Seems like you don't have proper answer for the question... 1) men are also emotional and some men are more emotional than a woman. 2) deeds are good and bad irrespective of the gender... So according to this some men having bad deeds shouldn't allowed in the graveyard
Yes it seems he is trying hard to fit in his desires But he said truth about the Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam encourage all Muslims to visit grave to be reminded of death and hereafter. All Muslims include men and women and the Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam didn’t specify it’s for men only. Secondly he spoke truth when he said Muslims while visiting grave should pray for the dead and not to the dead, of course we know that if we pray to the dead then it would be idolatry/shirk/blasphemy
""Or do you think that you will enter Paradise while such [trial] has not yet come to you as came to those who passed on before you? They were touched by poverty and hardship and were shaken until [even their] messenger and those who believed with him said, "When is the help of Allah?" Unquestionably, the help of Allah is near."" Al-Baqara : 214
Women are allowed to visit the graves. There are many ahadith supporting this view. Just because the Saudis don't allow them, doesn't mean it's impermissible.
Please dont talk without knowledge, there is an authentic hadith where mohammad صلى الله عليه وسلم cursed women who are visiting graves and women who are placing lamps beside a grave. So don‘t talk if you don‘t know.
Asalam o Alaikum. I feel like Dr Zakir didn't answer this question properly. I am a Muslim girl and as far as I know, correct me if I'm wrong, that woman are allowed to go if they have a Mahram man, like a father, brother, son etc. Also as he said there are examples of women going there it's only discouraged. Also Allah says in the Quran that He would forgive the most sinful of sinful if they repent. Also Holy Prophet peace be upon him always encouraged people to repent to Allah and always gave them hope that they would be forgiven. Dr Zakir should have explained that better. A reminder for myself as well. Jazak Allah Khair. I still respect Dr Zakir
Acc to my family. Well as a girl I was allowed to visit the graveyard but only as a child. Once I got older and hit puberty I couldnt go. But the reason being that remained vague. I didn't look further into it unfortunately.
Assalamu'alaykum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh. Excuse me, My name is Suhendra Dwi Paputra , I'm 19 years old. I'm from Jakarta, Indonesia. I'm a student of Islamic University of Madinah 2020/2021, And I was graduated from Al-Furqon Islamic Boarding School in Gresik, East Java which tought us arabic language, even the balaghah, dan the hole deen knowledge. Because of Allah's mercy, beyond the curriculum, I have memorized the hole Qur'an with the number of surah, the number of ayah, and the number of page. And I also have memorized The 8 books of hadith except Musnad Ahmad, the total hadiths are 42.000 with the number of books, Chapters, Hadiths and the pages also. I implore you to become Dr. Zakir's student , cause beside I want to be like Syaikh 'Utsaimin, I also want to be like Dr. Zakir Naik, especially I think Indonesian people need that. Jazakumullahu khayran
Masha’Allah, brother im impressed that not only you know many hadith but memorised whole Quran. I recommend you tell him in his private account might be easier and there is a chance he’ll see it
@@rm3105 As far as I know respectful Dr Zakir Nayak he always give his answers logically with proof of hadiths or Qur'an, but here as u said 0:38 he saying MAYBE woman r emotional, so he is not sure, and he didn't mention any proof. As a man I believe, most of men are very emotional than woman and obviously they don't show it outside. This is what digging my mind logically, and also if u Goole it u will come to know some people saying woman can go graveyard if they can control their emotions. Nowhere solid answers
The fallacy you're pointing out is not in the answer, it's in the question. The question itself didnt include a clear cut reference from quran/hadith, however Dr. Zaker tried to elaborate the judgement of the scholars since there is no clear cut answer/proof.
@@kishmish64 It's just his logical percentage-wise assumption, and also 15:23 he did not give any answers to those questions as far as I know. If you have a source for his answers u can give it to me, that would be helpful. Today I did comment on that video, for everyone's sake, I'm adding that comment below. " From my research, do not read Rashad Khalifa's translation. watch this (he claimed his self as a messenger of God). ua-cam.com/video/BwEPoKxUZwc/v-deo.html also, I compared it with our translation of Quran (Tamil) which is proving Rashad Khalifa's translation is WRONG. and I don't know why a guy who is deeply researched about this subject and highly recommends reading Rashad's translation, also which makes me more deeply thinking about his LOGICAL ASSUMPTION might be wrong. Allah Knows the best " From this, I assume he is trying to set people on the wrong path. Brother, you can not and don't believe everything in Islam in a logical manner, there are things beyond ourselves and logic. Eg, the Existence of Allah. Allah will guide true Muslims on the right path, make dua. Thanks
@@aariqgul229 No I am not. I know quran hadees and the muslim mentality very much because I was a muslim by birth. And I can say every religion is same in this.
I visited my mother's grave today, second time after her death in April this year. May Allah grant her Jannatul Ferdous. Alhamdulillah I didnt wail or make a scene. I don't have any brothers. Does that mean my mother wont have anyone to visit her grave? Of course not. Islam can't be so illogical. There is no such rule is Islam that prevents women to visit graves. In Shaa Allah I will visit her grave many more times.
