Why China Has Cancelled “Sissy Men"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 лис 2024
- In 2021, China's broadcasting regulator issued a ban on 'niang pao' or 'sissy men' from appearing on TV and video streaming sites. The derogatory term is used to describe men with effeminate looks. Do these rules signal a return to more traditional notions of patriarchy, masculinity and even nationalism?Click here to SUBSCRIBE to VICE Asia: bit.ly/2LhqAR9
Connect with VICE Asia:
Check out our full video catalog: bit.ly/2P3Y0pv
Videos, daily editorial and more: vice.com/en_asia
More videos from the VICE network: viceasi...
Like VICE Asia on Facebook: viceasia
Follow VICE Asia on Twitter: / viceasia
Follow us on Instagram: / viceasia - Розваги
Masculinity has nothing to do with patriarchy. I celebrate my masculinity not by disrespecting nor by disregarding femininity.
Name one bad thing that came from patriarchy, I can only think of Greece and Islam.
@@micklyons8858 Dude! First of all, I did not ask that question. You are talking to yourself. Secondly, I do not support patriarchy. If you are a white supremist then FYI: Women could not vote in Switzerland until 31 October 1971. Read!! you uneducated.
@micklyons8858 countless talent wasted (how many Marie Curies do you think where forced to be baby machines instead of doing anything with their potential), sexism against men, high male suicide rates, economic stagnation (females are 50% of the workforce, lower that and you'll have problems)
Simp
@@cl3rk228 That's not the fault of some fictitious patriarchy.
In high school I talked with a Chinese boy from ESL class, he said doing housework will hurt a man’s masculinity, therefore he never helped around the house. So I asked what he’s gonna do in college. He said he’ll live with mom and let her do everything. Recently one of my Chinese classmates from college had a baby boy. He posted a picture of his baby picking toenails with a caption says “so proud of my masculine son because real man picks toenails with hands.” Most of us aren’t like that, but few of them do weird mental gymnastics to protect masculinity.
It's strange he thinks that's protecting masculinity. It's more protecting a stereotype.
Pure stereotyping some fools action on entire masculinity
Oh wow! Your story is weird. It made my head hurt. Help!
@@deathrodamus9608 true
I'm a Chinese myself living in China and I do think I have more Chinese male friends than you are, but I don't think any of my friends have the idea of living with their mothers and letting them do everything, I think your example is just very exaggerated.
In fact, Chinese men are more willing to take care of household chores in East Asian countries comparing with Japan and Korea.
Also a very important reason why the Chinese government banned “Sissy Men” is what this video doesn't mention: Japanese and Korean culture was actually influenced by the US, especially Japan,U.S. basically redesigned the Japanese education system after the WW2, and the de-masculinization of East Asia, which was also part of the Anglo-Saxon strategy.Most importantly, our per capita gdp is only in the middle of the world, while our country is at risk of war. Americans can do whatever they want,they can have lgbtq+10000000,but we have a lot of things to do to revive our country,we are just too bussy to care
China does limit this culture, but better safe than sorry.
China is not Japan and Korea, it is politically and culturally independent, the Chinese government have right of not acceptting this culture，right?we can develop our own culture, for example, men dressed as women which is often seen in Peking Opera.
In Chinese culture, men are required to study literature（文） and martial arts（武）, we have our own traditional cultural pursuits, why must men become 'Sissy'？
Masculinity doesn't mean you shouldn't work in the household. It's about taking care of things ahead of you fighting your everyday battle to be a better man . To think that the Chinese society isn't too open about this stuff is not what I was expecting to hear but hey everyone has there beliefs but fundamentals are always there
The Professor is just contradicting himself 😂 He opposes the Western influences in China and yet reveres and brings up Western movies as an example for his opinion
West itself has changed from few decades. Many countries use to admire west for its disciplined society,Virtues and Freedom.
@@harshmishra3214 when was the West, namely America, disciplined, virtuous and free? 😆
@@meco4068 before 1960 when hippie culture,sexual liberation and drugs were not made mainstream in society
@@harshmishra3214 So, when black people sat on the back of the bus and couldn't go to school with white kids 👍
@@harshmishra3214 It wasn't free for anyone who wasn't white. The millions of black people in America before 1960 probably didn't feel too free with the Jim Crow laws. There were not many virtues to be admired about a society that allowed black men to fight in its military and then unfairly prevented them from receiving the benefits of doing so.
All I can imagine is some top chinese official watching way tooo much Andrew Tate 💀
Andrew Tate is a legend
Andrew Tate is a dumbfuck but sissy men is a much bigger problem
XI jinping
@@rockade2408he is a SEX OFFENDER, HUMAN TRAFFICKER, MISOGYNIST.
that's good
They want masculine bc theyre gearing up for war is the most concerning part. Not about self expression or even women liking them. Tensions are high in asia rn.
I get that too, but how you dress and how you live your personal life has nothing to do with your ability to fight or participate in the war. Effeminate men can also go for military training and whatever training in preparation for war, but when they come home, they should be able to be whoever they want to be!
@@nomfundoblackbird wrong. It is against china' belief. Confucianism is the root of China's societal identity.
Because sissy men cannot fight for their country cause they are weak
@@nomfundoblackbird Shut up
@@nomfundoblackbird yeah you must be an idiot
I think of myself as traditional straight male and don't always agree with everything when it come to this community when it comes to children but I do believe America and the west is great because people have the right to be who they want. Everyone should have the right to dress or do whatever they want to themselves. It should never be controlled by the government.
No, simply just 99%+ ppl against this toxic culture here，gov must respond to this
It shouldn't be pushed on people who don't want anything to do with it like they are doing in America, especially on the children.
It's absolutely everywhere.
@jordan hess Yes, spot on. The feminine agenda is a fraud to reduce men to rubbles and loot from them. Wake up men!
What you want is shaped by society. There's nothing "natural" or "objective" about the Western lifestyle and the way people are here. It's just another culture.
