A Serious Improvement For Minecraft

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 8 тис.

  • @pedrocarregosa15
    @pedrocarregosa15 5 років тому +25109

    ''no.''
    -Mojang, 2019

    • @aqueousdog
      @aqueousdog 5 років тому +1739

      "could you imagine if we made more big updates like the last two that would be hilarious"
      -Mojang, 2019

    • @WaterBias
      @WaterBias 5 років тому +713

      No
      -nojang 2019

    • @raspberrymilkshake5782
      @raspberrymilkshake5782 5 років тому +301

      @@aqueousdog The Nether update is a thing.

    • @spinesauce2687
      @spinesauce2687 5 років тому +780

      "Bees" -Mojang 2019

    • @zoinksscoob6523
      @zoinksscoob6523 5 років тому +311

      @@raspberrymilkshake5782 let's be honest here, it's not that big.

  • @leotard2536
    @leotard2536 5 років тому +8374

    "What good is a ship if you can't sail it?"
    As a Minecraft shipbuilder, I felt that

    • @AvroNotArvo
      @AvroNotArvo 5 років тому +491

      Put that on a cv.
      -Graduated from Harvard
      -Ran for president
      -Professional Minecraft shipbuilder

    • @oisin7748
      @oisin7748 5 років тому +113

      Do you know the mod "Archimedes' ships"?

    • @vernstein3877
      @vernstein3877 5 років тому +39

      wouldnt that be called minecraft shipwright?

    • @mashedtomato2079
      @mashedtomato2079 5 років тому +6

      How bout the slow minecarts?

    • @heavens.sorrow
      @heavens.sorrow 5 років тому +3

      Read it as he said it.

  • @TheNeatwork
    @TheNeatwork 4 роки тому +3176

    Whitelight: Change everything but the Nether
    Mojang: Changes only the Nether

    • @HDTomo
      @HDTomo 4 роки тому +20

      Me: why did you literally say "change the nether?" (Use ** bro)
      I got the joke just telling you

    • @diamondbowgamer3812
      @diamondbowgamer3812 4 роки тому +126

      Also whitelight: "Diamonds will always be the rarest and best resource."
      Also mojang: *No.*

    • @justronjay9226
      @justronjay9226 4 роки тому +5

      @@HDTomo Me: **I refuse to follow your rules.**

    • @HDTomo
      @HDTomo 4 роки тому +1

      @@justronjay9226 *!oh right? But I can not follow them in a worse way!*

    • @bluevolt2014
      @bluevolt2014 4 роки тому +2

      Noah what are you doing here

  • @activevertex4475
    @activevertex4475 5 років тому +1028

    “Our 5 legged friends”, horse’s don’t have 5 legs they have- OH...oh...

    • @shadysam7161
      @shadysam7161 4 роки тому +137

      yeah the tail

    • @pup1030
      @pup1030 4 роки тому +112

      @@shadysam7161 yup, that's what they meant

    • @shadysam7161
      @shadysam7161 4 роки тому +62

      @@pup1030 see? this guy gets it

    • @Arenuphis
      @Arenuphis 4 роки тому +43

      Did he mean all horses have s fifth leg?
      I guess that explains the simplicity of the breeding system

    • @activevertex4475
      @activevertex4475 4 роки тому +15

      Joakim Magnusson Fredlund Nope. Only the male ones.

  • @cthulhufhtagn7520
    @cthulhufhtagn7520 4 роки тому +1024

    seriously, did everyone miss that he called horses "five legged friends"

  • @egirlSkeletor
    @egirlSkeletor 5 років тому +3830

    "what if minecraft was dwarf fortress?"
    honestly sold

    • @steven1671
      @steven1671 5 років тому +316

      The reason why this has not been done yet is because no one wants to play a game that renders at 1 frame per second. The dwarf A.I. in DF takes so long to compute that giant fortresses with hundreds of dwarves can lower the framerate to 5 fps. And this is in a game with really really primitive graphics! Just imagine how slow and unplayable Minecraft would be if it had all of the dynamic systems that he mentioned in this video. There is no way to optimize such a game, so only a supercomputer could run it. Does anyone around here own a supercomputer? I sure as hell don't. And I'm sure most gamers don't. I'm sure a few extra dynamic elements could be added to Minecraft without sacrificing performance (and Minecraft could be optimized more), but the way he gushes on and on about shiny and interesting gameplay elements without considering why they haven't been done yet makes Whitelight sound a little ignorant about game development in general.

    • @TheAlison1456
      @TheAlison1456 5 років тому +164

      @@steven1671 That point is actually good. Meaning, I want to see someone refute it.

    • @Kydino
      @Kydino 5 років тому +72

      @@steven1671 I just hope consumer grade quantum computing happens sooner. Once we reach that point I believe we'll be able to create such experiences.

    • @ghostinthearchives
      @ghostinthearchives 5 років тому +28

      @@Kydino honestly, i would love to play a version of minecraft like this, but it's hard for me to convince myself to pay for a reasonably expensive computer, which is why i play minecraft on my low quality laptop anyway

    • @Eji1700
      @Eji1700 5 років тому +46

      @@steven1671 While it's true people often don't think of the insane cost of something as detailed as DF, I think the main dynamic system most OG MC players wanted was just simple physics. I may not need 200 properly handled AI's, but a basic gravity/mass/liquid system would take what started with modded pistons started forever ago and turn it into what many always wanted. DF gameplay half about managing your population and dealing with threats, and half about draining the ocean/paving over hell/lobbing enemies into the stratosphere.

  • @louiszhang3050
    @louiszhang3050 4 роки тому +2039

    "A series of dimensions, all randomly generated"
    Mojang: No, but we'll add it as our April Fools' Update in 2020

    • @yinyangs9560
      @yinyangs9560 4 роки тому +89

      "Just buy it in the Minecraft Marketplace"

    • @thesmileyman6817
      @thesmileyman6817 4 роки тому

      Lmao

    • @soupgirl1864
      @soupgirl1864 4 роки тому +47

      Imagine, though, if that was a test bed for actually implementing this. Remember how everyone was saying "You should actually keep this in."

    • @sehr.geheim
      @sehr.geheim 4 роки тому +20

      @@soupgirl1864 the April Fools Joke wasn't the dimensions, it was the fact that it was a joke and how they were implemented. 1.16 will be the infinite dimensions update!

    • @chrisdawson1776
      @chrisdawson1776 4 роки тому +9

      They stole Jay Exci’s idea

  • @liamf9003
    @liamf9003 4 роки тому +1997

    Someone please make a mod pack based off his ideas. It would be amazing.

    • @rightandreadytofight1468
      @rightandreadytofight1468 4 роки тому +29

      Wow no response

    • @abe9818
      @abe9818 4 роки тому +124

      you can combine multiple to get close to his ideas, but not exact

    • @remmoze
      @remmoze 4 роки тому +174

      do you realize that all that would take several years on every day development? People who don't know programming just don't understand how hard and long it is to make minecraft a "dynamic" game which you can't easily exploit.

    • @kitgoostrey6162
      @kitgoostrey6162 4 роки тому +56

      The winter idea is fantastic

    • @felipecavalcante3266
      @felipecavalcante3266 4 роки тому +9

      @@remmoze oof

  • @redstonerti9918
    @redstonerti9918 5 років тому +1007

    "No more of this ugly ass cheese"
    Possibly my favourite quote of all time

    • @saulomon1700
      @saulomon1700 5 років тому

      same bruh haahahhaa

    • @rusti33
      @rusti33 5 років тому +1

      i would like the comment, but there's already 420 likes

    • @Muimina
      @Muimina 5 років тому

      @@HenryMarkle 20:38

    • @slevinchannel7589
      @slevinchannel7589 7 місяців тому +1

      What a non-dynamic game. Whatever i build, no one will ever live in it. ANd the existence and meaning of Shipwrecks is just silly: not that we didnt knew that already thx to Iron-Golems being known to be build by Villagers, but we truly do live in a dumbed-down version of Minecraft
      !

  • @johnsmithworth9296
    @johnsmithworth9296 5 років тому +1343

    "im talking Game of Thrones winter"
    Well I guess we all know who voted for snowier snow

    • @puddlel1ama327
      @puddlel1ama327 5 років тому +51

      It isn't just snowier.
      It's snowier than before.

    • @ninenezumi
      @ninenezumi 5 років тому

      that is good

    • @erinkarp6317
      @erinkarp6317 5 років тому

      Me

    • @camwthedestroyer8737
      @camwthedestroyer8737 5 років тому

      everything will be fine now that the snow is snowier than before

    • @p11_studios
      @p11_studios 4 роки тому

      Dumb decision. We needed swamp and a new wood type 😂 sorry, I’m still salty

  • @plasmaxander912
    @plasmaxander912 4 роки тому +1236

    "imagine breeding a golden apple tree you could re-enact the bible"
    i dont think this world is ready for minecraft jesus

  • @raec1684
    @raec1684 4 роки тому +663

    it just makes me sad watching this because i want to play THAT version of minecraft

    • @exolotyl9044
      @exolotyl9044 4 роки тому +52

      It sounds so fun doing all of this, so many different kinds of runs you could do, do you want to be a king or do you just want to run it solo for the most challenging experience, do you want to strive to be the strongest warrior or just a guy learning the most about the world he got dropped into

    • @yeahkeen2905
      @yeahkeen2905 4 роки тому +3

      Download mods.

