"Can we make Rashford into a 25 goals striker consistently"..... the guy is 27 hes been playing professionally for 8 years and Neville still talking like he's a 20 year old
I mean history shows he just needs a left footed overlap partner and you get goals. Don't blame the player that the bald moron decided to rob him of any space to operate
The righteous PR cult that swooped around him ruined him, he stopped thinking how cool football is.... more worries about twitter and who's headlining the night clubs @@spacedoge6540
It's the same in all industries where chat is such a big part of the industry. Accountancy too. Brimming with failures and dysfunctionality. The PO scandal the same. Symptomatic. Grifting liars unready for everything.
There aren't any bluffers. They basically don't exist in this echoing world the professionals live in. There are multiple reasons why certain players work under one manager/club and not on other ones, but it's not because of them being deliberately bad. It's entirely psychological. Keane are from the old school where men are men and feelings are left in a box. That's not how it work today unless you get ONLY people with that singular mindset in your squad. ETH seemed like the strict old school type, especially considering how he solved the Sancho issue. Amorim seems much more charismatic. If I were a United supporter I would have been carefully optimistic about this new manager. You tried Keane tactic for 3 managers except maybe Solskjaer and it hasn't worked.
@AeonQuasar get your head out of the sand. There are a good many lazy, bluffers at the club. Until we get rid of these players and get some quality players who work hard and want to play for the club.
Exactly! Managers have no bearing on the players. They should just hire you! It’s so unfair that ETH was forced to get his players paying well! That’s not the job of a manager!
@@warriorrob1 for some players, yes. This will be the 5th manager for Rashford and he's just turned 27 It's not about quality for me it's the effort and work rate that's missing
"Can he make Rashford a 25 goal a season player" Sorry Gary but in no other workplace would managers be churned out to get the best out of such a sh**, overrated and inconsistent employee. Never seen a more protected player
Rashford is the best Man Utd player, he’s been compared to Mbappe, the only problem with Rashford is that he needs to be fed with the right tactics and conditions + confidence, then you have a world class player
The only reason Ten Haag was successful was because Rashford and Casemiro were incredible in his first season. There was no pattern of play at all even in his first season where we finished 3rd. Soon as Rashford and Casemiro form dipped, and Ten Haag had to rely on his tactical expertise he was found out.
Neville's opinion on a back 3 is infuriating. Everyone these days moves into a back 3 when in possession anyway. Also Amorim has frequently used wingers in the wing back roles, it's not a back 5!
3 or 5 back doesn't matter, you still need wingers that can track back and defend if they aren't natural wingbacks...we've been struggling to keep 2 centre backs fit, let's see how keeping 3 goes though I guess
Klopp indeed won his first tropphy in his 4th season, but he made progress each season since took over Liverpool. 1st season he reached two finals with many mediocre players, 2nd season he reached top 4 spot in premier league, the rest in history. Amorim will need time, but he needs to make some progress in his 2nd season, otherwise he's gone.
Yeah it's ridiculous to think you need 3 years of waiting around, getting dunked on by Palace and Brentford, before anything happens. There are plenty of examples of coaches having immediate and thereafter continuous improvement including klopp.
ETH won trophies in his first and second years.....Mourinho won Europa League. Van Gaal FA Cup. United get good managers. It's the mediocre players and always has been.
Shaw and Malacia (he’s not good enough but that’s a different story!) should both be fit by January. Dalot and Mazraoui can both play in that position. I totally accept that none of those players are the answer long term, but the position is key to Amorim’s tactics. We have to buy a superb left wing-back and we won’t get someone of that calibre in January
@@mattinterweb couldnt put it better myself people would think better of him if he wore the jokers suit from the film and the face paint look at his management record 😂😂😂
@@johnpaul4301bro you think he is only a coach for money? Its just his job? So why did he not win more so he receives more bonusses. I can tell you he will be upset no matter how much money they give him. He (like all coaches) think about 1 thing. And that is winning. And he lost the project / team so he wont be happy about it.
Yeah, already saying that the Ipswich game will be when Sky can "Fully assess Ruben Amorim and what his changes might be" Seem to forget this is United and he'll probably be lucky if even 60% oif the first team are available. Though it will be interesting to note if Mount and Shaw suddenly make miraculous recoveries...
He did fail? I'm sure you aren't from Manchester and don't go to Old Trafford each week who were the people who wanted his play and bitterness gone! We don't care what you think your not a real fan
He's only overrated because he's inconsistent. He is world class on his day. Garnacho is overrated, though, for sure. How many chances does that guy waste, craziness.
Getting 17 million to sit at home and he'll probably still be greedy enough to get another job on the side somewhere else earning a few more million instead of enjoying the rest of his life with his family spending the money
@@anirudhmenon9099 I'd do his job for half that pay and give media twice the interviews and hold an hour a day fan singing session and be happy about it instead of tryna make out he's been hard done by to take 15 mill to lose his job
@@Richard-d1y giving the age old wealth doesn't buy happiness question? It doesn't directly make you happy, but indirectly it does. Private health care for my family. Holidays all around, never have struggle to get by worries with money, send your kids to a better area to learn with less chance of growing up around rough characters etc the list goes on
Liverpool supporter. I hope Amorim has got guarantees from the club's owners. He does look like the most promising manager appointment since Ferguson stepped down. But he needs the club itself to sort out many of the current issues. I wish him well, but then I wished ETH well too when he was appointed. The P.L. needs as many clubs as possible performing as well as possible for competitiveness and entertaining football. That's the reason I want to see United improve.
Just to correct Jamie... Gerard Houllier was successful, after Kenny. Klopp was much later, but lets give that wonderful French man the credit he deserves. RIP.
Redknapp was everything that was wrong with football during that time. He has a resentment towards Houllier because Houllier wanted rid of the Spice Boys image & to get Liverpool back on the map. That Redknapp was just an overrated sicknote who cared more about his image than football. He was exactly the same when he went to THEM but I enjoyed it, Henry sent him well & truly to the retirement home!
