Back then, i was like "why is Peniel is acting like a Terminator?" At the redebut special, they said it was his concept, the company told him not to move. 😂😂😂
i think the position when debut era was: eunkwang: main vocalist, leader of the group hyunsik: lead vocalist, main dancer, visual changsub: vocalist sungjae: vocalist, rapper ilhoon: main main main rapper minhyuk: lead rapper, lead dancer, vocalist, visual peniel: sub rapper 😂 (poor peniel) & they are still normal person.. but now, all of them are vocalist, rapper, dancer, visual, composer, and abnormal person lol.. (there're no more different between main and lead because of the fair line distribution now) proud of their progress!
If only they knew shortly after this whole charismatic image they debut with, it will turns into a bunch of comdol (comedy idol). All thanks to changsub 😂
Back again here because i miss them so much.. Ilhoon looks so cute here with his chubby cheeks.. They are great and amazing from their debut era until now..!!
they are so amazing they have been singing live since debut and their live singing is so stable its amazing! like for example other rookie group usually lipsync especially when they debuted. but in btob's case they suck at lipsync like all of them prefer to sing live! they are the realest idol group to me sobs
Sungjae and Ilhoon are like babies here! I can't believe I grew up with their songs. Those times. I remember I used to feel sad for Peniel cuz he used to get less lines but now the line distribution are fair and btob is doing well in the scene.
still waiting for them to do a strong comeback..their new comeback is good but it is not as good as their debut song..Insane is definitely one of the song that really impressed me.
omg i can't even can we talk about how minhyuk's visual has always been hot af how the two maknaes look so fetus & rookie-like how peniel's so awkward standing around in those sunglasses (i bet its so dark for him HAHA) how hyunsik (my bias) looked so unappealing with his small eyes (& how his visual has improved from debut 😂) how eunkwang & changsub looked so cool you wouldn't imagine them being dorks and doing cringe-worthy aegyo
this maybe from before but I'm still feeling the same tension, nervousness, excitement and feeeelsss like when they debute....I missed this so much.... 😍😍😍😍😍 tnx for uploading again.....
i love all their title tracks ballads and dance songs. this song is amaaazing! i became a melody last year and im really surprised they werent more popular just from this song like its so good!
One of my fav song from them (irresistible lips is first). Hope their next comeback will be this kind of concept, and not ballad all the time. btob fighting ❤️💪🏻
Impressed with hyunsik : - he is so handsome at the same time i liked his tonned of voice! Superb Unique! ❤ liked if you agree. Btw , my bias is peniel 😘 and no lie, btob has their own talented.
i love how there’s a ‘?’ in the title as if they weren’t sure if this is btob’s debut song cause yeah, same, this is waaay too good to be a debut performance 😅 no one can deny that they performed this live with a super low MR volume haha couldn’t help but notice how few minhyuk and peniel’s lines were here, esp peuni! the ones who had the most parts were the longer cube trainees so, i wonder how far back before debut were minhyuk and peuni added in the lineup
i rarely comment on youtube but if i do, thats means i really love it..btob u gais ohsem..good in variety shows, singing and sungjae u a great actor..keep it up!
![[STAR ZOOM IN] BTOB 'You are so fly' Releasing cute dance 160512 EP.84](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DfMhdW6IUw0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[STAR ZOOM IN] BTOB 'You are so fly' Releasing cute dance 160512 EP.84](/img/tr.png)
![[HD] BTOB - Imagine + Insane (Hot Debut) @ 120322 Mnet M Countdown](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mLXfGmpj1V8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Eunkwang "Hyunsik, you are so romantic♥" [Hyena On the Keyboard/ 2018.04.25]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xFU01pMTZ0Y/mqdefault.jpg)
![[STAR ZOOM IN] BEAST - Fiction [M COUNTDOWN Ep.242] 160204 EP.49](/img/n.gif)
moment when sungjae and ilhoon was still cute baby and the hyungs' look was so innocent😂
Cindy Winando AGREE! they all looked so innocent meanwhile now😂😂😂
Yupp...
Chubby ilh0onie..
Chubby changsubbie...
yupppp so youngggg and cute now they grow so fast but their voice're still perfect ❤
they have been singing live from the start. People should really appreciate such groups even more.
Back then, i was like "why is Peniel is acting like a Terminator?"
At the redebut special, they said it was his concept, the company told him not to move. 😂😂😂
Hi. You
For me, this is their best song. 👍🏼
Same
Same
i miss their debut time😭😭during their debut era, sungjae and ilhoon still going to school..how time flies so fast
i think the position when debut era was:
eunkwang: main vocalist, leader of the group
hyunsik: lead vocalist, main dancer, visual
changsub: vocalist
sungjae: vocalist, rapper
ilhoon: main main main rapper
minhyuk: lead rapper, lead dancer, vocalist, visual
peniel: sub rapper 😂 (poor peniel)
& they are still normal person..
but now, all of them are vocalist, rapper, dancer, visual, composer, and abnormal person lol.. (there're no more different between main and lead because of the fair line distribution now)
proud of their progress!
