【全程字幕】新加坡前外交部長楊榮文佛羅倫斯演講全程QA 中西文化迥異精闢解析 全場震撼! 20240719

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 178

  • @emeritusdavidteo5553
    @emeritusdavidteo5553 4 місяці тому +49

    An in-depth understanding of Chinese history and current affairs anyone doing business with China should watch. The QnA after this session is candid and equally insightful. Thank you for uploading.

  • @naboosu6588
    @naboosu6588 4 місяці тому +40

    值得耐心听完❤

  • @張小可-b8l
    @張小可-b8l 4 місяці тому +45

    太有深度了....非常精彩

  • @paulsun8670
    @paulsun8670 3 місяці тому +23

    楊先生的知識水平很高,我昨天在洛陽二里頭遺址博物館,入館展示《論語.為政篇》,其內容如楊先生所雲。五千年的文明,五千年文化。

    • @stevenlim8958
      @stevenlim8958 2 місяці тому

      小本本不在身边……
      😘😍😍😍😍😍🥰🥰

    • @mindretreatful
      @mindretreatful 2 дні тому

      每一个有中国血统的新加坡的官员都知道,但每个人都可以用不同角度来表达这一点。George是我看到的最中国人的新加坡官员。

  • @donlee6155
    @donlee6155 3 місяці тому +40

    Singapore's walking encyclopedia.
    He is so good in his memory, replying questions without any prepared notes.
    Simply super knowledge and memory.
    Everyone must watch, in order to know how knowledgeable he was

    • @annec8430
      @annec8430 2 місяці тому

      超喜歡他!

    • @OmSoha-s3w
      @OmSoha-s3w 2 місяці тому +3

      So sad we lost him as a Minister. 😢

  • @szehianyap1092
    @szehianyap1092 3 місяці тому +5

    He is so knowledgeable ! It's a very informative speech. Very refreshing to listen to his speech. 👏👏👏👏👏

  • @rodwong8704
    @rodwong8704 4 місяці тому +30

    An excellent speech by Mr. Yeo, with in depth historical knowledge of China

  • @seowcherlak9217
    @seowcherlak9217 4 місяці тому +56

    我尊重楊榮文👍👍👍❤

  • @tuppenceworth5485
    @tuppenceworth5485 4 місяці тому +32

    Excellent talk, very educational.

  • @文磊-b5w
    @文磊-b5w 4 місяці тому +17

    很敏锐的观察,佩服

  • @richardlin4309
    @richardlin4309 3 місяці тому +10

    Definitely worth to spend time patiently through the whole lecture and Q&A section.

  • @Eyy7072
    @Eyy7072 3 місяці тому +4

    Brilliant! Well composed and well delivered. So informative and inspiring!!

  • @Niseedyyube6486
    @Niseedyyube6486 4 місяці тому +47

    He is so brilliant. Singapore government officials have some exceptional standards

  • @YokeChoonTang
    @YokeChoonTang 4 місяці тому +19

    Thankful for bringing insights with truth into the meeting. 1:03:25

  • @wuziouyang1470
    @wuziouyang1470 2 місяці тому +1

    This world really need people like prof yeo who knows both China and west in depth. We desperately need their advices to create mutual understanding. That way our planet will be safe and prosperous.

  • @alex-pw2iq
    @alex-pw2iq 3 місяці тому +22

    我们的部长有水准

  • @Paracosm-Nefelibata
    @Paracosm-Nefelibata 3 дні тому

    畅快淋漓的演讲

  • @edwinchan0123
    @edwinchan0123 День тому

    也太精彩了,楊先生,不知道你還記得在這偉大的國度裡,人民要舉起白紙來幹嘛呢,為甚麼要在烏魯木齊北路開始呢?能把話表達的如此亮麗,不簡單呀,這就是傳說中的政治人物嗎?

