Why Nepal needs to CANCEL Federalism
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 лип 2024
- Nepal adopted Federalism after several long discussion, fight and protests. "Gaun Gaun ma Singha Durbar" was what the politician promised. But even after the completion of first term, Federalism isn't delivering results as it should. People have been calling out Federalism as too expensive, just a way to feed politician and many more. So, does Nepal really need Federalism, or will it even work?
Source: docs.google.com/document/d/1E...
Worldlink Beacon Router: bit.ly/TNCNokiabeacon
Let's connect :
If you are on Facebook: [ / dipesh.tripathi.35 .]
If you are on Twitter: [ / nepalicomment ]
If you are on Instagram: [ / dipesh.trip ]
Research by:
Bishwa Rai ( / bishwa546 )
Edited by:
Arpit Thapa Magar ( / arpit_akkun )
Thumbnail by: Biphson Nepali ( / biphson_nepali )
Timestamp:
0:00 Intro
1:51 Sponsored Segment
3:28 History Before federalism
5:00 Calls for federalism
7:15 Federalization process
9:10 Earthquake and unity
10:30 Nepal passes the constitution
11:22 Problems with federalism in Nepal
15:53 Conclusion & the way forward
Worldlink Beacon Router: bit.ly/TNCNokiabeacon
🤔🤔😚❤️
❤
what will happen in nepal in 30 years all the people are going in other country who will leave in country
Faft Vaneko k ho
FAFT ko full video pani chaiyo
Nepali comment never fails to push out informative videos and enlighten us. These are the topics that needs to be talked abt
Euta arko vaai ko ni cha Thaha vanni
@@user-ji1hn7zf4c THANKS FOR THE INFORMATION !!
Why do you believe so much in content creator and youtuber. 😅
@@sikasbkoju3715 coz they talk with correct facts!
Dipesh, thanks for this video. Federalism itself is not a bad system but if it is not implemented properly, it can destroy all the things. Federalism has positive benefits as well as negative benefits.
One of the primary concerns regarding federalism in Nepal is the significant increase in administrative costs. The creation of provinces, each with its bureaucracy and administrative apparatus, has led to a multiplication of government offices and personnel. This exponential rise in administrative costs diverts precious resources from development projects, social welfare, and infrastructure, jeopardizing the nation's economic stability.
nepal is smaller than indian states like uttar pradesh ,maharahstha and you are still rooting for federalism . federalism is not good for smaller country like nepal
100% true
India, with its vast and diverse population, operates with 28 states and 8 union territories, while Nepal, with a significantly smaller population, has opted for seven provinces. However, the number of government officers and MLAs in Nepal per capita surpasses that of India, showcasing the disproportionate economic burden imposed by federalism on the smaller nation.
One of the primary concerns regarding federalism in Nepal is the significant increase in administrative costs. The creation of provinces, each with its bureaucracy and administrative apparatus, has led to a multiplication of government offices and personnel. This exponential rise in administrative costs diverts precious resources from development projects, social welfare, and infrastructure, jeopardizing the nation's economic stability.
Faft vaneko k ho
जनयुद्ध होइन धन युद्ध हो, जय गोरख🙏🇳🇵
Timi haru jastai le hard ho yesto vako
@@manaramrai9516k garxau ta bro ani? Soja saja janta lai bhram phailayera road ma utareka thia neta le. Tyo samayama timi pani neta haruko kurama ayera road ma utrina sakthiyou
Ferdalism in nepal, even in south asia cannot be compared to the swiss model. Not because we have different culture but because corruption, nepotism and favoritism is deeply rooted in our culture. Fedralism or any sort of decentralized system will work in our part of the world only when knowledge and self awareness will prevail, not education but self awareness!
Federalism is must needes in the country like Nepal which have cultural diversity. If federalism is not okey then nothing will be work in Nepal and we will destroyed soon by fighting each other. Just remove federalism bring back king and see, Nepal will sink in insurjancy very soon and divided to many state
@@user-ch3cs4yi1k I'm talking about sentiments just like yours. Unaware and misunderstood. I have not uttered a single word of monarchy and you come with a biased opinion making an assumption that I said what I said in favor of monarchy.
