalmente ao vivo dessa música nos anos 2000 visto que a partir de 2001 ela começou a usar playback em algumas partes nos shows e em apresentações de TV era totalmente dublado
Em 2001, Mariah não fez tour, o traço álbum Glitter tinha sido "fracassado", apesar da música loverboy ter sido famosa. Então, resumindo, ela não fez tour, então não tiveram shows em 2001... Apenas apresentações, e algumas eram 100% ao vivo. Já os programas de tv, eram dublados ss, mas não todos, pois tem aquele concerto que ela tá de vestido vermelho (não me recordo o nome do concerto no momento, que foi 100% live.
mas sim, essa foi uma das melhores performances de 2000, mas não diria que é a melhor, pois tem as da charmbracelet tour tbm, que são ótimas. Inclusive, ela tinha uma voz muito ressonante nos mid-belts nessa época ... Então eu fico indeciso .
apesar da voz dela ir se desgastando com o tempo, por conta dos nódulos, mals abitos com a voz, bebida, etc... A técnica e experiência sempre melhoravam e ela tinha um nogo timbre a cada ano praticamente, então ela só evoluía .
@@SomewhereOnTheOutside Pra mim essa é a melhor pq é 100% ao vivo, não existe nenhuma performance de Without You 100% ao vivo de 2001 pra frente, ela sempre dubla os agudos! Acredito que na Charmbracelet ela poderia cantar isso totalmente ao vivo tranquilamente, mas usava playback em todas as partes altas, menos no fim da música onde ela improvisava lindos D5s ao vivo e sustentava A4 com poder e ressonância
Amit Agmon It was Mariah at its best when we talk about the Rainbow tour as it was the beginning of this. BTW I really wanna see (or hear lol) My all from these other days and Vision of Love (especially Belgium and Milan)
Can't believe she was able to do this in the rainbow era.. its better than the track version. She sounds so confident and rested. Beautiful.
agreed. she highered it a semitone from butterfly era. she sounded close to daydream era here. a lot better than butterfly.
@@motivateprofit this is same key as butterfly
@@motivateprofit no LOL. She could have lowered the tone in butterfly, not highered 🤣 . Here is the same key from the butterfly era: a semitone lower than the original .
@@SomewhereOnTheOutside oh lol im aware now, back then i didnt know much lmaoo. cant believe that was a year ago already.
@@motivateprofit It’s 👌
I actually like this better when it's a pitch down, it sounds more mellow and sorrowful
Absolutely love Mariahs tone during Rainbow era 💜
2:06 Professional Cameras filming, all of her concerts were professionally recorded, i hope we have access to that one that
@Singapore Pearl i bet raimbow tour footages were saved because we had official video footages for Against All Odds
2:03 DAT RESONANCE!!! My ears are bleeding
2:47 DAT vibrato!!
effortless like daydream era, but the tone of butterfly era ......I'm literally in love with this performance 😍
2:50 She is too much. That was beautiful
And they say Rainbow tour sucked. I'm like what?! This was amazing.
the first dates were really good! then her voice got really tired :(
Tyrell Henry yes
Singapore Pearl cologne was pretty good too
@Singapore Pearl i agree. the cologne one she sounded tired. here she had a lot more reasonance and this one almost sounded like she lipped it! but she didnt.
She sang her face off!
You can literally see how confident she is in her voice! Look at her, she looks so pleased with herself in her actions haha! Love it.
This performance is amazing. I wonder why she was able to sing this song with such ease, this sounds as effortless as the ones from 1993/1994. I am aware of the fact the key is lowered by a semitone. I wonder how this would have sounded, if she had sung it in its original key.
A bit more forced and choppier, she wouldnt have held the notes the way she did.
mauro gentile Unless she was very confident and found another way to sustain it.
@@maurogentile7669 during rainbow, her vocal fatigue effected how high belts she could sing. Sustaining notes was never an issue for her even during rainbow. Her vocal tiredness never effected it
Maybe it would have sounded squeezed in some parts, because at that time her upper belts weren't in good condition.
@@motivateprofit Yes, finally someome sensible.
A slay. This is better than most of the performance from 93
robyn No not that far
@@nathantbc1486 this is better than a lot of Music Box Tour performances
@@antoncutie Agreed, specially if we compare this performance to the ones in the tour...