    • @raec1684
      @raec1684 4 роки тому +33

      @@yeahkeen2905 Thats not the same thing...

    • @Archris17
      @Archris17 4 роки тому +21

      @Hugo Fergusson Please god make it good. I literally go to sleep crying that I can't play this version of Minecraft.

    • @celtoucan4956
      @celtoucan4956 4 роки тому +5

      @Hugo Fergusson If you get this right, you will be a hero. Thanks in advance

  • @militarymist1199
    @militarymist1199 5 років тому +1394

    "You can breed a golden apple tree and recreate the bible."
    The bible 2: Electric bugaloo.

  • @zachbraunstein9478
    @zachbraunstein9478 5 років тому +1075

    "You can re-enact the Bible."
    Mojang: You have my attention

    • @SamucaGamer100
      @SamucaGamer100 5 років тому +8

      nah men their norse, you have to be able to re-enact norse myth in the game

    • @beurteilung713
      @beurteilung713 5 років тому +4

      @@SamucaGamer100
      Dude, there are very few people who follow Astartu in Scandinavian countries. Christianity is the most popular religion in all of them, even Iceland. Kinda off topic, but Iceland's Churches are probably some of the most badass things i have ever seen.

    • @AnythingbutThi5
      @AnythingbutThi5 5 років тому +2

      "You could reanact the bible!"
      christian minecraft servers: its free real estate

  • @insertrandomusernameherera9432
    @insertrandomusernameherera9432 5 років тому +375

    What if Pillagers held dominance over a biome? The mansion could act as their main headquarters and towers could essentially be bases set up across the biome. Groups of Pillagers can hunt animals and act as a threat for the player during the day. Monsters could also be hostile towards Pillagers, which could increase security around the towers and the mansion during night time. Each time you clear out a tower, the less control they have over the biome. The mansion itself could act as a sort of endgame dungeon where you fight all types of Pillagers and find rare items, defeating the leader would remove the Pillagers from the biome entirely.

    • @misterfister15
      @misterfister15 5 років тому +15

      i agree with this notion

    • @rafaelrubio4443
      @rafaelrubio4443 5 років тому +19

      Now mix this with Whitelist idea of hiring villagers as soldiers, make a raiding party to help you out and clear said towers faster, or you can do it on your own.
      The idea is to keep it possible both ways and let the player choose which way they prefer, maybe you could siege the woodland mansion and slowly kill the pillagers while you set up camp in front of their mansion, or maybe you go all in, put some TNT on their gate, blow it up and infiltrate guns blazing and all.
      So much is possible, im acutally playing RLcraft mod pack and the only thing missing would be hireable villagers to help you out if im being honest.
      the modpack already brings so many enemies and mobs is crazy, dungeons, seasons, dragons a lot more weapons to play with, its lots of fun.

    • @Lysergic_
      @Lysergic_ 5 років тому +8

      @@rafaelrubio4443 I feel like if they add hireable villagers, then they should also add in areas that are almost entirely impossible to raid alone, because then there would be a great functionality to the hiring aspect. Not completely impossible, but it should be hard enough to where you could choose between having to get a full set of enchanted diamond armor+tools vs. iron armor and tools and a bunch of villagers

    • @Vexvaporrub
      @Vexvaporrub 5 років тому

      @@Lysergic_ and then I feel like I'm playing skyrim.

    • @itrisky773
      @itrisky773 5 років тому +1

      woah... that sounds good
      but, please dont raid automaticly :D

  • @beawolfe
    @beawolfe 4 роки тому +164

    Personally I love expressing myself creatively in Minecraft, and I see it as my main goal when playing. But creative mode holds absolutely no interest to me, I want to actually put effort in for the reward, or it's no reward at all.

    • @Capytalistbara_edits
      @Capytalistbara_edits 4 роки тому +10

      Totally agree more satisfying doing it urself

    • @MultiZelda13
      @MultiZelda13 4 роки тому +10

      I agree and disagree. I was enjoying the hell out of my survival world. I loved the feeling of having a vision and the obstacles in the way of achieving that vision. But then I decided I wanted to build a giant tree 150 blocks high and something like that just isn't even viable in survival considering fall damage alone, not to mention the time it would take to harvest the materials. It's been a very different and somewhat less gratifying experience since I switched to creative mode... but I've also yet to finish my project (nor think it ever will be as my ambition scales over time). Whatever dynamics that did exist in survival are stripped completely in creative and I really do miss that.

    • @Sidharth_V_Jain
      @Sidharth_V_Jain 4 роки тому +2

      @@MultiZelda13 COUGH elytra COUGH

    • @MultiZelda13
      @MultiZelda13 4 роки тому

      @Marcus _ its not the same

    • @luciferlyset7543
      @luciferlyset7543 4 роки тому

      I just set bigger goals when I play creative, build a city rather than a village sort of thing.

  • @neildodd1319
    @neildodd1319 5 років тому +4371

    Minecraft community: we would like a cave update and more dynamic villages with economies
    Mojang: You said you want bees?

    • @jhinthevirtuoso4886
      @jhinthevirtuoso4886 5 років тому +106

      the nether update was needed though.

    • @MonkeyShark
      @MonkeyShark 5 років тому +52

      and let's name this mob something edgy like "Hoglin" instead of something cool like, "Hellhog"

    • @cgbiller
      @cgbiller 5 років тому +127

      @@MonkeyShark hellhog is edgier than Hoglin

    • @MarineRec
      @MarineRec 5 років тому +18

      you like jazz?

    • @MrMastoris
      @MrMastoris 5 років тому +50

      Adding bees was about the honey block, which expands redstone capability like crazy

  • @conteropolska
    @conteropolska 5 років тому +1352

    Minecraft before this video: "Sandbox, aciton game"
    Minecraft after this video: "Super extreme straregy, rpg and economy game"

    • @evaahh9584
      @evaahh9584 5 років тому +121

      CC yeah. It’d make this game fucking biblical but this much isn’t possible

    • @energyipad5566
      @energyipad5566 5 років тому +14

      if only

    • @ok2298
      @ok2298 5 років тому +9

      Reminds me of settlers of catan

    • @HiHello-wb9yq
      @HiHello-wb9yq 5 років тому +46

      @@evaahh9584 You're most likely wrong about that. Mods accomplish a lot of stuff like this already even with the limits of Minecraft, if the game itself was changed then it would help even more than mods and pave the way for mods that could make this entire video a reality.

    • @evaahh9584
      @evaahh9584 5 років тому +16

      Hi Hello yeah, but that ups the minimum requirements a fuck ton.

  • @mememan3799
    @mememan3799 5 років тому +901

    This is how me and my friends play Minecraft already. We all go off and build kingdoms and have a meta. If we actually had citizens and usable buildings and transportation systems..... that would seriously upgrade our experience.

    • @matttepp3038
      @matttepp3038 5 років тому +32

      Have you tried TekTopia?

    • @someguy9496
      @someguy9496 5 років тому +2

      Put villagers in the kingdoms then

    • @janneswilmink487
      @janneswilmink487 5 років тому +15

      Maybe take a look at the "Minecolonies" mod or simialr ones.

    • @mememan3799
      @mememan3799 5 років тому +1

      Jannes Wilmink unfortunately, (as of now atleast) we all play on console :(

    • @mememan3799
      @mememan3799 5 років тому +1

      Matt Tepp sadly we are on console at least for now

  • @johnwalker7474
    @johnwalker7474 4 роки тому +104

    Imagine you've spent an entire in-game year building an empire, making political friends and enemies with all the villagers, when one day you get a new achievement: "Winter is Here"

  • @emilianobustamante5013
    @emilianobustamante5013 4 роки тому +2405

    I'm secretly hoping that bees were released as a distraction while they secretly work on a huge update.

  • @Kalina47
    @Kalina47 5 років тому +661

    “I didn’t know my retinas could BE erect until today.”

  • @bmobmo6438
    @bmobmo6438 5 років тому +278

    So basically you're suggesting we combine Millenaire, MineColonies, Ancient Warfare and Tektopia into one super mod.
    Sold.

    • @GuiSmith
      @GuiSmith 5 років тому +35

      Also a seasons mod, probably Dynamic Trees, and some kind of dungeon quest progression mod like the Twilight Forest. That’s actually a very small modpack but with the most intense changelog over vanilla.

    • @dougo3592
      @dougo3592 5 років тому

      Bmobmo64 exactly haha but better minecolonies could be better

    • @nihitkhunteta6137
      @nihitkhunteta6137 5 років тому +1

      Might as well add the RLCraft in it too.

    • @xaid7486
      @xaid7486 4 роки тому +9

      @@nihitkhunteta6137 rlcraft has too many things imo

    • @minterj9916
      @minterj9916 4 роки тому +4

      @@GuiSmith add in optifine, archimedes ships, and biomes o plenty and its perfect for exploration

  • @oblivious6398
    @oblivious6398 4 роки тому +286

    You just said all my dreams for a perfect Minecraft and i was so shocked that it was all so Accurate i really wish mojang will implement that lets just pray for it to be true

    • @cheesemccheese5780
      @cheesemccheese5780 3 роки тому +2

      nice profile.