Peniel: English lines
Also Minhyuk and Ilhoon are producing songs
Actually,changsub is lead voc not hyunsik😂but now all of them is main vocal💙
Nul even sungjae?
@@hibye1861 yep...all of btob member have a powerfull vocal..and 4 of them can highnote as main vocal
Srry my bad english 😅
i think insane + irresistible lips is so underrated, i like btob to doing this kind of concept for the next comeback
Nanang Effendy now they have ill be your man..this kind of sound also
I think insane and irresistable lips are nice songs.like it too..
Hi. You. Hi
Hi. You
honestly changsub really handsome and cute during their debut
also innocent😂
changsub stands out the most among the grp as everyone is like black and white concept but his shirt got green
Yeah i knoww
If only they knew shortly after this whole charismatic image they debut with, it will turns into a bunch of comdol (comedy idol). All thanks to changsub 😂
and Eunkwang
When MNET is not sure if it is their Debut Song. Yes MNET, probably. :D
Isn’t because they first performed this in a drama or am I imaging that
i didn't even noticed ahahah :)) omg mnet smh >.
Hi. You. Hi. You
ILHOONIE WITHOUT JAWLINE IS SHOO CUTEE😭😭😭
Back again here because i miss them so much.. Ilhoon looks so cute here with his chubby cheeks..
They are great and amazing from their debut era until now..!!
Ever since live perf and vocal is king of king woooo9ohoooooooooooooooooo
Hi. You
From no trophies for 3 and half year and then they get their #MissingYou6thWin
came here after watching the Wind and wish live and im telling you their vocals only get better
I'm surprised they sing without background vocal ! I know I make the best decision to stan them ❤
this was the early 3rd gen so yeahh, they stil sing live without much bg vocal ^^
they are so amazing they have been singing live since debut and their live singing is so stable its amazing! like for example other rookie group usually lipsync especially when they debuted. but in btob's case they suck at lipsync like all of them prefer to sing live! they are the realest idol group to me sobs
Omg, what am i doing? I was so late, I can't believe I lost 7years of my life😢😢
"Only one for me" is my first debut of them.
Ilhoon was such a baby 😍😍
2020 still can’t stay away from this song!! Who’s with me?
btob really suit with this genre song.... irresistible lip same too
2:08 I remember I use to love whenever Hyunsik did that part lol
hyunsik is more handsome now
I watch this in 2017 and I feel sooooo late become a melody 😥
so...IS THIS BABY BTOB????? omg it's my first time seeing this idk how to feel, this is awesome btw!
Hi. You
Sungjae and Ilhoon are like babies here! I can't believe I grew up with their songs. Those times. I remember I used to feel sad for Peniel cuz he used to get less lines but now the line distribution are fair and btob is doing well in the scene.
Who's here in 2020 missing BABY BTOB just like mee 🥺💙!?
LIVE KINGS 💥
They've always been doing great live performance even from the very first stage. Their vocals are so stable for someone who sing while dance that fast
back to the day when changsub hasn't lost his baby fat 😢 he is dieting really hard to loose his weight. i miss my baby's chubby cheeks ㅠㅠ
still waiting for them to do a strong comeback..their new comeback is good but it is not as good as their debut song..Insane is definitely one of the song that really impressed me.
Love this video as we get to hear their real precious voices, they all sound so good live, with all that dancing
Why in this era, ilhoon looks very sexy? T___T
My boys are singing live since their debut until now. I'm so proud of them
Hi. You
BTOB!! 💙 Solid vocals since debut!
Peniel with his 🕶 in these older performances never fails to make me 😂
Peniel+Minhyuk duet rap line "makes me go insane" ... Blessed my ears 💙💙
This was when I enter first year of middle school now I'm senior year at university.
Always legend and my best BTOB 💙
i love this song! its a classic! evem from the beginning, BTOB has been eating their cd in live performances. they're so talented and awesome! :)
omg i can't even
can we talk about how minhyuk's visual has always been hot af
how the two maknaes look so fetus & rookie-like
how peniel's so awkward standing around in those sunglasses (i bet its so dark for him HAHA)
how hyunsik (my bias) looked so unappealing with his small eyes (& how his visual has improved from debut 😂)
how eunkwang & changsub looked so cool you wouldn't imagine them being dorks and doing cringe-worthy aegyo
Their best song~~~
Even they r still baby here😍😍😊😊😀
ah man... time flies... all those baby faces!!
So much memory on this debut songs. one of the best song in 2012
Hi. You. His
throw back to those old day when they're so young, insane forever will be my favorite song ❤
this maybe from before but I'm still feeling the same tension, nervousness, excitement and feeeelsss like when they debute....I missed this so much.... 😍😍😍😍😍 tnx for uploading again.....
