Why I switched from the iKamper to the Roofnest Falcon XL
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- Recently, I switched my rooftop tent from the iKamper Skycamp 2.0 to the Roofnest Falcon XL.
In this video, I explain why.
Roofnest Falcon XL:
roofnest.com/p...
The Replacement Air Mattress shown in the video:
amzn.to/2CPcF5O
====================================
Follow me!
/ edward_shin_
/ krokemoutdoors
=====================================
My Camera: amzn.to/2MK3PZm
Main Lens: amzn.to/2QhdZ5W
2nd Lens: amzn.to/37rNMqZ
#rooftoptent #IKamper #roofnest #overlanding
Follow me on Instagram for Real time updates and some behind the scenes stuff:
instagram.com/edward_shin_/
So being that there are two doors does that mean you can put the ladder on either side?
Conny Bjaaland yup
How is it in cold weather?
I still like my ikamper, the most wonderful thing about ikamper is during a wonderful storm you have the ability to keep the sides open and the skylight open with the waterproof windows...just love seeing the lightning and colors of a storm
Well demonstrated and explained as always. I really really like this style of RTT...despite being more expensive than conventional RTTs, this slim clamshell design is the only type I would consider putting on my car. I love that it has integrated channels around the sides and the ability to mount stuff on top...that would be a crucial factor for my compact rig. Maybe one day I'll finally be sleeping up there on my roof! :-) I hope to get a closer look at yours soon!
softroadingthewest yeah this design definitely has many benefits, especially for the type of camping/off-roading you like to do 👍. I definitely see one of these in your future 😉
Good points on the Falcon...it's strongest point is the ability to carry stuff on top using the racks and T-slot rails. However, not being able to store your bedding for two people and the ladder means all that needs to be stored in the rig and you have the chance of forgetting the ladder or sleeping gear behind. I also find the roominess of the iKamper to be ideal when the weather gets wet/cold etc and you want a place to chill, play a card game, draw, read , etc. You can do that more comfortably in king sized iKamper. Nice informative comparison between the two overall-thank you
Actually there is a way around this. You fold the mattress halfway back tuck it into the back part of the wedge. Then you put your sleeping bags and pillows on the wide end along with your pillows.
Ease of use wins every time. Great video.
Trail Adventures USA absolutely brother. Cheers Dave 🍻
This is a great video. Thanks for introducing me to the roofnest.
I kinda like the ikamper more, just due to the fact that I'm able to mount it on my 4runner and it tucks up nicely. As well as the window above, always great to have it open on a clear night and see the milky way! I keep my stuff outside so no issue with garages but i understand your decision! Great vid 👌
The Condor XL is a great alternative at around 3200$ compared to 4200 or so for the iKamper in the rugged black color
Miguel Galvez you cant go wrong with either tent, especially if your circumstances don’t create the same issues that I’ve had 👍
@@stumptownwoodworks i'll look into the condor XL! I appreciate it
Great video as always. I'm in the process of selling my iKamper 2.0 4x to go with something smaller, so this answered a lot of questions for me.
Galen Sinkey 👍
Hi Galen,
How much are you asking for your ikamper?
Thanks!
You described many of the same reasons I went with a clam shell type tent. I have limited clearance in my garage and needed a slim profile to be able to park in the garage. I can leave my bedding in my tent and love the convince of that set up. I went with the Camp King RTT and really love it. Thanks for sharing.
What's the height of your garage??
Thanks for all the iKamper vids. I would prefer the roofnest/cvt hardshell type tent but I always have 2-3 teenage kids camping with me so the iKamper is really the best option..
@mattd makes complete sense to me 👍
I think one of the biggest advantage of this style pop-up tent is the smaller footprint once fully deployed. it just takes up the space of the vehicle it's on whereas the ikamper and other foldout tents occupies the area next to the vehicle.
For the sake of an extra minute I’d rather have the larger tent.... also, if you wanna move the truck and have a none removable ladder just shorten it up so it’s not touching the ground 😃. Great video as always 🤙
Hi Edward,
Do you have any concerns with the gas struts being on the outside of the module, exposed to all weather conditions being that they are a critical part in these roof tent designs ?
