How Marrow came to capture the NEET PG Market……The Story of Evolution of NEET PG Coaching.
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 лип 2024
- The evolution of NEET PG coaching…..from Amit/Ashish to Marrow/Prepladder.
0:00 Introduction
0:33 Before MCQs to MCQs
1:10 2000-2010 - Amit Ashish Era
2:10 Post Liberalisation effect on PG Entrance
2:56 Rise of DAMS and Bhatia and era of Test and Discussions
3:30 Pulse and DAMS
4:00 Coaching in 3/4th year
4:40 Entry of Jio
6:00 Offline vs Online Battle
7:35 Individual Classes
8:10 COVID Pandemic and rise of Online Coaching
8:40 Entry of Unacademy
9:35 How Rich 🤑 Marrow Is
11:00 Synopsis
11:40 My comments
Disclaimer: The financials shared are from Ministry of Corporate Affairs (www.mca.gov.in) and do-not represent official statement of Company concerned.
Also, I hope you like the video.
The evolution of NEET PG coaching - to its present form.
The evolution of NEET PG coaching…..from Amit/Ashish to Marrow/Prepladder.
0:00 Introduction
0:33 Before MCQs to MCQs
1:10 2000-2010 - Amit Ashish Era
2:10 Post Liberalisation effect on PG Entrance
2:56 Rise of DAMS and Bhatia and era of Test and Discussions
3:30 Pulse and DAMS
4:00 Coaching in 3/4th year
4:40 Entry of Jio
6:00 Offline vs Online Battle
7:35 Individual Classes
8:10 COVID Pandemic and rise of Online Coaching
8:40 Entry of Unacademy
9:35 How Rich 🤑 Marrow Is
11:00 Synopsis
11:40 My comments
Sir please make videos on Fmge
Postmortem complete
i m from peripheral government medical college , my per year fees of college is Rs 30,000....and from 3rd year onwards i m taking marrow for Rs 30,000 per year .
I tried to study standard books in 1st year and 2nd year , and i didn't understand much , barely able to pass college exams.
after using marrow from 3rd year onwards , my understanding of subject has increased immensely , and i fell in love with mbbs .
Coaching are doing great job my building good concept for an avergae student like me , according to me the default is of college , where they don't teach us well , and we pay their fees only for degree .
isse better yeh hoga ki college mein marrow or prep ladder ki video dikhaye jaye at the expense of college , bcoz we already pay for college . isse bache daily class bhi attend karenge .
college mein kuch padhaya ni jata , average bache ko mere jaise itna jaldi samjh ni aata , toh marrow lena hi padhta h .
jab koi itne easily concepts samjha rha h , sabko voh hi padhna acha lagega , rather than koi substandard class mein teacher padha rha h , voh time waste lagega.
hmre pass choice honi chahiye college mein ki kiske video lectures aap class mein dekhna pasand karenge , toh jo best teacher hoga uske lectures hm dikhenge or hme sab ache se samjh aayega or paise bhi ni kharch honge . or coaching institute k itna advertisement bhi ni hoga , sirf teacher k advertisement hoga jo best hoga .
Same with me, also
Well said!
I was always curious about this!
Beautiful analysis and description. 🤩
Great and detailed analysis of coaching for neet PG.
Explained perfectly well, and all the essentials a student must know to wisely use the varied platforms and at same time, not fall in traps of coaching .
Hats off to your analysis Sir 🙌
Nice analysis.
appreciate !
Loved it 🙌
I like the way how he explains everything just wow
This Video has Highlighted the Business Model behind PG entrance .
Basically This Video is applicable on all The Entrance exams across this vast nation ..
Can u share your amazon list for guidance books??yesterday i saw it and today i cant see this..
you always tell ultimate src(annotated one) of pre para clinical subjects is first aid.?
Wht About Final yr subjects? ... plz guide how to go about that....!?
Thank you for a lecture.
Hello,
Is the Uworld helpfull in neetpg and INICET as like first-aid??
If yes then which one
Uworld step1 or 1,2 both ??
