Have heard this version and Paul's current touring band play it back in probably 2005 or 2006. Such different technology. George was perfect and so was Rusty Anderson's version.
@@dustyfats6639 listen to his solo career and on wings notably songs like ''Monkberry Moon Delight'' or ''Call me back again'' for that ''Oh Darling'' Shriek or ''Junk'' for that till there was you mellowness
yes but the solo he plays in this is one of the easiest solos in the history of guitar I learned to play it flawless when I was 12 years old but yes i agree he is an underrated guitarist and my favorite Beatle
Zovlo We used to have a minah bird that could whistle the end of Dock Of The Bay just like Otis Redding. It didn't get a contract with Atlantic Records though.
The Yawn hello I just saw your comment a year ago about George Harrison solo on Till There Was You didn't realize that I love all four of the Beatles and I especially Love George I think he was underrated he was lead guitar you know take care
@@dorkle9085 no hagas caso, hay gente que cree una tontería de que Paul murió en un accidente en el 66 y lo reemplazaron por otro, evidentemente es falso, si tuvo un accidente y se rompió un diente y se hizo un corte en el labio y eso es todo.
I can't help but think George Martin had something to do with the selection of this song for the band. It was atypical of the other covers the did at the time. George Harrison's guitar reveals a virtuoso command of the instrument. No pedals or effects...just beautiful simplicity. Amazing.
Agreed, it was put in a great place up until 1966, then it all went tits up, and since then it has just hit the skids, like Sir Fraud`s "career". Lmfao.
Reason #136 why the Beatles are unparalleled in music history...honestly feel sorry for those young people who don't give them a chance. Their level of songwriting (though they didn't write this particular one!), craftsmanship, performance, style - the brand new directions they took music, and culture in general - puts 99.9% of current artists to shame.
im 14 and I gave them a chance since im 9 but youre right most teenagers in my age prefer 1D, taylor swift and snoop dog and thats so sad. today songs have no meaning
If we ever have to explain what music is to an alien race from another galaxy... THIS is what we need to show them... this performance. Pure and astounding sound that touches the soul.
Is no one going to talk about how Paul's fingers seem to have lives of their own and knows where to go even when he is singing? He sings just as good playing bass as when singing solo
The genius of James Paul McCartney which I don't people realize or appreciate fully is that he is doing two (2!) different jobs at the same time ;singing the melody and playing the bass part, which are quite, QUITE different musical things. In other words, he is walking and chewing gum at the same time, except doing something much more difficult and challenging here (and on all Beatles records). George Harrison is doing something more closely related to the melody, playing the lead guitar (on With/Meet The Beatles studio album, a Spanish classical guitar).
Paul McCartney has not been given the credit he deserves, either as a singer or as a bassist. Everybody knows he is a great songwriter, but he`s also a great singer and musician! and i agree with you on George. George Harrison is the most underrated guitar player ever. Ringo is underrated as well. The Beatles were great musicians. They did not use session players like the Beach Boys. They did their own music. They hired musicians to do strings and trumpets, but they always played their own instruments, and they were all good musicians. John was a terrific rhythm guitar player. Ringo played great drums, George played beautiful guitar, and Paul could play every instrument you handed to him, and he played them well. His bass playing is just amazing..
This is precisely why it is so absurd that some claim he died and was replaced. You CAN'T replace that kind of talent. He is skilled in so many ways - bass, singing, performance, songwriting, guitar, piano... The list goes on.
I was 10 years old when I saw this for the first time; I am still 10 years old because of this song. The great George Harrison plays a solo for just under 18 seconds; he is 20 years old as million listen and watch history being made.
This has to be the best i have ever heard Paul singing, damn he hits some seriously high notes there and he hits them bang on and pitch perfect everything
My favorites Paul singing with Wings...Monkberry Moon Delight is insane ..of course Hey Jude ..he just goes nuts! lol! A few others I can't think of right now.