Neville chatting shite as usual. No one can accuse amorim of not having a style. If these players won't play it that's different. And acting like basically he needs to play like pep or be city. Meanwhile they say signings are all flops. So are they good enough to play that way. Lampard and rednknaps opinion doesn't count for anything. And Neville you can't keep relying on players who only turn up to save their seat on the gravy train for a new manager and then down tools again when the going gets tough honestly ffs
True but bear in mind United fans have said this about every manager they've had in the past 11 years, and all have been quite poor. Mourinho only one who was somewhat good imo. The Premier League is a lot different to the Portuguese League. Wait until he starts at United then we will see (was great at Sporting tho). Can't believe people are saying he's gonna be great at Man Utd before he has even started
@skwad240 he's a great manager but he'll fail as the environment at united is beyond toxic. They need to sack everyone and start again, which isn't going to happen.
No ex-player pundits are more negative about their former club, than ex-Utd players. Of course there should an element of being cautious, but this should also be an encouraging and potentially exciting appointment. But theee guys are just acting like miserable old men as usual
Because they wanted united to succeed they want the team to achieve what they achieved themselves It's not because they love having a dig at there former club
I don't think many clubs have fallen off so majorly as man united though. Arsenal. liverpool. chelsea tottenham all still fighting for stuff. Man utd? fighting relegation
United can't keep gambling on coaches with no proven records of success. They should only hire coaches that have done it before elsewhere. Almost all highly successful coaches in history have been successful at smaller clubs before moving up.
I used to think ex-liverpool players criticizing too much were a hinderance when liverpool fell from grace ... but these guys are next level! Part of the l reason the media can keep churning out stories to mock man u is thanks to these guys jumping over themselves to tear the club down.
@@Hideinacave These idiots on sky Not ONE been a top manager, they talk a great game and what these managers are doing wrong, if they were that good should be top managers
these lads have never ever watch Sporting play and think the portuguese league is like the 5th division in England, show some respect to such a good manager
Their ignorance is irrelevant to the fact that this is literally the weakest Porto and Benfica in over a decade. He didn't bring Sporting up.. its just that everyone else went down, Porto's decision for money over development caught up to them.
People say this everytime when a new player or manager come to the prem from a lower league and it always turns out in the long run the pundits were right
I’m tired of people saying rashford is a world class player. The sooner man united fans realise this, the better it’ll be for the club. The standard has to be better than whatever he’s doing. If Rashford is the standard, then we’ll be closer to relegation than winning the league. It’s actually embarrassing having Rashford as your benchmark.
National institutional affairs this is Manchester United were talking about here. Show some respect, no your place. Sit up straight and listen hard. The British Monarchy can only dream of having as much tourist attraction and history.
I wonder if anyone can answer this one, because there was a lot of talk of the players giving up on the manager, before he was sacked: If it was truly the case that the players gave up on the manager, then why did they even bother to turn up at the FA Cup Final last season?....
We Sporting fans were also this delusional. Porto and Benfica were always ahead of us, but we acted like we on the same level. Thankfully Amorim came with the right vision of the situation.
Couldn't tell you the last time I was this excited for a game, Regardless of how things go today change is coming and it's exciting, Love the fact Ruud is getting a few games in charge for him personally, this experience will be great for him and who knows he could be back in years to come ,but definitely think Amorim is the right choice and absolutely loved this press conference after the sporting game the other night, love his honesty, his desire to Utd boss and desire to bring back the glory days, I am Buzzing for him to get here , Just hope we keep bouncing for the nxt few games and give him atleast a chance to get us in the top 4 this season but if we don't so be it, I believe he is gonna make us a dominant force again, So today is a massive day for Ruud and the players and I think if we can just be a little tighter at the back today we can win this, massive couple of weeks for rashford aswell, I reckon he'll score 2 today and we win 2-1 , ever the optimist. COME ON UNITED GLORY GLORY MAN UTD ❤️ 🤍 🖤
Hojlund has scored 11 goals since he signed for united 😂 you can blame everyone for underperforming?? But when your main striker who is only 21 and barely ever fit, has only scored 11 goals its not hard to see why you dont win football matches?? Amorim signed gyokeres who by the way?? Has scored 16 in 10 already this season. The problem is not underperforming players!!! The problem is underperforming recruitment department.
Recruitment is a big factor. Not having a leader of the line is another big issue. All the forwards are trying to prove themselves and get ‘theirs’ instead of playing together. They know UTD is only good for one goal per game and want to score. Forget winning.
Hojlund never gets any service, that is the problem, because all our wingers are selfish. When he has had chances he's done well, he just rarely gets them.
it's gonna get worse from here on... Any manager coming into this set up is bound to fail. Unless, the manager is given a minimum time of 3-4 years. Even Pep will need atleast 4-5 years to compete for title with this set up and squad. There isn't any expectation from any new manager. The fans knows it.
I'm a westham fan just have to say over the years man Utd used to be a great team and I enjoyed watching them but how they are now hurts me im not one of those fans that hate Utd they will never be the same again they need to get world class players in Roy Keane was a legend
I Don't Think Manchester United are gonna Finish in the Top Four or Top Six this Season. They will be Lucky to Finish 9th. Yes Ruben has Done Good at Sporting Lisbon but I don't think He is the Man to get Manchester United back at the Top. All the Players in that Squad should all be Sold and Thrown Out. Replace them with the Players from the Under 21's & 18's. Shame they Won't Let Van Nistelrooy Manage till the End of the Season. Cause they do at least look like they are Trying under Him.
Just FYI that when INEOS bought nice football club they went through like 7 managers in 5 years. Highest finish in the league was 9th place. Not a good sign
We have an interim manager and the previous manager failed and they are sat there expecting something different….INSANE. Disrespectful to Chelsea also.
Amorim is a tough coach: the players ligning up for the next game are the ones who perform the best during the week's training. If you don't "eat the grass" as we say in Portugal, you are out! Few years ago, under Amorim, he pushed out Slimani, arguably our best striker at the time, simple because he didn't push himself enough during training. This was controversial but in the end, Amorim was right: the team became super meritocratic and everyone pushes themselves to their absolute limit. On top of that, out with Slimani, and later on we got Gyokeres.
