I literally have never commented on a UA-cam video in my entire life but I will just to say PLEASE continue with the Sugababes series for a little longer.... I would really love to see critiques of solos from Mutya, Heidi, Amelle and Jade as well as a little more from the later line up. Yes there were a lot of line-ups but that's just a fun detail of the Sugababes' history! Of course the series will have to end eventually but hopefully not prematurely!
ngl performance why this was one of the best stage sets I've seen for the group ever lol they don't normally have much going on they just stand and sing and maybe do the odd choreography, but I loved it!
Noooo please don't interrupt the series, I know it's very long but there are still so many things to see. There is still a review of About You Now, one of their most successful songs together with Push The Button, Freedom by 4.0 lineup and at least a solo performance of all the members of the band .... Mutya's solo performances are missing and Amelle, and Jade 😔 Please extend the series a little longer ❤️
I notice when Amelle is covering tracks, she’s mostly live with K&H singing to track or miming. She appears breathy when singing Mutya’s parts, I reckon that’s just down to her having to emulate a sound rather than her natural voice. When she sings live on originals her tone is different.
Keisha didn't mime here, she doesn't do pre recorded. She also always does ad libs in the songs and they are live. Heidi definetely was pre recorded here though.
LOVE the Sugababes, theyre my favs from UK pop... i asled you before and i ask you again... PLEASE react to THE SATURDAYS!!! at least to their Notorious performance at So You Think You Can Dance. I love that performance!!!
Loved the series but wish we got to see more Amelle original songs. Please see their performance of Follow Me Home from Top of the Pops...it really shows off Amelle’s vocal talents. Such an underrated voice.
I absolutely loved your series on The Sugababes and hearing your opinions, thank you. Keeping it British girl bands have you heard of The Honeyz and Eternal?
The Honeyz and, in particular, ETERNAL, were great British girl bands. Easther Bennett from Eternal is one of the most underrated, incredible vocalists of her generation. Mind-blowingly brilliant.
You need to do a mini series on the popular British girl band Stooshe who had a handful of hits in 2012, I think they've since split up but they had such a retro sound and were different to all the other girl bands around at that time.
Sooo glad you did a review of this video! I love this track by them and the whole staging. Very good vocals from Keisha, Heidi was clearly getting a tad help from auto tune. Maybe she was having an off day. Come on, get the reformed Sugababes AKA MKS. Can’t wait for 2020 🎶 🎧
Heidi and Keisha are singing to a backing track. They are NOT live. There are several tracks where Amelle came in and inserted quick studio vocals where Mutya sang, but they were not cleaned up and then she sang live during the performance.
It seems like they've changed some words cause of the Royal Variety but that didn't happened when Heidi's verse came along cause she still sang "I'll kiss my ass before I'm feeling blue". Caught ya, H.
Thank you for finally doing a Sugababes 3.0 reaction. But this song was written for Mutya. So judging Amelle on this is unfair. You can't do a Sugababes series and not do a Sugababes 3.0 song including Amelle. Please, About You Now.
I remember the Sugababes doing the treadmill dance routine before, but for some reason I thought it was their version of Obsession by Animation but with Mutya. Does anyone remember this?
I think Heidi was singing live.. you could hear changes to her studio delivery, it was just a good clear performance and she often struggles with pushing too hard
Its a fact that you like Sugababes 1.0 the most. I mean you didn't chose any Sugababes song from 2006-2011. Of course Amelle doesnt sound as strong as Mutya on Mutyas own songs. She sounded brilliant during 2007-2010. Especially during Catfights and Spotlights. Sugababes 3.0 sounded stunning towards their end. And some performances from Sugababes 4.0 are also great. I don't understand why you didn't chose a song thats from Change, Catfights and Spotlights or Sweet7?
I so agree! It’s popular to hate on every lineup since the original or since Mutya/Keisha/Heidi ... but I really liked every line up and thought every member brought something different for their era. I don’t think it’s fair to really compare the “replacements” to the original members
Babes someone is always gonna have a favourite! My fave is 1.0, but I think Catfights is a SUPER underrated and good album. I think that C&S and Sweet7 suffered from following trends (well, don't get me wrong) rather than creating them. At the same time, I can't with people arguing that Jade 'felt' like a Sugababe for all of 2 minutes, or that Heidi is a good live singer.