To be fair right here in the US, some states are trying to refuse gay marriages and ban drag shows
They are going to be banning a hell of a lot of Chinese movies then, loads of male Chinese stars are almost as pretty as their female co-stars. Funny to see a bunch of old men get so upset, as a 53 year old guy I just have a little laugh then get on with my life.
It's not about looking pretty. Looking pretty is good for them .They said men in China needs to be brave and strong like Their soldiers.
Well the old men in government love to see big strong men I guess lol
@@sarithajagajith6568 They have a population of 1.4 Billion they have more than enough strong men to go around, its the same old same old, old generations complaining about the youth adopting some silly trend, once these trendy people grow up and become older some of them will be complaining about "youth of today".
Its all over blown fear mongering nonsense, Nationalist country's always worry about what other countries think of them and their purity, mean while the rest of the world is obliviously busy doing their own thing.
Ur gay asf
stfu u idiot, worry about your own country
So by eliminating femininity in men that means they will all be better than women? So China is saying women are less than? Also the old man talking about how the US still makes manly mainstream movies. Well we are slowly making mainstream LGBT+ movies and tv shows now too. Rupauls drag race, a show about men dressing as women for entertainment, has now been in the mainstream for a few years... i dont know, this older mans logic seems dated and will most likely die out with his generation in most countries.
Why would you assume encouraging men to be masculine has to mean that women are considered inferior? Men and women have important but different roles to play in society. China recognizes and values that, unlike the US.
They don’t consider men are better than women, but they have different roles to play different responsibilities to take. It’s better for two genders to do things they’re good at. Most time, men are better at being soldiers and women are better to taking care of children. It’s acceptable to have some exceptions but for the majority it’s good for the stability and sustainability of a society.
Where tf did you get better than women from? That masculinity is better than femininity? Well yeah, that's only the case for MEN, no one's talking about women here lmao. In fact we strongly respect femininity in WOMEN, not in men, and the opposite is true for masculinity to, although we do praise a few certain masculine traits in a woman if she finds herself in a situation where she absolutely had to fend for herself in order to survive, but generally we will choose an overall feminine woman over an overall masculine one any day.
@@letisriva8581 Men are better at taking care of children, they should stay at home
Ofcourse , chinese society sees women as second class citizens,and treat men who look like them even worse.
Western societies want to be open societies, they allow this lifestyle to be promoted in culture, media, and entertainment. Good on them, let's see how their civilization turns out in the long run. Chinese society allows for these lifestyles to exist as individuals choices, but they see great danger in allowing such people to have influence in media, culture, and entertainment. The Chinese don't want their impressionable youths to be influenced by such people. Chinese people always have a big picture/long term view of their civilization.
There is an old saying that goes "If you tolerate everything, you stand for nothing". Westerners abandoned Christianity and spirituality and started adopting liberalism and debauchery. The West now lacks morality, decency, accountability, and competence. It is now being reflected in their politics, institutions, and government. Westerners have become extremely petty, fighting over gender issues and LGBT rights, instead of focusing on making their nations stronger. Chinese people are not blind, many of their elites got educated in the West and see what's happening in the West. They are not impressed by the West, most are appalled by the current state of the West and reject all these stupid ideas from the West. This is the primary reason why for the last 40 years, the West has been stagnant and China has been rising.
Oh really. as chinese i only see my own race become more and more NPC like, with money only their hobby and god. They will talk all the think out of the box bullshit but yet when you talk with them, it seems they have very narrow subject with only concern about money
Chinese history is rife with instability.
@@EveryTimeV2 Chinese history is far more stable than any other civilization in History. The Chinese will have periods of political instability but their civilization will never collapse. Most of their history is spent as rich, powerful, and stable.
The West will create a whole new civilization and then burn it down completely, then go through thousands of years of turmoil. When the Roman Empire collapsed, the West went through a thousand years of darkness call the Dark Ages. The Roman language (Latin) was no longer spoken by the people, Greco-Roman history and philosophy was lost for entire generations. If not for the Arabs and Muslims keeping a record of Greco-Roman history and literature nobody would know who Socrates was or who Plato was.
You won't see Chinese civilization go through something that traumatic. Their civilization will never collapse, their language, their bloodline, their heritage, their history, their culture, and their way of thinking has remained throughout history.
''The Chinese don't want their impressionable youths to be influenced by such people''
see this is why education is so important.
because YOU CAN'T INFLUENCE PEOPLE THIS WAY.
you think because there are ''sissy man'' on the TV children would also turn into them?
but that isn't how personality works, or gender identity.
its like saying ''seeing gay man, makes gay man''
but that just isn't how sexuality and gender identity functions.
YOU CAN'T CHANGE PEOPLE THEIR SEXUALITY AND GENDER IDENTITY.
they are BORN with it, no mater what anti gay camp, no matter what upbringing..
NOTHING you do can change how someone's brain is wired from birth.
yes westerners have abandoned Christianity and thank god they have. (ecksdee pun)
religion is a toxic cesspit that brings nothing but pain and suffering.
the only reason it is still here is because of indoctrination and lack of education.
it isn't odd that Atheism in a country rises when its education become better.
as people are more intelligent and have more answers to questions that they would have used religion to answer instead of actual facts and knowledge.
ps: you think China is on the rise?
HAHAHAHA
with what is it on the rise?
painting their hills and fields green with paint?
killing their people because of the ''as fast and cheap as possible'' mentality?
do you think shoving all problems onto the next person is a sign of progress?
do you think stapling leaves to trees is a sign of progress?
collapsing roads? entire apartment complexes coming down because their walls are made of beer bottles?
no individual rights, no freedom, no freedom from religion, no freedom of the press?
you think that is progress?
banning EVERYTHING that offends you is definitely a sign of ''progression'' right?
IMAGINE BANNING WHINNIE THE POO BECAUSE YOUR EGO IS SO SMALL YOU CAN'T EVEN TAKE A JOKE! XD
''progression man'' the Uyghurs definitely agree in their labor camps!
their ''covid'' policy is definitely not something to control their people with is is definitely still there because of covid right?.. oh wait.........
you sound like you have NO IDEA how fucked the country actually is..........
don't you think that having Gender and LGBT+ discussions is a sign of progression?
at least we can hold those discussions without being dumped into a labor camp?
don't you think that it i a privilege to discuss those things in the west?
wanna know why we can discuss them?
because other pressing matters have already been resolved.