    • @thatfinegentleman
      @thatfinegentleman 3 роки тому +2

      Or you can wait for Hytale to come out

    • @ember2933
      @ember2933 3 роки тому +2

      One of the main selling points of Minecraft is it's simplicity, everything Whitelight mentions in the video would make Minecraft feel more complicated than it already is, if everything he mentions were to be added to the game then a lot of people would protest against this mainly because this makes the game more complicated and deter their younger playerbase because of the relations system with villages (A.K.A. politics), meaning rival villages would send raids or attacks if they favor one village too much making them face the consequence of favoring one village over the other, and children don't like consequences

    • @thatfinegentleman
      @thatfinegentleman 3 роки тому +7

      @@ember2933 have you watched the video? Its a new gamemode, not a change to the game

    • @ember2933
      @ember2933 3 роки тому +2

      @@thatfinegentleman Yes, the things he described like the CK3 things are optional, but that doesn't mean the things like seasons are optional and is quite damaging to the game's main audience.
      Minecraft is mainly tailored towards kids and if you add winter alongside the features that come with it then a 7 year old would have a pretty hard time and find it hard to see Minecraft as a memorable game if it's this hard as his pet sheep or chicken would die to the frost with him included as all of his torches die out and mobs spawn around his house.
      Whitelight treats this game like it's a 3D CK3-Terraria hybrid.
      In order for Minecraft to live it needs children to find the game memorable and fun to them, making them come back to the game even as adults, and thus it has to be kept simple.
      If you want all of these thing then just download mods, it may not feel right because it's not official but if all of the things mentioned in the video were added then the game would lose a chunk of its main audience due to increased difficulty.
      With mods you can turn Minecraft into Hard Minecraft or quite literally into 3D Terraria and even Command & Conquer, I'm fine with that as long as it's not in the base game because Vanilla Minecraft is tailored mainly to kids.

  • @masefield9485
    @masefield9485 5 років тому +747

    2011 - better than wolves mod
    2019 - we need a better than bees mod

    • @bcgcentral7862
      @bcgcentral7862 5 років тому +13

      We could really use Better Than Wolves now.

    • @halotroop2288
      @halotroop2288 5 років тому +18

      @@bcgcentral7862 I've been seriously thinking about becoming the next FlowerChild, lately. This video hits the nail on the head for all the things *I already wanted to do* with a mod, or a Minecraft clone.

    • @MrDrury27
      @MrDrury27 5 років тому +3

      holy shit better than wolves, such nostalgia

    • @MrOverjay
      @MrOverjay 5 років тому +1

      Enter the Roost mod

    • @defensivekobra3873
      @defensivekobra3873 5 років тому +1

      What part of childhood did i miss?

  • @dancingdonga72
    @dancingdonga72 5 років тому +429

    Mojang: releases villages and pillage update
    Whitelight: Do it again

  • @ItsOnlyRocknRoll13
    @ItsOnlyRocknRoll13 4 роки тому +641

    I think the only things I've ever wanted in Minecraft are functioning ships, a much higher and deeper build limit, more realistic terrain generation so mountains are actually huge and big functioning contraptions like windmills, water wheels and such.

    • @bilbo_gamers6417
      @bilbo_gamers6417 4 роки тому +16

      Yeah. I mean, we can make do with mods for now ofc. I think Minecraft is mostly dead in spirit, the dev team isn't so interested in big sweeping changes or returning to the early simplicity.

    • @csongorhunyady1399
      @csongorhunyady1399 4 роки тому +11

      Are you into mods? There is a really great mod called "Create", it ads water wheels, windmills and whole bunch of cool things. Check it out if you are interested

    • @Conglomeration
      @Conglomeration 4 роки тому +4

      @@csongorhunyady1399 Create is one of my top favorite mods.

    • @JacesSanctum
      @JacesSanctum 4 роки тому +4

      There will be an update to mountain generation in the future.

    • @drakkus1236
      @drakkus1236 4 роки тому +4

      You my friend, need to try the create mod

  • @somenonsense7997
    @somenonsense7997 3 роки тому +154

    Personally, I feel like the suggested village overhauls are a dangerous path to tread, for too much or too powerful and you may push the game to be CK3 in block form; too little or too weak and you risk making mechanics of no relevance.
    Furthermore, even if you strike the balance just right, such that engaging in villager affairs is not the sole best course of game play(best for ambiguity's sake), there still exists the issue of cluttering up the gameplay and detracting from the game's creative aspects.

    • @rancidblock5615
      @rancidblock5615 3 роки тому +27

      And if the villages are too good. Why build a house anyways?, or crops? or defend yourself when there is guards? or fight for your "kingdom" when you can find one 3000 blocks away

    • @derpherp1810
      @derpherp1810 2 роки тому +18

      These are non issues holding the game back from what it could be. I think the kingdom mechanics would enhance the gameplay drastically, besides this won’t be for everyone. Not everyone needs guards and farmers working for them 24/7. Many players will still enjoy the simple humble farmers life.

    • @TTancevat
      @TTancevat 2 роки тому +9

      @@rancidblock5615 You would want to take the approach that minecrafts older structures did, the buildings would look, and function OK. Not good, not bad, but enough so that anyone, of any age, skill, or experience could do better, and that it would be encouraged.

    • @mystorioconscript3787
      @mystorioconscript3787 Рік тому +2

      @@rancidblock5615 A Rep system could fix that, You would have to do something very major to get their respect and allow you to live in their Village and have access to their resources, like saving a village from Raids. By default, Villages wouldn't let you live in the Village, you can't open chests, or sleep in beds there, if you steal something from Furnaces and other inventories, you'll be escorted out of the Village and not allowed in anymore.

    • @mystorioconscript3787
      @mystorioconscript3787 Рік тому

      And if you build buildings in the Village, then they will simply tear down the building.

  • @DRKNT640
    @DRKNT640 5 років тому +2566

    Everyone: why won’t mojang do this? 😡
    CPU of the average player: *laughs in java*

    • @ItsTeaMagic
      @ItsTeaMagic 5 років тому +135

      They have plenty of money and resources to do so
      It's all about money. Real reason is: "Money still flowing, why the heck we need spend more money on it? It just works"

    • @hellsredeemer
      @hellsredeemer 5 років тому +289

      @@ItsTeaMagic That has absolutely nothing to do with what he's making a joke about. He's referring about the quality of the processor for the average player's computer. Minecraft is heavily CPU based and believe me when I say that running a bunch of AI on a bad CPU is a fucking NIGHTMARE on java. So a lot of these suggestion have heavy technological concerns.

    • @davilimalol4612
      @davilimalol4612 5 років тому +39

      Welp, they didn't make bedrock for nothing.

    • @maggieent3215
      @maggieent3215 5 років тому +26

      @@davilimalol4612 java is an important part of minecraft. MC has to run on computers, too.

    • @davilimalol4612
      @davilimalol4612 5 років тому +14

      @@maggieent3215 but bedrock runs on PC (windows 10 edition)

  • @duuby
    @duuby 5 років тому +723

    "how about no and here is snowier snow"
    -Mojang, 2019

    • @braydunce
      @braydunce 5 років тому +7

      DaCornmonster except we have to wait HALF A YEAR FOR THIS SHITE

    • @kaanuysal579
      @kaanuysal579 5 років тому

      well, people really wanted it

    • @ww-pw6di
      @ww-pw6di 5 років тому +8

      ​@@braydunce Every 5 seconds of the video would take half a year to add.

    • @braydunce
      @braydunce 5 років тому +1

      w w except it shouldn’t. It’s the top selling game... I mean come one

    • @ww-pw6di
      @ww-pw6di 5 років тому +7

      @@braydunce shouldn't take as long as Mojang takes, but at the same time this video overestimates the ease of implementing everything and just lists on more and more complex things that change it from just a tiny thing to a 10 year road map where first 5 will have little to no updates.

  • @Whitelight
    @Whitelight  5 років тому +649

    Being realistic is lethargic so I didn't tackle it in the video. I'd like to say here that nothing bar the somewhat complex AI on the new villagers hasn't been done to some degree with mods. Everything's possible. Tektopia is the closest thing we have to these villages, and I'd love people to check it out.

    • @nafin9063
      @nafin9063 5 років тому +22

      Whitelight minecraft is procedurally generated so making towns like this work would be troubling.

    • @allegedgaming306
      @allegedgaming306 5 років тому +1

      What do you think of the Nether Update, trying to make the Nether more interesting and livable/survivable.

    • @ravency4377
      @ravency4377 5 років тому +2

      I want a game like this, but I'm unsure about Mojang's stance for this development.

    • @hellothere-sf1gl
      @hellothere-sf1gl 5 років тому +3

      WHAT if the beacon powers your villagers or its golems?

    • @Whitelight
      @Whitelight  5 років тому +17

      @@nafin9063 Good point. I know millenaire does something like it, so I wonder how they managed it.

  • @nathanielblubaugh4656
    @nathanielblubaugh4656 4 роки тому +87

    I agree with everything u said however if the game doesn’t seem to be “vanilla enough” to the majority of players it could ruin the game, I think that’s why They are scared to make huge changes like that

    • @atypicalatoms9425
      @atypicalatoms9425 4 роки тому +22

      A simple fix is to add a "vanilla" option that removes all of those added features.

    • @5koot13
      @5koot13 4 роки тому +16

      @@atypicalatoms9425 or make it so that the bedrock community can play older versions so that both sides of minecraft can be happy and revert to older versions

    • @mouthshovel
      @mouthshovel 3 роки тому

      @@5koot13 yes, I want to go back to classic console sometimes and maybe they could even port alpha to bedrock so we could play that too.

