DOCTOR WHO 14x3 REACTION | Boom | Season 1 Episode 3 | Series 14 Episode 3
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 чер 2024
- One of the BEST episodes of the series in a LONG TIME!!! #DoctorWho
Use code "OMN1" to receive $5 off for your first Sakuraco box through my link: team.sakura.co/omn or your first TokyoTreat box through my link: team.tokyotreat.com/omn
Intro: 0:00
Doctor Who Boom Reaction: 0:41
Doctor Who Boom Review: 23:25
You can support the channel by becoming a member or heading over to my Patreon to access our Discord, Full Reaction Watch Alongs, Behind the Scenes, Outtakes, and more:
BECOME A MEMBER: / @omn1media
BECOME A PATRON: / omn1media
Join Community Discord: / discord
Follow me:
Twitch: / omn1media
Twitter: / omn1media
Instagram: / omn1media
TikTok: / omn1media
Recent Top Videos:
X-MEN '97 EPISODE 10 REACTION: • X-MEN '97 EPISODE 10 R...
DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE TRAILER REACTION: • DEADPOOL & WOLVERINE T...
SHOGUN 1x8 REACTION: • SHOGUN 1x8 REACTION | ...
FALLOUT EPISODE 1 REACTION: • FALLOUT EPISODE 1 REAC...
X-MEN '97 EPISODE 5 REACTION: • X-MEN '97 EPISODE 5 RE...
JOKER 2 TRAILER REACTION: • JOKER 2 TRAILER REACTI...
HELLUVA BOSS 2x1 REACTION: • HELLUVA BOSS 2x1 REACT...
INVINCIBLE 2x8 REACTION: • INVINCIBLE 2x8 REACTIO...
X-MEN '97 EPISODE 1 & 2 REACTION: • X-MEN '97 Episode 1 & ...
HELLUVA BOSS 1x7 REACTION: • THE ONES WHO LIVE EPIS...
INVINCIBLE 2x5 REACTION: • INVINCIBLE 2x5 REACTIO...
HALO 2x6 REACTION: • HALO 2x6 REACTION & RE...
THE ONES WHO LIVE EPISODE 1 REACTION: • THE ONES WHO LIVE EPIS...
AVATAR THE LAST AIRBENDER 1x1 REACTION: • AVATAR THE LAST AIRBEN...
THE IRON CLAW MOVIE REACTION: • THE IRON CLAW MOVIE RE...
HELLUVA BOSS 1x1 REACTION: • HELLUVA BOSS 1x1 REACT...
HELLUVA BOSS PILOT REACTION: • HELLUVA BOSS PILOT REA...
HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 8 REACTION: • HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 8...
HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 7 REACTION: • HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 7...
HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 6 REACTION: • HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 6...
HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 5 REACTION: • HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 5...
HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 4 REACTION: • HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 4...
HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 2 REACTION: • HAZBIN HOTEL EPISODE 2...
TED 1x1 REACTION: • TED 1x1 REACTION | Jus...
HAZBIN HOTEL PILOT REACTION: • HAZBIN HOTEL PILOT EPI...
OCEAN'S ELEVEN MOVIE REACTION: • OCEAN'S ELEVEN MOVIE R...
WHAT IF 2x9 REACTION: • WHAT IF 2x9 REACTION &...
YU YU HAKUSHO EPISODE 1 REACTION: • YU YU HAKUSHO EPISODE ...
DOCTOR WHO THE GIGGLE REACTION: • DOCTOR WHO THE GIGGLE ...
SHIN GODZILLA MOVIE REACTION: • SHIN GODZILLA MOVIE RE...
DOCTOR WHO THE STAR BEAST REACTION: • DOCTOR WHO THE STAR BE...
SCOTT PILGRIM TAKES OFF EPISODE 1 REACTION: • SCOTT PILGRIM TAKES OF...
LOKI 2x6 REACTION: • LOKI 2x6 REACTION & RE...
FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY'S MOVIE REACTION: • FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY'...
THE FALL OF THE HOUSE OF USHER 1x8 REACTION: • THE FALL OF THE HOUSE ...