I'm a united fan but when people mentions Klopp took 4-5 years to win a major trophy, they need to mention the context and whole picture as well. He had to rebuild a team and club which has been a failure for decades. And most importantly, we could see instant impact and identity from klopp. Liverpool had the same dominating, high energy style throughout klopp era. They were making major strides in the league and europe and everyone knew liverpool were going to win big and go places eventually with klopp. So, the point is, even though managers need time and patience, there needs to be a clear impact and style of play and conviction of progression in that time, like klopp brought from day 1. Not the kind of vague fugazi 'progress' we were apparently making under ole. It needs to be un-debatable, for everyone, that united is going places with the manager, regardless of current results.
Failure for decades? The last i check, european, uefa, domestic cups were won under Houiller, Rafa and even short stint King Kenny....I don't rmbr Liverpool languishing so badly in the league for such a long time even under Woy Hodgson or losing 4,5,7 nil against their biggest rivals. Don't compare the present Utd with Liverpool of the past. The Utd today is worse and the entire state of the club is in shambles. It will be a miracle if they can finish 8th and equal last season standings.
With Amorim all the egos from the players are going into the bag....anyone who doesnt run and apply it seriously in training will see the game through TV. Amorim is perfect for this environment and he plays 343 with changes to 442.
You are putting Amorim on a pedestal. Be careful because that pedestal could fall very quickly. Let's talk about what no one wants to discuss: Amorim's weaknesses, which cost us two championships. First, let me clarify that Amorim has been at Sporting for five years and won two championships. The first was during the COVID season when Benfica and Porto suffered greatly from the pandemic, facing long absences of key players! The second championship he won was largely due to the signing of two top players, Gyökeres and Hjulmand. Interestingly, both were initially rejected by Amorim, but the management went ahead and signed them anyway, as he himself admitted. We can start our discussion here: Amorim is terrible at recruiting! Dozens of players came to Sporting only to turn out to be major failures, some even leaving in the same season they arrived! Amorim is very stubborn. This stubbornness cost us two championships! He insisted one striker was enough, and kept flops like Esgaio in the team! Amorim only knows one playing system. He only knows how to play with three central defenders and with the goalkeeper playing out from the back. Sporting struggles immensely against teams that press high. He’s incapable of preparing an alternative system and can only play this way. Amorim is very poor at reading the game. United fans will quickly realize this! He makes substitutions without any logic, completely out of context, often disrupting the team's rhythm! Don’t believe everything he says! He lies a lot! He’s not a man of his word! He said United was the club he wanted, but last year he got on a plane to England to sign for West Ham while the Portuguese championship was ongoing! This year, he abandoned the project, the club, and the players after just 10 matches. He will do the same with you!
Interesting, didn’t know this. I know a lot of sporting’s recent success was because of Gyokeres goals but I was unaware that it was more of a club signing than a Amorim signing but to be fair sporting wouldn’t have paid Braga what they did if he wasn’t a decent manager
@@Rando109 I can't say. When Sporting hired him, they made a blind bet, he had no experience nor did he yet have the title of coach. He made a lot of mistakes, but he also evolved. The biggest mistake you can make is thinking that if you were successful in one place, you will be successful in another! Sporting tolerated all the mistakes he made, he was patient. I don't know to what extent united works like this. I just expose the weaknesses he has and that after 5 years he still has them! Sporting is a team with many gaps, very little versatile, which Goykeres' goals hide! What I want to tell you is not to expect miracles. Don't even go along with the media hype!
lol as long as these ex players have jobs united goes no where bro isn’t even in the country yet and he Gota ignore you clowns not even a united fan but wow
People doubted Slot, since Liverpool hired him based on his performances from the Dutch league and his European performances, yet United get a coach from the Portuguese league that is actually ranked lower than the Dutch league, heck a club like Feyenoord beat Benfica recently in their own stadium in Portugal with 1-3
Too many players throw their arms up at each other. Like they just want to shift the blame to another player if a passage of play doesn’t work. People have already mentioned their names in the comments and I think those same players hold too much power and are toxic with it
Asking these two for managerial advice is like asking homeless people for financial advice. First order of business for Amorim is banning any ex players from access to any aspect of the club.
I think Neville is right in saying United shouldn't buy anyone in January. Give it the next 9 months to implement a coherent style of play, then next summer the manager will know exactly where they are short, then work to locate the best possible players in these positions. Its the most sensible approach
Hogwash! Agree that he will be able to better judge the players within the team. But he should move some, if he can, that he deems surplus or below par, and get others that better suits his tactics, if possible. Or he will be left with a bigger gap or job in the new season.
Jamie Redknapp ain't so bright. Man Utd had to give Erik Ten Hag THE ONE YEAR CONTRACT EXTENTION, that was already part of the deal he has signed 3 years ago. He wasnt given a new contract like this guy is saying. Erik deserved it, 2 trophies in two years, made one more FA Finale, had struggled with injuries last season, he had every right to be given one more chance. If you expect Amorim is going to bring two trophies in two seasons then you are wrong. Game against Chelsea has shown that the players need to take the blame and not the manager, because that bunch is uncoachable.
I swear if you go back to when Ten Bob was appointed you'll find a similar video with Neville spouting exactly the same stuff. "It's refreshing," "He needs time." "Can he get these players performing?" The toxicity is engrained at that club. It's going to take a big fix.
People underestimate the size of the Utd job. No other job in England compares. Only 2 men in history have won league titles with Utd. Granted they were both iconic figures in the history of football and were remarkably difficult to emulate, but this club needs men of incredible character
"Can we make Rashford into a 25 goals striker consistently"..... the guy is 27 hes been playing professionally for 8 years and Neville still talking like he's a 20 year old
I’m tired of this narrative. Why are we the only club waiting for a player to perform. He’s not new and not improving. He needs moving on.
I mean history shows he just needs a left footed overlap partner and you get goals. Don't blame the player that the bald moron decided to rob him of any space to operate
He's only here cos of the school dinners thing
Put him in division 2 he may get 18goals
The righteous PR cult that swooped around him ruined him, he stopped thinking how cool football is.... more worries about twitter and who's headlining the night clubs @@spacedoge6540
Rashford averages 9 league goals a season and hes nearly 27...time to accept he's bang average
Dennis bergkamp averaged 7 a season was he below bang average then?