2 роки тому+1
Not really high notes, but he does sing them perfectly.
When sung on the Sullivan show Paul distinctly pronounced "saw" as soar". At the time I imagined it was a British or " Liverpool accent. Here he sings "properly".
Just saw "The Music Man" again today and the host said Meredith Wilson's widow wrote the ballad and that the royalties//residuals for this song was larger than anything they got for the movie and the song "76 Trombones" because the Beatles chose to do it as a cover.
This is one of my favorite live performances, and Georges guitar work is as good here as pretty much anything else he did later on. Beautifully done lads.
This is why beatles's music is absolutely unique, you will appreciate even the instrumental accompaniment. I think they could have still made a hit even when it is just instruments playing in their music. I find this quality in music so rare nowadays.Gahd I so love George's solo and Ringo's percussion. Beatles is a legend.
If ever there was a definitive Valentine's Day anthem, this must be it! One of the most romantic songs ever written! And can it get any better with Paul lending his voice to it?
Unlike his current replacement, who has no talent whatsoever, and is not fit to lick the soles of James Paul McCartney`s boots, he could try for another 50 years, but he knows, just as we all know, that he never, ever will be.
This is the magic of the Beatles' music. Pure unadulterated music. My ears are glued to the radio whenever they play the Beatles, especially this song during my younger years. It makes me go back in those days. Reminiscing.
This was the original live performance recorded as they played. These guys worked their butts off and practiced a great deal which does make things seem so easy. George playing such lovely enhancements on guitar and Ringo's excellent percussion make this song...
A friend's band performed the song at a club in Big Bear, Cailf. Shirley Jones, who sang it in The Music Man, was in the audience. She chatted with them during the break and they talked her into getting up next set to sing it again. What a voice.
Paul McCartney.....................What a sweet guy. George Harrison sounds like Les Paul. WONDERFUL !!! It lifts my spirit and takes me to a place where we music lovers all know and love.
Actually, they were turned down for their first recording audition. The music producer thought the public would not like their style, which was different from anybody else's style.
I was nearly ten when our parents turned on The Ed Sullivan Show that night in Feb 1964. The entire history of pop music changed forever that night. I bought their first album the next day and began listening later relating to how George Harrison’s “jazz guitar” playing in minors and diminished and augmented chords in this number compared to jazz albums later realizing the guitar genius Harrison was. All four of them together was like magic. They made the 1960’s a special time to experience.
Agreed. I've been playing guitar for almost 40 years, and I can tell you that his solo here is excellent. The tone, phrasing, and groove are super. I like it better than the studio album version. For a 20 year old to play live with such refinement is truly amazing. The natural reverb from the hall adds a great ambiance I think.
I would like to expound a little more on my previous thoughts. An example here is at 1:23 - 1:26. He gets the harmonics of these 6 chords to swirl with each other beautifully. Perhaps his musical instinct ( or, perhaps, genius) told him the natural reverb would be part of the blooms.
Será que Sou o Único Brasileiro na Face da Terra 🌍 que se Emociona com uma Linda Canção dessa Simplesmente Incrível Explendido 😊 The Beatles o Melhor de Todos os Tempos Todo Sempre 🎉🎵🎉🎶🎉🎵🎉🎶🎉🎵🎉🎶🎉🎵🎉🎶🎉
+Susan Mendell I know. Being born 1960, even I was brought up to do that but no one does it today. Today's pop stars thank their audiences too but v. seldom by bowing! :)
George's guitar solo was so perfect.
That's why John and Paul picked George as the lead guitar player.
Have heard this version and Paul's current touring band play it back in probably 2005 or 2006. Such different technology. George was perfect and so was Rusty Anderson's version.
It sounds like a Mexican instrumental
@@engagementengagement8836 not mexican, spanish guitar
Few were as good as George .... Clapton, Hendrix, Beck, Page. But for the Beatles George was the perfect fit.
