Are Banded Pull Ups BAD?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 59

  • @CaliToTheCrowd
    @CaliToTheCrowd  5 місяців тому +1

    If you do need more help, take a look at my Couch To Pull Up Program: www.calitothecrowd.com/couch-to-pull-up-details

  • @hypemansteve3939
    @hypemansteve3939 Рік тому +21

    Considering you only do UA-cam on the side of a fulltime 9-5, we really have to respect this hustle. These videos are so well made

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому +6

      That means a lot, Steve! Takes a lot of time to make and it really takes it out of you 😂

    • @huhyou4271
      @huhyou4271 Рік тому

      We are still waiting for the absolute BLOW UP! You indeed do great work here. #staystrong #staycool

  • @kerryfromaj9032
    @kerryfromaj9032 2 місяці тому +3

    I just today received my resistance bands.
    My pull-up bar has been a struggle for weeks now.
    I can bench heavy full range and squat full range heavy. So why the trouble with pull-ups?
    Lack of familiarity and this is new for me.
    I’m 63 and realized I would injure myself if I didn’t get some help learning a “new to me”exercise.
    I enjoyed your well spoken intelligent UA-cam video today.
    Thanks for the help in my over 60 fitness training.

  • @gavsmart
    @gavsmart 2 дні тому

    Hi Andrew, I just wanted to say a qucik thanks for a wicked video and such a helpful explanation! I've heard some this before but I really appreciate the simple and unpretantious way you say it. Thanks v much :)
    I'm quite new to all of this, and have started working with my PT for a couple of months now, but he introduced me to banded pull-ups/chin-ups as tbh I was always so awful at them before! It makes so much sense the way you describe it as well as using them in general, as with the help of a band I could now make sure I was performing really solid, controlled pull-ups with great form, each and everytime, without wasting a ton of effort just even trying to do one terribly!
    Fast forward a few weeks/months, and now I'm reducing the resistance needed, dropping band sizes, and increasing the rep count of each set, but yet NEVER losing track of that good form as with the band it was able to become muscle memory before pilling on the challenge. I'm now even managing a few sets without a band which I couldn't dream of doing before without starting with bands!
    Thanks for a great resource and I'm off to check out the other videos! Best wishes, Gavin :)

  • @hubertgajewski4153
    @hubertgajewski4153 Рік тому +4

    I have just discovered this channel! I feel very lucky to do so. You explain the concepts so well and tackle questions that no other calisthenic youtubers seems to answer.

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому

      honour is all mine, Hubert! Glad you liked the video and welcome to the Cali Crowd!

  • @pwnie404
    @pwnie404 Рік тому +1

    You're by far my favorite youtuber in the calisthenics genre. No bullshit, just straight to the point, concise advise in well edited, short videos. Love it, cheers man

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому

      Wow! That is super high praise considering the players in this game! Glad you're loving on the channel! Waaay more to come! 👊🏿

  • @ShawnFumo
    @ShawnFumo 20 днів тому

    Thanks for the pushback on the "everything you know is wrong!" that gets used a bit too much for views. Having said that, there is another simple way to add assistance: just put a stool or something under so that when standing up your chin clears the bar, and use your legs to assist. The disadvantage is it is a bit less consistent (since you can't control exactly how much your legs are pushing every time), but the advantage is being able to have different resistance curves and on-the-fly changing the overall assistance. Can basically pick a number of reps to do and concentrate on keeping it just difficult enough to complete.

  • @dannilovescats6474
    @dannilovescats6474 Рік тому +2

    I've been seeing this a lot recently. I needed this video 😅

  • @Cobolock
    @Cobolock Рік тому +2

    I went from 6-5-4 banded pull-ups to 6-5-4 unbanded. My form is far from good but I prefer dealing with problems one by one, and now when I got my musles accustomed to pulling the body up I'm gonna fix my muscular memory (it doubtedly have solidified too well by now). Honestly, calling some well-known and broadly used equipment bad just makes the journey harder for novices.

  • @samueleastlund6137
    @samueleastlund6137 Рік тому +1

    Good video :) getting out there and using your muscles regularly is more important than avoiding exercises which might be ‘bad’, especially something as reliable and effective as a pull up!

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому

      100%!!!!
      So many get bogged down in inertia rather than simply moving more. Being able to move on our own volition is a gift that not everybody has and that alone should be good enough.
      Our bodies are smart and adaptable things

  • @ashsnape1937
    @ashsnape1937 Рік тому +1

    REALLY needed this mate 👍 I've been doing band pull ups for a while now ( with mixed feelings towards them) Recently I'm putting alot more time into ring inverted rows. Especially because I'm focusing mostly on push ups (horizontals) 🙂

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому +1

      Happy to help! For what it's worth, both are phenomenal exercises - in fact most people (myself included) could do with doing MORE horizontal pulling.
      Glad you're still smashing your training, Ash!

    • @ashsnape1937
      @ashsnape1937 Рік тому

      @@CaliToTheCrowd thank you my friend and keep up the great work 🙂👍

  • @krisumusic
    @krisumusic Рік тому +2

    I used bands for maybe 2 years to build up myself and since the year started I have not used bands for pullups at all. I also started doing heavy volume of pullups and chins, currently doing 10-15 reps per set. So around 50 per day perhaps, with one or two rest days here and there. I would say I could not have achieved this without bands for 1+ year. I weigh in around 90 kg at 189 cm so I feel really functionally strong at the moment! Something everyone should feel once in their lifetime :) I currently use bands for dips as I've neglected them, and it's working! I can now do dips without bands as well but it's ROUGH :D

    • @Cobolock
      @Cobolock Рік тому +1

      Negatives do wonders with dips, at least they did for me.

