salamualaykum i have gone on a few 3 day jammats and as a new muslim it was very helpful praying in the masjid all 5 prayers learning how to pray reading hadiths asking questions on quran. i dont really see whats wrong with them.
Allah guides people through anyone. But Tableeris have innovations and innovations are considered very dangerous in Islam. Even tho Tableeris are very nice people. But we prefer the sunnah of the prophet s.a.w.
With due respect, For any salafi it's easy to criticise the other schools of thought. A Tablighi focuses on basics of islam, and separates itself from all kinds of firqawariat. Those who hv issues with 40 days, can go in jamaa of 39 or 41 no issues at all. It's just to maintain a system.
Islamqa has a very balanced answer in regards to Jama’at al-Tabligh if you write , " islamqa , What is the ruling on the 40 days and 4 months to the different parts of the world to call Muslim brothers towards the duties of Islam? " or "Jama`at al-Tabligh: Pros and Cons" But i must say , this jamat is not in any way a school of thought, , you cant compare them to the other 4 school of thought Jazallah khair
And where is the evidence for these 41/39/40 days? Did prophet SAWS take his companions to khuruj? I challenge every tablighi to provide a clear cut evidence without any false interpretations from kitab and sunnah about the methodology of khuruj. And the claim that tableeghi jama'ah separates itself from sects is not true, almost every bayan includes the famous sentence "this is the true manhaj of Rasulullah" and that sentence itself proves that Tableeghi jama'ah believes that their manhaj is more correct than others. The best evidence that the biggest leaders "Qudamaa" of tableeghi jama'ah can provide is to cut some parts of some verses from their original context.
Akhi I have been seeing your problematical comments for the past months. I really for the sake of Allah advice you to seek knowledge from the favored 3 generations
Read fazail amal and compare it with quran o sunnah you'll understand their weird aqeedah 😅. Nice people but deviant still. Believe in fake stories, some they make up on the spot themselves. May Allah guide them and guide us
Jazaakallaahu khairan for the clarification Shaykh. For those who need to research more, a good book in English that demonstrates the aqeedah (belief system) of the Tablighi Jamat and its parent sect is: "The Jamaat Tableegh and the Deobandis: A Critical Analysis of their Beliefs, Books and Dawah" by Sajid A. Kayum. PDF copy avaiable online.
Tableegi Jamat people are fir the most part nice and well-intentioned but their ‘leaders’ , and the books they use are full of Indian fairytales, unverified stories, Indian sufi fiction and outright lies and blasphemies in some cases. So they will have. Book that is 80% discussing sound ahadith but in between there will be fabricated Hadith, weak hadiths and also the authors will start telling their stories of a pious man in india who would not eat for 20 years, 😂😂 and then some Indian sufi stories about a man who would speak from his grave saying I a, having a good time in my grave or that those whose hearts are attached to Allah don’t really die,……..so as the sheikh said be vigilant - you will see 80% of people amd things very nice but that 20% poison will be lurking around that will destroy your aqida or put doubts in your mind esp if you are a teenager or in your early 20s.
Psychology has proven it takes 40 days to build a habit so when they go for 40 days as Musa alaihe salaam did their faith grows so much stronger and when they come back they change for the better alhamdulelah there are even singers and dancers that came back to deen through the dawah of tableegh jamat such as legend Junaid Jamsheed look up his story for yourself
Shaykh didn't deny that they have some khair but that doesn't mean that there are no issues. The manhaj is full of different innovations and that's dangerous. I believe that "psychology" is not a good evidence.
Shaykh what you said about the Tableegj Jamat is not true they are upon the Quran and the sunnah strictly I don’t just say this but I know from experience and my husband s been in it for years alhamdulelah it’d brought nothing but khair and barakah into our lives and the lives of millions of people around the world. You cannot give dawah sitting at the comfort of ur own mosque and just home people are misguided out there they need someone to not only give them advice but take them away from all Worldly matters into the house of Allah where all they do is pray read Quran read ahafith and connect with their Lord. Nowadays this is the best kind of dawah that u can do. The 40 days comes from the 49 days that Musa also be Salam was ordered by Allah to meet Him and he fasted n prayed during the 40 days also it helps a lot with breaking bad habits and to build new habits in 40 days while ur away from bad environment and worldly distractions please shaykh try to find them and see for yourself what they actually do and don’t not based on something you have heard
I don't agree that these pillars of Tabeeghi Jamaat are based on Qur'aan & authentic Sunnah. We only go to Sharah min Qableenah (the Shariah of the previous Prophets Alehymusalaam) if we need to. IMO you can't just go around saying oh just because I can't find anything in QUR'AAN or authentic Sunnah to back up my position, then I will just use something from Musa Alehisalaam's time. The point about most of them being Maturidi/Ashari is a separate point. If it is permissible for Salafi Hanbalis to pray behind them, then surely it is allowed to accompany them in making tableegh to Muslims/Non-Muslims.
