HasanAbi Reacts to Why Urban Planning Matters (and Why I Hate Houston)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 617

  • @NotJustBikes
    @NotJustBikes 3 роки тому +2084

    I'm very glad to see that the first few minutes of my video provided Hasan an opportunity to get up and take a piss. 🤣

    • @castortoutnu
      @castortoutnu 3 роки тому +140

      I feel like he does that every two videos he uploads

    • @GijsInc
      @GijsInc 3 роки тому +60

      Do you like Hasan? Greetings from a Dutch guy, you've really helped me appreciate where I live haha

    • @aprilshowers3008
      @aprilshowers3008 3 роки тому +4

      Hah it's awesome you two know of each other

    • @TriopsTrilobite
      @TriopsTrilobite 3 роки тому +5

      Like your vids :)

    • @chumincoomim
      @chumincoomim 3 роки тому +5

      Love your shit bro

  • @shellminator
    @shellminator 3 роки тому +665

    The thing is Americans always say CARS ARE FREEDOM, but when you are forced to use your car for school, food, work, all movement because you don't have anything else, it's not freedom it's a prison

    • @McFwoupson
      @McFwoupson 3 роки тому +52

      For real. I have epilepsy so I can't drive. Life here in Texas is hell if you're not able to drive. Pretty much have no freedom. I never go anywhere except my workplace which is a 40 minute walk bc I have to bum rides off people to get anywhere.

    • @shellminator
      @shellminator 3 роки тому +9

      @@McFwoupson I use a car to go to work, it's a 10mile drive to a place where i would need to use atleast 3 different transports, but it could be done in maybe a bit less then 1 hour but it takes 15m by car.
      So the situation in Lisbon and Portugal overall is not excellent for public transport, but it's getting better, people need to atleast have the option of not using a car.
      If you live and work in Lisbon you can live without a car.
      Students and older citizens can go in any public transport FOR FREE or atleast very reduced fees.
      The month pass is around 35$ for all transports.
      Most EU cities will be like that altho more expensive.
      But our cities are not for the cars, they are for us..
      Cities need to make better and cheaper public transport and make it harder for car owners.
      Americans need to fight to have their cities back, more highways destroying your neighborhoods and creating ghettos is not the answer
      PS: I'm sorry for your condition, best of luck my friend!

    • @earlaweese
      @earlaweese 2 роки тому +24

      *It’s literal hell, man. I was born and raised in hell. America is hell. I absolutely abhor it here.*

    • @frzferdinand72
      @frzferdinand72 2 роки тому +8

      @@McFwoupson Fellow epileptic here - SAME! I can't drive anywhere. I live in a San Francisco Bay Area suburb, so it's not nearly as egregious as Houston or Florida, but it's still way too car-dependent.

    • @sh0werp0wer
      @sh0werp0wer Рік тому +3

      I lived in the US for a couple of years as a student, and I couldn't pinpoint why I hated it so much until I watched Not Just Bikes' video on Houston, and I literally come from a fairly walkable European city with good public transport. It was a true lightbulb moment for me, as the closest I got before that was "why are there no bus lines anywhere", the rest I just assumed as some law of nature being there for a reason, didn't even register as dogshit urban planning. I feel like this is how 99% of people think about these things, and he kind of addresses that at the beginning of the video as well. Now back in Europe I appreciate the freedom of not needing a car, being able to just walk or hop on a bus/tram/metro anywhere, it's so fucking liberating compared to having this 2 tonne metal limb you need to go anywhere.

  • @RordamJ
    @RordamJ 3 роки тому +786

    When my family was homeless I had to walk to school. At a certain point away from the campus, the sidewalks would get increasingly worse and then just... stop. I was a teenager who was an arm's length away from a highway full of teenager drivers. I wish America wasn't so car-centric, those shots of cities in the Netherlands were beautiful.

    • @rodolfodoce
      @rodolfodoce 3 роки тому +79

      you basically hate freedom, development , prosperity and democracy.
      the american way. holland is disgusting.
      i am joking. it’s all a big lie.
      usa is horrible. even to visit.

    • @luketorrini70
      @luketorrini70 3 роки тому +12

      @@rodolfodoce you got me 😂

    • @RordamJ
      @RordamJ 3 роки тому +9

      I checked my city's walk score and it is 41.

    • @finlanderxx
      @finlanderxx 3 роки тому +12

      Glad you survived

    • @iroh9816
      @iroh9816 3 роки тому +8

      @@RordamJ mine is 91 and i thought my city was car dependant

  • @Zehnt1337
    @Zehnt1337 3 роки тому +1086

    When I studied urban planning (in germany) american urban spaces were discussed several times. And not a single time in a positive way. Many american cities embody everything european planners are taught to avoid for almost 40 years now since we had a shift in planning paradigms.

    • @hello7032
      @hello7032 3 роки тому +80

      It’s absolutely shit here

    • @mynewname7830
      @mynewname7830 3 роки тому +136

      That image of the 20 lane highway full of vehicles seemed like pure dystopian hell..

    • @politedog4959
      @politedog4959 3 роки тому +19

      wo kann man denn Stadtplanung studieren? :D

    • @BeastyBite
      @BeastyBite 3 роки тому +22

      @@politedog4959 architektur studium beinhaltet stadtplanung

    • @daniel.friedrich
      @daniel.friedrich 3 роки тому +9

      @@BeastyBite sonst aber auch im master, gibt aber auch wenige unis wo man direkt nur stadtplanung macht, meine ich.

  • @Diego-zz1df
    @Diego-zz1df 3 роки тому +86

    "So how did you get radicalized?"
    "I spent two days in Houston."

    • @PhoneHalHome
      @PhoneHalHome 3 роки тому +12

      I'm jealous it took you 2 days where it took me 14 years

    • @injeraenjoyer4570
      @injeraenjoyer4570 9 місяців тому

      Try 19 years, including every single one of your formative, most important ones

    • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
      @cupriferouscatalyst3708 2 місяці тому

      "I walked 800 meters in Houston"

  • @timurnurzhauov1917
    @timurnurzhauov1917 3 роки тому +538

    America: "Lmao, look at the copy-paste structures in the Soviet Union."
    *Also America

    • @angusmarch1066
      @angusmarch1066 3 роки тому +72

      Bruh, I know right? imagine caping so hard for a country that is essentially one big parking lot.