I would love you to check out UK girl band M.O (No scrubs @ Kiss FM, Bad Vibe @ Kiss FM or their One Dance acoustic cover) Big statement but I think they're the best in the UK right now!
Heidi lip-synced, probably wasn't a good time for her to be singing live. Happens all the time with live performances. Beautiful voice on that girl though!
Reading comments about Siobhan & how she’s amazing, to be honest I don’t think she had any stage presences back in 2000 & was boring to watch perform. Yes she can sing but what good is that if they are boring to watch. As for this sugababes series I don’t think 3.0 & 4.0 have been given a far go. The performances that got judged was both performances where it had only been weeks of the replacement joining. So they didn’t have time to gel as a group. When if you watch performances of 3.0 & 4.0 later down the line they sound amazing cos they had time to gel. Also I don’t get why 1.0 has had 3 vids? To me Siobhan was boring, wasn’t really a “sugababe” from just one album/ 4 singles that basically got them dropped by their record company & I would much rather see Heidi in the come back as she was a bigger part of the sugababes that Siobhan.
Yeah but Heidi cannot sing well, is superficial and hypocrite and Keishe and Mutya don't like her at all. They would never sing with her again. That's why they got back together with Siobhan who is a stunning vocalist and quite nice as a person.
I would have thought about you now or denial.. would be more suitable songs or from their albums when amelle joined. Even the song girls.. This song dosesnt compliment amelle as it Mutya vocals that sound much better on it.
Georgina, the vocals here where pre-recorded to make it sound live. Often singers will re-record their vocals to make it sound like its ‘live’ and then mime over the track when they are performing it live! So yes they were miming here
I don’t think you”be done enough of Jade to fairly rank them yet. I hope the last video is Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up), that’s where you’ll see 4.0 come into their own
Yes, but it would be easier to sing live on the chorus when the other two are singing it as well. Their vocals in the chorus were probably backed up with recorded vocals too.
Not a bad perfomance; Heidi's part perhaps wasn't lipsynced...?? Could it be that she was controlling her breath!! Her odd vibrato sounded the same as in other live perfomances; in the album version they edited a little bit more making her sound cleaner ......I wish tough you would've chosen another perfomance of the last lineup and reviewed Jade's vocals in crash and burn aswell as their performance as a group.
“I loved her verbrato there... runaawwaaayy... that was not it. Never mind” 🤣
I literally have never commented on a UA-cam video in my entire life but I will just to say PLEASE continue with the Sugababes series for a little longer.... I would really love to see critiques of solos from Mutya, Heidi, Amelle and Jade as well as a little more from the later line up. Yes there were a lot of line-ups but that's just a fun detail of the Sugababes' history! Of course the series will have to end eventually but hopefully not prematurely!
ngl performance why this was one of the best stage sets I've seen for the group ever lol they don't normally have much going on they just stand and sing and maybe do the odd choreography, but I loved it!
Noooo please don't interrupt the series, I know it's very long but there are still so many things to see. There is still a review of About You Now, one of their most successful songs together with Push The Button, Freedom by 4.0 lineup and at least a solo performance of all the members of the band .... Mutya's solo performances are missing and Amelle, and Jade 😔 Please
extend the series a little longer ❤️
Yes, Mutya singing Just A Little Bit on Later With Jools Holland is great!
Agreed! Please Georgina! Keep the series going on a litte longer!
Mooooore! I can recommend some more Siobhan too, although Keisha solo is a bit hard to find.
The drums were VERY cool!! The treadmill thing was pretty awesome. (I can’t chew gum and walk at the same time!!😂)
Their cover on En Vogue’s Don’t Let Go is their best vocal performance, imo.
I wish you'd reacted to a No Can Do performance, 3.0 really get to show off their vocals and harmonies during those.
