They let the authors of different songs lead in them on that album. Kirstie wrote this one. She also wrote 'Love Me When I Don't', 'Exit Signs' and 'It's Different Now'.
Mitch had a beautiful supporting role in Kirstin's lead vocals. That's one of the reasons I love this track. I love his ad-libs. They went pretty intricate with the background vocals and percussion . This is a Kirstie written song also. Great reaction per usual. Thanks!🙏🏾❤️
@@SalvoG Yes she co-wrote it with producers Mathew Koma and Dan book. In the making of This album they all would do writing groups. It would be a writer/ producer plus one or two members of PTX in a room, just flushing out ideas and writing songs, this one was just Kirstie and the producers, no other members. 😊
Kirstin wrote this song. She has really come into her own. She has grown a lot professionally and she's in a positive relationship with Ben. She also wrote or co wrote Love Me When I Dont.
Definitely the noise you're looking for is Matt's bass. As another poster said, what Mitch is doing is called descant (kind of a echo an octave higher).
What I find interesting about this song is you are hearing Kirstin's and Mitch's lower registers as well as hearing Mitch soar above her vocals. Scott, Matt and Kevin while they are there, they are more background - if that makes sense- you can't always pick out their individual voices like you can Mitch's.
Makes sense. It seems I can always hear Mtich, even when there is a tight harmony with all five of them, his voice is so unique. I even hearing him humming at the end of Hallelujah.
I would call parts of what Mitch sang (when he was floating above, singing “be my eyes”, that could be called a descant- a melody/harmony written to “float” above the rest of the arrangement.
I would say Mitch has supporting vocals in this track instead of background. Not the lead, but more in the forefront than a background vocal, like what Scott does here.
I always forget how much I like this song until I hear it again. Kirsten actual went through a creative spurt and wrote or co-wrote a bunch of the songs on the Luck Ones. I’ve heard her talking about it in (I think) it was an Instagram live.
I love this song. One thing I noticed, when listening to just audio with no video distraction, while Kirstin sounds amazing, Mitch is doing so much in the background and I'm loving it. Great reaction 😎
I think I'd maybe call Mitch's part here a descant. It's not THE melody, but it is A melody that sort of enhances and lays over the main melody. I like you fragile sky city visual!
This was shot in the lock-down. They were in separate homes. The editing put all the guys in around the glass pieces and even the together shots. Kirstie is a great songwriter, of course Kevin co writes with her. Love her stuff. Thanks for reacting. Stay safe.
Nice reaction. Thank you. The sound that you were curious about was made by Matt. Mitch said that this was his favorite song from the album. Kirstin is a terrific writer/co-writer.
I know exactly what you meant about the feel of the song haha and Mitch had supporting vocals here which were stunning. I always enjoy when Kirstie takes the lead on a song because we get to see how much her voice has truly grown and matured over the years. she's a real powerhouse for sure. ❤️
I'm sure I've heard Mitch say that this is favourite PTX original or possibly just his favourite The Lucky Ones track. Such a well written song, and a great Kirstin/Mitch vocal combo. (I also think she said her fav off this album was Anchor, which is a Mitch lead). I love this one, and an older one she wrote called Water.
Something that I think this song does a great job of illustrating that I feel gets somewhat overlooked at times about PTX is the complete lack of ego that they've shown over a decade plus of this. They could each have an absolute superstar solo career at literally any moment they want. But here they are singing backup to each other. It's just something you don't see a ton of, and I think, one of the most refreshing things about PTX.
Matt is what you are hearing. The most important thing which I had commented on in another video is that Mitch has a Patreon and he went live 2 weeks ago and said this was his favorite song on the album and he wishes that he had been in in the writing process but then backtracked and said he might have disrupted the flow. This was filmed like coffee in bed and mad world where COVID wasn't in lockdown but it still wasn't safe to be around other people. I thought they did a great job!!! They are always meticulous about every part of what they do and that I think is why they stand out so much. Talent of course plays a huge part in it but I think if you outwork everyone else and care about what you are making and love it, all of those together make them the top
To be honest, when I first heard this I did not like it. Now it is one of my favorite songs. I think it’s the lyrics. I love it!! Also love Coffee in Bed and Anchor. Love your observations!