@@hayseether you seems to be unware of cultural diversity of Nepal. Why people faught till the 10 years? there are huge unsatisfied section in the Nepal on the basis of geography and cultural ethnic group. Federalism is just 11 years old now and still did not act as we imagine. Its truely injustice to conclude federalism has failed.
@@user-ch3cs4yi1k federalism is not failed but Nepal is itself a failed country......u cannot deny that.......and finally Nepal is dying and cannot be revived with the federalism agenda or any monarchial system or republic system......any system in the world is not bad itself take the example of the ceremonial monarchial system countries like Denmark, Sweden, and other Nordic countries or the the republic countries like Germany France Italy etc......the Main problem of Nepal is corrupt citizens like ourselves who always talks about the diversity and differences about the people's creating the divide among ourselves everyone is born different stop making the diversity as agenda .......Nepal is dying due to the youths like ourselves......accept the diversity but don't make it agenda everyone is born different
As an individual, my opinion on federalism in Nepal is shaped by the challenges faced in its implementation. The administrative complexities, ethnic tensions, and issues related to resource distribution have raised concerns. Some argue that federalism might exacerbate regional disparities. However, it's crucial to acknowledge diverse perspectives and consider the complexities of Nepal's unique socio-political context when forming an opinion on the effectiveness of federalism in the country.
India has a political agenda towards political unstatibility in Nepal.
Federalism is just another chapter.
Do u think it is decrease after bjp or same ?
English aaudaina bhane jabarjasti English mai kina lekhya? K bhana khojya Nepali ma bhana na@@demonempire5963
It's not about which political group is in power. it's more of a common political interest of Indian government.
Read autobiography from any R&AW chief or any ambassadors. It has always been in interest of their government.
Since its independence from the British regime, it has always been their agenda.
One of the primary concerns regarding federalism in Nepal is the significant increase in administrative costs. The creation of provinces, each with its bureaucracy and administrative apparatus, has led to a multiplication of government offices and personnel. This exponential rise in administrative costs diverts precious resources from development projects, social welfare, and infrastructure, jeopardizing the nation's economic stability.
NOOOOOOOO... India doesn't want political instability in Nepal, it just wants a government to stay in power which isn't pro-China. It doesn't have to be pro-India necessarily, it just should not be pro-China. Both the government and citizens of India considers Nepal as an ally (ignore the media, they always spread BS). So we won't like the fact that our ally(Nepal) is siding with our enemy(China).
यो पिंड खाने उमेरका बुढाहरुलाई आर्यघाटले नलगेसम्म देशमा स्थिरता हुने भएन।संघियता खर्चालु भएको हो नेताहरुको संख्या र मन्त्रालय संख्या धेरै घटाउनुपर्छ।
Great and well made video. Federalism ko barema discussion is necessary for it to work better. Great work Dipesh Bro.
I fear for Nepal future not in 5 yrs but in 50 yrs.
Can you genuinely imagine and visually the future of Nepal and trust the people that rule today.
The people are loosing the integrity ,confidence & intellectual judgement quality quickly than ever.
Corruption is not just a crime, it’s a cancer for the whole country if not cured timely.
Dishonesty is what we are cultivating in our society now, destruction is what that awaits us down this road.
संघियता चाईदैन मेराे बिचारमा।
स्तानीय सरकारलाई बलियाे बनाए पुग्छ।
One of the primary concerns regarding federalism in Nepal is the significant increase in administrative costs. The creation of provinces, each with its bureaucracy and administrative apparatus, has led to a multiplication of government offices and personnel. This exponential rise in administrative costs diverts precious resources from development projects, social welfare, and infrastructure, jeopardizing the nation's economic stability.
Chahincha ni sathi
Great video & great background music as well.
Salute to you Sir for your research and presentation 🫡🫡.
गजेडिलाई ईतिहास के थाहा,हामिले भोगेका छौ दुख के हो भनेर,३माना चामल को लागि लाईन लाग्नु परेको तर त्यो चामल ठुलो परिवारलाई मुश्किलले दुई दिन पुग्थ्यो😢
Thanks for giving this high level of content.🙏
Few things :
1. Faulty election system of Nepal and the representative numbers.(Bonkers!!!)
2. After successful Sikkim endeavours in 1975, there seem to have been several seeds sown for separation of Terai from Nepal, to counter the chicken neck issue, which later failed to materialise following Mrs. Gandhi loosing the elections and India's own domestic turbulence.
