Stand Mixer Creaming Method in Baking | KitchenAid Classic Plus vs Kenmore Ovation

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 61

  • @barbarajohnson7782
    @barbarajohnson7782 2 роки тому +8

    I am so happy the KitchenAid won your contest! I bought mine from QVC in April 2020 and it came with all the attachments including the Flex Edge Beater which helps with scraping the sides. It also came with the clear plastic Pour Shield so you can pour ingredients into the mixer while it’s running and you don’t end up wearing your flour mixture. I am surprised that Sears is still around. I know many stores have closed and they are contracting out things they used to do. So sad. Great video Amy, thanks.

    • @province312
      @province312 2 роки тому

      KitchenAid mixer are tops now for certain one they have a pastry beater which going to get one for my 7 quart pro stand mixer.

  • @CShannon1991
    @CShannon1991 2 роки тому +1

    Amy,
    When it comes to the creaming method in a stand mixer, NOTHING beats my KitchenAid!!!

  • @irmabigler3516
    @irmabigler3516 2 роки тому +10

    I noticed that the Kenmore"s bowl is too big around and flat bottomed compared to the kitchenaid which will make a difference how it creams

    • @JeannetteShoreland
      @JeannetteShoreland 2 роки тому

      Yes. I use the Ovation primarily to mix meats, such as meatloaf, sausage, and burger mixtures. It does not overmix or macerate the ingredients.

  • @JoseOnTheAir
    @JoseOnTheAir 2 роки тому +1

    I found your channel last year and it helped me decide on a Classic Plus myself! For the baking I do, it's the perfect first stand mixer for me. I'd say unless you're getting into heavier doughs or really want a splash of color, I'm happier with saving some money to get a Classic Plus vs an Artisan if there's no deals going on.

  • @LacyO86
    @LacyO86 2 роки тому +1

    "It just jaggied it around" LOL perfect description of what it did 🤯

    • @AmyLearnsToCook
      @AmyLearnsToCook  2 роки тому +2

      I have no idea why I said jaggied LOL! I am kinda nervous in front of the camera at times. Thanks for watching, Lacy!! I hope it was entertaining lol

  • @barbarastepp7077
    @barbarastepp7077 2 роки тому

    Really helpful to see those side by side! Thanks Amy

  • @petersmith9785
    @petersmith9785 Рік тому

    G'day from Australia my mother used to have Sunbeam Mixmasters her first one she got back in the 1970s then my father and I bought her a new model from a store called Harvey Norman in Wagga Wagga NSW where I still live both my parents have gone to God. My mother used to make banana cakes and Christmas cakes as well as other tasty treats baking was one of her favourite things to do. BTW Great video!!

  • @carolynharmon7074
    @carolynharmon7074 2 роки тому

    I never knew the butter and sugar needed that much mixing, Thanks!!

  • @lorieann8522
    @lorieann8522 2 роки тому +3

    Love these Wednesday videos. My oldest gets her IgG infusion every week on Wednesday so while we chill out together, I watch your video.
    Amy, have you purchased the scale/sifter attachment for the KA? I got it 2 years ago and oh boy does it work great! No puffing of flour everywhere and it can be a scale on its own.
    I think it's time KA reaches out to you to design an Amy Learns To Cook mixer!!!

  • @vibe80118
    @vibe80118 11 місяців тому

    I was glad to see that you gave the Ovation another go. I want one so much because of the opening in the middle but I do a lot of baking and need a great mixer. Although I have quite a collection of mixers, my favorite and the one that lives on my counter is my Kitchenaid k5ss which I purchased new in 1982 for $199.99; a lot of money for a mixer back then. I bought my Cuisinart DLC 7 the same year, for the same price and it still lives on my counter as well. Works better than any other food processor I have ever used! One thing I am wondering about the Ovation Amy; there is another UA-camr I watch whose show is all about cake baking. She has an ovation and loves it. In fact; she did a review and said she was very pleased with how it creamed. I wonder if they made any changes to the paddle since you purchased yours?

  • @jeanettelipman
    @jeanettelipman 2 роки тому +3

    Love your channel, new subscriber, by the way I can't cook, but hope to find out. And I love vintage cookware and shining it up. Copper especially so.

    • @EricLearnstoCook
      @EricLearnstoCook 2 роки тому +1

      Thanks Jeanette. We appreciate it. I hope you stick around and learn to cook. Amy is the original pan freak. Once again, glad you found our channel and subbed. We appreciate it.

    • @jeanettelipman
      @jeanettelipman 2 роки тому

      @@EricLearnstoCook thank you Eric for the welcome. I appreciate that.

  • @ukspankedyank
    @ukspankedyank 2 роки тому +4

    KA completely KO'd the other one. :-)

  • @glojosefsen
    @glojosefsen 2 роки тому +1

    Hi Amy… I wanted to buy mixer but I’m not sure what kind of mixer (stand mixer or spiral mixer). Do you have suggestions what kind of mixer applicable for kneading pasta dough with 50% hydration ratio?

