Ahsoka VS Star Wars Rebels - Live Action VS Animated | Video Essay
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 сер 2023
- Ahsoka is the new Star Wars Shows on Disney Plus and has finally been released. The show features Rosario Dawson as the iconic character Ahsoka.
This show also functions as a Season 5 to the hit animated show Star Wars Rebels. And includes characters such as Hera Syndulla, Sabine Wren aswell as Grand Admiral Thrawn who will feature later in the series. Aswell as Ezra Bridger who will also make an appearance.
But the big question is, how does the characters and world building of Ahsoka compare to its animated counterpart, Star Wars Rebels?
Previous Video: • Oppenheimer | Quick Mo...
Patreon: / ecartman12
Direct Donations: streamelements.com/se-7775612...
PayPal Donations: goo.gl/ravaVq
Music in this video:
• Star Wars: Ahsoka Them...
My Twitch Channel:
/ 3minrevs
Follow me on:
Twitter ► / ecartman12
Facebook ► / ecartman12
Google Plus ►Google.com/+EricCarterS
Instagram ► / ecartman12
TikTok ► / ericcarteryt
The footage, music and images featured in the video were for critical review and parody, which are protected under the Fair Use laws of the United States Copyright Act of 1976. - Розваги
Clone wars:Micro (2003) vs Clone Wars (2008) vs Rebels (2014) vs Tales Of The Jedi (2022).
Kenobi series vs clone wars 2008.
The Mandalorian vs Ahsoka vs Kenobi series.
*Godzilla:Legacy Of Monsters (live-action) vs Skull Island (Anime)*
The only problem that comes with comparing Star Wars Rebels and (other than people’s complaints about the show) Ahsoka. Is that so far Ahsoka isn’t even finished and Star Wars Rebels. Has FOUR SEASOOONNNSSSS! Of animated content that fans a lot more to chew on.
They really should've cast the Voice Actors as the actual characters. If the actor can pull it off and looks enough like the character there's zero reason not to cast them.
Exactly even if a acter is good as the character it still feels weird
yeah just from the looks alone hera in rebels is far different as the hera in live action, for starters hera has a triangular face while in live action she has a square face.
Definitely feels like a love letter to Rebels fans.
And hopefully with the next episode, Clone Wars fans. :)
I enjoyed the Ahsoka show so far even though I see points made by people who aren't fans of it and agree with some of their complaints but we are only one fourth of the way through the show so there is time to explain.
What are your thoughts on Rebels as a whole?
I’m my opinion my biggest red flag when it came to live-action Ahsoka was her head tails, they were made longer in the Ahsoka series but I’m still not satisfied. Obviously it’s because the actor would have trouble playing the character with a long and heavy wig but I like to think that there is an (in-universe) reason for why her head tails were short.
My head canon: Even though it’s flesh, Twi-Leks and Taguritas have the ability to cut their head tails similar to how humans can cut their nails or hair. Sometime between the events of the Rebels epilogue and the Mandalorian Ahsoka shortened her head tails only for them to start growing back by the time of the Ahsoka series.
I thought he was gonna release his The Flash versus video but makes it up with another banger video
Glad to see this show getting some positive recognition amidst all the negativity. Do you stand by your theory that the show will involve the World Between Worlds?
Yes I do. And I think my theory turned out to be right in the end. :)
I thought you'd be releasing the flash vs video first, but you released another banger video. Speaking of which, when is the Flash vs video coming out on YT?
I am excited to see how the show will progress, a strong start with potential. Only issue is really with them nerfing ashoka a little,she should've bodied everyone with ease but I'm sure she'll show her power later on
I don't agree. Having overly powerful characters as protoganists kinda diminishes the stakes alot.
@@Peer165Not unless the writers can create a story that can accommodate such power. But yeah, you got a point.
@@Peer165 I can see it point but with a villian as smart as thrawn or powerful as a nightsisted I feel like it makes sense to have ashoka be as powerful as she was in rebels
Imo, i think u should continue making these tv show reviews on YT, eric. I know u have your "let's watch" show in Patreon, but man, these tv show reviews of u are so great. ✨️
How would you feel if Darth Vader and Darth Maul had an action sequence against each other in Star Wars Rebels ?
Could have been interesting. But Maul would not have stood a chance. Ahsoka even said that too him when she faced him in the final four episodes of The Clone Wars.
Well I thought they could have gotten away with something like this in the Kenobi show and made it work
@@EricCarter12can you do versus video on the live action jungle book 2016 vs mowgli legend of the jungle 2018 please and love the ahsoka ❤😂😅😊🎉
@@EricCarter12do cinderella 1950 vs cinderella 2015 live action remake
@@EricCarter12 m3gan 2023 vs child's play 2019 remake
But can we agree that the whole "casually surviving a lightsaber in the chest" is bullish*t?
