Mon père décédé était un fan de Nathalie Stutzmann, et il me l'a fait découvrir à l'époque à la télévision. Merci et elles ont toutes les deux, des voix sublimes et magnifiques. Merci.
I'd have never immagined these two singing together, as I know them from very different operatic styles! I love this performance, both voices blend so well together! Makes me want to listen to them both in, for example, Pergolesi's Stabat Mater...
This is wonderful - orchestra fabulous and both singers provide a beautiful flawless performance. What a shame it doesn't seem to be on itunes!?! I love Nathalie's voice but have never come across Mariella before - what a shame as she sings with such ease!
You are entitled to your opinion. One cannot please everybody. That is called personal taste. My opinion however doesn't change because of your dislike. Stuttzmann has a stunning voice. Even at her older age now she can hardly be bested. I don't think I am alone in that opinion. A very rare type of voice that fills all the registers in her medium with all the power and emotional nuances required on an operatic stage.
Absolument superbe. Deux cantatrices d'exception. Il y a déjà 25 ans! C'est formidable. Tout le talent de Nathalie Stutzmann est déjà bien présent, éblouissant et sa partenaire n'est pas moins talentueuse. Comme cela nous change de tant d'autres cantatrice que l'on hisse au pinacle bien qu'elles soient tellement moins talentueuses. Parfois, n'ont qu'un tout petit filet de voix, inexpressives, ....
Le dernier commentaire date de deux mois, merci à Simone. les autres se répartissent sur 12 ans. Cet aria (tout bonnement merveilleux et chanté merveilleusement) mérite plus audience. Quand vous êtes à cours d'imagination pour clôturer une lettre, ou un SMS à votre Bien Aimée, vous pouvez, simplement, copier le lien.
I question if Mariella Devia tried more baroque roles in the past, i heard a recording of some cleopatra arias and she’s really amazing. I know Nathalie rocked the Baroque repertoire.
Beautiful blend of voices; did Devia sing much Baroque repertoire? I know Stutzmann did (she sang practically everything, and beautifully), if Devia didn't, she should have, she's terrific.
All'' Apogeo della loro preziosa vocalità è raro ascoltare due cantanti sapersi ascoltare e cercare una convergenza che è un vero Contento....E il direttore le asseconda come meglio non si potrebbe.
J'ai écouté une merveilleuse composition musicale interprétée par Maria Devia et Natalie Stutzman, et dans mes pensées sur les chanteurs, les acteurs et les actrices, purs dans l'âme et le style de vie, comme des anges, il y avait un dicton: "Ils ne sont pas de la merde", et après un quelques secondes j'ai entendu un être hétérosexuel ou homosexuel vulgaire: «Tu es toi-même vulgaire.» J'ai répondu dans les mêmes pensées: «tu es vulgaire, pas nous», et déjà en anglais rétorquait «tais-toi, une créature déraisonnable qui ne se sentira jamais mes sentiments. »Cette créature, insatisfaite de son esprit limité, a de nouveau réagi à mes conseils, car cette créature ne comprend pas qu'il se dispute avec une personne qui a une oreille merveilleuse pour la musique et a vu comment nous sommes tous nés et comment nous mourons. Par conséquent, vous avez besoin de lire plus, et pas moi, sinon vous deviendrez une créature insensible. En bref: nous nous réunirons au tribunal pour emprisonner ceux qui impolis ma mère et ma merveilleuse pensée. Quiconque ne sait rien de D.ieu et l'homme n'a pas besoin de lire mes commentaires pour m'assurer que j'ai du caractère - ma connaissance me reviendra, ma mémoire reviendra sans aucun traitement, mais vous êtes si insensible que cette odeur cadavérique vient de vous même maintenant. Je sais ce que je dis et écris - vous êtes vous-même contradictoire et vulgaire! НЕ МЕШАЙТЕ МНЕ СЛУШАТЬ МУЗЫКУ - ИНОГДА ОНА ЛЕЧИТ.
does anyone know where and when this was recorded? The blend of the voices superb, though I have to admit with handel that after about 10 min I find myself wanting Donizetti, Bellini, Rossini!
and she sang like a lady, she followed the "Zeitgeist" switched over to a first class counter tenor. She lost the beautiful brilliance. The overtone spectrum became muddy, that is requested today...🙁
She can still sing like a lady and does with great tenderness but many of her roles are trouser or extremely passionate which means she has to drop the lady. I enjoy the versatility. I really liked the recording of her doing KURT Weills Youkali . And the Schubert song cycles are excellent. Des Baches Wiegenlied is superb. Very tender
As gorgeous as this is, she said in an interview the baroque repertoire doesn't mean anything to her.... I don't think she could have done much with it anyways. She's too much of a Bel Canto voice.. Mozart is already a bit stretch.. as far as my taste goes..