If anything is laced with Indian culture, Indian influence , Indian stories , Indian focus , started in india, then leave it as its toxic. It’s that simple. 😊
Sufis due to not knowing Sunni hadith science use weak hadith and end up copying alot of bida from teh shi'uh from mawlid to praying to graves. Even the term Soufi I think started with a shi'uh!
Ridiculous objection concerning 40 days. So if a muslim goes away from his home to a different location. Away from his friends and the influence of his environment. And focuses on his salah and zikr during those 40 days. Is his religous observance likely to increase decrease or remain the same. And on the flipside if it is a contemptible bidah. Then hiring huge conference halls to give Islamic talks, handing out books pamphlets etc. Is that not a bidah.??? Where did the Salaf do this???
Dear Sheikh, Your answer was very very vague and very general. Tabligh is not a school of thought or a Madrasa it is a movement for rectifying the Ummah. They are the most united brothers in the world, it seems your issue with them is a personal one as opposed to anything else.
I been in jamaat Tablighi alhamdulilaah change my life I took shaahaadaa 2013 don't speak bad about the jamaat or deal with Allah ta'laa
salamualaykum
i have gone on a few 3 day jammats and as a new muslim it was very helpful praying in the masjid all 5 prayers learning how to pray reading hadiths asking questions on quran. i dont really see whats wrong with them.
whatever prophet Muhammad (SAW) or the favourite 3 generations have never done, even if that is really good, we couldn't do that as simple as that.
Allah guides people through anyone. But Tableeris have innovations and innovations are considered very dangerous in Islam. Even tho Tableeris are very nice people. But we prefer the sunnah of the prophet s.a.w.
@@TanzimMerajlike driving a car or flying in a plane? 😂😂😂
With due respect, For any salafi it's easy to criticise the other schools of thought.
A Tablighi focuses on basics of islam, and separates itself from all kinds of firqawariat.
Those who hv issues with 40 days, can go in jamaa of 39 or 41 no issues at all. It's just to maintain a system.
Islamqa has a very balanced answer in regards to Jama’at al-Tabligh if you write ,
" islamqa , What is the ruling on the 40 days and 4 months to the different parts of the world to call Muslim brothers towards the duties of Islam? " or "Jama`at al-Tabligh: Pros and Cons"
But i must say , this jamat is not in any way a school of thought, , you cant compare them to the other 4 school of thought
Jazallah khair
And where is the evidence for these 41/39/40 days? Did prophet SAWS take his companions to khuruj?
I challenge every tablighi to provide a clear cut evidence without any false interpretations from kitab and sunnah about the methodology of khuruj.
And the claim that tableeghi jama'ah separates itself from sects is not true, almost every bayan includes the famous sentence "this is the true manhaj of Rasulullah" and that sentence itself proves that Tableeghi jama'ah believes that their manhaj is more correct than others.
The best evidence that the biggest leaders "Qudamaa" of tableeghi jama'ah can provide is to cut some parts of some verses from their original context.
Akhi I have been seeing your problematical comments for the past months. I really for the sake of Allah advice you to seek knowledge from the favored 3 generations
Read fazail amal and compare it with quran o sunnah you'll understand their weird aqeedah 😅. Nice people but deviant still. Believe in fake stories, some they make up on the spot themselves. May Allah guide them and guide us
Jazaakallaahu khairan for the clarification Shaykh. For those who need to research more, a good book in English that demonstrates the aqeedah (belief system) of the Tablighi Jamat and its parent sect is:
"The Jamaat Tableegh and the Deobandis: A Critical Analysis of their Beliefs, Books and Dawah"
by Sajid A. Kayum. PDF copy avaiable online.
