This is going nowhere and will never be solved. It's clearly not any investigating agency's failure rather involvement of someone influential and close to TMC.
From the beginning... There r questions raised on crime scene... Even from the pictures out... People can clearly make it there in no struggle in crime scene... And also forensic report is changed twice... Tampering of evidence happened... Whom r the kolkata police protecting... And y CBI has not considered the site of crime... If the body is brought to seminar hall.. Can it be done by 1 person as off... Complete mess by entire police and judicial system... Trying to protect people in power...
Forensic report even mentions that there r no biological stains found in crime scene... How can that happen... Even looking the severity of injuries and struggle done by victim... People in India r not fools... Even court tried to prove sanjoy roy as culprit ... Everyone knows wt happened... Mamtha banerjee is jst trying to protect her party only by not proving that crime happened with her assistance... No one believes u mamtha banerjee... Porn star of West Bengal... Better profession suitable to mamtha banerjee
Barkha , first of all let me say that just like you I too have been following this tragic case and there is no doubt that it’s a horrific incident. But at the same time I too have questions pertaining to this issue. Why was she the only one to have been a target for this when there are other young women who have been working and are still working in the same hospital premise? The first lawyer Mr Bhattacharya was asked to leave the case by the parents and the relatives of the girl and vrinda Grover joined in as a lead advocate. Now we hear that Ms Grover has withdrawn from this as well. What could be the possible reason/s for this decision that makes me wonder if there is something in the closet that we don’t know of. Being empathetic is humane but logical explanations are somewhat more important. Maybe there is more in the case than what meets the eye?
@@sunayanadattaghosh2931 you should be ashamed for making such statements.. there are many more cases of suspected sucide in the r.g kar hospital in previous years. If you don't know just check the facts. As for the lawyer mrs. Grover she was handling it very poorly. The victims parents said repeatedly that cbi is not informing anything regarding the case even after sc order. They were highly disappointed as the two main accused in tampering evidence got bail. It was duty of the lawyer to raise concern legally but she didn't do it instead she ditched the case . So I think there's no mystery why victim is not getting justice except you wish turn an blind eye to the actual reason.
If we remember the CBI had suggested shifting investigation of R G Kar case to another state, which ex CJI had rejected. There must be some vital reason behind CBI's seeking permission for shifting the case to another state.
It’s such a shame to live in a country where justice doesn’t prevail!! The common man’s life is of no value to these power hungry politicians But there is a God above who watches all that transpires & His wrath & judgement will surely fall on the perpetrators of this horrific crime Their end will be agonising & horrible for sure
There appears to be some kind of direct political pressure.We are all blindly criticising the CBI team led by an experienced,reputed expert like IPS Seema Pahuja, by making derogatory statements. But,if we can all recall, we would realise it is CBI Team who had raised concerns like possibility of tampering and alteration of evidences, could be a part of larger conspiracy and a preplanned murder, seminar room may not be the place of occurrence of crime, financial irregularities may have been escalated by Sandip Ghosh in other state hospitals,etc. CBI had religiously submitted their status reports of investigations in sealed envelopes to Supreme Court, reading which ex CJI had remarked that the case is disturbing and he had not seen such a report ever in his 30 years of practice. This was seen in live streaming. We should think now as to what could be the possibe reason behind the same CBI team not taking much of an action now, unable to handover chargesheets, and has become silent despite of accusations,etc.? This could be perhaps because there is some kind of understanding between 2 political leaders of 2 political parties.CBI is probably under tremendous political pressure from the Centre,not to disclose big names. Political interference could also be the reason behind the withdrawing of a reputed and senior advocate as Vrinda Grover from the case. It seems to be all the more apparent because we did not hear the PM and Home Minister making a single statement on R G Kar case, which had shaken the country.BJP at the Centre is not in sync with state bjp.We saw the Home Minister, in his visit to Bengal at Petropol border, lecturing for 1 hour, asking people to vote BJP to power in Bengal in 2026, but could not spare 5 mins to meet R G Kar victim's parents who had requested a meet with Home Minister, without paying heed to state bjp 's requests regarding the same.It seems the only interest and objective of Central BJP is to get more members in the party from Bengal and to come to power in Bengal. They have got nothing to do or say against the gruesome and brutal murder and rape of Abhoya , which has shaken the world. Had the Central and State BJP joined unitedly to find out the criminals , Abhoya and her parents could get justice. The state govt did not give CBI NOC for issuing chargesheets as both Sandip Ghosh and Abhijit Mondal were state govt employees, and hence NOC was required from state govt . Moreover, several doctors of RGKar are involved in the crime, and their counterparts,nurses,staff,etc must have been well aware as to who all are guilty, but they have chosen to stay tight lipped and not cooperate with CBI.They are rather interested to criticise CBI. 3 things to ponder on... 1st, is IPS Seema Pahuja feeling uneasy (which is natural )to interrogate another IPS officer, Vineet Goyal,who is directly connected with the case ? Or, she has been asked not to, due to political reasons? 2nd, the CFSL report was handed over by the team to CBI on 11th September, which may have been probably handed over to SC by CBI . So, none other than CBI and SC had access to the report. Then, why has CBI disclosed the report now ? And why CBI ignored the findings of the CFSL report ? 3rd, CBI had been continuously submitting status reports to ex CJI, who did not even hint or disclose anything,anticipating that it would jeopardise the investigation. Then why was no instruction /action taken by SC for disclosure of already submitted status reports or why nothing was advised by SC to CBI?? The lady doctor has been a member of every household since 9th August , after her brutal and gruesome murder. She had been the only child of lower middleclass parents, whose lives have been shattered. Whole of India prays that justice be given to her parents and actual criminals be booked.
