Film Theory: Did Mulan REALLY Save China? (Disney Mulan Trailer)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- Special thanks to Raycon for sponsoring this episode!
Get 15% off your order here! ► buyraycon.com/f...
Mulan is an AMAZING movie - the songs, the characters, the redefining of roles in society! During my previous Disney series of videos where I figured out the most deadly of Disney movies, Mulan peaked my interest for another reason. While researching the avalanche scene where the majority of the Huns were taken out, I learned a bit more about how the science of avalanches work. It posed the question, did Mulan's rocket attack REALLY defeat the Huns or did the Huns ACCIDENTALLY defeat themselves? You are about to find out!
Get yourself some Theory Wear!! ► bit.ly/2N1m7V7
Never Miss A Film Theory! ► bit.ly/1dI8VBH
#Mulan #Disney #MulanTrailer #DisneyPlus #Theory #FilmTheory #Matpat
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get Your 30 Day Free Trial Now ► share.epidemics...
MORE FILM THEORIES
What is Disney's Body Count? ► bit.ly/2Cr5Eph
No One Survives Disney! ► bit.ly/2AiXqhu
Wall-E's SECRET Villain ►► bit.ly/2B2mlJa
We Found NEVERLAND! ►► bit.ly/2HOGbqk
Rapunzel's Hair is Destroying Itself! ► bit.ly/2M0DbbZ
Credits:
Writer: Matthew Patrick
Editors: Forrest Lee and Dan "Cybert" Seibert
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman
Sources:
en.wikipedia.o...
abyss.uoregon.e...
time.com/47445...
www.base-medic...
www.ultimate-s...
www.getprepare...
science.howstu...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
www.dosomethin...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
abyss.uoregon.e...
en.wikipedia.o...
books.google.c...
en.wikipedia.o...
en.wikipedia.o...
www.nationalge... - Фільми й анімація
I feel like the only logical question after this is: “Did Mulan just sentence her own friends (and herself) to death, or would they have actually been safe where they were?”
I'm pretty sure they were standing off to the side on a slightly higher cliff. They were down to their last rocket & thought they were going to be killed when she did that. But she & a few others jumped down to engage the others so they were kind of in danger.
I mean if they took out the entire hun army but they lost their lives, that’s what they were fighting for. They were willing to risk their lives
To be fair, Shang did say “If we die, we die with honour.” And the rest of the troops were prepared to fight an unfair battle in hopes of just dying with honour, knowing they will fail regardless. Shang only said that to make it seem like their death would not be in vain. Mulan went off on the idea that everyone was prepared to die and tried to get rid of as many Huns as possible. She probably expected to be swept away with the rest of the Huns but thankfully the Imperial Army found shelter and helped her out later. It was basically a suicide Mission.
They were out numbered, could not likely to survive the cavalry charge anyway.
Oh yeah, I 100% agree that they were prepared to die, just posing the question: is it plausible that they survived?
A friendly reminder to all, form someone that has been a lot near and on snowy mountains
1. Move to the Side.
Once you see an avalanche heading your way, do not try to outrun it. Find the highground, some mountains have big rocks you can run up on to get away.
2. Grab Something Sturdy.
This does not mean run down to the forrest and lock down on a tree as the avalanche will instead of sweeping you away crush you against the tree.
3. Swim.
you will be tossed around like a ragdoll inside a avalanche, if you do find yourself inside a avalanche your main goal should be to stay close to the surface as when the avalanche finaly stops it will harden like rock and you will not be able to move so for the life of you try stay as close to the surface as you can.
4- Hold One Arm Up.
this one ties in with number 3, if you do find yourself inside an avalanche a life and death changing decision will be getting an arm above the surface as this can save you in a few ways.
you might be able to start digging up your face so you can breathe again.
you can wave your arm so any potential rescuers can see you and rescue you quickly
5. Create Room to Breathe.
do your very best to have some room in front of your face and ensure that your stomach is not compressed by the extreme pressure that comes with being inside a avalanche.
the snow will become a cocoon around you and try to press all the air our of you, as an example try breathing with someone sitting on your stomach.
6. Stay Calm.
Panic never helps. If you panic you will forget all the important things that might save you when it matters.
7. Look up how to rescue others from the cruel fate of being stuck in a avalanche.
there are plenty of tools that can increase the likelyhood of sucsessfull rescue.
8. when in snowy and mountainous areas always come prepared and never go alone
9.make sure to always know the emergency number and make sure you will allways be able to call the emergency number, even if you can save someone they might injuries that must be treated as fast a possible and since avalanches are strong there is a big risk of ripping off the clothes of the one who got caught
these are just a few reminders, if you care about you family and friends and plan to visit snowy and mountainous areas make sure you know how to deal with dangers
You might have just saved a few hundred lives, ya know that :p
Thanks, Luffy. Would have expected more of a seafaring lifestyle, but snow is just as useful!
Thanks
If I went to a snowy mountain and got caught in an avalanche and I didn’t see ur comment id be dead thank you your a life saver for real
Should be top comment
Mat: *Excitedly talking about Mushu and the music*
Me:..... Who's gonna tell him?
hush, let him be.
Tell him wha 😮
Edit: Nevermind. I think I got it
R. I. P Matthew
Worst remake yet.