  • @yeechinyong5498
    @yeechinyong5498 4 місяці тому +31

    杨荣文👍💪🌞💯🎉

  • @_Urahara_Kisuke_
    @_Urahara_Kisuke_ 2 місяці тому +1

    Such a well read and well informed gentleman.

  • @ZhanhuiLi
    @ZhanhuiLi 4 місяці тому +9

    Very insightful speech and QnA! It is worth your time watching it.

  • @leigh.lin.21l39
    @leigh.lin.21l39 Місяць тому

    謝謝!

  • @iriswai1825
    @iriswai1825 3 місяці тому +8

    Mr Yeo is so brilliant and solid, excellent lecture

  • @antoniusdesun5509
    @antoniusdesun5509 4 місяці тому +25

    Pencerahan yang sangat membantu perdamaian dan kemakmuran serta kemajuan dunia 👍👍👍👍👍

  • @kengsengchan6005
    @kengsengchan6005 Місяць тому

    Very informative,,

  • @karenduncan6953
    @karenduncan6953 4 місяці тому +10

    It is really good value of speechs.

  • @hongqi5734
    @hongqi5734 3 місяці тому +3

    Professor Yeo is among the most reliable person on China's history, affairs and subjects. Kishore Mahbubani is another person who is truthful and unbiased.

  • @Michelleisonthego
    @Michelleisonthego 3 місяці тому +13

    respect!

  • @oyakefire
    @oyakefire 4 місяці тому +13

    杨先生毕竟是职业外交官,在演讲和问答中语言非常含蓄,点到即止。
    关于中国和欧洲的文化异同及特殊性,Martin Jacques先生的讲述更加深刻。

  • @donlee6155
    @donlee6155 3 місяці тому +10

    All Singaporean must watch and listen.
    He is so knowledgeable.
    Today's Singaporean politicians don't possess his knowledge.
    Singapore foreign minister hardly has 50 % of his exposures.

  • @jimning
    @jimning 4 місяці тому +8

    excellent!

  • @oasislin4587
    @oasislin4587 3 дні тому

    while I respect Mr Yeo's great anaylisis, I still believe if China could reduce their aggression in the SCC, that would stabilise all concerns about their innocence for desiring to conquer the world.

  • @654dfgs98
    @654dfgs98 4 місяці тому +35

    中國人相信老天爺自有安排!做壞事會有相應報應,做善事會有善報 ,太極陰陽,什麼事都有正反兩面。

  • @風跡
    @風跡 3 місяці тому +3

    精彩的演讲

  • @zzf967
    @zzf967 4 місяці тому +20

    这段无稿太牛逼

  • @SANN-1969
    @SANN-1969 4 місяці тому +6

    Treasure may over lifespan through times, but growth in productions and services never end

  • @civl-i7z
    @civl-i7z 8 днів тому

    聰明人講話是要對方也進行思考

  • @tlee9615
    @tlee9615 4 місяці тому +3

    Factual account 👍

  • @shinichifukumoto1088
    @shinichifukumoto1088 9 днів тому

    The content being said is so true, the west especially the U.S. should open it's heart and try very hard to study and understand the Chinese developments for the past 3 decades....the achievements by the Chinese is enormous on every aspects. International trading between all nations on earth should be greatly appreciated because through trading we all benefit prosperity on the other hand, U.S. sanctions on many countries is actually hindering the well being of it's own citizens......
    Wake up America, this 2024.....lets make the world GREAT again, NOT just you....!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @fed02
    @fed02 3 місяці тому +6

    Unscripted... it shows a real deep understanding of China. Amazing.

  • @XingfangHUO
    @XingfangHUO 3 місяці тому +4

    中国文化非常棒

  • @guaylayhua5653
    @guaylayhua5653 4 місяці тому +4

    👍👍👍👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏❤️

  • @sunnyyuki2483
    @sunnyyuki2483 2 місяці тому

    非常重要领导人❤

  • @XyYx-on1gl
    @XyYx-on1gl 3 місяці тому +8

    應該是「都江堰」,不是「都堰江」,不過不要緊,楊 先生對中國的了解仍然勝过許多中外人士!