Polisch... ZAWSZE PISZĘ PRAWDĘ To JEDNO Z N A J P I Ę K N I E J S Z Y C H W Y K O N A Ń TEJ ARII Sygnuję Andrzej Celmer Zajączkowski 9 04 2024 ❤ ❤ ORKIESTRZE 🎉
... And yet, if it were just the sound and no vid, no one would guess; their voices blend magnifiquely and their interpretation is very well balanced, wich is the main consideration. Connection in music is through the ears I would guess.
@@frogmouth That's totally absurd, I love all good singers, from bass to soprano, and I'm very fond of baroque. It's not at all my fault if these people don't even bother to sing properly.
I SO WISH they had recorded the entire Rodelinda. And Giulio Cesare. Alcina. Ariodante. Okay, Ruggiero and Ariodante may be too high for la Stutzmann. But even as Bradamante and Polinesso, she would’ve been GREAT. I recently met Maestro Stutzmann in person, at the Met , after her Don Giovanni. That makes wonder: just how PETITE la Devia really IS?! (Unfortunately I’ve never seen her in person. STILL, one of my VERY FAVORITE DIVAS!!!)
Mon père décédé était un fan de Nathalie Stutzmann, et il me l'a fait découvrir à l'époque à la télévision. Merci et elles ont toutes les deux, des voix sublimes et magnifiques. Merci.
Quelle merveille! Je n'avais jamais entendu cet enregistrement. Voici deux voix qui se marient si bien, quelle subtilité, j'adore et en redemande !!!
The best performance of this gorgeous duet I've heard. Such delicacy, intelligence and warmth.
What can we say?They're perfect!!!
Their voices go straight through my chest and in to my heart
I'd have never immagined these two singing together, as I know them from very different operatic styles! I love this performance, both voices blend so well together! Makes me want to listen to them both in, for example, Pergolesi's Stabat Mater...
Cor Cordis- very good idea
1991?
Замечательно поют дуэтом где никто не выделяется. Штутцман и до сих пор поёт и дирижирует в стиле Барокко и это Ее стиль. Даже в одежде.
Natalie Stutzman que mujer mas carismatica ! Que voz y que interpretacion ! La amo
Die Harmonisierung dieser beiden Stimmen ist großartig. Sie ergänzen sich in geradezu hervorragender Weise!
Seltene Schönheit, die mich erfreute!
как же Наталья чувствует музыку, переживает и пропускает через себя. и с годами это становится все сильнее.
Thank you for downloading this. What a treasure!!!
Великолепный дуэт. Чудесное контральто и прекрасное сопрано. Как красивы и молоды они были.
Young anyway
When angels gather together...
Do you really imagine angels' voice like Stutzmann's? And don't you then prefer hell?
Two miracles of nature singing toggether. Just wonderful.
Due voci che si fondono nell'universo!♥️
DIVINE!!!! La Stutzmann era perfino bella....
Beautiful, beautiful! Nathalie's voice is a godsend.
Tx a lot for uploading.
Devia's voice is very beautiful. Stutzmann's is just horrid.
@@DiomedesDioscuro Horrid?!
Do you know what that term means?
@@edwardamosbrandwein3583 It's not a difficult word, is it?
@@DiomedesDioscuro "Beauty is in the eye of the beholder or the ear of the listener."
@@edwardamosbrandwein3583 No, it's not. Snobbery is in the ear of someone who does not realize how ugly is that voice.
Duas grandes e belas vozes! 👏👏👏👏👏🇪🇸🇧🇷
What a moving, gorgeous performance of this sublime music! Thank you.
Je decouvre ce magnifique duo, par 2 voix exceptionnelles.
Two of my very favorite ladies in one of my favorite duets!
Excelente duo cantado por dos grandes!!!
Devia in Rossini and Baroque is amazing... Even better than in romantic stuff, she should have recorded more baroque!!! That's amazing!
This is wonderful - orchestra fabulous and both singers provide a beautiful flawless performance.
What a shame it doesn't seem to be on itunes!?!
I love Nathalie's voice but have never come across Mariella before - what a shame as she sings with such ease!