    • @masterdeetectiv9520
      @masterdeetectiv9520 3 роки тому +3

      @@atypicalatoms9425 ah yes, lets add features that a majority of people wont like but they can play old version

    • @atypicalatoms9425
      @atypicalatoms9425 3 роки тому +3

      @@masterdeetectiv9520 I said a simple fix not a perfect one, also my idea is as simple as a toggle on the main menu.

  • @chakowe
    @chakowe 5 років тому +664

    Take a shot every time he says intrinsic or extrinsic, that’s a true game of survival.

    • @williammanness9943
      @williammanness9943 5 років тому +15

      Your liver would become a creeper

    • @lawbot2966
      @lawbot2966 5 років тому

      dont forget to turn off hardcore mode, unless you want to die ig

  • @0hmeg4
    @0hmeg4 4 роки тому +794

    “You go down to 12 and start stripping” - Whitelist

  • @Alex-ln9dn
    @Alex-ln9dn 5 років тому +316

    "basically, cave update, innit."
    -Whitelight

  • @Lukethelion3
    @Lukethelion3 4 роки тому +64

    Whitelight: “go down to 12 and start stripping” 4 hours later, my parents walk in only to see me half naked dancing to pigstep at level 12

  • @grox2417
    @grox2417 5 років тому +891

    "A serious improvement for Minecraft"
    *Literally describes Minecraft 2.0*

    • @iWhisperASMR
      @iWhisperASMR 5 років тому +28

      Most of this has been done on some level. He showed the boats, and there is infinite world generators already, one that even have new block tiles like the cancer white blocks that just spread until the entire pocket dimension is gone. Also Ender Man Levels in permant darkness that have the surface struck with lighting none stop while they all live in giant underground caverns with nothing but The End Dirt blocks mostly.
      I mean there's mods with full on magic and lunar temples and genetic modification and immersive biomes.
      Only real change is implementing more complicated systems with villagers.
      We already have full automated computer storage and mining using nuclear reactors built in replica of the real thing with numerous energy types and cross compatibility with them.
      Minecraft 2 would be just like Skyrim is to Morrowwind.

    • @andrewyeeter6068
      @andrewyeeter6068 5 років тому +8

      @@iWhisperASMR A simple no would have done the trick

    • @KevinMcScrooge
      @KevinMcScrooge 5 років тому +7

      @@andrewyeeter6068 no

    • @themysteriousstranger4580
      @themysteriousstranger4580 5 років тому +18

      @@iWhisperASMR Mods are mostly just extensions of already existing game systems. Dynamic gameplay would create NEW SYSTEMS there is nothing like complex environmental interaction described in this video in the modding community today.

    • @JD-wv1yi
      @JD-wv1yi 5 років тому +5

      Hytale is minecraft 2

  • @NotA3xCombo
    @NotA3xCombo 5 років тому +407

    As long as a villager doesn't start constantly reminding me that another settlement needs my help, then this is good.

    • @kylestanley7843
      @kylestanley7843 5 років тому +19

      That would be scarier than herobrine

    • @mijkolsmith
      @mijkolsmith 5 років тому +6

      Spore flashbacks

    • @tobiasziesmann1720
      @tobiasziesmann1720 5 років тому +2

      @@mijkolsmith So true! We need a new Spore that still allows for empire building and discovery. That game was amazing!

    • @spleendid8705
      @spleendid8705 5 років тому +10

      Fallout 4 flashbacks

    • @FranciumBoron
      @FranciumBoron 5 років тому +9

      But what about that one settlement that needs your help? Here, I'll mark it on your map.
      - Preston Garvey.

  • @brandonb7079
    @brandonb7079 5 років тому +294

    Imagine reading the patch notes and seeing "Added Herobrine's Castle, and Herobrine"

    • @r.a.g.3428
      @r.a.g.3428 5 років тому +18

      That shit be so surreal

    • @thealchemistking4063
      @thealchemistking4063 5 років тому +17

      The horror, of, EVERYONE. It would be incredible

    • @Alzter0
      @Alzter0 5 років тому +32

      They should fucking do this. As cringy as Herobrine is he's basically an official Minecraft character. And if he had a fucking castle AND a boss fight? I'd fucking go insane man.

    • @barrittchambers8940
      @barrittchambers8940 5 років тому +3

      Bruh just reading that gave me goosebumbs

    • @sameendusk2623
      @sameendusk2623 5 років тому +5

      "Added Herobrine's castle."
      nothing pertaining to herobrine himself in the patch notes, but you still find him ingame.
      he never left.

  • @lawsonbrewer5225
    @lawsonbrewer5225 4 роки тому +42

    youtubers when they do some "mining off camera": 13:31

  • @itsvioneko
    @itsvioneko 5 років тому +933

    "go down to 12 and start stripping"
    -whitelight 2019

    • @sethvandivere9208
      @sethvandivere9208 5 років тому +34

      Hol'up

    • @salamndert
      @salamndert 5 років тому +7

      You probably know this but he means y 12 best height to find diamonds at and strip mine which is when you mine in on direction

    • @DeadSpacedOut
      @DeadSpacedOut 5 років тому +10

      @@salamndert yeah i figured he meant that

    • @rainworldfan7757
      @rainworldfan7757 5 років тому +10

      Fucker knew what he said

    • @bobjobjoe8887
      @bobjobjoe8887 5 років тому +7

      12 works for console, but yeleven for pc, hes a fucking console player

  • @tumbke
    @tumbke 5 років тому +317

    "A Serious Improvement For Minecraft" aka hire Modders as Developers

    • @lindamadhatter1015
      @lindamadhatter1015 5 років тому +11

      Y tho everyone would Go ballistic with their ideas and everyone would have their stuff they all want to See it in Game and yee fuckin' hell's going to Break loose there would be too much input

    • @Swagbastian
      @Swagbastian 5 років тому +10

      It would pretty much be a new game. Basically what he's saying in this video is make a new game with Minecraft's engine.

    • @monteiperier
      @monteiperier 5 років тому

      Vazkii and the creators of inspirations and charm should be devs since they have Minecrafty stuff in

    • @ajinasawor
      @ajinasawor 5 років тому +1

      @@Swagbastian that's basically what modpacks is. new games with minecraft's engine

    • @notsogreatcourier9536
      @notsogreatcourier9536 5 років тому

      @@Swagbastian and i think thats exactly what we need for mc

  • @jackarchibald1980
    @jackarchibald1980 4 роки тому +408

    This made me realise when you just stand there in minecraft and watch the world go by it’s literally dead. The game is nothing without the players influence.

    • @jackarchibald1980
      @jackarchibald1980 4 роки тому +32

      JustCows wrong

    • @bigboydaigle9318
      @bigboydaigle9318 4 роки тому +40

      JustCows look at Red dead 2 it is a living breathing game that moves without you.

    • @dasaiyantv8483
      @dasaiyantv8483 4 роки тому +28

      @@justcows7772 On the top of my head I can say that Morrowind, Oblivion, Skyrim, Terraria, Zelda, and Metroid that disprove that, though acknowledging you said "nearly."

    • @bigboydaigle9318
      @bigboydaigle9318 4 роки тому +17

      10Chrome yes with red dead the world moves on and progresses without out you. NPC’s have schedules and personalities and houses that are incomplete slowly get built over the course of the game. Minecraft still moves on but nothing really happens.

    • @bigboydaigle9318
      @bigboydaigle9318 4 роки тому +4

      @10Chrome I get that but it still feels more alive than MC

  • @PlanetaryNukeFS1
    @PlanetaryNukeFS1 2 роки тому +32

    7:09 "They say Minecraft's only limit is your imagination, I disagree. You can realize anything, but only in form, never in function."
    These words explain what I've been struggling with everytime I come back to this game. I think to myself that I want to build this mansion, or this castle, and by the time I complete it I realize how hallow and dead it is. The best I can do is make it up by making the environment more vibrant, but without the NPC's to run anything, I find there is no point. The best point of function I can make in the game is a home, because I know I can occupy it with some pets and myself. But for projects beyond what one person can handle is just left to be abandoned.

  • @marydoctor1773
    @marydoctor1773 5 років тому +1190

    *2050*
    Time traveler:
    So how did AI take over the world?
    2050 person:
    Well it all started with a game called Minecraft...

  • @deathscreton
    @deathscreton 5 років тому +622

    "Let's have a look at our five-legged friends."
    Hol-up

    • @gilgameshthetreasurehunter2750
      @gilgameshthetreasurehunter2750 5 років тому +12

      Lets go for 8 and call it Sleipner.

    • @arcade5765
      @arcade5765 5 років тому +3

      @KingOverHeaven! nice one

    • @GuiSmith
      @GuiSmith 5 років тому +5

      In Minecraft, they’ve got some tail action. In reality, the males have some... leg action. Thick as a leg action.

    • @xiodos
      @xiodos 5 років тому +1

      deathscreton horses have humongous dicks...

    • @rusji0311
      @rusji0311 5 років тому

      @KingOverHeaven! the entire steed

  • @Pluppsy
    @Pluppsy 5 років тому +833

    "Go down to 12 and start stripping"
    To cop: "yes sir this man right here"

    • @tuttelmaster7801
      @tuttelmaster7801 5 років тому +11

      this joke is what i am in the comments for

    • @oscargland7214
      @oscargland7214 5 років тому +7

      I cant express how much I love this comment

    • @steVENOM
      @steVENOM 5 років тому +1

      LionMaker wants to know your location

    • @Speed001
      @Speed001 5 років тому +2

      16:12

  • @ocinnico2608
    @ocinnico2608 4 роки тому +8

    The fear mechanic like one in one of the mods in Rebirth of the Night is really something that should be in more survival games

  • @whirlarc5916
    @whirlarc5916 5 років тому +567

    Mojang: takes too long to make a fairly simple update
    Minecraft Community: “Fine I’ll do it myself”

    • @Stafarns
      @Stafarns 4 роки тому +5

      i don't get why they don't get someone from the community to help with programming/designing

    • @ddandymann
      @ddandymann 4 роки тому +16

      @@Stafarns Most of the mojang team are former modders of the game, so they do actually. They also have a lot of people in the technical community ( people who actually understand how the game works) advising them.

