Agreed, he knows the game backwards - like Murray Mexted does too. But I wish JM would stop trying to use big words: sometimes he mispronounces them or uses them outta’ context. He should the wankers who are ‘media training’ him. Why not just front as the talented rugby kid from Gore? Wtf’s wrong with that?
Yes, I played beside Murray he was always opinionated but, he also had a good reason behind his thinking, as he has aged he has got better. Murray is a specialist on the area of the loose forwards and says some really interesting stuff. He just isn’t an experienced ex AB but still has considerable skin 8n the game as, the Managing Director at International Rugby Academy.
A,B, C or D - it does not matter, the lack of preparation for 2027 and lack of new blood is the main concerm, using the same players who have failed st the highest level since 2018 is the concern, time to invest
Clarke has show his need and his commitment for, and to, the jersey.. He's shown strength of character; vital for going to so-called "dark places", otherwise known as bleak adversity.
I give them a c +. I predicted at the beginning of the year that they would win 9 or 10 from 14 and they are on track. The pack is great. But the 10, 12, 13 are a real problem. Look at how well Alb passed , set up two tries. Plummer alb, proctor, for me. Worth a shot against Japan
The pack is looking great, but when analysing the gain line they are still not providing enough front foot ball for the backs, that is one of the reasons the backs are in such a state of flux.
Blackadder is far too injury prone. Barrett is ok but is liable to have brain explosions under pressure at 10. We need to find a solid, no frills number 10 who can kick goals in the high 80% range. I’d like to see Plumber given a few games at 10.
@hankgoldenshaft Yeah I think your right but you've got to set them up to flourish not fail,it's got to be the right game the right time you don't just chuck them out there with no plan in mind,they are very particular in how they introduce players,stuff we may not consider
I believe we need to be very careful about emphasizing the big 'three'. If the ABs aren't fully on their game, the dynamic Italians could also tip us up. We should be making mention of all four teams, not just 3! Heed the warning please.
Jordie Barrett!!!! are you serious Marty. FFS, he's one of the worst in the backline and his injury was a blessing in disguise. Do you really think he would have hit Sevu Reece on the chest like ALB did? Hell no.
Tjoe ur words sound like wow. Its difficult for me to deduce different, every and all serious disastrous lost Jordie was on field.Razor not seeing that AB GO DOWNHILL WHEN HE PLAY, BIT HIM NOT WE GO UP,
@@nathannweyer4741 Oh, so no different then players in the Ireland, Scotland, England, France to name a few squads then. See, is not a problem, is it?.
@@KiwiGraggle well is it though? Because each of those teams have only a handful of guys who are from another country and alot of them qualify on a perent or grandparent who ARE from their selected country. Nz are much much different, they give thousands of full scholarships to young promising player in samoa, tonga and fiji in hopes they will be good enough for the all blacks. So back and check how many all blacks are born in new zealand and let me know. I'd guess less than half
@nathannweyer4741 You Brits, whine, whine and whine. Just shut up, you have WW3 looming for the UK, and you are concerned about what I think. I could not care less what you think fella, alright 👍🏼. The arrogance of you Brits and you also misunderstand what I actually meant.
@nathannweyer4741 Censored my comment, so I am not allowed to reply with what you need to be told, so who cares. UK live in a snowflake and censored society that is all going to be ended soon. Take care, and whine at someone else fella, because I honestly do not care what you think. Cheers 👍🏼
The measure of sucess or failure is a measure that requires a Starting, Middle & End Point. So based on that, from what criteria of Rugby Stats are you drawing your conclusions. It's a question with no negative purpose or intention.❤
It does not matter how many points the ABs scored… the Boks would have found a way to score more and win.. People just look at point difference The 2015 ABs did just that… whatever opposition scored, they simply came back and won (even if it was tight)
It's delusional to think Aus is 10 in the world. The ranking system has its flaws, for example, fiji is ranked 9th and NZ beat them comfortably with a second string team. The team that beat fiji in San Diego would not beat Aus. I believe this current Aus team is better than Fiji, Italy and Scotland. Possibly better than Wales right now but unfortunately, for aus, they have to play South Africa, Nz and Argentina every year and they have been struggling to pick up ranking points
@@corneldebeer5578 the only game that was tight in 2015 was the WC SF.A nd you could put that down to the frog ref that did everything he could to get the saffers over the line.
Its too late to save the northern tour. We’re toast with no marmite. The new blood should have come in for Cane, Ioane, Perenara at least. The blunt razor’s cold and it stinks. (monkeys)
Thee secret to beat the all blacks is to do something that annoys them during the haka period, cause it's the only weapon they got now, England did it 2019 world cup semis, Ireland during 2-1 series win in new Zealand, Argentina did it this year RC first round, the boks did it in third round RC in Ellis Park
Should of told Ireland that secret in last years RWC b4 the QF no one gave them the memo 😂, you haven't even told us wat your dumb secret is,go see a doctor
Don't get the Blackadder thing. To me he's slow around the park, lacks punch in contact, and has spent most of his international career on the injury list at this stage. He's an earnest toiler, sure, but not all thst effective and clearly made of twigs.