Tell him about what and uh do u want me to tell him
Me don't get it
MatPat’s hopes for the live action Mulan did NOT age well
Yes
lol this comment is true gold
Yup
Well she did support the HKPF...
@@ceoatcrystalsoft4942 yeah I know, that’s one many reasons why I said his hopes didn’t age well lol
Belle: "I saved the Beasts humanity!"
Mulan: "I single handedly decimated an entire army in the span of minutes, then hunted down and killed the surviving commander."
Ryan Peacock you could also put Anna: I saved my own life and my kingdom from eternal freezing before Mulan
@@lily-zj7in we talking disney timeline.. or movie in real life... cuz mulan came out years before.
I always considered mulan as a badass character, but dude! Your prespective made her even more badass!
Belle: "well... we're not comparing here, so let's just say we've all done good in our own way, okay?"
Hobi’s sprite bottle yeah with the power of “love”
Disney: "Let's remove the songs and comedy relief character to be more accurate"
Also Disney *mixes multiple time periods centuries apart*
It has nothing to do with accuracy. Also we can't be sure is those would be actually removed. After all contrary to what people think we actually do see Mushu in trailer...
@@TheRezro They said the film wouldn't be a musical, there'll still be music (because most every movie has music), but characters won't be breaking out into song like before. And Mushu's exclusion is intentional, and it looks like he's being replaced with a phoenix, seemingly because the Chinese, who are apparently the primary target audience for the film, hated the character in the '98 film and the tone of this remake seems to be quite a bit darker, trying to be more accurate to the story the film is based off of, and the comedic character of Mushu doesn't fit that tone.
@@TheFancyUmbreon yet all the top-ranking movies in china have a dragon in them... alter the character....
@@Souls4Roca I think the problem was about tone clash and not that Mushu was a dragon.
But what about tangled frozen and the princess and the frog???
"The human voice can't cause an avalanche."
8 year olds on xbox voice chat: "Allow us to introduce ourselves."
SO true
Pretty much every parent: "Let me introduce me to my children". :)
At least during quarantine that is.
Yep
What about sir pelo ? He scream is loud after all
If this new Mulan doesn't have "I'll Make a Man out of You" then they should stop production right now.
Sad thing is,
They didn't, and they also didn't include Reflection (only the orchestra version of it) smhhh
zzB4CKUP4CC0UNTzz The orchestral versions were enough for me. It would’ve been weird for them to sing a musical number. They did have a few lyrics and quotes in the movie but I’m not gonna spoil it for op ☺️
You can't really think of this as a remake since the only thing that is the same is the premise that's It nothing else is the same
@@Vixen1409 Yeah after seeing the trailer I agree.
@@zmadisonz AND THEY DIDNT HAVE MUSHU OR GENERAL SHANG
Hey matpat, on Netflix there's this film called "the platform" and basically it's about a prison that has 333 floors and a buffet of food is placed at room 1 and gradually goes down to the last floor. And I was wondering I'd you could calculate if there enough food to feed everyone at the facility.
I've seen it and there is no way the little girl would be alive
Great theory idea il give the show a watch
Mateusz Ponikowski yes
@@luisbaldomar9969 ever consider she was on one of the 50 upper floors shown during the timelapse with the protagonist
11:12 Did MatPat seriously compare the hypotenuse length to the height of the mountain??
He should've compared the vertical range (Max vertical distance of rocket from ground) to the height of mountain.
*Mulan can't save the whole Chinese dynasty*
*you know the saying* :
*"CHINA IS WHOLE AGAIN......."*
*"THEN IT BROKE AGAIN"*
"The empire long united must divide, long divided must unite; this is how it has always been."
It's from the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. :-)
Classic xD
I can hear this
-When you can hear this-
History of the world
I ultimately request that mat pat read the book “Charlie Thorne and The Last Equation” and find out what the equation really was. (If you haven’t read it, it ends by Charlie learning the equation that could destroy the world but it never says what it is)
Yes, bro I still want to know what Pandora is!
E=mc2?
@@bastion8804 Do you even physics bro?
Oh god his third theory channel is gonna be book theory and fnaf is still going to invade it
What's 9 + 10
mattpat: "I have the hopes highest for live action mulan"
oh mattpat... you were soo disappointed
Matpat : tired of baby shark
**Every parent/uncle/babysitter in the world liked that**
Leon The Fox and older teen siblings
And anyone who has to deal with children who don’t know how to turn the volume down on their mother’s phone.
Thats offensive to aunts for not being included.
I'm a young uncle (14 years old) and I can confirm that baby shark is babies favourite.
@@AeridisArt
Or even worse, the ones who know how to turn it up
I would love for a movie to have people hiking a snowy mountain and one of them yells or screams so the group hushes them. The screamer snaps back that they won't cause an avalanche, that's a myth, blah blah, and the group is like that's not what we're worried about! Then yetis attack
Sounds like one of those bad sci fi shows lol
Yup sounds like a z grade horror flick that could be filmed in any snowy spot
Sounds like Scooby Doo plot
That...sounds lame
Person being mauled by Yeti: THIS IS EVEN LESS REALISTIC! AH MY LEGS!
matt: Can small explosives set off an avalanche?
