@@foodog777 the ORIGINAL audio was her describing a dream, but it was replaced with 3 separate tracks overlayed onto each other: >A technical manual >A studio employee telling a story about his dad making him hold boots over his head >Dave reading a love letter
Anyone who thinks William Goldsmith could have played this at this level is dreaming. Taylor said he couldn’t match Dave either although I always thought T nailed it live.
@@TouringFunkBand1I think Taylor said it best in his masterclass when he speaks on the matter, he was a great touring drummer but just wasn’t able to do what Dave wanted in the studio
Grohl, they re-recorded pretty much all of the drums in february 3 months before the album released without telling goldsmith and overlayed the new drums over the tracks
For me, the guitars are overpowering in this mix. The thing about distorted guitars is that they take up a lot of sonic room, and so you tend to mix them lower than the other instruments. Here, it sounds like everything is mixed about the same. So, it means you can hear more detail in the guitars, but at the expense of everything else.
3:25 so much powerful i think
There are two types of people in this world: Those that can hear Louise Post on the studio version (she's there) and those that can't.
Until I heard the reconstructed one I couldn’t but I can always hear her now. Probably delusional tho
That's it? There's two types of people and this is the line that distinguishes them... hmm
@@Pedro-n1q3k its a joke my brother
@@dantethepunk6932 I know I got it. I was buzzed and feeling not-at-all clever so I decided to swing for the fences on that one
People with good audio equipment vs people without it
They should've keep that bridge female monolog in the final version
Dave has said the indistinct talking in the bridge was him reading a technical manual many years ago.
Yeah I think this version might’ve came after, I’m not sure
@@partsparis probably a voicemail left by his ex like the one voicemail he has in the final
@@foodog777 the ORIGINAL audio was her describing a dream, but it was replaced with 3 separate tracks overlayed onto each other:
>A technical manual
>A studio employee telling a story about his dad making him hold boots over his head
>Dave reading a love letter
I think the particular 3 different sentences evoke a particular emotion in me that makes me prefer Dave’s personally
Dude the fucking guitar sounds so much better
Its not mastered yet. You are getting tons of mid… the way it sounded going into the mics. Mid= Grunge, Nirvana etc. its beefy.
@@Gunnyfelker wouldnt you say a song like frances farmer will have revenge has a lot of treble/high in it?
the treble is a lil tiring to listen to
Does this version sound so much more full or is that just me?
It's probably the device or headphones you're using. To me it actually sounds less full with little low end
no i hear it too. its the guitar
it sounds wider
You're right. I think the background guitar sounds more destorted and it makes it fuller and more sustained
To me it sounds like doubled guitars left and right, giving a four guitar sound. Wild!
That sounds so much better! Maybe just because it’s different, but I think it sounds different.
My favorite Foo song.
NICE. I wouldn't say it was infamous, more just famous. But awesome track. I don't know how you get these releases, but keep it coming!
The guitars are panned fully, whereas on the album version they are more central
This is so interesting to listen to.
Go check out the isolated vox. You can hear louise backing tracks. Once you hear them isolated youll always hear them on the song
this is how it sounda from memory lol
This version is much more raw and powerful. Sounds more livelier
this version is better than the final
This is better than the final mix
Can anyone help me to find copies of MW and Everlong rough mixes, please? Thanks in advance.
Post taylors death we get the meaning to the whispers manuel
This is very similar to the album version.
Really like this version!
Anyone who thinks William Goldsmith could have played this at this level is dreaming. Taylor said he couldn’t match Dave either although I always thought T nailed it live.
Goldsmith is a beast though.
William is a decent drummer. A beast? Nah. This is what a beast looks and sounds like. 😈 😲
ua-cam.com/users/shortsBFyPmI50ars?feature=share
They’re all great drummer but I think this so came so deep from Dave’s heart that no one else could ever play it with the same feel.
@@TouringFunkBand1I think Taylor said it best in his masterclass when he speaks on the matter, he was a great touring drummer but just wasn’t able to do what Dave wanted in the studio
Goldsmith is a great drummer but Grohl is an animal. Very hard to match.
brilliant
Fantastic
Aww, they could have made it into a sweet duet, like That's What Friends are For by Dionne Warwick and Stevie Wonder!
Do you have a link to the file by any chance?
this version sounds more natural and bigger
Dave's guitar track is on the left , right?
Right lol
Is grohl or goldsmith drumming here?
Grohl, they re-recorded pretty much all of the drums in february 3 months before the album released without telling goldsmith and overlayed the new drums over the tracks
@@ghostly6175 You mean January? because this is a January 1997 mix
@@ghostly6175 also Goldsmith quit before Dave even showed Everlong to the rest of the band, he never actually played it
this is better
why does this just sound better? i mean the drums could be mixed better, and the guitars turned way down, but it's better sounding!
I have a drop a short of this on my channel this such a great song foreverlong 🎸🤘❤️
starting from 3:05
For me, the guitars are overpowering in this mix. The thing about distorted guitars is that they take up a lot of sonic room, and so you tend to mix them lower than the other instruments. Here, it sounds like everything is mixed about the same. So, it means you can hear more detail in the guitars, but at the expense of everything else.
100th comment
910
Compression can kill good music
Are you saying this is over compressed?
@@judebiswas6665 it's all normalised things stand out less and it has that slick feel to it
@@azelisanamei wouldn’t really say over compressed, it was still a few more years until things got VERY compression heavy
@@proxyysellz hmm yeah probably true but when you compare the two, the official release sounds kinda bland to me
this is better