The reason is itself not mentioned in hadiths so why should he lie? It is just forbidden without reason and being Muslim you should respect every saying of hazrat Muhammad PBUH even if it doesn't make sense for you... Btw in this case particularly, women are allowed to go in graveyard but only sometimes...they cannot go regularly like men but sometimes only
ganesmages MUSLIMS DONT WEAR BURQAS ITS A ARABIAN CULTURE CLOTHS AFRICANS MUSLIMS OESANIA MUSLIMS AND EUROPE MUSLIMS THE REST OF THE MUSLIM WORLD DON’T ITS ONLY THE HIJAB THAT IS ABLOGATORY FOR WOMEN TO WEAR WHEN SHE PRAYS AND MOST OF THE TEAM APPERS FOR OTHER STRANGERS SAME GOES FOR MEN TO NOT SHOW THEIR LEGS OR THEIR BODY WHEN THEY PRAY OR APPER FOR OTHER STRANGERS THAT ARE NOT PART OF THEIR FAMILY
@Siyovaxsh En-sipad-zid-ana yesss it's all based on the context , we can't really give a generalized opinion on permitted or not . For some prophet did permit for some he didn't
بسم آلله الر حمن الر حيم فَلَآ أُقۡسِمُ بِمَا تُبۡصِرُونَ So I swear by what you see وَمَا لَا تُبۡصِرُونَ And what you do not see. إِنَّهُۥ لَقَوۡلُ رَسُولٖ كَرِيمٖ [That] indeed, the Qur'an is the word of a noble Messenger. وَمَا هُوَ بِقَوۡلِ شَاعِرٖۚ قَلِيلٗا مَّا تُؤۡمِنُونَ And it is not the word of a poet; little do you believe. وَلَا بِقَوۡلِ كَاهِنٖۚ قَلِيلٗا مَّا تَذَكَّرُونَ Nor the word of a soothsayer; little do you remember. تَنزِيلٞ مِّن رَّبِّ ٱلۡعَٰلَمِينَ [It is] a revelation from the Lord of the worlds. The Nobel, glorious Qur'an(69:38-43) إِنَّا نَحۡنُ نَزَّلۡنَا عَلَيۡكَ ٱلۡقُرۡءَانَ تَنزِيلٗا Indeed, it is We who have sent down to you, [O Muhammad], the Qur'an progressively. -Sura Al-Insan, Ayah 23. قُلۡ أَيُّ شَيۡءٍ أَكۡبَرُ شَهَٰدَةٗۖ قُلِ ٱللَّهُۖ شَهِيدُۢ بَيۡنِي وَبَيۡنَكُمۡۚ وَأُوحِيَ إِلَيَّ هَٰذَا ٱلۡقُرۡءَانُ لِأُنذِرَكُم بِهِۦ وَمَنۢ بَلَغَۚ أَئِنَّكُمۡ لَتَشۡهَدُونَ أَنَّ مَعَ ٱللَّهِ ءَالِهَةً أُخۡرَىٰۚ قُل لَّآ أَشۡهَدُۚ قُلۡ إِنَّمَا هُوَ إِلَٰهٞ وَٰحِدٞ وَإِنَّنِي بَرِيٓءٞ مِّمَّا تُشۡرِكُونَ Say, "What thing is greatest in testimony?" Say, " Allah is witness between me and you. And this Qur'an was revealed to me that I may warn you thereby and whomever it reaches. Do you [truly] testify that with Allah there are other deities?" Say, "I will not testify [with you]." Say, "Indeed, He is but one God, and indeed, I am free of what you associate [with Him]." -Sura Al-An'am, Ayah 19. فَإِن لَّمۡ يَسۡتَجِيبُواْ لَكَ فَٱعۡلَمۡ أَنَّمَا يَتَّبِعُونَ أَهۡوَآءَهُمۡۚ وَمَنۡ أَضَلُّ مِمَّنِ ٱتَّبَعَ هَوَىٰهُ بِغَيۡرِ هُدٗى مِّنَ ٱللَّهِۚ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ لَا يَهۡدِي ٱلۡقَوۡمَ ٱلظَّٰلِمِينَ But if they do not respond to you - then know that they only follow their [own] desires. And who is more astray than one who follows his desire without guidance from Allah ? Indeed, Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people. -Sura Al-Qasas, Ayah 50. Please stop please stop misguiding people or else you will be wrongdoing.
Wow I love Allah so much allhmdullillh Allah is only one God bless dr. Zakir naik I hope my brother dr zakir naik will come to Kurdistan Iraq one day thank you my brother Allah be with you
You belong to the group who say why women should give birth why women is able to conceive and not men lol, You're missing the basics SIR and I'd suggest do some thinking before rushing or be excited to jump the gun and through insults that has no value.
The prophets wife Aisha used to visit her brothers grave and the prophets daughter Fatima use to visit her uncles grave regularly, so it wouldn't make sense for women to be forbidden from the graves if the prophet use to allow his wife and daughter and plus it's in the hadith which we don't know if it's authentic or not and if there is not a single verse in the Qur'an then I think it couldn't be true that women are not allowed to go to the graveyard.
I am not sure about the answer. The Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam Later encouraged Muslims to visit the grave to remind us of our hereafter. And men and women both need to be reminded Maybe for cultural reasons in some countries it may not be allowed. All Muslims countries allow except a few And in many places graveyards are just open without boundary walls etc adjacent to normal side walks etc. So women and men are passing by.
But that’s only the scholars and they are not our ideals. Prophet Muhammad is our main character in Islam and he clearly prohibited women from entering graveyard. He cursed at the women who visit graveyard and this was something the sahabas followed and to this day we have muslims following this. These people here commenting around saying that women should be allowed is extremely wrong and disrespectful to the Prophets honor alone. We’re now at a point where we are trying to normalize something that the prophet cursed. Follow the path of the prophet only and don’t risk your here after for some scholars.
A lame answer if I heard it right! He said that our beloved Prophet said that a women is not allowed at the graveyard, due to her deeds!! So if a mans deeds are also lacking, then is he to be prevented from going too? Where are the hadith for this and why wasn't this addressed? We men, are also human, we have emotion and feelings too. We cry etc. So the response was a weak one and the hadith are fake.
Assalamu Alaikum, I wanted to ask you a question that a woman has been away from her husband for five years, if her husband has passed away, then should a woman remain in his Idda?
@@hendrasyah8146 why dont u muslim give up ur pagans hindu culture....isnt islamic culture sufficient for d believers?Allah says in Surah Baqarah enter Islam completly
Maybe women are emotional?! Maybe?!! Does this really looks like a rational explanation to you?! How we reacts emotionally depends on individuals and not on bases of gender.
@@kslakhani Well, there is no concrete answer to that. Some studies say that women do express emotions more than men and some studies say that emotional difference between men and women primarily stem from socialized gender roles rather than biology.
I don't care if women are not allowed, I go to graveyard myself, have gone for several purposes too. Graveyard is a peaceful place to just sit beside your beloved person's grave.
