A lot of people in the comments saying this is boring and pointless... it's beautiful and hypnotic to me. I'm not trying to read into and kind of intellectual, philosophical explanation for these images, I'm just enjoying the textures, shapes, colors and the rapid editing. I love the occasional impressionistic glimpses of things that are recognizable like a face or trees before they disappear and the images become undefinable again. This guy is an artist and his canvas was celluloid. It creates a certain magical feeling when you watch it that I guess is an acquired taste. I don't blame you if it's not your cup of tea, but there is value to this.
I’ll never forget a comment left on a Brahkage film that was posted on UA-cam years ago. “Watching Stan Brakhage on UA-cam is like getting a blow job with a plastic bag “. Not that I agree. Because thank you for sharing. but I feel like that is an accurate statement Long live film
or as william carlos williams put it: "--Say it, no ideas but in things--" and vertov is an excellent illustration of your idea that the found object is more compelling than our "predictable inventions". i think that is why i enjoy "Untitled (for Marilyn)" and "Comingled Containers" the most of his later work. in these films he strikes a balance; his abstract meditations are rooted in recognizable realities. for me, his vision becomes more powerful within this context.
thanks---another subject (if i may go on) of interest to brakhage is the subjective nature of human perception of the real. at about 14:40 (i think) of prelude is a shot in which the screen appears blank until it gradually focuses and we discover some objects as though under a microscope (now you see it, now you dont). later in dsm there is a close-up shot of branches in which he focuses five separate times closer and closer (what we see depends on what we focus on). in i think part 1........
Major, thanks for all the input! For me the thrill I get from Brakhages earlier work comes from his using pieces and splinters of reality, his scooping from the inexhaustiveness of the world to weave it into his filmstream/ our dreamstream. The found object is always superior to the predictable inventions of our dull brains - in film categories think of Vertovs kino eye(s) leaving the studio vs. the boredom of Cartoon - in visual (fine) arts terms think of painting vs. colourising. And ....
The man who designed the credit font was named Ronaldo Kuhler, he's in the documentary "Roccaterania" He died earlier this year. He was quite a unique character - RIP Ronaldo.
there is a new 2 disc set out called "Treasures IV: American Avant Garde Film 1947-1986" that has apparently been released as region 0. it is available through amazon uk but its kind of pricey. it has one film by brakhage and is an excellent introduction to this neglected genre. maybe you can get your school to buy it!
the mountain he climbs appears to be getting steeper until he's climbing straight up and we realize this illusion is created by tilting the camera. the camera/eye plays tricks!
the name of the essay is "Dog Star Man: The First 16mm Epic"----Film Culture (magazine New York)#29 Summer 1963-------i like mcclure too. the book "Film Culture Reader" has work by brakhage, mcclure and others. pound at the time of "gaudier-brzeska" was exploring the possibilities of writing a long 'imagist' poem. brakhage wondered if he could make a long film in his similar, collage-like style. brakhage and poet robert creeley and their wives were close around this time.
I wonder if the soundtrack should be of a projector running. Brakhage recommended that his films be shown in people's living rooms as well as theaters, and he was well aware of the faint sound of the projector in the otherwise silent background of his films.
the prelude to dog star man is the masterpiece of brakhage at the end of his early period.....i think there is a very simple story to the whole film----a guy climbs a mountain and chops down a tree.......but, as with say james joyce, theres a lot behind seemingly mundane things........i hope people pick up on your recommendation to watch the criterion version........thanks for making this available at least.........
The best way to watch this is move your face close to your screen (works great on my Imac) so you can see your eyes reflected in the square screen over the images, adding a triple or quadruple layer that makes you directly involved, as all bourgeois contemporary art like this intends, best of all it's easy to skip through the dark opening.
Forgot to tell you: The complete Dog Star Man can now be found on Veehd. Decent Divx quality, you should still try to catch it in a theatre or at least seek out the Criterion DVD.
ive only just now read a little online of okopenkos ideas of the "fluidum". it certainly seems to correspond with brakhages "hypnogogic vision". also in a way Dog Star Man is almost a cinematic illustration of pounds "idiogrammic method". okopenko sounds very interesting! what would you recommend i read (in translation unfortunately)?
This clip should have been in HQ. But since UA-cam has done away with that option, please add &fmt=18 to the url to see the slightly better mp4-version.