PS: Experts (International and national) were a bit surprised when they heard that Nepal was willing to go to Federalism because
1. It didn't have the funds.
2. The land area was small.
3. The population was also less.
Then experimentation begun and ringmasters observed carefully, talking notes which would be useful in future scenarios.
Needless to say, who did what.
To quote several "key international position holders", who have spoken along the following line, off the record :
"It's all about setting the narrative and selling it to the public and in Nepal's case it seems that is particularly about creating an ever lasting controllable chaos."
Very well researched. Thank you.
Your videos are quite impressive man it brings lot of chaos on mind
Until corruption doesn't reduce and patriotism doesn't rise in politician. none any system of Government will move forward our nation.
One of the best UA-cam channel
Keep it up brother
🇳🇵 🇧🇪
संघीयता चाहिदैन भन्नेहरु धेरै छ्न तर तिनिहरु बाट किन चाहिदैन भन्ने प्रश्नको एउटै उतर छ खार्चिलो भयो तर के संघीयता खारेज हुदैमा के यो समस्याको समाधान हुन्छ त नेपालमा संघीयता नै रहि रहनु पर्छ किनकी पहिले के कस्तो अवस्था थियो अहिले कस्तो भएको छ तर यस्लाई केही सशोधान गर्नु पर्ने देखिन्छ प्रत्यक वडामा 1 जना अध्यक्ष र 2 जना सदस्य वडा राम्रै सङ चलाउन सक्छ र प्रदेशमा सामनुपातिकलाई केही हदसम्म कम गरेर प्रत्यक्ष निर्वाचन प्राणाली र सकेसम्म कम भनाएयो भने खर्च त कम भै हाल्छ र स्थानीय तहहरुले स्थानीय सरकार सन्चालन ऐनमा भएका सबै काम कर्तव्य र अधिकारको प्रभावकारी कर्यान्वयन गरेमा संघीयताको ठाउमा अरु बिकल्प हुन सक्दैन
Pakistan which have bigger area and complex diversity in culture have only 5 states but in Nepal we have 7 states. Federal system have no need. There should be referendum regarding this problem. #referendum.
Literary nepal ma 12 person ko lagi ek neta 🤡
@retinagaming6518 Referendum hunuparxa yo barema. Yo neta haru le garna mandainan.
Wtf 😂 you choose Pakistan as a nation to look up to lol
@@phakyouwhat's wrong with that?? Today Pakistan had some issues but that doesn't mean we shouldn't look at Pakistan and most importantly he is talking about the province not an economy...
One of the primary concerns regarding federalism in Nepal is the significant increase in administrative costs. The creation of provinces, each with its bureaucracy and administrative apparatus, has led to a multiplication of government offices and personnel. This exponential rise in administrative costs diverts precious resources from development projects, social welfare, and infrastructure, jeopardizing the nation's economic stability.
Babbal video daju. Federalism Nepal ko lagi imp xha tara yo kura taba samma implement huna sakdaina jaba samma center le chahadaina cuz reason same cha sabai power aafnai haat ma lyaune chahana. Feri center le matra navai province le ni garna sakeko chaina kaam. For example dherai jasto province harule1st term ma gareko sabai vanda thulo kaam nai aafno pradesh ko naam rakhne matra vayo. Federalism ko system implement huna na sakeko vanekai shayad visionless manche haru tyo thauma pugnu ra power kai lagi matra janu vanne chai malai lagcha..
Truly you help people to make their perception. and I think it should be continued.
love from UAE dipesh brother you make amazing content🇳🇵🙏🇦🇪
We need Federalism for better Services and for better Inclusive of peoples freedom and development.
You have a very balanced perspective, thanks
broko content malai ramro lagcha I respect you tara yo videoma sanghiyatako barema kura gareko chau tara suruma yo sanghiyata vaneko k ho bujhayera firstma ani kura haru nikaldai garda ramro huntheo sanghiyatako artha sabailai thaha nahuna sakcha
Powerful video content !