Most women weep when they visit a grave, I was with my mother when my father passed away, she began to weep Weeping is not allowed in the grave yard because the dead can hear it and it burns them, also it is like your are questioning the wisdom of Allah when you weep
The reason that women are forbidden to go to graves is also another reason for daughters being discriminated. I have seen many grandsons get favourable affection from grandparents because "the grandsons can pray for me at the grave. The granddaughters cannot do that. So I show more affection for my grandsons" Wait a go Islam. You give every reason for people to not want girls
Have sabr (patience) my dear and fight with your nafs. who are we to question allahs wisdom. He knows what we do not. As for grandparents that have favouritism don’t you believe the most just (Al-Muqsit) will deal with them.
There is no discrimination in Islam. When Allah Himself has no gender why would He think women are less pious. This is all a cultural, patriarchal viewpoint and not the instruction of Quran. There is no restriction in Wuran or Hadeeth about women in graveyards. Logically, also, it doesn't make sense. Mr Naik claims the Prophet said 'some women ', so how are we to judge them?? And what about men who are the majority in actual crimes. How many women do you know who are murderers, thrives or rapists??
There one more reason which he didn't say was that dead people can see you "naked". Because they see every person naked is why women are forbidden to go to the graveyard. You have clothes on but that is how they see people who visit the graveyard.
So it’s ok for female ghosts to see men naked? But male ghosts might get a ghostie boner? Are Muslims actually serious???? Are Muslim men horny like dogs even in death??????
Heh, he is not even sure of his answer, first there is a hadith that prevents women from going to the grave, then of course, there is a hadith which some scholars say the Prophet allowed women to go to the grave. So, now the Prophet is a law-maker beside God !! and why the hell is he using these hadith when they are full of contradictions ? It's sad to see that this Zakir Naik with all his knowledge fails to distinguish between truth and illusion, he still follows fake ahadith attributed to the innocent Prophet, instead of following the trusted source, the words of God; Quran. Plus, "Women are emotional" !! please, like men do not have emotions, and will not cry to the loss of a dear one. For a Muslim doctor who is supposed to guide the nations to say such misogynistic bullshit, ought to make some modern objective logical Muslims feel so special
Misogyny, misogyny, misogyny. Shame on all of those who refuse to see this. A mother losing her child, not being able to visit the grave. No compassion at all with her well-being. The reasoning is beyond unintelligent. In other parts of the world, women go to funerals and graves. Do you really think people think about SEX in these situations? The sexualisation on women is extreme. "Oh, she can't be there, because a Jinn might get atttracted!". Infuriating! Muslim women, rebel!
I AM MUSLIM BUT THIS IS BY FAR THE WORST RULE EVER I DON’T AGREE WITH IT AT ALL SAME GOES FOR MY FAMILY WE DONT FOLLOW THIS RULE IT DOSENT MAKE ANYSENSE 🤦♂️🤷♂️
But according sunnah breastfeeding adult man 10 times makes the woman his mother in the eyeys of Mohammed and Al-Lah. What amazing science in Quran and hadiths. ⚠️⚠️⚠️please watch message of love channel. 🤢🤢🤢Sukran
There are unemotional women and emotional men, individuals exist, this seems cultural and not Islam. I saw an Iranian funeral at our cementary , women there, maybe this has more to do with sect .
I would request dr. Zakir Naik to adress the Wuhan corona virus from a medical point of view... May Allah save us... BismilAllahi ledhi la jedurru mea ismuhu sheyan fil ardi ve la fi semai we huve Samiul-Aleem.
A bit surprised because its a cultural issue. Quran says nothing about it for example. And how are we supposed to judge women, whsts the criterion. Its sad to see scholars say such illogical things.
Honestly this should be very straightforward. Have you seen the graveyard visitings? When they take the person to the grave, it gets too crowded in a way that the men are all touching each other with bodily contacts and collisions, and it would be a disgusting situation for any of our women to be there, getting their bodies touched by other people's bodies due to the crowd level. Secondly, indeed, women get very emotional and do bad things in such case, such as crying on a man's shoulder or even hugging random people. Thirdly, graveyards are not always very nice. Some are hills and some have slope etc, and I have seen with my own eyes women falling and getting injured. Ok, aside from that, later on, if a woman misses someone and wants to go to a visit to the graveyard, her Wali, husband, son, brother, or uncle, can take her and take care of her. Hope that answers the question👍
Well the answer to the problem you mentioned is very simple 1, in a situation where the body is taken to the graveyard OUR MEN can behave nicely as people do it in other societies, there is no need of TOUCHING each other. 2. If she is very emotional and can act in wrong way then she should not be allowed to see a dead body even at her house as she can TOUCH other MEN and cry on THEIR SHOULDERS. 3. Finally if she wants to visit any graveyard,dargah etc she can be accompanied by another woman and she doesn't have to get PERMITTED by her husband. I hope you got the solutions for all your problems
Last i checked a dead corpse is an unclean object and the place that has it is unclean for 7 days. This is why i can't rock with Islam or any other religion.
not permitted because of deeds? what does that mean? this is ridiculous. if i get killed, my mom and sis cant attend my funeral? what kind of nonsense is that.
Then why are they allowed to be burried in the same graveyards. What do u mean by deeds? All men visitors are pious and all women bad. Visiting graveyard reminds us of our last resting plce,makes heart soft, fearful to Allah and motivate to ask forgiveness and do good deeds
So as per this logic, women are not supposed to remind their AAKHIRAAH. What the non sense!!! She can't go to graveyard because she's emotional and she can produce as many children as her husband wants. Kis duniya m jee rhe ho bhai
I have a question. We know that In Islam free mixing between male and female is Haram. And any physical touch between 2 Gayeri Mahram is considered as fornication and serious sin in Islam. Then why in Hajj Islam allows free mixing ? Specially Tawaf at close circle to Kaba has a lot of gathering, where any people will be embraced totally by other. Can a be in that much of gathering while it is haram and almost embracing ?
Lol brother it looks like you have never gone to hajj just seen it from television... I have gone to Umrah in 2015 Alhamdulillah and I can tell you there's nothing like that... They are disallowed to look at other women otherwise their Umrah will become void...And lol you think there is a lot of gathering in hajj? It looks like that on TV only, in actual there is a fine space between people ask from the people who go to Hajj; and specially now because of COVID-19 the things will be more measured for Hajj.... 2022..
@@hasnain9654 I've also went to umrah and the commentator is right. There is a lot of gathering and pushing and shoving during tawaf. Men and women literally squeezed together. You're experience must have been different but I had people thrown at me everywhere.