And can you see beautiful staircase and Baroque- style grids behind the orchestra? Nice place of the epoch
Adoro el canto, benditas voces, benditas leyes del canto que han favorecido tan bellamente a estas mujeres....
Браво! Очень красивый дуэт!!!!
¡MARAVILLOSAS!!!¡¡ESPLENDIDAS!!
Sublime ! Toutes les deux sont extraordinaires. Et de plus il y a Marc Minkowski jeune !
Stutzmann is stunning! Such a strikingly beautiful voice. Best real contralto voice indeed.
Beautiful? It's awful! Come on!
You are entitled to your opinion. One cannot please everybody. That is called personal taste. My opinion however doesn't change because of your dislike. Stuttzmann has a stunning voice. Even at her older age now she can hardly be bested. I don't think I am alone in that opinion. A very rare type of voice that fills all the registers in her medium with all the power and emotional nuances required on an operatic stage.
@@civileso Which operatic stage?
@@DiomedesDioscuro Any.
@@civileso could you please name one? I have NEVER seen her in ANY operatic scene.
Hermosa ,bellísima interpretación, de dos grandes mujeres, soprano y contra alto; armonía en su más alto grado ..
dos magníficas voces e insuperables...
¡Genial!
Absolument superbe. Deux cantatrices d'exception. Il y a déjà 25 ans! C'est formidable. Tout le talent de Nathalie Stutzmann est déjà bien présent, éblouissant et sa partenaire n'est pas moins talentueuse. Comme cela nous change de tant d'autres cantatrice que l'on hisse au pinacle bien qu'elles soient tellement moins talentueuses. Parfois, n'ont qu'un tout petit filet de voix, inexpressives, ....
I really don't know why Devia hasn't devoted more of her time to Baroque opera. She was born to sing this kind of music!
Не оторваться,как хорошо.!
Чудесный дуэт.
Como dos ángeles.....
Perfection
Le dernier commentaire date de deux mois, merci à Simone. les autres se répartissent sur 12 ans. Cet aria (tout bonnement merveilleux et chanté merveilleusement) mérite plus audience. Quand vous êtes à cours d'imagination pour clôturer une lettre, ou un SMS à votre Bien Aimée, vous pouvez, simplement, copier le lien.
amazing. this pairing is great. some notes are reminiscent of that famous Mezzo/Soprano Aria from Lakmé. I believe it's called the flower duet
I question if Mariella Devia tried more baroque roles in the past, i heard a recording of some cleopatra arias and she’s really amazing. I know Nathalie rocked the Baroque repertoire.
I love Handel's arias and duets. He had a very special melodic and dramatic sense. Other Baroque composers only composed "music", without any meaning.
PERFECT!!
that perfection
una maravilla!!!!
Excelente lección de buen cantar!
Nathalie é maravilhosa...Sensacional!
Zwróćcie uwagę na oczy obu śpiewaczek! Tylko N.Stutzmann śpiewa z pamięci!!
Beautiful blend of voices; did Devia sing much Baroque repertoire? I know Stutzmann did (she sang practically everything, and beautifully), if Devia didn't, she should have, she's terrific.
what did you mean for "terrific" ?
Duo de rêve pour une musique de rêve
quelles voix et personnalités exceptionnelles, les opposés
Dos Maravillas juntas
I love this - thanks for uploading
Astonishingly beautiful.
All'' Apogeo della loro preziosa vocalità è raro ascoltare due cantanti sapersi ascoltare e cercare una convergenza che è un vero Contento....E il direttore le asseconda come meglio non si potrebbe.
J'ai écouté une merveilleuse composition musicale interprétée par Maria Devia et Natalie Stutzman, et dans mes pensées sur les chanteurs, les acteurs et les actrices, purs dans l'âme et le style de vie, comme des anges, il y avait un dicton: "Ils ne sont pas de la merde", et après un quelques secondes j'ai entendu un être hétérosexuel ou homosexuel vulgaire: «Tu es toi-même vulgaire.» J'ai répondu dans les mêmes pensées: «tu es vulgaire, pas nous», et déjà en anglais rétorquait «tais-toi, une créature déraisonnable qui ne se sentira jamais mes sentiments. »Cette créature, insatisfaite de son esprit limité, a de nouveau réagi à mes conseils, car cette créature ne comprend pas qu'il se dispute avec une personne qui a une oreille merveilleuse pour la musique et a vu comment nous sommes tous nés et comment nous mourons. Par conséquent, vous avez besoin de lire plus, et pas moi, sinon vous deviendrez une créature insensible. En bref: nous nous réunirons au tribunal pour emprisonner ceux qui impolis ma mère et ma merveilleuse pensée. Quiconque ne sait rien de D.ieu et l'homme n'a pas besoin de lire mes commentaires pour m'assurer que j'ai du caractère - ma connaissance me reviendra, ma mémoire reviendra sans aucun traitement, mais vous êtes si insensible que cette odeur cadavérique vient de vous même maintenant. Je sais ce que je dis et écris - vous êtes vous-même contradictoire et vulgaire! НЕ МЕШАЙТЕ МНЕ СЛУШАТЬ МУЗЫКУ - ИНОГДА ОНА ЛЕЧИТ.