Tienanmen square was also ''very progressive'' man sooo wow!
so progressive to shoot your next generation to shit because they want ''freedom''
here is your ''on the rise'' country.
ua-cam.com/video/CdVFIFnDcrU/v-deo.html
THE CHINESE CENSORSHIP SONG
ua-cam.com/video/1Ic4CbHANQk/v-deo.html
How to kick chinese from csgo servers
ua-cam.com/video/PWXsiOVeTFE/v-deo.html
大陸封殺：陽光開朗孔乙己 MV, Blocked in mainland China: Sunny and cheerful Kong Yiji MV
lyrics:
In my tattered scholar’s gown, I head to the Lu Village pub
Barman! Warm two bowls of liquor, here’s nine coppers for some grub
Spouting scholarly babble in my ragged gown, I roll into the pub
Barman! Warm two bowls of liquor, here’s nine coppers for some grub
They mock my erudition, my face is turning red
You dare impugn my honor? I’ll go on drinking and butting heads
Rickshaw Boy didn’t work hard enough, that’s why he’s dead
Everything Lu Xun wrote was stuff that shouldn’t be said
Chen Sheng and Wu Guang had it rough because they wouldn’t work for their bread
Accusing eyes turn to me and ask: “What’s gotten into your head?”
I glance down at my gown and say I’m-
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
The Man has the nerve to write, “It’s time to knuckle under, see?”
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
I’d rather slack off than let you exploit me
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
You drive a Lamborghini, yet laugh and call me lazy
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
This corrupt society’s got fuck-all to do with me!
I keep my face clean, but my pockets are always empty
So I throw on my gown and write copy for the powers that be
I thought work would be a breeze, but it’s 996: six days a week, twelve hours a day
When I have the nerve to “maliciously” ask for my pay, the cops drag my hungry ass away
How is there no labor law in this evil society?
Why’s it so easy for the elites to trample on our dignity?
The tales no one dares to tell are beyond belief
The other patrons stare and ask, “How come you aren’t scared?”
I laugh and say it’s because I’m-
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
The weakest branch, I stopped fighting back long ago
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
Time weathered my edges, now I’ve only got scars to show
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
Optimism’s my armor, but behind the mask the tears flow
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
You ask if I’m happy, but all I want to do is curse
The tavern starts buzzing when I finish my verse
What does all their negativity and mockery have to do with me?
I went to school to help China rise, not to be some delivery guy
Hearing this, everybody smirks
Except for that one stupid jerk
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
I tear through this crumbling wall, looking for justice and light
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
We all need the applause, whether it’s criticism or praise
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
In the censored comment section, how many embers of dissent still blaze?
Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji, Sunny and Cheerful Kong Yiji
I’d hoped to be a Zhuge Liang, instead they’ll take me out like Shang Yang
but lets just Censor these things right?
who the f cares about freedom, personal opinions, human rights, freedom of the press, freedom to decline, personal religious persecution into labor camps.
taking care of the environment, taking care of their next generation, taking care of the elderly.
i mean.. we ARE talking about a country that gave 80% of their low income elderly population HIV/AIDS because they asked them to donate blood using the same needle with everyone. (so educated WOW!)
this was 40 years ago by the way in the 80's.
want me to go on?
i mean i can write full pages of how the Chinese are being oppressed?
i can go on for hours and still not mention everything..........................................................
''The West now lacks morality, decency, accountability, and competence''
funny you mention these things..
lack of morality by persecuting people based on their religion or background? CHECK!
decency, ever seen the Chinese at a all you can eat buffet? yeah....... CHECK! (almost like they have been starving for ages before)
accountability **************************************
Why are there no CC's?
I think featuring a trans woman here unnecessarily diverts this documentary from the topic of discussion. Like in J-POP and K-pop, the so-called "sissified" men are essentially straight men that women swoon over. The issue of anti-trans or anti-LGBT is a totally separate topic that belongs in another video. Japan and Korea are still very much homophobic even with the "sissified" men being praised and widely accepted.
I support LGBT, but I'm also against the recent rise of popularity of eliminated men. I don't expect trans to be masculine, but I expect men to be.
Yes totally agree, this piece is detracting from this social phenomenon and trying to make this about identity and gender politics. I think it's more complex then that, and that this cancellation is more about geopolitics than gender politics or China trying to prevent unchecked soft power (sissified male celebrities and influencers) from detracting from its hard power (military might) as it's trying to literally and figuratively flex it's striking capabilities over Taiwan and the US.
The so-called "sissified" men are *NOT* straight men. Only a small minority of them are. Most of them are queer people who are forced to not be open about their orientation/gender identity and keep it as a secret. You probably know it better than me what kind of oppression/discrimination lgbtq kpop idols face after they come out. This is pretty much an lgbtq issue, this "canceling sissy men" will harm the lgbtq community(especially, gay men and even trans women since they're seen as "men" in the eyes of transphobes) more than anyone else and it'll barely affect straight men.
@@Zejva I'm not sure. In the context of East and Southeast Asia, I think now there's actually an expectation if not a pressure for men to beautify themselves because that's what women idolise. Otherwise, they're not handsome enough or are plain boring. I live in Thailand which is extremely open when it comes to LBGTs, so gay/ trans men can straight out be openly gay/ openly trans. Noone cares. Yet, many straight men are these so-called sissified men, because when you look at commercials and TV shows, all the supposedly handsome men look that way. The fact that women swoon over these men (and many certainly do) is all the more reasons for men especially young men to try to imitate. Even if the celebs themselves are not straight. People don't know that. They just know that it's what women or the "society" find handsome.
Men from all the K-POP bands are essentially products that have been produced that way by their companies regardless of their own opinions, so I don't think whatever they actually are would manage to make its way to the public without their companies' approval.