Paul definitely has one of the best voice in music.
Agreed. So versatile; he could sing anything.
George Tran wouldn’t say in music but for what the Beatles were yes he was really good at it.
@@dustyfats6639 listen to his solo career and on wings notably songs like ''Monkberry Moon Delight'' or ''Call me back again'' for that ''Oh Darling'' Shriek or ''Junk'' for that till there was you mellowness
Had. Never heard such a strong vibrato out of him since.
Had the best voice, you mean, there have been 7 different "Pauls" since this original Paul. Lmfao.
George Harrison is honestly so underrated as a guitarist.
Not for the Beatles! 👌👌👌
yes but the solo he plays in this is one of the easiest solos in the history of guitar I learned to play it flawless when I was 12 years old but yes i agree he is an underrated guitarist and my favorite Beatle
Zovlo We used to have a minah bird that could whistle the end of Dock Of The Bay just like Otis Redding. It didn't get a contract with Atlantic Records though.
Doesn t matter how easy or difficult. Its about the perfect notes at the right time. Tasty playing.
Never underrated in my world!
George was an absolute genius...
So sad he's gone :(
This George is still alive & kicking ; )
@@helenhanson5781 he's not
@@cricinfinity1213 ur an idiot
George Harrison: age, 20 years, talent, by the millions.
20 years 😮
Omg Georges solo was top class
The Yawn uh like duh
The Yawn hello I just saw your comment a year ago about George Harrison solo on Till There Was You didn't realize that I love all four of the Beatles and I especially Love George I think he was underrated he was lead guitar you know take care
Denny Olver yeah people dont often see it but he was a world class guitarist...
Actually he does that solo much better on the Ed Sullivan Show. Much more polished.
Excelente 🎸🎸🎸
Paul McCartney is proof of the existence of angels :)
Omg, if only you knew just how wrong you are . . Lol . . but, God willing, everyone will know the truth very soon ; )
@@helenhanson5781 What?
@@helenhanson5781 you are a frightening, frightening drunk
@@dorkle9085 no hagas caso, hay gente que cree una tontería de que Paul murió en un accidente en el 66 y lo reemplazaron por otro, evidentemente es falso, si tuvo un accidente y se rompió un diente y se hizo un corte en el labio y eso es todo.
Simply amazing. No auto tune, no overdone stage show, no gimmicks...pure genius.
Thankfully the audio quality is not as bad as the video...
Pure TALENT!!
I can't help but think George Martin had something to do with the selection of this song for the band. It was atypical of the other covers the did at the time. George Harrison's guitar reveals a virtuoso command of the instrument. No pedals or effects...just beautiful simplicity. Amazing.
No. It was Paul. IMHO.
Yeah, it was actually Paul
That, my young friends, is what you call a “BAND”.....who just happens to be the best in the world 😎🎸
Perfect.
This band put music in a place it will never be again.
Agreed, it was put in a great place up until 1966, then it all went tits up, and since then it has just hit the skids, like Sir Fraud`s "career". Lmfao.
@@helenhanson5781 you forgot to take your pills again jennifer
@@helenhanson5781 Es una pena que te hayas perdido del 66 al 70.
Right
Paul's vocal is THE BEST
I love how he shakes his head in that funny way :)
Gives his voice that extra bounce ...
True :) every artist has his own style in bringing that extra spark of personality
He's keeping time with his head. He was a decent drummer as well.
paul nowadays didnt do that
yes
Reason #136 why the Beatles are unparalleled in music history...honestly feel sorry for those young people who don't give them a chance. Their level of songwriting (though they didn't write this particular one!), craftsmanship, performance, style - the brand new directions they took music, and culture in general - puts 99.9% of current artists to shame.
And that's an understatement.
I got my grand kids hooked onto them when they were little, now most of them are teenagers and one is 20 years old!