@@eddiejohnson2201have you seriously just compared Marcus rashford to Dennis bergkamp…
@@BradleyGiles-mf7ew I mean you made it about stats. And he answered with stats lol
A goal every 3 games in all comps for a winger is Elite. If he played for any other club, he'd be celebrated as one of the best in the league.
Below average i said
Fair play to Keano; he’s been saying this for years. There are too many bluffers in that dressing room.
It's the same in all industries where chat is such a big part of the industry. Accountancy too. Brimming with failures and dysfunctionality.
The PO scandal the same. Symptomatic. Grifting liars unready for everything.
There aren't any bluffers. They basically don't exist in this echoing world the professionals live in. There are multiple reasons why certain players work under one manager/club and not on other ones, but it's not because of them being deliberately bad. It's entirely psychological.
Keane are from the old school where men are men and feelings are left in a box. That's not how it work today unless you get ONLY people with that singular mindset in your squad.
ETH seemed like the strict old school type, especially considering how he solved the Sancho issue. Amorim seems much more charismatic. If I were a United supporter I would have been carefully optimistic about this new manager. You tried Keane tactic for 3 managers except maybe Solskjaer and it hasn't worked.
Despite the constant overhauling?
@AeonQuasar get your head out of the sand. There are a good many lazy, bluffers at the club. Until we get rid of these players and get some quality players who work hard and want to play for the club.
"Can he make Rashford a 25 goal a season player?"
Why are we still asking this, why is the responsibility not on Marcus Rashford? Always the manager.
Exactly! Managers have no bearing on the players. They should just hire you! It’s so unfair that ETH was forced to get his players paying well! That’s not the job of a manager!
Look what slots done to grav at Liverpool . No one on earth thought that player existed last year it’s come from the manager. Diaz another one
@@wephilips6651Wtf.
@@warriorrob1 for some players, yes. This will be the 5th manager for Rashford and he's just turned 27 It's not about quality for me it's the effort and work rate that's missing
Bcoz th3 managers tactics and gameplay bring out the best out of its players. By your logic, a player can thrive under any manager.
"Can he make Rashford a 25 goal a season player"
Sorry Gary but in no other workplace would managers be churned out to get the best out of such a sh**, overrated and inconsistent employee.
Never seen a more protected player
Rashford is the best Man Utd player, he’s been compared to Mbappe, the only problem with Rashford is that he needs to be fed with the right tactics and conditions + confidence, then you have a world class player
The only reason Ten Haag was successful was because Rashford and Casemiro were incredible in his first season. There was no pattern of play at all even in his first season where we finished 3rd. Soon as Rashford and Casemiro form dipped, and Ten Haag had to rely on his tactical expertise he was found out.
@@CriticalThomist Lmao Rashford is absolute trash, you have no ball knowledge
@@CriticalThomist Are you mentally challenged?
Forcing Rashford on him already
Lampard, Keane and Neville giving managerial advice..
😂😂😂
Ultimate casual take. Keane won the Championship with Sunderland and then kept them in the EPL.
ROFLMAO....good point.
😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Neville's opinion on a back 3 is infuriating. Everyone these days moves into a back 3 when in possession anyway. Also Amorim has frequently used wingers in the wing back roles, it's not a back 5!
Neville's managerial career went well
@@hatchetmac😂
3 or 5 back doesn't matter, you still need wingers that can track back and defend if they aren't natural wingbacks...we've been struggling to keep 2 centre backs fit, let's see how keeping 3 goes though I guess
Back 3 is a back 5, annoys the hell out of me when people who don’t get that. 5 back on defence, 3 back in attack, simple.
3 at the back won’t work unless they bring in LWBs also
Zirkzee, mount and Bruno don’t fit the system
Klopp indeed won his first tropphy in his 4th season, but he made progress each season since took over Liverpool. 1st season he reached two finals with many mediocre players, 2nd season he reached top 4 spot in premier league, the rest in history. Amorim will need time, but he needs to make some progress in his 2nd season, otherwise he's gone.
Yeah it's ridiculous to think you need 3 years of waiting around, getting dunked on by Palace and Brentford, before anything happens. There are plenty of examples of coaches having immediate and thereafter continuous improvement including klopp.
ETH won trophies in his first and second years.....Mourinho won Europa League. Van Gaal FA Cup. United get good managers. It's the mediocre players and always has been.
Amorim is very arrogant
This will be a car crash
Portuguese league is a different kettle of fish to premier league
@@fonz114 Amorim arrogant??? Lol you must be joking. He's known for being humble. He even told that the win 4-1 against City was luck
Neville - "I wouldn't buy anyone in January"... WE HAVE NO FIT LEFT BACKS/LEFT WING BACKS GARRY!
Gary, it’s spelt Gary!
Lol depends if the club has money
Shaw and Malacia (he’s not good enough but that’s a different story!) should both be fit by January. Dalot and Mazraoui can both play in that position. I totally accept that none of those players are the answer long term, but the position is key to Amorim’s tactics. We have to buy a superb left wing-back and we won’t get someone of that calibre in January
@@Draper99Shaw will get fit and then get injured again, that guy is the new Phil Jones, learn a lesson from that and get rid of him
@@Youafool500 I know that Shaw is a liability, and I would definitely get rid of him. That makes no difference to the point I made
Gary predicted united to be above liverpool end of this season , now look at him
he's an absolute clown. So tired of him.
Keane did too. Two plonkers.
@@mattinterweb couldnt put it better myself people would think better of him if he wore the jokers suit from the film and the face paint look at his management record 😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
He said Ronaldo was a problem 😅 Ronaldo was a problem as he was the only player with a heart to win and discipline
When the seagulls follow the trawler, it is because they think sardines will be thrown into the sea.
If my nan had wheels she’d be a bike
The king ❤
Cantona classic!!!
If you want dog get yourself a loyalty
I love football
These managers get massive payoffs, can we stop acting like “losing their jobs” means they’ll face hardship!!!
They'll also get another job anyways. It's not like their career is finished. Even then, they could retire rn with the money they have
exactly lol. I can't believe they act like they will be missing their next meals. Fraud Hag is laughing at the bank rn
@@johnpaul4301bro you think he is only a coach for money? Its just his job?