It could have been clearer had this video not mixed in the two groups. Many gay men from China are not a part of this subculture at all. I could be wrong though. Maybe these men are queers in China. It's also possible that those older men in power cannot distinguish between the two themselves and see this as a way to curb LGBT.
One comment on the video pointed out that this could actually be the political issue of limiting foreign influence/ soft power in China. I think it's a plausible theory. Last year China also shut down a Japanese festival that was held by local businesses to sell Japanese and Japanese theme products.
This fool dont nkow wath they is
@@fahmraktnul4279 I don't know about that :/
I think the main reason the government is banning/canceling "sissy" men is because they view their existence as "gay propaganda" and that they're promoting homosexuality. Russia, Turkey and some other countries has done something similar. For example, Russia canceled bts concert because they consider it as "lgbt propaganda" even though none of the bts members openly identify as queer(as far as I know).
I also think being "sissy" is about how you act more than how you dress. For example, most kpop idols do look and 'dress' feminine but most of them definitely do not act feminine. They just behave like average basic cishet men. So, I don't really see them as "sissy/feminine" at all. They're barely any different than the guys in the west, Middle East in my eyes. Every region has its own beauty standards and men looking feminine might be the beauty standard in East Asian countries which is completely okay. I think I have a different understanding of the word "sissy" which is why your comment confused me.
Also, I dont think Thailand and china is comparable to each other in terms of lgbt acceptance, so I'm not sure if that was a good example. I believe this banning "sissy men" will harm lgbt community, especially trans women, more than it'll harm straight men. Because it is a choice for those cishet men to dress feminine mainly because girls are into that, they can stop it whenever they want. However, it isn't a choice for trans women(I'm sure they're also labelled as "sissy men" in the eyes of conservative people)
Good question. Why do men hate sissy men? Doesn’t the fact that these men exist make you by default more masculine? Less competition on the datingmarket for women. Why is that a bad thing?
i think the discussion is not about dating, its about the more young men become feminine, then more and more men will get influenced and in that way china as a whole can get feminized and then there will be no physical strength left and china will become vulnerable to outside threat. i think they are thinking 60 to 80 years ahead
We don't want other men's lives destroyed
They only bother men who are insecure in their own masculinity and feel the need to take it out on others.
@@abishieksamlin5211 destroyed by what exactly?
@@esoekidjo unnatural ideas makes men weak and the next generation weaker
The U.S doesn't support "sissymen" we support your right to choose for yourself, and if your rights begin to infringe on someone else's that's when it becomes problematic.
Lmao yes that’s why they queer the kids in the school system; everyone is ‘choosing for themselves’ no cultural manipulation at all here lol
Freedom is not necessary it may be harmful
@@Grace17893 stay salty fascist
U.S. promotes sissy behavior like never before. There is an agenda behind it, a really gay one #Pause
I’m ok with LGBTQ 🏳️🌈 but when the bathrooms 🚽 started being labeled as a Triangle instead of Men / Women, I started disliking LGBTQ. Why do I have to share a bathroom with men because of the minority???
Very good. Not allowing this Western bs
Free TOP G
Obviously you don’t know anything about Chinese/Asian culture 😂 feminine men have been looked highly upon in China since the arrival of Buddhism and up until the 18th century
there's a small translation error at 11:37 -- he says he does NOT think they are referring to him
Honestly I wish they would ban effeminate men imagery in the us media too.
lmao I saw Nine Percent members then Lu in the first few seconds of the vid, it's not their fault that some of them were born pretty or with what they claim as 'feminine' look also we are in 2023 now 😭
same, like everyone will receive love even if they are hairy macho or cute beautiful, there is people for every taste, they are just canceling them because the older ones are feeling out of the trend
No, they are not necessarily pretty. It's subjective. What matters is what their look will bring to society, will it be useful or will it waste resources or even harm society?
Chinese government wants to beat out this understanding of being pretty
China Government loves Lao Bao fashion, exposed beer belly, chain smoker, bad teeth. They think Mao was manly. 😂😂
Does this mean that the Chinese government will have to define what they mean by "sissy men"? And then enforce that definition through policy?
If you are a guy and wears make ups, you are probably a “Sissy men” 😂
No, this is like a lot of Chinese policy, using undefined terms. The regulator will pick up some examples to ban or punish, then it's up to the platform and individual to interpret the rest. This will create a chilling effect.
@@evangle1234 That's not just Chinese, it's in the west too. Look at how dirty cops love words like "obstruction", "resisting", and "disorderly" as vaguely-defined ambiguous "crimes" that they can wave around like magic-spells to falsely-arrest anybody for any reason. 😒
its easy to define sissy men. colorful makeup? colored lipgloss? sissymen
Chinese law is extremely vague done to give benefit of doubt to its enforcers. They don't need definitions for things.
the issue isn't 'sissy men'. the issue is that in china you have a tyrant of a government that sees fit to impose it's will on all forms of personal creative expression
mate US suck cock so much
Your government officials enforce political correctness and rainbows LGBT too
Sissy men is also an Issue
@@sagarjadhav6568 compared to European and Middle Eastern men all Asians including Indians look like sissies. And ugly too. So I don't know why you ppl make such a fuss.
@Sagar Jadhav How is it an issue? And could you define what you mean by "sissy men"?
Bruhhhh *Twitter* would erupt if they learn about this
Weak men create hard times.
Based, China sees the truth
Very good work .
Good for them
get a life lmao 💀💀
To be fair, China's history had been rife with troubled periods under soft, effeminate leadership e.g. late Song Dynasty, Qing Dynasty and illustrious rises under hard, stern-faced leaders e.g Tang Dynasty, Yuan Dynasty (my fav).
With the threat of war looming, they'll want hard men (and women) in all their essential services so a soft image would be the last thing they'll want to promote.
It's good to see China tackling this problem. Meanwhile the west completely allows this to be rampant.
Yes we need to be more like China and Russia and other strict religious countrys, the government should lock these people up and control such unlawful behavior.