ONE PIECE ANIME EPISODE 1 REACTION: • ONE PIECE EPISODE 1 RE...
AHSOKA 1x5 REACTION: • AHSOKA 1x5 REACTION & ...
ONE PIECE 1x5 REACTION: • ONE PIECE 1x5 REACTION...
RRR MOVIE REACTION: • RRR MOVIE REACTION | F...
TRANSFORMERS RISE OF THE BEASTS MOVIE REACTION: • **THEY'RE DOING IT** T...
MY ADVENTURES WITH SUPERMAN EPISODES 1+2 REACTION: • MY ADVENTURES WITH SUP...
SUPERMAN & LOIS 3x13 FINALE REACTION: • SUPERMAN & LOIS 3x13 F...
BUMBLEE MOVIE REACTION: • TRANSFORMERS BUMBLEBEE...
HOW TO TRAIN YOUR DRAGON 3 MOVIE REACTION: • *RIGHT IN THE FEELS* H...
THE FLASH 9x9 REACTION: • THE FLASH 9x9 REACTION...
THE MANDALORIAN 3x8 REACTION: • THE MANDALORIAN 3x8 RE...
MIGHTY MORPHIN POWER RANGERS ONCE & ALWAYS REACTION: • MIGHTY MORPHIN POWER R...
CREED 3 MOVIE REACTION: • CREED 3 MOVIE REACTION...
THE LAST OF US 1x9 REACTION: • THE LAST OF US 1x9 REA... - Розваги
Re "thoughts n prayers" Moffat said in an interview this week, " I want people to stop saying it. It is witless; it is appalling that in the face of people's genuine tragedy and traumatic loss, you trot out a stock phrase. What is the matter with you? "Thoughts and prayers?" How about you send money? I mean, how about you send some help? How about you do something? "Thoughts and prayers" is, "Nevermind. Oh, well."
I thought that if I can just get it in there like, "Exterminate," as what evil robots say, then maybe people will stop saying that idiotic phrase"
"Thoughts and prayers," they said,
As she lay down nearly dead.
"No room for tears," they crooned,
"Be happy heaven's coming soon.
You'll be around forever,
Though we'll see and feel you never.
So thoughts and prayers," they said,
As her eyes closed, lifeless, dead.
Moffat talked about how he wanted "Thoughts and Prayers" to come across the same way "Exterminate" does, cause he was fed up with people using that phrase.
It works so well. This is up there with some of my favorite episode of the show since 2005
Villengard is a Moffat creation first mentioned in Empty Child/Doctor Dances as the origin point for the sonic blasters used by Jack and River in their debut appearances, the factory was replaced by a banana grove after the Doctor destroyed it during The Last Great Time War, which is a story depicted in the comics which explains where the Doctor met Dorium.
(Dorium provided River with a vortex manipulator in Matt’s first series as the Doctor, and was one of the favours called in to help during the events of A Good Man Goes To War, ultimately being decapitated by the Headless Monks, he was the living head the Doctor speaks to in the Wedding of River Song.)
Holy crap are you serious?
12 also went to Villengard in Twice Upon a Time where he met Rusty again.
Moffat really wrote another certified banger 😎 “killing” the companion was 100% a signature Moffat move
Good thing the new….
The inconsistencies are an effect of faith. It's like being in a bad relationship and all your friends are telling you it but you think they are wrong or jealous. Blind faith will always cloud logic. Also a great band.
I think the daughter’s reaction to seeing the hologram of her dad is more of a faith thing than an intelligence thing. I think she knows what the holograms are, but the way she was brought up she genuinely believes that THAT is her dad, or some part of him.
Brazil detected!!! 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
In the end, when the Doctor is talking about writing a diary in drums the rithm that he starts singing is the Brazilian Funk beat 😉
Eu assisti dublado e achei que era algo da dublagem, mas realmente acontece na original
the woman in the ambulance has been in every episode so far
Susan Twist? I think she’s in episode 4 as well
Does she use instant translocation or something
@@Worldoffanboy0278 I’m getting Clara vibes when she divided herself over time
@dominicsoutham147 it could very well *be* Clara, because she goes into the Doctor's time-line after he dies (whenever that happens), so she did split herself all over the Doctor's time-line, including Doctors after the 11th.