Yes we can DEFINITELY agree on that.
Disney seems to be loving doing that. Eg:- Thanos, Korg, Zeus and Shuri
Hey eric have you ever considered doing a star warss original trilogy versus video? Oh and hows you avatar versus video doing. Nice video
Good voice acting doesn't mean you can act nearly as well infront of the camera too.
True. But they're actors. They've been in front of the camera before. So if a Director does their job, then they should be able to rise for the challenge.
@@EricCarter12 Fair.
I'm ready for the next episodes
I’ll eventually get around to watching this but right now I’m currently taking a break from Disney+ shows after finally watching Gargoyles for the first time and rewatching both Gravity Falls and Avengers Earth’s Mightiest Heroes (All are great shows BTW, highly recommended)
Alternate title: Star Wars Rebels: the live action remake
What are your thoughts on Ray Stevenson’s character in this show? Given how this was one of his last roles before his death I’m very curious.
I thought he was ok in the first three episodes. But he was AMAZING in episode 4. Especially his scene with Sabine. It showed that he was a man of integrity. And not just a two dimensional bad guy.
Dave Filoni has always been good in that way with his villains.
I think they used the same robot chopper as the one that would be rolling around in the rebels office
Rebels wins, hands down. Dave Filoni may be good when it comes to animation, but seriously fumbles when he tries his hands at live-action. I mean, look at what he did on Mandolorian season 3 and Book of Boba Fett. Both were terrible and he had a hand in both of them. Also, Ahsoka's sense of humor is gone, and is just stoic now, along with Hera Sindula and Sabine Ren. Why are they all so stoic now without any sense of humor? Plus, why is it that now in TWO Star Wars shows when somebody is stabbed through the midsection with a lightsaber, they don't die?! What the hell?!
Its so great to see you again.
Please do Kung Fu Panda vs How To Train Your Dragon?
Avengers infinity war vs justice leauge
Hey what did you think of Andor?
I haven't seen it. What did you think of it?
@@EricCarter12 it was incredible very different from other star wars projects the first few episodes are slow and very diolouge heavy but once you get used to it it's so much better than the other d+ shows like kenobi and Boba fett. The prison arc is probably the best Disney sw content out there.
@@EricCarter12hi
I like both of them
Will you do more Last Of Us show vs Game?
I always prefer animations look to beatiful ❤
So, now that Ahsoka is finished, is your faith in Filoni broken now?
Can you do conjuring vs insidous
This show was pretty good I loved it
2:19 they can’t do that because Rosario Dawson was already Ashoka in the Mandalorion. Also what did you think of every movie in the original trilogy?
7:11 Kate kessidy is so frrrrr,She destroyed Indiana jones and Star Wars
Anyone else going to talk about how he pronounces Clone Wars as Clone weres
Not even a fair comparison. Animated Star Wars is vastly superior to Live Action Star Wars.
What about the original trilogy?
@@langfordentertainmentstudi6745 Sorry man but the Clone Wars animated show is way more engaging and entertaining than the original Trilogy.
@@thefanwithoutaface8105 okay. I really respect that. The Clone Wars is very awesome.
@@langfordentertainmentstudi6745 That and it had the benefit of coming out later when storytelling and world building had improved, while the OG is fine but not nearly as cool by comparison.
@@thefanwithoutaface8105Yeah I can see why.
Hi Eric have you seen andor
No I haven't. But I might give it a watch soon.
I love Rebels cartoon my childhood
Sabine looks like Gamora
I didn't really like Sabine using the force,she was one of my favourites and seeing how she was mishandled in the show.
My opinion so please be civil about it.
have you watched percy jackson show trailer
This should’ve been a Animated Series with the Original Voices Actors or the Voice Actors give the Roles in Live Action, this Series doesn’t have any of the Star Wars Energy or the Nostalgic Feel, it’s not a Bad Series but it’s not Good Either as of Yet, this feels like a Sabine Series than a Ahsoka Series but we will see, also I predict the Black Knight is Ezra.
We respect your opinion about Star Wars.
One piece east blue arc live action vs anime/manga
For me Ahsoka is falling flat because I really don't like Sabine's character
Ezra
Take notes Kathleen Kennedy: this is how you do Star Wars!
Did you actually like the Star wars rebels TV show
Are you going to watch the live action One Piece
It’s decent so far but to be honest if this show gets worse and sucks then I’m officially done with Star Wars as Ashoka is pretty much my last hope.
Keep Kathleen Kennedy away from this show.