Thelma Schoonmaker's Favorite Scorsese Moments

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 81

  • @chrisgaitan1915
    @chrisgaitan1915 8 років тому +427

    Greatest film editor ever.

    • @carl_anderson9315
      @carl_anderson9315 5 років тому +12

      I normally never say “Best [space] ever”, but this time I have to agree. At least in the top 10 best editors in film history.

    • @omidfilms
      @omidfilms 5 років тому

      Took the words out of my mouth

    • @mimicrybypravesh
      @mimicrybypravesh 5 років тому +2

      Anne V Coates was better, edited Lawrence of Arabia

    • @ruly8153
      @ruly8153 4 роки тому +1

      Yes
      BUT!!!
      She’s a women and shouldn’t be working in film

    • @Thespeedrap
      @Thespeedrap 3 роки тому

      @@ruly8153 Who are you to judge somebody.

  • @ndogg20
    @ndogg20 5 років тому +154

    The editing in Goodfellas set a new trend in film making. 2 1/2 hours length and it goes by in the blink of an eye. Its been imitated to death since then
    and is now the standard in making a film flow , but when it premiered it knocked people out. Schoonmaker is the magic in Scorsese's brilliant concepts.

    • @waynej2608
      @waynej2608 Рік тому +4

      Agree. Clearly, it's not surprising that she and Scorsese have worked together for decades. Both are off the charts talented! A match made in heaven, etc. They've thoroughly earned the praise. 👍

    • @AndyJay1985
      @AndyJay1985 Рік тому +1

      I always tell everyone the day Henry gets busted always heightens my anxiety.

    • @hippiecheezburger5457
      @hippiecheezburger5457 Рік тому +2

      Goodfellas is a flawless film she has a lot to do with it

  • @FreakieFan
    @FreakieFan 8 років тому +161

    Editing is truly an invisible art. Always had the utmost respect for editors

  • @NxDoyle
    @NxDoyle 5 років тому +47

    One of the best cinematic marriages in the history of film. A great lesson for up-and- comers too: don't forget continuity, but don't revere continuity.

  • @jameswelday8451
    @jameswelday8451 2 роки тому +21

    A cinematic treasure. Her genius, along with Scorsese, is undeniable.

  • @Model_Roe
    @Model_Roe Рік тому +11

    Raging Bull is my favorite movie of all time this lady is brilliant much respect Thelma

  • @liltick102
    @liltick102 9 місяців тому +1

    1:55 So many time’s I have looked up my own writing / searched to if either what I wrote, or if a song I made was even my work or not because it impressed me in-post so much. Great feeling.

  • @brandoncaridi5229
    @brandoncaridi5229 5 років тому +14

    Thelma is the GOAT of editing!

  • @krisla8211
    @krisla8211 8 років тому +48

    Fantastic video! She is a wonderful film editor and her working partnership with Martin Scorsese is unrivaled.

  • @tontaelli
    @tontaelli 5 років тому +9

    This lady transcends any box you could possibly try to put her into. She is fantastic. A brilliant editor without equal.

  • @filmbuff2777
    @filmbuff2777 Рік тому +1

    I'm glad she talked about Gangs of New York. I love this film, & I think it deserves more respect than it gets. The revenge story is more nuanced & has more depth than something like Gladiator (which is a cut & dry revenge story with one dimensional characters), & the world Scorsese re-created was really well done.

  • @jackreed7287
    @jackreed7287 5 років тому +21

    Hugo is a masterpiece.

  • @AntonBaumgartner
    @AntonBaumgartner 4 роки тому +6

    a little bit disappointed that she didn't flatter herself for the amazing sequences in Goodfellas and Casino

  • @candelise
    @candelise Рік тому +3

    I would happily spend serious money taking Thelma to dinner and asking her a million questions.

  • @NaturaBreeze
    @NaturaBreeze 5 років тому +21

    Imagine being so good as an editor that you're Scorsese's editor :)

    • @micajohansson1138
      @micajohansson1138 Рік тому

      Martin has worked with Thelma, she edited his first feature film and then since Raging Bull they have worked together.

    • @davidswanson5669
      @davidswanson5669 Рік тому +2

      @@micajohansson1138hard to say who was the luckier one, to have found each other. My guess is that she’d say she was the lucky one, but she’s certainly proven herself time and time again.

  • @fercho9905
    @fercho9905 Рік тому

    The intro scene for Raging Bull is just heaven.

  • @suzannebaily5293
    @suzannebaily5293 4 роки тому +2

    She is an editing genius!!!

  • @fredfat1606
    @fredfat1606 5 років тому +3

    one of the best film editors

  • @theowlreviewerofficial
    @theowlreviewerofficial 5 років тому +37

    If she is still around, I'd love to meet her. Seems genuine and passionate about her editing work and collaboration with Scorsese

    • @ClassicalMusic2002
      @ClassicalMusic2002 5 років тому +9

      She is!

    • @wildsmiley
      @wildsmiley 5 років тому +8

      She recently was the editor on Scorsese’s The Irishman. She has been nominated for an Academy Award many times and has won 3 times. Bet she’ll be nominated for The Irishman too.

    • @Model_Roe
      @Model_Roe Рік тому +3

      She's still alive LoL just worked on Killers of the Flower Moon I want to see it

  • @jiiig8667
    @jiiig8667 Рік тому

    Brilliant brilliant brilliant. I love this.
    These r the people I'd like to hear more from. ❤

  • @csitMusic
    @csitMusic 5 років тому +7

    Thelma Moviemaker.