Their vocals were already insane
definitely an awesome debut song for them. hope to one day hear something similar again like this. aint gonna lie. miss this era. lol
i love all their title tracks ballads and dance songs. this song is amaaazing! i became a melody last year and im really surprised they werent more popular just from this song like its so good!
One of my fav song from them (irresistible lips is first). Hope their next comeback will be this kind of concept, and not ballad all the time. btob fighting ❤️💪🏻
they put too much power in this performance. from sing, dance and rap! 💖
They remind me of beast.. they're indeed beast junior... at some point, I would like btob to join around us after they finished with cube...
This song is where it all Started .. 😭😭😭
Im so happy for the Melodies who loved them since Debut ..
💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
they should make minhyuk and peniel rap together again it sound so good 😫💙💙
Strong live vocals for dayyysssss. AND THIS IS A DEBUT SONG/STAGE!!!
Easily one of the best kpop groups to have very good live songs!
watching this video make me realized how much they've improved and I'm here like a proud mother
I'm here after kingdom and..... I didn't knew they can dance...
Ilhoon fetus ㅠㅠㅠ
Impressed with hyunsik : - he is so handsome at the same time i liked his tonned of voice! Superb Unique! ❤ liked if you agree. Btw , my bias is peniel 😘 and no lie, btob has their own talented.
their songs in 2012-2013 is my JAM!! :)
Hope that they will stop Ballad in their nxt comeback..
they said they will.
Without ilhoon 😢
WOW I guess I'm sleeping that time this song was first come out. They're pretty good live singers. I should buy their album.
I miss that time ♡
sameㅠㅠ
Hi. 😪◀😪
i miss peniel`s hair he looks cute 😍 but today he looks manly with his bald head ❤
when btob was still cool (?) or at least protected their images lol
2000 days with BTOB :xxx
Chử Ngọc Ly 😍😍😢😢
Em coi lại thấy đứa nào cũng dthuong quá TT
omg my fetus babies😍😍😍 they look so cute esp fluffy ilhoon
so pretty is a bop like this on their album idk why they didn't make it as a single
Since debut they sing live!! KINGS👑
Peniel looks so stiff and awkward :)) and just look at Ilhoon's baby and innocent face, I mean, who can't resist that 😆
When you can actually hear them LIVE and not have the stupid backtracks cover up their beautiful voices
why i feel so exciting watching this?? I love you my babies ❤❤
Hi. You
Hi
my favorit song of btob
Hyunsik was their visual during this time
:P
Oh my god they were so young 😍😍😍 look at ilhoon with his baby face ❤❤❤❤
i love how there’s a ‘?’ in the title as if they weren’t sure if this is btob’s debut song cause yeah, same, this is waaay too good to be a debut performance 😅 no one can deny that they performed this live with a super low MR volume haha
couldn’t help but notice how few minhyuk and peniel’s lines were here, esp peuni! the ones who had the most parts were the longer cube trainees so, i wonder how far back before debut were minhyuk and peuni added in the lineup
KALIAN KERENNNNNNNN, IT'S WAS SO COOL.
that one fan that shouted when they finished and then the rest of the fans followed xD
Changsub was cute everytime 😍
One of the best performances I've ever seen ❤️ Their vocal line is amazing
this is so raw, so live. i like it, they're always good my boys melody forever
This is sooooo cool debut song!! 😍😍😍😍😍😍... Sorry for discovering you too late BTOB. 😳😳😳😲😲😲😲😲.. New fan here.
the best song from btob......
Ilhoon looks cute here, but i really apreciate that they sing live and no lipsync
first time I saw no lipsing ... good btob ... loce from Indonesia
i rarely comment on youtube but if i do, thats means i really love it..btob u gais ohsem..good in variety shows, singing and sungjae u a great actor..keep it up!
生歌が強すぎる、、BTOB♡
I think I only can recognize eunkwang and changsub in this performance the other look so different from now especially the maknae lines XD
I miss this BtoB...
love the beats to literal bits and their debut song too but golly gee the style and outfits were really of its time... real something
2020? Anyone?
Absolutely
2019?? 2:27 AM listening to this while making my lesson plan.
OMG same, BTOB and lesson plan is life❤
😂😂😂 it makes me awake... and able to think well. HAHA
amazing debut performance🎤their vocals were so stable
I MISS MY 11-YEAR-OLD ME . I WAS SO INTO THEM
one of the best live performances, wish groups performed like this today
This song is just great. Miss this era
Insane and Wow were my jam like 5? 6? Years ago? Like god damn this is such a throwback, I wasn’t even into K-Pop yet LOL
00:06 "YOOK SUNGJAEE" 😂
Proud Melody in here
Cute sungjae,, best live performace is btob 😍😍😍😍
I love this kind of 2nd gen vibe
Omgosh, I won't be able to express how addicted I was to this song!! 😂😍
best debut song
Omg the feels. Having goosebumps.