    • @AesthetixVB
      @AesthetixVB 3 роки тому +23

      @@angusmarch1066 They sure like their parking lots

    • @Gloomdrake
      @Gloomdrake 3 роки тому +1

      @@angusmarch1066 our roads and buildings are rotting

    • @nutyyyy
      @nutyyyy 2 роки тому +1

      Soviet and American cities are/were awful.

    • @LS-Moto
      @LS-Moto 2 роки тому +18

      @@nutyyyy Soviet cities were not necessarily beautiful, but they provided housing, nearby stores and untilities, as well as public transportation. The basic needs of people were covered. The housing prices in the west would also drop, if cities would actually build buildings for people to live in.

  • @sourceeee
    @sourceeee 3 роки тому +389

    As a car owner it would be stupid to not make public transportation and urban infrastructure more accessable for pedestrians. It takes more cars off the road, saves money for the person who owns a car and one who doesn't, and it makes driving to and from places shorter. It helps everyone.

    • @livelyosprey
      @livelyosprey 3 роки тому +24

      Communism is when sidewalk

    • @carsonfarmer1074
      @carsonfarmer1074 3 роки тому +12

      Communism is when bus

    • @AesthetixVB
      @AesthetixVB 3 роки тому +10

      Communism is when train

    • @Saturn_Rising
      @Saturn_Rising 3 роки тому +37

      commumism is when walk

    • @IBeforeAExceptAfterK
      @IBeforeAExceptAfterK 3 роки тому +40

      It helps everyone except the car and oil companies. Guess who has lobbyists trying to perpetuate this broken system?
      Edit: C-c-c-c-combo breaker!

  • @bloodymary__
    @bloodymary__ 3 роки тому +149

    I live in houston, and I can't believe how much I've been groomed to believe our urban planning is normal. So many times I've stepped on dirty grass paths full of litter next to large lanes just to walk somewhere a 1/4th a mile. Insane.

    • @vyros.3234
      @vyros.3234 2 роки тому +5

      Its getting better though. They are improving from the inside out, starting in Central houston, Downtown, and the Med center. Hopefully they continue to improve. Something that complicates is all the little cities that make up the Houston Metro area.

  • @KrishnaDasLessons
    @KrishnaDasLessons 3 роки тому +628

    Hasan's new urban planning arc is so amazing.

    • @almed23
      @almed23 3 роки тому +43

      He isn't kidding when he said infrastructure in America is dog sheight

    • @KrishnaDasLessons
      @KrishnaDasLessons 3 роки тому +55

      @@almed23 Our trash infrastructure is the reason why our carbon emissions are so high. Same situation for Canada.

    • @GlizzyTrefoil
      @GlizzyTrefoil 3 роки тому +9

      Strongtowns would absolutely be worth checking out for Hasan!

    • @John-zl8qx
      @John-zl8qx 3 роки тому +14

      ikr, I got into my urban planning phase about a few months ago found Adam Something, Not Just Bikes, and Alan Fisher all great channels with amazing content.

    • @butteredmap9064
      @butteredmap9064 3 роки тому +8

      @@John-zl8qx yeah same here. I think found a couple of Not Just bike’s videos and found other channels like Alan Fisher, Adam Something, and others. It’s given me a better appreciation for the built landscape and how it can be more pleasant to live and work with more walkabilty like sidewalks, bike infrastructure, public transit, and green spaces. Huge pluses that it heavily reduces carbon emissions from car traffic and endless building sprawl and enables you to live without a car.

  • @stevenjohnson7287
    @stevenjohnson7287 3 роки тому +172

    The best way to describe sidewalks in the US is that they're aesthetic. You're not meant to use them and they don't go anywhere. For a pertinent example, you can be ticketed for walking along a highway in Washington state if there isn't a sidewalk, or jaywalking when one is available for a higher fine. But when a new Cosco was built on the highway near me a few years back, the city added a roundabout to the turnoff for it. Which had sidewalks. On both the exterior and interior island. A half mile from any connecting sidewalk. And of course since the bike lane is literally 9 inches wide on that stretch of highway; if I want to use Cosco's sidewalk I have to stand in 55 mph traffic, risk a ticket, and jump traffic to use that fancy island sidewalk. (Also yeah, the 55 mph traffic goes right into a traffic circle and then hits a traffic light a few hundred yards down the line.) Also I didn't realize this until I started walking more, but a Zebra crossing doesn't mean traffic disruption for pedestrians in the US. Spokane literally has a handfull of marked pedestrian crossings across a 6 lane highway near me without any kind of signage or signals for drivers nowhere near a traffic light. The city decided that the cure for people getting ticketed for dodging traffic was to make areas where it's not ticketable.

    • @penpenultra
      @penpenultra 3 роки тому +2

      Can confirm as a fellow Washingtonian.

    • @AssBlasster
      @AssBlasster 2 роки тому +1

      I feel blessed to have grown up in a suburban city that had a continuous sidewalk network on all roads. Could walk 7 miles from my HS to home with sidewalks. I didn't realize that this reality about sidewalks until I visited Houston.

    • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
      @cupriferouscatalyst3708 2 місяці тому +1

      Aren't sidewalks in the US basically sewage lids? Unless I made that up in a fake NJB video I saw in a dream or something, I thought they were basically just concrete slabs placed on top of sewage pipes that people also happen to walk on top of.

    • @stevenjohnson7287
      @stevenjohnson7287 2 місяці тому

      @@cupriferouscatalyst3708 Not for sewage, but they are incorporated in flood management in things like planned communities. Suburbs and the like often do have open spaces underneath that pipe rainwater to a grassy bowl in the middle of the community that helps prevent flooding. Most areas try to keep rainwater and sewage separate, since flooding septic treatment tanks with too lean of a sewage mix (or one with a bunch of oil and other runoff chemicals from the roadway) can really mess up the cultures used to break down waste.
      However, in the overwhelming amount of places the sidewalks are pretty much just concrete slabs thrown on top of the dirt.
      The slabs regularly shift and raise, around tree roots and in my area they actually slant to almost a foot high on one end, which I'm pretty sure makes them impossible to pass over with a wheelchair.