Barkha, don't know whether you know or not, when Sajay Rai was brought to the lower court in a prison van, he had shouted telling journalists that he has been framed, that he is innocent,etc, that the ex CP had pressurized him. This we saw and heard on television. From the next day, he was brought in with a convoy where Sanjay Rai could not be seen, with noise proof windows ,Kolkata police started honking continuously and tapping the top of the van so that even if Sanjay tried to divulge any names to media, he cannot be heard. Can u say why ?? What was so fearful ?
I had unfortunately looked at the photos on Instagram which were leaked by someone, and the scene looked much much different from how so many people were describing it to be. Earlier accounts stated that legs were twisted or blood was coming from the mouth or nose, but it wasn't the case.
Well, there is now no doubt that CBI as well as the SC are complicit in prolonging the case so that it ultimately moves away from public memory. We are now back to square one.
Again, you guys are at it...propogation of lies...why barkha ...why? You were so good...i feel so sad seeing the likes of you fall prey to propaganda and not facts in your struggle for relevance. Disheartened!!!
Mumtaz Begum should have been kicked out of office when this crime occurred. Why is she still there ? She has been bad news to W.Bengal a thug in many ways .
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
This is going nowhere and will never be solved. It's clearly not any investigating agency's failure rather involvement of someone influential and close to TMC.
From the beginning... There r questions raised on crime scene... Even from the pictures out... People can clearly make it there in no struggle in crime scene... And also forensic report is changed twice... Tampering of evidence happened... Whom r the kolkata police protecting... And y CBI has not considered the site of crime... If the body is brought to seminar hall.. Can it be done by 1 person as off... Complete mess by entire police and judicial system... Trying to protect people in power...
Forensic report even mentions that there r no biological stains found in crime scene... How can that happen... Even looking the severity of injuries and struggle done by victim... People in India r not fools... Even court tried to prove sanjoy roy as culprit ... Everyone knows wt happened... Mamtha banerjee is jst trying to protect her party only by not proving that crime happened with her assistance... No one believes u mamtha banerjee... Porn star of West Bengal... Better profession suitable to mamtha banerjee
Hold the government accountable. I feel so sad for the parents, where is the accountability??
Barkha , first of all let me say that just like you I too have been following this tragic case and there is no doubt that it’s a horrific incident. But at the same time I too have questions pertaining to this issue.
Why was she the only one to have been a target for this when there are other young women who have been working and are still working in the same hospital premise?
The first lawyer Mr Bhattacharya was asked to leave the case by the parents and the relatives of the girl and vrinda Grover joined in as a lead advocate.
Now we hear that Ms Grover has withdrawn from this as well.
What could be the possible reason/s for this decision that makes me wonder if there is something in the closet that we don’t know of.
Being empathetic is humane but logical explanations are somewhat more important.
Maybe there is more in the case than what meets the eye?
@@sunayanadattaghosh2931 you should be ashamed for making such statements.. there are many more cases of suspected sucide in the r.g kar hospital in previous years. If you don't know just check the facts. As for the lawyer mrs. Grover she was handling it very poorly. The victims parents said repeatedly that cbi is not informing anything regarding the case even after sc order. They were highly disappointed as the two main accused in tampering evidence got bail. It was duty of the lawyer to raise concern legally but she didn't do it instead she ditched the case . So I think there's no mystery why victim is not getting justice except you wish turn an blind eye to the actual reason.
Mamata Banerjee's phone call needs to be checked by CBI.
If we remember the CBI had suggested shifting investigation of R G Kar case to another state, which ex CJI had rejected. There must be some vital reason behind CBI's seeking permission for shifting the case to another state.
It’s such a shame to live in a country where justice doesn’t prevail!! The common man’s life is of no value to these power hungry politicians But there is a God above who watches all that transpires & His wrath & judgement will surely fall on the perpetrators of this horrific crime Their end will be agonising & horrible for sure
SC and CBI under extreme pressure....Center needs state's coop for polls..so....
There appears to be some kind of direct political pressure.We are all blindly criticising the CBI team led by an experienced,reputed expert like IPS Seema Pahuja, by making derogatory statements. But,if we can all recall, we would realise it is CBI Team who had raised concerns like possibility of tampering and alteration of evidences, could be a part of larger conspiracy and a preplanned murder, seminar room may not be the place of occurrence of crime, financial irregularities may have been escalated by Sandip Ghosh in other state hospitals,etc. CBI had religiously submitted their status reports of investigations in sealed envelopes to Supreme Court, reading which ex CJI had remarked that the case is disturbing and he had not seen such a report ever in his 30 years of practice. This was seen in live streaming.