Me: well yeah, 'cause if they can't why is ski patrol setting off bombs at the top of the mountain?
Ski patrol: secretly murdering people under the guise of preventing death by avalanche
They're actually firing sedatives into the kaiju people mistook for a mountain, to keep it from waking up and rampaging again.
What if the ski patrol were a bunch of Bakugos
You should avoid skiing for a whipe cuz you know too much.
But HEY ! THAT'S JUST A THEORY.
...MY STEPDAD IS DOING *WHAT* IN THE MOUNTAINS!!
XD
9:13 not a bad attempt, the “Huo” and “Long” were very close, but the other two are pronounced something like “Choo” and “Shu-ei”
P.S. “Huo” “Long” “Chu” “Shui” are four characters.
火龙出水嘛没毛病
yeah i made a similar comment but i just typed the chinese characters out lol
I just wanna say the Hán Việt (Chinese-word but Vietnamese? I dont know how to explain it :/) version of it is Hỏa Long Ngự Thủy ( if i translate that right)
Hỏa: Fire
Long: Dragon
Ngự: at ( something like that)
Thủy: good ol' water
Just a little fact i think you will enjoy
P.s: I'm not a pro at these kind of thing so correct me if im wrong.
“Huo” would mainly be referred to fire, “long” would mean dragon, “chu” would mean this: 出 and “shui” means water.
Also, he translated it wrong. “Huo-Long-Chu-Shui” translates to “Fire Dragon Coming Out Of Water”.
*Who’s gonna tell him it ain’t gonna be a musical*
Ella Bishop more importantly who’s gonna tell him about Mushu
Just as importantly, who's gonna tell him they removed Li Shang
@@BoldlyGoing And what about Hawky? She appears to be a lady now...
and no mushu
What a dumb move by Disney of cutting out the only reason that we all boomers were gonna see the remake
There is an inside joke in my family. After a story is told, someone says,”And that is how Mulan saves China.” Don’t know where it came from but i love it
Spooky Filmz Ent.
“Comfuyent?”
I love this.
Milan? As in Italy?
It was autocorrect, Robert and I didn’t notice it
Omgsh I have something similar. Every time someone would do something out or weird. I'dsay dishonor.
The important question here that we're all missing: would Mulan and company have been able to survive that avalanche themselves?
IDK how that was edited. The villan was right in front of her, then avalanche, then friendly company is safe, but villian is buried. That doesn't make logical sense to me
Most likely not
@@xilomaladeadzoul5315 in the film, the army was hiding behind a convenient rock
@@Stettafire Wow it's almost like it's an animated film for kids that shouldnt be analyzed at a deeper level than that :D
Also the rocket travels in an arc and not a straight path
This is more entertaining than the live-action Mulan tbh.
Hehe ohhhhhh my friend.......that is a sick burn!
Everything is more entertaining than live action Mulan
The LA!Mulan was horrible smh
I think disney seriously did a good job though with Aladdin's remake. But I will not forgive the 2019 version of lion king! NEVER!
@@leonardosomma4196 LITERALLY!
my science teacher caught me watching film theory...instead of me getting in trouble she was proud of me for learning...and she became a fan
xXgradediggerXx Gacha your teacher is a legend
R/thathappened
A once in a life time chance
@@jayku1624 r/foundthemobileuser
Serinity59 r/don’texposeMe
Sgt: Hey private! Call in the Calvary!
Pvt: Sir? The Calvary? Sir?
Sgt: Did I stutter private?! Call in the Calvary! We're crucifying these mother lovers!
Pvt: But sir, there was no calvary, the name is cavalry sir. Sir, i am concern with your english
Sgt: I don’t mean Cavalry, I mean Calvary! The hill where Jesus Christ was crucified!
Was literally thinking the same thing
@@theamazingquetzal3933
Pvt: oh, did not think about that sir, i am sorry, i will call the calvary now
@@theamazingquetzal3933 top 10 Uno reverse card moments
Mat: "Mulan doesn't need to rely on unrealistic cgi to make something look more real than the 2d character they drew."
Disney: *makes the personalities of their characters less realistic than the 2d character they drew*
don´t forget the weird cgi where mulan can use magic... somehow
What is sgi?
@@QUBIQUBEDcgi*
@QUBIQUBED computer-generated... Something.
Mulan without Mushu is like a grilled cheese sandwich without the cheese. D=
I love myself some grilled
It sucks that we dont get mushu, but without the signature training song I cant imagine this movie is gonna be worth paying to see. It's so sad, it's like one of my favorite disney songs. 😭
So she is grilled sandwich
So bread?
@@arandomperson7949 grilled bread
When I was a kid, I discovered the Slab Avalanche on a small scale in my back yard. I was playing around, causing little snowfalls with a stick, trying to figure out why some places would work and others wouldn't when my dad came over and told me that what I was doing was the same thing as real life avalanches. It blew my mind. Both because I was doing something that happens on such a devastating scale, but it was also the first time I realized Small Scale Testing was a thing. It was kinda nuts for a kid to grasp that these HUGE forces of nature could be recreated in such a small, controlled environment.