Gas struts generally don't like being exposed to the elements over the longterm.
I've been researching RTTs for a year. For me, trading space and storage for a 1 minute savings of set up time just doesn't pencil. CVT and iKamper are both insanely overpriced! I just don't see their value. I appreciate your videos and this made me feel much better about my choice to go with another company where I'll get a lot more bang for the buck.
If you don’t mind me asking, what did you end up buying?
@@magnushaslund3481 none, actually. The RTT trend is incredibly overpriced.
@@magnushaslund3481 I ended up abandoning this overpriced trend and sticking with my $300 Napier truck tent.
It’s a nice setup , but it’s still pricey for me as a person that doesn’t have that kind of money available compared to my tent I bought from under $1,700!
What tent did you go with?
Another great video!!! I am looking for a rooftop for my 4Runner & Tundra. The falcon checks all the boxes but 3500-3600 is still a big nut. I wish it was around 2700 for this model with the rack. Maybe in the future with a sale or a code. Keep up the great work
I'd switch too if someone reached out to me for a free $3,500 RTT. My hard top is $1,700 and it comes with standard LED disco lights I side and out, lol.
RyuGoesHunting EvilRyu witch one is that 1700?
It is Tuff Stuff Alpha. At the time of purchase, they had it on sale for $1900 and there was a discount code I used.
Thank you for the good review. We`re currently in the process of selecting a hard-shell RTT to replace our old soft/folding one. Some comments on your comparison:
- Price: I think it would have been better if you`d compared the price of the cheaper Skycamp Mini to the Roofnest Falcon as they are more similar in size
- Moving around the vehicle after setting up the tent: you could have just slide up the ladder on the Skycamp and leave the tent unfolded to move the car a little bit
- At least in Europe there are places where you are allowed to use a RTT that doesn`t use more space than your car like the Roofnest whereas a tent like the Skycamp would not be allowed.
Hope you don`t mind my suggestions, other than that it`s a really helpful video. After looking at the Eezie Awn Stealth, Alu Cab 3.1, Bush Company Alpha and the Roofnest, we went for the Skycamp Mini 3.0. We can leave our sleeping bags in there, have more space and less weight to carry.
The Roofnest is so bad its laughable. I had one and sold it in 3 weeks. Truly the worst tent ever. They're sold under the Tentbox name in the UK. In fact they're sold all over the world under different names. You cannot store any bedding in this roof tent, its not tall enough. The gas struts are so cheap they start rattling after a few hundred km, the back door doesn't close at the bottom, no zipper, no velcro, just a little weighted bar which lifts up in windy weather and that ice cold wind blows right onto your head. Its got a membrane stuck to the canvas meaning its not breathable, its a condensation hell.
good video...
this is funny to watch.. before i just watched anoter video that the guy just said he didn't like Roofnest because a lots of issues...
this is why i can't decide what i will buy.. have a nice day
Very informative, nice review 👍 Nice tundra build well thought 💪Try our's next 😉
I'm definitely really considering this after debating on Skycamper and GoFast Campers! Glad I stumbled across this!
I was debating between this and GFC, but ended up getting this because of the price point and lead time. Still, a month wait before I get it. I already have a softshell, so just upgrading.
@@caesardgreatest I have yet to install mine, but it's just about that time! I'm stoked.
@@PIZOtv let me know how it turns out!
I was looking for some information on what truck I should buy and I stumbled into these videos.. I love the set up and I feel extra expenses in my future 😂😂
Same
Ikamper still better. World map, duh lol. Just intalled my Tuwa Pro Bed Rack and my Ikamper mini is in shipping as we speak. Good content brother man! Love it. Keep it up.
Very good video Edward! Thanks for sharing!
Sheesh, that's about 7-8K empty sitting on the back of that truck.....Until I can figure out how to hoist or teach my mutt to climb a ladder, I''ll have to stick with my Gazelle T4 (orange one shown in the video) I love the Roofnests, but my buddy wants to be right next to me all the time LOL. Plus, with my Gazelle, I can put my cleanwaste toilet in there and I can stand up to change clothes and clean off. I do love your set up though!