Another Kirstin driven song that's older is Rather Be. It's one of my favorites. Of course there is their second song on Episode 8 of The Sing Off. How's that for a tease to get you back to doing those???
Kirstin has a real sultry sound when she sings those lower notes. I feel like that is why you kept running it back to hear her. Really love this song! Radio play should be a no brainer! Thank you for reacting to this one!
I think what you were hearing, (the mystery sound), I think that was Matt doing 1/2 bass 1/2 beatbox, I've heard him do that before, and it can throw you off, until you see his face on camera when the note hits.
You also saw a kirstin lead when you watched water on popspring. Rather Be, My favorite things, Seasons of love, and Once upon a December are also great kirstin leads. She also has a big part in Shallow. She and Scott duet it with a little surprise part from Mitch. Plus you get Kevin celloboxing. (Beatboxing while playing cello). He’s the one who created it and is the only one who does it as far as I know.
absolutely LOVE the message in this song....what are friends and loved ones for?...being eyes when we are blind to things not good for us. Love it! Kirstie wrote this one.
Most of the songs on The Lucky Ones were co-written with and co-produced by a pair of experienced pop songwriters / producers, Matthew Koma and Dan Book. And there were multiple vocal editors on many tracks. My theory is that any odd sounds are the result of taking a vocal phrase and doing some extra sound editing.
I wouldn't say your inner vision is off, even visually this suggests clouds and glass. Plus, I am of the opinion that personal interpretation or visualization is never "wrong." It may not be the intended one, but what it means to you is how the music spoke to your soul....
Kirstin also has solo songs as well that are super good! They are on her UA-cam channel and every song is amazing so it doesn’t matter which one you pick to listen to first!
Yes, descant would probably be the correct musical term for what Mitch is doing here... but in PTX-speak, you can just call it "ear-candy" ;-) I don't think your visual is weird - they kept everything very light here, and porcelain has a beautiful crystalline structure that bounces sound around before fading away, so it fits perfectly! Along with the lightness, we are getting the richness of Kirsten's mezza-soprano with her staying in the lower part of her register in this one - same for Mitch in the lower parts. I love that PTX continues to stretch their arrangements and evolve how they use the members' voices. I especially love the positive message in this song 🎵 ❤
This was filmed before vaccines were available to everyone so I think they were shot separately and then it was put together. The album was released in February 2021. The shot of all of them looks like a composite of each of them put together. It looks a little odd but you do what you have to do to keep everyone safe until everyone is vaccinated.
ive always thought that Scott isnt very prominent in this one because he is doing a lot of bass with Matt. Giving the low notes a reverb sound to them. You tried to identify a low bum sound at one point and i think that is both Matt and Scott hitting a low note together.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
They let the authors of different songs lead in them on that album. Kirstie wrote this one. She also wrote 'Love Me When I Don't', 'Exit Signs' and 'It's Different Now'.
Oh wow thats pretty neat, and good to know
Mitch had a beautiful supporting role in Kirstin's lead vocals. That's one of the reasons I love this track. I love his ad-libs. They went pretty intricate with the background vocals and percussion . This is a Kirstie written song also. Great reaction per usual. Thanks!🙏🏾❤️
oh she wrote this?!
@@SalvoG Yes she co-wrote it with producers Mathew Koma and Dan book. In the making of This album they all would do writing groups. It would be a writer/ producer plus one or two members of PTX in a room, just flushing out ideas and writing songs, this one was just Kirstie and the producers, no other members. 😊
Kirstin wrote this song. She has really come into her own. She has grown a lot professionally and she's in a positive relationship with Ben. She also wrote or co wrote Love Me When I Dont.
I like this song way more then Happy Now.
Definitely the noise you're looking for is Matt's bass. As another poster said, what Mitch is doing is called descant (kind of a echo an octave higher).