At least that's one of the current theories.
That being said, if she is Clara, the big enemy in the end (The One Who Waits) could very well be the Great Intelligence.
@PumpkinPanic Oh I’ve noticed! :P mentioned it in the video! I’m hoping it’s Susan but I’m also cool with it being anyone else as well!
Fun fact, the song the Doctor sings (Skye Boat Song) was also played on the recorder by the Second Doctor back in the 60s in the Web of Fear and by the Master in 2022’s Power of the Doctor.
Annnnnd the 2nd Doctor also discovers the Scotsmam who inspired Outlander. The Skye Boat song is also the Outlander theme song. I love that someone else spotted this!!!
In the behind the scenes 'Doctor Who Unleashed' they showed the base encampment set in detail. It took 4 weeks to build and included wonderfully complex detailing......and appeared on screen for about 80 seconds. 😂 They also used the Volume LED film environment first used in The Mandalorian.
I'm sure someone else has mentioned it: Varada Sethu who played Mundy will be an additional companion in season "2".
"WHO TURNED OUT THE LIGHTS?" The AI just reminded me of the Library.
I watched this episode with my 11 year old daughter, who is new to Who this season (we’re going to go back and watch earlier new Who later). I used to watch with her older sister, and my oldest daughter’s favorites are Matt Smith and Amy Pond. So I was already a sobbing mess, watching this beautiful (and absolutely scathing) episode with such wonderful fatherhood themes mixed in with incendiary social commentary screeds, and then they had to go and say “fish fingers and custard.” 😭😭😭
In defense of the daughter, I don't think she thought it was her real dad. I think she even called it a hologram at one point. But I don't think she realized immediately that it meant her dad was dead. Hologram calling might just be common technology to her, so she thought she walked in on somebody talking to her dad via hologram. But even when she does learn that her dad is dead, she clearly has fully accepted the ideas about the afterlife that were taught to her and doesn't consider it tragic or sad. I thought her character was fairly consistent and a pretty interesting insight into the culture she was brought up in.
Might have been a video AI he sent but it’s ok Ruby ( 3,000 years old ??)
I meeeeean, yes, it could be excused to an extent but not fully. She might not know what a landmine is, she might be as attached to the hologram as she is to her real dad because that's part of her beliefs. But the way she's acting in certain parts is *way off*. Like she's a much much younger child or completely lacks awareness about ANYTHING around her. Adults around her (including a guardian figure to her) are screaming about blowing up, crying, shooting and she's just... "awwww, remember the antelope, daddy?".
Very weird part of an otherwise fantastic episode.
In my humbkest opinion, this was just the best episode in a long long time. Super edge-on-the-seat thrilling, excellently captivating and effective, and most importantly absolutely necessary for our time and this very year. A scathing manifest against war fought for the sake of war, war perpetuated by capitalism and in the name of faith by a church that can't fathom to question its own righteousness, war against a non-existent enemy, war on the back and cost of familiy and children.
This, Wild Blue Yonder and The Devil's Chord are my top three episodes for this era so far.
Same.
Glad Moffet came back to write for an ep, his era and writing were always my personal favourite.
What if the woman, we assume is Ruby's mother, is also played by Susan Twist and isn't her mother at all. The Doctor also dropped Baby Ruby off, that didn't make him her Father. Maybe the woman took her, to hide her, to keep her safe.
The deadly apathy of "thoughts and prayers" and the commercial advertisement and media propaganda of war while maintaining a political level of "acceptable casualities" to justified continued violence is so relevant to today.
The actress playing Mundy had already been announced as the next companion in the second season. Who knows if it’ll be the same character or not??
Didn't know that. He did say he's coming back
hope next season will be trio. those tend to by my favorite doctor who dynamics when he has two companions
She won’t say like Peter Capaldi was in series 4 as a dad and cast as the doctor. Freema played a character in Canary Wharf taken over by Cybermen. Then she played Martha.