Trump 2024
Idiot...
All it took was was for China to ban femboys to get all the American conservatives salivating over the CCP.
Yup when the roman empire fell the men in roman society became feminine and dressed like women towards the end. Makes perfect sense
Finally someone who’s not brainwashed. Very based.
So they ban "sissy men" but not the dog meat trade or the exploitation of workers. Tf is going on over there..
Or the encampment of uyigurs and everyone not han chinese
Watch this get deleted. Worthless dictators.
They are not the u.s let them do as they please, we don't control the world
@@jessedukelacrosse6470 I am not American so no and if we all ignored the problem nothing would get done 🙂
Mind your own country's problems first lmao
@@kys3130 No how about China stop being dicks arresting and killing there protesters or people that believe in freedom you sad guy
But Pretty Boy Look still have a selling point there
The subtitles are too small to read. Please do voiceovers for foreign languages.
Honestly...I think America could at least follow this policy that China is trying. Everything else no, that tyrannical government is terrible.
Why though? I thought America was about freedom?
Lol… have you been asleep under some rock? Have you not seen how tyrannical our government is?
The cultural marxism destroying America came from China. The plan is to destroy western values and it's working so China can become the superpower.
I'm actually jealous. USA needs this.
You like government control?
@@Andrew-ob5ij he's a big fan of the social credit system too.
@@Andrew-ob5ij the alternative is LGBTQ infiltrating schools and converting children. They even made a song about it. 🤢🤡
@@neildeep Not even a Christian but you Atheist idiots will crash civilization with your myopic perspectives. Rather Trump than slow Joe.
@@GearZNet converting children 🤣, how fragile is sexuality that you think you can just change a persons like that
This should be done here. Look what is happening in our country. As always, China continues to remain one step ahead when it comes to sanity.
ah yes less freedom! lets be more like that autocratic country that dictates what everyone can be and do, sounds "sane" to me.... no thanks
Did you just say a dictator ship, it is one step ahead of the rest of the world in sanity? A government that controls it’s peoples every movement and literally sends people to the modern equivalent to concentration camps. A country that is right now ethnically cleansing another group because of their religious and ethnic background.
LOL China-bots pretending to be westerners on the loose. 😂
@@I.____.....__...__ Sure I am. Typical lefty reply. I must be a bot if I don’t agree with your degenerate, mentally ill ways.
Enjoy your few points of increased social score promoting your tyrant hate filled garbage. They'll change you next dumb fuck.
Good on China for protecting their values as a nation.
Lol clearly you don’t know anything about the history of China. Feminine qualities in men were present between the arrival of Buddhism and the 18th century.
While they are canceling sissy men why not they cancel tomboy gals....double standards at its finest
As the xi loves seeing big strong men on tv I think lol
Communists love taking peoples rights away, just like conservatives in the US
Maybe in this cold war-ish global environment the top leaders want to have as much masculinity as possible in order to protect the country
@@hepsima Masculinity doesn't protect countries, a multi-billion dollar military does.
If and when tomboy become celebrated all over the media and become the mainstream, maybe.
Interesting to see how some old people think
interesting how a fark boi replies on youtube
@@rockade2408 that's right
Not just some though because here in Asia, it's the majority of them.
Old people built the world you live in now. What is your contribution? Don't say emotional support.
@@bythemoon3437 let's be honest, with the conservative propaganda in the west, it's a majority of old people in America too.
Listen men, what you put on the outside cannot define who you are. You can be weak looking or soft looking but actually be strong and wear makeup, grow long hair and still be brave, strong or whatever it is considered as "masculine". Have both sides. Not just one. Be soft , caring, polite, understanding along with being tough, brave and strong.
Good to talk about the positives of masculinity, as there both positives and negatives to it
-Average low IQ matriarch promoter.
Men, don't listen to this Bitch
what i learned is that don't believe what women say believe what they do
Now imagine your father acting feminine but strong
Damn these comments ain’t it.
Live and let live. Why tf do u care how someone else who u don’t know personally looks and acts????
Speaks more about these guys insecurities than the "femboys“
Amazing. This is exactly how I feel about it. Thanks for sharing
They're beautiful and old men just tilting at them insecurely.
First they came for the twinks… 😔
And i did nothing..
@@8pija22 Shut up nonce.
@@micklyons8858 Don't project onto me, you creeper
twink =/= sissy
@@8pija22 Shut up, you got caught out talking about twinks, so don't try to turn the fact that you are nonce looking for twinks back onto me, you sick freak. You know what you are, you sick pedo.
that prof is right about some things and wrong about others. westerners cant fathom why, in china, or other clan/kinship based family systems, 'if the family dies, so does the nation.' the family system in china&countries in the middle east have been patrilineal &communitarian for centuries. the west is not entirely responsible for sk/japan's differences though. sk and japan have historically featured patrilineal stem families (w/ primogeniture) & might be more receptive therefore to western family systems. shit like lgbtq movements, sissy men, feminism is NOT a question of moral progress. it is a question of clashing family systems. of course the west would see these movements as 'progressive,' as it fits easily under the assumption that egalitarianism is inevitable, and b/c the anglosphere never developed past the nuclear family. but where does the west derive its the authority to export THEIR moral and family system? how tf is this different from the forced religious conversions and 'civilizing the brutes' rhetoric from the imperialist era? don't forget that chinese (and vietnamese, for that matter) commies are FIRST anti-imperialist and SECOND marxist (IMO)
In the west everyone wants freedom for all, just because you believe don’t agree with it you can take peoples freedoms away, right?
Do you really think China cares about "family systems" when it limited families to one child each and now have to kidnap women from other countries + bribe people to reproduce? You're delusional.
Or you could just let people be themselves. Nobody is forcing *you* to be a "sissy man", so why force someone else *not* to be one?
Westerners have a habit of forcing their ideas on others, this rainbow flag stuff is no exception. "Let me tell you about your country" is their motto.