@@crestfire8008Okay i think that maybe Hajj/Umrah population is increasing day by day... But it is not free mixing,, free mixing happens by choice and intention,, u are doing tawaf for worship purpose not to search for a girl...this is the case of extreme neccessity
@@hasnain9654 if that is your answer then why did you lie and said there is no pushing and shoving during hajj/umrah??? You literally mocked the person for believing what they see on TV as if the TV is not showing the truth. You do know hajj is broadcasted by Islamic channels and not some "Christian Jewish conspiracy"??? Why so defensive now? Instead of lying why didn't you just say "well it is not free mixing because you are not there to look for boyfriend and girlfriend". Instead you said "there's no free mixing and crowds". The problem with Muslims like you is your answer keeps changing when presented with new evidence.
@@crestfire8008 did i say that channels don't broadcast the actual Hajj on TV? u assumed everything by yourself shamelessly,, i meant to say that the crowd is indeed more but not enough to make people tiredsome in doing rituals of Umrah..Hajj is a different story,, making Umrah was easier before... U are the first man I am hearing who complains that people pushing one over another in Tawaaf... This thing I never experienced myself in 2015 neither any of my family member complained about it... Crowd has increased
Seems like you don't have proper answer for the question...
1) men are also emotional and some men are more emotional than a woman.
2) deeds are good and bad irrespective of the gender... So according to this some men having bad deeds shouldn't allowed in the graveyard
Prophet allowed everyone. No gender specified. Only winning and complaining akoud isn't. Crying is permissible but that shldnt be loud.
Yes it seems he is trying hard to fit in his desires
But he said truth about the Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam encourage all Muslims to visit grave to be reminded of death and hereafter. All Muslims include men and women and the Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam didn’t specify it’s for men only.
Secondly he spoke truth when he said Muslims while visiting grave should pray for the dead and not to the dead, of course we know that if we pray to the dead then it would be idolatry/shirk/blasphemy
Thank u for being with muslims and solving our problems. May Allah, the Almighty bless u.
""Or do you think that you will enter Paradise while such [trial] has not yet come to you as came to those who passed on before you? They were touched by poverty and hardship and were shaken until [even their] messenger and those who believed with him said, "When is the help of Allah?" Unquestionably, the help of Allah is near."" Al-Baqara : 214
Subhan Allah
mohammad abid
ua-cam.com/video/TxMeN-N9Xi0/v-deo.html
Ameen
Women are allowed to visit the graves. There are many ahadith supporting this view. Just because the Saudis don't allow them, doesn't mean it's impermissible.
Exactly! Why wouldn't they be allowed! Culture≠islam
Please dont talk without knowledge, there is an authentic hadith where mohammad صلى الله عليه وسلم cursed women who are visiting graves and women who are placing lamps beside a grave. So don‘t talk if you don‘t know.
Asalam o Alaikum. I feel like Dr Zakir didn't answer this question properly. I am a Muslim girl and as far as I know, correct me if I'm wrong, that woman are allowed to go if they have a Mahram man, like a father, brother, son etc. Also as he said there are examples of women going there it's only discouraged. Also Allah says in the Quran that He would forgive the most sinful of sinful if they repent. Also Holy Prophet peace be upon him always encouraged people to repent to Allah and always gave them hope that they would be forgiven. Dr Zakir should have explained that better. A reminder for myself as well. Jazak Allah Khair. I still respect Dr Zakir
He isn't exactly sure I think he said some scholars permit some don't
ua-cam.com/video/AdSQGlXPa9s/v-deo.html
watch this one. Omar Suleiman explained it beautifully
Acc to my family. Well as a girl I was allowed to visit the graveyard but only as a child. Once I got older and hit puberty I couldnt go. But the reason being that remained vague. I didn't look further into it unfortunately.
@@lawlietlawliet There is no reason stated in the Qur'an or Sunnah :/
Woman to woman, sister to sister, thanks
Islam allows Muslim women to go to the cemetery. Unfortunately in the Indian subcontinent Muslim
women are discouraged to go to the grave.
Assalamu'alaykum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh.
Excuse me, My name is Suhendra Dwi Paputra , I'm 19 years old.
I'm from Jakarta, Indonesia. I'm a student of Islamic University of Madinah 2020/2021, And I was graduated from Al-Furqon Islamic Boarding School in Gresik, East Java which tought us arabic language, even the balaghah, dan the hole deen knowledge.
Because of Allah's mercy, beyond the curriculum, I have memorized the hole Qur'an with the number of surah, the number of ayah, and the number of page. And I also have memorized The 8 books of hadith except Musnad Ahmad, the total hadiths are 42.000 with the number of books, Chapters, Hadiths and the pages also.
I implore you to become Dr. Zakir's student , cause beside I want to be like Syaikh 'Utsaimin, I also want to be like Dr. Zakir Naik, especially I think Indonesian people need that.
Jazakumullahu khayran
Masha’Allah, brother im impressed that not only you know many hadith but memorised whole Quran. I recommend you tell him in his private account might be easier and there is a chance he’ll see it
From Allah we came and to Him is our return
إنا لله و إنا اليه راجعون
The translation is more like : to God we belong and to Him we shall return.
Zakir sir is a real hero to explain Islamic truths
@@edward_kenway86 May Allah guide you to the right path
*As a woman If I not enter a graveyard I would never take death serious.*
Is that so?? Are you a muslim? If you are then know that every Muslim has to follow the rulings, whether it makes sense to you or not.
Maybe sir? I believe u didn't answer her question properly with proof sir,
Mohammed Zalahi
He did actually answer the question becuz we women are weak will start crying so much
@@rm3105 As far as I know respectful Dr Zakir Nayak he always give his answers logically with proof of hadiths or Qur'an, but here as u said 0:38 he saying MAYBE woman r emotional, so he is not sure, and he didn't mention any proof. As a man I believe, most of men are very emotional than woman and obviously they don't show it outside. This is what digging my mind logically, and also if u Goole it u will come to know some people saying woman can go graveyard if they can control their emotions. Nowhere solid answers
The fallacy you're pointing out is not in the answer, it's in the question. The question itself didnt include a clear cut reference from quran/hadith, however Dr. Zaker tried to elaborate the judgement of the scholars since there is no clear cut answer/proof.