  • @BruceGoo
    @BruceGoo 4 місяці тому +6

    I can feel he has strong and depth Chinese Culture recognition.

  • @hoekoktong9099
    @hoekoktong9099 4 місяці тому +6

    Bro Yeo your spree+h has a proufound eflfect on mankind , fraternity of brotherhood 👏❤️👍

  • @hongqi5734
    @hongqi5734 3 місяці тому

    I find the person who presented himself as an Indonesian sounded more like a Filipino, his accent is so similar to that of the people from Philippines.

  • @donlee6155
    @donlee6155 3 місяці тому +2

    You wanted to know, how China interact with Hong Kong and Taiwan.

  • @gabrielzhu
    @gabrielzhu 4 місяці тому +12

    讓西方跟懂東方

    • @clement3718
      @clement3718 4 місяці тому

      西方永远不会听亚洲人的话,尤其是中国人的话。白人仍然是他们在种族上优于其他种族。这是因为自工业革命以来,它们在经济和军事上迅速发展。凭借他们的军事实力,这些白人殖民了欧洲和北美以外的世界其他地区。

    • @wilson-99110
      @wilson-99110 4 місяці тому

      @@Bitheluck 你整个一杠精,西方人不在乎台湾?

    • @tingyang5619
      @tingyang5619 3 місяці тому

      西方精英懂,故意误导西方民众。希望西方民众能更懂中国吧 -- 但是这也是寄希望于西方民众和西方精英本质是不一样的,不知道可不可以这样认为。

  • @bellewan-r6o
    @bellewan-r6o Місяць тому

    不知為什麽,每次聽楊先生演講,答話,都有種東拉西扯的感觉。

    • @BoLi-rl1fu
      @BoLi-rl1fu Місяць тому

      😂因为他讲他的观点时会讲很长一段寓言故事,而解释观点的部分很短,所以在大段的演讲里,会像一个一个关系不大的寓言故事的拼凑。但在剪短的回答里,因为只有一个小主题,反而会比较容易理解。

  • @柯南-l8q9m
    @柯南-l8q9m 6 днів тому

    上海人的优越感海外都出名

  • @Tl7121
    @Tl7121 4 місяці тому +4

    This is a Taiwanese news network. From some of the comments, I can feel their pain. Indeed, truth hurts....

  • @AlexTeejua
    @AlexTeejua 4 місяці тому +14

    难得的华侨

    • @arthurljt
      @arthurljt 4 місяці тому +7

      不是华桥! 是华裔新加坡人 或新加坡华人. 华桥是指移居海外的中国公民......

  • @medialcanthus9681
    @medialcanthus9681 4 місяці тому +5

    Deadly delta from India and they still dare to jeer at China .
    Shanghai and HK are no better, jeering at their own people .
    Same for some overseas ex china people. Jeering at their ancestral land. Same for Taiwan jeering at motherland. Poor China.

  • @ckg9040
    @ckg9040 4 місяці тому +2

    他現在服務於那家公司啊?他敢說真話?

    • @btgan3838
      @btgan3838 3 місяці тому +1

      退休了啊

    • @HuikitWee
      @HuikitWee Місяць тому

      Kuok groups of company underr Robert Kuok

  • @LimCK1971
    @LimCK1971 3 місяці тому +2

    能把中国的故事讲得让人心服口服的。。。。都不是中国人。

    • @wangwang9654
      @wangwang9654 3 місяці тому +2

      其实也正常,同样的事实,当事人来说比旁观者来说,更容易让人预设观点,吹毛求疵。而第三方总是让人感觉更客观一些,何况这么高水平的第三方呢

  • @whackino
    @whackino 4 місяці тому +1

    PM material but alas…

  • @jarretkc
    @jarretkc 4 місяці тому +2

    再怎麼講,也改變不了美中關係。

    • @jimwei1965
      @jimwei1965 4 місяці тому +9

      那又如何?