Another real issue is where is the team that will go compete at the next two world cups for NZ? Since they not winning every game, why not select more younger players anyways 😂
That's a slightly different skill set, not sure if he has the tools for it. He has great footwork speed to burn, he does run hard and straight and would be hard to stop. Whether he has the hands to catch and pass and the vision is another thing. But hey his dad would be the best person to help him.
It's not a bad suggestion but probabbly won't happen. But we are missing a big strong ball runner like Nonu or Laumape at 12 or 13. I also liked the way SBW used to offload in the tackle. That skill is so under rated right now.
Marshall has become one of the best rugby analysts in the world.
You're joking , we all give em shit for talking shit , haha , ol marshy , greatest half ever , but knowledge , naaaaaa , we love our marshy
He’s analysis is as good as his pass from the base of the scrum .
Agreed, he knows the game backwards - like Murray Mexted does too. But I wish JM would stop trying to use big words: sometimes he mispronounces them or uses them outta’ context. He should the wankers who are ‘media training’ him.
Why not just front as the talented rugby kid from Gore? Wtf’s wrong with that?
When he first started off in broadcasting he was rubbish, but he has improved to the point where is well worth listening too.
He's a loudmouth alcoholic
Agree re Clark coming from 23 form to now he has put in the mahi and mental shift to earn his place without doubt. Good on him
Really enjoy discussion between Martin and Justin Marshall/Murray Mexted.Honest straight talking by experienced pundits.🇿🇦
Yes, I played beside Murray he was always opinionated but, he also had a good reason behind his thinking, as he has aged he has got better. Murray is a specialist on the area of the loose forwards and says some really interesting stuff. He just isn’t an experienced ex AB but still has considerable skin 8n the game as, the Managing Director at International Rugby Academy.
A,B, C or D - it does not matter, the lack of preparation for 2027 and lack of new blood is the main concerm, using the same players who have failed st the highest level since 2018 is the concern, time to invest
its the first year in the cycle. The 2023 all blacks only really started preparing for the world cup after they lost the irish series. we'll be fine.
ALB is twice the 12 or 13 Barret & Ioane are
With half the pace and none of the X factor.
Clarke has show his need and his commitment for, and to, the jersey.. He's shown strength of character; vital for going to so-called "dark places", otherwise known as bleak adversity.
I give them a c +. I predicted at the beginning of the year that they would win 9 or 10 from 14 and they are on track. The pack is great. But the 10, 12, 13 are a real problem. Look at how well Alb passed , set up two tries. Plummer alb, proctor, for me. Worth a shot against Japan
The pack is looking great, but when analysing the gain line they are still not providing enough front foot ball for the backs, that is one of the reasons the backs are in such a state of flux.
Robertson is a flake though, he won't. He is a club manager really.
Was forward pass 😂
Blackadder is far too injury prone. Barrett is ok but is liable to have brain explosions under pressure at 10. We need to find a solid, no frills number 10 who can kick goals in the high 80% range. I’d like to see Plumber given a few games at 10.
Sorry plumber won't be getting much of a go this year,maybe against Italy and Japan
@@ManaBlack208 yeah, that sounds about right. The ABs have always been super conservative with blooding new players which I think needs to change.
agree Plummer should be given a go.Better game manager need to blood 10's now
@hankgoldenshaft Yeah I think your right but you've got to set them up to flourish not fail,it's got to be the right game the right time you don't just chuck them out there with no plan in mind,they are very particular in how they introduce players,stuff we may not consider
I believe we need to be very careful about emphasizing the big 'three'. If the ABs aren't fully on their game, the dynamic Italians could also tip us up. We should be making mention of all four teams, not just 3! Heed the warning please.
Italy might trip us up 🤣 go see a doctor moron
True they're ranked higher than the Wallabies
Jordie Barrett!!!! are you serious Marty. FFS, he's one of the worst in the backline and his injury was a blessing in disguise. Do you really think he would have hit Sevu Reece on the chest like ALB did? Hell no.
Tjoe ur words sound like wow. Its difficult for me to deduce different, every and all serious disastrous lost Jordie was on field.Razor not seeing that AB GO DOWNHILL WHEN HE PLAY, BIT HIM NOT WE GO UP,
You mean forward pass?
id back roigard over TJ, hes class
Wallace Sititi looks a great player. Anyone know where in NZ he is from/born?
Yea a little nz town called Samoa 🇼🇸
@@nathannweyer4741 Oh, so no different then players in the Ireland, Scotland, England, France to name a few squads then. See, is not a problem, is it?.