Riiiiiight
im 14 and I gave them a chance since im 9 but youre right most teenagers in my age prefer 1D, taylor swift and snoop dog and thats so sad. today songs have no meaning
but there are also other great bands. i mean, we can't keep pretending like they're "THE GREATEST BAND IS ALL OF HUMAN EXISTENCE OH MAH GOD"...
George was fantastic....
This performance shows how gifted a guitar player George Harrison was. Always played for the song
best solo ever by the best guitarrist on the rock history: george harrison!!!
I really like the beatles, but I think I would have to give that title to prince when he was alive
If we ever have to explain what music is to an alien race from another galaxy... THIS is what we need to show them... this performance. Pure and astounding sound that touches the soul.
George is just masterful on the guitar!
Is no one going to talk about how Paul's fingers seem to have lives of their own and knows where to go even when he is singing? He sings just as good playing bass as when singing solo
The genius of James Paul McCartney which I don't people realize or appreciate fully is that he is doing two (2!) different jobs at the same time ;singing the melody and playing the bass part, which are quite, QUITE different musical things. In other words, he is walking and chewing gum at the same time, except doing something much more difficult and challenging here (and on all Beatles records). George Harrison is doing something more closely related to the melody, playing the lead guitar (on With/Meet The Beatles studio album, a Spanish classical guitar).
I dig it. It's lost on alot of people, how difficult his performances were. I am a HUGE fan and forget sometimes
Paul McCartney has not been given the credit he deserves, either as a singer or as a bassist. Everybody knows he is a great songwriter, but he`s also a great singer and musician! and i agree with you on George. George Harrison is the most underrated guitar player ever. Ringo is underrated as well. The Beatles were great musicians. They did not use session players like the Beach Boys. They did their own music. They hired musicians to do strings and trumpets, but they always played their own instruments, and they were all good musicians. John was a terrific rhythm guitar player. Ringo played great drums, George played beautiful guitar, and Paul could play every instrument you handed to him, and he played them well. His bass playing is just amazing..
This is precisely why it is so absurd that some claim he died and was replaced. You CAN'T replace that kind of talent. He is skilled in so many ways - bass, singing, performance, songwriting, guitar, piano... The list goes on.
@@daniellet9293 nobody thinks he died and was replaced. But it's obvious the beatles were making some kind of joke about that.
They're considered one of the greatest bands ever... Do you even know the meaning of underrated?
George's guitar licks just ooooze 1960's sound; especially the last "cha-cha-cha" chords. Fantastic!
More like bolero style than cha cha cha.
I was 10 years old when I saw this for the first time; I am still 10 years old because of this song. The great George Harrison plays a solo for just under 18 seconds; he is 20 years old as million listen and watch history being made.
Even though it's a cover, still one of my favorite Beatles song
one of the greatest solos. it's not just as many notes as possible. it works with the progression perfectly
James, I have to agree with you 100%. The Beatles were Mufti-talented writing, performer, musicians.
So clean and the musicality of Paul is out of this world
this is the sweetest song ever , Paul McCartney's voice and charm is ageless !
This has to be the best i have ever heard Paul singing, damn he hits some seriously high notes there and he hits them bang on and pitch perfect everything
My favorites Paul singing with Wings...Monkberry Moon Delight is insane ..of course Hey Jude ..he just goes nuts! lol! A few others I can't think of right now.
Not really high notes, but he does sing them perfectly.
When sung on the Sullivan show Paul distinctly pronounced "saw" as soar". At the time I imagined it was a British or " Liverpool accent. Here he sings "properly".
Today, as countless times before throughout 54 years, here I am swaying and singing along to this absolute jewel of a song. No Beatles, no life! 😉
Paul your voice is so refreshing every time that I hear you. I could hear you all day and evening, and never get sick of you singing!
George’s guitar solo was marvelous ,unbelievable ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Paul’s voice is one of kind 😌
Amen
They will never be again. I am happy to say I grew up listening to the Beatles
george -the worlds most underrated guitar hero!!-when i saw music man the first time i said "hey they got that from the beatles!"