That's actually really neat ^_^ fun stuff to occur to a kid
Very cool
imagine this being your type of childhood experiments. the closest thing to this that i ever did as a kid was pour ice cold water into a hot glass jar that had been left in an outdoor fire to watch (and hear) it explode. it sounded like a gunshot and the neighbors came over to check on us
BIG brain
@@minna3286 My accidental experiment was... well, i wanted to have some cold drink, but didn't have an ice. So i just filled thin glass pot with hot drink, and tried to lower it into the tub with cold water.
I wasn't even able to submerge it completely, 0.5 sec was enough for submerged portion of pot to just ... break away, without even a sound. It was just "plop" and done, now i only hold only top half of the pot.
Eddie Murphy doesn't play any characters, he just plays himself in different stories
true.
In the biz, they call this NAR: no acting required. Same with Luna Lovegood.
Ryan Reynolds too.
@Kristopher Prime Jim Carrey can act extremely well given the chance. I mean Bruce from Bruce Almighty is very different from Ace Ventura.
What about Jim Parsons when he plays Sheldon Cooper in The Big Bang Theory and Oh in the movie Home?
Guys... when talking about how Mulan is the “forgotten child of Disney’s 90s lineup”
He
Forgot
Hercules...
I believe that's the joke.
HERCULES?
Not Heracles!
I never saw that movie😆
@@TheLegendzMinecraft You should its actually really good!!!
13:27 I thought when he said “I’m constantly losing small Important objects” I was like, “don’t lose ur son” but the he mentioned it was because his child kept throwing them around. PHEW
Like the last bit of sanity left in him XD
Fun fact: Both of Mulan's parents are still alive by the end of the movie.
Maybe that is why Disney doesn't like the movie as much as the others. 😅
And Hercules
Fun fact, the actual Chinese story involves her mother committing suicide.
O-oh..
@@fishecllub3652 well then its a good thing her parents where still alive by the end of the movie.....
Matpat:"Is Mulan the first shrek movie?....
no its not"
me:cuz shrek is the second Mulan movie
I agree
LMAO
*shivers* Mulan 2...
@@Moonstar79 Welp my theory ruined'
Mulan 2: The one with All Star
"your voice isn't powerful enough to make a avalanche"
people from anime's:
"are you sure about that?"
this should be top comment
@@oreofrisk true
@@oreofrisk Good think Dragon Ball doesn't exist in Mulan!!!!
You know you've aged when even Matpat changes his own sprites.
aw, but I liked his old sprite!
@@Anonomius0 Me too lol
The one on the podium?
@@justjoking5252 Yeah. That one.
Ok
"and apologizing for butchering the pronounciation huolongchushui"
me cringing while sitting next to my totally Chinese parents
羲羲g̶r̶e̶e̶c̶i̶e̶s̶s̶ Me, not Chinese, cringing that he mixed up cavalry and Calvary
It's always better to encourage others who are making an attempt at a foreign language. Atleast he pronounced the first half pretty good. Yay Matpat! lol
and here I'm trying to figure out what Beijing has to do with it and not Luoyang, considering the time period?
Me: *Cringes at pronunciation in half chinese*
同感，这火龙出水说成：货long吹岁
Mulan: *Saves china*
Matpat: Imma do what is called a pro gamer move
Edit: Matpat really looks like a high school teacher right now
Matpat then: college student
Matoat now: you became what you swore to destroy
@@kitsuneakage22 *Matoat*
Who wouldn't want matpat as their school teacher
The real loss of the life-action Mulan movie:
The cricket.
yes
They changed it into a spider... A really jumping spider, who can make really big CGI jumps. You know what at this point the cricket would make more sense 🤷♀️
2:59 MatPat you should’ve said: “Let’s get down to down with physics, and we’ll make bad puns,” see I can do it too
Omfg. Why am I laughing at this
?
Ooh ooh lemme try...
Add up all these theories
And we’ll find
A sum
I’m going to sing this whenever I start physics
I'd understand if I wasn't fucking dumb
Matpat: *Proving Mulan was possible*
Everyone: *liked that.*
Spooky Filmz Ent. Why?
*Edit* never mind
Spooky Filmz Ent. Uh.. why??
@@luvzlayy he is just some weirdo mining for views
Guys just report him
Did Mulan save China?
MatPat: Well yes but actually No... not really.
11:12 Did MatPat seriously compare the hypotenuse length to the height of the mountain??
He should've compared the vertical range (Max vertical distance of rocket from ground) to the height of mountain.
Saransh Gautam I’m sorry I don’t understand what u just said at all
noah thewright me neither some ppl ain't blessed with brains brother 😂✋️
Saransh Gautam, that gets a bit more complicated-however Matt’s math is still plausible. Sense the arc of the mountain doesn’t interfere with the impending rocket, the height and ground distance remains the same-in fact-it could make it easier. Instead of trying to get a option over a 90 degree slope, hitting the target is like throwing a ball at a slope instead.
@@noahthewright7942 The vertical range of rocket means the maximum height covered by the rocket above the ground "while it moves in its parabolic path". So ue should've compared that with the mountain's height instead of the hypotenuse of a right angled triangle made by the rocket when it is at it's peak.