I have a lot to learn lol
@@SalvoG having watched so many reaction videos and plowing through hundreds of comments, i have learned a lot really. Pentaholics are awesome lol
What I find interesting about this song is you are hearing Kirstin's and Mitch's lower registers as well as hearing Mitch soar above her vocals. Scott, Matt and Kevin while they are there, they are more background - if that makes sense- you can't always pick out their individual voices like you can Mitch's.
Makes sense. It seems I can always hear Mtich, even when there is a tight harmony with all five of them, his voice is so unique. I even hearing him humming at the end of Hallelujah.
I believe the sound you are trying to figure out is being done by Matt. You can catch his mouth movements in two shots.
I would call parts of what Mitch sang (when he was floating above, singing “be my eyes”, that could be called a descant- a melody/harmony written to “float” above the rest of the arrangement.
I wish I knew more about the technical terms to help me as I am listening. Who knows maybe further into this journey Ill know a lot
She also wrote it……She’s been in the boys shadow to long….Judy D
Not only was it a Kirstin lead. It was written by Kirstin as well
Kirstin also leads in All my favorite things, she also has some great solo works
Yes, & she also has a large part in Can You Feel The Live Tonight from the Lion King!
I would say Mitch has supporting vocals in this track instead of background. Not the lead, but more in the forefront than a background vocal, like what Scott does here.
I always forget how much I like this song until I hear it again. Kirsten actual went through a creative spurt and wrote or co-wrote a bunch of the songs on the Luck Ones. I’ve heard her talking about it in (I think) it was an Instagram live.
I love this song. One thing I noticed, when listening to just audio with no video distraction, while Kirstin sounds amazing, Mitch is doing so much in the background and I'm loving it. Great reaction 😎
This is in my top five PTX songs, just gorgeous! Kirstie + Mitch = AMAZING !!
Kirstin takes the lead in "My Favorite Things". Definitely an interesting video.
for just pure harmonies listen to My heart with you. absolutely beautiful
I think I'd maybe call Mitch's part here a descant. It's not THE melody, but it is A melody that sort of enhances and lays over the main melody. I like you fragile sky city visual!
Other great Kirstin leads are Rather Be, Love Me When I Don't, and Seasons of Love!!
This was shot in the lock-down. They were in separate homes. The editing put all the guys in around the glass pieces and even the together shots. Kirstie is a great songwriter, of course Kevin co writes with her. Love her stuff. Thanks for reacting. Stay safe.
Nice reaction. Thank you. The sound that you were curious about was made by Matt. Mitch said that this was his favorite song from the album. Kirstin is a terrific writer/co-writer.
I know exactly what you meant about the feel of the song haha and Mitch had supporting vocals here which were stunning. I always enjoy when Kirstie takes the lead on a song because we get to see how much her voice has truly grown and matured over the years. she's a real powerhouse for sure. ❤️
I'm sure I've heard Mitch say that this is favourite PTX original or possibly just his favourite The Lucky Ones track. Such a well written song, and a great Kirstin/Mitch vocal combo.
(I also think she said her fav off this album was Anchor, which is a Mitch lead).
I love this one, and an older one she wrote called Water.
Something that I think this song does a great job of illustrating that I feel gets somewhat overlooked at times about PTX is the complete lack of ego that they've shown over a decade plus of this.
They could each have an absolute superstar solo career at literally any moment they want. But here they are singing backup to each other. It's just something you don't see a ton of, and I think, one of the most refreshing things about PTX.
I love this song. Catchy yes, and beautiful harmony as usual.
Matt is what you are hearing. The most important thing which I had commented on in another video is that Mitch has a Patreon and he went live 2 weeks ago and said this was his favorite song on the album and he wishes that he had been in in the writing process but then backtracked and said he might have disrupted the flow. This was filmed like coffee in bed and mad world where COVID wasn't in lockdown but it still wasn't safe to be around other people. I thought they did a great job!!! They are always meticulous about every part of what they do and that I think is why they stand out so much. Talent of course plays a huge part in it but I think if you outwork everyone else and care about what you are making and love it, all of those together make them the top
Great song. It is one of my favorites from TLO, But there are so many good songs on that album it is difficult to choose just one.
