Transcript times It’s So Easy 00:03:22 Bad Obsession 00:07:03 Chinese Democracy 00:12:14 Slither 00:15:52 Hard Skool 00:20:44 Mr. Brownstone 00:24:30 WTTJ Prelude 00:28:37 Welcome to the Jungle 00:29:41 Pretty Tied Up 00:36:00 Absurd 00:41:00 Double Talkin’ Jive 00:44:35 Estranged 00:50:00 Down On The Farm 00:59:39 Live and Let Die 01:03:30 Rocket Queen 01:07:05 - Drums, Keys, Fortus, Slash talkbox solo and jam, 01:10:00 Reckless Life 01:19:30 - Slash 01:21:08 You Could Be Mine 01:22:40 TV Eye 01:29:00 Anything Goes 01:30:30 Civil War / Voodoo Chile 01:34:32 Intros 01:42:39 Slash Solo 01:44:11 Sweet Child O’ Mine 01:52:25 November Rain 01:58:40 - Slash 02:02:53 Wichita Lineman 02:08:20 - Slash acoustic 02:11:00 Catcher in the Rye 02:12:17 Knockin on Heavens Door 02:17:45 - Slash/Fortus solo and jam 02:20:15 Nightrain 02:30:00 People Get Ready (Acoustic jam) 02:36:00 Encore Coma 02:38:00 Walk All Over You 02:48:00 Patience 02:54:00 Paradise City 03:00:00
someone above replied having seen them 25 times and this being one of the best shows ever. I finally had a chance 35 years after becoming a fan, and I thought they were outstanding. Every time we thought the show might end soon, it's like they gassed up the car and ran with it! @@MarceloCheloGonzalez1189.
Thanks so much for capturing this show! I went with my daughter, her first concert, and now we get to relive it. These guys played their hearts out that night.
After all the years of drama, infighting, egos, rehab, ODs, other bands, solo projects, etc., it really is great to see them doing what they are born to do…touring with each other, playing epic shows like this one and they finally just generally seem to appreciate it and seem to be having a really good time doing it. Thank you for sharing this video!
As someone who has loved GN'R since they first started, thank you for this. My Mom passed away one year ago. Very few things have distracted me from my grief. This has. Many thanks!
Yes he doesn't have the same power in his voice as he used to and yes he sounds a bit high pitched at times but in all he still kicks ass, let's not forget he's 61 now.
Let's you not forget he's 61 years old because you're the one that's pointing out his discrepancies. No one really gives a s*** about that kind of stuff . Nobody is as good as they used to be . So why even bring it up . Just relax and listen to the music.
@@ErwinUbachs How about Good Enough 😁 I mean these guys have been through a lot so give him a break huh . It's a miracle that half these guys are still on tour and not dead. 😳
I personally know UA-cam does zero justice for being there live .. with that being said how does Axl sound live now? He actually sounds good to me here but how live?
@@kidmac1514 of course hes not the same as he was and a lot of people are haters, but for a guy that's 61 years old I think he sounded great, they played non stop for over 3 hours it was an amazing show, Met life stadium was rocking to say the least, If i could do it again i would. I'm from California and i flew over there for the show it was totally worth it. Hope your doing good.
Probably one of the best live recordings since they started touring again. Some of the other cell phone videos don't have a good quality, and make Axl sound pretty bad, but he seems to be on it for this show.
He sounded like old Axl during Reckless Life but some other songs you could barely hear him. Over all the concert was great and Axl is working hard to get his voice back. Listening to the concert on UA-cam - his voice doesn’t sound as good.
we gonna be on the floor in Nashville. how was the Pitt? Does VIP get the front before general admission? just trying to figure what to expect. sorry for question. My son is 19 and he's absolutely insane about GnR
@@bodavis9586not trying to fight with you and you’re obviously entitled to your opinion but if your expectation is for Axl to sound like he’s 28 yrs old during the Illusions your then I don’t know what to tell you. The guy is 61 and he sounds incredible to be running around on stage for 3 plus hours and putting on a performance. No frontman 30 years ago sounds like they did back then
@@user-jq1wk8pd8r not trying to argue either and you are also entitled to your opinion and I obviously don’t expect him to sound like he did 30 years ago but for example Rob Halford,Bruce Dickinson,and Robert Plant have all been doing it longer and are older and they still sound amazing and don’t sound like they did 30-40 years ago
Seems like Axl is getting better at doing the things his voice can do well, and not trying to do what he’s not so good at. Still nowhere near what he once was, but he’s getting better at not sounding like Mickey Mouse. Props to him for singing live knowing it’s not perfect.