The hundreds of soldiers riding down the mountain on horseback while the falcon soars overhead and the music plays in the backround is such a good scene, it deserves the respect.
I died when Mat trying to pronounce "Huo Long Chu Shui" lol
I appreciate the effort thou.
The original Chinese name songs great but why does the translated version sound so lame?
He should have probably kept the og og translation which I think should be: water coming out of a dragon. I don't know, but when I grew up listening to all sorts of translation by Americans of Chinese (and English by Chinese), I kinda just prefer the most direct translation, and not tryna fancy the translation up using words like "issuing" etc.
AmazingSalad you Chinese too?
Beatrice Palmer he mispronounced Huo and Sui cuz both are the 3rd tone not 2nd
I have had experience that non-chinese speakers...really cannot speak in the four tones of a Chinese phrase. It's fun to hear though.
If I’ll Make a Man out of you isn’t played at my funeral I’m not going
*Isquidy walks out of the coffin*
@@jakethegamer4977 hahaha hahaha hahaha hahaha
*Hol up*
😂
ya same
Voice is two magnitudes lower than needed to cause an avalanche. So what WILL cause an avalanche?
Me, an intelectual: **three people screaming**
Hahahahahahahahahahahhahahahaha
A plot-twist: one wouldn't need the whole herd galloping, the army was already shouting all together.
I like how he mentions the best parts of the movie from the original Mulan are the stuff that the live-action one is leaving out. He's like "I'm so excited for the new Mulan because I like Mushu and The Make A Man Out Of You Song!"
Are you excited for your second Disney remake on a row to have NO SOUL OR EMOTIONAL WEIGHT?
Evan Ghanason they said they’re cutting some of those things to make the movie more “realistic”, but they’ve turned the Hanz falcon into a fucking witch
*THEY WONT HAVE THE SONG EITHER?!?*
The ONE live action version I'm looking forward to and they're taking out so much!! 😭
@@rainynight02 maybe we can petition fir it to be added! It should. I mean sonic looks great now, a song is (I'm pretty sure ) easier then remaking an entire cgi character
@@ambermargheim5726
It just depends. They'd have to learn the song as well as all of the coriography for each scene, which can take months for everyone to learn properly.
Since it's supposed to release soon, it won't happen.
MatPat: “will there be Szechuan sauce?”
Me: Not only will there not be Szechuan sauce, but there will also not be chicken nuggets or a movie
NUUUUUUU
I like it that way
nOOOoooOoOoooUUuUU nOT THe saUCe I neED it iN mY blOODSTreaM
My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined
NOOOO9OO
Matthew is just the kid that went overboard on all of the school projects
He's definitely that guy that puts quotes either at the start or the end of his essays
THE DR34M that’ll be me too also business analytics let’s gooo
He said in a conversation with that he was and that’s still what he does
Hah hah *SWEATS PROFUSELY*
Totally not me (‘AwA’’)
@@vidiav4614 same (nervous laugh)haha
everyone: uses metric system based on universal constants such as the speed of light and the mass of hydrogen
america: bout half a football field
@@tylerfabend7883 yeah dude nothing real world about universal constants or anything
@@tylerfabend7883 aha yeah but my point is americans unlike idk everyone else have been trained by society to conceptualise things within the constraints of these units while for example here in australia we judge things the same way but with more useful and convenient units, this isnt a slap in the face for yall either no doubt if i was american id probably have pride in a unique unit of measurement too.
Mat Pat: Will there be ScHEzWaN sAuCe?!?!
McDonald’s: A sh*t. Here we go again...
Rick and Morty fans unite!
Bring it back for good
I Like sous
Wouldn't sales go up a lot and wouldn't poorer people who get it able to make themselves lots of money
@@mangaartistshamz8816 The joke is that the sauce fans are insane.
Mulan is so underrated like idk why everyone is sleeping on it
Bruh the underrated/forgotten Disney renaissance movie is Hercules
TheRealWhiteFalcon THANK YOU
Too bad the new one is gonna be trash
nooo milan is definitely my favorite disney
@@mdaily318 Really? The new one isn't trash, it's going to be based off the legend of Mulan. There's a few differences, for example the fact that she doesn't pretend to be a man, she just impresses everyone into joining. It's honestly much more progressive than the Disney one, but a little more boring.
I’d be more inclined to think Mushu was a descendant of Donkey and Dragon
See, now this is the kind of theorizing that scares me. Matpat has already done some serious cross-overs, I don't need the Eddie Murphey multiverse here. There is too much mid 90's energy there
This is golden
Yes, but what suggests Mulan was set after Shrek?
Stettafire fairytale creatures are everywhere in Shrek, but Mushu’s the only one in Mulan, which could suggest the fairytale population being whittled down for some reason
Cavalry: mounted soldiers
Calvary: the hill where Jesus was crucified
ProductBasement came here to point that out lol
I only came to the comments for this.
Here's a Film Theory theory: MatPat deliberately mispronounced "cavalry" to make people like me come down and write a comment. It helps with UA-cam algorithms and gets the channel more "UA-cam points". But, hey... That's just a theory! A Film Theory theory!
@@christopherhornback4000 (O_O)
@@christopherhornback4000 Holy quack we're playing to his tune 🤪
@@ElectricMusicianDude Right?! He's got us, and he (smugly, and adorably) knows it!