So why did he not win more so he receives more bonusses.
I can tell you he will be upset no matter how much money they give him. He (like all coaches) think about 1 thing. And that is winning.
And he lost the project / team so he wont be happy about it.
I don't think anyone is saying ten Hag is gonna be on universal credit by the summer 🤔 Confusing take that
the manager of Manchester United gets a 2.5 year contract, the other gives Mudryk a 9 year deal, I have no clue
YOU clearly don't understand FFP & loopholes towards making further transfers.
@Nostradanus86
Calm down Wilcox.
@@RoadsideGee wilcox 🤔
'The last 5 permanent managers have failed' - I feel like that tells you that changing the manager is probably not going to fix the problems.
Roy looking like he is off in 10 mins to walk the dogs
To be honest that's exactly what he does in his spare time.
@@wolfbane3579isnt that every dog owner?
“Unlike humans, dogs don’t talk s**t.”
....... or stick on the slippers and go for a nod .............
That's his job lol
The amount of pressure these lots putting on the new manager already is crazy!
It's only pressure, if you care. I think Amorim won't care what these guys have to say, mostly.
Heavy lies the crown as the say
Yeah, already saying that the Ipswich game will be when Sky can "Fully assess Ruben Amorim and what his changes might be"
Seem to forget this is United and he'll probably be lucky if even 60% oif the first team are available.
Though it will be interesting to note if Mount and Shaw suddenly make miraculous recoveries...
The biggest mistake ETG made was to put his main focus on trophies instead of setting up the team to play the right way and let trophies follow.
Without trophies he gets sacked sooner
Not even remotely true. He literally won a trophy and people wanted him sacked that season@@timleague9617
You sound as if it was our intentional sang from ten hag. Guy was a fraud. He only won those finals because of luck. I
@@brawrecords he won them nonetheless.
@@timleague9617 without properly setting up the team, he gets sacked eventually and I'd like to believe he wanted to be there for a while.
"This is Manchester United" 😂🤣
Love it.
past tense is your friend Gary
Man u the gift that keeps giving 🤣🤣🤣.y.n.w.a
@mike.b.1641 YNWA 💪🏼👌🏻
Neville loves to ignore how good mourinho was at united… “all failed miserably”
He did fail? I'm sure you aren't from Manchester and don't go to Old Trafford each week who were the people who wanted his play and bitterness gone! We don't care what you think your not a real fan
@@dondamon4669You're just a mid table club now with trash like Antony, Maguire and Lindelof.
@@dondamon4669top red alert
Lives in the past
@@dondamon4669Be a real Utd fan - be as arrogant and entitled as this guy.
Rashford is the most overated player in premier league history
He's only overrated because he's inconsistent. He is world class on his day. Garnacho is overrated, though, for sure. How many chances does that guy waste, craziness.
@@Gj-8422 stop crying now
@@Alx-h9gwhen is his day once in two years ?
🙄 Whatever, keep hating?!
@@ReddevilsFanNGainz86 yeah sound 😂😂
Has anyone felt sorry for someone who’s been sacked with a £17m payoff?
Getting 17 million to sit at home and he'll probably still be greedy enough to get another job on the side somewhere else earning a few more million instead of enjoying the rest of his life with his family spending the money
Not to mention he's from a very rich family. I've no sympathy for him personally
@@anirudhmenon9099 I'd do his job for half that pay and give media twice the interviews and hold an hour a day fan singing session and be happy about it instead of tryna make out he's been hard done by to take 15 mill to lose his job
Wealth is relative. You are super rich compared to some in the world. Does that mean you can have no problems?
@@Richard-d1y giving the age old wealth doesn't buy happiness question?
It doesn't directly make you happy, but indirectly it does. Private health care for my family. Holidays all around, never have struggle to get by worries with money, send your kids to a better area to learn with less chance of growing up around rough characters etc the list goes on
Liverpool supporter. I hope Amorim has got guarantees from the club's owners. He does look like the most promising manager appointment since Ferguson stepped down. But he needs the club itself to sort out many of the current issues. I wish him well, but then I wished ETH well too when he was appointed. The P.L. needs as many clubs as possible performing as well as possible for competitiveness and entertaining football. That's the reason I want to see United improve.
United fan here in Uganda.......thats why we prefer liverpool to win the league this season other than bottlers fc and man city
Just to correct Jamie... Gerard Houllier was successful, after Kenny. Klopp was much later, but lets give that wonderful French man the credit he deserves. RIP.
Redknapp was everything that was wrong with football during that time. He has a resentment towards Houllier because Houllier wanted rid of the Spice Boys image & to get Liverpool back on the map.
That Redknapp was just an overrated sicknote who cared more about his image than football. He was exactly the same when he went to THEM but I enjoyed it, Henry sent him well & truly to the retirement home!
He had success was he a great manager, no. He bought Diouf over Anelka
So was Rafa
I immediately thought this myself.
@@Youafool500 winning 5 trophies in a season ain't bad. Benitez wanted Gareth Barry over Xabi Alonso!
Super Sunday has just become a counseling session for Gary Neville 😄
Neville chatting shite as usual. No one can accuse amorim of not having a style. If these players won't play it that's different. And acting like basically he needs to play like pep or be city. Meanwhile they say signings are all flops. So are they good enough to play that way. Lampard and rednknaps opinion doesn't count for anything. And Neville you can't keep relying on players who only turn up to save their seat on the gravy train for a new manager and then down tools again when the going gets tough honestly ffs
Neville started off well but he is a god awful pundit these days
*Amorim
Amorim
Where does your opinion rank?
@@dabesst5091 put that down to auto correct cheers tho
Amorim won 2 league titles in a league dominated by strong Porto and Benfica teams the last 20 years, more impressive then what Ten Hag did with Ajax
And came into a VERY toxic enviroment and started winning instantly
True but bear in mind United fans have said this about every manager they've had in the past 11 years, and all have been quite poor. Mourinho only one who was somewhat good imo. The Premier League is a lot different to the Portuguese League. Wait until he starts at United then we will see (was great at Sporting tho). Can't believe people are saying he's gonna be great at Man Utd before he has even started
nope, Sporting is one of Portugal big 3, winning with Sporting is good but not extraordinary, if he won with Vitoria or Boavista than it's special
@@SongofIceandTeabro I am a Sporting fan and I assure you that what he did was UNBELIEVABLE
@skwad240 he's a great manager but he'll fail as the environment at united is beyond toxic. They need to sack everyone and start again, which isn't going to happen.