Mohammed Zalahi
ua-cam.com/video/TxMeN-N9Xi0/v-deo.html
@@kishmish64 It's just his logical percentage-wise assumption, and also 15:23 he did not give any answers to those questions as far as I know. If you have a source for his answers u can give it to me, that would be helpful. Today I did comment on that video, for everyone's sake, I'm adding that comment below.
"
From my research, do not read Rashad Khalifa's translation. watch this (he claimed his self as a messenger of God).
ua-cam.com/video/BwEPoKxUZwc/v-deo.html
also, I compared it with our translation of Quran (Tamil) which is proving Rashad Khalifa's translation is WRONG.
and I don't know why a guy who is deeply researched about this subject and highly recommends reading Rashad's translation, also which makes me more deeply thinking about his LOGICAL ASSUMPTION might be wrong. Allah Knows the best
"
From this, I assume he is trying to set people on the wrong path. Brother, you can not and don't believe everything in Islam in a logical manner, there are things beyond ourselves and logic. Eg, the Existence of Allah. Allah will guide true Muslims on the right path, make dua. Thanks
Masha Allah great answer
Allah sub ko eman naseeb kary
Hope he answered the question.
The answer is women are not treated equal.
It's your ignorance
@@aariqgul229
No I am not. I know quran hadees and the muslim mentality very much because I was a muslim by birth. And I can say every religion is same in this.
@@kaifi7 no bro islam is the complete and true religion u can't compare Islam with other religion and as far as I know Islam is the way of life
@@aariqgul229
I can understand your feeling towards your religion. It's extremely hard to accept the truth I know because I had the same feeling too.
May Allah protect you. sir
Ameen
I visited my mother's grave today, second time after her death in April this year. May Allah grant her Jannatul Ferdous.
Alhamdulillah I didnt wail or make a scene.
I don't have any brothers. Does that mean my mother wont have anyone to visit her grave? Of course not. Islam can't be so illogical.
There is no such rule is Islam that prevents women to visit graves. In Shaa Allah I will visit her grave many more times.
As you as should❤
You should not visit her frequently.. also get married have children and have your spouse and children visit them
May Allah bless you...Dr.Zakir sir.
Roni Hasan
ua-cam.com/video/TxMeN-N9Xi0/v-deo.html
Allah tayala bless you sir
Frst Comment ❣️
May Allah forgive our sin and protect us from shaitan and hellfire
#Truthandbelief
May i know wht u mean by shaitan?? Pls explain brother
@@ganesmages The Devil
@@abelievereverrising283 have u seen??
@@ganesmages no I have not seen him... That's like almost impossible.
@@abelievereverrising283 u mean devil have gender?? Why ur saying is almost impossible ??
Maybe
It means even dr naik is nt sure abt his answer
The reason is itself not mentioned in hadiths so why should he lie? It is just forbidden without reason and being Muslim you should respect every saying of hazrat Muhammad PBUH even if it doesn't make sense for you... Btw in this case particularly, women are allowed to go in graveyard but only sometimes...they cannot go regularly like men but sometimes only
🌷🌷🌷Dr Zakir 🌹🌹🌹🌹
Please upload latest speech of Zakir Naik.
Great man salute you sir Zakir Naik
Mashallah Dr zakir
exactly....wht a logical explanation....
really, women vry emotional bt permitted
😂 the mental retardation in this comment section is actually blowing my mind
Brother now ur talking abt logical?? Can i ask u a logical question ?? Why women wear hijab n burqa??? Pls use logical answer. Can u brother??
ganesmages
MUSLIMS DONT WEAR BURQAS ITS A ARABIAN CULTURE CLOTHS
AFRICANS MUSLIMS
OESANIA MUSLIMS
AND EUROPE MUSLIMS
THE REST OF THE MUSLIM WORLD DON’T
ITS ONLY THE HIJAB THAT IS ABLOGATORY FOR WOMEN TO WEAR WHEN SHE PRAYS AND MOST OF THE TEAM APPERS FOR OTHER STRANGERS
SAME GOES FOR MEN TO NOT SHOW THEIR LEGS OR THEIR BODY WHEN THEY PRAY OR APPER FOR OTHER STRANGERS THAT ARE NOT PART OF THEIR FAMILY
Isbat Ul Kareem
There is nothing in the Quran to support this !!!
ua-cam.com/video/TxMeN-N9Xi0/v-deo.html
.-.
With due respect one of the worst argument I have heard yet.
@XYU Who are you say which religion is right and which is wrong? You are nobody.
You don't make any sense.
Talha Anwar
ua-cam.com/video/TxMeN-N9Xi0/v-deo.html
@Siyovaxsh En-sipad-zid-ana yesss it's all based on the context , we can't really give a generalized opinion on permitted or not . For some prophet did permit for some he didn't
I appreciate that
بسم آلله الر حمن الر حيم
فَلَآ أُقۡسِمُ بِمَا تُبۡصِرُونَ
So I swear by what you see
وَمَا لَا تُبۡصِرُونَ
And what you do not see.
إِنَّهُۥ لَقَوۡلُ رَسُولٖ كَرِيمٖ
[That] indeed, the Qur'an is the word of a noble Messenger.
وَمَا هُوَ بِقَوۡلِ شَاعِرٖۚ قَلِيلٗا مَّا تُؤۡمِنُونَ
And it is not the word of a poet; little do you believe.
وَلَا بِقَوۡلِ كَاهِنٖۚ قَلِيلٗا مَّا تَذَكَّرُونَ
Nor the word of a soothsayer; little do you remember.
تَنزِيلٞ مِّن رَّبِّ ٱلۡعَٰلَمِينَ
[It is] a revelation from the Lord of the worlds.
The Nobel, glorious Qur'an(69:38-43)
إِنَّا نَحۡنُ نَزَّلۡنَا عَلَيۡكَ ٱلۡقُرۡءَانَ تَنزِيلٗا
Indeed, it is We who have sent down to you, [O Muhammad], the Qur'an progressively.
-Sura Al-Insan, Ayah 23.