Exactly. Amelle felt way more comfortable during these days and they sounded awesome
I notice when Amelle is covering tracks, she’s mostly live with K&H singing to track or miming. She appears breathy when singing Mutya’s parts, I reckon that’s just down to her having to emulate a sound rather than her natural voice. When she sings live on originals her tone is different.
Keisha didn't mime here, she doesn't do pre recorded. She also always does ad libs in the songs and they are live. Heidi definetely was pre recorded here though.
I looooooove the way Amelle says "Runaway"
I recommended / asked for this thank you! I hope it was my request you honoured! Haha. This showcases the girls live abilities so well IMO
“Treadmill, I like this, this is cool” - agreed 👍
Where’s Mutya?
I hate “happy all the time” people but I can’t get enough of the honest vocal coach 😂
I love this intro so funny and entertaining! Always the best gorgeous Georgina 🤩🤩
LOVE the Sugababes, theyre my favs from UK pop... i asled you before and i ask you again... PLEASE react to THE SATURDAYS!!! at least to their Notorious performance at So You Think You Can Dance. I love that performance!!!
I think the word you wanted to mean second to last is 'penultimate' :-)
Dans you made me go back into phonetics class !
I was just about to say this
Loved the series but wish we got to see more Amelle original songs. Please see their performance of Follow Me Home from Top of the Pops...it really shows off Amelle’s vocal talents. Such an underrated voice.
Jordan T follow me home was still technically a Mutya song lol
sugarlipsinc omg it was too🤦
@@sugarlipsinc Didn't Mutya release a song technically written by Amelle
I absolutely loved your series on The Sugababes and hearing your opinions, thank you. Keeping it British girl bands have you heard of The Honeyz and Eternal?
She also needs to do Stooshe, another popular British girl band that had a handful of hits in 2012.
The Honeyz and, in particular, ETERNAL, were great British girl bands. Easther Bennett from Eternal is one of the most underrated, incredible vocalists of her generation. Mind-blowingly brilliant.
You need to do a mini series on the popular British girl band Stooshe who had a handful of hits in 2012, I think they've since split up but they had such a retro sound and were different to all the other girl bands around at that time.
I can't believe it's the second last video no!!! Lol This was my favourite series after Destiny's Child
Effie Escandelo yes!! Everything you’ve said! Thank you!! 🙂
She can do so many more !
Just came across your channel recently Georgina ....enjoying your critiques and your lovely personality ♡
Down that brew Georgina lol 😆 love your vids x
Always loved Ameles voice 🌹
Sooo glad you did a review of this video! I love this track by them and the whole staging.
Very good vocals from Keisha, Heidi was clearly getting a tad help from auto tune. Maybe she was having an off day. Come on, get the reformed Sugababes AKA MKS. Can’t wait for 2020 🎶 🎧
Love watching your video's! Greetings from Belgium!
I love watching your videos, greetings from Colombia!
Heidi and Keisha are singing to a backing track. They are NOT live. There are several tracks where Amelle came in and inserted quick studio vocals where Mutya sang, but they were not cleaned up and then she sang live during the performance.
Heidi's verse was defo lip synced. Maybe she was sick or something
yeah live performances always did a number on her immune system :(
Yep, she was probably sick
You can hear her breathing whilst singing ...was live
@@bobbikhan8401 lol no it wasn't.
SHE WAS LIVE
It seems like they've changed some words cause of the Royal Variety but that didn't happened when Heidi's verse came along cause she still sang "I'll kiss my ass before I'm feeling blue". Caught ya, H.
Thank you for finally doing a Sugababes 3.0 reaction.
But this song was written for Mutya. So judging Amelle on this is unfair.
You can't do a Sugababes series and not do a Sugababes 3.0 song including Amelle.
Please, About You Now.
Sir George so unfair how people compare amelle to Mutya, I became a Sugababes fan when amelle joined. Love her voice. Even more so on her own tracks.
Love your channel!
Weird that you chose this one since they’ve stated that they ALL lipsynced in an interview mainly because of the treadmill, yes even Keisha...