No ex-player pundits are more negative about their former club, than ex-Utd players. Of course there should an element of being cautious, but this should also be an encouraging and potentially exciting appointment. But theee guys are just acting like miserable old men as usual
Something their fans don’t seem to realise when they’re complaining about negative media coverage…it’s often their own ex-players being negative
Well they are jealous that none of their mates was appointed a United coach
Thank god, they don't run the club or can no longer bully the Glazers into keeping clueless Ole in charge, with a lifelong contract.
Because they wanted united to succeed they want the team to achieve what they achieved themselves
It's not because they love having a dig at there former club
I don't think many clubs have fallen off so majorly as man united though. Arsenal. liverpool. chelsea tottenham all still fighting for stuff. Man utd? fighting relegation
Should let rudd van nistelrooy have the job see what he can do.
United can't keep gambling on coaches with no proven records of success. They should only hire coaches that have done it before elsewhere. Almost all highly successful coaches in history have been successful at smaller clubs before moving up.
Ten Hag brought in 10+ Ajax/Eredivisie past and present players and left 😂
Ten Hag didn't bring in anyone. The manager doesn't sign players.
@@F08OWPi'm sure he had 0 influence in getting his ex players from ajax to man utd.
@@F08OWP Except he did. It was in his contract that he would have control over recruitment. That was one of the big disagreements he had with Ineos.
@@F08OWPhe did.
@@F08OWPHe didn’t bring anyone this summer, but he was absolutely responsible for a lot of the signings in the previous 2
I used to think ex-liverpool players criticizing too much were a hinderance when liverpool fell from grace ... but these guys are next level! Part of the l reason the media can keep churning out stories to mock man u is thanks to these guys jumping over themselves to tear the club down.
Maybe they should get you on there Totes and you can tell them “it’s not the winning, it’s the taking part”, then everybody can hold hands
What Iim concerened about is pundits like these putting so much pressure on him and then he ends up crumbling. Why cant they be patient with a rebuild
Pundits ????????
Why can't they be patient? Why can't the club be patient, a 2.5yr deal?😅
@@Hideinacave These idiots on sky Not ONE been a top manager, they talk a great game and what these managers are doing wrong, if they were that good should be top managers
They are telling the truth..man utd owners only give the manager 2 1/2 year deal you balloon not pundits😂
@@user-um1pc8ry8v Yes and they have all been given Millions and millions to spend on crap you clown 😂😂😂
Great to see world class players and Jamie Redknapp.
I died! 😂🤣
these lads have never ever watch Sporting play and think the portuguese league is like the 5th division in England, show some respect to such a good manager
Theyre lost. Keane is bitter since he wanted the job. Neville is just a has been. Completely useless all of them
Their ignorance is irrelevant to the fact that this is literally the weakest Porto and Benfica in over a decade. He didn't bring Sporting up.. its just that everyone else went down, Porto's decision for money over development caught up to them.
@@kallekofot7240Keane wanted the job? Don’t be daft.
@jm11111
Portuguese league is championship level? Mental illness.
People say this everytime when a new player or manager come to the prem from a lower league and it always turns out in the long run the pundits were right
I’m tired of people saying rashford is a world class player. The sooner man united fans realise this, the better it’ll be for the club. The standard has to be better than whatever he’s doing. If Rashford is the standard, then we’ll be closer to relegation than winning the league. It’s actually embarrassing having Rashford as your benchmark.
I love how sky always bring out the guns when it comes to speaking about man utd 😂
National institutional affairs this is Manchester United were talking about here. Show some respect, no your place. Sit up straight and listen hard. The British Monarchy can only dream of having as much tourist attraction and history.
I still have no idea how ten hag wanted his team to play and the reason why he bought the players he did
Lampard saying Arteta really successful manager lol
I wonder if anyone can answer this one, because there was a lot of talk of the players giving up on the manager, before he was sacked:
If it was truly the case that the players gave up on the manager, then why did they even bother to turn up at the FA Cup Final last season?....
A pundits round full of failed managers and we're supposed to listen to their opinions lmao
Quality 😆👍
And Jamie Redknapp which is even more damning
Certainly they know better than you
@@heliumtrophyGet Clinton Morrison and Paul Merson on the case
@@wolfbane3579🤡
Too many Dutch players in the team that were brought in by ETH. Time for RA to make drastic changes
Aren’t these the same guys saying they should stick with Hag 😅
Exactly. This is why i hate the english media. The hypocrisy is off the charts.
Ho yes because know-it all nevillie always tells us, United are NOT a sacking club
@@kevinbeck6785 a not-sacking club is a wasting time club.
Glazers & Woodward messed it up when they said we don't have to be successful on the pitch to be successful.
Did Gary just say United aren’t an underdog? Really? The united delusion continues.
Dont forget he thinks man u will finsh above liverpool and united's midfield is better then liverpool it shows that he has trauma from valencia
Ok Sir . We are underdog please... Are you ohkay now ?
Underdog? Nah bro, more like relegation contenders
It's hard being objective as a fan. The copium is always right at hand...
We Sporting fans were also this delusional. Porto and Benfica were always ahead of us, but we acted like we on the same level.
Thankfully Amorim came with the right vision of the situation.
Couldn't tell you the last time I was this excited for a game,
Regardless of how things go today change is coming and it's exciting,
Love the fact Ruud is getting a few games in charge for him personally, this experience will be great for him and who knows he could be back in years to come ,but definitely think Amorim is the right choice and absolutely loved this press conference after the sporting game the other night, love his honesty, his desire to Utd boss and desire to bring back the glory days, I am Buzzing for him to get here ,
Just hope we keep bouncing for the nxt few games and give him atleast a chance to get us in the top 4 this season but if we don't so be it, I believe he is gonna make us a dominant force again,
So today is a massive day for Ruud and the players and I think if we can just be a little tighter at the back today we can win this, massive couple of weeks for rashford aswell, I reckon he'll score 2 today and we win 2-1 , ever the optimist.