قُلۡ أَيُّ شَيۡءٍ أَكۡبَرُ شَهَٰدَةٗۖ قُلِ ٱللَّهُۖ شَهِيدُۢ بَيۡنِي وَبَيۡنَكُمۡۚ وَأُوحِيَ إِلَيَّ هَٰذَا ٱلۡقُرۡءَانُ لِأُنذِرَكُم بِهِۦ وَمَنۢ بَلَغَۚ أَئِنَّكُمۡ لَتَشۡهَدُونَ أَنَّ مَعَ ٱللَّهِ ءَالِهَةً أُخۡرَىٰۚ قُل لَّآ أَشۡهَدُۚ قُلۡ إِنَّمَا هُوَ إِلَٰهٞ وَٰحِدٞ وَإِنَّنِي بَرِيٓءٞ مِّمَّا تُشۡرِكُونَ
Say, "What thing is greatest in testimony?" Say, " Allah is witness between me and you. And this Qur'an was revealed to me that I may warn you thereby and whomever it reaches. Do you [truly] testify that with Allah there are other deities?" Say, "I will not testify [with you]." Say, "Indeed, He is but one God, and indeed, I am free of what you associate [with Him]."
-Sura Al-An'am, Ayah 19.
فَإِن لَّمۡ يَسۡتَجِيبُواْ لَكَ فَٱعۡلَمۡ أَنَّمَا يَتَّبِعُونَ أَهۡوَآءَهُمۡۚ وَمَنۡ أَضَلُّ مِمَّنِ ٱتَّبَعَ هَوَىٰهُ بِغَيۡرِ هُدٗى مِّنَ ٱللَّهِۚ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ لَا يَهۡدِي ٱلۡقَوۡمَ ٱلظَّٰلِمِينَ
But if they do not respond to you - then know that they only follow their [own] desires. And who is more astray than one who follows his desire without guidance from Allah ? Indeed, Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people.
-Sura Al-Qasas, Ayah 50.
Please stop please stop misguiding people or else you will be wrongdoing.
ps4Game -Player
As long as Muslims follow Hadiths we will always have problems
ua-cam.com/video/TxMeN-N9Xi0/v-deo.html
Not allowing women in the graveyard is 😥 sad...
Wow I love Allah so much allhmdullillh Allah is only one God bless dr. Zakir naik I hope my brother dr zakir naik will come to Kurdistan Iraq one day thank you my brother Allah be with you
Come on. In Islam,men can do everything and women nothing. You have got those stupid explanation for everything. Why WOMEN sir??
You belong to the group who say why women should give birth why women is able to conceive and not men lol, You're missing the basics SIR and I'd suggest do some thinking before rushing or be excited to jump the gun and through insults that has no value.
The prophets wife Aisha used to visit her brothers grave and the prophets daughter Fatima use to visit her uncles grave regularly, so it wouldn't make sense for women to be forbidden from the graves if the prophet use to allow his wife and daughter and plus it's in the hadith which we don't know if it's authentic or not and if there is not a single verse in the Qur'an then I think it couldn't be true that women are not allowed to go to the graveyard.
I am not sure about the answer.
The Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa sallam
Later encouraged Muslims to visit the grave to remind us of our hereafter. And men and women both need to be reminded
Maybe for cultural reasons in some countries it may not be allowed.
All Muslims countries allow except a few
And in many places graveyards are just open without boundary walls etc adjacent to normal side walks etc. So women and men are passing by.
They are not allowed to go regularly like men, but they can go... This is what I have heard from hadiths
Well said sir
Some scholars say it allowed for women to visit the grave if they are covered properly
That’s true
But that’s only the scholars and they are not our ideals. Prophet Muhammad is our main character in Islam and he clearly prohibited women from entering graveyard. He cursed at the women who visit graveyard and this was something the sahabas followed and to this day we have muslims following this. These people here commenting around saying that women should be allowed is extremely wrong and disrespectful to the Prophets honor alone. We’re now at a point where we are trying to normalize something that the prophet cursed. Follow the path of the prophet only and don’t risk your here after for some scholars.
All men in this world have only done good deed!!!! Utter nonsense
Alhamdulillah
Mashallah
I love my brother dr zakir naik so much from Kurdistan Iraq
کیا خواتین کو جنازہ پڑھنا جائز ہے ؟؟؟پیلز جواب دے۔
Massallah
It was a dissatisfactory answer..!
Be great if they had the choice!!! Stop thinking women are week! They can handle so much more pain than any man can handle😉
Perfect zakir Bhai.
Sahi jawab.
A lame answer if I heard it right!
He said that our beloved Prophet said that a women is not allowed at the graveyard, due to her deeds!!
So if a mans deeds are also lacking, then is he to be prevented from going too? Where are the hadith for this and why wasn't this addressed?
We men, are also human, we have emotion and feelings too. We cry etc. So the response was a weak one and the hadith are fake.
Those narrow minded mullah will never ever accept this reality. They will always suppress the women
How do u know?
@@videosapien6458 it's clearly visible in his speech.do you think that women should be allowed to the mosque?
Thts why i have this question, why women got to wear hijab or burqa?.
@@ganesmages it shows modesty which is compulsory for both men and women
My favourite teacher
@@leonidbrezhnev9917 y thank u
@@leonidbrezhnev9917 uhh Dr. Zakir Naik is the teacher
Really?? Ask him question on ruh@soul?? See can he able to answer or not.
@@leonidbrezhnev9917 not she Nadeem is a male
@@leonidbrezhnev9917 I just corrected you
Assalamu Alaikum, I wanted to ask you a question that a woman has been away from her husband for five years, if her husband has passed away, then should a woman remain in his Idda?
Nice
Allah hu Akbar
Please answer this request, Jazakumullahu khayr
r u hindu brother?
@@azamkhan1526 I'm moslem
@@hendrasyah8146 why dont u muslim give up ur pagans hindu culture....isnt islamic culture sufficient for d believers?Allah says in Surah Baqarah enter Islam completly
👍 *gud answers*
buhat acha video iam a muslim alhamdullellah ...may allah bless zakir naik allah long live him may allah help all muslims ameen
May Allah help all Muslims ummah
#Truthandbelief
Plz make this channel functional in india..we cant search any video or lookout in this channel
Maybe women are emotional?! Maybe?!! Does this really looks like a rational explanation to you?! How we reacts emotionally depends on individuals and not on bases of gender.