Russell T Davies does, and he says not the same.
@@fayesouthall6604Karen Gillen was also in season 4 before being cast as Amy.
Nice to see Varada in this episode before she becomes the Doctors new companion ❤.
By the sounds of things, she's joining the ranks of Freema Agyeman, Peter Capaldi and Karen Gillan (amongst many others!) in doing the guest star becomes main cast route.
Great reaction. Watched a few reactions to this and it's funny to me how one of the most recent complains from Jodie to Tennant was how the Doctor was using the sonic a lot and how it was doing a little too much and now we have one episode where it's completely absent and it's one of the first things people are noting and asking, saying it would've been really helpful in that situation.😂
Yeah and theres actually a really good reason for why the sonic wasn't used here. Because any movement at all, the Doctor or Ruby getting the sonic from his pocket, could potentially cause the mine to go off. The Doctor was quite literally stuck from being able to use his sonic. That is if he even had it on him which lets be honest, the Doctor always has his sonic with him.
@@HarleyQuinn-vb5dm That was exactly what I thought. They could have explicitly stated that on the episode itself, but the lack of the sonic screwdriversl itself didn't bother me because I thought "Ok, the Doctor wouldn't be able to use it because he couldn't move and maybe Ruby doesn't know how to use it (if it is in the Tardis) or can't use it (if it is with the Doctor)".
It was a solid way to disable The Doctor’s ability to use it though I’m surprised that it wasn’t at least mentioned! Maybe he forgot it in the Tardis along with his key!
@@Omn1Media I dont think he could get it out his pocket without going boom
They clearly never watched Classic Who then? The Doctor always use to rarely use his sonic it was only used to unscrew doors to escape and to blow up a few bases but it wasn't this major thing like it would become with New Who he treats it like a magic wand and I hate that the Doctor should be using his wit not his sonic.
Ncuti Gatwa was born in Nyarugenge, Kigali, Rwanda, Africa.
The family escaped from Rwanda during the Rwandan genocide against the Tutsi in 1994 and settled in Scotland.
Love the 2nd Doctor/Outlander nod with The Sky Boat song.
I cried at fishfingers and custard.
"I love him, man. He's really good!" You just described my feelings watching your reaction.
It wouldn't be a moffatt episode without him reminding you he's written doctor who before
Also, I hope Moffat didn't expect Star Wars fans to miss the "Vater/Father" connection.
Vater is father in German. Vader means "father" in Dutch.
In terms of Splice they did admit they meant for her to be 4/6 years old but struggled with casting that young so they went a little bit older. I think it would’ve made a lot more sense with the lower age.
With the daughter and the father’s hologram I think it’s a case of this happens all the time, with her probably seeing people talk to these holograms like they are the real person.
Mrs Twist is absolutely everywhere
My main theory so far about Ruby and the Pantheon. I think the Pantheon are gonna be timelordes survivors. Ruby is going to be related to them and the doctor. I think they are gonna reveal Susan being part of the Pantheon and Ruby being her daughter/granddaughter
I think The Doctor is "The Oldest" and Maestro didn't realize that their sibling was standing next to them the whole time. Oh and that Ruby is gonna be Susan's daughter.
@@christianschoff2490 meant to say the pantheon being revealed to be surviving time lordes
@@BARALover96Its the Pantheon of Discord
@@christianschoff2490 Maestro did say the Oldest was "there that night" (Christmas). Who else was there besides baby Ruby and Ruby's mother? The Doctor.
@@BARALover96 I don't think so. I think The Doctor was from the Pantheon and Tekteun weakened their abilities by dispersing them amongst the Time Lords. I think that The Doctor would originally have been the being representing rebirth but they fell through a gap in reality before being found.
No other actor could have pulled this off. The emotional investment was brave and triumphant.
I think the snow is Rubys Bad Wolf. 3,000 years old !!!
I loved this episode, and your reaction and review did it full justice. Cheers!