"dog star man", "the dead", and "sirius remembered" are all concerned with death. the connection between the "white tree" (which he cuts down in "dsm") and the death of his dog was made in "sirius remembered". many of brakhages allusions and influences were literary. "gaudier-brzesksa" by ezra pound was important to him at this time. "dog star man" was the name of a bad novel he read when he was younger. he liked the title. his friend michael mcclure wrote a very good essay about this film.
Hey guys I saw your little conversation below very nice , and I though to ask you if know any artist (really fresh name lets say) that works with the digital "media" , destroying the codes of the videos or "munipulate" softwere script and stuff like that ??? Thanks
Yeah, I should have said "compelling". (originally I wanted to write "infinitely superior"-hoho). and you´re right about the balance, obviously in DSM there´s enough going on no camera recorded in the external world... And to drop one more name related to the invented/found (in German one could say "erfunden/gefunden") opposition: Manny Farbers dichotomy of "Termite art vs. white elephant art" - the termite keeps on burrowing, overcoming just the next obstacle, "finding" in the process...
fantastic - i'm fan of mcclure (pound, too), & a friend is publisher in brazil of 'scratching the beat surface'. d'ont i want to abuse of his patience, but wich the name of the essay?
If you don't want to watch this experiment in silent i recomand to watch this movie with William Basinski - The Disintegration Loops album or the music of krautrock band Faust
Yes, Andreas Okopenkos poetological essays are really exhilarating. I only got to Pound through them. The essays on "Fluidum" and "Konkretionismus" could be found in some german "Collected" or "Selected Writings". Unfortunately they don´t seem to have been translated. (On Google Books -"El proceso creativo" p.239 are some excerpts - you prob. have seen it) His best known literary work would be the "Lexikon Roman" a novel organized in lexicon articles, where the reader can zigzag through...
A belated answer: Yes, it's still available. Veehd's search function is a bit wonky, best to use Google to search the site. I've now added the link to the description.
i think that this film dialogues w/ 'sirius remembered' (59). sirius is 'star-dog'. the cherokees call her of 'wolf'. do you have more information on that?
@gokinsmen Correct. Except that the artist himself totally helped to promote this basic mistake even to the point of wanting people to believe every hand-painted frame had some personal metaphorical significance symbolizing his thought process. Terrified by the word "abstract". Imagine this kind of verbiage for every painting ever painted.
@CultOfByron --as far as i know none of the hallucinogens are "addictive", but the word has certainly changed its meaning in the last 30 years. i really cant imagine anyone being "psychologically" addicted to lsd. i believe that the words "addiction" and "compulsion" have been confused in the popular media, and this confusion has spread into the medical community. i dont believe cocaine is physically addictive, i.e. there are no physical withdrawal symptoms. opiates are another matter.
"One of the most beautiful films ever made"? Brakhage himself said he would edit out from his films anything that had any resemblance of aesthetic appeal, that is of being "beautiful". He was an orthodox "contemporary artist" bowing before John Cage's nonsense that "the art begins where the beauty ends". I'm sure Leonardo, Michelangelo, Shakespeare, Mozart and the others would agree too. Yeah, right...
@Nachtpfauenauge665 I can see how this art can be daunting as it is so far from what you expect to see even in objective terms...I would suggest reading gene youngblood's book "Expanded Cinema". There is a free pdf download on the net if you google it...that's a good place to start, but just don't expect to ever watch films like this with a mindset similar to watching traditional cinema...
... the "Images" of a boat trip down the Danube. Again, there seems to be no translation... In english I only found "Child Nazi" (haven´t read it, but prob. worth getting) and some pieces in "Contemporary Austrian Poetry in Translation: An Anthology" - but that was just a quick search. (Just read on in the Google Books piece and it´s actually quite good)
...while Brakhages later films (the painted ones) surely are beautiful, they lack a certain something - the real. I think the Pound connection is quite instructive (as is Pound himself, the teacher): using the concrete image as trigger for memories leading to the sudden attack of the "fluidum" (Austrian writer Okopenko coined this) , getting rid of the decorative and the plague of allegorism -all these ideas and postulations could -ehm- illuminate also something like Dog Star Man.