    • @Stafarns
      @Stafarns 4 роки тому +2

      @@ddandymann oh didn't know that thx for the info. still wonder why they aren't listening to the communities advice for simpler updates
      tbh though i'm not a coder so it the simplest thing could be very hard to code

    • @gaevlos1281
      @gaevlos1281 4 роки тому +3

      Mojang: ''You wanted *_Bees_* right?''
      Meme community: *starts violently chanting the Bee Movie script backwards

    • @alexsurh1472
      @alexsurh1472 4 роки тому +2

      @@ddandymann Problem is they aren't really in charge of what updates are being worked on. Corporate tells them to work on certain things like bees, pandas, shitty shit that nobody cares about

  • @klarahogberg6828
    @klarahogberg6828 5 років тому +589

    ”Ofcourse an empire will fall”
    ...I used to rule the world

    • @VeliocMinecraft
      @VeliocMinecraft 5 років тому +31

      Chunks would load when I gave the word.

    • @PHVNT0M978
      @PHVNT0M978 5 років тому +23

      @@VeliocMinecraft Now every night I go stow away

    • @starbrightmiore3234
      @starbrightmiore3234 5 років тому +21

      @@PHVNT0M978 hide from the mobs I used to slay...

    • @lexalot8337
      @lexalot8337 5 років тому +20

      @@starbrightmiore3234 They once were terrified

    • @eros6644
      @eros6644 5 років тому +19

      @@lexalot8337 Every time I looked into their eyes.

  • @knoxbarringer
    @knoxbarringer 5 років тому +326

    “Trees made from shadows sounds cool”
    Yes, yes they do

    • @yogurtofthemultiverse2200
      @yogurtofthemultiverse2200 5 років тому +3

      Trees made from shadows, endermen running after you if you tried breaking them without an end-game axe, leaves made from crystals that have floaty particles when you break them, ground with eyes and mouths that deal damage when you step on them or give every nearby mob sight of you, it could be the best fucking dimension

  • @Sludgelorrd
    @Sludgelorrd 4 роки тому +10

    I think instead of a trinket that lets you fall through the void, it should be a pickaxe that lets you mine bedrock. More straight forward and minecrafty.

  • @dafphtthedislikeupdater7836
    @dafphtthedislikeupdater7836 5 років тому +937

    Oh dear god, just hearing this makes me sick as a server runner. Imagine all the world folders...

    • @spoonutensil6336
      @spoonutensil6336 5 років тому +41

      O God u right what if the world's deleted themselves when u left so u don't build up in them excessively and just quickly go in them to explore or gather new cool looking blocks

    • @PiercingSight
      @PiercingSight 5 років тому +17

      @@spoonutensil6336 - That would be interesting. A new fresh seed for that world after every visit.

    • @TriggeredForDays
      @TriggeredForDays 5 років тому +9

      You could disable the world like the nether and end; delete your comment.

    • @dafphtthedislikeupdater7836
      @dafphtthedislikeupdater7836 5 років тому +17

      @@TriggeredForDays make me

    • @SophieNotSophie_
      @SophieNotSophie_ 5 років тому +9

      The question is should I make it a mod

  • @krackin619
    @krackin619 5 років тому +537

    Everyone: This game needs constant updates and new experiences
    Mojang: How bout bees

    • @JayQwery
      @JayQwery 5 років тому +21

      1.15 is just a bug fix update... meaning the bees are literally a Joke. Honey blocks are cool though.

    • @brunoleite3958
      @brunoleite3958 4 роки тому +4

      Redstoners liked it

    • @Azurepetalls
      @Azurepetalls 4 роки тому +16

      ok in their defense that was mainly an optimization update and bees were just sprinkles on top

    • @takebacktheholyland9306
      @takebacktheholyland9306 4 роки тому +4

      1.16:ummm, may i enter now?

    • @NotGayBen
      @NotGayBen 4 роки тому +3

      1.15 was incredible they literally took a whole update just to fix bugs and make the game run better

  • @filurenerik1643
    @filurenerik1643 4 роки тому +1986

    “You can build a castle, but with no men to guard it, no king to rule it and no enemies to attack it. You can build a boat but there’s no way to sail it and nowhere to sail”
    -Whitelight 2019
    This quote puts exactly words on why I feel Minecraft is flawed. Edit: My best comment before this has less likes than this has comments. Thank y’all so much!

    • @littlemoth4956
      @littlemoth4956 4 роки тому +45

      Wait, the game is flawed because it doesn't have gameplay revolving around very specific builds? That's just stupid.
      That's like saying it's flawed because there aren't cyborgs to populate my futuristic science fiction neo-city. Just braindead.

    • @omarg5645
      @omarg5645 4 роки тому +150

      @@littlemoth4956 Its just an exmple moron

    • @blakelawrence6849
      @blakelawrence6849 4 роки тому +4

      Filurenerik 164 yes exactly!

    • @kersaherpafuqer784
      @kersaherpafuqer784 4 роки тому +13

      @@littlemoth4956 precisely, it's against the game design philosophy they've stuck with

    • @jerrickmarques8777
      @jerrickmarques8777 4 роки тому +22

      true there's no difficulty progression and i really dont want to install mods bc i really enjoy playing the snapshots... as soon as you spend an hour gathering resources you're pretty much invincible to all mobs

  • @benji8648
    @benji8648 3 роки тому +6

    All of that village stuff about being able to build kingdoms is what makes minecolonies such a good mod, it allows a totally diffrent style of play, with resource management and trying to defend the colony changes the whole experience into an entirely diffrent game

  • @duncanbones
    @duncanbones 5 років тому +688

    I would buy a game like this in less than a heartbeat.

    • @burninroses1755
      @burninroses1755 5 років тому +8

      I would buy the one we have now in shorter time.

    • @sanguine7616
      @sanguine7616 5 років тому +7

      @@burninroses1755 Wow you are so epic and clever, can you please teach me philosophy?

    • @Lysergic_
      @Lysergic_ 5 років тому +5

      @@sanguine7616 did you just have a bad day or actually find this comment to be a good use of time?

    • @user-nn1dj6tw6o
      @user-nn1dj6tw6o 5 років тому +7

      @@Lysergic_ I mean saying "I would buy the one we have now in shorter time." after watching the video and taking it in is a very weird thing to do in my opinion. The idea that this video gives me is a well structured random but controlled world that small actions can cause massive changes. A game like this would be an absolute game changer for the gaming industry, honestly. Think about it, imagine if what is said in this video would be possible, imagine what new games would be made and imagine how more fun games would be and how much more fun you can get from it.

    • @i_dont_truly_exist690
      @i_dont_truly_exist690 5 років тому +1

      same

  • @Ithenos
    @Ithenos 5 років тому +987

    So you want a Mount & Blade: Minecraft Edition of sorts.

  • @rhami8894
    @rhami8894 5 років тому +305

    "But what about, and hear me out here... snowier snow."
    - Mojang, 2019

    • @nefhelimwhat609
      @nefhelimwhat609 5 років тому +3

      Do you think they can recreate this video instantaneously and this is bigger than any update they have ever done

    • @loading....6512
      @loading....6512 5 років тому +5

      Your profile picture makes it funnier

  • @fizzlock
    @fizzlock 4 роки тому +25

    What's sad is that most of this won't be done. Due to Bedrock being the main platform, if it can't run on a mobile device, they won't do it.

  • @8Delian8
    @8Delian8 5 років тому +118

    Jesus Christ, this guy literally broke down what I wanted Minecraft to add.
    Maybe one day we will at least get somewhat close to this vision.

    • @imaeve9550
      @imaeve9550 5 років тому +2

      Look up "Hytale" and you'll be surprised

    • @soar_community
      @soar_community 5 років тому +1

      Check out the Ancient Warfare 2 mod. Basically adds what this guy discussed in the video. To a lesser degree, but it's still similar.

    • @kido_
      @kido_ 5 років тому

      or... Hytale?

    • @8Delian8
      @8Delian8 5 років тому +1

      @@imaeve9550 I know about "Hytale", but we don't even know when we are going to get it... and also see if it delivers

    • @bugsybro3011
      @bugsybro3011 5 років тому

      should take a look at colony survival.

  • @zabuza4959
    @zabuza4959 5 років тому +212

    New employee: "Finally, I got this awesome job at Mojang and it's actually really easy"
    Whitelight: "no"

  • @gangpardos3833
    @gangpardos3833 5 років тому +414

    19:42 “You can recreate the Bible.”
    God: Here we go again

    • @sorcierenoire8651
      @sorcierenoire8651 4 роки тому +25

      Players: TOWER OF BABEL
      God/MOJANG: *HEIGHT LIMIT

  • @gideonharris6555
    @gideonharris6555 4 роки тому +44

    Dude this is awesome. I know you’re getting a lot of backlash for this but this seems interesting. I know people are probably going to get mad at this comment and they have a right to be. I first was hesitant when looking at the title of this video, mostly because I was wondering how someone could have problems with one of the best games in the world, but you’ve reminded me that change is good when done right, and adding a new mode in the game won’t take away from other modes or away from the game itself. Loved the video! Keep up the good work!