    • @dewinmoonl
      @dewinmoonl 4 місяці тому +6

      That's not the point of this presentation

    • @cocoyoung7996
      @cocoyoung7996 4 місяці тому +4

      清风拂山岗 明月照大江

    • @朱俊华-o6k
      @朱俊华-o6k 4 місяці тому +3

      用中介的角色忠告欧美的智库学者,比老共的外交部、中宣部发言有用多了!

    • @于小楼
      @于小楼 3 місяці тому +3

      注定的事情,为什么要改变?重点是减少误判和互相毁灭。

  • @RPV-xe3by
    @RPV-xe3by 4 місяці тому

    食用油安全

  • @kamli6123
    @kamli6123 6 годин тому

    中共的代理人?

  • @Allgood33
    @Allgood33 4 місяці тому +1

    The epicenter of the Benedictine records were more about the church and a lot of it was magical nonsense.

  • @JiasenLiu
    @JiasenLiu 7 днів тому

    啥?新冠处理得好?第一句就听不下去了,这人大外宣吧。

  • @laurenleeahchye7064
    @laurenleeahchye7064 4 місяці тому +3

    新加坡的起步是航 空分家,台湾老蔣是李光耀的师父 台湾可自主为何新加坡不能吗?是否有讲错, 多多指教!!?

    • @lohti6399
      @lohti6399 4 місяці тому +5

      新加坡一開始不想獨立。新加坡加入後,因種族議題被馬來西亞踢出局。但由於李光耀的領導,新加坡在那之後做得非常好。

    • @中华神龙
      @中华神龙 4 місяці тому +6

      台湾可自主?台湾什么时候能自主过😂

    • @lohti6399
      @lohti6399 4 місяці тому +2

      @@中华神龙
      由於圖形位置的原因,這是不可能的。新加坡在早期因為多元種族而有理由獨立,但台灣沒有理由。如果台灣獨立,這可能看起來像是種族分裂。

  • @franzMong
    @franzMong 4 місяці тому

    Evidently the speaker can NOT give up his inclination as an offspring of Chinese Culture and Chinese heritage, despite the fact that he was an Foreign Minister of Singapore.

    • @TanSpeakersCorner
      @TanSpeakersCorner 4 місяці тому +14

      Singapore has been very frank about this kind of discussion where culture,race,religion is here to stay whether we talk about it or not. Look up one of the Lawrence Wong talk (before he is Pm, very pragmatic actually)
      Look, name me one Western country that isn’t tied to their ancestral roots despite having different nationality. South African white? Even Australia still swore loyalty to British Monarch. Muslim towards the Islam and Jew having tried to reinvent themselves in many different identity in Russia, America, Israel but at the end of the day…always come back to Jewish identity. Watch Oppenheimer the movie, you can see their dilemma.

    • @vivavivo5071
      @vivavivo5071 4 місяці тому +7

      Agreed ​@@TanSpeakersCorner

    • @superchargerone
      @superchargerone 4 місяці тому

      @franzMong
      evidently you do not know how to think within context. context is king otherwise you think eating sht is good just because dog eats them lol. this is a talk about understanding china so where is he supposed to draw history from? out of his but? what is wrong with him using his heritage to understand china? just as he use his religious believes to understand the roman catholic church and his education to understand european culture. where else would someone intelligent draw wisdom and knowledge from? lol tell us what would you have done?

    • @CattleFarmer667
      @CattleFarmer667 4 місяці тому +18

      Why should George Yeo reject his Chinese ethnicity? In Singapore and Malaysia we are encourage to be proud of our own ethnicity.

    • @tuppenceworth5485
      @tuppenceworth5485 4 місяці тому

      Many ethnic Chinese who embraced Westernisation by emigrating to the West realise the grass is not always greener on the other side and Western culture is not as superior as they thought. The rapid rise and development of China is proof of that.