  • @ilyhomesick
    @ilyhomesick 3 роки тому +109

    As a Native Houstonian, this city is extremely car dependent. Until i was 16 i pretty much felt like i was on house arrest, there was no where to travel even in my suburb, and i live 15 mins from downtown. It sucks man

    • @earlaweese
      @earlaweese 2 роки тому +6

      *I’ve lived here my entire life and this city is truly hell. I just wish I had the fortune to have my life played out on camera from day one so that people can see just how fucking hellish it’s been and how evil people have been to me and how they’ve gotten away with it. It fucking HURTS. The pain is immense and it’s soul-ache. My soul is literally SUFFERING and what did I do to deserve this? Nothing.*

    • @samuelrappaport6162
      @samuelrappaport6162 2 роки тому +2

      @@earlaweese 😂😂 I think this is deeper than cars

    • @bishoptatum8737
      @bishoptatum8737 2 роки тому

      @@samuelrappaport6162exactly 😂😂 had nothing to do with infrastructure. He just had to vent😂

  • @sahirde
    @sahirde 3 роки тому +436

    I think Hasan is getting into city planning and that's awesome cause njb is great

    • @timetaker7816
      @timetaker7816 3 роки тому +10

      Same I love njb and eco gecko some of my favorite UA-camrs

    • @Mitchthemysteryman
      @Mitchthemysteryman 3 роки тому +9

      I actually was taught by City Beautiful. I went to Cal Poly. Great professor! He knows of NJB, and I hope they do a collab.

    • @fuglong
      @fuglong 3 роки тому

      Yes!!!!!

    • @GeertTheDestoyer
      @GeertTheDestoyer 3 роки тому +2

      Njb is awesome, was hoping for this for a while.

    • @co2_os
      @co2_os 3 роки тому +4

      Adam something going super viral definitely raised awareness of urban planning.

  • @QueenHalo
    @QueenHalo 3 роки тому +60

    As someone who can't drive due to an eye disability, this stuff is very important. I have to either rely on walking, public transit, carpooling, or uber

    • @Crueltyfree28
      @Crueltyfree28 Рік тому

      I hate houston, I have vertigo but this week I need to practice driving.

  • @nicholasphigginsalfaro7967
    @nicholasphigginsalfaro7967 3 роки тому +109

    I just moved to Spain a few days ago and I can literally walk everywhere in this city. If I don’t feel like taking the whole walk to a place that’s far, I’ll simply take a bus for 1.5€. There’s bike lanes on literally almost every street. Parking that are appropriately located on the roads with massive underground parking under the city itself in which elevators are used to take people to the surface. The efficiency along with the elegant architecture of Pamplona, Spain, amazes me every time I leave to asses to my responsibilities or to simply read at a park.

    • @smeetsnoud1
      @smeetsnoud1 2 роки тому +6

      I'm native Dutch and Not Just Bikes made me appreciate my country and other European places sooo much more.

    • @cr-nd8qh
      @cr-nd8qh 2 роки тому

      I was in the navy back in 2001 and we went to tarrigona Spain. It was a beautiful city

    • @_rileyweaver_637
      @_rileyweaver_637 Рік тому

      sounds like COMMUMISM to me

  • @magnus_cockstrong
    @magnus_cockstrong 3 роки тому +64

    people say cars give you freedom, which is fine if you have the nine thousand a year to spend on a car, but when urban planning forces you to have a car in order to work or get anywhere you need to go that is a removal of freedom. Planning cities for people as opposed to for cars isn't the same as prohibiting car ownership.

    • @Ryleeman54number2
      @Ryleeman54number2 3 роки тому +2

      Wtf cars dont cost 9k a year

    • @magnus_cockstrong
      @magnus_cockstrong 3 роки тому +10

      @@Ryleeman54number2 car payment, insurance, gas, maintenance, accidents, tickets. I've seen a few estimates of average annual cost that are lower, but not by much.

    • @Ryleeman54number2
      @Ryleeman54number2 3 роки тому +1

      @@magnus_cockstrong if youre broke you shouldnt have car payments

    • @magnus_cockstrong
      @magnus_cockstrong 3 роки тому +6

      @@Ryleeman54number2 broke people tend to just not have cars. Which in a way is no car payments.

    • @Ryleeman54number2
      @Ryleeman54number2 3 роки тому +2

      @@magnus_cockstrong yes but i dont see how a 2000 dollar car thatll run for years is costing me 9000 a year. I literally drive for a livint and hit nowhere near that lol

  • @pblmrt
    @pblmrt 3 роки тому +229

    I’m glad more millennials and Gen Z are getting into urban planning because it just easier to live in areas where everything is walkable for you. From grocery, work, school, and entertainment, there’s has been cities building neighborhood for that purpose to have all that together instead miles apart. And using light rail, heavy rail, speed bullet train, and busses using alternative energy is not only cheaper to use but the best way to fight climate change. If only Americans care more about convenience rather than “independent”. I find the rural areas so so so boring and very ugly. Like you spend a lot of money for a big house and put in a lot of unnecessary stuff you don’t need. There’s miles and miles of houses but some of these neighborhoods don’t have a park or a shopper area in the middle of them. To be honest that seems to be more communist than whatever Europeans are doing with their cities. Urban renewal has been key in 21 century and it’s works so much better for the average Joe. Small businesses will greatly appreciate this and you can use those extra land for other stuff like gatherings and festivals. I rather be somewhere that is close to everything I need and want to go to rather than drive miles and miles to get too. I have a car and I take very good care of it but a lot of people don’t care about maintaining their car to run good. They just get rid of it and pay more for the next one. Simply bad thinking since maintaining is just a lot cheaper. I live in area that is somewhat getting there as there’s a reliable bus system that takes me to work and a few grocery stores a mile away. But there’s a lot of work that need to be down in order to make the city where I’m at and others better.

    • @fuglong
      @fuglong 3 роки тому +1

      Wow based

  • @hankshen4117
    @hankshen4117 3 роки тому +197

    As a Not Just Bikes patron, I love seeing this crossover

    • @levector2445
      @levector2445 3 роки тому +6

      Aaaah yes the iconic "chair x njb" collab

    • @Diego-zz1df
      @Diego-zz1df 3 роки тому +2

      NJB/WTYP 3-hours-long crossover discussing Houston & the Katy Freeway as engineering disasters.