All of her Without You performances from 1995-2000 were a lot better than any Without You performances in 1993 and 1994. It goes to show her technique improved dramatically despite her nodules getting worse.
@@antoncutie the only difference is she didnt hold the last not at the end like she did in Music Box, Daydream, and Butterfly
wow this is 100% live!
Yeah, it's great. But I think it would be better if she stands up. It's way harder to sit down and sing such a difficult song. She dropped her breath support at some points, especially at 2:15 when the note was sang by the back-up singer
@@johnle7705 There's a performance she did in germany during that year that sounds better than this
@@pd5603 Do you have a link to that performance?
@@johnle7705 She hits the note for a couple beats but added a small run to change the vowel and then went for a lower note. While I get what mean by her letting the bg singer do the whole top note, it doesn't sound like Mariah dropped her support. She probably dodged it out of habit or discomfort with the closed vowel. She would dodge notes like crazy during this time and the latter years of Butterfly but I personally like this specific note change. I think it created shades of interest to the chords that sounded more dark and unique to me.
@@johnle7705 not if you know how to sit down to maximize breath intake
"Sounds like another era or something"
that doesn't praise this perf. this is simply one of the best perf.
Just sit and sing with the incredible and flawless performance. I love you Mimi.
One of her best versions. So beautiful!
Totally live awesomeness! :)
0:35 it is perfection! Love the ad libs. So emotional!
Her tone and the way she manage sustained notes was on point here
Singing this song sitting down .... ugh ! Impressive
@2:57 I love that passion she used to have singing this.
This is unbelievable!!! I personally haven't been a fan of the Rainbow Era but damn this is amazing!!
18 years ago...☹️ where has our lives went?
Hahaha
21 now
cant believe she could still sing it during the rainbow era (probably because this was the 2nd show) I know she still sang it fully live during the Butterfly tour.
this is better than her butterfly tour performances
AI KEN LIIIIIIIIII
I can forget this!!! never...
This is amazing, by far one of my favorite performances of this song.
Slaying sitting down....constricted diaphragm!! 😍
MARIAH CAREY IS BACK
Can't stop watching this and MSG version they're just STUNNING 😍
Thank so much for uploading.
god, she´s soo good!
daydream popped out
This wasn’t her best vocal era (rainbow) especially with live performances… but this night.. she said… I got this. Loved it.
... e tudo isso sentada, muito difícil fazer isso!
The best singer eeeeeeeeeeeever!
Something that Madonna can't do lol
Every now and then, I came back to this amazing performance
Chills, slay everywhere !!!
Love the performance ❤❤
a slap in the face from whoever said she had lost her voice in 97 haha.
too bad we don't have the ending of the video -.- she did great here, which is really impressive considering that her voice has never sounded worse than that period (1999-2000)
Raspy and Wonderful😍💖
Best
That operatic final vibrato belt is so wonderful. Sound like someone else.
I would love to see the what the camera man recorded.
Simple amazing !!! I miss mariah to sing live
Έλληνας; :D
Αδάμ Τσαρούχης she still does actually
1:39
2:03
2:05
She is sitting down tho lol
Singapore Pearl actually it doesn’t
@@idontknowlol2420 yes it is
@Idontknowlol uhm yeah when you sit down, your diaphragm is less than in an ideal position. If you hunch a bit, it can constrict the diaphragm and affect your breath control
@@kelvinpyaeko yes true, but I’ve tested this myself. When your sitting down, you can hit higher notes easier, but in exchange u loose some breath.
@Singapore Pearl when your sitting down, it’s easier to hit high notes, tested this myself. But it’s harder for your breath and harder to support your belte
I Love this!!!!!
Ugghhhhh I was waiting for the last part. 😭😭
there's a full audio on YT
@iiAmitx3 that's true, her voice wasn't so great during this era but sounded great on Glitter. Actually, I thin she sounded better on Glitter than Rainbow.
@aod2k9 Yea she sang this on the Butterfly, Charmbracelet, and Adventures of Mimi Tour as well as other mini concerts, there all on youtube just search
Musica linda e cantora fenomenal
^^
@MrChristian10 Não, me enterraram ontem. Triste fim. ✊😞
@MrChristian10 👼
18 years
Her best performance of this song in the rainbow era
And she started lipping this since charmbracelet tour...