    • @CShannon1991
      @CShannon1991 2 роки тому

      My suggestions for a stand mixer that is capable of kneading pasta dough is in my list for you to consider:
      1) KitchenAid Pro 600.
      2) KitchenAid Pro Line 7.
      3) KitchenAid 8 Qt Commercial.
      4) Bosch Universal Plus.
      5) Ankarsrum.
      6) Kenwood Chef.
      These are my list for a stand mixer that you are looking for to do the task you want done.

  • @spicymasalazone5753
    @spicymasalazone5753 2 роки тому

    Oh my god amazing reviews thanks for your efforts👍👍

    • @AmyLearnsToCook
      @AmyLearnsToCook  2 роки тому

      Thanks for watching, Spicy!!! I hope everything is going well out your way!

  • @sharonlatour6230
    @sharonlatour6230 2 роки тому

    In all fairness, you you stop and scrape both at the same time? Thanks for the video. I like my KA! Did you think the KA had a faster high speed than the Kenmore?

  • @sashineb.2114
    @sashineb.2114 2 роки тому +3

    Hi Amy, Thanks for another terrific mixer review. I remember your original one about the Kenmore and how it wasn't doing a very good job. Glad to hear the Classic Plus is still performing so well. If you're doing some comparison videos, would you please consider the KitchenAid Commercial vs. the mixing capability of the Kenwood Cooking Chef (or your 5-quart Kenwood Titanium)? Many thanks, and have a great day.

    • @chineeboy18
      @chineeboy18 2 роки тому +3

      That would be a really good Stand mixer versus battle.

    • @sashineb.2114
      @sashineb.2114 2 роки тому +3

      @@chineeboy18 Thanks, I thought so, since the Kenwood is supposed to be a stronger mixer than the KitchenAids. I noticed in Amy's review for each that the KA Commercial 8 quart had some hesitation when kneading the bread dough, but there was none with the Kenwood. It's just too bad we can't get Kenwood attachments in North America. It seems like they've forgotten about us.

    • @chineeboy18
      @chineeboy18 2 роки тому +1

      @@sashineb.2114 The Kenwood Titanium stand mixer is a solid piece of kitchen hardware. Will be nice to see it compete against a commercial KA.

    • @JeannetteShoreland
      @JeannetteShoreland 2 роки тому +1

      @@sashineb.2114 I just bought the Kenwood 7 quart mixer and have encountered the same problem. I compared the array of Kenwood attachments available to customers on Amazon UK and discovered that we are not enjoying the same degree of customer attention. I noticed that DeLonghi is the parent company so we may see some improvement in the future. All that being said, the quality of Kenwood's attachments puts all other mixers to shame.

    • @sashineb.2114
      @sashineb.2114 2 роки тому +1

      @@chineeboy18 Yes, I agree. It would be a good comparison. Have you see the Joy of Baking UA-cam channel? Stephanie uses a Kenwood 5 quart Titanium mixer, and she loves it.

  • @BeeABetterBaker
    @BeeABetterBaker 2 роки тому

    Thank you for sharing this review! ☺️🐝

  • @sweetea7035
    @sweetea7035 2 місяці тому

    In my personal opinion, I NEVER get better creaming than when I use a powerful double beater hand mixer. The texture of cake is so much better. I wish kitchen aid had an attachment like that

  • @ΒασίληςΜαντζιώκας

    Please do a review of the kenmore elite standmixer !! (The one without a hole)

  • @SinDog3
    @SinDog3 2 місяці тому

    seems like the Kennemore was set at a lot slower speed especially at the beginning. Can you do another test with both going at the same speed.

  • @Rebel9668
    @Rebel9668 2 роки тому

    I always add the sugar 1st using 3/4 cup of white sugar and 3/4 cup of dark brown sugar (just a personal preference). Then I melt the butter and pour it in over the sugars and start the mixer. Maybe I'm cheating but I've always been satisfied with the result.

    • @AmyLearnsToCook
      @AmyLearnsToCook  2 роки тому +1

      Yeah some recipes use 1/2 white sugar and 1/2 brown sugar. It depends on the recipe. My peanut butter cookies uses 1/2 and 1/2. If you are making purely sugar cookies or like lemon cookies, you want to use all white sugar because you don't want the flavor or color change. Thanks for watching, Rebel!

  • @kevbiker3982
    @kevbiker3982 2 роки тому

    Only machine I have found that matches the Kitchenaid is the SMEG. Longevity is being analyzed as I use them both

  • @marksilver9291
    @marksilver9291 2 роки тому +2

    Too bad the kenmore doesn't perform better. I like the innovative design! I also think the Kenmore requires more product too work well.