    • @vvvvvv66666
      @vvvvvv66666 3 роки тому +1

      Same

    • @Fletchayabetcha
      @Fletchayabetcha 2 роки тому

      You are the elite

  • @Misterz3r0
    @Misterz3r0 3 роки тому +77

    There's something really cute about being asked to be sued. It's such a 90s phrase. "HEY, I LIKE CHOCOLATE! SO SUE ME, OK! " lol
    You can tell the chatter was raised by Gen X parents.

    • @zuresei
      @zuresei 3 роки тому +5

      I don't doubt they're a millennial themselves.

  • @AllTheArtsy
    @AllTheArtsy 2 роки тому +31

    If that dude with anxiety lived in a walkable city, he'd have enough money to actually see a therapist

  • @niofalpha
    @niofalpha 3 роки тому +268

    “Alright, I’m super excited for this video.
    *Leaves*
    That’s the Sigma Male grindset

    • @nialllappin4159
      @nialllappin4159 3 роки тому +1

      Except transanabi is a single white female nails painted and all

    • @TheJevardo
      @TheJevardo 3 роки тому +18

      @@nialllappin4159 lol legit what a sigma would do though 😂🤣 ignores societal norms of male behavior and dress code

    • @Comuniity_
      @Comuniity_ 3 роки тому

      @@nialllappin4159 painting your nails is real sigma male behavior fuck you mean

    • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
      @cupriferouscatalyst3708 2 місяці тому

      He got too excited and had to pee lol

  • @RunningPen
    @RunningPen 3 роки тому +192

    That "sue me" comment was hella cringe. Walkable cities doesn't mean "no cars." C'mon.

    • @maeschder
      @maeschder 3 роки тому +63

      Also if he "needs" nightly hour long drives, he needs therapy or a change in lifestyle, not a car.
      Also all the stuff he mentions about access to cities should be part of the transit planning OBVIOUSLY.
      No one is saying "we need more public transport" and only means "more trams in cities" (whether it be for infrastructure or climate change reasons).

    • @alcabone1126
      @alcabone1126 3 роки тому +51

      @@maeschder you can have nightly rides on a bicycle lol, it also provides you with exercise. If a city is designed with bicycle paths then you don't have to worry about being run over.

    • @ZealothPL
      @ZealothPL 3 роки тому +12

      It depends
      We can't pretend it doesn't mean way less cars though
      Just own it. There simply isn't enough room in cities for parking for everyone to drive a 2 ton box everywhere. If you really want to do that, just get ready to sit in traffic on one or two lanes (vs 20) as busses and trams speed past you on dedicated lanes. There isn't really any other way.

    • @imChabs
      @imChabs 3 роки тому +2

      It's a recurring and exhausting fallacy... Either they're being extremely disengenuous, or absolutely deluded.

    • @khailils446
      @khailils446 3 роки тому

      @@alcabone1126 Yeah, instead you have to worry about nutjobs robbing or killing you.

  • @yahwehvii6059
    @yahwehvii6059 3 роки тому +163

    Owning a car would be a lot nicer if I didn’t have to throw money at it so often cause of all the commuting I have to do. Sure, I could make more money or fix it myself but we need all day public transit. It’s senseless to make life so inconvenient for not having a vehicle.

    • @rodolfodoce
      @rodolfodoce 3 роки тому +20

      why do you hate freedom?
      owning a car is literal freedom in north american culture, you hate us for our freedumb…./s

    • @roxqu
      @roxqu 3 роки тому +18

      @@rodolfodoce DAMN RIGHT, OUR CARS IS A RIGHT, SCREW THOSE LIBERALS

    • @shroomzie
      @shroomzie 3 роки тому +8

      like the guy said man people are so addicted and blinded by car dependency they can’t even COMPREHEND a city that is built more for humans. it’s literally unteachable to some americans it’s DESPICABLE 😂

    • @co2_os
      @co2_os 3 роки тому +4

      Middle eastern gulf countries are like that but on steroids, and it's full of maniacs that don't even respect traffic laws. Fuck me I need to leave asap.

    • @yahwehvii6059
      @yahwehvii6059 3 роки тому +1

      @@co2_os I think may have seen evidence of that somewhere. It looked like a free for all. Stay safe.

  • @theaskew
    @theaskew 3 роки тому +68

    As a Houston native, I can confirm that driving fucking SUCKS here. The culture is dope tho

    • @Mysterical01
      @Mysterical01 3 роки тому

      It is literally a nightmare lol. I agree there's a lot to love though.

    • @illestnino1
      @illestnino1 3 роки тому +1

      45 is the worst.

    • @BeastyBite
      @BeastyBite 3 роки тому +5

      is driving the culture?

    • @DarkestKnightshade
      @DarkestKnightshade 3 роки тому

      @@BeastyBitenah

    • @JohnDoe-rg4tl
      @JohnDoe-rg4tl 3 роки тому +1

      leave houston and go to a shitty blue state

  • @theawoken7914
    @theawoken7914 3 роки тому +35

    That’s why I like New York City as bad as much of it is you literally don’t need a car and the sidewalks are as big as lanes

  • @harshh9000
    @harshh9000 3 роки тому +64

    urban planning arc possibly one of my favorites from azan

  • @0Caracalla
    @0Caracalla 3 роки тому +60

    Houston could have put a lot of local rails in certain areas but they never did. They could've also put a train like back in the day going from Houston to Galveston. Houston just builds endless roads

  • @martinn.6082
    @martinn.6082 2 роки тому +14

    "Bro I need a car to go on nightly drives for an hour to sort my thoughts."
    Weird take

    • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
      @cupriferouscatalyst3708 2 місяці тому +1

      American anxiety is the weirdest. And it's sad; I do sympathize. Everyone seems to live in their own isolated fortress, and they seem to think that they'll immediately get shot unless they sit inside a smaller fortress when not in their bigger fortress. I guess that is the settler colonial mentality though.