40 day = كل بدعة ضلالة وكل ضالة في النار
Tableegi Jamat people are fir the most part nice and well-intentioned but their ‘leaders’ , and the books they use are full of Indian fairytales, unverified stories, Indian sufi fiction and outright lies and blasphemies in some cases. So they will have. Book that is 80% discussing sound ahadith but in between there will be fabricated Hadith, weak hadiths and also the authors will start telling their stories of a pious man in india who would not eat for 20 years, 😂😂 and then some Indian sufi stories about a man who would speak from his grave saying I a, having a good time in my grave or that those whose hearts are attached to Allah don’t really die,……..so as the sheikh said be vigilant - you will see 80% of people amd things very nice but that 20% poison will be lurking around that will destroy your aqida or put doubts in your mind esp if you are a teenager or in your early 20s.
Stopped lying 🤥
They have good biryani. lol
BIDAH IS BIDAH
Assalamualaykum brother, hope you are well. Please provide daleel on your conclusions about this effort of deen?
Psychology has proven it takes 40 days to build a habit so when they go for 40 days as Musa alaihe salaam did their faith grows so much stronger and when they come back they change for the better alhamdulelah there are even singers and dancers that came back to deen through the dawah of tableegh jamat such as legend Junaid Jamsheed look up his story for yourself
Were Muslim we follow the sunnah and quran we don’t follow psychology
Please provide proof for 40 days of habit building. Because I have an educational background in this very field, and there's no proof of that...
Shaykh didn't deny that they have some khair but that doesn't mean that there are no issues. The manhaj is full of different innovations and that's dangerous.
I believe that "psychology" is not a good evidence.
Shaykh what you said about the Tableegj Jamat is not true they are upon the Quran and the sunnah strictly I don’t just say this but I know from experience and my husband s been in it for years alhamdulelah it’d brought nothing but khair and barakah into our lives and the lives of millions of people around the world. You cannot give dawah sitting at the comfort of ur own mosque and just home people are misguided out there they need someone to not only give them advice but take them away from all Worldly matters into the house of Allah where all they do is pray read Quran read ahafith and connect with their Lord. Nowadays this is the best kind of dawah that u can do. The 40 days comes from the 49 days that Musa also be Salam was ordered by Allah to meet Him and he fasted n prayed during the 40 days also it helps a lot with breaking bad habits and to build new habits in 40 days while ur away from bad environment and worldly distractions please shaykh try to find them and see for yourself what they actually do and don’t not based on something you have heard
I don't agree that these pillars of Tabeeghi Jamaat are based on Qur'aan & authentic Sunnah. We only go to Sharah min Qableenah (the Shariah of the previous Prophets Alehymusalaam) if we need to. IMO you can't just go around saying oh just because I can't find anything in QUR'AAN or authentic Sunnah to back up my position, then I will just use something from Musa Alehisalaam's time. The point about most of them being Maturidi/Ashari is a separate point. If it is permissible for Salafi Hanbalis to pray behind them, then surely it is allowed to accompany them in making tableegh to Muslims/Non-Muslims.
You are correct
Alhamdulilaah
He has knowledge when he speaks. The sheikh
If anything is laced with Indian culture, Indian influence , Indian stories , Indian focus , started in india, then leave it as its toxic. It’s that simple. 😊
40 days are practiced, by Shias.
Sufis due to not knowing Sunni hadith science use weak hadith and end up copying alot of bida from teh shi'uh from mawlid to praying to graves. Even the term Soufi I think started with a shi'uh!
I don't believe that the caller is from Texas :) Nah. Not really
JAK! :)
Ridiculous objection concerning 40 days. So if a muslim goes away from his home to a different location. Away from his friends and the influence of his environment. And focuses on his salah and zikr during those 40 days. Is his religous observance likely to increase decrease or remain the same.
And on the flipside if it is a contemptible bidah. Then hiring huge conference halls to give Islamic talks, handing out books pamphlets etc. Is that not a bidah.??? Where did the Salaf do this???
✌😇🧘♂️
They say something but does something else…..
Jamaat Tabligh was created by Britishers of India. It's why they get VISA to travel to Britain and it's colonies without any Hurdles1
Dear Sheikh,
Your answer was very very vague and very general. Tabligh is not a school of thought or a Madrasa it is a movement for rectifying the Ummah. They are the most united brothers in the world, it seems your issue with them is a personal one as opposed to anything else.
Not really but brothers in Tablighi jama'ah are requested to provide evidence for their manhaj.
Not that everyone follows his desires.