"non-narrative" - yes, true enough for the Prelude; it´s also the reason why part two is not as successful, I think. There you can´t avoid the narrative of the stumbling Walden character. Still, sitting through the whole 5 parts in your local Filmmuseum is a wonderful experience. Never had one boring minute. Never have with Brakhage.
i am sometimes a skeptic against experimental films, but those who think that creating this is just putting random shit together, then he should try reading deleuze, godard, and some other film philosophy and try creating one of these. before you do that, you don't know what experimental films are. Experiments succeed and fail. When it fails, doesn't mean the theory is rubbish and is a waste of time. It means that the path has already been explored.
@gokinsmen I don't believe acid is addictive in the sense that you mean, you're talking about opiods, cocaine and things like that. The only sense in which lsd is addictive is psychologically.
to be honest it doesn't stimulate or impress me at all, but i have to admit i'm not really educated in the reception of abstract films... i never got what it's all about and where the difference between art and random images can be defined. i love surreal movies but i can not cope with this kind of movies. maybe someone could teach me how to approach this kind of art? why is it so established?
"said he would edit out from his films anything that had any resemblance of aesthetic appeal," - he didn´t quite succeed in that respect, right? And I wouldn´t give a toss about his "art" had he succeeded. Thankfully, film in its brighter moments (as can be seen here) is more than just art, certainly more than "orthodox" laboratory art.
gokinsmen, you beat me to it, but yeah, icantdotreflips, forget about the "metaphors" - they´re bad for your eyes. And where you see randomness and chaos I chose to see a certain "openness" which provides surprise and "new" to me. To the others: Please don´t hate him for not being able to get into the groove (Should have disabled that bloody thumbs-up/thumbs-down apparatus)
Alas, I'm a film student on what is supposedly ranked as the top film theory course in the whole U.K., and my university has the 2nd largest film library in the world, yet essentially no non-narrative cinema is taught and the library's collection is totally devoid of many incredibly important film makers like Brakhage. It's made worse by the fact that it is essentially impossible to acquire any of his works over here. The criterion anthology, for example, has only been released as region 1.
"Imagine an eye unruled by man-made laws of perspective, an eye unprejudiced by compositional logic, an eye which does not respond to the name of everything but which must know each object encountered in life through an adventure of perception."--Brakhage, Metaphors on Vision "terrible editing"? guess its how you look at it......
Wish I had seen this film when I thought all the crappy looking film I was shooting in 8mm was caused by a light leak or failure to properly change it in total darkness or some lab snafu. Based on seeing this, I am thinking now that I was an experimental filmmaker and didn't even know it.
Dude, it's not about metaphors, symbolism, or storylines. That's the mistake people make -- they think he's trying to make snooty "high brow" art. He's not. His art is primal, not intellectual and certainly not narrative. In other words, Brakhage isn't making "movies," he's creating a purely sensory experience that stimulates and invigorates your brain. Think of it as an acid trip without any of the nasty side effects of drug addiction.
Hey guys I saw your little conversation below very nice , and I though to ask you if know any artist (really fresh name lets say) that works with the digital "media" , destroying the codes of the videos or "munipulate" softwere script and stuff like that ??? Thanks
A lot of people in the comments saying this is boring and pointless... it's beautiful and hypnotic to me. I'm not trying to read into and kind of intellectual, philosophical explanation for these images, I'm just enjoying the textures, shapes, colors and the rapid editing. I love the occasional impressionistic glimpses of things that are recognizable like a face or trees before they disappear and the images become undefinable again. This guy is an artist and his canvas was celluloid. It creates a certain magical feeling when you watch it that I guess is an acquired taste. I don't blame you if it's not your cup of tea, but there is value to this.
"Forget about the metaphors--they're bad for your eyes" is possibly the best sentence I've read in a long time.
I’ll never forget a comment left on a Brahkage film that was posted on UA-cam years ago. “Watching Stan Brakhage on UA-cam is like getting a blow job with a plastic bag “. Not that I agree. Because thank you for sharing. but I feel like that is an accurate statement
Long live film
Thank you.. this guy is amazing. It's like watching beautiful alchemy.
or as william carlos williams put it:
"--Say it, no ideas but in things--"
and vertov is an excellent illustration of your idea that the found object is more compelling than our "predictable inventions". i think that is why i enjoy "Untitled (for Marilyn)" and "Comingled Containers" the most of his later work. in these films he strikes a balance; his abstract meditations are rooted in recognizable realities. for me, his vision becomes more powerful within this context.
thanks---another subject (if i may go on) of interest to brakhage is the subjective nature of human perception of the real. at about 14:40 (i think) of prelude is a shot in which the screen appears blank until it gradually focuses and we discover some objects as though under a microscope (now you see it, now you dont). later in dsm there is a close-up shot of branches in which he focuses five separate times closer and closer (what we see depends on what we focus on). in i think part 1........