I love their originals!
To be honest, when I first heard this I did not like it. Now it is one of my favorite songs. I think it’s the lyrics. I love it!! Also love Coffee in Bed and Anchor. Love your observations!
Another Kirstin driven song that's older is Rather Be. It's one of my favorites. Of course there is their second song on Episode 8 of The Sing Off. How's that for a tease to get you back to doing those???
Kirstin has a real sultry sound when she sings those lower notes. I feel like that is why you kept running it back to hear her. Really love this song! Radio play should be a no brainer! Thank you for reacting to this one!
I think what you were hearing, (the mystery sound), I think that was Matt doing 1/2 bass 1/2 beatbox, I've heard him do that before, and it can throw you off, until you see his face on camera when the note hits.
I believe Kirstie wrote this
You also saw a kirstin lead when you watched water on popspring. Rather Be, My favorite things, Seasons of love, and Once upon a December are also great kirstin leads. She also has a big part in Shallow. She and Scott duet it with a little surprise part from Mitch. Plus you get Kevin celloboxing. (Beatboxing while playing cello). He’s the one who created it and is the only one who does it as far as I know.
This is one of my favourite songs by them!
absolutely LOVE the message in this song....what are friends and loved ones for?...being eyes when we are blind to things not good for us. Love it! Kirstie wrote this one.
Most of the songs on The Lucky Ones were co-written with and co-produced by a pair of experienced pop songwriters / producers, Matthew Koma and Dan Book. And there were multiple vocal editors on many tracks. My theory is that any odd sounds are the result of taking a vocal phrase and doing some extra sound editing.
I like the ethereal look and sounds.
me too for sure
I wouldn't say your inner vision is off, even visually this suggests clouds and glass. Plus, I am of the opinion that personal interpretation or visualization is never "wrong." It may not be the intended one, but what it means to you is how the music spoke to your soul....
You should check out her solo EP. LOVE A lot of very good songs, I Can See It is my favorite.
Thanks for your persistence in getting these reaction videos up where we can watch!
Absolutely love this!! My thoughts are the sound you are hearing is Matt's low bass.
There is no video for it, but one of my favorite Kirstin led songs is Sweet Nothing.
Kirstin also has solo songs as well that are super good! They are on her UA-cam channel and every song is amazing so it doesn’t matter which one you pick to listen to first!
Love your reaction!
Didn't the musical tune from Enya? Sail away? Love this song.
Yes, descant would probably be the correct musical term for what Mitch is doing here... but in PTX-speak, you can just call it "ear-candy" ;-)
I don't think your visual is weird - they kept everything very light here, and porcelain has a beautiful crystalline structure that bounces sound around before fading away, so it fits perfectly! Along with the lightness, we are getting the richness of Kirsten's mezza-soprano with her staying in the lower part of her register in this one - same for Mitch in the lower parts. I love that PTX continues to stretch their arrangements and evolve how they use the members' voices. I especially love the positive message in this song 🎵 ❤
She has her own music and it’s great. Watch on UA-cam.
Recommend their Rather Be, Come Along, Amazing Grace, and My Favorite Things.
Kirstie wrote this, I believe.
This was filmed before vaccines were available to everyone so I think they were shot separately and then it was put together. The album was released in February 2021. The shot of all of them looks like a composite of each of them put together. It looks a little odd but you do what you have to do to keep everyone safe until everyone is vaccinated.
KIrsten led in the cover of Say Something, worth checking out
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Kirsten wrote this song. Awesome!!!
ive always thought that Scott isnt very prominent in this one because he is doing a lot of bass with Matt. Giving the low notes a reverb sound to them. You tried to identify a low bum sound at one point and i think that is both Matt and Scott hitting a low note together.
💖💖💖💖💖
Listen to Orinocco Flow by Enya, similar vibes.
That would be Matt...
Kirstin Leads a good percentage of songs. This is NOT A SURPRISE!!!
Another Kirstie lead..My Favorite Things!!