  • @skysky1977
    @skysky1977 3 місяці тому

    I used to admire him a lot. He's one of our excellent foreign minster. However, after he lost the election, him like any other government officials start to play the role of the "china expert". Its easier to earn the RMB by saying the good things of China. and yes the western media like to magnify areas of human rights and democratic ideologies which the CCP is obviously lacking. But the reality is also that china is not being "misunderstood" This China now is starting to become assertive after it grew in strength over the past decades. Whether its the national security law, or its 9 dash line in South China Sea, or threathening Canada or Australia with trade tariffs when they say something that the CCP dislike. This world need to improve, not for someone to fear speaking up against someone in power, whether its Putin or Xi Jin Ping. Until they change and start to rely on international law to resolve disputes or allow criticism of their own regime, the world will never accept communist China.

    • @litesp
      @litesp 3 місяці тому +1

      To avoid exposing yourself as a liar and propagandist, please do NOT use CCP. The proper term is CPC. When you talk about human rights and international law, are you not aware that the US and its NATO allies are completely backing a genocide in Gaza by Israel that is in complete violation of INTERNATIONAL LAW. When the UNSC votes for an immediate ceasefire, the US continues to block any effort for peace. The ICJ and ICC has condemned these crimes against humanity and ordered Israel to stop murdering Palestinians through violence and starvation. Are you not aware that the US and western allies destroyed Iraq, Libya, Syria, Sudan, Yemen through illegal military force? Were you not aware that Canada kidnapped the CFO of Huawei based on lies about the company violating unilateral and illegal sanctions? It was Australia that was first hostile to China on orders of the US by joining AUKUS and planning to spend nearly 400 billion to build nuclear submarines against Chinese "aggression"? They were going to protect their trade with China from China. How many Chinese military bases surround the US to counter the 400 US bases surrounding China? If you consider trade tariffs a threat, do you know that American sanctions is an act of war? The US is sanctioning 30% of the planet. The US does NOT follow international law but rather use the Rules-based International Order which is unwritten, not approved, randomly applied, excludes America and its allies.

    • @litesp
      @litesp 3 місяці тому

      To avoid exposing yourself as a liar and propagandist, please do NOT use CCP. The proper term is CPC. When you talk about human rights and international law, are you not aware that the US and its NATO allies are completely backing a genocide in Gaza by Israel that is in complete violation of INTERNATIONAL LAW. When the UNSC votes for an immediate ceasefire, the US continues to block any effort for peace. The ICJ and ICC has condemned these crimes against humanity and ordered Israel to stop murdering Palestinians through violence and starvation. Are you not aware that the US and western allies destroyed Iraq, Libya, Syria, Sudan, Yemen through illegal military force? Were you not aware that Canada kidnapped the CFO of Huawei based on lies about the company violating unilateral and illegal sanctions? It was Australia that was first hostile to China on orders of the US by joining AUKUS and planning to spend nearly 400 billion to build nuclear submarines against Chinese "aggression"? They were going to protect their trade with China from China. How many Chinese military bases surround the US to counter the 400 US bases surrounding China? If you consider trade tariffs a threat, do you know that American sanctions is an act of war? The US is sanctioning 30% of the planet. The US does NOT follow international law but rather use the Rules-based International Order which is unwritten, not approved, randomly applied, excludes America and its allies.

    • @shenshixing1949
      @shenshixing1949 3 місяці тому +5

      you should say this to America

  • @melvinsoh99
    @melvinsoh99 3 місяці тому +1

    Well well you are very good speaker for ccp government 你抱人家的大腿要抱了,这样明显吗?

    • @litesp
      @litesp 3 місяці тому

      Only liars and propagandist say CCP. Honest critics says CPC.

  • @徐志鈞-u6e
    @徐志鈞-u6e 3 місяці тому

    廢話很多

  • @mingChen-q3h
    @mingChen-q3h 4 місяці тому

    坡县人的危机意识:害怕在中国人面前没有存在感,或存在感降低!这么粘人,今后怕是有的中国人受了!