Ile save 5 grand and put my hammock up 😀🇬🇧🏍❤️
Jakey B absolutely nothing wrong with that 👍👊
I am interesting in the rack system. You have a link for that?
Oh I thought sponsors changed
What do you use as a heater during winter?
I'm thinking of using a jackery power supply with a space ceramic heater.
What size Megamat did you go with? Your link points to the medium which is 40 inches wide. There is a wide whick is 52 inches. The tent is 58 inches wide. Your matress appeared to fit perfectly.
Nice setup... great tent. You do what's best for you not others, that's what I like about you. Good for you bro. Thank you for sharing, take care Edward.
RedWhite&Blue 78 thanks bro. Hope you and your little ones are doing well 🍻
Switched from a Tepui softshell to an AluCab and love it! As always even your content and thanks for sharing. I personally believe clamshells are the only way to go moving forward. Great insight on driving the rig around too. 😎. #tentprotip! Never thought about that.
Clam shell doesn't give good rain protection
@@supergoobergirlable odd you say that as tons of Aussie’s and South African’s used them while I was in those countries. Plus, I have used them extensively since I found a place to but one in the states about 6-7 years ago. Are you pairing your clamshell with a rain fly on all sides?
Nice set up, Edward. I love how "thin" this RTT is vs other tents. Deploying it is quick and easy. The one item that scares the crap out of me is that menacing looking shovel...lol. Your Tundra is badass!
Alexander Weaver haha it’s a great shovel (kraxy beaver) 👍
Hi Edward, thanks for your reviews, very informative as always. I believe you may have missed a Pro for your viewers. Another advantage this has over the ikamper is that the ladder may be repositioned to side (s) or back. I caught that in the montage but you didn't mention it. Please verify if it's true. Thanks
@g_money yes, it is true! Good eye! The Roofnest falcon comes with two ladder mounts you can configure any way you’d like
Funny. I just watched a UA-camr from the Vancouver area do a review of an iKamper from Big Tent Outdoors...
Great stuff as usual, brother!
@meanonemeanone thanks bro 👊🍻
excellent analysis
I regret not bugging you some during the campout on the Alvord, to get a closer look at the tent. The narrower Falcon might be a good option for my daughter's Nissan Pathfinder down the road.
In noticed when you opened it, there was a good amount of suction as it tried to fill it's lung as it opened. And again, a little "poofy" as you were drawing it closed. I usually drop my Maggiolina Airtop in the front first as I completely close the front window, and both sides to keep dust and water from getting in during travel. I leave the rear window open half way to help facilitate air into and out of the tent as I open/close it. Seems to help speed up the opening, and reduce the "poof" of the tent when closing.
I really like the slots down the sides of the tent, as it would allow for mounting all kinds of cool stuff to it. The rack on top would be good for your SUPs if you didn't want to have to inflate them each time you used them. My wife and daughter fill theirs at home with the shop compressor, and then use my truck to haul them to the lake/river and back.
Great functioning tent!
C_INSAYN good tips! I do try to keep most of the windows closed, with a slight opening to let air travel. This is because in case we we have to open up the tent while raining, nothing gets wet inside. We also bought a cordless inflator for the SUP’s, which I’m hoping will facilitate the inflation, but I like your pre-inflation idea!
You would think with the price of roofnest products they would have the black out canvas. You get a lot of light through that.
I would have liked to see how it mounts to the vehicle.
35 second set-up. Pretty awesome.
WoW! Quick setup! I truly like this design best than the last! Love the colors, looks good on your Tundra!
Happy, safe travels🙏❤️
Can you tell what brand of rack you have on your truck and what the specs are? I have the Yakima Outpost HD and want to get the Roof Nest Falcon XL and want to make sure the truck can handle the tent and the paxs. Thanks.
Great review. Still 4K for a tiny tent is obsurd. At 6'2" 270 that is a tent for ONE person. Love your videos but this tent is a racket.
Good assessment. ..helpful. Thanks man.
A ladder on the side takes up a second parking spot parallel to your vehicle. The rear entry ladder may save a second parking spot.