The problem with this movie to me is this.
If Mulan would've just stayed home, her father would have gone. But he wouldn't have died. If he was so bad at fighting, he would have just been sent home, like Mulan was in "I'll make a man out of you." Sure, she didn't find herself and blah blah blah, but she did still have her father.
Plus the recruitment edict said "every ABLE BODIED male first born of each household". No one given how advanced Chinese medicine was even back then in Feudal Imperial China is going to accept Fa Zhou as able bodied, he'd fail the first physical test or the guy doing the actual recruitment (being fairly older himself) would probably say "sorry Fa Zhou you are clearly not fit enough and have no sons.".
It wasn't about logic. It was a case of honor.
@@kacperszatko8192 does/did the standing army of China have an Honorable discharge policy?
That, or taking into account that her father was already a war hero, he would have been given a command that was p cushy, maybe training new recruits.
Chloe Chlarson i would think as an already trained soldier, seeing that he had armor and a sword and knew how to use it as he was moving through the forms before his leg gave him trouble, he would have ridden out with Shang’s father as fully trained soldier.
*Talking dragon exists*
"ok but how realistic is this rocket?"
Mat: I bet Mulan will be the best because of accuracy and songs
Me: Uhm..
6:16
When he said that I immediately thought
“Then the mongols came over ready for war, and died in a tornado”
Bill Wurtz eh? Nice
Then they had a good time fighting the Japanese and died in a tornado
Matpat: "Calvary charge"
me: well it's a common mispronunciation of "Cavalry," I won't be *too* angry
Graphics: "Calvary"
(ノಠ益ಠ)ノ彡┻━┻
Put that table back!
@@markcrawford5810 He's right thou
[>
Fun fact: Calvary is the name of the hill Jesus was crucified on
(┛❍ᴥ❍)┛彡┻━┻
I feel betrayed for him changing the pictures of himself
Bici Animations 🤣🤣🤣 me too, I can't get used to it
"I'm excited for the mulan remake."
*oh are you in for a treat*
I came in with curiosity.
I left with a degree in Chinese history.
Hahaha you expected Dio, but it's me, a commenter recognizing you again
Praise Lord Nuxanor!!
I’m just gonna go ahead and sub to you and Some Guy With a Mustache, at this point it’s getting ridiculous
Did you learn Chinese, though
This is only 5%
disney: we have two options. new movies, or more live action adaptations.
nahhhh who are we kidding obviously live action adaptations
Say every company in existence... and America also exist 0_0
You forget reboots and unnecessary sequels, so much for original idea's.
Isnt onward a disney original IP?? And Moanna, Coco too.
666slateran666 A. It’s a joke. B. Pixar is technically owned by Disney, but onward and coco are both Pixar movies.
Disney: Nah Mulan isn't that great
Also Disney: Mulan is a Disney princess despite not being royalty or marrying royalty.
She married shang, the nephew of the emperor
@@Dokataa Don't really thinking that counts, but still, I never knew this
What source says he's related to the emperor? I don't remember coming across it.
@@pardn when the movie takes place, most generals were the brothers of the emperor
Excuse me, she did what she did because she loves her father; it's called sacrifice.
The live Mulan was probably my least favorite live remake because it was more like a movie inspired by Mulan and wasnt really Mulan
If the grandma doesn't stop traffic in this movie, Im suing.
I don’t think they have her grandma in the live action movie.
@@JohnDoe-hr4cf YOU CAN'T JUST GET RID OF THE GRANDMA!
@@connernewt7678 They got rid of Mushu, Cricket, and Li Shang. Anyone is up for the cutting room floor now.
@@JohnDoe-hr4cf :( Aww man.
@@zusfrankenstein8561 NOOO! But boy am i glad i'm not gonna wast time or money to see it.
The Huns did exist during the Mulan movie!
Edit: To help out here, the Huns are not restricted only to the Huns that invaded Rome. A good example being the Xiongnu who were located around modern-day Mongolia, right over the borders of China. The Xiongnu fought a war against China called the Han-Xiongnu war from 113BC to 91AD.
Ironically enough, the title used by the leaders of the Xiongnu was "Chanyu" which sounds weirdly similar to Shan Yu, the leader of the invading force in Mulan.
If the Mulan movie really took place during the Tang dynasty thXiongnu wouldve been long defeated by the han
@@snowlynx1585 Disney said that Attila the Hun and Genghis Khan were big inspirations for Shan Yu.
@@snowlynx1585 Actually the timeline part of the movie is really confusing. There are different aspects of the movie following different timelines.
I wish there was a secondary channel of Matpat's Movie Reviews. Just to see what he and his team can make something that resonates just like their theories.
"Cavalry" are horse-mounted soldiers. "Calvary" is where Christ was crucified.
Thank you Clint, Very cool
Dude I can’t express how irritating it is when he mixes them up 😂
@@kingchris-xt9lf What does Clint's comment have to do with "boomers?" Are you just saying that because "Christ" was in his comment? You might prefer that he say "Jesus" instead of "Christ," but his point stands: "Calvary" (MatPat's spelling) is a proper noun, and "Cavalry" is what he meant. Clint is simply pointing out the misspelling.