And there was music....
And wonderful roses...
His smile is so adorable :3
Paul is such an angel.
I miss George immensely. Rest in pride, my idol George!🙏
Just saw "The Music Man" again today and the host said Meredith Wilson's widow wrote the ballad and that the royalties//residuals for this song was larger than anything they got for the movie and the song "76 Trombones" because the Beatles chose to do it as a cover.
GOD! that voice was pure....george, ''simply'' awesome.....legendary performance
I love the way he shakes his head.... cute!!!
This is one of my favorite live performances, and Georges guitar work is as good here as pretty much anything else he did later on. Beautifully done lads.
This was the only song I could convince my Dad to listen to by The Beatles. He was a terrific Dad: 1924 - 1979 = W.S.C., Jr.! * Cav *
I adore Paul. And always will. They all sounded great. Just lovely instrumentals
This is why beatles's music is absolutely unique, you will appreciate even the instrumental accompaniment. I think they could have still made a hit even when it is just instruments playing in their music. I find this quality in music so rare nowadays.Gahd I so love George's solo and Ringo's percussion. Beatles is a legend.
This is a rendition of another song but yes I agree
But I never sawr them winging! No, I never sawr them at all!!
Till there was youuu.....
What a charming rendition of this sweet song from "The Music Man" by Paul of the 60's. Love it!
Great for All Times !
knowing the Beatles music was and always wil be a blessing to me.
Great solo!!! Well done George!
If ever there was a definitive Valentine's Day anthem, this must be it! One of the most romantic songs ever written! And can it get any better with Paul lending his voice to it?
QUE HERMOSO Y PERFECTO SOLO.....GRANDE HARRISON
listening to this for the 8th time now. So classic ♡
George and Paul are just amazing
Love this version and performance! Paul is so cute, young and talented! Love Paul ♥
Talented as Fk!
Unlike his current replacement, who has no talent whatsoever, and is not fit to lick the soles of James Paul McCartney`s boots, he could try for another 50 years, but he knows, just as we all know, that he never, ever will be.
@@helenhanson5781 sabes que lo del reemplazo es imposible, déjate de tonterías y disfruta de la música.
This is the magic of the Beatles' music. Pure unadulterated music. My ears are glued to the radio whenever they play the Beatles, especially this song during my younger years. It makes me go back in those days. Reminiscing.
This was the original live performance recorded as they played. These guys worked their butts off and practiced a great deal which does make things seem so easy. George playing such lovely enhancements on guitar and Ringo's excellent percussion make this song...
after listening to the beatles so much,i find myself bobbing my head like paul....the struggles of being a beatles fan;)
the most romantic song I ever heard. love, love, love!!!!!
Perfect George
After Let It Be, I think that may he his best Beatles guitar solo. George Martin helped him with it, but it's just perfection.
Beautiful beyond words. We remember you Paul, rest in peace.
Paul is still alive
+Zoe Hamilton
Even without shoes?
+stinnm fsusd so what? he has his shoes off big deal that doesn't mean he's dead that's stupid
+Norm Rohrer : RIP Paul. Gone but not forgotten.
There were many Pauls after this one, can you point me toward any info of proof of his demise, so to speak please? Thanks ; )
Great for ALL times !
Love how they are moving to the music. Innocence!
My favorite part: George's guitar solo, even on the ending
A friend's band performed the song at a club in Big Bear, Cailf. Shirley Jones, who sang it in The Music Man, was in the audience. She chatted with them during the break and they talked her into getting up next set to sing it again. What a voice.
He is so gorgeous.
Paul McCartney.....................What a sweet guy. George Harrison sounds like Les Paul. WONDERFUL !!! It lifts my spirit and takes me to a place where we music lovers all know and love.
oh man, that solo was beyond perfection!!