+Supcharged such a shame, this is one of my fave songs of her :( she also never put in the effort to make a new pre-recording since that time
Go watch 2015 Israel
The fact that there’s professional cameras and there’s still no official release of the rainbow tour is so annoying. I hope they haven’t lost the footage and we see it one day.
@keeponsangin She sang Without You and Make It Happen in the Europe Leg of the tour only
@iiAmitx3 Thank you so much!!!!!!
She should have went on vocal rest after a decade of singing live
Milan is probably the last show where Mimi had came close to her prime (attempts, amount of lipping, popularity)
She did this sitting down to!
Ela soa como uma mistura de Daydream (posicionamento mais nasal) com Music Box (posicionamento mais oral), definitivamente a melhor performance totalmente ao vivo dessa música nos anos 2000 visto que a partir de 2001 ela começou a usar playback em algumas partes nos shows e em apresentações de TV era totalmente dublado
Em 2001, Mariah não fez tour, o traço álbum Glitter tinha sido "fracassado", apesar da música loverboy ter sido famosa. Então, resumindo, ela não fez tour, então não tiveram shows em 2001... Apenas apresentações, e algumas eram 100% ao vivo. Já os programas de tv, eram dublados ss, mas não todos, pois tem aquele concerto que ela tá de vestido vermelho (não me recordo o nome do concerto no momento, que foi 100% live.
mas sim, essa foi uma das melhores performances de 2000, mas não diria que é a melhor, pois tem as da charmbracelet tour tbm, que são ótimas. Inclusive, ela tinha uma voz muito ressonante nos mid-belts nessa época ... Então eu fico indeciso .
apesar da voz dela ir se desgastando com o tempo, por conta dos nódulos, mals abitos com a voz, bebida, etc... A técnica e experiência sempre melhoravam e ela tinha um nogo timbre a cada ano praticamente, então ela só evoluía .
@@SomewhereOnTheOutside Pra mim essa é a melhor pq é 100% ao vivo, não existe nenhuma performance de Without You 100% ao vivo de 2001 pra frente, ela sempre dubla os agudos! Acredito que na Charmbracelet ela poderia cantar isso totalmente ao vivo tranquilamente, mas usava playback em todas as partes altas, menos no fim da música onde ela improvisava lindos D5s ao vivo e sustentava A4 com poder e ressonância
@@usedtobe1197 Ss, tenho que concordar contigo.
@heyto now almost 11 years ago :P
Best daydream concert: tokyo dome, rotterdam
Best butterfly concert: Tokyo dome
Best Rainbow concert: Milan
best butterfly concert is sydney or taipei
one of the last full live without you or its the last...
Chelsea bruicefileds she did it i think 2 more times after that
Amit Agmon The last time she sang it fully was in the London concert from this Rainbow tour
Higor Gabriel yea only on a few dates of the european leg. Too bad we only have 2 of them
Amit Agmon Too bad we don't have these concerts :(
Amit Agmon It was Mariah at its best when we talk about the Rainbow tour as it was the beginning of this. BTW I really wanna see (or hear lol) My all from these other days and Vision of Love (especially Belgium and Milan)
Music Box and Charmbracelet were found dead!
Omg the raspier 1993 tone
100% live
I think this is the last time she sang this song completely live.
The last time was actually in London from the same tour (there's even audio)
@@justanamelessperson9247 could u link it, cant find it
@@butterflyera ua-cam.com/video/UeDoxxnvJTM/v-deo.html
wow, wasn't expecting it to be this good, her voice was mostly hoarse on this tour.
Uma vocalista de verdade !
@iiAmitx3 yea i know
she sounds like butterfly era
Butterfly era she sang this worse. She sustained the notes and the rasp was gone here
Sounds great. She was nowhere near as acrobatic around this time but she'd definitely stopped with that nasal tone she had on daydream tour.
i wish her voice now was at least like this :(
remove the "at least"
@@musicboxtour5854 said what i said
Rainbow era's tone was one of the best her tone.
It's better
@@ARlANACAREY remove the "at least" cuz this performance is better than some performances in debut, emotions, and music box era.
why did she eat so much omg mother
Free concert, demand refund for lipsynching
This Is 100% live
È diverso dalla versione studio ma che cosa avete nella testa
bro doesn't know the difference of live and lipsynch lol. to him, it's just the same hahahahah
@@batch9518 Sit down
@@batch9518 Sit down if you can't tell the difference
^ i no right, crazyness. she still lks so yung 2.