Ninguém é perfeito filho. E ele nunca mais será como antes. Acorda para a vida !!! Porém mesmo com suas limitações hj em dia, ainda consegue fazer mais de 3 horas de show, e o que realmente vale, é que nunca se utilizou de playbacks para enganar o povo. Parabéns Axl Rose vc é 10. É isto que tem para hj gostem ou não .
the best version of Estranged since he started losing his voice.. he sounds amazing, just listen to a concert of a year ago, totally another level, he is working on his voice and I cannot wait for them to come back to Europe!
When I saw them on their first tour back together they stood as far apart as possible from each other on stage so it is really nice to see them on good terms
I can't believe they played Pretty Tied Up. I've watched a few gigs over the years n never seen them play it. Awesome. Plus Estranged and Coma at the same show. Lucky audience 😊 Great gig.
SHOW ÓTIMO COMPLETO, A BANDA ESTAVA IMPECÁVEL, AXL SUA PERFORMANCE ESTÁ MELHOR A VOZ TEVE ALGUNS DRIVES DO AXL ,MAIS GOSTEI , OBRIGADO ✌️ , SAUDAÇÕES BRASILEIRAS 🇧🇷 A NEW JERSEY EUA 🇺🇸 , GUNS FUCKN N ROSES 🔫🌹🌹🔫🎤🎩🚬🎸🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷
I know axl, slash and duff have been back for several years now, but watching slash play chinese democracy just makes it all come together. Would love another velvet song or two make the setlist.
Disfrutemos lo que queda de esta genial banda de rock estan dandolo todo en el escenario y mantienen vivo el genero quien mejor que ellos demostrando que todavia pueden los guns n' fucking roses seran eternos!
Obrigado amigo! Essa banda é foda, rock and roll de primeira qualidade, agradeço a Deus por ter presenciado ao vivo 2 vezes! Vida longa ao GUNS N FUCKIN’ ROSES! 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
2:21:47 Richard Fortus' solo is amazing, dude got the guitar chops, yet he sounds godly soulful, and should be way more in the spotlight! I've been a slash fan my whole life, but Richard is sooooo underrated, what a player!
I was up in the nosebleeds at this show having a blast, but your view was better, thanks for posting….30+years since my last GnR concert so in spite of a bad note here and there by the guys, this was an absolutely epic show!!
I was at the Hershey show on the 11th, and they were absolutely amazing! Considered going to this show, too, but might go to Saratoga Springs to catch Carrie Underwood as an opener!
It would be nice if axle sang a bunch of songs that were on the snake pit album called ain't Life Grand because those are some great songs and I think some of them were written with Axl in mind. But then they split up . 😢
I am a life long fan, my very favorite since I was 12! ( I am currently 47) My daughters and I will be at Geodis Park in Nashville to see them on the 26th! We have Night Train premium package tickets. This will be my 1st time to see them in concert, and to say I am excited is an understatement!! This rock n’ roll Momma is gonna rock the night away! 🤘🏻🤘🏻
Saw these guys, pre-appetite. 1986. Opening up for Cheap Trick. Spent the day hanging out, setting up and such. Then watched front-center. I had no idea at the time what I was watching.
@@slashandizzyriffs ya... growing up in LA during that timeframe was a lot of fun. So many great shows, and you could just ang out. Nothing like the shit world we live in now.
One of the best gigs in the last time! Only this drummer. man the beginning …paradise city. there was so mutch more punch in it with matt on the drums. so much more fire..