Keisha sounded like a mess, and that was WITH lip sync?!
I mean, this song isn’t really to showcase their voices really, Keisha has seen better days for sure
Amazing performance I think. This is for sure the best lineup of the Sugababes on my opinion. ALSO PLEASE DO THE SATURDAYS!!!
I remember the Sugababes doing the treadmill dance routine before, but for some reason I thought it was their version of Obsession by Animation but with Mutya. Does anyone remember this?
sugababes are so amazing
The penultimate video - also will you do another sugababes video when the original three eventually release their next album?
It can’t be the last there’s lots more !!
Ilove u so much Gorgina!😍
I think Heidi was singing live.. you could hear changes to her studio delivery, it was just a good clear performance and she often struggles with pushing too hard
Its called pre-recorded vocals, she recorded it days before the show
Nope definitely pre recorded
Its a fact that you like Sugababes 1.0 the most.
I mean you didn't chose any Sugababes song from 2006-2011.
Of course Amelle doesnt sound as strong as Mutya on Mutyas own songs. She sounded brilliant during 2007-2010.
Especially during Catfights and Spotlights. Sugababes 3.0 sounded stunning towards their end.
And some performances from Sugababes 4.0 are also great.
I don't understand why you didn't chose a song thats from Change, Catfights and Spotlights or Sweet7?
Completely agree i think if you're going to critique amelle Heidi and keisha it needs to be from the change album or catfights and spotlights
@@stephenbradley8472 yup. I think the rating on Thursday will be pretty unfair
Totally agree!
I so agree! It’s popular to hate on every lineup since the original or since Mutya/Keisha/Heidi ... but I really liked every line up and thought every member brought something different for their era.
I don’t think it’s fair to really compare the “replacements” to the original members
Babes someone is always gonna have a favourite!
My fave is 1.0, but I think Catfights is a SUPER underrated and good album. I think that C&S and Sweet7 suffered from following trends (well, don't get me wrong) rather than creating them.
At the same time, I can't with people arguing that Jade 'felt' like a Sugababe for all of 2 minutes, or that Heidi is a good live singer.
mutya would be a difficult act for anyone to follow, amelle is ok, but shes not Mutya
penultimate was the word when you were saying prequel!
It is crazy iSH 😂😂 my lovely lady
I would love you to check out UK girl band M.O (No scrubs @ Kiss FM, Bad Vibe @ Kiss FM or their One Dance acoustic cover) Big statement but I think they're the best in the UK right now!
There is Another Version in UA-cam With Heidis Real Voice 😉
I thought they sounded pretty good, considering this isn't a song Amelle was originally on I thought she sounded good, put her own spin on it.
Heidi lip-synced, probably wasn't a good time for her to be singing live. Happens all the time with live performances. Beautiful voice on that girl though!
Looked like Heidi is lipsynching
Heidi was deffo miming she pulled the microphone away from her mouth but no sound change.
Did like the treadmill parts though very affective 👍
Reading comments about Siobhan & how she’s amazing, to be honest I don’t think she had any stage presences back in 2000 & was boring to watch perform. Yes she can sing but what good is that if they are boring to watch. As for this sugababes series I don’t think 3.0 & 4.0 have been given a far go. The performances that got judged was both performances where it had only been weeks of the replacement joining. So they didn’t have time to gel as a group. When if you watch performances of 3.0 & 4.0 later down the line they sound amazing cos they had time to gel. Also I don’t get why 1.0 has had 3 vids? To me Siobhan was boring, wasn’t really a “sugababe” from just one album/ 4 singles that basically got them dropped by their record company & I would much rather see Heidi in the come back as she was a bigger part of the sugababes that Siobhan.
Yeah but Heidi cannot sing well, is superficial and hypocrite and Keishe and Mutya don't like her at all. They would never sing with her again. That's why they got back together with Siobhan who is a stunning vocalist and quite nice as a person.
