Shadcn ui is truly the goat. Chakra was my favourite after I used Tailwind because it gave me that control over the components but Shadcn ui is simply overpowered 💯
Lol. I've used shadcn, radix, and mui. I've also tried out chakra and ant, but not in-depth. I quickly abandoned radix and shadcn because they just weren't full-featured enough, after using them I regretted leaving the true GOAT, which is mantine. Mantine is so far above these UI libraries is actually funny. I'm now back with mantine and the difference is night and day.
@@benotisanchez5583 Yeah you're right in your place. I totally forgot about Mantine lol. Even I rejected TW and Radix in the first place because Chakra and Mantine literally gave everything. Mantine is really good I agree and I'll blindly use it anytime. Shadcn ui gives kind of vercel vibes and the way it blends with tailwind makes me love it even more. So yeah if I had to pick any 2 frameworks that'd be Mantine or Shadcn ui. Thanks for reminding me about Mantine
@@benotisanchez5583 Comparing shadcn to Mantine is like comparing apples to oranges. One is a tailwind-based component collection with minimal abstraction, while the latter is a complete component framework that does everything with maximum abstraction and a design system of its own. There's no superior approach. Only preferences.
YES I am struggling to choose the right UI library for my next project or startup application. Unfortunately this video just made me struggle more. Thanks.
Cool breakdown, I really like Mantine UI with tailwind, because it has the ready made components and you can kinda bypass designing and still get shit done. Would love to see a video comparing the developer speed of making a full page with Mantine vs Shadcn..
@@jpjpjpjpjpjpjpjp Interesting! is that even possible?? i'm curious how you can combine mantine + tailwindcss - This is the first time i've heard of doing this and i'll give this a whirl
yeah we use mantine at work and i use it for personal projects, hands down my favourite ui to both use and setup, easy mode and especially now with 7.x it's even nicer to just use css modules (or scss) to force my team at work to create re-usable components
Copying and modifying source code for an enterprise project is generally not advisable. This approach effectively permits developers to create their own framework, which may include suboptimal decisions. Developers are paid to achieve business objectives, not to develop a new framework.
One thing I don't get is why we have to "choose" between tailwind and -- say -- CSS modules. Isn't it simply a 1-to-1 relationship between them? I'd imagine there's some tool that could re-write your project code to take all the tailwind and put it in a module (and vice-versa)
If you’re thinking of tree shaking then sure, it optimizes the bundle. But the library sources are still in your project directory and the IDEs still scan them to provide you with the correct type suggestions, autocompletions, etc. Therefore installing only necessary parts of the library might improve the performance during the development. Might be helpful for those who have slower machines or really large projects.
Ive used shadcn, radix and mui. Ive also tried out ant and chakra. Non of these libraries actually come close to the goat: which is Mantine. Mantine is so much more superior it's hard to even compare the rest.
Worked with this library for a project, one of ky best experiences with a ui library fast and efficient
there is also elastic ui, baseweb from uber, carbon from IBM, mantine, primereact and more....
Shadcn for the win!
Shadcn ui is truly the goat. Chakra was my favourite after I used Tailwind because it gave me that control over the components but Shadcn ui is simply overpowered 💯
Lol. I've used shadcn, radix, and mui. I've also tried out chakra and ant, but not in-depth. I quickly abandoned radix and shadcn because they just weren't full-featured enough, after using them I regretted leaving the true GOAT, which is mantine. Mantine is so far above these UI libraries is actually funny. I'm now back with mantine and the difference is night and day.
@@benotisanchez5583 Yeah you're right in your place. I totally forgot about Mantine lol. Even I rejected TW and Radix in the first place because Chakra and Mantine literally gave everything.
Mantine is really good I agree and I'll blindly use it anytime. Shadcn ui gives kind of vercel vibes and the way it blends with tailwind makes me love it even more.
So yeah if I had to pick any 2 frameworks that'd be Mantine or Shadcn ui. Thanks for reminding me about Mantine
@@benotisanchez5583 Comparing shadcn to Mantine is like comparing apples to oranges. One is a tailwind-based component collection with minimal abstraction, while the latter is a complete component framework that does everything with maximum abstraction and a design system of its own.
There's no superior approach. Only preferences.
YES I am struggling to choose the right UI library for my next project or startup application.
Unfortunately this video just made me struggle more.
Thanks.
Go for shadcn 🫡
Shadcnui is fine for most projects. If not refactor with another component library or make your own.
Go tailwind UI. Copy and paste.
Cool breakdown, I really like Mantine UI with tailwind, because it has the ready made components and you can kinda bypass designing and still get shit done. Would love to see a video comparing the developer speed of making a full page with Mantine vs Shadcn..
do you style the mantine components with tailwind? i haven’t figured the right way to integrate the two because mantine has its own theming system
I’ve used them both , and trust me shadcn is on another level
@@jpjpjpjpjpjpjpjpyea they do have there own styling system but u still can override it with tailwind
@@jpjpjpjpjpjpjpjp Interesting! is that even possible??
i'm curious how you can combine mantine + tailwindcss - This is the first time i've heard of doing this and i'll give this a whirl
yeah we use mantine at work and i use it for personal projects, hands down my favourite ui to both use and setup, easy mode and especially now with 7.x it's even nicer to just use css modules (or scss) to force my team at work to create re-usable components
Copying and modifying source code for an enterprise project is generally not advisable. This approach effectively permits developers to create their own framework, which may include suboptimal decisions. Developers are paid to achieve business objectives, not to develop a new framework.
to be fair, making your dashboard was probably pretty easy since it's nearly identical to their example dashboard.
Hi! Starting learning programming after a 20 year hiatus... Is radix ui a substitute for tailwind? Thanks!
One thing I don't get is why we have to "choose" between tailwind and -- say -- CSS modules. Isn't it simply a 1-to-1 relationship between them? I'd imagine there's some tool that could re-write your project code to take all the tailwind and put it in a module (and vice-versa)
If there’s not, make it yourself. 😂 it’s a good idea and might get used by lots of big companies.
MANTINE is brutally under-rated !!!!
I couldn't find anything about autocomplete for example. I usually use MUI and I have everything I need.
Next ui is the best for me 😂🤣
There is so much difference between daisyui and shadcn?
tailwind beast
Did u say mantine>>>shadcn
Mantine is the best one
it's all written in typescript? gosh feel for new gen devs... we need native UIs with webassembly access without js monstrous spaghetto
mantine is the best
at around 5:36: wait isn't there some kind of optimization when u are only using one tiny thing out of a giant library?
If you’re thinking of tree shaking then sure, it optimizes the bundle. But the library sources are still in your project directory and the IDEs still scan them to provide you with the correct type suggestions, autocompletions, etc.
Therefore installing only necessary parts of the library might improve the performance during the development. Might be helpful for those who have slower machines or really large projects.
People are seriously sleeping on Mantine
Big fan of that!
Ive used shadcn, radix and mui. Ive also tried out ant and chakra. Non of these libraries actually come close to the goat: which is Mantine. Mantine is so much more superior it's hard to even compare the rest.
Chakra is my favorite
more like chadcn/ui
I use Kendo React - I pay for this GOAT. Consider if your app makes money.
Op
It's called Svelte 😆
its not a objective tutorial
I hate tailwind and this project forces you to use it, so it's a no from me.
why? twc is awesome
Tailwind is goat
You’d rather spend hours making your own css for every project? Tailwind saves so much time and you can customize it to fit your nuances 😂
Adapt or give up
Why do you hate TW please elaborate
Why the light theme hate? Light theme is objectively superior
No
Factsxxxxx