Major, thanks for all the input!
For me the thrill I get from Brakhages earlier work comes from his using pieces and splinters of reality, his scooping from the inexhaustiveness of the world to weave it into his filmstream/ our dreamstream. The found object is always superior to the predictable inventions of our dull brains - in film categories think of Vertovs kino eye(s) leaving the studio vs. the boredom of Cartoon - in visual (fine) arts terms think of painting vs. colourising. And ....
The man who designed the credit font was named Ronaldo Kuhler, he's in the documentary "Roccaterania" He died earlier this year. He was quite a unique character - RIP Ronaldo.
there is a new 2 disc set out called "Treasures IV: American Avant Garde Film 1947-1986" that has apparently been released as region 0. it is available through amazon uk but its kind of pricey. it has one film by brakhage and is an excellent introduction to this neglected genre. maybe you can get your school to buy it!
the mountain he climbs appears to be getting steeper until he's climbing straight up and we realize this illusion is created by tilting the camera. the camera/eye plays tricks!
the name of the essay is "Dog Star Man: The First 16mm Epic"----Film Culture (magazine New York)#29 Summer 1963-------i like mcclure too. the book "Film Culture Reader" has work by brakhage, mcclure and others. pound at the time of "gaudier-brzeska" was exploring the possibilities of writing a long 'imagist' poem. brakhage wondered if he could make a long film in his similar, collage-like style. brakhage and poet robert creeley and their wives were close around this time.
I wonder if the soundtrack should be of a projector running. Brakhage recommended that his films be shown in people's living rooms as well as theaters, and he was well aware of the faint sound of the projector in the otherwise silent background of his films.
(please note: the reference to "fourteen:forty" was not meant as a link to click on, of course)
the prelude to dog star man is the masterpiece of brakhage at the end of his early period.....i think there is a very simple story to the whole film----a guy climbs a mountain and chops down a tree.......but, as with say james joyce, theres a lot behind seemingly mundane things........i hope people pick up on your recommendation to watch the criterion version........thanks for making this available at least.........
@aswanksta thank you very much for the reference i will look in to it
The best way to watch this is move your face close to your screen (works great on my Imac) so you can see your eyes reflected in the square screen over the images, adding a triple or quadruple layer that makes you directly involved, as all bourgeois contemporary art like this intends, best of all it's easy to skip through the dark opening.
Forgot to tell you: The complete Dog Star Man can now be found on Veehd. Decent Divx quality, you should still try to catch it in a theatre or at least seek out the Criterion DVD.
Entoptic!
ive only just now read a little online of okopenkos ideas of the "fluidum". it certainly seems to correspond with brakhages "hypnogogic vision". also in a way Dog Star Man is almost a cinematic illustration of pounds "idiogrammic method". okopenko sounds very interesting! what would you recommend i read (in translation unfortunately)?
Maybe Stan Brakhage does not perceive this as beautiful, but I do, and that's all I need to love this movie.
This clip should have been in HQ. But since UA-cam has done away with that option, please add &fmt=18 to the url to see the slightly better mp4-version.
"dog star man", "the dead", and "sirius remembered" are all concerned with death. the connection between the "white tree" (which he cuts down in "dsm") and the death of his dog was made in "sirius remembered".
many of brakhages allusions and influences were literary. "gaudier-brzesksa" by ezra pound was important to him at this time. "dog star man" was the name of a bad novel he read when he was younger. he liked the title. his friend michael mcclure wrote a very good essay about this film.
Hey guys I saw your little conversation below very nice , and I though to ask you if know any artist (really fresh name lets say) that works with the digital "media" , destroying the codes of the videos or "munipulate" softwere script and stuff like that ???
Thanks
Yeah, I should have said "compelling". (originally I wanted to write "infinitely superior"-hoho). and you´re right about the balance, obviously in DSM there´s enough going on no camera recorded in the external world...