    • @TheJayJayYoung
      @TheJayJayYoung 4 місяці тому +20

      好個此地無銀三百兩。新加坡從來都不是Yes Man,該說No時就說No,有理有據,這是新加坡的立足之道。新加坡從來不主動批評或討論任何一個國家,卻是多國的座上嘉賓,何須刷存在感。你若不同意可以拿出數據質疑他的言論,畢竟有理走遍天下,無理寸步難行。

    • @mingChen-q3h
      @mingChen-q3h 4 місяці тому

      @@TheJayJayYoung 李显龙带领坡县全民耍嘴皮子、敲键盘,蹭热点刷存在感,蹭中国刷存在感,蹭美国刷存在感……
      马凯硕:中国崛起势不可挡!
      郑永年:中国将进入全民弱z时代!
      ……

    • @mingChen-q3h
      @mingChen-q3h 4 місяці тому

      @@TheJayJayYoung 你知道坡县现在为什么很难舔到中共高官吗?因为我看不惯!坡县要技术没技术,要钱没钱,只会耍嘴皮子虚张声势、坑蒙拐骗!

    • @mingChen-q3h
      @mingChen-q3h 4 місяці тому

      @@TheJayJayYoung 我每天要举报上百篇编造虚假故事和经历的坡县文案,李显龙的视频被列入低质内容了,还每天发上万遍,都没流量了,打开主页却全是,啥玩意嘛!

    • @mingChen-q3h
      @mingChen-q3h 4 місяці тому

      @@TheJayJayYoung 人均GDP8万美元又怎么样,还不是像个三岁小孩一样,整天粘着大人!

  • @ckwong1226
    @ckwong1226 4 місяці тому

    谢谢!

  • @leesimmons9159
    @leesimmons9159 4 місяці тому +3

    👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍❤️

  • @jajuchao7225
    @jajuchao7225 4 місяці тому +2

    加油

  • @wuziouyang1470
    @wuziouyang1470 2 місяці тому

    I had a classmate in high school who was a muslin from xingjiang in 1978. The school treated him with great favor. When we had a simple dish of vegetables without protein which we as Han needed too when we grew up
    and felt hunger, he got beef every lunch. He was tall and strong. We felt extremely unfair as Han.

    • @飞出水面的鱼
      @飞出水面的鱼 2 дні тому

      在汉文化中,长子总要做出更大的牺牲,承担更多的责任。56个兄弟姐妹中,汉族是长子。

  • @kevinchan3176
    @kevinchan3176 4 місяці тому +2

    惊讶地发现他对中国的了解和中国人毫无差别。

    • @jimmyzhang0916
      @jimmyzhang0916 3 місяці тому +1

      一般中国人对中国的了解,肯定比不上他

  • @真潘-g6c
    @真潘-g6c 21 день тому

    an errand boy for the CCP

  • @myTaiwan666
    @myTaiwan666 3 місяці тому +1

    可惜了,这种是总理级别的人财。

    • @donaldjoseph3903
      @donaldjoseph3903 3 місяці тому +1

      天佑新加坡。

    • @litesp
      @litesp 3 місяці тому

      Too bad Taiwan is currently governed by puppets of the US and Japan.

  • @yanhuang4843
    @yanhuang4843 2 місяці тому

    2022
    not2002

  • @wuziouyang1470
    @wuziouyang1470 2 місяці тому

    I was against the government who imposed race inequity discriminating Han.

  • @蛆蟲糞坑
    @蛆蟲糞坑 4 місяці тому

    拆哪子孫㊗️

  • @philipsf859
    @philipsf859 2 місяці тому

    太失望了

  • @nsjl1332
    @nsjl1332 3 години тому

    👍👍👍👏👏👏

  • @ckwong1226
    @ckwong1226 4 місяці тому

    谢谢!