I've been trying to compare both iKamper and Roofnest tents, so this video has proven valuable to me, thank you very much.
Does that soft awning come off completely
Great video!! Do you know of any clam shells that can be accessed thru the floor (instead of the ladder on the outside?) Thanks
This is llthe video I needed to see today..
what does your wife think of this vs the ikamper?
The ikamper looks heaps better, but on the other hand its good you can mount other stuff to this new RTT like awings and solar panels etc its still good i guess, but i reckon this tent is good for couples that do more hardcore offroading and like fast setups, and ikamper is good for a family and more on the mild touring side, both great imo.....Keep up the great work mate from Australia. represent 😉
Quang Lam all great points! Cheers
Appreciate the video! This was very useful to see the comparisons!
That’s a great tent. But what are your thoughts on the James Baroud? I am thinking about getting one for my rig. I am just in the process of getting my rig built by the guys at wanderlust. Just waiting on my parts to show up. Thanks bro
Deal breaker for me is unlike other rtts the bug mesh is on the inside.I like to open windows from the inside and still have the mesh in place to let in the light.with the roof nest you have to unzip the mesh to open the windows , may not be a big deal for some.really is a shame tho.
This is great thanks!
Separately, do you have advice as to what you’ve found to be a great truck and model (experience around quality) to accommodate the RoofNest?
What rack system (brand) do you have (as shown in this video)?
This roof tent looks awesome, I'm looking into getting a roof tent for my 2019 4x2 Toyota Tacoma. Would you tell me or do you have a video on what type of bed rack you have installed on your truck to house the roof tent?
Hello we hope your well and keeping safe . we also hope your having a great weekend . and WOW what a cool set up and to take 28 seconds for that to be up was amazing . thats deffo a plus in my eyes. I bet you are so glad they reached out to you to test this . Kind Regards Sarah and Glenn
Hey I love your videos! Thanks to you I got a iKamper 2.0 for my Tacoma this spring. I've been having adventures here in Alaska and love it! If you get a chance check out one of my overland videos. Cheers!
IKamper also supports two small camp chairs and still two full-sized sleeping bags. Way more room. I'm biased because I'm going to use my IKamper until it totally pooches on me :)
Hi. Do you mean you can leave the bedding inside when it's closed up?
Hey man I am looking to set up my chevy colorado w potentially a falcon pro. I found a bed rack that looks similar to yours from RCI. I am wondering what it is you are using for the cover halfway up your liner and the drawers beneath? I am trying to find a solution for keeping my gear dry when I am driving through weather. Thanks!
I been waiting for this video
THE TITLE NEEDS A CHANGEDA LITTLE SO THAT SOMEONE WILL NOW YOU SWITCHED FROM A FLAWED IKamper SKYCAMP 2.0 TO ROOFNEST FALCON XL NOT THE CORRECTED SKYCAMP 3.0 WHICH JUST CAME OUT THE END OF 2021 OR BEGINNING OF 2022
Overall, it can’t be faster than ikamper. After setup you have to put all your bedding into the clamshell then inflated the mattress. Then you have to pull all your stuff out and deflate the mattress. Overall it takes way more time. Also if you had the ikamper you could buy the Hest mattress and it’s the most comfortable mattress on the market and don’t require air inflation. It also blows away that Exped in comfort. Even the ikamper X-Cover is faster to setup than having to put all your bedding inside and inflate/deflate.
Hi, thank you for all this info very good.... one question, what cie are you r Bed Rack ... thank s
LOOKS NICE ! I LIKE THAT'S THIN & HELPS WITH GAS MILEAGE ! BE SAFE ! HAVE FUN ! GOD BLESS YOU BOTH & THE PUP TOO ALWAYS ON YOUR JOURNEYS ! ENJOYED !
I’m sure you’ve covered it, but can you tell me or point me to your video where you talk about keeping gear on top of your shelves in the bed and not worrying about theft. :)
@sean_brody I only put things in my bed that I’m okay with losing. 😉👍
Can I put the IKamper or your new Roofnest Falcon XL on the hardtop of a Toyota Hilux?
Where do I get the kind of setup in the back of the car?