And to drop one more name related to the invented/found (in German one could say "erfunden/gefunden") opposition: Manny Farbers dichotomy of "Termite art vs. white elephant art" - the termite keeps on burrowing, overcoming just the next obstacle, "finding" in the process...
fantastic - i'm fan of mcclure (pound, too), & a friend is publisher in brazil of 'scratching the beat surface'.
d'ont i want to abuse of his patience, but wich the name of the essay?
Do these films not have sound? Be cool if they did
Can anyone recommend the best book written by Brakhage. Thanks
Ok, the "Google Books piece" is also available in html: Consciousness and Literary Creativity by
Hermann Hendrich
If you don't want to watch this experiment in silent i recomand to watch this movie with William Basinski - The Disintegration Loops album or the music of krautrock band Faust
Yes, Andreas Okopenkos poetological essays are really exhilarating. I only got to Pound through them. The essays on "Fluidum" and "Konkretionismus" could be found in some german "Collected" or "Selected Writings". Unfortunately they don´t seem to have been translated. (On Google Books -"El proceso creativo" p.239 are some excerpts - you prob. have seen it)
His best known literary work would be the "Lexikon Roman" a novel organized in lexicon articles, where the reader can zigzag through...
@gokinsmen Acid is not an addictive drug
Well, narrative and character are not purely sensory.
He has escaped that stupid rut that I always (ignorantly) thought movies somehow had not climbed out of... I was just watching the wrong movies!
@plobone try Cory Achangel
@gokinsmen too bad acid isnt addictive but i think your right about him
A belated answer: Yes, it's still available. Veehd's search function is a bit wonky, best to use Google to search the site. I've now added the link to the description.
i think that this film dialogues w/ 'sirius remembered' (59). sirius is 'star-dog'. the cherokees call her of 'wolf'. do you have more information on that?
@gokinsmen
Correct. Except that the artist himself totally helped to promote this basic mistake even to the point of wanting people to believe every hand-painted frame had some personal metaphorical significance symbolizing his thought process. Terrified by the word "abstract". Imagine this kind of verbiage for every painting ever painted.
This is absolutely gorgeous.
@stranislao si, senza everything. Only the sound of the projector behind you...
@CultOfByron --as far as i know none of the hallucinogens are "addictive", but the word has certainly changed its meaning in the last 30 years. i really cant imagine anyone being "psychologically" addicted to lsd. i believe that the words "addiction" and "compulsion" have been confused in the popular media, and this confusion has spread into the medical community. i dont believe cocaine is physically addictive, i.e. there are no physical withdrawal symptoms. opiates are another matter.
"One of the most beautiful films ever made"? Brakhage himself said he would edit out from his films anything that had any resemblance of aesthetic appeal, that is of being "beautiful". He was an orthodox "contemporary artist" bowing before John Cage's nonsense that "the art begins where the beauty ends".
I'm sure Leonardo, Michelangelo, Shakespeare, Mozart and the others would agree too. Yeah, right...
@Nachtpfauenauge665 I can see how this art can be daunting as it is so far from what you expect to see even in objective terms...I would suggest reading gene youngblood's book "Expanded Cinema". There is a free pdf download on the net if you google it...that's a good place to start, but just don't expect to ever watch films like this with a mindset similar to watching traditional cinema...
prelude 1961----part 1 1962----part 2 1963----parts 3 & 4 1964
when it was produced?
... the "Images" of a boat trip down the Danube. Again, there seems to be no translation...
In english I only found "Child Nazi" (haven´t read it, but prob. worth getting) and some pieces in "Contemporary Austrian Poetry in Translation: An Anthology" - but that was just a quick search.
(Just read on in the Google Books piece and it´s actually quite good)
ma tutte le parti di Dog Star Man sono mute,senza musica,senza niente????
...while Brakhages later films (the painted ones) surely are beautiful, they lack a certain something - the real.
I think the Pound connection is quite instructive (as is Pound himself, the teacher): using the concrete image as trigger for memories leading to the sudden attack of the "fluidum" (Austrian writer Okopenko coined this) , getting rid of the decorative and the plague of allegorism -all these ideas and postulations could -ehm- illuminate also something like Dog Star Man.