@@KiwiGraggle well is it though? Because each of those teams have only a handful of guys who are from another country and alot of them qualify on a perent or grandparent who ARE from their selected country.
Nz are much much different, they give thousands of full scholarships to young promising player in samoa, tonga and fiji in hopes they will be good enough for the all blacks. So back and check how many all blacks are born in new zealand and let me know. I'd guess less than half
@nathannweyer4741 You Brits, whine, whine and whine. Just shut up, you have WW3 looming for the UK, and you are concerned about what I think.
I could not care less what you think fella, alright 👍🏼. The arrogance of you Brits and you also misunderstand what I actually meant.
@nathannweyer4741 Censored my comment, so I am not allowed to reply with what you need to be told, so who cares. UK live in a snowflake and censored society that is all going to be ended soon.
Take care, and whine at someone else fella, because I honestly do not care what you think. Cheers 👍🏼
Im amazed Marty gave the All Blacks a B grade . Very surprised.
The measure of sucess or failure is a measure that requires a Starting, Middle & End Point. So based on that, from what criteria of Rugby Stats are you drawing your conclusions. It's a question with no negative purpose or intention.❤
Whaddayamean?
Sititi
Vai'i
Caleb Clarke
Will Jordan
The Mighty Williams
Ratima
We have had a good year of return to form and new talent.
@@duncanwcraig9668 Caleb exceeding dad , eroni
Sadly not because of razor’s acumen often because of injuries.
They are starters now, tomorrow, next year. Please Razor
Marshy we lost tests with Cane & TJ already. What difference its going to make?The youngsters are raring to go.
Australia is ranked 10th. Hard to grade the ABs based on how they played against the 10th ranked team. It is delusional think the ABs have improved.
Australia played well, we showed much improved game management . Pity you can't see that, and I give the season c +. Not a B
We lost to south africa by less than a converted try, 6,that's not bad for a rebuild,I like where this team is heading
It does not matter how many points the ABs scored… the Boks would have found a way to score more and win.. People just look at point difference
The 2015 ABs did just that… whatever opposition scored, they simply came back and won (even if it was tight)
It's delusional to think Aus is 10 in the world. The ranking system has its flaws, for example, fiji is ranked 9th and NZ beat them comfortably with a second string team. The team that beat fiji in San Diego would not beat Aus. I believe this current Aus team is better than Fiji, Italy and Scotland. Possibly better than Wales right now but unfortunately, for aus, they have to play South Africa, Nz and Argentina every year and they have been struggling to pick up ranking points
@@corneldebeer5578 the only game that was tight in 2015 was the WC SF.A nd you could put that down to the frog ref that did everything he could to get the saffers over the line.
We need to play guys like Ruben Love man
He is
Says the. Truth
Clarke is cemented in the backline.
Its too late to save the northern tour. We’re toast with no marmite.
The new blood should have come in for Cane, Ioane, Perenara at least.
The blunt razor’s cold and it stinks. (monkeys)
Great interview but these were better without that goofy one news intro and outro.
Great to see ABs finally using the bench correctly. MACKENZIE is a bench player. He should NEVER start again.
Thee secret to beat the all blacks is to do something that annoys them during the haka period, cause it's the only weapon they got now, England did it 2019 world cup semis, Ireland during 2-1 series win in new Zealand, Argentina did it this year RC first round, the boks did it in third round RC in Ellis Park
That is why I 💯 want to Abs to drop the Haka 100%
Should of told Ireland that secret in last years RWC b4 the QF no one gave them the memo 😂, you haven't even told us wat your dumb secret is,go see a doctor
Don't get the Blackadder thing. To me he's slow around the park, lacks punch in contact, and has spent most of his international career on the injury list at this stage. He's an earnest toiler, sure, but not all thst effective and clearly made of twigs.
Another real issue is where is the team that will go compete at the next two world cups for NZ?
Since they not winning every game, why not select more younger players anyways 😂
Rieko consistent selection, lackluster performances
Yes, he is not repaying Razor at all. Procter are waiting
He should be on the wing instead of Reece
Haka performance is good😂
Marshall is a disgrace, he should be talking to a hot dog in front of him not a microphone
Caleb Clarke has to play at 12
He barely has the brain for wing.
@@Marius_vanderLubbe😂
@@Marius_vanderLubbe don’t be a C U on TUESDAY
That's a slightly different skill set, not sure if he has the tools for it. He has great footwork speed to burn, he does run hard and straight and would be hard to stop. Whether he has the hands to catch and pass and the vision is another thing. But hey his dad would be the best person to help him.
It's not a bad suggestion but probabbly won't happen. But we are missing a big strong ball runner like Nonu or Laumape at 12 or 13. I also liked the way SBW used to offload in the tackle. That skill is so under rated right now.
Mark always trashed tupou so what does he have to say now lol