@@rebeccaavoca9143 They kept the background track with Jonghyun, they sing over and along with his vocals. He is no longer with them but they have not canceled him, they continue to use his voice and sing (live) with him where possible.
Shawols filling in for jonghyun at 1:15 while key harmonises and when key sang jonghyun's parts at 2:30 and lifted his hands towards the sky were the parts that really got me
The fact that just the three of them can perform this songs shows how immensely talented each SHINee member is. 👍🏼👏🏻 But it also makes me feel a bit sad… 😢
i can't help but feel bittersweet seeing 3 of them on stage, but it's so comforting hearing all 5 in the background, and they're covering onew's and jonghyun's parts so well!!! i miss them 😭
@jackielyntamayo6890 Onew is sick and is resting. SM stated that due to Onew's health complications, he would be taking a temporary break to rest & recover, as a result will not participate in the concerts or SHINee's comeback or other activities. Let's pray he gets better soon 🙏
OMG.....so awesome to see this on stage again. I played this performance like crazy a lot back in the days. And I'm still crazy for the song and performance
무대구성 멋지네요 온유와 종현이가 보이는거 같아요 그러면서도 꽉찬구성이 진짜 많이 생각해서 짜신거 같아요 온유님 꼭 다시 건강해져서 같이 하는 모습 보고 싶네요. 저도 문득문득 종현이 생각이 나는데 멤버들은 더 힘들겠죠 같이 위로해주고 싶은데 그 마음이 가늠하기 어렵네요 그래도 잘 이겨내고 멋진 모습만 보여주는 샤이니 사랑합니다.
Я все думала, как же они смогут и хореографию и вокал вытянуть втроем. На заднем фоне слышно Джонхена - это конечно мощь, его голос, он будет здесь всегда. Отработать целую серию концертов. У ребят получилось,профессионалы, что тут скажешь. Желаю вам новых суперхитов, сияйте like the diamonds 💎 in the sky 🌌
I cant help but feel bitter sweet watching this. I feel so happy and proud watching the three of them pull off sherlock. At the same time, my heart is heavy watching only the three of them on stage. I can also see Taemin wearing out. I'm not sure how far along the concert sherlock was performed but you can see Taemin had a hard time keeping up and at some point, he just gave up on singing entirely to focus on dancing. But still, my heart feels like it might burst of pride at how well they did it!
2:45 jjong powerful voice helping them👑 they really shine as 5 members 👑
I’m trying to hear it I just hear Taemin
i knew it...i really heard jjong😍
its Taemin sounding like Jonghyun 🥺
Yes, that falsetto or whatever is called after the "buteo" part IS Jonghyun
I hear only Taemin, but he sounded like Jonghyun there
HOW ARE THEY SO GOOD AT FILLING IN??? ESPECIALLY TAEMIN!!
I swear I keep hearing Jinki and Jonghyun
I think at 2:45 it was actually jonghyuns voice
@@mxchi6707 so basically they just lip-sync?
@@rebeccaavoca9143 They kept the background track with Jonghyun, they sing over and along with his vocals. He is no longer with them but they have not canceled him, they continue to use his voice and sing (live) with him where possible.
@@rebeccaavoca9143they are not lip syncing I definitely hear Taemin. He is singing with the backtrack
@@rebeccaavoca9143 they are singing over an original backtrack with jjongs voice in it
That was so intense! They are amazing! Their energy was as if they were performing with 5 members! Same feeling, same intensity!
They are SO AMAZING!! It's so impressive how they just command this song even with 3 members! I love SHINee so much ❤❤❤❤❤
Amazing as always. Shinee
Shawols filling in for jonghyun at 1:15 while key harmonises and when key sang jonghyun's parts at 2:30 and lifted his hands towards the sky were the parts that really got me
Incredible ❤
Breaks my heart to see 3 Members, but They Killed It!!!!