💜💐
❤❤❤
semplicemente storiche....
Doua voci magnifice. Divin.
Nathalie seems so young here ! When was this concert brodcasted ?
does anyone know where and when this was recorded? The blend of the voices superb, though I have to admit with handel that after about 10 min I find myself wanting Donizetti, Bellini, Rossini!
Is it from the 80's?
By the dresses and appearances it seems so
1991
No, solo pessimo gusto
did you listen to adriano in siria by pergolesi with devia and dessi? it is really beautiful!
I’ve never seen Nathalie younger and truly would have had no idea that was her by just visuals. 😅
Хоть на женщину похожа. Но голос супер!!!¡
Eccellenti entrambe. Brave!
C'est enregistré au Royal ou quoi?
lol so true for me too!
6 J'aime pas... pas aimer quoi? Merci c'est BEAU
Absolutely gorgeous! (I guess that's when Nathalie Stutzmann still dressed like a lady, lol!)
and she sang like a lady, she followed the "Zeitgeist" switched over to a first class counter tenor.
She lost the beautiful brilliance. The overtone spectrum became muddy, that is requested today...🙁
She can still sing like a lady and does with great tenderness but many of her roles are trouser or extremely passionate which means she has to drop the lady. I enjoy the versatility. I really liked the recording of her doing KURT Weills Youkali . And the Schubert song cycles are excellent. Des Baches Wiegenlied is superb. Very tender
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
Ma la Devia non ha più cantato barocco?
No, per fortuna.
@@fabriziomariagarzi5534 Accidenti, a me sembra tutt'altro che male questa Devia...Ce ne fossero...
Questa è la vera tecnica...se tutti i cantanti odierni le vedessero sul serio sì eviterebbero tanti urli e bocche ultra spalancante
Boze, od ove lepote mi suze podjose,,,
As gorgeous as this is, she said in an interview the baroque repertoire doesn't mean anything to her....
I don't think she could have done much with it anyways. She's too much of a Bel Canto voice.. Mozart is already a bit stretch.. as far as my taste goes..
Polisch...
ZAWSZE
PISZĘ
PRAWDĘ
To
JEDNO
Z
N
A
J
P
I
Ę
K
N
I
E
J
S
Z
Y
C
H
W
Y
K
O
N
A
Ń
TEJ
ARII
Sygnuję
Andrzej
Celmer
Zajączkowski
9
04
2024
❤
❤
ORKIESTRZE
🎉
@AngeMarais ...Sara Mingardo???? :-(( direi imparagonabili
No connection between the two. Lovely voices: they share a music stand but not a glance!
... And yet, if it were just the sound and no vid, no one would guess; their voices blend magnifiquely and their interpretation is very well balanced, wich is the main consideration. Connection in music is through the ears I would guess.
Stutzmann's voice already sounded horribly when she was that young! But I guess there were not many contraltos to choose from.
@@frogmouth No, they're all bad, but Stutzmann sounds ugliest, by far.
@@frogmouth That's totally absurd, I love all good singers, from bass to soprano, and I'm very fond of baroque. It's not at all my fault if these people don't even bother to sing properly.
@@frogmouth I would say this guy is a troll. I try not to give these idiots the satisfaction of rising to their bait.
@@ruthmcintyre2313 I agree. I must do the check why does it irritate, check source and 🙄 instead of taking the bait.
@@DiomedesDioscuro poor you
I SO WISH they had recorded the entire Rodelinda. And Giulio Cesare. Alcina. Ariodante. Okay, Ruggiero and Ariodante may be too high for la Stutzmann. But even as Bradamante and Polinesso, she would’ve been GREAT. I recently met Maestro Stutzmann in person, at the Met , after her Don Giovanni. That makes wonder: just how PETITE la Devia really IS?! (Unfortunately I’ve never seen her in person. STILL, one of my VERY FAVORITE DIVAS!!!)