Sir,which resource is good for previous year question paper for neet pg , kindly reply
is there any particular trustable source of previous year question for neet pg? Or do i have to rely on the Coaching institute pyqs?
sir i didn't read standard books for physio in 1st yr..now reading robbins in 2nd yr..how to improve physio now
I have been preparing exams and trying to crack exam but couldn't do it... The key year which I felt was 2019 bcoz there was definitely boom of these apps and it become evident by result of neet 2020 pg exam..covid actually speed up the boom and changing the whole scenario of exams.this has also lead to paper changing pattern from one liners to clinical bcoz of these apps bcoz cut offs went too high..now after 4 years (last time 2018 neet pg),that cut off went down(where 600/800 marks was under 1000 rank compared to last year where 600 marker was under 2500 rank
Please sir tell us from where we get previous year questions
For Q bank sir which source is best n can you please tell whether dams DVT is good ? Or bad
Dr. can you please tell where can we find previous year question papers?
Imo most of the coaching/apps came up as replacement for the standard textbook because of the simple fact that a lot of students need initial guidance/lecture to start getting into the topic and studying it, and sadly most of the times all the faculty did was dump the ppts prepared for/by their post graduates. Not defending all the unnecessarily bloated content and subsequent chest thumping they do but still, for me personally these apps became necessary at certain points.
Excellent analysis
Sir can you please suggest some USMLE sources which will be really helpful for PG entrance.
Thank you
efforts 🙌🙌 aditya sir
Sir could you make a video on review books used by you for pyq questions
This is as legit as it can get !
Sir,Which best book for pyq ,it is possible to crack neet pg only using first aid step 1
U r rocking
Forgot about TMCAA Thrissur (Kerala) ?? .. . Where enormous students from all over India cleared pg entrance since 1982 . It has trained legends like Dr. Rakesh Nair himself , Dr. Deebu Sebin the CEO of marrow , Dr Vandana Puri, Dr. Rebecca James, Dr. Raviraj and many more .It definitely does not advertise like Dams , Bhatia, marrow or prepladder but spreads through the word of mouth . So when talking about the evolution of pg entrance I think is certainly incomplete without mention of TMCAA.
Yes. I did forget about that!
Thanks!
Will cover it in some other video!
I attended med pg which was a spinoff TMCAA and dr Rakesh taught me while he did his final year md medicine ... The man was amazing then and is still now ... Dr Ashwath Kumar made obgyn so amazing!
Only flaw was the almost daily classes which cut into the time ..
Proud to be a TMCAA product
@@subhajitdutta376 sir !! 🙌
@@nishanarayan8984 does this institution teaches students all over India for neetpg or only for native students?
Sir could you please make a video on what are the best institutes to do general medicine just like you did it for radiology would be so helpful sir ❤️🙂
Sir , will you guide the next neet batches too ?
Excellent 👌
These online platforms are the major reason behind poor clinical abilities a mbbs or even a MD/MS getting..
You compare today's young doctors from past ( 1990) young doctors, you'll get the difference.
The essence of clinical skills led in their blood and we're just running in a rat race to get MD Radio/MD med (most of us)..
Not a good sign for students in future.
Books are gem and will be forever.
i completely disagree , atleast these platform are teaching so well , so i being an average student able to grasp concepts . otherwise in college there is nothing taught , and it is hard to understand standard book , when nothing is taught in colleges .
after watching lectures from marrow , im easily able to read standard book .
these coaching institute should not be blamed . colleges should be blamed , which are there only for giving degrees not knowledge .
@@ananyasingh6621 💯 agree
@@ananyasingh6621 I think it’s tough for these Big guns of Top medical colleges to digest the fact that now we are all on equal footing…I being from a peripheral GMC can get the best lectures for a minimal amount..But it should be used as a supplement as Standard books are a must to become good doctors and have command over the subject
Drastic change in video quality is quite appreciatable! 👌🏻
The audio quality is worse dummy!