Yeah when I heard him say "Calvary" while showing a picture of a horse with a rider, my ears just itched like bad :P
The spelling is cavalry not calvary
Teacher: Do you even study Science?
Me: I do.
Teacher: How do you study?
Me: I watch Film Theorists, lol.
LOL I use it to study Maths
K
@beint I just thought about it and I don't even know lol ignore me😂😂😂
When u learned more form matpat than school-
Brain time
When you're so early there arent jokes yet
True tho
True dat
For real
Ikr
11:12 Did MatPat seriously compare the hypotenuse length to the height of the mountain??
He should've compared the vertical range (Max vertical distance of rocket from ground) to the height of mountain.
Hearing someone being excited about the new mulan movie hurts my heart a little bit...considering how bad the new movie is.
"Screaming causing avalanches is a myth."
Dragonborn: Challenge accepted.
TheSefirosu200x from d&d or from something else sorry if I’m an idiot and should know what you mean
@@Polar2710 skyrim.
Oh well I’m a huge idiot thanks
FUS ROH DA
Fuus roh AAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!! *running for life*
2:32
"Unless your of course, wait for it"
"The Mongels"
*cue the clip from Crash Course History*
Yes yes yes yes yes, my thoughts exactly
"We are the exception!"
LGBT stands for
Lets
Get down to
Business
To defeat the Huns
WHY DID I GET DAUGHTERS
😂
@@haruhifujioka5952 When I asked for sons
Matpat: I can't wait for the live action Mulan
Me: look at him, so blissfully ignorant
You forgot one important question:
"Would a small red dragon be able to light a Chinese rocket?"
It *IS* a dragon so probably yes.
Welcome to the red dragon, where everybody is a winner.
Mushu vs. Flint FIGHT!!!!
I mean, even at 7d6 damage, that should be enough to light a fuse.
Well some Chinese dragons CAN breathe fire. And MUSHU is apparently one of the varieties that CAN. Fire+Rope=burning rope which equals cannon fire. So yes. A cannon can be lit by a small Chinese dragon.
7:08 It's cavalry... It really bothers me when people get that one wrong for some reason.
"Calvary"
The fact that the editors, script writers, and Matpat himself messed that up is really sad.
Well now that you've pointed it out it annoys me to so thank you for that well I don't have emotions so I'm good.
Well now that you've pointed it out it annoys me to so thank you for that well I don't have emotions so I'm good.
Spooky Filmz Ent. No, I don’t think I will
I think the term is "cavalry" and not "Calvary".
Yeah I was confused with that
Darth Revan they’re different words with different meanings
Cavalry = mounted troops
Calvary = one name for the hill on which Jesus was crucified
Cavalry is a collective term for mounted soldiers.
Calvary is the name of an infamous hill just outside Jerusalem where a lot of Roman public executions were held, including the crucifixion of Jesus of Nazareth. Also known by the epithet Golgotha “The place of the skull.”
@@darthrevan4933 Of course, anyone you are asking who says "calvary" is correct is completely wrong.
"we want to make mulan realistic so we are removing all songs and dragon"
.... they added a whaman that transforms into a bird ._.
I'm sorry but what? O.o
EXACTLY!
The bird lady was actually from the original myth, as was the villain they are using. The director of the remake wanted to incorporate more from the story it's based on.
I thought it was more to be true to the original story rather than realism
sounds more realistic to me. Western style music in Medieval China? totally not realistic.
It’s sad how epically Disney failed at the live remake of one of greatest films ever.
MatPat: "Your voice alone cannot create an avalanche."
Me: What about a dorm of twenty teenage guys?
No
@Feenix Fyre Art its no
Why do not you test it out😁
@Feenix Fyre Art it's still a no
Feenix Fyre Art you’ll have to excuse that guy, he lacks the capacity to understand humor, poor fellow
He’s done it, he’s found an actual use for the pythagorean theorem
Cough cough Civil Engineering, Astrophysics, Geography, weaponry... It's pretty useful if you aren't able to measure an angle but need to find the direct distance between you and something...
I know that this is a joke but I do want to stress the importance of the Pythagorean theorem. Although not obvious, it is extremely useful!
Autumn Mix science maths and commerce( in the current age) are the most key subjects in human existence. U could not have typed if the resources were not provided to the genius minds who made the device u currently hold( who often than not use that theorem u joke about). Then sold to u by an outlet built by the again genius minds and then sold to you to earn profit and let the spectrum continue forward. Seriously ppl need to start respecting.
Wasn't it...trigonometry?
You must be really young to think the Pythagorean theorem is not useful
Mulan
Sings a song about wishing to see her reflection
Is staring at a mirror
The real question:
How was Mulan not found out as a girl sooner？
Yeah..she looks more like a girl with her bone structure so it's really odd how they didn't find out.
Lookup women who historically tricked people into thinking they were men... It happened a loooottt.
@@Pomshka ok
I'm thinkin' the real Mulan from 4th-5th century China was flat chested. A-cup breasts make a woman look just a little more like a man, like a feminine male, and are a lot more common in starving regions of the world. That time period in China must have been hard times when it came to food, too.