We should think now as to what could be the possibe reason behind the same CBI team not taking much of an action now, unable to handover chargesheets, and has become silent despite of accusations,etc.? This could be perhaps because there is some kind of understanding between 2 political leaders of 2 political parties.CBI is probably under tremendous political pressure from the Centre,not to disclose big names. Political interference could also be the reason behind the withdrawing of a reputed and senior advocate as Vrinda Grover from the case. It seems to be all the more apparent because we did not hear the PM and Home Minister making a single statement on R G Kar case, which had shaken the country.BJP at the Centre is not in sync with state bjp.We saw the Home Minister, in his visit to Bengal at Petropol border, lecturing for 1 hour, asking people to vote BJP to power in Bengal in 2026, but could not spare 5 mins to meet R G Kar victim's parents who had requested a meet with Home Minister, without paying heed to state bjp 's requests regarding the same.It seems the only interest and objective of Central BJP is to get more members in the party from Bengal and to come to power in Bengal. They have got nothing to do or say against the gruesome and brutal murder and rape of Abhoya , which has shaken the world. Had the Central and State BJP joined unitedly to find out the criminals , Abhoya and her parents could get justice.
The state govt did not give CBI NOC for issuing chargesheets as both Sandip Ghosh and Abhijit Mondal were state govt employees, and hence NOC was required from state govt .
Moreover, several doctors of RGKar are involved in the crime, and their counterparts,nurses,staff,etc must have been well aware as to who all are guilty, but they have chosen to stay tight lipped and not cooperate with CBI.They are rather interested to criticise CBI.
3 things to ponder on...
1st, is IPS Seema Pahuja feeling uneasy (which is natural )to interrogate another IPS officer, Vineet Goyal,who is directly connected with the case ? Or, she has been asked not to, due to political reasons?
2nd, the CFSL report was handed over by the team to CBI on 11th September, which may have been probably handed over to SC by CBI . So, none other than CBI and SC had access to the report. Then, why has CBI disclosed the report now ? And why CBI ignored the findings of the CFSL report ?
3rd, CBI had been continuously submitting status reports to ex CJI, who did not even hint or disclose anything,anticipating that it would jeopardise the investigation. Then why was no instruction /action taken by SC for disclosure of already submitted status reports or why nothing was advised by SC to CBI??
The lady doctor has been a member of every household since 9th August , after her brutal and gruesome murder. She had been the only child of lower middleclass parents, whose lives have been shattered. Whole of India prays that justice be given to her parents and actual criminals be booked.
The people of Bengal deserve this type of justice when they elect such government.
Beeing a central agency and controlled by central govt CBI will not take any action against Bengal's rape & murder case , corruption etc .
I am really disappointed in the country that I love, there is a want of overhaul of the entire system.
Yes, let SC inform Indian citizens what status reports CBI has handed over to them in sealed envelopes
Barkha, don't know whether you know or not, when Sajay Rai was brought to the lower court in a prison van, he had shouted telling journalists that he has been framed, that he is innocent,etc, that the ex CP had pressurized him. This we saw and heard on television. From the next day, he was brought in with a convoy where Sanjay Rai could not be seen, with noise proof windows ,Kolkata police started honking continuously and tapping the top of the van so that even if Sanjay tried to divulge any names to media, he cannot be heard. Can u say why ?? What was so fearful ?
I had unfortunately looked at the photos on Instagram which were leaked by someone, and the scene looked much much different from how so many people were describing it to be. Earlier accounts stated that legs were twisted or blood was coming from the mouth or nose, but it wasn't the case.
Why isnt the Central Govt intervening so that the poor girl and her parents get justice ? Or, they donot want so ?
Some kind of understanding between the leaders of 2 political parties. CBI and judiciary under tremendous political pressure.
What does Firebrand Mahua Moitra have to say about it?
Does she get paid for it? Follow the money
It is questionable as to whether CBI is competent enough to deal with the sensitive issue?
Public and journalists were too quick to politicise the crime….
Shame on state & central governments for distorting the facts and protecting criminals. This can happen only in Ram Janam Bhoomi … INDIA 🙏🏼.
Well, there is now no doubt that CBI as well as the SC are complicit in prolonging the case so that it ultimately moves away from public memory. We are now back to square one.
Please share the new report repeatedly highlighted by Dr. Sarkar.
Is confusion confounded deliberately?
Wat is the prime minister doing ? Hasn't he got a daughter? Can't he feel the pain of the parents?
Again, you guys are at it...propogation of lies...why barkha ...why? You were so good...i feel so sad seeing the likes of you fall prey to propaganda and not facts in your struggle for relevance.
Disheartened!!!
Brkha? Good? When?!
Mumtaz Begum should have been kicked out of office when this crime occurred. Why is she still there ? She has been bad news to W.Bengal a thug in many ways .