  • @jeremydiaz9642
    @jeremydiaz9642 5 років тому +432

    Minecraft's base game + Terraria's loot system + Mount & Blade's Army Control +Space Engineers vehicle construction + Stalker's dynamic world = *_"Game of the century"_*

    • @knyt0
      @knyt0 5 років тому +3

      mods

    • @thegamerserpent4271
      @thegamerserpent4271 5 років тому +11

      Knyt I don’t think any mods have gotten to the level of Mount & Blade and Space Engineers

    • @SolidSt8Dj
      @SolidSt8Dj 5 років тому +4

      Minecraft is already the best selling game of all time...so game of the century would be a downgrade...

    • @sanguine7616
      @sanguine7616 5 років тому +27

      @@SolidSt8Dj That is one of the dumbest things I have ever read.

    • @spoony8485
      @spoony8485 5 років тому +5

      I think it would be a super fun game to play, but the thing that makes Minecraft so popular is it’s accessibility. Anyone with any brain level can play it and enjoy it with relative ease. This as a would easily be the best Minecraft mod ever made though.

  • @ashildhaugsland5419
    @ashildhaugsland5419 4 роки тому +217

    There's only one thing i need.
    Those pink trees.
    And seasons. That would be nice too.

    • @jsome2348
      @jsome2348 4 роки тому +1

      Åshild Haugsland and a cave update

    • @leotard2536
      @leotard2536 4 роки тому

      Pink wood is coming in 1.16 :)

    • @aixide
      @aixide 4 роки тому

      @Harry Christie The planks are purple-pink

  • @icedwhitechocolatemochafra9851
    @icedwhitechocolatemochafra9851 5 років тому +49

    I remember me and my friend messing around in a village. We got the golem angry but were able to trap it. We went exploring to find a swamp biome. After a few days we came back tonthe village as we wanted to develop it. No villagers were remaining.
    We assumed that one of our other friends killed them for us stealing his bow. But then it hit me that the only thing protecting the village was the golem, and with their only protector being trapped in a 3 x 3 5 deep sacrificial chamber, no one could protect them. The undead raided in the night, breaking doors killing the villagers and taking away the young. They couldnt do anything to stop them.
    If only more things like this happened. If only.

  • @Obama-zg8gt
    @Obama-zg8gt 4 роки тому +27

    They should just make Minecraft 2 or something. I know that sounds stupid but the problem with Minecraft now is that it’s on Java which is very old. They should make it a full on game like Minecraft bedrock but better. Shaders should already be in the game. You should be challenged in a similar way that Breath of the Wild does with having to adapt to different climates, weather, and to certain enemies. I’ve always wanted seasons in Minecraft. They should improve the wildlife in different biomes like adding snakes in the desert and adding vultures in the Mesa biome. They should make villagers more important than they are and their should be a better reason to protect them than just the librarian having a mending book. The jungle and Mesa are the two biomes that I believe need the biggest improvements. There should be new dangerous mobs to look out for in the day like snow golems. As much as I love this game, there is so much potential for better. I’m not going to rely on mods to make it better. The game by itself should be better.

    • @noonesarino7913
      @noonesarino7913 3 роки тому

      Minecraft 2 ha It has no story It does not need one and a minecraft 2 will be dumb Since they're basiacally starting a new and also You do know You need to have a good machine ti run minecraft with mods

    • @Obama-zg8gt
      @Obama-zg8gt 3 роки тому +3

      @@noonesarino7913 Maybe not create a new game. But at least keep building onto the game. Again, they should focus on bedrock more instead of Java. Which they are... I guess. I haven’t played the bedrock edition in a while but I know they are adding shaders into it. They have put a lot of focus on Java too, considering the two latest updates, nether and cave. But there is only so much Java can do before it starts to be too much for it. Think of Java as a gaming engine. A really shitty gaming engine. If a game like battlefield tried to run on it, they would severely limited with what they can do. But since it runs on the frostbite engine, it looks beautiful and runs beautifully . The reason I say they should make a whole new game is because if you try and run the ray tracing shaders on Java on your computer, it’ll burn your pc to a crisp. But if they just made the game with stuff like ray tracing already implemented, then I don’t see how it wouldn’t be much better. Otherwise, a game like red dead 2 or last of us 2 would be running at like 10 FPS on consoles and stuff. I don’t think mods affect the games performance too much, depending on the mods. I play Java on my MacBook Pro and with like 12 different mods that adjusted like terrain and added new mobs and locations, it still ran at like 20-30, which isn’t good, but it’s a MacBook.

    • @s66s46
      @s66s46 3 роки тому

      They need to implement new mechanics so all mobs can counter cheese tactics like building up or building in.

    • @justaguywiththebestopinion3718
      @justaguywiththebestopinion3718 3 роки тому

      So basically breath of the wild but with Minecraft graphics

  • @Quaggabagel
    @Quaggabagel 5 років тому +405

    I cant stress enough the wasted potential that is “minecraft” ~ George Washington

    • @wipwops8311
      @wipwops8311 5 років тому +11

      you forgot to add the 1978 as the date he said it

    • @zeratul____1228
      @zeratul____1228 5 років тому

      oh it was actually Overwatch that was wasted potential.

    • @iWhisperASMR
      @iWhisperASMR 5 років тому

      Check out some mods

    • @JumalaPlays
      @JumalaPlays 5 років тому

      Lol he never said that

    • @potatoesstarch2376
      @potatoesstarch2376 5 років тому +2

      @@JumalaPlays What? are you sure? I'm pretty sure he said it.

  • @FranciumBoron
    @FranciumBoron 5 років тому +571

    "I didn't know my retinas could be erect until today."
    *[Chokes on drink]*

  • @p11_studios
    @p11_studios 4 роки тому +380

    Being a “pro” builder, I actually have agreed with the need for dynamics for a long time. I have a whole city and it feels so stagnant some days. You have to imagine things like plumbing and electricity. So bravo, hope Microsoft splurges to incorporate some of these. I wouldn’t care for a full on RPG style, I think this makes the game unique, but some aspects would be very nice
    I’ve always kind of wanted Minecraft to just take a direction. People think it’s meant for medieval, but some mechanics suggest post-apocalypse or fantasy after a world tragedy. I don’t know, just saying we need some amount of purpose

    • @Arenuphis
      @Arenuphis 4 роки тому +2

      What are you reading the post apocalyptic air from?
      The strongholds?

    • @kingucrimson5383
      @kingucrimson5383 4 роки тому +4

      Play cities skylines if you want to build a city

    • @acethefiredragon8525
      @acethefiredragon8525 4 роки тому +25

      Yes, as a fellow builder I agree. Although my style is more Asian style builds. Too many people only focus on 2 types of builds: modern and medieval, while only a minority do Asian style. In my opinion, modern and medieval is just overrated and generic now. But enough of that. I’ve built large Asian style cities, and they look beautiful. But they feel so empty and lifeless. I sometimes wish I could create a city full of life and not a large city of emptiness. It’s very sad that once you’ve built something incredible and beautiful, the feeling you get is momentary joy immediately followed by the inescapable feeling of loneliness and emptiness. So adding city dynamics is something I really wish could happen.

    • @p11_studios
      @p11_studios 4 роки тому +14

      Ace The FireDragon I can always appreciate someone who ventures outside the typical styles. I just like imitating what is around me, I’m familiar with the formulas and design concepts so it’s rather easy. But yeah, the most lifelike thing I’ve done is a recent street fair in a back alley between a bunch of sky scrapers. It’s a nice detail, recommend for any city builders

    • @Gogglesofkrome
      @Gogglesofkrome 4 роки тому +11

      @@Arenuphis I tend to get the 'post apocalyptic' sort of feel from the fact that the vast majority of the world is empty, and and there are a disproportionate amount of ruins and locations with loot in them in comparison to the number of villages that are rather rare in comparison. It doesn't help that it takes no time at all for entire villages to fall to zombies, so there's this overall sense of very real decay, with peaceful life being as rare as it is fleeting - requiring direct intervention to sustain.
      --TLDR: we'd probably have seen more interactions with the world, more crafting and more survival. Maybe we'd even see some elements of managing a society as well, but probably not.
      In terms of features, there's one way to interpret the game in regards to features that we would have seen show up, were minecraft to have not been sold. For example if we're to consider what Notch wrote on his old, now defunct dev blog and youtube channel on the early days of minecraft development, you could see how he originally planned to make the game an overhead viewed one where you would control a number of characters that would do things for you. Slowly he wanted more of a 'down low' and first person interaction with the world, so eventually he made it just a one character, single player survival game.
      Despite this the source of inspiration remained, with the option to strike deep, build and mold the world around you as necessary to survive, craft countless innovations, and to reach the 'underworld' being key aspects that had been brought over from dwarf fortress. Since survival has gotten almost effortless however, a lot of this regard for survival has been lost; however none the less future updates toward this regard would probably remain were the game to follow it's original development path.
      We would have probably eventually gotten our hands on something like a magic system, more alternate worlds to explore, and more abstract challenges like actual repercussions for trying to escape the danger of the night by sleeping, only to find that you'd woken up in the sky dimension, which was later on instead scrapped and reused as the framework for The End.