@@amyliaclenny1866 That, and who was the Chinese army to question, when they needed as many soldiers as possible?
Now to see what the “Huns” really were in the movie.
Edit: The mongol theory is correct the Mongols existed in the 13th-14th centuries which is the guessed time of the movie.
Hun just means an unprovoked group of people whom are destructive.
The Mongol theory is one of the only real things the Huns could be, with the other being nomadic tribes from Manchuria
13th-14th century? Meaning the original movie or the upcoming one? For former, that's simply not true. Mulan takes place in ancient China, somewhere between 300-600 AD.
@@Vitalis94 It's possible that the Huns could be Mongols, just not the Mongols of Chinggis Kahn.
The Mongols are always the exception so anything is possible
Me: *reads the title*
“What next “DID tiAnA rEaLLY TUrN InTo a FrOG?”
nah, she just got really stoned.
@@DBZVelena * insert alice in wonderland theory *
Mat pat can do that theory he even did
A theory on cars the
Title is (is cars really cars) and turns out they are not cars
ADRIEN
I'd watch that
0:26 Nugget: PRAISE DA SAUCE! NUGGET IS NOT WORTHY OH THE SAUCE'S GREATNESS!
Btw the pronunciation is: who-oh long chew shway
The characters are 火龙出水 :)
Its a bit hard to use english alphabet to get a American to properly say it right.
At times I'd say that they need to alter a few letters:
Huo Long Tsu-ew Shuei
@@rerako4755 well I know Chinese, english and malay but now I'm working on german and French. I'm 10.
Abigail Molenda they’re 10, give them a break..
@@weihong3697 wierd flex but ok
Chan Wei Hong that’s impressive
No one:
Not a soul:
No one at all:
Oliver: ***Yeets things around the room while listening to baby shark***
Ok
Ok.
Ok
Either Jesus was crucified on that mountain, or the entire team missed that it's supposed to be "cavalry" and not "Calvary" lol
that bugged me so much!
@@ph4d3rfysh94 Pretty sure they did that on porpoise >=D
Fancy seeing you here, Scott.
#Struggler4Life
Hmm, I think it's actually ice cream.
Maybe it's maybelline.
Fun fact: I’ve never eaten at McDonald’s
Fun fact: You are cool.
Me, humming ‘Make A Man Out Of You’
MatPat: “No one doesn’t sings along when ‘Ill Make A Man Out Of You’”
Me: “OH SH-“
*sees profile photo*
*VIETNAM FLASHBACKS*
Your grammar sucks
I mean, if they were Mongols then we wouldn't have had that sick burn in the song.
*DID THEY SEND ME DAUGHTERS*
*WHEN I ASKED FOR SONS?*
"You missed! He was three feet in front of you and you missed!"
It's actually "You missed! How could you miss he was three feet in front of you!!"
Over The Bend, Entirely Bonkers Duly noted
Over The Bend, Entirely Bonkers Duly noted
You actually didn't get it too wrong. In Mandarin Chinese, there are different intonations you have to use, otherwise, the word is a completely different word, and it's really hard to get unless you're 1st language is Mandarin or another Chinese language.
This might be an awesome theory:
How much did the entire trip to Egypt cost in Jojo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders & Battle for Egypt?
This. I want this.
But obviously not accounting for psychological damage tho
Everything
It cost one avdol, a dog, and a milfhunter.
Keninja Greninja Matpat, we NEED this!
I have a theory request for matpat: can you find the hidden a113 in monsters inc. because ALL Pixar movies are supposed to have them and nobody has a 100% confirmation, only speculation.
That would make a pretty bad video, just point to it and say 'there'. While it would be nice to know, I don't think team theorist is who you should be asking.
isnt that the theory of the super carlin brothers?
Video audience: so avalanches are dangerous, big woop
Me: whats the catch?
You forgot one crucial detail: Snow could not have piled up on that mountain in the first place because the mountain is way too steep, so no avalanche.
nobody:
Rick and Morty fans: bRinG bAcK tHe sAucE
Marianna Rodriguez The sauce is low key trash
@@jess37911 so are Rick and Morty fans.
Marianna Rodriguez sauce is the boss
Except the vid he used was a guy who hated Rick and Morty and the fans.
He used to post a lot on 4chan talking about how he did it to make them look bad.
Nobody:
Rick and Morty fans: I watch Rick and Morty!
No one:
Matthew: since its quarantine imma calculate how mulan caused an avalanche
This is pretty normal for him
He'd do it regardless
it's actually mat daddy
Honestly lately his theories just get old after awhile I used to be a fan but he constantly has to put logic in cartoons, it gets exhausting after a while
queen kamisrel thats the point and its pretty interesting
12:55 - "Casual Mulan is best Mulan."
Meanwhile, I'm over here gawking at Anna's legs.
So much merchandise created for Disney Princess Dolls. New doll outfits, new Children's clothing to sell in Disney stores! All in such a short few minutes of screen time.
Well great, now I’m looking 😂😂😂
Why does Anna look like she's potentially thicccc
69th like ❤️
I'm part of a ski team, and I learned a bit about avalanches during one of the ski team weekends, but I had no idea that avalanches could be that deadly. That's honestly really cool. (And should teach me to not go on really dangerous runs haha)