Despite administrative expenditures across provinces any system would be useless if there’s no trust built in the system .Corruption, lack of transparency, compromised integrity, and infrastructure challenges can undermine the principles of federalism by affecting the fair distribution of resources, hampering efficient governance, and eroding public trust in the system. Federalism system comes with challenges and its not gonna be successful in a year or even in a decade it’s a process with evolving system. If we take a similar geographical challenges then Switzerland has practiced federalism since its modern state was established in 1848. Its Federal Constitution outlines the division of powers allowing for a decentralised system of governance. It’s proven this has contributed to the country's stability, political neutrality, and economic prosperity. However, like any system, it has faced challenges, but overall, it won’t make sense if there’s no transparency integrity.
Great video. Keep it up 🙏🏻
स्थानिय सरकार र संघीय सरकार मात्रै चाहिन्छ ।
Ek dam informative video
Thank you Dipesh,
In Nepal, there is widespread propaganda as a result ppl do not even understand what federalism is.
There is an assumption that in unitary states there are no provincial assemblies; however, even in Panchayat Nepal had Zilla Panchayat and Anchal Panchayat; and there are assemblies in China, Sri Lanka, Philippines or Japan all of them are Unitary countries.
There is a need to enforce regional laws even in Unitary States, so that the central government can focus on crucial issues such as Immigration, Fiscal Policy, and International Relations. Nepal, apart from the term Federal is just a Unitary system. However, in Nepal ministries are more interested in building infrastructure that could make a quick buck and recognition as well as saruwa-baduwa (transfer or promotion) of all staff more than that which is seen in Unitary state.
Nepal was one of the most centralized country in the world and remains one of the most centralized country in the world. And the only way out is to decentralize the country, for this Nepali mindset has to be decentralized. Till everything is guided by Singha Durbar- Kathmandu will remain overpopulated and the most polluted city in the world.
Federation/decentralization is not an option but the only method to get anything done. Before the concept of community Forest- the entire forest was a disaster; after the concept of community forest- then locals participated in the preservation of the forest. Centralization has proven to be a failure in authoritarian communist states and has proven to be a failure in Nepal, but ppl are too stubborn to understand this simple fact.
People assume that federalism is too expensive and to transfer the political power of provinces to the local government- the problem is, if we transfer 7 cabinets into local government then we will have 753 cabinets, this is not practical even for the advance economy- this is only possible if we just have 7 cities (like the size of cities of that seen in China). This will also be a very unpopular decision, we can make some adjustments with the structure we have.
Your analysis has always be a top-notch. Couldn’t agree more with the line “It’s the central government which has caused the failure of federalism, rather than the provincial government”. In fact, we nepalese haven’t paid attention to the corruption done by central government, which always has outweigh the total budget of all provincial government.
100% agree with you sir and whole team TNC❤❤❤❤
Thanks bro for teaching me a new lesson about Nepal, your videos are always great 🙏🫡
Nepal needs two tier federalism. Central and local government. The mid tier provincial government is not needed.
Very nice analysis
Great video!
Music is too loud bro. Story line bhanda music tira dhyan jane jasto bhayo.
Thank you, sir, for the information 🙏 geart informative video
संघियता र प्रदेशको नामकरणमा यतिका हुलदंगा र धेरै नेपालीको ज्यान गयो । संघियता आफैमा नराम्रो होइन तर तह तहमा जनताको लागि सेवा र सुविधालाई प्राथमिकता नराख्दा आज संघियतालाई नै हटाउने जस्तो मानसिकता र विचार आउनु नौलो होइन । तर यसको सुरुवात के का लागि र किन गरिएको थियो ? यि यस्ता प्रश्नमै यसको जवाफ लुकेको छ ।
absolutely correct!
Federalism will just increase the separatism mindset in peoples
Weather its federalism monarchy or republic at last the one suffers or suffering are we the common people
You are amazing dai ❤❤iam always waiting your videos
Good job👏👏
Great video dai
Bro, buy a dynamic mic like atr 2100x, Samson q2u ...❤
I just love to watch those kinds of contents, also I want to see my country as a developed country, I don't have the enough knowledge in political. I didn't understand many Nepali terms used in this contents, but I know our country is falling apart.
thank you so much !
please make video on गाउँ फर्क राष्ट्रिय अभियान what was that again that campaign needed ....