  • @Lightblue.JA18
    @Lightblue.JA18 Рік тому +1

    Im her fan its brilliant and so adorable

  • @warnutztheloser
    @warnutztheloser 5 років тому +3

    Great Film Editor very Inspiring

  • @gpubskrw4076
    @gpubskrw4076 Рік тому

    This'll seem an odd observation, but watching her talk brings to mind Carol Kay, the bass player in the Wrecking Crew. Both women GIANTS in their chosen fields, and both great in interviews.

  • @greyeyed123
    @greyeyed123 Рік тому +1

    In watching old westerns from the '40s, very often I notice in two shots that one of the actor's faces is not even facing the camera enough to see any expression at all, and the other (usually the star) is mostly facing the other person so most of their reactions are lost also. It occurred to me that (bad) directors and actors may have been thinking of movies in terms of stage plays at that time. Or maybe many just weren't very good or didn't care about how the movie was done.

  • @stephenmccollum1391
    @stephenmccollum1391 5 років тому +4

    absolute LEGEND

  • @theitalianalien8477
    @theitalianalien8477 5 років тому +2

    I adore this woman

  • @genericname34
    @genericname34 5 років тому +7

    0 dislikes, that’s when you know it’s art

  • @joannkelly7994
    @joannkelly7994 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you.

  • @RG-vx9jh
    @RG-vx9jh 5 років тому +1

    🙏 God bless you and your family mam

  • @fascinatinglist9654
    @fascinatinglist9654 5 років тому +6

    she should change her name to Thelma Moviemaker

  • @josephgavrilides8383
    @josephgavrilides8383 5 років тому +3

    What a legend!

  • @can2709
    @can2709 5 років тому +3

    I have no idea why, but she keeps reminding me of Lucille Austero from Arrested Development...

    • @mhcolby
      @mhcolby  5 років тому +1

      Yeah it's funny they kind of have the same accent! Might be that they both had British mothers?

  • @alanFconrad
    @alanFconrad Рік тому

    she's great

  • @aeromundos
    @aeromundos 5 років тому +2

    Making videos for my channel nowadays i know how important the editing process is (it can even save a project from total boredom) , indeed is like putting a puzzle together Thelma has the gift and is a example of excellence in the field to many aspiring filmakers.

  • @65g4
    @65g4 5 років тому +6

    Love her editing work an absolute tradgedy that Scorsese didnt win for Raging Bull

  • @lsaf6573
    @lsaf6573 5 років тому +1

    Awesome!

  • @SalamiKing7
    @SalamiKing7 5 років тому +2

    Legend!

  • @giovannisanseviero5726
    @giovannisanseviero5726 4 роки тому

    Going for the truth all the time.

  • @franciswoodbeck768
    @franciswoodbeck768 5 років тому +2

    Legend

  • @MikeMJPMUNCH
    @MikeMJPMUNCH 7 років тому +9

    How could they not get her to talk about Goodfellas.

    • @plasticweapon
      @plasticweapon Рік тому +1

      she's tired of talking about goodfellas.

  • @pietropascale6302
    @pietropascale6302 5 років тому +2

    What software did she use to edit

  • @annettewernblad7807
    @annettewernblad7807 9 років тому +3

    Great video - his name is spelled Scorsese, though :-)

  • @dakritic
    @dakritic 5 років тому +4

    3 people actually think that “Dances with Wolves” was superior to “Goodfellas”. 🙄

  • @GarrettDavis-nu3ti
    @GarrettDavis-nu3ti Рік тому

    She's so beautiful. I always saw her as well,,,,,,,,, not beautiful. Gotta admit, I normally don't tie beautiful women in with tough-guy/ gangsta Movie's. ( Except as moll's.)

  • @Skanda1111
    @Skanda1111 8 років тому +1

    what's the track that plays when the video starts?

    • @diegoignaciomunozvalenzuel3013
      @diegoignaciomunozvalenzuel3013 5 років тому +4

      It's been 2 years, you probably don't even remember about this, most probably you found the track. Anyway, is Met Lab Zoso Sticker-7horse

  • @arsh0603
    @arsh0603 5 років тому

    Dear Thelma Schoonmaker, Do you still edit? You have been a great inspiration.

    • @mhcolby
      @mhcolby  5 років тому +2

      Magical Moments I believe she’s in post on “The Irishman” now :)

    • @carl_anderson9315
      @carl_anderson9315 5 років тому +1

      Matthew Colby yep!

    • @plasticweapon
      @plasticweapon Рік тому

      easy enough to find out...

  • @linusfotograf
    @linusfotograf 5 років тому +3

    It’s odd how she keeps calling him by his lastname. Love their work together

  • @Fishnutz737
    @Fishnutz737 Рік тому

    she bothers me a lot

  • @FunkMasterKRoc
    @FunkMasterKRoc 9 років тому +1

    what software is she using?

    • @mhcolby
      @mhcolby  9 років тому

      +FunkMasterKRoc I'm not positive, it was something I didn't recognize. Not avid, ppremiere, or FCP. Maybe some sort of custom Avid UI? Or Edius?

    • @booneh
      @booneh 9 років тому +11

      She is using Lightworks, which she has edited on since she switched to digital. It's more like a flatbed film editor with Avid (and pretty much everything else) being more like an old video editing machine. Lightworks was kind of on its last legs for a long time, but now it's coming back strong.

    • @mhcolby
      @mhcolby  9 років тому +2

      Interesting! Glad you could answer this.

    • @subwaygaragemusic
      @subwaygaragemusic 7 років тому +1

      And did you notice that she is running Lightworks on Windows? LOL

    • @MrJJNath
      @MrJJNath 5 років тому

      Roadrash

  • @ChrisPeck-niganma
    @ChrisPeck-niganma 3 роки тому +1

    Cool. I likes her