Is woman more emotional than man?
@@kslakhani Well, the same question can be said about man.
@@shah555 talk in general
@@kslakhani Well, there is no concrete answer to that. Some studies say that women do express emotions more than men and some studies say that emotional difference between men and women primarily stem from socialized gender roles rather than biology.
Mohammad Shah right , if it’s a loved one, man and woman express emotions
حَدَّثَنَا إِبْرَاهِيمُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ الْجَوْهَرِيُّ، حَدَّثَنَا رَوْحٌ، حَدَّثَنَا بِسْطَامُ بْنُ مُسْلِمٍ، قَالَ سَمِعْتُ أَبَا التَّيَّاحِ، قَالَ سَمِعْتُ ابْنَ أَبِي مُلَيْكَةَ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ ـ صلى الله عليه وسلم ـ رَخَّصَ فِي زِيَارَةِ الْقُبُورِ .
Grade: Sahih (Darussalam)
Reference : Sunan Ibn Majah 1570In-book reference : Book 6, Hadith 138English translation : Vol. 1, Book 6, Hadith 1570
JazakAllah khair.❤
I don't care if women are not allowed, I go to graveyard myself, have gone for several purposes too. Graveyard is a peaceful place to just sit beside your beloved person's grave.
Dr. zakir Aoa. What deeds of certain women for which they are not permitted to the graveyard. Can you please explain. JazzakaAllah.
Wait? Did he even answer her question??
No
Nope
That reason was not at all good enough
Sir aapka channel show nahi ho raha hai
In india it's banned
Dr sahab Plz Sahi Bukhari Ki Hadees Number b bta den .apne btaya nh
Zakir sb the lady is asking v not women r allowed to visit qabristan, dargah?
The hadiths that came saying women are not allowed are not sahih..so both men and women are allowed
Channel kaha gaya apka ???
Banned kar diya india may( aur bhi bhout country may)
brianna D'souza vpn zindaabaad
@@iamrashid1210 vpn matalab?
brianna D'souza dusre country k server se connct krdeta hai vpn usse khul jata hai channel
@@iamrashid1210 ok
ridiculous, a woman should be able to visit her husband and children, of course anyone is emotional when their loved ones pass.
Most women weep when they visit a grave, I was with my mother when my father passed away, she began to weep
Weeping is not allowed in the grave yard because the dead can hear it and it burns them, also it is like your are questioning the wisdom of Allah when you weep
Sorry I meant the dead suffer when people around them weep, not burn
@@zamthe6ft715Provide proof
The reason that women are forbidden to go to graves is also another reason for daughters being discriminated. I have seen many grandsons get favourable affection from grandparents because "the grandsons can pray for me at the grave. The granddaughters cannot do that. So I show more affection for my grandsons"
Wait a go Islam. You give every reason for people to not want girls
Have sabr (patience) my dear and fight with your nafs. who are we to question allahs wisdom. He knows what we do not. As for grandparents that have favouritism don’t you believe the most just (Al-Muqsit) will deal with them.
@@ayshaabdalla6563 your god constantly discriminates women. I have no respect for such a god
There is no discrimination in Islam. When Allah Himself has no gender why would He think women are less pious. This is all a cultural, patriarchal viewpoint and not the instruction of Quran. There is no restriction in Wuran or Hadeeth about women in graveyards. Logically, also, it doesn't make sense. Mr Naik claims the Prophet said 'some women ', so how are we to judge them?? And what about men who are the majority in actual crimes. How many women do you know who are murderers, thrives or rapists??
Islam literally declared a modest girl as a free ticket to jannah to the family bruh
@@LAMI4H Islam also declared that most women will go to hell
Please tell current news about imam mahdi
There one more reason which he didn't say was that dead people can see you "naked". Because they see every person naked is why women are forbidden to go to the graveyard. You have clothes on but that is how they see people who visit the graveyard.
lol what?
So it’s ok for female ghosts to see men naked? But male ghosts might get a ghostie boner? Are Muslims actually serious???? Are Muslim men horny like dogs even in death??????
Heh, he is not even sure of his answer, first there is a hadith that prevents women from going to the grave, then of course, there is a hadith which some scholars say the Prophet allowed women to go to the grave.
So, now the Prophet is a law-maker beside God !! and why the hell is he using these hadith when they are full of contradictions ?
It's sad to see that this Zakir Naik with all his knowledge fails to distinguish between truth and illusion, he still follows fake ahadith attributed to the innocent Prophet, instead of following the trusted source, the words of God; Quran.
Plus, "Women are emotional" !! please, like men do not have emotions, and will not cry to the loss of a dear one. For a Muslim doctor who is supposed to guide the nations to say such misogynistic bullshit, ought to make some modern objective logical Muslims feel so special
Well said bro. We dont let people use religion for their own agenda
Dude... Just stop. The entire earth is a grave yard. Good luck not steeping on the dead.
Woman have rights in Islam. I hear that so often
Ha xD
Of course xD
Yeah they do
Read SURAH AN NISA
@@videosapien6458 send me a link
ua-cam.com/video/0lMNMwTB5M8/v-deo.html lol i dont know if you will watch a 2 hour video but here is surah al nisa
@@falahaltamimi3484 thanks alot brother
@@Sp3ll633 plz listen understand and reflect
Upon our life and the next
Misogyny, misogyny, misogyny. Shame on all of those who refuse to see this. A mother losing her child, not being able to visit the grave. No compassion at all with her well-being. The reasoning is beyond unintelligent. In other parts of the world, women go to funerals and graves. Do you really think people think about SEX in these situations? The sexualisation on women is extreme. "Oh, she can't be there, because a Jinn might get atttracted!". Infuriating! Muslim women, rebel!