COME ON UNITED
GLORY GLORY MAN UTD ❤️ 🤍 🖤
Yet another idiotic take by Gary and the Gang. Everybody knows Man United is the club you come to to end your career.
A new manager does'nt do anything. There's something different that's rotten at Man United. I already feel sorry for Ruben...
Gary Neville the best world class manger - would really like
To shake him off United now, been a virus around for too long. ❤
Hojlund has scored 11 goals since he signed for united 😂
you can blame everyone for underperforming??
But when your main striker who is only 21 and barely ever fit,
has only scored 11 goals its not hard to see why you dont win football matches??
Amorim signed gyokeres who by the way??
Has scored 16 in 10 already this season.
The problem is not underperforming players!!!
The problem is underperforming recruitment department.
How much you want to bet Gary will say he's better than Jackson lmaooo
Can't blame hojlund he's feeding off scrap there's no service from the wingers
Recruitment is a big factor. Not having a leader of the line is another big issue. All the forwards are trying to prove themselves and get ‘theirs’ instead of playing together. They know UTD is only good for one goal per game and want to score. Forget winning.
Agreed
Hojlund never gets any service, that is the problem, because all our wingers are selfish. When he has had chances he's done well, he just rarely gets them.
Roy was told to take off his navy jacket to prevent them looking like the Four Tops
😂
😁
All about the cardigan. Pure class
😂😂😂
So glad they’re finally being allowed to express their thoughts publicly on the Ten Hag decision. They must’ve been holding onto this for so long
Needs to get some of those players out of there. They’re getting manager after manager sacked
4 great players. But when are sky sports going to start allowing pundits who are not footballers come through?
it's gonna get worse from here on... Any manager coming into this set up is bound to fail. Unless, the manager is given a minimum time of 3-4 years. Even Pep will need atleast 4-5 years to compete for title with this set up and squad.
There isn't any expectation from any new manager. The fans knows it.
I'm a westham fan just have to say over the years man Utd used to be a great team and I enjoyed watching them but how they are now hurts me im not one of those fans that hate Utd they will never be the same again they need to get world class players in Roy Keane was a legend
Can't run, can't score, can't play, no style...tell you what says the football agent...I'll give Man Utd a call...you'll go a long way there
The numbers don't lie
And when issues persist in math and science, the "common denominator" is usually the thing that needs "review".
In a way it’s unfair to put him in mid season, but works also to his advantage. Amorim will know what works and doesn’t currently .
They are ready to eat the new coach alive
First thing he needs to do is sell Rashford because he holds to much power and gets managers sacked if he’s asked to work hard…
And fernandes
How is Rashford getting more stick than Luke Shaw?
work ? dont swear at him
@@joashk3650 because Shaw has been injured
I Don't Think Manchester United are gonna Finish in the Top Four or Top Six this Season.
They will be Lucky to Finish 9th.
Yes Ruben has Done Good at Sporting Lisbon but I don't think He is the Man to get Manchester United back at the Top.
All the Players in that Squad should all be Sold and Thrown Out.
Replace them with the Players from the Under 21's & 18's.
Shame they Won't Let Van Nistelrooy Manage till the End of the Season.
Cause they do at least look like they are Trying under Him.
Yes
Grey colours the mode of the day, fellas & Kelly? Drab!
These are the people who consistently should be in the studio
Lampard talking about coaching is crazy 😂😂😂😂😂
More emojis please
Just FYI that when INEOS bought nice football club they went through like 7 managers in 5 years. Highest finish in the league was 9th place. Not a good sign
Gonna be interesting to see. Probably win a title before Arsenal and Chelsea though!
HA HA
Yeh championship title 😂
@@sma3429 👍👍
😂😂😂
We have an interim manager and the previous manager failed and they are sat there expecting something different….INSANE. Disrespectful to Chelsea also.
Group of failed managers.
Amorim is a tough coach: the players ligning up for the next game are the ones who perform the best during the week's training. If you don't "eat the grass" as we say in Portugal, you are out!
Few years ago, under Amorim, he pushed out Slimani, arguably our best striker at the time, simple because he didn't push himself enough during training.
This was controversial but in the end, Amorim was right: the team became super meritocratic and everyone pushes themselves to their absolute limit. On top of that, out with Slimani, and later on we got Gyokeres.
insightful
Gary knows nothing. Souness and Jamie predicted this after the 7-0 and Gary dismissed Seven Hag as a ‘blip’
Amorim has no pressure on him! How much worse can they get?
Three failed managers….and Jamie Redknapp.
The dinner lady at scunthorpe's canteen was linked with the United job
I'm a united fan but when people mentions Klopp took 4-5 years to win a major trophy, they need to mention the context and whole picture as well. He had to rebuild a team and club which has been a failure for decades. And most importantly, we could see instant impact and identity from klopp. Liverpool had the same dominating, high energy style throughout klopp era. They were making major strides in the league and europe and everyone knew liverpool were going to win big and go places eventually with klopp. So, the point is, even though managers need time and patience, there needs to be a clear impact and style of play and conviction of progression in that time, like klopp brought from day 1. Not the kind of vague fugazi 'progress' we were apparently making under ole. It needs to be un-debatable, for everyone, that united is going places with the manager, regardless of current results.
Well said
Failure for decades? The last i check, european, uefa, domestic cups were won under Houiller, Rafa and even short stint King Kenny....I don't rmbr Liverpool languishing so badly in the league for such a long time even under Woy Hodgson or losing 4,5,7 nil against their biggest rivals. Don't compare the present Utd with Liverpool of the past. The Utd today is worse and the entire state of the club is in shambles. It will be a miracle if they can finish 8th and equal last season standings.
Pundit table full of failed managers talking about what the new manager needs to do 😂
I really don’t wish him well 😂
Nice fan that you are
With Amorim all the egos from the players are going into the bag....anyone who doesnt run and apply it seriously in training will see the game through TV. Amorim is perfect for this environment and he plays 343 with changes to 442.