"non-narrative" - yes, true enough for the Prelude; it´s also the reason why part two is not as successful, I think. There you can´t avoid the narrative of the stumbling Walden character. Still, sitting through the whole 5 parts in your local Filmmuseum is a wonderful experience. Never had one boring minute. Never have with Brakhage.
i am sometimes a skeptic against experimental films, but those who think that creating this is just putting random shit together, then he should try reading deleuze, godard, and some other film philosophy and try creating one of these. before you do that, you don't know what experimental films are.
Experiments succeed and fail. When it fails, doesn't mean the theory is rubbish and is a waste of time. It means that the path has already been explored.
Pipefx, I uploaded another 5 minutes of Dog Star Man for you - this time even in HD.
ma tutte le parti di DogStaman sono mute????
Any chance Dog Star Man is still available on VEEHD. Just joined and searched but nothing came up.
@gokinsmen I don't believe acid is addictive in the sense that you mean, you're talking about opiods, cocaine and things like that. The only sense in which lsd is addictive is psychologically.
I listen to brown noise, though I may later try some music
to be honest it doesn't stimulate or impress me at all, but i have to admit i'm not really educated in the reception of abstract films... i never got what it's all about and where the difference between art and random images can be defined. i love surreal movies but i can not cope with this kind of movies. maybe someone could teach me how to approach this kind of art? why is it so established?
look up Myron Ort.
"said he would edit out from his films anything that had any resemblance of aesthetic appeal," - he didn´t quite succeed in that respect, right? And I wouldn´t give a toss about his "art" had he succeeded. Thankfully, film in its brighter moments (as can be seen here) is more than just art, certainly more than "orthodox" laboratory art.
gokinsmen, you beat me to it, but yeah, icantdotreflips, forget about the "metaphors" - they´re bad for your eyes. And where you see randomness and chaos I chose to see a certain "openness" which provides surprise and "new" to me.
To the others: Please don´t hate him for not being able to get into the groove (Should have disabled that bloody thumbs-up/thumbs-down apparatus)
It has no story line because it is experimental film.
So I'm not the only one that followed the story then...
one of the most powerfull non-narrative in the filmhistory
Alas, I'm a film student on what is supposedly ranked as the top film theory course in the whole U.K., and my university has the 2nd largest film library in the world, yet essentially no non-narrative cinema is taught and the library's collection is totally devoid of many incredibly important film makers like Brakhage. It's made worse by the fact that it is essentially impossible to acquire any of his works over here. The criterion anthology, for example, has only been released as region 1.
en réalité cette vidéo est plus colorée, plus intense
I always thought his talk was irresponsible; a way to hide his lack of knowing.
"Imagine an eye unruled by man-made laws of perspective, an eye unprejudiced by compositional logic, an eye which does not respond to the name of everything but which must know each object encountered in life through an adventure of perception."--Brakhage, Metaphors on Vision
"terrible editing"? guess its how you look at it......
Man, I screwed that up. I thought it was Darren having an affair with Larry.
LSD is not addictive.
Had to pause this weird shit....didn't want the phone ringing with a voice saying i got 7 days!!
Wish I had seen this film when I thought all the crappy looking film I was shooting in 8mm was caused by a light leak or failure to properly change it in total darkness or some lab snafu. Based on seeing this, I am thinking now that I was an experimental filmmaker and didn't even know it.
@gokinsmen you can't get addicted to acid!!
Only an idiot thinks you can be addicted to acid... Haha prohibition sucks.
No need to take a pill.
Dude, it's not about metaphors, symbolism, or storylines. That's the mistake people make -- they think he's trying to make snooty "high brow" art. He's not. His art is primal, not intellectual and certainly not narrative. In other words, Brakhage isn't making "movies," he's creating a purely sensory experience that stimulates and invigorates your brain.
Think of it as an acid trip without any of the nasty side effects of drug addiction.
this is so deep the marianas trench doesn't have shit compared to this
This is boring.
I agree
watch T,O,U,C,H,I,N,G if you're a man
animal collective..what the fuck? Listen to pink floyd's echoes.
A ripoff.
oh yeah...made in PITTSBURGH PA.!! home of the greatest football team in the universe
Hey guys I saw your little conversation below very nice , and I though to ask you if know any artist (really fresh name lets say) that works with the digital "media" , destroying the codes of the videos or "munipulate" softwere script and stuff like that ???
Thanks