Same :((
아련히 들리는 종현이 목소리가 너무도 먹먹한데 멤버들은 어떤 마음으로 이토록 최선이었을까. 정말 너희는 강인하다는걸 꼭 기억해주기를
1:25 Jjong's voice is so powerful even as backvocals
SHINee forever, waoooo
The fact that just the three of them can perform this songs shows how immensely talented each SHINee member is. 👍🏼👏🏻 But it also makes me feel a bit sad… 😢
Shinee members are such amazing artists ❤❤❤ They are so strong ❤ I'm proud of them ❤
Amazing. Can’t wait to watch it on Beyond Live Sunday 😍
i can't help but feel bittersweet seeing 3 of them on stage, but it's so comforting hearing all 5 in the background, and they're covering onew's and jonghyun's parts so well!!! i miss them 😭
@@hma429 he’s been having health issues I think
Amazing with only 3.just goes to show how talented they are.❤
Listening this in 2023 makes me so happy omg
Damn, so intense. I’m exhausted watching
SHINee's BACK!!!! AND THEY SLAYED IT 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Love you shinee member ❤❤❤
SHINee always will be 5 their are proof it its live im so happy for my SHINee and pray for onew he will be fine soon miss you Jjong 🥺💎💎
Hi can i ask what happen to onew why he’s not in concert?
@jackielyntamayo6890 Onew is sick and is resting. SM stated that due to Onew's health complications, he would be taking a temporary break to rest & recover, as a result will not participate in the concerts or SHINee's comeback or other activities. Let's pray he gets better soon 🙏
@@JApple97 awww , thankyou for aswering❤️
OMG this the original HARD. I freaking love it !! I’m screaming now. Shinee Shinee Shinee 💥
I LOVE YOU BOYS, ALWAYS AND FOREVER 🧡💛💚💙💜
They are amazing
Sherlock ahora... Me muero de emoción. Wow!! ❤👏🏼👏🏼✨🎶🥰🇦🇷
Mix emotion while watching
El debe estar muy feliz arriba también de seguro cantando con una hermosa sonrisa 😀❤️ kin angel
Still the best live singers!!! 5HINee 5orever!!!
Ot5 shining shinee are still there even they performed with 3 members only😍
How well they did with just three. Brilliant. Talent!!!!! Get well soon Onew. Fantastic Taemin, Key, Minho. 💙💙💙💙
영원하라 샤이니
Solo con 3 componentes y siguen siendo los Reyes del k-pop, grandes artistas. Forever SHINEE ❤❤
I just want to say thanks for the uploads the quality is excellent 👌🇬🇧
Oh my god Taemin absolutely ate, his hair though!!! And his vocals incredible! They all ate.
オンユが早く戻って来るのを祈りたい。SHINee凄すぎ😂
He did assure us he will be back and he’s taking the break now to preserve himself for the future. I hope it’s nothing serious.
Well done Shawols! Without missing a beat at the end of Key's "here we go" the famous fan chant is sung.👏
Thank you
ありがとう SHINee
いつまでも輝き続けてくれて
my favorite song! they deserve everything and beyond!
So proud of how far Taeminnie has come. He is an amazing singer.
OMG.....so awesome to see this on stage again. I played this performance like crazy a lot
back in the days. And I'm still crazy for the song and performance
하 김종현 너무 보고싶다 우리 샤이니들 너무 사랑해 온유도 얼른 쾌유하길 맴버 모두 건강하자 😢
The backtrack with Jinki and Jonghyun's voices 🤧😭😭😭
와... 미쳤다... 너무 완벽하고, 그때 그 시절이 떠올라 울컥하고 아련해지네.. 너무 멋있다 진짜
masterpiece
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤❤❤
TAEMINNIE AMAIZING
TOTALLY AGREE!!
taemin did them jjong expressions very well 🙈 !!
my fav Shinee song! the chorus is so cool :)
진짜 존나 멋있다. 연차를 막론하고 무대에 진심인게 너무나도 보임..
Shawols coming together to sing jonghyun’s part is so cute 🥰 at 2:41
Miss Onew , brilliant to see them together👏👏👏👏🥰🥰🥰
Los amo son los mejores. ONEW te extraño, pido a dios por tu vida, que te mejores, esperamos por ti. SHINEE FOREVER AND EVER.❤❤❤❤❤❤
They worked so hard😲🙌
Pls upload more of the concert videos ❤
I love them and i always gonna support them. In 2023, I still miss Jonghyun... Shinee forever
OS MELHORES DO MUNDOOOOO
🤩😍VEO CLARAMENTE A MIS 5 BRILLOSOS!!!!!!!! 🩵👉✨💎5HINee🥰♥️🩷💚💛💙
I love so much SHINee
Dear god that was amazing. Super difficult for just 3 and they freaking nail it so well! Proud of you guys! So so proud.