Now the west is being destroyed by Marxism that infiltrated academia where did that come from if not China?
holy shit china is actually based
"While in the us and europe their culture doesn't promote sissy men" reaaaaally???
5:33 "would there be anyone to go to the battlefield?" this sums it up. They want to conquer the world or keep dreaming about it and you can't do it with kind and nice persons that just wanna live and let live. A country with modern technologies and weapons that thinks that only cis-women are suppose to be sensitive is terrifying.
Even in the U.S you find pushback like this against effeminate men, and it's rather funny, because at the end of the day, anyone can go to a battlefield..
Thats why peaceful progressive countries like the USA have more than 50% trans troops comitting suicide while also being so peaceful that they only started 30+ illegal invasions of sovereign countries in the past 80 years. But china wants to conquer the world, sure. What a clown lol
Or, they want to be able to defend their country and know that you can't do that with a bunch of ladyboys
It is different with the case in the u.s, is most often the religious rights,and pary tryingvto use them to get votes,cos even among those so called religious rights,some are gay men and women in secret, it is complicated with such group in America,and they are milked for by republican party for their vote,not that they are doing it cos gay men and women are not man enough ,cos you have loads of guys and Lesbians in the U.S military,doing their job,by serving their nation.
Your imagination
Whoa that means Vice would out of employees.
Idiot...
lol
Comment makes no sense.
kek
Based
Based China
Wasn't also there a problem where when they ban females advertising for fashion clothing and so every business had men to do it instead? Very contradicting lol
If only the rest of the world banned these goddamn things
Real men eat pussy
*well done china*
ccp bot
@@Gyarukittenz Fed
@@Gyarukittenz cia bot
@@Xasan404 C.I.A = cum in my a*s
Free TOP G
I find it hilarious. Chinese culture? Manly Chinese men? Where are they?
Do you study history? Do you know Confucius? China is a Confucian country. China is the country with the most heritage in the world. Many castles, palaces, and roads in China have existed for more than 2,000 years. China invented paper, compass, guns, gunpowder, fireworks, sunglasses, makeup, nail polish, rice, noodles, kites. And who invented them? They are Chinese men. Without Chinese men, there would be no Chinese culture. How much heritage does your country have?
You are ignorant Apollo, go back to cleaning toilets at Mc Donalds.
@user-rj9rv8qj9z Obviously they don't have any 😢
@@Yangpeiling-de-zhangfuwell my country England goes back quite a few thousand years ,once had a global empire and we didn't have a century of humiliation to give us a huge chip on the shoulder that yours seems to have.
@@Yangpeiling-de-zhangfu China is old but isn't the oldest heritage. Persians and Egyptians are older. Greeks are about the same age. Europeans have invented more than any group too by far. Even the computer or cell phone you used for that message was first invented by a person of Euro heritage.
About time!
@Neil Deep who are those🤣
Why don't they be a man and say they're homophobic. They've being sissified themselves
No sisification doesn't always lead to being gay, it usually leads to being trans. Very very different things. Gay is a sexuality, Trans is an identity crisis.
I don't speak the Twitter language.
Also they're not banning this perse, they're banning not selling your time more efficiently.
That's fucked up, don't you think? Why should the government control how "productive" I am in my private life? Unless...you don't think people should have private lives and should exist solely to work 🤔
@@laneatkinson6441 people have a duty to their country to make it as prosperous as possible
@Meteor194 1.) Says who? 2.) Why should I listen to that person? 3.) Do you think the "prosperity" of a country is more valuable than the rights of its citizens to have a life aside from working?
@@laneatkinson6441 To be fair, it is the prosperity that others build that allows people like you and I and other citizens to indulge in other pursuits. So it isn't a matter of "says who", or "why should I listen to that person". Any self-respecting individual with morals and values such as reciprocity and a Chinese phrase "饮水思源" aka knowing where the water you drink comes from and appreciating it, will put in the effort to better themselves, physically (fitness), mentally (resilience), and accomplishments (achievements in any field whether work or sports etc.) and in doing so bring more prosperity to the country. The problem sometimes with the idea of so called "sissy men" like in Japan and Korea is that it fetishizes this thin, weak, and unhealthy look. Recently Korean idols have been going to the gym and you can see NinePercent Idols of China actually having muscles and abs, I think that is admirable.
@@sw36jl How someone dresses or acts in their private life has no bearing on water quality. Try harder.
Finally a heart warming story out of China💯🙏🏾
Yes, it’s good to actually see China doing something correct.
@@carlhash6540 get your fat *ss of the internet and touch some grass. you're weird
be gone, homer fudd.
I dont know what others mean by saying men aren't what they used to be anymore... Do u guys know about the sacred band of thebes from Greece? They were an elite unit conprised of 150 male pairs/lovers that makes 300 men for that unit. This happend around 4th century BC
Ancient Greeks and Romans were _super_ gay, it's all over their pottery and statues and everything else. It was even policy that's it's cool to be a top. 🤷 Only bottoms got flack (read shafted 😉).
Free TOP G
@@I.____.....__...__ the gay term shouldnt be synonyms with those overatted sexual intents. We need to stop this. Its not good and healthy. " Super gay ". This is irratating and saddening. To be frank, and honestly, some people and the so called related norms, should be adjusting their impure morality values by now, and so like haste.
It harmly boost and enhance the "gay people are mostly and or totally perverted in anyways" type of stereotypes. Like sometimes, peoples be like, can't think, thought, feel or even felt that, gay people have a feeling of romantic that, have a real sense of love too. Pure loyalty and good modesty of innocence's. You know, without any dirty and more disgustings-ly, of these and those sort of, kind like certain thoughts of / and pattern.
Its tiring and depressing mixed with anxiety, on to even have the feeling of need to explain the actual that, to other "misunderstand" people that apparently, "gay ≠ *sexual related things and issues, & whatsoever"
Gay≠sissy
This is why China will be #1 superpower
On one hand it's important to preserve traditional gender roles and aesthetics, on the other hand, I don't like governments telling creatives what they can and can't publish.