Quem achou que o velhão tava acabado, se enganou feio!!!!❤❤❤❤❤ Ainda tá na ativa. Estou feliz ver minha banda favorita reunida, faltou da a chance pro Matt aí sim!❤❤
![Pantera - Live at Resurrection Fest 2023 (Spain) [Pro-shot 4k 50fps]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WMnhw6H-Wfg/mqdefault.jpg)
Transcript times
It’s So Easy 00:03:22
Bad Obsession 00:07:03
Chinese Democracy 00:12:14
Slither 00:15:52
Hard Skool 00:20:44
Mr. Brownstone 00:24:30
WTTJ Prelude 00:28:37
Welcome to the Jungle 00:29:41
Pretty Tied Up 00:36:00
Absurd 00:41:00
Double Talkin’ Jive 00:44:35
Estranged 00:50:00
Down On The Farm 00:59:39
Live and Let Die 01:03:30
Rocket Queen 01:07:05
- Drums, Keys, Fortus, Slash talkbox solo and jam, 01:10:00
Reckless Life 01:19:30
- Slash 01:21:08
You Could Be Mine 01:22:40
TV Eye 01:29:00
Anything Goes 01:30:30
Civil War / Voodoo Chile 01:34:32
Intros 01:42:39
Slash Solo 01:44:11
Sweet Child O’ Mine 01:52:25
November Rain 01:58:40
- Slash 02:02:53
Wichita Lineman 02:08:20
- Slash acoustic 02:11:00
Catcher in the Rye 02:12:17
Knockin on Heavens Door 02:17:45
- Slash/Fortus solo and jam 02:20:15
Nightrain 02:30:00
People Get Ready (Acoustic jam) 02:36:00
Encore
Coma 02:38:00
Walk All Over You 02:48:00
Patience 02:54:00
Paradise City 03:00:00
One of the Best set list ever!!!! 😇👐😍🙌
someone above replied having seen them 25 times and this being one of the best shows ever. I finally had a chance 35 years after becoming a fan, and I thought they were outstanding. Every time we thought the show might end soon, it's like they gassed up the car and ran with it! @@MarceloCheloGonzalez1189.
Obrigado pelo setlist 😉👍
@@MarceloCheloGonzalez1189.if they had don’t cry and yesterdays on it, it would for sure be the best
Thanks for the timestamps! Small edit. It's "Paradise City."
It’s awesome to see Axl so happy!!!
He does seem to have more energy.
So he should put more energy into his voice too because as it is it's no longer possible.
@@samuelvictor007lo que pasa es que el esta cuidando su vos
Funny, he seems to be dancing on hot coals! Bwahahahaha!
Thanks so much for capturing this show! I went with my daughter, her first concert, and now we get to relive it. These guys played their hearts out that night.
After all the years of drama, infighting, egos, rehab, ODs, other bands, solo projects, etc., it really is great to see them doing what they are born to do…touring with each other, playing epic shows like this one and they finally just generally seem to appreciate it and seem to be having a really good time doing it. Thank you for sharing this video!
As someone who has loved GN'R since they first started, thank you for this. My Mom passed away one year ago. Very few things have distracted me from my grief. This has. Many thanks!
@@Mike-wn7oh
Thank you so much for your kind words. My deepest condolences to you, as well. Wishing you all the best.
Sorry to hear about your loss
@@healthymealthy775
Thank you!
Sorry for your loss man, guns n’ roses are kicking ass for her!🤘🏻
@@goggie9245
Thank you! Yes, they are. GN'R are the greatest band of all-time, and it's not even close.
Axl literally sounds AMAZING after all these years! Im gonna see them tmrw in Toronto! I waited 27 years for this!!!! This will be history for me.
Yes he doesn't have the same power in his voice as he used to and yes he sounds a bit high pitched at times but in all he still kicks ass, let's not forget he's 61 now.
Pessoal obrigado por reconhecer o talento de hoje Axl é e sempre sera idolo de nossas vidas.
@marialuciana4493 I don't speak Portuguese but from what I understand, personal thanks for recognising Axls talent?
Let's you not forget he's 61 years old because you're the one that's pointing out his discrepancies. No one really gives a s*** about that kind of stuff . Nobody is as good as they used to be . So why even bring it up . Just relax and listen to the music.
@@chriskroll4166 there's not as good and there's still good, not sure which one 😉
@@ErwinUbachs How about Good Enough 😁 I mean these guys have been through a lot so give him a break huh . It's a miracle that half these guys are still on tour and not dead. 😳
Axl sounds really good. Great show.