  • @andreisidro6544
    @andreisidro6544 3 роки тому +69

    I dropped out of urban planning on my 4th year but some stuff about the way american cities were designed really stuck with me such as
    - Most cars are used for about 40min to 1h a day, so the other 23h of the day they are doing nothing but taking up space.
    - Cities like NY, while with a good public transportation network, have their own share of problems, such as the fact that in some streets the buildings are so tall it blocks light from entering the street for most of the day. That's one of the reasons why most european cities have height restrictions on their buildings.
    - When you do new urban developments it should be mandatory to have a mix of luxury, affordable and public housing and you want to equipt them with public squares, libraries, schools, theatres and so on to be used by all of its residents. That way rich people will directly invest in the community and this will improve chances of social mobility. From what I heard, american ghettos are the opposite of that

    • @billson9256
      @billson9256 2 роки тому +1

      one example in north america where you also have a height limit is montreal, you cannot make a building that excedes the height of the mont royal (233m)

  • @timothygroten4193
    @timothygroten4193 3 роки тому +25

    “Let’s slap some more lanes on that!”
    I live in Houston and am passionate about urban design. I literally died when you said that 😂😂

  • @Larryboy2701
    @Larryboy2701 3 роки тому +141

    Not Just Bikes is sooooo good

    • @gabrielchristy7341
      @gabrielchristy7341 3 роки тому +4

      I really wanna see a more explicitly leftist discussion of urban planning. Like looking at lefty planning from history. (Vienna, Mondragon, sewer socialism in the US, Soviet planning, Cuban planning, or any city planning/reconstruction in Rojava (i wonder if they have highly democratic urban planning too)) also look at urban planning in imperialist cities, how was Hongkong designed under the Brits? Or Delhi, or some of the French colonial capitals in N. Africa.

    • @gabrielchristy7341
      @gabrielchristy7341 3 роки тому +3

      But also, yes, NJB rocks.

    • @Larryboy2701
      @Larryboy2701 3 роки тому +11

      @@gabrielchristy7341 Yes, and. Lol
      Eco Gecko has a very good series about how the suburbs are horrible for a multitude and it is explicitly leftist. NJB is just implicitly leftist.

    • @fnfal6286
      @fnfal6286 3 роки тому +1

      @@gabrielchristy7341 can City planning be left or right? For me its just good or bad City planning

    • @osl5686
      @osl5686 3 роки тому +1

      Cars are sometimes not checking for pedestrians...nor bikers. I think cyclists have it the worse especially when roadrage is involved.

  • @robynreanimates3503
    @robynreanimates3503 3 роки тому +16

    Having walkable cities doesn't mean abolishing cars. I'm in support of all of this and I'm a fucking driving instructor. All it would do is make my job safer

    • @xenotiic8356
      @xenotiic8356 3 роки тому +1

      I love your pfp holy shit. The Kanna hair with the rat head is amazing.

    • @robynreanimates3503
      @robynreanimates3503 3 роки тому

      @@xenotiic8356
      Thanks! Pretty proud of it tbh

  • @Blackrain7070
    @Blackrain7070 3 роки тому +56

    Hasan's discussions with chats non-american audience, like with the person who asked if we have bike lanes, kinda makes me wish Hasan would go on a Google Street view tour of Los angeles and show/describe the area for people who have never been there. How unnecessarily spread out everything is and how little consideration there is for any form of moving around that ISNT by car

  • @LKNardo
    @LKNardo 3 роки тому +37

    Went to the Netherlands once for my best friends wedding and now I’m trying to figure out how to move there. Seriously, it’s so beautiful and pedestrian friendly, which is why I loved it so much.

    • @TheOrangVegetal
      @TheOrangVegetal 3 роки тому +6

      It can be kinda hard to find a house here since there is a huuuge housing shortage nationwide. Try to avoid the randstad area if you dont want to sell both of your kidneys in order to buy a house lol

    • @LKNardo
      @LKNardo 3 роки тому +3

      @@TheOrangVegetal my friends bought outside Haarlem city center for half a million euros. But it’s a house they can grow into, took a long time to find one though. Honestly in the small I live in, the housing market is so competitive it took us months to be accepted for an offer. Seems housing is just hard to come by in a lot of places lately.

    • @weetikissa
      @weetikissa 3 роки тому

      @@TheOrangVegetal North America is just as bad if not way worse.

  • @spillikyn9128
    @spillikyn9128 3 роки тому +41

    i remember walking to the gas station nearest to my house for the first time this summer. I've lived in the same house for 6 years, and that gas station was always such a quick stop for anything while driving, so i thought it wouldn't be that bad to walk there. "its right up the road." except, as i was walking i realized that cars could drive 45 mph down this road, with absolutely zero sidewalk in many places, and at one point a random "crosswalk" that not a single car acknowledged was there. Not only that, but the fact that i realized in order for a carless household to get food, they would need to travel not only that road, but a highway without any sidewalks to get their produce, and not even good produce. It pisses me off so much that cities and towns have zero consideration for any individuals anymore, and instead focus on business (i'n my town's case, tourism).

    • @earlaweese
      @earlaweese 2 роки тому +3

      *I HAVE BEEN SUFFERING IN THIS CITY FOR YEARS. I HATE IT.*

  • @ChrisSudlik
    @ChrisSudlik 3 роки тому +32

    Not Just Bikes, City Beautiful, Strong Towns are amazingly interesting, great channels that everyone should watch, it's taught me so much about the city where I live.

  • @kinfmin443
    @kinfmin443 3 роки тому +11

    The city skyline noises near the end of the video, now I feel bad for destroying all those houses just to build new highways 💀

  • @taylorwaterman7316
    @taylorwaterman7316 3 роки тому +19

    There are SOME bike lanes in LA but yeah biking in LA is taking your life into your own hands since NO ONE IN LA CAN DRIVE.

    • @xenotiic8356
      @xenotiic8356 3 роки тому +3

      I can't afford a car, so I bike, and yeah it is scary sometimes, even though I don't live in a super busy part of LA.

  • @laughingatnothing4642
    @laughingatnothing4642 3 роки тому +14

    I am Studying Urban Planning (in India) and american suburbs are often cited as planning failures.