    • @smsstuart
      @smsstuart 2 роки тому

      Yes, it's hard not to like the 'attempt' at this Pour-In Top design idea. Unfortunately, as seen here - just for starters - if fails. The Ovation is a 5-quart capacity mixer; not a 7, 8 [or even] 6-quart.size. Just how 'much more product' does it need to work well-? 2-sticks of butter/1-½ cups of sugar is hardly a small amount; and not an untypical quantity for many cookie recipes. Regrettably, it's back to the drawing boards. (But that ship sailed long ago).

  • @niazikitchenandvlogs
    @niazikitchenandvlogs 2 роки тому

    Thanks

  • @JeannetteShoreland
    @JeannetteShoreland 2 роки тому

    I have had my Kenmore Ovation for 2 years and would like to upgrade the whipping and mixing attachments. If anyone has successfully found a mixing paddle with a silicone scraper that could be used on this mixer, I would really appreciate this information.

  • @Caitlin1928
    @Caitlin1928 2 роки тому

    If you did Kenmore vs Cuisinart, Kenmore would win. With the Cuisinart, it doesn't really cream, although it does a good job with all the cookie ingredients in there.

  • @lorieann8522
    @lorieann8522 2 роки тому +1

    It looks like the Kenmore kept the sugar on the top for quite awhile before it got integrated in to the butter.

    • @EricLearnstoCook
      @EricLearnstoCook 2 роки тому

      Thank you LorieAnn. The Kenmore will mix, but takes longer. Not being able to mix in the middle (do to the hole) and such small beaters does limit it. But I'm thinking it's a set it and forget it mixer. Just let it mix for a while. Lots of people love it, but it doesn't compare time-wise to so many other mixers out there. But to show how well a mixer can cream (or not) was Amy's goal here.

  • @smsstuart
    @smsstuart 2 роки тому

    Amy. Yes, "the road to hell is paved with good intentions". The idea of a Pour-In Top design holds such promise for a planetary stand mixer; and yet... Clearly this one failed, and continues to do so. Don't know if the idea can be better-executed so it produces the right kind of results, or it's an impossibility. The original 103 year-old planetary mixer design just keeps on plugging along, with its only real competition coming from the Bosch Universal Plus. Thanks for this comparison test.

    • @AmyLearnsToCook
      @AmyLearnsToCook  2 роки тому

      I really like the design. I wish that there was a way to improve on it. With the hole in the middle, you just don't get the same planetary mixing as you do with traditional mixers. It was a fun test tho lol

  • @charlesfoleysr6610
    @charlesfoleysr6610 2 роки тому

    I believe the kitchen aide has come out with a paddle with a neoprene wiper on the edge of the creaming beater.

    • @CookingWithCash
      @CookingWithCash 2 роки тому

      Yes but Kenmore doesn’t have that so it wouldn’t be fair to include that in the comparison.

  • @whatscookinnashville
    @whatscookinnashville 2 роки тому +1

    😋❤️

  • @Yoda63
    @Yoda63 2 роки тому +1

    Did you ever have a mixer start smoking?!

    • @EricLearnstoCook
      @EricLearnstoCook 2 роки тому

      Amy's Cheap Stand Mixer Challenge: Sunbeam Mixmaster, Hamilton Beach & Dash Go. 24 minutes in, one of the mixers quits. No smoke, but it was poor quality. We later looked and it had a ton of bad reviews on Amazon. So no smoke, but it did die on us.

  • @brandonrobinson3480
    @brandonrobinson3480 2 роки тому +1

    Kenmore don't push beside bowl maybe not coming fast as kitchenaid

    • @CShannon1991
      @CShannon1991 2 роки тому

      That Kenmore even on High Speed, to me, it’s STILL NOT fast enough as the KitchenAid. In fact, look at Amy’s Kenmore Ovation review and skip to the part where she tested the whisk to whip egg whites and you’ll see what I’m talking about.
      Even on the highest speed, that Kenmore is STILL SLOWER like a turtle.

    • @brandonrobinson3480
      @brandonrobinson3480 2 роки тому +1

      @@CShannon1991 I'm still a firm believer of kitchenaid. Very trustworthy brand live up to its name.

    • @CShannon1991
      @CShannon1991 2 роки тому +1

      @@brandonrobinson3480 So much better than Kenmore even though Kenmore and KitchenAid are both owned by Whirlpool.
      Also, watch out for a fellow UA-camr whose name I’m not going to mention but he is a Kenmore Fanboy who praises this Kenmore Ovation stand mixer and he throws insults at Amy.

  • @CShannon1991
    @CShannon1991 2 роки тому

    Amy,
    Now do another test but this time, a new test should be how fast either stand mixer can whip egg whites for meringues!

    • @AmyLearnsToCook
      @AmyLearnsToCook  2 роки тому +1

      Egg whites would be fun! When I did the initial video on the Ovation, I couldn't hardly get it to whip 5 egg whites.

    • @CShannon1991
      @CShannon1991 2 роки тому

      @@AmyLearnsToCook Well, could you do the test on your KitchenAid Classic Plus whipping egg whites?