I was there I've been wanted to see them live for over 30 years now, the show was amazing oh, thanks for sharing!
me too....awesome show
I personally know UA-cam does zero justice for being there live .. with that being said how does Axl sound live now? He actually sounds good to me here but how live?
@@kidmac1514 of course hes not the same as he was and a lot of people are haters, but for a guy that's 61 years old I think he sounded great, they played non stop for over 3 hours it was an amazing show, Met life stadium was rocking to say the least, If i could do it again i would. I'm from California and i flew over there for the show it was totally worth it. Hope your doing good.
Really good happy that axl is finding better control and trying to stay out of falsetto, much better❤
Guns n’ Roses was my first concert. They opened up for Iron Maiden in Vancouver in 1988. So awesome.
cool, I just missed them in the UK in 87. Finally made it to Wembley 91 , one of the greatest days ever :)
Fuuuccckkk what a great show to attend!
I saw them on that tour - Calgary. Just before they blew up.
I was there ! Section 3, floor level. What a great show
I was in that same section, and the show was a blast. I'm still thinking about how great it was 3 days later. Lol
Nice video of the show, I do miss the old Axle voice. He just killed it for me. Glad I saw the shows in the early days
Man, they sound and look awesome! The next few years could be really something.
Axl on Fire 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Probably one of the best live recordings since they started touring again. Some of the other cell phone videos don't have a good quality, and make Axl sound pretty bad, but he seems to be on it for this show.
his mic was really weird for this show, wasn't turned up loud enough or something
@@gage6402it sounded like it came in and out on a few songs
@@gage6402 Voice he still sounds the same.
Caralho só reclamam é impressionante. Kkkk
He sounded like old Axl during Reckless Life but some other songs you could barely hear him. Over all the concert was great and Axl is working hard to get his voice back. Listening to the concert on UA-cam - his voice doesn’t sound as good.
Cool seeing Dice Clay enjoying the show! Thanks to him guns got back together {almost all back together}
He did a bit of (kind of uncomfortable) stand-up before Guns came on stage and right after the Pretenders opened lol
I too was at this show on the floor. They were incredible.
we gonna be on the floor in Nashville. how was the Pitt? Does VIP get the front before general admission? just trying to figure what to expect. sorry for question. My son is 19 and he's absolutely insane about GnR
Absolutely EPIC concert… GNR are phenom & Slash has got be one of the all time best guitarists! Thanks for posting this!!
Epic from everyone except axl
@@bodavis9586Don’t know what you watched but I was there live in person and Axl sounded fucking awesome!
@@user-jq1wk8pd8r i watched the video and he sounded terrible
@@bodavis9586not trying to fight with you and you’re obviously entitled to your opinion but if your expectation is for Axl to sound like he’s 28 yrs old during the Illusions your then I don’t know what to tell you. The guy is 61 and he sounds incredible to be running around on stage for 3 plus hours and putting on a performance. No frontman 30 years ago sounds like they did back then
@@user-jq1wk8pd8r not trying to argue either and you are also entitled to your opinion and I obviously don’t expect him to sound like he did 30 years ago but for example
Rob Halford,Bruce Dickinson,and Robert Plant have all been doing it longer and are older and they still sound amazing and don’t sound like they did 30-40 years ago
61 years-old and still the same 27 energy
Seems like Axl is getting better at doing the things his voice can do well, and not trying to do what he’s not so good at. Still nowhere near what he once was, but he’s getting better at not sounding like Mickey Mouse. Props to him for singing live knowing it’s not perfect.
Ninguém é perfeito filho. E ele nunca mais será como antes. Acorda para a vida !!! Porém mesmo com suas limitações hj em dia, ainda consegue fazer mais de 3 horas de show, e o que realmente vale, é que nunca se utilizou de playbacks para enganar o povo. Parabéns Axl Rose vc é 10. É isto que tem para hj gostem ou não .
the best version of Estranged since he started losing his voice.. he sounds amazing, just listen to a concert of a year ago, totally another level, he is working on his voice and I cannot wait for them to come back to Europe!