Amazing video
It has not covered the issue of Self-determination power to provincial government. Alongside,it also didn't pointed out about the threat of having ethnic model of federation.
Good luck bro keep it up
नियमित दर्शक हरु कोको हुनुहुन्छ हाजिर हुनुहोस ल
धन्यवाद ❤
Civic education is important then any full proof system and that Nepal lacks
Keep it up..
Bro why did you delet kirat pradesh video !?
Yes we strongly need FEDERALISM
Background music kati thau ma alli loud vako ho ke
baground sound noise bhairxa........ kam grdinuuu
dates are missing ?
राजसंस्था जिन्दावाद 💖🙏🇳🇵
Balanced analysis.
Bro please make a video on the judicial system in Nepal . Because people don't have enough information...
Sahi kura ho brother
In my view, making federalism work better in Nepal requires a multifaceted approach. Improving coordination between different levels of government is essential, as it enhances efficiency and prevents conflicts. Addressing issues related to resource distribution ensures that all regions benefit equitably. Encouraging inclusive governance by actively involving diverse communities can help alleviate ethnic tensions. Additionally, a periodic reassessment of the power dynamics between the central and regional governments ensures a more adaptable and responsive federal structure. It's crucial to foster an environment of continuous improvement and flexibility to meet the evolving needs of Nepal.
😂
Typical Social Studies subject answer
This is a huge issue, and hence cannot be decided by people or politicians alone. We have to look for data and facts; there needs to be a proper comprehensive economic analysis by an unbiased entity and *then* decision made through referendum. But I guess that's too much to ask from our current MPs.
You are Druv rathe of our country🎈❤😊🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵
Dai MADE IN NEPAL vanney topic ma manxey lai motivate garney type ko video banaunu paryo dai please mero request ho you tapailai
गणतन्त्र मुर्दाबाद संघियता खारेज गरौँ देश बचाऔँ ❤❤
तिमि तिम्रो देश तिमी बचाउ। हामिलाई हाम्रो देशमा federalism नै चाहिन्छ। संघीयतालाई जति चाडो कार्यनयन गरौ। किनकी कर्णालिलाई काठमाडौले बुझ्दैन। जनजातिको उत्पिडन राज्यले बुझ्दैन।
@@user-ch3cs4yi1k❤️❤️🙏🙏
Watching frm india your regular viewr😍😍🙏🙏🙏
# Demand for referendum. Nepalese politicians, bureaucracy,experts and some Nepalese People don't showcase knowledge at all. They have been a puppet of foreign countries and political parties. Central and empowered local govt is enough. No.of local level also needs reduction through merger. Compare with countries having larger area and population than Nepal in terms of no.of governments
Good content
back ground sound is disturbing 3;29 to 4 ;55
This topic needs even more research, can you guys make a separate series for on this topic addressing rampant corruption at all three levels and how could they deliver better?
Hats off
Constitutional monarchy is the best system of governance for Nepal
@@On_my_way_to_Nirvana-jx7ps ehh ho ani democracy vako Pakistan, India chai k vayoni? Esto powerful ximeki vako desh ko bich ma basera afno sovereignty jogaunu vaneko kei haina? Atomic bomb vanne chij hunna mahasaye atom bomb ho. Learn proper English before trying to act educated. Timerukai neta vaunauda le trade union ra k k nonsense khokera desh ko industry haru sakkako vuleu. Selective momory and hypocrisy at its best wow.
@@On_my_way_to_Nirvana-jx7psstop watching Aaj Tak and other news channels too much. Don't give that nonsense about the growth rate, at one point Nepal had a growth rate of approx 8 %, so does that mean Nepal was the fastest growing economy? How relevant is such nonsense number crunching when in reality people hadn't felt one single bit off it? You're brownwashed is what you are.
Now im in india 🇮🇳 as an indian army i work here and I dont know more about federalism thanks for share this big matter of our country
Jai nepal 🇳🇵
@The Nepali comment
Make video on ram born in Nepal 🇳🇵❤
हाम्रो देशमा स्थानीय सरकार लाई राजश्व संकलन गर्न धेरै उपाय छ तर प्रदेश सरकारलाई राजस्व असुलीको खासै अवसर छैन। मुख्य कारण यहीँ प्रदेश सरकार असफल हुनुको कारण। आफ्नु धरै नेता हरुलाई व्यवस्थि हुने भएपछि Top Political Party हरू चुप छन्।
I dont know. Maybe we do.