Sir, I m repeating NEET PG. Which one should i take TnD of bhatiya or dams . Please reply
Awesome
When are you selling annotated FA
Waiting
😱 omg! Brutally honest.the real essence in cracking entrance is doing standard books in ug years understanding concepts and doing pyqs and related topics.its so simple bt dese coaching apps have made cracking exams so very complicated creating a FOMO. so well summarised sir.
so so true !! many times i thought that i would skip qbank.. but every time i suffer from FOMO and go back to the same !! I am stuck ..
So if a person has not read any standard text during his ug time is he doomed
He still has to study from somewhere and there is no timeto take standard books and study
So these platforms do help
@@jakejolly3261 I have not met a single person who did ‘well’ (that is - got a top 1000 rank) who did not read standard textbooks.
You can get an average or below average college but not AIIMS etc if you did not read standard textbooks.
Unfortunately this is lost on lost people.
People might be using DAMS/Bhatia /Marrow or whatever- but toppers always ensured reading Standard textbooks during MBBS.
Past sins do come to haunt you, unfortunately.
Is the person doomed? - Ofcourse no.
But you can’t cover up for 4 y of consistency just beucase you’re using an app.
@@DrAditya2935 okay sir thankyou
@@DrAditya2935 How to get back in the game (as an intern) if your target is INICET, you haven’t read a single standard textbook in your UG ( because that was not promoted in your college 😩 ) but you want to come in the mainstream, skip this mediocrity and are willing to work hard/smart for it
What I feel that few UA-camr's are directly or indirectly mentioning about marrow in their most of videos and influence the students who just cracked neet UG took these apps subscription from the first year & took part in the pg race like a machine from first year. Don't you think few UA-camr's are putting these subconsciously in students mind🤔
Oh, one of the most famous MBBS YTbers takes 50k/video for Marrow promotion.
Even if the paid promotion banner is not there - doesn’t mean it’s not paid promotion.
It’s insinuation and inception.
@@DrAditya2935 Yaa guessed so.
@@DrAditya2935 ummm Dr Darsh** P****?
Darshan patel ya fr anuj pacchel?
How does it Matter?
I too have promoted PrepLadder. I do like it’s Rapid Revision.
But I won’t get promote them over Standard Textbooks or their use in 1/2nd Proff.
guys which are the books best for clearing concepts
Bhaiya,video on best review books for each subject your recommendations.
Sir like you said I'm only doing recent Neet and inicet questions from q bank of all 19 subjects along with first aid. This will be only resource till exam.
Do Atleast from 2015!
Sir esic medical College se ug krne pr us state ka 50%pg quota milta hi
Sir between chacha nehru bal chikitsalaya Delhi and Kem Mumbai which one should I choose I don't have any problem with bond or stipend? Just want best learning experience kindly guide me sir
KEM
M a average private medical final yr student and wish for pg watching marrow and notes lacking behind in books now it give me anxiety will i b really able to crack pg or not
sir,please make a guided video for the average guy to crack neet pg.please .i am very confused ,tried some statergies and yyet failed.
That's true though.. Marrow at present is the leader in PG prep. Videos, q bank and tests combined, Marrow does provides an unparalleled preparation resource as clearly shown by the results, be it the number of toppers or strike rate. Although I agree with you, Aditya sir that PG prep has now lost it's essence and has become a competitive business and money making market. However, I too agree that PYQs and reference books are still the best way to prepare.
Sir I m following SWT of marrow ...and binding up all my materials I have made during my professional years.
Annotating the First aid also. Marking PYQ. Sir what else I shud b doing???????
It’s more than enough.
If you add PYQs and SWT points to FA - it will be complete!
@@DrAditya2935 Thankyou Sir.
Sir please make vedio for review books of all the 19 subjects.it will be great help
Already there on his quora.can go and search
Sir I am using dams, i am studying from their books. Is it ok or should I change. Pls reply🙏
Choose one …..stick to one.
Please make video on from where we get previous year questions please sir we have less time please sir please
Sir best places for previous year question
Sir even the previous year question papers are far different from Marrow GT question papers. I don't understand how medicos are comparing the two and getting crazy behind scoring high in GTs. Needless to say - marketing by Toppers' adds to it. Yes, but materials are very lucidly understandable in these apps, that one must appreciate.