    • @Saturn_Rising
      @Saturn_Rising 3 роки тому +6

      lmao good. it's awful to live in American suburbs

    • @SKAOG21
      @SKAOG21 Рік тому +1

      rightfully so, India is much more walkable, and people are not obsessed with 4 tonne pickup trucks

  • @joebarnhart1691
    @joebarnhart1691 2 роки тому +8

    In Houston, pedestrians are seen as poor losers, which feed into the narrative that if your poor in the U.S. then it's your fault. Your low status is of your own doing and therefore they don't care about you. Public transportation is provided at minimum cost for those poor so they can eventually get to their minimum wage jobs provided for the EMPLOYERS convenience.

  • @martinn.6082
    @martinn.6082 3 роки тому +26

    I live in Berlin, Germany and I went to LA once. It's insane how bad transit is there. The commuter train is smaller than some airport trains.

    • @GC-yw1mn
      @GC-yw1mn 3 роки тому +7

      LA is transit is utter shit, but it isn’t like that everywhere. I live in Chicago, and transit is actually great. It’s consistently on time, and I’ve never been in train or bus that has broken down. I also have never had this kind of sidewalk problem. It’s a suburbia problem.

  • @toniderdon
    @toniderdon 2 роки тому +13

    I'm so pissed about some of the ignorant american comments in his chat:
    Someone literally asked "Why don't they just get a car then, there are so many cheap ones?"
    And someone else asked "Why is that a problem?"
    Is education really that bad in the US or are people blind on both eyes like wtfff is wrong with some people in the chat

    • @BramLastname
      @BramLastname 9 місяців тому +1

      The best response I've heard to that is
      "Well I thought about getting an audiobook, but I guess driving a car never killed anyone. Guidedog fetch my cane, this commenter is gonna teach me how to drive."

  • @connerreimers6506
    @connerreimers6506 3 роки тому +12

    holy shit I literally live exactly where that dude is walking through Houston. Literally 10 minutes from that BestBuy Whataburger and Discount Tire

  • @cathsaigh2197
    @cathsaigh2197 3 роки тому +10

    Imagine all the room that would be saved if those Houston parking lots were replaced with something useful.

  • @angusmarch1066
    @angusmarch1066 3 роки тому +19

    'God' bless the London Underground and TFL. I really underestimated how important it was until I realised that some other cities didnt even have buses.

  • @rainbowappleslice
    @rainbowappleslice 2 роки тому +6

    You know it’s bad in US cities when you can’t tell what a bike lane is

  • @owencole5774
    @owencole5774 3 роки тому +11

    I have to drive 45 minutes to my school and 45 minutes back. This is in Austin.

  • @christophercrawford3263
    @christophercrawford3263 3 роки тому +16

    Dude Not Just Bikes is easily the best urban planning video out there. Freaking love this channel

  • @Tengokujin
    @Tengokujin 3 роки тому +11

    23:10 I enjoy that Hasan tries to "um, actually" with "flood plains" in response to literal reclaimed land that's *below* sea level.
    He probably should've lead with "Look, the Netherlands actually have their shit together and hold back their flooding, unlike Houston, which is located on massive flood plains."

  • @Levaaant
    @Levaaant Рік тому +1

    "I'm very excited for this video"
    Immediately gets up and leaves once it starts

  • @inventor4279
    @inventor4279 Рік тому +12

    Its insane to me Americans dont realize in most of the world people can just......walk

  • @chiphill4856
    @chiphill4856 3 роки тому +12

    A good design takes the same amount of effort as bad design. And usually less expensive to build.

  • @stewart2589
    @stewart2589 2 роки тому +4

    Anyone who says car=personal freedom has never had personal freedom before

  • @jamirholmes1030
    @jamirholmes1030 3 роки тому +12

    When Hasan said “If you’re thinking ‘Damn this looks like my suburb in Missouri”, I flipped. I live near St. Louis and walk 2 miles to work everyday. I have to jaywalk to efficiently get to work since so many sidewalks just end with no alternative besides two awkward crosswalks that are a quarter mile back. It’s frustrating knowing this is a problem in so many other cities. Don’t get me started on right on red lights >:(

    • @Adanmacreates
      @Adanmacreates 3 роки тому +1

      SAME also in STL and it sucked getting to work. I am trying to keep my job remote now lol

  • @delltuh
    @delltuh 3 роки тому +5

    i live in houston and i didn’t realize in other cities you could walk places at all until i traveled out of houston for the first time, and while young i thougjt that only the homeless walked, and that busses and trains didn’t exist in america. it’s sad, and it’s still super bad.

  • @hello7032
    @hello7032 3 роки тому +17

    It might be cause I’m getting old, but seeing the set up in the Netherlands was so satisfying, I want to live there

    • @jorisessen8410
      @jorisessen8410 3 роки тому +3

      why does age matter? i think it looks better for all ages

    • @hello7032
      @hello7032 3 роки тому +1

      @@jorisessen8410 should’ve elaborated more, just by how much I got excited by it

    • @hello7032
      @hello7032 3 роки тому

      @L M happy for you

    • @martjinnova5300
      @martjinnova5300 3 роки тому

      @L M Should be, I have been to the Netherlands several times and I always want to stay when I visit my friends.

    • @nuuwnhuus
      @nuuwnhuus 3 роки тому +2

      I believe not just bikes has a video on why it's better for kids even. Age doesn't matter it's just simply better.

  • @o0Avalon0o
    @o0Avalon0o 3 роки тому +6

    The rich old city I stayed in (for a summer job with my friends) had decent sidewalks, but then had huge "hail Mary" crossings where you'd be lucky to make it across all the lanes safety.

  • @WolfNamedJohn
    @WolfNamedJohn 3 роки тому +8

    Memes aside, Houstonians immediately hated the I-10 expansion and are equally not happy with the city's plans for 59(69) apart from the repair of the road itself because they've been extremely slow fixing all the damage on it over the last 20 years.

  • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
    @cupriferouscatalyst3708 2 місяці тому +1

    I didn't actually think the sidewalks in LA were particularly bad when I lived there. My issue was more that the sprawl makes walking so freaking boring (and time-consuming, obviously). For those who haven't been, it's basically GTA V's Los Santos except there are 10-50 blocks of copy-paste housing grids between every single recognizable landmark.