Yes it’s all bullsh it
I AM MUSLIM BUT THIS IS BY FAR THE WORST RULE EVER I DON’T AGREE WITH IT AT ALL
SAME GOES FOR MY FAMILY WE DONT FOLLOW THIS RULE IT DOSENT MAKE ANYSENSE 🤦♂️🤷♂️
Firstly a Muslim woman can’t have a male friend unless she is to marry wed the opposite gender I hope this helps
But according sunnah breastfeeding adult man 10 times makes the woman his mother in the eyeys of Mohammed and Al-Lah. What amazing science in Quran and hadiths. ⚠️⚠️⚠️please watch message of love channel. 🤢🤢🤢Sukran
What movies are you all watching that you believe that women are so emotional that they cannot control themselves… such bs
Very good sir
Basically yes women can go as long as they don’t yell or cry loudly
Aren't women allowed to the grave after the funeral is done.
I want know about Hanuman Chalisa.
Does visiting the graveyard remind you of your mortality? - what would people who work in the funeral industry say ? - “ the issue of desensitisation’
Urdu me bhi speech upload kijiye
Being a Muslim can i recite hanuman chalisa
He failed to mention the hadith or give any proof
There are unemotional women and emotional men, individuals exist, this seems cultural and not Islam. I saw an Iranian funeral at our cementary , women there, maybe this has more to do with sect .
Koi iski Urdu translation bta do mehrbani ho gi
I would request dr. Zakir Naik to adress the Wuhan corona virus from a medical point of view... May Allah save us... BismilAllahi ledhi la jedurru mea ismuhu sheyan fil ardi ve la fi semai we huve Samiul-Aleem.
A bit surprised because its a cultural issue. Quran says nothing about it for example. And how are we supposed to judge women, whsts the criterion. Its sad to see scholars say such illogical things.
that muslim girl is so beautiful, WOW
Is Islam against cremation?
What is that
Yeah
some one when you burn someone’s body after they die..
A terrible answer or explanation for why women are not allowed to go to the cemetery or graveyard.
Because Muslim men have decided so despite the fact the Aysha ra went to the graveyard and said in Hadith the prophet said it was fine
Womens are allowed to go listen to engineer mohammad Ali mirza
Honestly this should be very straightforward. Have you seen the graveyard visitings?
When they take the person to the grave, it gets too crowded in a way that the men are all touching each other with bodily contacts and collisions, and it would be a disgusting situation for any of our women to be there, getting their bodies touched by other people's bodies due to the crowd level.
Secondly, indeed, women get very emotional and do bad things in such case, such as crying on a man's shoulder or even hugging random people.
Thirdly, graveyards are not always very nice. Some are hills and some have slope etc, and I have seen with my own eyes women falling and getting injured.
Ok, aside from that, later on, if a woman misses someone and wants to go to a visit to the graveyard, her Wali, husband, son, brother, or uncle, can take her and take care of her.
Hope that answers the question👍
Woow well said
@@lovablelunatic5274 thank youuu 🙏
Exactly, Thank You!
Well the answer to the problem you mentioned is very simple
1, in a situation where the body is taken to the graveyard OUR MEN can behave nicely as people do it in other societies, there is no need of TOUCHING each other.
2. If she is very emotional and can act in wrong way then she should not be allowed to see a dead body even at her house as she can TOUCH other MEN and cry on THEIR SHOULDERS.
3. Finally if she wants to visit any graveyard,dargah etc she can be accompanied by another woman and she doesn't have to get PERMITTED by her husband.
I hope you got the solutions for all your problems
@@firozkhan-fy2hd you're creating unnecessary fuss
What? 🤔
Last i checked a dead corpse is an unclean object and the place that has it is unclean for 7 days. This is why i can't rock with Islam or any other religion.
not permitted because of deeds? what does that mean? this is ridiculous. if i get killed, my mom and sis cant attend my funeral? what kind of nonsense is that.
I wish islam re unite for those rohingyan .... Do not destroy those place that dont want you just help the rohingyan people
Then why are they allowed to be burried in the same graveyards. What do u mean by deeds? All men visitors are pious and all women bad. Visiting graveyard reminds us of our last resting plce,makes heart soft, fearful to Allah and motivate to ask forgiveness and do good deeds
So as per this logic, women are not supposed to remind their AAKHIRAAH. What the non sense!!! She can't go to graveyard because she's emotional and she can produce as many children as her husband wants. Kis duniya m jee rhe ho bhai
I have a question.
We know that In Islam free mixing between male and female is Haram. And any physical touch between 2 Gayeri Mahram is considered as fornication and serious sin in Islam. Then why in Hajj Islam allows free mixing ? Specially Tawaf at close circle to Kaba has a lot of gathering, where any people will be embraced totally by other. Can a be in that much of gathering while it is haram and almost embracing ?
Lol brother it looks like you have never gone to hajj just seen it from television... I have gone to Umrah in 2015 Alhamdulillah and I can tell you there's nothing like that... They are disallowed to look at other women otherwise their Umrah will become void...And lol you think there is a lot of gathering in hajj? It looks like that on TV only, in actual there is a fine space between people ask from the people who go to Hajj; and specially now because of COVID-19 the things will be more measured for Hajj.... 2022..
@@hasnain9654 I've also went to umrah and the commentator is right. There is a lot of gathering and pushing and shoving during tawaf. Men and women literally squeezed together. You're experience must have been different but I had people thrown at me everywhere.
@@crestfire8008Okay i think that maybe Hajj/Umrah population is increasing day by day... But it is not free mixing,, free mixing happens by choice and intention,, u are doing tawaf for worship purpose not to search for a girl...this is the case of extreme neccessity
@@hasnain9654 if that is your answer then why did you lie and said there is no pushing and shoving during hajj/umrah??? You literally mocked the person for believing what they see on TV as if the TV is not showing the truth. You do know hajj is broadcasted by Islamic channels and not some "Christian Jewish conspiracy"??? Why so defensive now? Instead of lying why didn't you just say "well it is not free mixing because you are not there to look for boyfriend and girlfriend". Instead you said "there's no free mixing and crowds".
The problem with Muslims like you is your answer keeps changing when presented with new evidence.
@@crestfire8008 did i say that channels don't broadcast the actual Hajj on TV? u assumed everything by yourself shamelessly,, i meant to say that the crowd is indeed more but not enough to make people tiredsome in doing rituals of Umrah..Hajj is a different story,, making Umrah was easier before... U are the first man I am hearing who complains that people pushing one over another in Tawaaf... This thing I never experienced myself in 2015 neither any of my family member complained about it... Crowd has increased
In Maliki Islam it's okay