Lee Taemin
Lee Jinki
Kim Jonghyun
Kim Kibum
Choi Minho
Sherlock
bitnaneun
SHINee 💙💚
I love shinee so much you don’t understand Key doing Onews parts is so hawt 🫦
무대구성 멋지네요 온유와 종현이가 보이는거 같아요 그러면서도 꽉찬구성이 진짜 많이 생각해서 짜신거 같아요 온유님 꼭 다시 건강해져서 같이 하는 모습 보고 싶네요. 저도 문득문득 종현이 생각이 나는데 멤버들은 더 힘들겠죠 같이 위로해주고 싶은데 그 마음이 가늠하기 어렵네요 그래도 잘 이겨내고 멋진 모습만 보여주는 샤이니 사랑합니다.
2minkey outsing themselves
only shinee can do that !!
Bravo !!!!! 🏆🏆🏆
Я все думала, как же они смогут и хореографию и вокал вытянуть втроем. На заднем фоне слышно Джонхена - это конечно мощь, его голос, он будет здесь всегда. Отработать целую серию концертов. У ребят получилось,профессионалы, что тут скажешь. Желаю вам новых суперхитов, сияйте like the diamonds 💎 in the sky 🌌
샤이니 팬인게 자랑스럽다
Enjoy this song so much! I wish all four of them could be at Kcon this year in LA! It truly would be a treat for all us Shinee fans! ❤
Ok, I'm a perv. I caught Taemin's hard abs. Baby cheese been workin out...😅
I hope he wearing crop top in musicshows!
2:45 you can hear jhon hyun voice🥺🥺
I'm not crying🥺❤️
Well done 😭 😭
❤❤❤
두번째 콘 사이드좌석에서 봤는데 이렇게 앞에서 보니까 더 멋있네 하...앵콜 열어줘...ㅠㅠ
멤버 셋이 이게되는구나...
People who act surprise abt OKMT rock concert vocals are still living in 2010!
泰民,民豪,key,演唱會唱得很棒。⛪♥️♥️♥️🌹🌹🌹👑👑👑🐑🐑🐑🙏🙏🙏📹🤗😀🎵🎤🖱️🎧⌨️🖥️📱🎹🎸✌️👍👏。
不好意思我很久沒追韓團了,我方便問一下溫流人呢
@@sophin8693好像身體健康狀況不太好,瘦很多,所以沒參與近期活動😭
@@cozy6424 謝謝您的回覆!
Obrigada por postar o vídeo ❤
Só faltou Onew.... E Taemin voltou 😊😊
Thanks for sharing here x
Im having goosebumbs by just watching this fancam. What more If I got the chance to witness this on live?
Isso tá muito lindo aaaaaaa
SHINee is in the house!!! 💎 They are amazing 🔥 SHINee is back back back back back!! 😎
1:15 Shawols singing jonghyun's part ❤
感動😂
태민이형 춤 지리네여
OH I’M CURIOUS YEAH
Wow I can see Taemin's abs 🥰🥰🥰
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
I cant help but feel bitter sweet watching this. I feel so happy and proud watching the three of them pull off sherlock. At the same time, my heart is heavy watching only the three of them on stage. I can also see Taemin wearing out. I'm not sure how far along the concert sherlock was performed but you can see Taemin had a hard time keeping up and at some point, he just gave up on singing entirely to focus on dancing. But still, my heart feels like it might burst of pride at how well they did it!
SHINEE🌹
ARTES MUNDO. 🌏
KOREA DEL SUR
OMG this hair on taemin
Jonghyun's voice is in the background?
my friend, they do it all the time. don't you hear?
@@chedreo that's why i'm asking💀
@@Annie-ii3qu yeap, usually jonghyun's voice is playing in the background.
Ever heard of a backtrack?
2:45 i honestly cannot tell if the jjong or taemin (so proud of my boy)
Jonghyun's & Onew's vocals are in the background, it's a backtrack 😁
quality is impressive! what did u film on?
they scream for taemin and minho but not key?😃😃😃😃 didn’t expect less from korean fans
Taemin is my bias but I love Key he has worked hard.
The three of them are amazing. It must be so hard without Onew. When is he coming back.
1:16 is Shawol's covering Onew's line XD
Yo estuviera llorando, si lloré con View cuando la cantaron en Madrid
Soy um dorito forever.
이상하게 3명이서하니까 너무 마음이아프다...
Yeah …