30:30 ☺️ I totally agree with you, Omni. It was a drastic change with a daughter from the beginning to the later part. I actually had this haunting feeling that the daughter was gonna die.
22:51 Is that the reason the Doctor used to stick with just one outfit? Now he keeps changing clothes, he can't find his key.
This episode was phenomenal! Best of the RTD 2 era in my opinion. I forgot that when Stephen Moffat isn’t writing his own long-form story, which he’s kind of bad at, when he’s just writing episodic one-offs, he’s a fantastic writer. This is some of the most Doctor Who-esque dialogue we’ve ever had. It was filled with so much tension. My shoulders still hurt. And it was filled with all of Moffat’s classics: religious soldiers, evil robots, faltering tech. And it finally felt like Ruby had a defining moment as a companion in defying the Doctor by handing him the casket and not tossing it. I also loved the inclusion of the “Skye Boat Song.” Does anyone know what the Doctor was saying about the dead president and his wife? Was he quoting something or is that another clue to this season’s mystery box?
I think it is about a story that he tells Clara in Hell Bent, when he keeps telling her about a story about a person that stole the President's wife and a moon. Then he admits that person was him and it wasn't the President's wife, it was the President daughter, and he didn't steal the moon, he lost it.
The unspoken love with the hologram ending was done in the Twelfth Doctor story "Before the Flood".
imo this is way better than the previous two, and it makes me just happy that main doctor who is actually getting fun again
16:36 Yeah they pulled no punches with this one.
The long round lol I just got flashbacks from Clara's last words
Ruby herself reminds me of Clara Oswald
Daddy Moffat is back with a banger
What Is the 2 minute silence at 11 11?
Held each year at 11:00 am on 11 November, the silence coincides with the time in 1918 at which the First World War came to an end with the cessation of hostilities, and is generally observed at war memorials and in public places throughout the UK and Commonwealth.
I think you might be my new favourite reaction channel, purely because you laugh at everything I laugh at
I reacted exactly the same about the people being stupid lol
He didnt use the sonic because he couldnt move to get it out of his pocket. Any shift in weight would have set it off without an equal counterbalance.
I prefer doctor who when the deus ex sonic isnt available.
It was a creative solution to neutralize it being able to fix the situation! Imagine if, like the key, he just forgot it in the Tardis and Ruby just DIDNT get it! Lmao
Great episode, great reaction! 💜💜➕🌈🟦
Moffat writing for RTD just hits different. On course for being the best episode of a RTD season yet again.
Episodes like this make me so fucking confused as to how anyone can disparage Moffat. He consistently writes the best episodes of the show, hands down. I'm looking forward to his Christmas episode this year.
Moffat is the king of one off episodes.. it's arcs and as a show runner and trips himself up trying to be more and more clever
Hands down without a doubt my favorite episode in years of new who, Moffat never fails to deliver an impact with his one-off episodes
After the fantasy of the previous episode, this felt much more like my kind of Doctor Who, much more grounded in the scientifically plausible. Aside from the unnecessary jab at faith (this could have been any army in the Whoniverse), this was a fantastic episode. Great work, Moffat!
This was a very Midnight like episode, I loved it
Vater is father in German. Vader means "father" in Dutch.
his sonic got destroyed last episode
But it had a different colour from before there must be more than one
@@Scroteydadatrue
I wish they got rid of the bloody thing.
I think the daughter didn't change so much as the reasoning behind her odd (to us) behaviour isn't explained until the Doctor tells her her dad is gone and she comes back with "He's just dead, he's not gone" - with everything else going on in this episode I think it played out a bit wonky because it's not really apparent until the end.
We only met the anglicans once in the matt smith era. The weeping angel two parter. I think you're confusing them with the others, like in "good man goes to war". They are madame kovarians soldiers that split off from the papal mainframe/church of the silence. I don't even think they're human.
Those were the ones I was meaning was the ones with Jorah Mormont which was the Angel episodes! :o they also ran River's prison though right?