This epitomizes why I fell in love with Sir Paul back in 1964 and love him to this day. He is such a class act.
When I saw this, I knew they were GOOD (I was 9). The music establishment was won over instantaneously!
Actually, they were turned down for their first recording audition. The music producer thought the public would not like their style, which was different from anybody else's style.
Nailed it. Paul headbobs coz he's nervous but delivers an outstanding live vocal performance. And George is right there for the solo. Exquisite.
I was nearly ten when our parents turned on The Ed Sullivan Show that night in Feb 1964. The entire history of pop music changed forever that night. I bought their first album the next day and began listening later relating to how George Harrison’s “jazz guitar” playing in minors and diminished and augmented chords in this number compared to jazz albums later realizing the guitar genius Harrison was. All four of them together was like magic. They made the 1960’s a special time to experience.
Fabulous! McCartney's Lyric Pop/Tenor voice, George's extraordinary lead guitar work, Lennon & Ringo supply a solid rhythm section.
this song that made me fall in love with The Beatles
From what is probably the best musical ever made before one of the late 60s-early 70s efforts -- _The Music Man._
Through the roof talent
Great version of a standard by the best group ever
This is the song that made me like the Beatles in 1964. Still my favorite.
Crystal clear voice,Paul
George's solo in this is everything.
Agreed. I've been playing guitar for almost 40 years, and I can tell you that his solo here is excellent. The tone, phrasing, and groove are super. I like it better than the studio album version. For a 20 year old to play live with such refinement is truly amazing. The natural reverb from the hall adds a great ambiance I think.
I would like to expound a little more on my previous thoughts. An example here is at 1:23 - 1:26. He gets the harmonics of these 6 chords to swirl with each other beautifully. Perhaps his musical instinct ( or, perhaps, genius) told him the natural reverb would be part of the blooms.
GEORGE!!!!!!! AAAAAAHHHHHH!!!! x)
Well, they played this concert on 4th of November .
‘63, the day that I was born. That’s why I like this songtitle.
Anyone else think that today's music sucks more than a plunger? I do! This, the beatles, is truely perfection.
Through the sixties, Beatles were on the radio all day and night. It was so wOw!
1:15 for all those of you that want to hear the best part of this whole performance.
BEATLES FOREVER !👍
George was playing so intently, wouldn't even look up. Always had a crush on him... 🖤🤍
Paul tocando con los dedos y muy arriba para conseguir un sonido grave-contrabajo......Genial!!!!!
the lyrics are just so beautiful
Será que Sou o Único Brasileiro na Face da Terra 🌍 que se Emociona com uma Linda Canção dessa Simplesmente Incrível Explendido 😊 The Beatles o Melhor de Todos os Tempos Todo Sempre 🎉🎵🎉🎶🎉🎵🎉🎶🎉🎵🎉🎶🎉🎵🎉🎶🎉
i want to play this all throughout the day ♡
his voice makes me melt
Ahhhhh Paul has such a beautiful voice...and a face to match :-D dear god, why did have to be born in 1994????
Brilliant performance!!!
It was incredible to witness this pivotal moment in music history on t.v.
The way they are bowing after the tune is so oldfashioned!
Still.... magic performance!
+arnarne That's the way it was done back there...it's called manners....being polite and thanking the audience.
+Susan Mendell I know. Being born 1960, even I was brought up to do that but no one does it today. Today's pop stars thank their audiences too but v. seldom by bowing! :)
Plus, Princess Margaret was in the audience. It would have been a serious faux pas not to bow in the presence of royalty..
arnarne they thank their audience by "twerking" I imagine.
Old fashioned? It's over 50 years ago. What dd you expect?
such a truly beautiful voice - sad loss that he left us so young.
Beatles x sempre li adorooooooo ❤
Paul could charm the pants off an octopus. That voice...and those looks...someday I will invent a working time machine :D
Still wonderful and magical after all these years!