    • @krisumusic
      @krisumusic Рік тому

      @@Cobolock Will try! Thank you :)

  • @MalcolmTrez
    @MalcolmTrez Рік тому +1

    Your videos are always the highlight of my Sundays

  • @zeswutz
    @zeswutz Рік тому +1

    Thank you! 👊🏻🙏🏻 This channel is class

  • @mgnoodle2589
    @mgnoodle2589 3 місяці тому

    I’ve just got bands a couple of days ago and I find the band forces me to engage the core and make me more stable. I’m happy just being able to try and I’m doing what’s right for me that’s keeps me consistent and stops me from giving up.

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  3 місяці тому

      Absolutely love this!!!!
      The enjoyability of our sessions is so important.
      Debating on if something is perfect is to neglect that 80% of people don't even move their bodies at all.
      Keep pushing through and I'm sure you'll have the pull up in no time!!! 💪🏿💪🏿

  • @daniella3528
    @daniella3528 Рік тому

    I love that you dispel the nonsense out there! Banded pull ups are how I got strong enough to do pull ups! If these people had their way, we'd all never exercise!!!!

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому

      100% Daniella!

    • @Sarah-bn1hg
      @Sarah-bn1hg 8 місяців тому

      Hi how long did it take you and how often did you practice ?

  • @clarity2115
    @clarity2115 4 місяці тому +1

    Bands helped me a lot. I'd do regular body weight 1,2,3 reps for multiple sets then add bands for higher repetitions

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  4 місяці тому +1

      A quality method for getting your volume up 👊🏿

  • @crayzmarc
    @crayzmarc Рік тому

    Good to see another video

  • @jaxonlee4587
    @jaxonlee4587 Рік тому

    Amazing video bro! Banded pull ups are the best progression!

  • @oneloveSURFISTA
    @oneloveSURFISTA Рік тому

    I never used bands for anything and I'm fairly new to calisthenics. By seeing other people using it I have the impression that depending on the excercise the band kinda "forces" your body out of the ideal form, in a way that you have to fight the resistance to maintain good form.
    Since I never used it, I'm not really sure whether this impression or right or not. Probably not since almost everyone uses bands to assist their training. I'll see if I buy some bands for myself to test them and see how it feels.

  • @sdasdgfdgd2931
    @sdasdgfdgd2931 10 місяців тому

    Tbh i only started increasing my pull up numbers, when i stopped doing banded pull ups and started doing pull up negatives

  • @kryptoniterazor
    @kryptoniterazor Рік тому

    Appreciate the thorough analysis and comments about "controversialism." It seems forbidden knowledge demands high prices and everyone has a secret method to sell.

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому

      100%! Generally, the simple stuff works. Yes, there are niche techniques around the edges, but 90% of the biggest results comes from doing the simple stuff well 💪🏿

  • @pr63F1
    @pr63F1 Рік тому

    Can you do video about workout plan , what to do first , how many and like this ?

  • @Gisellekits
    @Gisellekits Рік тому +1

    Quality video

  • @pagarsky
    @pagarsky Рік тому

    Small bit of constructive feedback - the like/subscribe popup is too loud, compared to the voice. Otherwise the video is great, keep up the good work! :)

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому +1

      Noted! and my bad - I have been having audio issues with my video templates since I got a new mic - thinking of just going back to my old one tbh!

  • @darrensimmons6943
    @darrensimmons6943 Рік тому

    Funnily enough I got into a twitter war with somebody about the banded pull up and sent them this video. Hopefully this makes him see the light

  • @tumblewed538
    @tumblewed538 Рік тому

    heyho, massive thanks for making these, many of your videos greatly help me to sniff out some of the many mistakes i make during my callisthenics journey.
    I have a little(big) question; When i do pushups, situps, pullups, or even splits, my neck tends to get very stiff, and i even end up with a little muscular tinitus on my left ear. Due to incorrect posturing my body is very disbalanced, including a larger left trapezius.
    Im working on fixing my posture and disbalances, but do you have any tipps, insights or video recommendations for me ?

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  Рік тому

      No worries, and glad you're enjoying the channel.
      I do have some tips actually as I had a similar problem a few years back!
      The first tip I'd give you is to try out this follow along: ua-cam.com/video/YOrmHEJOQTU/v-deo.html
      All my favourite posture improvers are in there.
      And also, every time you notice yourself in bad posture, roll your shoulders back, squeeze your shoulder blades together and try to tuck your chin into your neck while keeping your head in a straight line with your spine.
      I plan on doing a posture video in future so look out for it 👊🏿

  • @simonsaes1678
    @simonsaes1678 Рік тому

    I've been seeing this a lot too! imagine actually telling people that one of the best progressions for the pull up is bad???!!! It is this sort of over complexity that makes the fitness world so silly sometimes

  • @DejiDigital
    @DejiDigital Рік тому +1

    Volume is so low on this video… what happened?

  • @grahama3324
    @grahama3324 2 місяці тому

    What bands are recommended please?

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  2 місяці тому

      I have some in my shop if you need them:
      www.calitothecrowd.com/shop

  • @tankster90
    @tankster90 11 днів тому

    Anyone else watching this after having a resistance band smack them in the eye? 💀

    • @CaliToTheCrowd
      @CaliToTheCrowd  11 днів тому +1

      The amount of bruises I have from bands... 😭

    • @tankster90
      @tankster90 11 днів тому

      @@CaliToTheCrowd resistance bands truly are a weapon of mass destruction 💀