@@Omn1Media oh fair enough i guess the prison guards might've been anglicans. I actually double checked on the wiki, and the Jorah soldiers are never named as anglicans (they probably are though) and i was wrong. In good man goes to war, they are Anglican marines. I guess working for madame kovarian. I just remembered two characters that introduced themselves as "The thin/fat gay married Anglican marines". I suppose it makes sense that the anglicans joined the papal mainframe. Essentially a super church of religions across the universe.
It can't get worse - Yes it can - The Episode.
Yup, definitely a Moffat story, and alot of references to his previous stories.
Thanks, Omni! ⏳
Couldn't use the sonic. He cant move. and no one can touch him
That’s the next…… Hey Omn1👋🏻.
😊 by the way, the other thing that was weird about the daughter, when she said that her mom was gathered which I took it as she died, but she was not phased by it. It’s almost like the young are taught that death is not an end. They’re just somewhere else. Also, she may have grown up with the whole concept of those AI as being I guess their family because it’s an AI copy, I guess. Remember without having any background story to the company who knows what propaganda they have created all these centuries. But at the same time Mundy was devastated when the other guy got killed instead of like how the daughter is just accepting of death. I don’t know it was weird. It was weird. I have to admit.
All the critics of the show so far who aren’t just claiming woke: the show isn’t edgy anymore and is too family friendly
Moffat: HOLD MY FISH CUSTARD
Woke in my opinion is a word they use but have no idea of it's meaning and certainly couldn't explain it , or might just be people to not hang out with. Even Jesus Christ was "woke", aware of injustice and quite outspoken.
Omn1, this show is really trying to push you to towards that nervous breakdown.
#FabulousFifteen Doctor 🩵
His face not even moving when the ambulance Said "age 3082 YEARS"
Why would it move ?
@@kjo1849 I thought he would be surprised, cause the TARDIS scanned Ruby and Said She was human, no human lives that much.
@@jefersonmedeiros9545The ambulance stated her calendar age, meaning how many years it had been since her birth, not how old she is. It was probably included to tell you that they are in the year 5086.
Could be a clue but probably just the ambulance noting that she is over 3000 years into her future due to time travel
@@eh708 Oh, I didn't think that way, but makes more sense. Also explains why the TARDIS Said She was 19 YEARS
😊 oh yeah one last thing I know that war profiteering company is from Doctor Who from a long time ago like I think almost all the way back to the original doctors went through five
I LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!
Doctor who becomes 40K for an episode and I love it.
This episode was too real in so many ways. As someone who is in the ordination process but delayed for a few reason, I know all too well the "resources are only for the ordained" motif and the way that the church has become very organized like a political, military faction- just like in the episode with the angels.
I feel like these episodes are out of order. In the last episode she said it was June or July. Two episodes before that it was Christmas. But this is her first time seeing an alien sky?
Unless they just want to the past a lot? It's possible.
People watch soaps and are convinced that some characters are real people and not just actors.
Moffat struggles with long-term story arcs, but he's *so good* at one-off episodes! I loved this episode for so many reasons.
He didn’t struggle he just tries harder
@@kjo1849 No... he struggles. His long-term story arcs always tend to fall apart. Not just in Doctor Who, but in general. Sherlock was great, and at only 3 or 4 episodes a season, was short enough to avoid this issue... for a bit. But by season 3 -- I think it was? -- it had gone on long enough that it all fell apart. It went from being a Sherlock Holmes detective show to a governmental conspiracy show... for no real reason, other than, "Moffat didn't know how to keep the character arcs going without revolving the world around his character."
@@IceMetalPunk You say that, but the Silence was teased at the beggining of Matt Smith's arc, and it had its conclusion at the very last episode in a brilliant way
@@Koraki0000 True. I should have been more specific: he struggles with long-term *character* arcs. Plot arcs I suppose he can manage, but when it comes to characters, given enough time, he always ends up overcompensating with the plot to force character development, rather than letting it happen organically. In my opinion, at least; others may feel it's more organic than I do.