  • @Niket462
    @Niket462 Рік тому +2

    The ideas put together by Whitelight were so detailed, I could practically visualize the entire game, I think the facts he has put up are true, and would certainly make minecraft so much more complex and interesting than it is in it's current state.

  • @robertskitch
    @robertskitch 5 років тому +99

    "In previous versions of Minecraft villager clerics sold Ender pearls. ... Let's bring that back."
    It's hard to bring back something that never left. >_>

  • @DrippY5
    @DrippY5 5 років тому +292

    „We made snow snowier“
    -Mojang 2019

    • @mrcocoloco7200
      @mrcocoloco7200 5 років тому

      Wow

    • @felixrivera895
      @felixrivera895 4 роки тому

      I hate what they did with snow. Not because ice spire sor whatever are bad, but because of deadfalls hidden under floating snow. The literal worst

  • @KrisDey-BestGPaccount
    @KrisDey-BestGPaccount 5 років тому +626

    Modders: I made an entire new dimension, a new RPG system, and 300 new mobs in 3 months
    Devs: Wow look, we added a bee, look forward to this release in two years!

    • @agentdelta569
      @agentdelta569 5 років тому +161

      I honestly get the impression the current minecraft devs have no idea what they want to do with the game, and so they spend forever asking themselves "is this where we want to take minecraft"
      Compare this to the weekly (yes WEEKLY) updates notch gave minecraft early on some of which were just like "heres the nether lol also, have cakes"

    • @dbelow_1556
      @dbelow_1556 5 років тому +87

      @@agentdelta569 That's part of the burden of success, Minecraft's too popular now for them to go ham with the fun stuff to add like Notch did. They have to constantly mind whether or not what they add in will be doable on all platforms. This is a shame admittedly, but I'm happy the game is even still getting updates honestly

    • @peanutbrainedbuffoon7913
      @peanutbrainedbuffoon7913 5 років тому +39

      @@agentdelta569 well I mean at that time they actually had to compete with people. Now they barely update cause they have no one to compete with. Eventually someone will come along and mojang will actually have to do something. And then we just have more updates for both games. That would be ideal.

    • @emilyiscool891
      @emilyiscool891 5 років тому +21

      Donovan Hughes hytale

    • @peanutbrainedbuffoon7913
      @peanutbrainedbuffoon7913 5 років тому +8

      @@emilyiscool891 well yeah, but that just has a possibility to be good. It could completely flop. Even if hytale is bad I bet someone else will still take the same role.

  • @agolden7554
    @agolden7554 4 роки тому +16

    Am I the only one that was excessively excited about the idea of selective breeding in Minecraft?

  • @SylverUI
    @SylverUI 5 років тому +208

    After watching this video
    Hytale: WRITE THAT DOWN!! WRITE THAT DOWN!!!
    Minecraft: Oh i forgot that i need to program how bee's would work today....

  • @emmagrace7766
    @emmagrace7766 5 років тому +129

    I always try to play “medievally” but it’s just impossible when everything is the exact same.

    • @human6310
      @human6310 5 років тому +1

      Yeah, doesn't it. castles look like shit and torches are literally just radioactive match sticks.

    • @FDelaporte
      @FDelaporte 5 років тому

      Same lol

  • @GoldenNorway1
    @GoldenNorway1 5 років тому +209

    "How to make mining interesting?" Well... I'm a miner IRL, and there's ALOT that can be done with it to make it interesting. -Look at TerraFirmaCraft, which already have done alot of stuff.
    I present to you some examples...
    1. Allow for cave-ins. -The deeper you go, the dangerous it gets.
    2. Make support beams, or stulls, to avoid these collapses.
    3. Of course, you'll need more ore... perhaps even more rock types, just to give more building options.. And weapons, armor, tools and so on.
    4. Make poisonous gas a thing, then add airpipes and compressors to mine safely.
    5. Realistic ore vein generation.
    6. More light sources.
    7. Pumps for flooding..?
    8. Useful ore carts, allow for trains and heavy loads.
    9. Ore chutes, able to fill the ore carts from the stopes.
    10. Realistic caverns, caves and underground biomes (crystal caves, lakes, rivers, deep ravines with forests etc.)
    11. Allow for better digging tools, some extremely expensive to make.
    It took me 1 min to write this shit down, don't know it it's any good... point is, though, it's so easy to think of new ideas.
    IT'S A GAME ABOUT MINING & CREATIVITY, MOJANG...! BE CREATIVE!

    • @mrkoala5127
      @mrkoala5127 5 років тому +14

      GoldenNorway1 these are all incredible ideas! Partly because the are realistic. The awesome thing about Minecraft though is that it doesn’t need to be. So realistic implementations are just the tip of the iceberg of what is possible.

    • @GoldenNorway1
      @GoldenNorway1 5 років тому +10

      @Nickster Studios | I somewhat agree... But I don't necesearly think that the combat is ruined. I actually liked that update.
      But the caves and mining... It's just old an needs to be updated.

    • @sugvon
      @sugvon 5 років тому +7

      Dude post this in the official feedback page of minecraft

    • @thekingofnipples9806
      @thekingofnipples9806 5 років тому

      I think some of it is good but there is a point when it gets too real

    • @theapexsurvivor9538
      @theapexsurvivor9538 5 років тому +1

      1. Yes, though it should be dependent on rock stability (eg. Sandstone can have a church carved into it without support or collapsing (Coober Pedy), and narrow tunnels (1*2*x, 2*2*x) should be safe after reaching solid rock (soil / gravel&clay / loose stone / solid rock) as it's structurally sound. Things like explosions should loosen stone).
      2. Yes, especially with various support levels (wood and solid stone are both pretty good, but steel and obsidian are way better, Nether items are better still, and end items are the best (0G and can hold up a ~32(?) block radius)).
      3. Yes.
      4. Yes, 3 types of gas should work: heavy (flows down, plants can use it plus light (14?) to gain 1 extra growth t/s for 10 seconds in moist soil (consuming 1 block of gas); gives nausea, drowning, weakness, and mining fatigue the longer you stay in it; puts out torches), light (floats up and causes suffocation damage/poison and blindness while standing in it, and is flammable), and volatile (flows up but can pool and flow down, causes nausea, hunger, and night vision, and will explode if ignited or in contact with a "hot" light source).
      5. Yes.
      6. Yes.
      7. Yeah, a weak siphon can be made from suger cane/bamboo in an _|‾ shape, while medium siphons use wool on top and bottom of a weak siphon and sticks/planks on the sides, and strong use a wet sponge on the bottom, a dry on the top, and iron walls. Slow pumps (as fast as siphon but can connect to pipes) use a siphon under a piston and sticks/planks/iron on either side of the piston, fast pumps use a second piston under siphon and use zamak(zinc+aluminium)/iron/steel walls.
      8+9. Chained minecarts with improved hopper loading should cover these.
      10. Yes.
      11. Yes.

  • @yorankoppes
    @yorankoppes 3 роки тому +6

    I play both creative and survival, primarily intrinsically motivated. I like building whatever I want in creative, but it sometimes seems a bit pointless. For those moments, survival provides purpose because you have to live a virtual life and you can build things to use yourselves.

  • @CaptainLennie
    @CaptainLennie 5 років тому +232

    This would be awesome, but let's be honest:
    It ain't gonna happen

    • @robert_gaming
      @robert_gaming 5 років тому +23

      Mods will make it a reality, and if not on here then Hytale will definitely have a mod like it.

    • @quocvietophu1627
      @quocvietophu1627 5 років тому +6

      @@robert_gaming Hopefully Hytale will be good

    • @CaptainLennie
      @CaptainLennie 5 років тому

      @@robert_gaming I hope so

    • @GigaChad-kg4yo
      @GigaChad-kg4yo 5 років тому +4

      If it doesnt happen in Minecraft, it will happen in other games one day.
      Technology is going forward and we have games, engines, hardware and incencitives people would have NEVER expected.
      If humanity doesnt go down in an apocalpyse, we will have it one day.

    • @defectivesickle5643
      @defectivesickle5643 5 років тому +1

      @@robert_gaming I don't get why everyone is treating Hytale like the Messiah of Sandboxes now.

  • @elf7677
    @elf7677 5 років тому +92

    You got me at mumbo's house having a purpose

    • @lolilikedragons3528
      @lolilikedragons3528 5 років тому +1

      It's sad tbh Redstone is literaly a quality of live mechanic that improves efficiency and to look cool. Thats literaly all redstone is good for. It's sad theirs no situation in game that actually motivates players to learn such an interesting mechanic. This video's ideas actualy gives Mumbo's redstone contraptions meaning and usefuleness.

  • @keepermovin5906
    @keepermovin5906 4 роки тому +180

    Imagine with ships there are pirate ships full of illigers to attack you and they try to sink or steal your ship

  • @bleepbloop5251
    @bleepbloop5251 4 роки тому +7

    I think the interactive Villagers idea (tek) is probably my favorite one here. I've always liked fixing villages I come across (because I feel bad when I do bad things lol), and I was always would (steal) borrow one of its homes, revamp it, and pretend as if I lived among the villagers. I think it'd be neat to see the villagers have more life than just wandering around, occasionally farming, closing and opening doors, and glaring at me from their windows.
    Also those enderman ideas... 👀

  • @chaos0987654321
    @chaos0987654321 4 роки тому +300

    dude if someone straight up starts a project to implement these additions, i'd help out to play/bugtest

  • @Wasabi4
    @Wasabi4 5 років тому +132

    So basically the video just be like: "Minecraft is a nice sandbox to release my creativity on to, but what fun is that if my creativity isn't being challenged?"