I am trying to switch from yakima rtt to this tent for how simple it is to set up and pack.
Also aluminum shell is huge plus.
What do you recommend for a Rav4 2021 of any of this Roof Tens?
It looks like a burnt Pop-Tart that's been dolled up with the trim from a herse... Just kidding. 😉 Great video! (It's always a pleasure.)
When you come back to iKamper, we'll all be here with open arms to accept you back in club! ...much love!
Haha thanks @jason_plank 😋
Which Mega Mat size did you purchase? And how does it fit in the Falcon 2 xl?
all of these tents you can get in alibaba (thats where all the suppliers anyway) for a fraction of the ridiculous prices these "big name" companies. they just slap a brand name and triple the price, they are all the same. all made in china. . .
I’m sorry Edward but for me you haven’t won the argument. I think the iKamper looks better. I understand the garage roof issue and you had to change. I hope the iKamper will fit my garage. I do appreciate your videos 👍
@julian_taylor to each they’re own 👍
For that price I'll just get a rv, lol.
So would it be even possible to keep the lower rack system and have the falcon xl hang off the rear instead of over the cab? Like the tent but wanted to keep a low rack system.
Been waiting to hear your views on the new RTT
Awesome stuff. Just thinking what kind of attachment rack you installed to the truck for the roof tent? Thks
on the truck roof is a Frontrunner outfitters slimline rack, and on the bed is the Leitner Designs bedrack
How does it compare to the iKamper in terms of wind? Seems like the iKamper has thicker lining on the outside and would fare better in 30 mph or greater conditions. As always, thanks for the vids.
@david_spiegelman I’ve been in a few camps where the winds were very high (see my recent alvord desert meetup video), and the tent has done great so far
Can you show details how you attached the awning to the rtt?
Great video. I got a Roofnest Sandpiper and I'm very happy with the tent.
Hi Edward! Not sure if you plan to keep this with your Rebel but do you think you can comfortably sleep 2 adults and a 7 yo? Or would the iKamper SkyCamp 2.0 be better for a family of 3?
Your voice is very relaxing 🥰
Katelyn Fitz 😘
Oh sorry someone already wants to buy....
Why are tent guys so concerned about saving a couple of minutes of setup?
How do you keep it warm in cold weather?
I like your channel but you have to stop it with the petty talk points about the comparisons. Just say that you like it better.
My Kabari 23zero is really close to that one I do like how dark the inside is on my Kabari
Edward, do you leave your trash bag on at highway speeds? Does it scratch the tailgate at all? Great video as always!
Misplaced Overland yes, but I place a magnetic pad in between the bag and truck tailgate 😉
...What is the brand of the container on the passenger side of your bed ?...
I like your bed ruck, can you send me an information about the brand…thanks
Look at that truck still a better looking truck then what you have presently
This is awesome! Thanks for the review. I've been tempted but reluctant to go roofnest and such due to the high cost, but we do camp a LOT, so I'm thinking this would be a great investment.
Just curious, your replacement inflatable mattress, did you remove the roofnest provided mattress for yours, or did you place your inflatable mattress on top of roofnest's mattress?
I removed the mattress that came with the Roofnest . The mattress is a little thicker, but packs thinner when deflated, which also helps the tent close more easily.
You're honesty and unbiased feedback is refreshing. I appreciate what you do and have subscribed!
@ashton_smith I appreciate it, Ashton! Welcome to the channel 👊
how tall are you? from all the videos I've watched nobody shows just how room is in these; and they look very compact. honestly doesn't look like you'd have much room in there for anything other than you and somebody else.
Michael Weeks 5’11 and there’s plenty of room in my opinion. I’ll show how it is inside in future videos
@@KrokemOutdoors appreciate it! Keep up the content.
How is the built quality? Cause roofnest made in China, however ikamper in Korea, on videos ikamper seems solid. Greatings from Kyrgyzstan)
Soooo... where's the iKamper now? asking for a friend :D
wiltordle sold 😁
I’ve seen solar panels mounted on an iKamper.
Love it. Where is that dry lake bed you camped at?
MIguel Trejo this was the alvord desert in Oregon