Sir please make video as a 4year student how to start preparing for fmge and next how to manage time please sir thank you
Hi sir! I recently got a rank of 5k in neet pg...... My 1 st choice is M.D psychiatry but my parents want me to do M.d paediatrics which also happens to be also my 2nd favourite subject...
Even though it's a personal choice,I am facing this dilemma because I like paeds too . What should be better?
And if I choose psychiatry should I choose MMC or Delhi colleges as I don't know Hindi other than basic things....
Clearly delhi colleges are a winner considering stipend and bond... But will language be a great barrier?
If I choose to go for delhi. Which is best for psychiatry...IBHAS/MAMC/LHMC/RML/VMMC.... Also what about CIP Ranchi, I need a good work life balance..wanna chill and study too.. kindly give your valuable feedback. Thank you sir..
Big fan of your videos.
Go for psychiatry. No saturation. Other pathy doctors can't treat your patient. Psy medicine not available outside. Completely closed corner.
@@patilgunwantpatil4792 Thank you so much!
Amazing sir. But sir people like me who are in fourth year and has been using marrow since last 1.5 year, what should we do after watching your last vedio I literally thought it won't be able to revise whole syllabus in last 10 days before inicet Or neet pg. First aid is an option but what about other subjects? Please help sir
If you remember the last video - I said it’s a good resource for 3/4th year.
You just have to figure out a way to funnel down those notes.
Test and Discussion amd it’s related notes during Internship will help.
Thank you sir
Bro what about your neet ug mcq practice app??
Bro there were no neetug apps at those times 2012 time😂😂
@@megha8783 dude i’m not asking him about those apps which he used in 2012.i’m telling him for his own app launch as he also commented earlier in his videos.😎😎
@@Ramadannotes he told he wont
Sir should I use books like arvind arora mudit Khanna gobind gard,sparshgupta for pg preparation?
pyq s from them. i’ll soon be uploading a video on same. please watch it
@@DrAditya2935 thx
Sir please make video on review books you used 😁😁😁😁 please 😅
Pls talk about best app for Neet SS
Sir i need your help
My sisiter feels lazy over whole day
I visit Many reputed hostal like at patna, chandigarh but none of them find the exact difficulty. Her almost every medical test report is good. But she always feels lazy, pain in brain. Lack of energy
Sir i request you to look in this difficulty
Please reply
Just a suggestion : tell her to limit her on screen time to 3hrs for a week I have done it myself and I have suffered from what she suffering is right now and encourage her to go to the gym at least 3 to 4 days a week
@@ibrahimsiddiqui2623 her screen on time is less I think because she hate social media accept you tube on an average 2 hour per day
Give her B complex vitamins Becoz when person is feeling low in energy and lazy 1 diagnosis is deficiency of B complex vitamins Becoz TCA needs B complex vitamins and when person is deficient glucose is unable to release energy and person feel lazyness
Feels like rachna ranade is doing a video of fundamental analysis of marrow
Haha. I will take this as a compliment.
11:00 ❤❤❤
I'm 210% agreed.
But dr Aditya, can you plz tell us the way to overcome the regret we have, of not studying that seriously and those standard books in 1st and 2nd year?
Then,How to do well now in pg entrance without coaching?
Yes, we all get to realise it around our Pre-final and final years. I also have been looking for this anwer.
Same bro…Kaash tb Guyton pd lete
@@vedicmetalhead1029 Bhaiya ..I am first year Mbbs student just joined the college ..please suggest me are standard books really that important...please please as my seniors and even physiology teacher suggests just read a.k Jain..and not Guyton as they say you will just waste your time reading gyton and will not be able to retain it....
Don't delete this,
Y?
@@blackpanther3270 y defamation? Kya hua? Actually
I really don’t think Marrow will find it defamatory 😂😂
Please watch the full video.
@@blackpanther3270 he made that video private I guess?