  • @berndb3141
    @berndb3141 3 роки тому +10

    As someone who lives in a rural area in Germany I apreciate mixed zone housing a lot. Puplic transportation is bad and this helps a lot. You don't have to drive everywhere, you can walk to a lot of places or go on a short drive if you have a car. I have a car but I also can walk to where I need to be without puting myself in danger.

    • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
      @cupriferouscatalyst3708 2 місяці тому

      "Mixed zone housing", or as we call it everywhere on the planet except in the United States: "housing".

  • @emilioparrilla465
    @emilioparrilla465 3 місяці тому +1

    "Don't you have bike lanes?"
    Sometimes they let us ride in the gutter next to the cars :)

  • @adameliezer4723
    @adameliezer4723 3 роки тому +5

    Lmao its all fun and games until you realize you know exactly where he's filming

    • @adameliezer4723
      @adameliezer4723 3 роки тому +1

      Also why I now go to college smack dab in the middle of the city in Philly. Can get anywhere I want walking/public transit.

  • @cobalfrostwyrm
    @cobalfrostwyrm 3 роки тому +3

    "excited for this video"
    -fucks off to piss.
    -eats noisily
    -goes of on barely related tangents

    • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
      @cupriferouscatalyst3708 2 місяці тому

      Yes? That's what excited people do. Pee, make noise, and ramble. I'm sorry you've never been excited :/

    • @cobalfrostwyrm
      @cobalfrostwyrm 2 місяці тому

      @@cupriferouscatalyst3708 nah mate thats what inconsiderate people pretending excitement for views do. Guy is phoning it in and being disgusting.

    • @cupriferouscatalyst3708
      @cupriferouscatalyst3708 2 місяці тому

      @@cobalfrostwyrm yeah a guy who only cares about views would definitely leave in the middle of his own stream 😂😂😂 Why don't you go and watch someone whose content you actually enjoy? Life is short, man.

  • @arwynstar
    @arwynstar 3 роки тому +10

    Man, I saw a video recently on the roads in Denmark being more pedestrian-centric. It looked wonderful- would cut down on speeding and people running lights as well as keep walkers safer.

  • @heyyou1911
    @heyyou1911 3 роки тому +9

    Grew up in houston and i really dont like walking for this reason. Its just hot and sketchy.

  • @Benjrun123
    @Benjrun123 3 роки тому +4

    "I'm so excited to watch this" *leaves immediately*

  • @raney150
    @raney150 3 роки тому +7

    Toronto is probably so high on that list because of the trams that aren't on the subway map. Without the trams, Chicago would kick Toronto's ass. Which is why I wish Chicago would also build a tram network that integrated well with the L. It could make the L so much better.

  • @celestia849
    @celestia849 3 роки тому +3

    I’m from Scotland and when my family and I would walk to places in Florida and we apparently got weird looks for just walk and I remember times there was no pavement and our confusion about the lack the of pavements

  • @HiopX
    @HiopX 3 роки тому +4

    Houston needs a 420 lane highway

  • @gisellecolon3380
    @gisellecolon3380 3 роки тому +20

    I live 2 min from that area in Houston. It’s a great city in terms of culture. Our streets are so trash.

    • @98981danny
      @98981danny 3 роки тому

      They picked one of the best streets to shit on too lol 1960 sucks 💀

    • @crashban10
      @crashban10 3 роки тому +1

      They can make a whole documentary about I-45 and why it sucks

    • @98981danny
      @98981danny 3 роки тому +1

      @@crashban10 or 610 near the galleria area 😷

    • @fuglong
      @fuglong 3 роки тому

      Hell yeah bruther southern culture, skee yee

  • @Shinius
    @Shinius 3 роки тому +4

    17:20 From Winnipeg, did not expect to be savaged on the HasanAbi channel.

  • @autohmae
    @autohmae 2 роки тому +2

    4:35 sorry, but the person in the chat would probably actually like living in a well designed city and just use their bike to go to work

    • @autohmae
      @autohmae 2 роки тому +1

      23:33 well, the Netherlands solved floods too. And Amsterdam is also swamp land.

  • @sdmpx
    @sdmpx 3 роки тому +2

    Yelling at my phone because he’s hovering over the subscribe button but not clicking it.

  • @_-_sinexus_-_
    @_-_sinexus_-_ 3 роки тому +4

    Whoever said "Unlondon monkaW" in chat when he mentionened his home town at the beginning wins the internet today

  • @dianas.3892
    @dianas.3892 3 роки тому +12

    Portland, OR and Portland proper has sidewalks. We also have great public transportation thats reliable.

    • @joenuts5167
      @joenuts5167 3 роки тому +2

      Yes we do. One of the only things I like about living here

    • @HH-le1vi
      @HH-le1vi 3 роки тому

      And lots of rioting

    • @Saturn_Rising
      @Saturn_Rising 3 роки тому

      @@HH-le1vi 😐

  • @ellies741
    @ellies741 3 роки тому +6

    Ah, brings back memories of being the only nutjob walking in Houston...

    • @Saturn_Rising
      @Saturn_Rising 3 роки тому

      what was it like?

    • @ellies741
      @ellies741 3 роки тому +7

      @@Saturn_Rising hell lol, no seriously, at points you do run out of sidewalks, people look at you funny and taking a cool drink for the journey is a must if you don't wanna pass out from the heat.

  • @GentlemensClubHolyEdition
    @GentlemensClubHolyEdition Рік тому +1

    As an Australian I can tell you we should not be in the top ten most livable cities in the world

  • @bbqseitan7106
    @bbqseitan7106 3 роки тому +15

    Austin TX is working on expanding its rail and bus system to a wholistic extent, as in round the clock service AND building a subway
    Super stoked

    • @hello7032
      @hello7032 3 роки тому

      Glad to hear it

    • @JohnDoe-rg4tl
      @JohnDoe-rg4tl 3 роки тому +1

      move to a blue state shitters. Stay outta the better red states

    • @hello7032
      @hello7032 3 роки тому +2

      @@JohnDoe-rg4tl okay John Doe. Do explain what glorious red states we should leave?