❤❤❤ youare good work 💪💪
💔💔💔 youare bad work 💪💪💪
Federalism has both pros and cons. The system itself isn't bad, it's the people involved.
In depth story ra ,the nepali comment dui jana partner jasto lagyo content haru sunda herda,
Big fan❤❤❤❤❤
नेपाल जस्तो सानो देशमा सङ्घीय सरकार र स्थानीय सरकार भए पुग्छ। प्रदेश सरकारको कुनै आवश्यकता छैन।
"the nepali comments" ra "IDS" duitai le world link ko router bechne ad pako raixa :D. but content chai ramrai hunxa hai....
Video tw rmro banaunu hunxa tara worldlink jasto jhampat ko ads ra background music irrigated x ale😑
Please make a video on kalo diwas
Why kalo diwas is celebrating on ashoj 3
Appreciate your videos please make ur case study on Himalaya Jet airlines of Dipendra Gurung, really curious about this company if it's a scam or real ?
Decentralisation is must to match the speed of today developmental works in any nation. However in my opinion it was really unfavorable for Nepal as changing strategy won't do any better. Our country has many possibilities of development whether power is decentralisation or not. There is lack of effort which is essential now as well as back then. Federalism itself will not bring changes.And Nepal can't support federalism financially too. Federalism is best for those nations which has caught the pace of development but not for Nepal which is in beginning phase.
I think, in my opinion Federalism works best if the provinces has autonomy like in the USA. They should provide a clear framework for the division of powers between the federal government and the provincial government. Right now, the main issue with federalism in Nepal is power tussle among various levels of government. All of the local and provincial government eye a seat at Kathmandu, which is causing the downfall of federalism in Nepal.
Biggest fans are here ❤
plz make video on how many things nepal import from india .
it can give idea for new enterpreneurs .
thank you
Raja aau, desh bachau🤴🕉️
नेपाल र भारतको सरकारी कार्यालयहरू र कर्मचारीहरूको संख्यामा तुलना गरेमा, संघीय परिणामले नेपालमा कसरी अत्यधिक कर्मचारीहरू र MLAहरूले आर्थिक भार बढाएको देखिएको छ। भने भारत, जसले बढी जनसंख्या र ठूलो भू-विस्तार छ, २८ प्रदेश र ८ संघीय क्षेत्रसँग कार्यालय सञ्चालन गरेको छ। तर नेपालले सात प्रदेशहरूमा विभाजित हुनुभएको छ। तलका, भारतको संख्यातुलनामा नेपालले अधिक कर्मचारी र MLAहरू बनाएको देखिएको हामीले बताउँछौं। यो असमानताको कुरा गरेको छ कि संघीयताले नेपाललाई आर्थिक रूपमा जोखिममा राखेको छ।
@@user-tg5ut6ic8l baidesh rin kaha puraye
Aaja pradesh ko power khe chaina
Arthik boj garaye desh ma
Berojgari, Bharastachar failaye
Yo kharek hunu apariharya cha
In my view, Nepal doesn't need federalism we need directy elected pm and 75 samsad..one from each district..
77 districts ho sir😂
@@LordSaurav if I broke one district into 2 or more times then there will be an 150+ so, that's why those same districts separate into two doesn't count...
Kathmandu ra Manang dubai 1 samsad pauney? Population anusar adjust garnu parchha.
@@Anon-md5ep population anusar garyo vaney feri teha inquality vayo vanxan, feri auta specific tribes haru lae target garera tiniharu ley desh khayo, bechyo vandaii karauxan so, I think one samsad from one district ley kasaiiley kasailae dosh lagauna sakdainan ra tiniharu ko mukh pani talinxa... ani feri sabaii migrants haru lae vote halna tiniharu kaii district janu parxa Aru district bata vote halna mildaina vaney kanun vayo vaney tesley kei hat samma help garxa...
He tells fast
Yes 👍🏻
you great boy
Thumbnail❤❤🎉🎉
Ad bich ma chai kina