Gender roles can have negative impact too. Especially for women. Haven't you studied politics and history? Haven't you heard about woman's issues in the society. Men already have empowering social norms but women are demoralised which is bad.
If gender roles are biological and innate, why does the government have to enforce them? It's almost as if they're *gasp* made up to control people 🤫
@@sarithajagajith6568 what does men have that women don't?
@laneatkinson6441 lol? In the last few decades, more and more people have been born with hormone disorders which affects their gender expression.
@sarithajagajith6568 duh, do you think I'm an idiot? Obviously there's some negative traditional gender traits that should be forgotten.
Men, women, LGBTQ, and others... Accept everyone and just funk yourself.
Lol, this is so funny. The thinking is very and certainly archaic. Quite tiring going on this kind of cycle again and again. Not just in China tho, though it's also here in our country it's all over. On repeat.
Can't help it. They're still even ours is quite traditional. Exhausting.
What is that, the simple, logical reality of the difference between men and women that we are ignoring and entertaining? 🤔
It is better for a society that accommodates everyone, without going backwards, time had changed,if we keep bringing up the way we live in the past to the way we are living in the present, there will be clashes like we are seeing now.The way the chinese thinks doesn't belong to this time and zgae that puts them at odds with the rest of the world.
I love Americans way when it comes to this type of isdues, no matter what.
China saved itself from this cancer... Kudos to china..
Sissy men have always existed in Chinese culture. They appear throughout history, sometimes in very powerful roles.
those are eunuch with no testicle
If by sissy men in powerful roles you mean the eunuchs who collapsed dynasties and weakened the nation, then that should be proof enough why China wants to stamp out such degeneracy.
@@yip2454 no always
Sissy men were invented by Americans. and cannot represent a nation
jeez, the mental hoops to connect sissy men to being the US fault....bravo sir.
Which country has the most degenerate culture, well, it's the US, which hosts Twitter, TikTok, Tumblr, etc.
@@iac92lol tiktok literally came out of China ,it's owned by Byte dance which is a Chinese company and that's why Congress in USA is actually trying to ban it ,really should be better informed before commenting
@@anonymiss495 What does that have to do with my reply?
Thank you China !
USA promotes Boybands... nsync back street boys etc... than you have "scene emo" than you have micheal jackson and Prince... this guy saying US only promotes masculine.. lol dont make me laugh...
Now USA is promoting trans lol.
Meanwhile, we have a sissy man named Richard holding the rank of General.
russian bot
@@8pija22 The only one who sounds like a bot is you. You sound as if you are purely stifled of any real creativity so all you can afford to do is name call. If you aren't a bot I don't know what else you could possibly be, as you certainly aren't human. If you were a human being you would have known how to behave like one, you certainly aren't acting like a human being. If there is any humanity left inside you then you ought to feel deeply ashamed.
@@micklyons8858 Lol really got you going huh? Fragile masculinity at its finest.
@@8pija22 The only one whose masculinity is fragile is yours, it's clear that you feel threatened by masculine men, you are a weak man who feels the need to lash out behind a screen at other men. The fact that you feel the need to attack another man's masculinity probably means you suffer from a lack of manhood. My masculinity is an innate part of me, something that you clearly do not possess, you mustn't assume that a masculine man like me is somehow fragile.
@@micklyons8858 Nah you probably don't even lift
There's something a lot more sinister about the feminization of males online. It's not just about men being able to feminize themselves. It's also a really weird and slightly disturbing fetish when it comes to strong addiction in pornorgraphy. I've seen this kind of thing not only tear families apart, but its currently mentally destroying men many men. Not all, but a good percentage of them.
I think it's okay for men to have a healthy balance of feminine and masculine traits, the way a traditional gentlemen portrays himself, but once cross dressing comes in to play it can be a gateway to more detrimental aspects depending on the person.
I don't think it's necessarily bad that China is censoring these kind of videos, seeing how lost America is right now with their "woke" movements specifically because they want to be inclusive. Not everything is always acceptable just because people's feelings come into play. I understand that people express themselves differently, but these kinds of acts including a majority of other unconventional acts are exactly what lead to weaker societies.
How is the west being inclusive? It's still not acceptable to be a feminine male in the USA or a western country that is why there is a push for feminine men to transition into women. Conservative and religious society has done so much damage by making these things illegal in the past and yet hasn't learnt from the past and wants to continue destroying lives.
yeah
The old Asian gentleman in the beginning is 100% correct, be soft and gay all you want but stop allowing these men to be idolised or masculinity will fail to exist
the fact that they're being idolized by many women no less means that women don't value men who are super masculine oppressive brutes. Women value men who are soft, kind and won't abuse them. This is what masculine men fail to understand that women like feminine or kind, gentle men who will respect them.
3:40 He has good points about the larger socioeconomic effects of feminization
Hard time creates strong men,strong men create good times, good time creates weak men ,weak men creates hard times..
7:00 unlike other countries where there is freedom.
Dude go to iran or Pakistan and live there for a while you live in a developed country and u still find something to complain about.go to countries in Africa where u have that freedom but other things in ur life will be missing
Ok, when the Professor said western media does not promote feminine men as rolemodels at all, I spit out my drink laughing.
I am from hong kong and this is one good thing china has done. Keep Going👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Shake shake they blocked it immediately of course
The Chinese are thinking logically and sensibly, unlike our almost anything goes culture in America, "if it feels good, do it", regardless of the long-range consequences.
based China
based socialism
Having seen Western moral collapse, Beijing wish to avoid a similar fate.
I hope more Americans watch this, their LGBT works are getting toxic 😱 not long ago, they have baby-friendly-drag-shows 😱
The true masculinity is knowledge remember that.
spoke like a true DYEL.
China once again is right, they have really smart politicians.
W CHINA from ENGLAND
come over here to china then we’d love to have you
Subtitles & text on screen. I hate it.