I’ve never been a GNR fan but I have to admit it’s cool to see Axl & Slash standing next to each other onstage again.
Don't forget about Duff Bro
When I saw them on their first tour back together they stood as far apart as possible from each other on stage so it is really nice to see them on good terms
Was thinking that too. I know they've been back together for awhile now but it's still crazy to me.
Thank you for this! You did an incredible job recording the whole concert. Seeing them in Toronto next week!
So awesome!!! I throuley enjoyed watching this concert this morning. Thank You for video!!!!!
Better voice than usual😊
I can't believe they played Pretty Tied Up. I've watched a few gigs over the years n never seen them play it. Awesome. Plus Estranged and Coma at the same show. Lucky audience 😊 Great gig.
SHOW ÓTIMO COMPLETO, A BANDA ESTAVA IMPECÁVEL, AXL SUA PERFORMANCE ESTÁ MELHOR A VOZ TEVE ALGUNS DRIVES DO AXL ,MAIS GOSTEI , OBRIGADO ✌️ , SAUDAÇÕES BRASILEIRAS 🇧🇷 A NEW JERSEY EUA 🇺🇸 , GUNS FUCKN N ROSES 🔫🌹🌹🔫🎤🎩🚬🎸🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷🇺🇲🇧🇷
Catcher in the Rye ❤️
I know axl, slash and duff have been back for several years now, but watching slash play chinese democracy just makes it all come together.
Would love another velvet song or two make the setlist.
Slither
Great recording. Thank you!
Disfrutemos lo que queda de esta genial banda de rock estan dandolo todo en el escenario y mantienen vivo el genero quien mejor que ellos demostrando que todavia pueden los guns n' fucking roses seran eternos!
Catcher In The Rye is a beautiful song.
I seen them in Pittsburgh on the 18th and they were outstanding.
Obrigado amigo! Essa banda é foda, rock and roll de primeira qualidade, agradeço a Deus por ter presenciado ao vivo 2 vezes! Vida longa ao GUNS N FUCKIN’ ROSES! 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
E a voz do Axl está incrível. Eu realizei o sonho de vê - Los ao vivo ano passado.🤩
Thank you from New Jersey.
so amazing！
Thank you for sharing. Sounds great! 🤘
2:21:47 Richard Fortus' solo is amazing, dude got the guitar chops, yet he sounds godly soulful, and should be way more in the spotlight! I've been a slash fan my whole life, but Richard is sooooo underrated, what a player!
also on that note look who's sitting behind him, Dice!
Yep. Richard is an absolute monster.
@@thegreatwhitehope77 he was a surprise guest at this show. Did a 10 min routine.
THANK YOU FOR UPLOADING THIS! My battery died prematurely so had to miss out on several songs partially or completely!
I was up in the nosebleeds at this show having a blast, but your view was better, thanks for posting….30+years since my last GnR concert so in spite of a bad note here and there by the guys, this was an absolutely epic show!!
Good video music Always succes for you
Wow what a setlist! I’m seeing them at Fenway Park and cannot wait!🤘🏻 wow they played Coma
I think they’re playing coma in all their shows because I saw them in Hershey about a week ago and they also played it
I was so pumped to hear them play Coma at Hershey! Have fun at Fenway!
They didn't play it hear in Montreal :(
Muito obrigado
tito santana thanks for sharing. ARRIBA!!!!!!!!
36:36 Axl como nos anos 90!!!! Fenomenal! 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻
Thank you!
1:52:22 Sweet Child O' Mine! Followed by Nov Rain, the climax! Gr8 job recording this, Tito! 🤑👍
Thanks for posting this!!!
Estranged is such a fantastic song
I was at the Hershey show on the 11th, and they were absolutely amazing! Considered going to this show, too, but might go to Saratoga Springs to catch Carrie Underwood as an opener!
TOO cool Axl is not just willing to sing SLITHER, but he truly digs singin' it & it's a great song that deserves to be heard!
It would be nice if axle sang a bunch of songs that were on the snake pit album called ain't Life Grand because those are some great songs and I think some of them were written with Axl in mind. But then they split up . 😢
Muchas gracias 👍🍻
Forever
Set List top, que Banda, vida Longa pro Guns n roses 🎸🔥
awesome set, Axl sounding AMAZING
Gostei muito bom!!