You are putting Amorim on a pedestal. Be careful because that pedestal could fall very quickly. Let's talk about what no one wants to discuss: Amorim's weaknesses, which cost us two championships. First, let me clarify that Amorim has been at Sporting for five years and won two championships. The first was during the COVID season when Benfica and Porto suffered greatly from the pandemic, facing long absences of key players!
The second championship he won was largely due to the signing of two top players, Gyökeres and Hjulmand. Interestingly, both were initially rejected by Amorim, but the management went ahead and signed them anyway, as he himself admitted. We can start our discussion here:
Amorim is terrible at recruiting! Dozens of players came to Sporting only to turn out to be major failures, some even leaving in the same season they arrived!
Amorim is very stubborn. This stubbornness cost us two championships! He insisted one striker was enough, and kept flops like Esgaio in the team!
Amorim only knows one playing system. He only knows how to play with three central defenders and with the goalkeeper playing out from the back. Sporting struggles immensely against teams that press high. He’s incapable of preparing an alternative system and can only play this way.
Amorim is very poor at reading the game. United fans will quickly realize this! He makes substitutions without any logic, completely out of context, often disrupting the team's rhythm!
Don’t believe everything he says! He lies a lot! He’s not a man of his word! He said United was the club he wanted, but last year he got on a plane to England to sign for West Ham while the Portuguese championship was ongoing! This year, he abandoned the project, the club, and the players after just 10 matches. He will do the same with you!
Interesting stuff 👍
He sounds like Ten Hag version 2.0 lol
So do u think he is a good appointment?
Interesting, didn’t know this. I know a lot of sporting’s recent success was because of Gyokeres goals but I was unaware that it was more of a club signing than a Amorim signing but to be fair sporting wouldn’t have paid Braga what they did if he wasn’t a decent manager
@@Rando109 I can't say. When Sporting hired him, they made a blind bet, he had no experience nor did he yet have the title of coach. He made a lot of mistakes, but he also evolved. The biggest mistake you can make is thinking that if you were successful in one place, you will be successful in another! Sporting tolerated all the mistakes he made, he was patient. I don't know to what extent united works like this. I just expose the weaknesses he has and that after 5 years he still has them! Sporting is a team with many gaps, very little versatile, which Goykeres' goals hide! What I want to tell you is not to expect miracles. Don't even go along with the media hype!
Why I love this is because all of them criticizing were all Manager and couldn't do anything at Chelsea, Valencia and Sunderland.
How does Redknapp still have a job here?
Because if you talk with enough confidence, even if what you're saying is complete rubbish. People like it.
Because I said so
This is like the first time united is letting a coach bring his staff with him. I think that will be very helpful.
More important things in life than watching an overrated footballer, earning hundreds of thousands of pounds a week.
You can’t say it might take 4-5 years but then not give ANY manager 4-5 years 🙄 that’s dumb.
Exactly 👍
lol as long as these ex players have jobs united goes no where bro isn’t even in the country yet and he Gota ignore you clowns not even a united fan but wow
Best analysis on the situation by Roy 👍
as a ex manu fan, its the most confusing club ive ever supported, moving to man city was the best thing i could of done for my mental health.
We don't miss you, we love the circus. :-)
Glory chasers 😂
........ are you Visa or Mastercard ......... ( ie plastic .... )
You’re not a fan at all of any team 😂😂😂 you’re either 10 years old or you’re American 😂 you don’t just switch teams haha
10:30 "If you're not going to run, you're going to get nowhere fast". I see what you did there Roy, nice one
Roy’s honesty, Frank’s analysis and Jamie’s personality is brilliant, well balanced and a joy to listen too. Gary is alright
People doubted Slot, since Liverpool hired him based on his performances from the Dutch league and his European performances, yet United get a coach from the Portuguese league that is actually ranked lower than the Dutch league, heck a club like Feyenoord beat Benfica recently in their own stadium in Portugal with 1-3
It's gas seeing Valencia's finest ever coach telling the new United manager what to do. Bit like Liz Truss becoming advisor to the UK prime minister!
Too many players throw their arms up at each other. Like they just want to shift the blame to another player if a passage of play doesn’t work. People have already mentioned their names in the comments and I think those same players hold too much power and are toxic with it
If someone actually did watch him play. You'd be mistaken to think Neville wasn't some journeyman but a yester year GOAT😂😂😂😂😂😂
Asking these two for managerial advice is like asking homeless people for financial advice. First order of business for Amorim is banning any ex players from access to any aspect of the club.
I think Neville is right in saying United shouldn't buy anyone in January. Give it the next 9 months to implement a coherent style of play, then next summer the manager will know exactly where they are short, then work to locate the best possible players in these positions. Its the most sensible approach
Hogwash! Agree that he will be able to better judge the players within the team. But he should move some, if he can, that he deems surplus or below par, and get others that better suits his tactics, if possible. Or he will be left with a bigger gap or job in the new season.
I genuinely feel Ineos listened to the "top reds" instead of going with their gut and cutting the cord in the summer. It sets the club back a year.
Jamie Redknapp ain't so bright. Man Utd had to give Erik Ten Hag THE ONE YEAR CONTRACT EXTENTION, that was already part of the deal he has signed 3 years ago. He wasnt given a new contract like this guy is saying. Erik deserved it, 2 trophies in two years, made one more FA Finale, had struggled with injuries last season, he had every right to be given one more chance. If you expect Amorim is going to bring two trophies in two seasons then you are wrong. Game against Chelsea has shown that the players need to take the blame and not the manager, because that bunch is uncoachable.
I swear if you go back to when Ten Bob was appointed you'll find a similar video with Neville spouting exactly the same stuff.
"It's refreshing," "He needs time." "Can he get these players performing?"
The toxicity is engrained at that club.
It's going to take a big fix.
People underestimate the size of the Utd job. No other job in England compares. Only 2 men in history have won league titles with Utd. Granted they were both iconic figures in the history of football and were remarkably difficult to emulate, but this club needs men of incredible character
Lampard and Neville talking about our new manager is crazy 😂 just let our manager settle in and do his job!
8:21 Neville, "that has got to change if he doesn't change that he will fuuu...." 😂
United need to get rid of the following: Rashford, Shaw, Maguire, Lindelof, Casemiro, Eriksen. Give Amorim some fresh legs