Finally someone’s finally doing something about it
China needs to bring back the good ol cultural proletarian revolution to end this nonsense
China number one
At last, the situation has reached a breaking point. As someone who has lived in Korea for over 11 years, I believe similar changes are necessary in both Korea and Japan. This issue transcends discussions of feminism, patriarchy, or gender politics. It's about preventing cultural influence from impacting political power in the complex landscape of Asian geopolitics, particularly in the era of AI algorithms. Just as Andrew Tate was once idolized and subsequently discredited for promoting 'toxic masculinity,' there can also be a glorification of 'toxic femininity.'
In contrast to the relative security of the West, this region must be prepared for potential military conflict. North Korea poses a threat to the security of both Korea and Japan, while the US presence in these countries poses a risk to North Korea and China. Additionally, tensions surrounding Taiwan create instability for the entire region. Preparedness for any situation is crucial, and it is essential to have a strong military force, rather than relying on pop culture's influence, to maintain or fight for peace. A warrior, regardless of their gender identity, embodies traditionally masculine qualities.
On a related note, there is an interesting series of events leading up to Andrew Tate's arrest. Tate is known for his ability to inspire and mobilize his primarily American male adolescent followers. The US army faces challenges in recruiting this same demographic for its operations in Iraq and the Middle East. After announcing his conversion to Islam, Tate was arrested for sex trafficking just a month later and detained without formal charges. Perhaps allowing an individual with such views and newfound religious beliefs to influence potential future soldiers is not in the best interest of those in power. It's certainly something to consider.
Andrew tate was arrested for human trafficking, his literal family owns a human trafficking ring. War in reality is such a waste of time and outdated way of solving conflicts. It's a lot easier to formally sign agreements and make amends then bomb tf out of each other and no actual differences being made. Andrew tate was only idolized by braindead 12 year olds whos closest proximity to a vagina was at their birth, everyone's hated him including me and everyone still does. Realize how the countries that are constantly fighting wars are the most poor or have the worst infrastructures. China's economy and real estate is literally plunging and crashing, literally everyone there isn't paying their mortgages out of protest. Another example, when Russia was busy spending quite literally all of their money on the Berlin wall, the soviet union quite literally disolved only like 2 years later. War literally is such an outdated and dumb way of solving conflicts. Get your fat *ss off the internet and touch some grass instead of sucking Andrew Tates d*ck because you get no p*ssy. 💀💀
@@Gyarukittenz HELP U ATE HIM UP 😭
@@h1nsicon ik i did xoxo
When has war ever lead to peace? The problem is hard power that is ruthless and doesn't respect the sacredness of life. All it is a monster with insatiable bloodlust. If soft power means kindness, compassion, virtues that is the way forward.
@@CatherineIves when the allies defeated Nazi Germany. Soft power can be virtuous or insidiously toxic it depends upon the intention, message, and medium and a lot of what is being pumped out of the corporate Korean entertainment companies does not have compassionate intent, but rather one of mass consumption and consumerism without regard to weather what they put out there will be toxic to society and culture.
As an Indian, this's something i support China for.
China planning for the future. Meanwhile We taking anti-anxiety meds and arguing over "what is a woman" in the highest court of the land.
China is also running itself into the ground
What a "sissy" insecure government lol
This!
If it's banning this is positive, then they must ban it. Don't make fun of them in a useless way.
Prof is speaking the truth
I hope the US military will perform mandatory gender reassignment for all of its male soldiers
I actually find the professor has good point. I feel bad that individuality can’t be promoted, but they are allowed to do what they want in their personal time. They don’t want to promote effeminate men and lose their soldiers. The point he made about Korea and Japan was interesting. But also, women can also be soldiers too, so I am still middle ground on this topic.
Old men want to see big strong men, hmm not sure why they are thinking about them 🤔
Perhaps in their eyes they need masculine men to protect and serve the country and therefore secure the safety of the nation in the generations to come
@@hepsima its strange to me that China, with the largest army in the world, thinks that it needs more masculine men to fight wars with. Logically it would be the opposite, since they have such a large population they would be able to afford to have less "masculine" men. Also who are they going to fight? The US and India both have nukes and any war with them would end with annihilation for both, more manpower would mean nothing
@@Hel1mutt Biggest perhaps but not the best, the US spends the most on its military. As for nukes, yeah idk if any big powers are willing to use them because of MAD, we havent seen Russia use any in the invasion of Ukraine. How would it differ from Taiwan and China if China ends up trying reunification.
''We don't need masculine soldiers because we have nukes'' is not a good argument
@@hepsima r/whoosh 🤦
@@I.____.....__...__ can you ellaborate redditor
It's good, we can already see what is happening in the US.
There's nothing wrong of all this and it's up to them for they has the freedom to change their personality just like in Thailand. They done nothing wrong against the law. Their government need to be more open as we are moving forward to the future and not reverse back to the old way and those obsolete laws.
China is full of "progressive" communist politics rife with new age bullshit and socialist garbage, the new Maoist system in China is hardly traditional at all, the reason China is the way it is comes from a lack of traditionalism, you can't blame China's problems on traditionalism, China has destroyed it's own culture a long time ago.
I think this documentary confuses people. Sissified men like those in K-POP are nothing like transgenders in Thailand. They are essentially straight men. I personally don't agree that straight men should look more feminine than gay men or transgenders which is happening right now, but I also don't think it's something that should be governed by laws or regulations. It's just a K-POP trend that will go away soon (the sissy one not the transgender one which is completely different.).
If it's correct to ban the sissy publicity, we must ban it.
I'm with China on this one
Lol it's simple.....war prep!!!
Omg lol that could be it
both of u r idiot
if you are surrounded by 60% of the US navy, you would be too
We are who we are worldwide, no matter what.
Wasted.
Lies. The devil is though with this lie he has spread of homosexuality
It's a tautology to say "who are who we are". However, it is sometimes implied that people are supposed to be free. But people should only have the freedom to do things that benefit society
People should be a.lowed to do things that benefit society,that is chinese line, what about things that benefit both society and folks,afteral, it is folks that made up society
SUCH CRAP this man who still speaks of Swartzeneger in 2022+ and is unaware of RuPaul 🤣