I thought it was very clear that Splice knew the AI wasn't her real dad lmao, she even said she knew it was a hologram. She cared bc it was her only lead to finding the real him, nothing implied she would know that the hologram meant he was dead. Which is also why her faith pays off in the end. The reason she only freaks out once the Ambulance attempts to purge John is because she was about to lose that lead, lol
similarly i think it's a bit silly to think Mundy denied his feelings bc she didn't know lol, trying to gaslight yourself into thinking they don't have feelings for you because you don't have feelings for them is common both irl and in media. I mean jeez they even set this up super early on when she was still in the base camp
wild how the episode naturally referenced every other modern Doctor and the 2nd Doctor, i think his poem about the moon and the president's wife is my favorite example though.
Thinking of his happiest moments with The Master, their time at the academy and his time with Missy, is the thing that finally calms him down, which is just so sweet
I'm glad other people seem to be enjoying this. For me, it kind of fell apart when the civilians showed up (after the doctor had successfully redistributed his weight) and they proceeded to act like total fools. The little girl's behavior in particular felt totally contrary to any logic or believability. (Omn1 apparently had similar issues.) In retrospect, I suspect that maybe she was originally written to be like 3-5 years old, and they ended up casting 9-12. So instead of just innocent, she came across as having the IQ of a turnip.
This episode was all kinds of fucked up. And I'm pretty sure that's one way to permanently kill a timelord. There's no regenerating from "you're the explosive".
Yup, same Anglican Marines we saw back in Matt's era in Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone and also in A Good Man Goes To War. I don't think we've ever got a proper backstory to them in the show, or why the Anglicans are apparently the military for the future Church
i have no idea what you say in the intro in ANY video you might as well not say it tbh 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Great reaction, as always Mike! 100% agree with you about the daughter... I'm also one of the few (it seems) that thought she was being a tad dumb re. heading out into a legit battlefield & not recognizing her dad was no longer actually there. Maybe denial? Regardless, that's just a tiny nitpick of an excellent episode ❤
I love when the Doctor gets angry and frustrated at humans and calls them stupid and acts superior.
I don't think they were even human remember this is set on another planet.
This was more like it . Tense , well acted with a moral message , Great effects and really well scripted . Moffat may save the Doctor yet .
I loved this episode, but that girl was too old to be that naive. If she was 4 or 5 maybe but she was like 12 or 13. Was she supposed to be handicapped? Autistic? Just think it would have read much better if the character was younger.
That's religion for you
She’s an indoctrinated religious child, like heavily indoctrinated.
great ep, but i feel like it would of been better if the kid didn't go to the battlefield, could of still done the dad to dad thing without her being there imo, especially since nothing really seems to faze her she was the only one not in a panic for some reason. it made the fact her dad died have less impact weirdly
Glad you’re doing dr who missing Helluva Fridays
Why are they wearing U.S. helmets?
As the U.S spends the most on military equipment, that would be my guess in the context of the story.
The only positive thing i'll say about this episode is it's not set on earth i'm happy that were finally on another planet for a change and no sonic screwdriver thank christ but the story itself was another typical moffat story no one dies, annoying kids, no stakes and no villains.
I dont mean to sound rude, this is a genuine question.
Do people really enjoy the first 22 minutes just being tiny sized clips of the show and a dude going “wow” “oh no”.
Feels so pointless, id rather just skip to you giving your proper opinion afterwards
Well there’s definitely more than just that during the reaction but the majority people are only here for that section. Most people leave when the reactions over and rarely stay for the review or after thoughts. Only about 10% of viewers watch beyond the reaction.
@@Omn1Media Thats wild to me, but fair enough, everyone has different tastes. Glad you found your audience!:)
I think the writing for the daughter was inconsistent and just badly done later on the battle field. I don’t think it’s the actress’s fault.
Shit was written well clearly in that culture the air is as real as a human
The allegory is so ham-fisted the pig is still alive. Having him say "Do you get it?" multiple times into the camera was so stupid. It feels like this episode was written years ago meant for 11 and Clara with the way both of them are acting. Moffat brought back all his greatest hits in the worst way possible. Easily my least favourite episode so far.
They are renaming the show doctor poo because it's a load of plop