@@DrAditya2935 Sir Ulta this will do a positive PR from them rather than a negative one 😂
Sir, please tell any premade high yield resource like first aid for FMT, ANESTHESIA, GYNAE and all possible majors and minors which are delineated from path+pharma=medicine/surgery combo.
I had made my notes from Sakshi Arora
For FMT - there is a book called Sumit Seth - really concise. Along with T and D notes.
Aneasthesia- Just previous year Questions.
@@BLUEBIRDclinic No.
why are you getting Confused ?
Did I ever or anyone talk about Kaplan notes or Uworld notes?
We have always mentioned only First Aid .
Hey! Please continue the human physiology whenever you get some free time. Your videos help a ton:)
Ipad to DSLR cam 👀😅 nice change over
iPad to iPhone
Sir what about INICET ? Pyq should be given priority?
Yes!
An advice- use a better quality mic
Gupta ji i think aap ko pg entrance ke upar book likhni chaiye 😂😅
It's hilarious to see all coaching centres claiming the same toppers. Its accurately shown in a spoof how coaching buy the ranks. The spark is in you people not some app claiming it. Behold they claim 92% strike rate 🤣 Just that Marrow is better in Qbank only rest even their tests show no resemblance to an actual exam. It's will give you decent rank if you choose only Marrow. Toppers have mastered major concepts and they practice alot. My friend used to make questions for PrePG app. It's the practice and core concepts he says. There is no shortcut to success.
Have done full marrow videos + qbank
Notes only for short subjects
Grg for Pharma
First aid read once
Gave 1st two Gts score around 350-400
How to improve my score and what else to add
One source always I too neet pg 2023 aspirant
Repetitive Revision Keep grinding
Keep up the grind and work on your weakness
Sir , I just completed my internship and only 6-7 months left for neet pg 2023 which coaching I must be choose this time most people say marrow but I think prepladder is best for 6-7 months. 6 days after result and I am still confused 🤔 . Please help me and give me a perfect answer . Because I am very much confuse what to do and how to study .
Marrow is too much of everything, go for prepladder, do pyqs early don't leave for the last month.
@@zen2911 thanks
@@arunkumar.k5 hi sir since you have already completed mbbs could you tell me. If I should go for a 3rd drop or tske a pvt deemed med clg this year?
@@ziaredruby29 If u can take a private seat then you should take it . Nothing to worry about books are same in private or government medical College.
@@ziaredruby29 BUT make sure that college is MCI affiliated .
This in infact a marrow promo only😅
Audio quality is fluctuating.
Sometime it feels normal but suddenly audio becomes very dull with a subdued volume.
Trying to improve day by day. Have ordered rode microphones.
@@DrAditya2935 Great video though. You should make more analyses like these.
@@rajpranjal8861 Thank You!
Marrow rocks sir
It sure does(for 3/4th year)
Sir,which resource is good for previous year question paper for neet pg kindly reply
Shoutout sir pls🥰🥰
Felt like Iam watching some documentary ….
Hope you liked the documentary!
sir is prepladder good for 3rd nd 4th yr subjects?
as content of marrow is vast..nd prep is concise..so prep should be taken in 3rd nd 4th yr?
Yes prepladder is more concise and revisable than marrow, but still marrow has better questions bank and test series than prepladder.
@@drharshad7205 ok thanks sir
Sir please add lights on how to revise final year subjects for neet pg
Hi sir
Srry 2say sir....if u know such a depth concept to crack entrance....then why don't u make ur own app....
Hahaha. I will. Let me finish my studies.
The audio quality of some of your videos is bad , please fix / get a good mic.
what's the next step in evolution?
Post CoVid era will be true test of offline vs Online Battle.
Let’s see who comes on top.
Other thing would be a USMLE style evolution. If NEXT happens.
Offline would win. Especially since the proposed part II is a clinical exam.
Sir one teasing question, why you didn't joined the marrow as it is a blooming business😂
New background
How is chacha nehru for md paeds sir?
It’s good!
If you’re getting it, don’t leave it.