    • @vladb420
      @vladb420 5 років тому +5

      huh, that's a really good summary

    • @happynihilist2573
      @happynihilist2573 5 років тому +2

      Ham...
      Yeh, pretty much.

    • @Kajiyaification
      @Kajiyaification 5 років тому +6

      the video is pretty much i want to play dnd but dont know anyone who plays it

  • @notrealjohnny5399
    @notrealjohnny5399 5 років тому +572

    "wait wait... aren't we doing that"
    -hytale 2020

    • @dawsome7579
      @dawsome7579 5 років тому +28

      exactly what i said, cant wait for the beta to release!

    • @LuviousDuggs
      @LuviousDuggs 5 років тому +2

      Soooo true

    • @tolliv3r
      @tolliv3r 5 років тому +2

      what is hytale??? someone explain please🥺

    • @jeffdaniel772
      @jeffdaniel772 5 років тому +9

      @@tolliv3r just search up hytale on youtbe for the trailer, its a game made by one of the biggest minecraft server hosters

    • @Hema115
      @Hema115 5 років тому +9

      @@jeffdaniel772 you mean the biggest minecraft server hosters

  • @i1gods1l68
    @i1gods1l68 4 роки тому +6

    I can’t tell you how many times I’ve watched this video it just feels like this shows my own wants and needs while also showing the side of the spectrum that I’d never thought of

  • @Vikinger119
    @Vikinger119 5 років тому +306

    I want to play the game you've made in your head, leading my armies in a coalition of my friends against whatever eldritch menace lies at the end.

    • @JAiZYouTube
      @JAiZYouTube 5 років тому +4

      You should play an MMO then

    • @zubbworks
      @zubbworks 5 років тому +5

      I would probs just send a suicide horde at my friends forrest to mine it all down. That, and I would have them mine every block underneith his house leaving only one layer thick. Just cause.

    • @rickyrain7773
      @rickyrain7773 5 років тому +12

      @@JAiZUA-cam
      Mmos are garbage though

    • @shkrelii
      @shkrelii 5 років тому +8

      JAiZ mmo’s don’t have the same vibe as Minecraft.

    • @err0rakadeadk4t
      @err0rakadeadk4t 5 років тому +1

      @@rickyrain7773 minecraft is mmo itself. In fact, most of the multiplayer games are mmo's

  • @jeefberky9101
    @jeefberky9101 5 років тому +44

    As someone who adored minecraft as a kid and ended up being less and less interested as I got older I would be THRILLED if this came to be

  • @TheLoneRayven
    @TheLoneRayven 5 років тому +54

    Whitelight: "It's easy to make this a great game, just add this advanced AI and about 6 different dimensions, then it'll be amazing."
    Mojang: "We've got tumbleweeds or frogs, you pick which feature comes next. You'll get another feature in about 6 years."

    • @ploperdung
      @ploperdung 5 років тому +4

      @Mathijs Krijger Not that long, especially with mojang's resources. You're just being fooled by the very slow pace mojang works at

    • @connor9502
      @connor9502 5 років тому

      Mods

    • @howdoyoudo5949
      @howdoyoudo5949 5 років тому

      @Mathijs Krijger Mods exists

    • @ploperdung
      @ploperdung 5 років тому +1

      @Mathijs Krijger Dude modders do that shit in a way shorter amount of time and they are a small team so Mojang can do that in a relatively short amount of time

    • @SpartaCraft22965
      @SpartaCraft22965 5 років тому +3

      ​@Mathijs Krijger No, it doesn't. Once you have a plan, the coding is simple. How many new block types do you need for a new dimension? Let's see; Stone equivalent, Dirt equivalent, and 2 or 3 new ores. Maybe some trees; 2 more block types. Creating new randomly-generated structures are easy because you can store specific block configurations in files, or you can generate specific shapes using those blocks from a pre-made list of voxel configurations. The hardest part is probably designing new mobs, but that's really so easy now with all the inspiration out there that it's barely even a hitch.
      No; making new blocks, items, structures and mobs are not difficult, especially for an experienced programmer with the cooperation of an intermediate designer. With a team of 2-4 people, making a mod that includes most of the things in this video would probably take not even a full year if each of them worked just 30 hours per week.

  • @forresttfoxx
    @forresttfoxx 4 роки тому +8

    This is exactly what I want, verbalized in the way I want, that I was too lazy to voice myself. Thank you.

  • @holo379
    @holo379 5 років тому +316

    "It's important that we just leave them as an open mystery."
    "No." -Matt from game theory

    • @What-sf5ey
      @What-sf5ey 5 років тому +4

      honestly it does sound like matt cracked the mystery

    • @chasecoulter2888
      @chasecoulter2888 5 років тому

      @The Keeper of Autism and Cringe lewd

    • @evenasgrimplass9411
      @evenasgrimplass9411 5 років тому

      @@What-sf5ey Nah, his theory sounds bonkers.

  • @icedcxffee2159
    @icedcxffee2159 5 років тому +428

    "Okay,but what about bees?"
    "O H and the mountains of course"
    -Mojang 2019

    • @squiggles9612
      @squiggles9612 5 років тому +12

      Its mainly a bug fix update with bees and mountais like the cherry on top, its the Nether update is the thing that is getting the hype up

    • @BlackJar72
      @BlackJar72 5 років тому +6

      Working on my climatic biome mod has me thinking a lot about mountains myself -- to do it right, including snowy mountains with hot bases (think the Andes or Kilimanjaro) and progressive climate -- would actually be great but far bigger than the other votable options would have been. I doubt that's what they'll actually do. (And at this point, neither will I.) But bug fixing an optimization is something they really needed to do.

    • @MechanicalGizmo
      @MechanicalGizmo 5 років тому

      *snowier snow intensifies*

    • @lolilikedragons3528
      @lolilikedragons3528 5 років тому

      @@BlackJar72 Exactly large servers have stayed on 1.12.2 for a reason and i hope to god that 1.15 optimizes java enough to finally allow them to update to that version

  • @araindog1657
    @araindog1657 5 років тому +65

    “...Reworking or removing phantoms”
    *Cries tears of sadness, knowing such a thing will never happen*

    • @lindamadhatter1015
      @lindamadhatter1015 5 років тому +1

      They ain't that Bad Just sleep now and then?!? Or Take them down with a decent bow and aim in one or two shots depending on your enchantments.

    • @wanderingmadman558
      @wanderingmadman558 5 років тому +5

      There's a block that's super effective at dealing with phantoms.... it's called a bed, use it.

    • @skyguy1236
      @skyguy1236 5 років тому +2

      @@wanderingmadman558 but that defeats the purpose of everything.. Why build a house when you can just sleep through the night. Why even go through the night if some stupid mob is going to kill you for even trying.

    • @wanderingmadman558
      @wanderingmadman558 5 років тому +1

      @@skyguy1236 How does that defeat the purpose of everything? I built a house with a web block roof specifically to farm phantoms... makes them really easy to kill. ...and fyi, you don't need to sleep the whole night, every night. I usually jump in bed just before dawn, every third day, if I want to keep them away for a while.

    • @glacier8678
      @glacier8678 5 років тому +4

      Linda Madhatter10 still there completely annoying and seem more of an annoying nuisance instead of a threat. Elytras arena endgame material and people would already have a mending villager with them. It defeats the purpose of adventuring because you just get harassed by phantoms. They don’t enrich the purpose of survival, they only punish you for not sleeping.

  • @caisearle
    @caisearle 4 роки тому +3

    I love minecraft not for the building but the adventure! The unlimited possibilities in the world! But theres just not enough to explore, not enough dungeons to raid and not enough things to find in the world in general

  • @lotsofducks3236
    @lotsofducks3236 5 років тому +60

    "They'll never know we were the ones who planned the attack" *NoW THiS Is aN AvENgERS LevEL ThrEAT*

    • @lotsofducks3236
      @lotsofducks3236 5 років тому +4

      all joking aside, I love all of the ideas layed out in the video, keep it up!

  • @teodorpirnat8386
    @teodorpirnat8386 5 років тому +145

    "Well no, but here's bees and snowier snow" -Mojang 2019

  • @novencolt5929
    @novencolt5929 5 років тому +233

    Anon: Can we have updates like those?
    Mojang: We have updates like those at home.
    Updates at home: 🐝+🐷

    • @CrazzyJ-iw5rc
      @CrazzyJ-iw5rc 5 років тому

      beeeeeeeeeeees

    • @braydunce
      @braydunce 5 років тому +2

      Claric von Sage EXCEPT WE HAVE TO WAIT HALF A YEAR FOR THEM!

    • @carmenmantilla7988
      @carmenmantilla7988 5 років тому

      @@braydunce the bees are coming this year

    • @braydunce
      @braydunce 5 років тому +2

      Carmen Mantilla ik but bees are shit. Honestly who cares for bees

    • @novencolt5929
      @novencolt5929 5 років тому +1

      @@braydunce I agree, would of been happier with new dog skins/breeds

  • @amosbirb2616
    @amosbirb2616 2 роки тому +3

    Making a mod that attempts to work with this, Whitelight’s third video, SimplySarc’s concept for copper and phantoms, Minecraft Abnormals concepts that they themselves haven’t implemented, and the majority of Mojang’s own backlog