I was there! Great show!!
Just heard perhaps on radio they will probably debut it in Pittsburgh on Friday 18th
I’m going tonight in Pittsburgh
I am a life long fan, my very favorite since I was 12! ( I am currently 47) My daughters and I will be at Geodis Park in Nashville to see them on the 26th! We have Night Train premium package tickets. This will be my 1st time to see them in concert, and to say I am excited is an understatement!! This rock n’ roll Momma is gonna rock the night away! 🤘🏻🤘🏻
Thanks!!
I was at that show. It was fucking awesome!
Thank you GNRFor the reunion❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😊😊😊😊 we love you
What a fuckin Jewl this is .. Thanlk you for sharing this . Music back then was different… Legend’s !!
Awesome concert. I doubted those that said Axls voice sounded better in person but its absolutely true. Your phone can't record it accurately
Love that these guys played each others songs like they are true GNR songs.
Awesome❤
Em meio a tantas outras bandas, guns n roses nunca perdeu o rendimento. Guns n roses sempre lotou grandes estádios.
AXL melhorou a voz e Slash sempre arrasa!!
Ele só perde a voz aqui no Brasil.
Thank you so much this capture and upload. 🤘🏻🙌🏻🤘🏻
I love you Guns n Roses. I am Form Brasil.
They're just getting better! A 3 hour set is pretty sick. Maybe I gotta see em again.
Amazing! I’ve seen them 25 times now and this was one of the best!
Awesomeness! 🤘🏼
In the Nightrain everything was like in old days:) Damn awesome and respect for holding that camera 3hours:)
I wish the crowds would be quieter so we could hear the group better. But I guess I am just old. .
Love GNR
Awesome ⚘🇬🇧🕊
Spettacolo puro
Axl is the king of rock and roll Axlrose1
Fantástico! 💯 👏 👏 👏 👏 👍
Catcher in the Rye! 2023!
I see them the 24th at wrigley Field, with my lil sisters I’m so excited! ❤
Saw these guys, pre-appetite. 1986. Opening up for Cheap Trick. Spent the day hanging out, setting up and such. Then watched front-center. I had no idea at the time what I was watching.
that would have been cool
@@slashandizzyriffs ya... growing up in LA during that timeframe was a lot of fun. So many great shows, and you could just ang out. Nothing like the shit world we live in now.
Thank you Rock's Lords!
Great Stuff
Siento los amaré ❤👏👏👏
Amazing performance!!!
that was badass
Can't wait to see them in Charlotte
One of the best gigs in the last time! Only this drummer. man the beginning …paradise city. there was so mutch more punch in it with matt on the drums. so much more fire..
I agree. Matt got screwed not being apart of the current lineup.
Lol. Kids kids kids..
Steven Adler is what they’re missing. Smh.
@@johnsillings6330 have you seen Steven Adler recently? He’s literately brain dead from doing drugs
..🎼🎶.strange., power,show Atmosphäre on stage alltime GnR... Performance... Well &Mr.Axl. Rose..2.. again2023 world tour💐'sca
Well shot with nice close up. Thx !
So classic and epic . Always been a fan of GnR , thanks for uploading ,enjoyed .
Amazing day 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻sadly they didn’t play DONT cry
Quem achou que o velhão tava acabado, se enganou feio!!!!❤❤❤❤❤
Ainda tá na ativa.
Estou feliz ver minha banda favorita reunida, faltou da a chance pro Matt aí sim!❤❤
Axl's voice.....a shadow of what it was once. I'll always remember their show in 92 at the Nassau Coliseum. I was 22.😊
'it's so easy when everybody's trying to please me'
His voice isnt the same from 92 ,shocking.........
It’s not what it once was, but it’s better than it’s been in quite a while
Damn you are friggin old...
Its 2023, not 1992 anymore buddy.
Three hour shows, damn. Back in the day Axl was always three hours late😅..
Vejo que o baterista melhorou muito. Já toca idêntico aos antigos bateristas.
Can't wait until September!!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Slash at the end 🤣
Young song writers are disappearing but the show must go on. Right. Thanks for caring