Thank you sir🙏
@Aditya Gupta sir one more doubt sir B/W Kem Mumbai and chacha nehru Delhi which should I choose🙏 please help me sir
Marrow is popular simply because of the financial flexibility.. Most of my friends in my college share a single a Marrow membership by paying 20k each person.. This facility is not available for DAMS and Bhatia
Now its not like that are blocking device itself. I have seen many docs whose account and devices were blocked by marrow
@@sym99 but me and my friends are using it perfectly
@@sym99 Marrow doesn't have policy on not using 2 device at same time.
Your friends would have tried to screen record the videos- you will blocked immediately
@@friendlyneighborhoodhuman recently they have started blocking accounts. I can show u screen shots also
@@friendlyneighborhoodhuman to prevnt it if ur using apple products then dont give permission to track, it will reduce risk to certain extent and dont login any other account from same device which ur sharing. For eg in one ipad if ur using ur own account then never log in with others credentials like ur friends, cz marrow people will track u and ur friends account with device and locations also. If want more details i can show u screenshots via telegram if ur interested. Otherwise be careful and all the best.
9:02 " ugh slaves" in caption 🤣
Tum ho hi nahi is duniya ke
How much do faculty in coaching Institute earn, any idea??
5-10L/month
It was 300 something rs for 3 months 😂 weak maths boss
What will be your advice for final year student..now no time to read standard textbooks ...these coaching apps are only option (sab se worse thing about coaching app vedio's kitni bar dekh lo yadd ni rahti & instead of solving Q-bank ..unke explanation ko apne notes me add karne me time waste karo)it's like trap ...what will be your strategy to get come out from it
Use coaching apps for understanding concepts.
These are wonderful.
Rapid Revision is great from what my juniors told for Final proff(as in theory exams)
@@DrAditya2935 thanks sir..but main issue yahi aa raha h app se vedio's cover kar rahe forgot mostly jitte bhi frnds h...sir can you make vedio on step by step prepration (from basic)& complete app/book resources for those who are in 4th /final yr preparing for fmge/Pg..want to start prepration from zero level
I don't know why aditya Gupta hate marrow so much..... Because be honest we are those students who can /had not read standard text book in first and second year.
Marrow and prepladder are really clear our concept. I had read kdt for pharma in first year and after that i had read grg... Obviously grg's pharma make better impaction.
At the one point you are pressuring on concept budding and at the other point you are saying that read first aid, this is creating little bit confusion.
Agree or not...!?
How the fuck is this video critical of marrow?
Tell me where I said it’s bad?
Didn’t I say it better than DAMS etc and made it available to peripheral colleges not in Delhi or Mumbai.
Keep your preformed biases to yourself.
Also, I don’t hate Marrow.
Heck, Let ke say this loud and clear so that you guys understanding
Marrow is the best resource for a 3/4th year.
That’s it
It’s not for interns.
Or post interns.
Who cannot revise it since it’s huge.
I guess he always said to use first aid only for revision purpose before the exam, not as a primary source in mbbs. Also, idk why people get so defending when critical of marrow/prep. These are just apps, you pay for them and they provide their services. Cheers!
Absolutely. First Aid is for Interns!
Use Marrow or whatever suits your boat in 3/4th year.
But for Revision in Internship - nothing beats First Aid.
@@DrAditya2935 totally agree sir 🙏.
Dams literally robbed students in those days
True I have 1 lakh for it😢
Ek arvind Arora ko mein janta hu
Woh to gawar hai
Waiting for a person to score rank 1 in pg entrance without any coaching apps😅
Won’t happen simply because of FOMO.
To be very Frank - Adarsh Pal - the current INI topper - didn’t use them much.
Just the Qbank.
@@DrAditya2935 Thanks for the reply sir😊
sir...pls help...i am targetting neet 2023...what should i do...as u suggested i have usmle first aid 2022 as of now with me....what should i refer to for previous year questions? pls help sir...
Consider any online platform it's easy to do questions on a app make MCQ solving a habit
@@nishantyadav5838 thnks bro...for previous year questions is marrow enough?