    • @bbqseitan7106
      @bbqseitan7106 3 роки тому +6

      @@JohnDoe-rg4tl the only red state that isn’t a drain on the federal govt, that actually pulls its weight, is TX and that’s because the BLUE cities generate all the money and are the hubs
      No one comes to Texas to live in Wichita Falls

    • @McFwoupson
      @McFwoupson 3 роки тому

      They're also planning on widening i-35 by a large margin though which is an absolutely horrible idea bc adding more lanes doesn't work. It's also a 4 billion dollar project. Won't fix anything.

  • @BeastyBite
    @BeastyBite 3 роки тому +4

    my european ass doesn't even have a drivers license. I'm 27 lol

  • @eddiepollau4577
    @eddiepollau4577 3 роки тому +3

    Stayed in Davis, CA for a bit while touring colleges & rented bikes with my family. It was mind blowing to see so many ppl using bikes in an American city. It’s the only place I’ve seen in the US where that’s the norm. Wish this were common everywhere like in the Netherlands.

  • @joshuak8194
    @joshuak8194 3 роки тому +6

    My cousins from Europe explained this to me when I was like 10 and I never forgave America

  • @monsoonmast
    @monsoonmast 3 роки тому +4

    Its way worse though. Eco Gecko has a great series of video essays on it.

  • @snowless456
    @snowless456 Рік тому +2

    Shout out to NotJustBikes for radicalizing me even though I live in NYC

  • @raymondflores1583
    @raymondflores1583 3 роки тому +6

    I deadass live in this area of Houston and it’s so funny watching this guy roasts tf outta my city planning just bc he had to work from one end of a shopping center to the other end lmaoo

    • @Saturn_Rising
      @Saturn_Rising 3 роки тому

      is it not as bad as he says

    • @nuuwnhuus
      @nuuwnhuus 3 роки тому +10

      @@Saturn_Rising Literally every frame he shot in Houston showed things that aren't acceptable lol.

    • @GeneralPuppet
      @GeneralPuppet 2 роки тому +4

      @@Saturn_Rising It is as bad as it seems

  • @Hinderz
    @Hinderz 3 роки тому +8

    Those most liveable cities list always end up with a bunch of Australian cities because of soft factors like weather/days of sunshine plus the usual unemployment rate, higher education, and social safety nets (universal healthcare etc) except for Melbourne (which kept its tram network when the car manufacturers came to Australia) they are all car centric as hell though.

  • @ironickrempt
    @ironickrempt 3 роки тому +2

    My city has a walk score of 28. Bike score of 34 and no transit score because we don’t have that. The sidewalks and “bike lanes” are dangerously tiny and intermittent, they are generally so close to the road they look like a gutter. American urban planning is such a nightmare.

  • @hilmarnicolay7234
    @hilmarnicolay7234 Рік тому +1

    Saddest thing about this is that it's not too long ago that the US had everything we praise Europe for.

  • @AlexCab_49
    @AlexCab_49 3 роки тому +4

    I live in the San Fernando Valley and there's also arterial streets w/o sidwalks and I was once forced to walk out into the street with fast cars. The only city in California that isn't car centric and is very walkable is San Francisco, but it's too expensive to live in and I don't have a good reason to move there. I also don't really want to leave LA. But the city is improving, just at a snails pace.

    • @xenotiic8356
      @xenotiic8356 3 роки тому

      Totally relatable dude. I also live in the valley, and a hilly area at that, but I don't have the money or license to maintain a car, so I've opted to bike. Things are getting better, especially after the passage of Measure M, but for now I have to manage dodging traffic across wide, hilly 50 mph stroads with crappy sidewalks and bike lanes that often have road rubble in them.

    • @AlexCab_49
      @AlexCab_49 3 роки тому

      @@xenotiic8356 I live in the western part of the valley and it's very suburban here and also boring. I might move to Van Nuys or NoHo area since it's denser and have more things in walking distance and better transit. I also like San Fernando too.

  • @radiationshepherd
    @radiationshepherd 3 роки тому +2

    I remember trying to bike to my towns mall as a teen and realizing the only possible way there required me to cross a busy freeway with no crosswalk. And since then I noticed people trying to get to their jobs at this mall dashing accross the same area

  • @nubnooblet
    @nubnooblet Рік тому +1

    i live in fake london and its so weird seeing the streets and intersections i just drove on like 30 minutes ago in a hasan reaction video.
    also, of course he got up and didnt even see those fake london streets

  • @frontrowviews
    @frontrowviews Рік тому +2

    This video shows why people call America a third world country with a Gucci belt

  • @yyyyaaarrr
    @yyyyaaarrr 3 роки тому +4

    Big brain moment: get rid of the city and build more roads = less traffic 😱

  • @soulwarsnerd
    @soulwarsnerd 3 роки тому +11

    Not just bikes is a good ass channel

  • @weirdfish1216
    @weirdfish1216 3 роки тому +2

    yes i love not just bikes i’m so glad hasan watched them

  • @viktorparvanov8863
    @viktorparvanov8863 3 роки тому +5

    Well the delta works protect the Netherlands from flooding but Texas wouldn't spend money on public infrastructure, where's the profit brother?

  • @jeremeh911
    @jeremeh911 2 роки тому +1

    i love how hasan doesnt understand the rankings of livable cities. its why a third of aussie citizens werent born in australia, we came here cause its good stuff mate.

  • @danielfrisk925
    @danielfrisk925 Рік тому

    30:44 Great idea to build the highways straight through the city, huh? Ontop of the polution, noise

  • @YahBoiMocha
    @YahBoiMocha Рік тому

    So error on the video. Pin Oak is not off the Katy Freeway. It is off 59 (now nationally called 69) and it goes SW and NW not East and West which is a pretty big difference in Houston.

  • @dragonslaya16
    @dragonslaya16 3 роки тому +2

    Bruh wait till he sees Florida lol

  • @Mr___f
    @Mr___f 3 роки тому +1

    I live in one of the most walkable cities in the US and even here I had to follow the dirt path in the grass to walk to the mall...

  • @Ryan-fc1yt
    @Ryan-fc1yt 3 роки тому +2

    I agree with the chatter in that I too enjoy night drives lol. I actually find it some what enjoyable to drive on the interstate long distance. This is contrasted by making it to a city and finding it extremely hard to navigate and immediately being filled with anxiety with trying to watch out for pedestrians and the other cars. Basically I like the drive to my destination but once there I wished I had just flown and relied on the public transit there.