@@MilesAwayBg mutya and keisha sucks and their personality is ew
Keisha has the choice of who she wants to work with and she does not want to work with Heidi. Siobhan ain't going anywhere
I would have thought about you now or denial.. would be more suitable songs or from their albums when amelle joined. Even the song girls.. This song dosesnt compliment amelle as it Mutya vocals that sound much better on it.
Georgina, the vocals here where pre-recorded to make it sound live. Often singers will re-record their vocals to make it sound like its ‘live’ and then mime over the track when they are performing it live! So yes they were miming here
I think Heidi is the only one lip syncing though.
Why would they do that?
They're live
penultimate is the word you're looking for
My fave line up is
1. keisha Mutya Heidi..
2. keisha Heidi amele
3. Heidi amelle jade
4. Siobhan keisha Mutya
Why so much slate for Heidi- not needed? 😮 I think this is a great performance.
Is Heidi's verse pre-recorded?
Second to last is penultimate Georgina 😇😀
lmaoo Heidi blew the cover.... *rolls eyes* lol I was sure it was all live before she had her solo
Second to last = penultimate. Trust me. I’m a teacher!
I don’t think you”be done enough of Jade to fairly rank them yet. I hope the last video is Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up), that’s where you’ll see 4.0 come into their own
Dan Stearn love that performance! ❤️
Agree.
She should have used more songs including Amelle and Jade.
Or a Sweet 7 song
Yeah that's my fav performance of theirs. Gonna watch it now
Dan Stearn she was really complimentary about jade!
Hi!! OMG! I'm the first comment! Love the channel!
Love you Georgina, please shorten the channel introduction part at the beginning.
No doubt Heidi was not singing live, and she didn't sell the miming.
It would of been done in studio so she was lip syncing because my producer that worked with britney Spears he did that for her
I love amelle, favourite Sugababe!
Love Amelle and Heidi ❤️❤️
they were all lipsyncing pre-recorded vocals, probabIy because of the treadmill
Amelle's diction drives me nuts if I listen too closely.
You can hear Heidi is singing live on the chorus....and in the end
...not sure that we heard the same thing. . .
Yes, but it would be easier to sing live on the chorus when the other two are singing it as well. Their vocals in the chorus were probably backed up with recorded vocals too.
No you just don't like Heidi that's why you want to make something up if she is singing well
Penultimate video 😊
I wonder if Heidi was unwell, so lip synced her bit 🤷🏻♀️. Just a thought
to me they are all lipsynching, it's just it seems like Heidi didn't get to record a "live" version of her part
yeah they seem to be lip synching to pre recorded vocals all of them not just Heidi.
Lisa to me Heidi is lip synching to the studio version, and the other girls lip synching to the pre recorded love version
It wasn't 100% live and even then Amelle sounded off, the diction drives me nuts. As you said MEH!
She didn’t sound off
She can't sing live. Period.
Maybe Heidi was a bit off and they replaced her vocals in post production?
Kinda unfair how you haven't gone to sweet 7 and listen to more of Jade
She also ignored Change and Catfights and Spotlights.
Basically every song from 2006-2011
Noooo you have to do them allllllllllll!!!!!!!
Was Heidi lipsyching?
Not a bad perfomance; Heidi's part perhaps wasn't lipsynced...?? Could it be that she was controlling her breath!! Her odd vibrato sounded the same as in other live perfomances; in the album version they edited a little bit more making her sound cleaner
......I wish tough you would've chosen another perfomance of the last lineup and reviewed Jade's vocals in crash and burn aswell as their performance as a group.
Lip sync to live pre record
3rd.😍😍😍
Penultimate ;)
I feel like they were all using pre-recorded vocals ...
Maybe she was full of cold it happens or she cant sing that song well as us used to
I think pre-recorded live vocal a la Cheryl tbh
If it's pre-recorded it's not live? I'm so confused. Like it's not just you hut everyone in the comments says they're doing this and like... What?
Penultimate
God this performance is a mess. And Hole in the Head just isn't right without Mutya.
100% lipsync. They can do better
That is lip sync
The Honest Vocal Coach I love you so much , you’re amazing
Heidi is the weakest. Very airy voice.
I don't like this song at all...oh yucky.